Premium Essay

The Foxmeyer Drugs' Bankruptcy: Was It a Failure of Erp?

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By tomyhawk
Words 2060
Pages 9
The FoxMeyer Drugs' Bankruptcy: Was it a Failure of ERP?
Judy E. Scott, The University of Texas at Austin, Abstract
This interpretive case study of FoxMeyer Drugs' ERP implementation is based on empirical frameworks and models of software project risks and project escalation. Implications of the study offer suggestions on how to avoid ERP failure. warehouses, the transition to the first automated warehouse was a disaster. Disgruntled workers damaged inventory, and orders were not filled, and mistakes occurred as the new system struggled with the volume of transactions. $34 million worth of inventory were lost (Jesitus 1997). Second, the scope of the project was risky. FoxMeyer was an early adopter of SAP R/3. After the project began, FoxMeyer signed a large contract to supply University HealthSystem Consortium (UHC). This event exacerbated the need for an unprecedented volume of R/3 transactions. Although, prior to the contract, testing seemed to indicate that R/3 on HP9000 servers would be able to cope with the volume of transactions, in 1994 R/3 could process only 10,000 customer orders per night, compared with 420,000 under FoxMeyer's original mainframe system (Jesitus 1997). Third, the execution of the project was an issue due to the shortage of skilled and knowledgeable personnel. FoxMeyer did not have the necessary skills in-house and was relying on Andersen Consulting to implement R/3 and integrate the ERP with an automated warehouse system from Pinnacle. Although at the height of the project there were over 50 consultants at FoxMeyer, many of them were inexperienced and turnover was high (Computergram International 1998). Finally, the environment quadrant of the risk framework includes issues over which project management has little or no control (Keil, Cule, Lyytinen and Schmidt 1998). Although FoxMeyer must have realized the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Instructor’s Manual Erp

... CHAPTER OBJECTIVES 1. Develop an understanding of how ERP systems can improve the effectiveness of information systems in organizations. 2. Understand the business benefits of enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems. 3. Understand the history and evolution of ERP. CHAPTER OUTLINE 1. A Foundation for Understanding Enterprise Resource Planning Systems a. The Emergence of Enterprise Resource Planning Systems 1. What is ERP? 2. The Evolution of ERP 3. The Integrated Systems Approach b. Business Benefits of ERP c. ERP Modules d. ERP Design Alternatives e. The Business Case for ERP 1. Cost-Benefit Analysis for ERP 2. Can ERP Provide a Competitive Advantage? f. The Challenge of Implementing an ERP System g. Summary ANSWERS TO END-OF-CHAPTER QUESTIONS Questions for Discussion: 1. Use on-line library databases to identify articles in trade publications which provide case studies of ERP implementations. These articles may provide some insight into each of these questions. a. How widespread is the use of ERP across certain industries? b. What are the benefits reported from implementing ERP? c. What are its limitations? 2. Research and learn about the implementation of ERP. Use trade publications and on-line library databases (e.g. ABI Inform, ProQuest, First Search, Wilson Select Plus, available through your library) to conduct a search for articles. a. Find a success story of ERP implementation. What factors contributed to the success......

Words: 8305 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Erp, Enterprise Resource Planning project implementation: A case study of ERP in Rolls-Royce Yahaya Yusufa,*, A. Gunasekaranb, Mark S. Abthorpec a Business School, University of Hull, Hull HU6 7RX, UK Department of Management, University of Massachusetts, 285 Old Westport Road, North Dartmouth, MA 02747-2300, USA c Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, Nottingham Trent University, Burton Street, Nottingham NG1 4BU, UK b Abstract Economic globalisation and internationalisation of operations are essential factors in integration of suppliers, partners and customers within and across national borders, the objective being to achieve integrated supply chains. In this effort, implementation of information technologies and systems such as enterprise resource planning (ERP) facilitate the desired level of integration. There are cases of successful and unsuccessful implementations. The principal reason for failure is often associated with poor management of the implementation process. This paper examines key dimensions of implementation of ERP system within a large manufacturing organisation and identifies core issues to confront in successful implementation of enterprise information system. A brief overview of the application of ERP system is also presented and in particular, ERP software package known as SAP R/3, which was the ERP software package selected by Rolls-Royce plc. The paper takes an in-depth look at the issues behind the process of ERP implementation via a case study......

Words: 9029 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Erp Failures

...Case Study ERP Implementation Failures ERP systems are an integrated software solution that is typically offered through a vendor as packaged software that supports the organization’s supply chain and other business functions, such as, receiving, inventory management, customer order management, production, planning, shipping, accounting, and human resource management. The use of ERP is very widespread across a multitude of industries. As a matter of fact, a report by Computer Economics Inc. states that, “76% of manufacturers, 35% of insurance and health care companies, and 24% of Federal Government agencies already have an ERP system or are in the process of installing one.” Over 60% of Fortune 1000 companies have implemented ERP systems (Hawkins & Stein, 2004). It is not just large firms that are implementing ERP systems, small and medium size companies are making use of ERP systems as well (O’Leary, 2004). ERP systems have expanded across the globe and many of world’s leading companies consider Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems an essential information systems infrastructure to survive and prosper in today’s economy. There are many advantages to ERP systems. Companies that have successfully implemented ERP systems report improvement in management decision making, improvement in efficiency, improvement in information exchange, improvement in performance and productivity levels and improvement in customer service and customer satisfaction, just to name a few.......

Words: 1570 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Erp Implementation-Procedures, Issues, Challenges & Failures

...FREE TERM PAPERS ON SITE: SOFTWARE PROJECT MANAGEMENT A Term Paper ON ERP Implementation-Procedures, Issues, Challenges & Failures Introduction An Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system is an integrated computer-based application used to manage internal and external resources, including tangible assets, financial resources, materials, and human resources. Its purpose is to facilitate the flow of information between all business functions inside the boundaries of the organization and manage the connections to outside stakeholders. Built on a centralized database and normally utilizing a common computing platform, ERP systems consolidate all business operations into a uniform and enterprise-wide system environment. An ERP system can either reside on a centralized server or be distributed across modular hardware and software units that provide "services" and communicate on a local area network. The distributed design allows a business to assemble modules from different vendors without the need for the placement of multiple copies of complex and expensive computer systems in areas which will not use their full capacity. To be considered an ERP system, a software package should have the following traits: ➢ Should be integrated and operate in real time with no periodic batch updates. ➢ All applications should access one......

Words: 4678 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Erp and Concerns Regarding Failures

...literature concerning ERP implementation problems during implementation phases and causes of ERP implementation failure. A multiple case study research methodology was adopted to understand “why” and “how” these ERP systems could not be implemented successfully. Different stakeholders (including top management, project manager, project team members and ERP consultants) from these case studies were interviewed, and ERP implementation documents were reviewed for triangulation. An ERP life cycle framework was applied to study the ERP implementation process and the associated problems in each phase of ERP implementation. Fourteen critical failure factors were identified and analyzed, and three common critical failure factors (poor consultant effectiveness, project management effectiveness and poo555îr quality of business process re-engineering) were examined and discussed. Future research on ERP implementation and critical failure factors is discussed. It is hoped that this research will help to bridge the current literature gap and provide practical advice for both academics and practitioners. Keywords: Critical Failure Factors, ERP Implementation, ERP Life Cycle. 1. Introduction An ERP system is an integrated software solution, typically offered by a vendor as a package that supports the seamless integration of all the information flowing through a company, such as financial, accounting, human resources, supply chain, and customer information (Davenport, 1998). ERP......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Erp- Facts, Benefits and Critical Elements for a Successful Implementation in Small Manufacturing Company

...Resources Planning (ERP). Perhaps we can still survive without technology, but without ERP, a company may fail to remain competitive as they fail to respond quickly to new practices and procedures. Indeed, a company who quest for competitive advantage in this era of intense competition where business entities compete for innovation, expanding customer’s expectation and internationalization of markets, a company regardless of their size must have a reliable ERP to support them. ERP has proven to be an effective tool for competitive advantage as ERP help to delivery products of the highest quality on time, as quickly as possible and at the best price. Davenport (1998, p.121) suggests that “ERP appear to be a dream comes true as these software promise the seamless integration of the information flowing through a company. Markus et al. (2000) defines ERP as commercial software package that enable the integration of transaction oriented data and business process throughout an organization. The purpose of this paper is to discuss facts about ERP, its benefits and the critical success factors in ERP implementation especially for small manufacturing companies, which is in this paper, will sometime refer to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). The remainder of this paper is organises as follows. In Section 2, facts about ERP software is presents. The ERP and its relations to small manufacturing company are discusses in Section 3. Section 4 outlines the benefits of ERP,......

Words: 3119 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Top 10 Corporate Information Technology Failures

...Top 10 Corporate Information Technology Failures AMR Corp., PROJECT: “Confirm” reservation system for hotel and system for Budget Rent A Car Corp., hotel and rental car bookings Hilton Hotels Corp., Marriott International Inc. WHAT HAPPENED? After four years and $125 million in development, the project crumbled in 1992 when it became clear that Confirm would miss its deadline by as much as two years. AMR sued its three partners for breach of contract, citing mismanagement and fickle goals. Marriott countersued, accusing AMR of botching the project and covering it up. Both suits were later settled for undisclosed terms. Confirm died and AMR took a $109 million write-off. Snap-On Inc. PROJECT: Conversion to a new order-entry system from The Baan Co. WHAT HAPPENED? Despite three years of design and implementation, a new order-entry system installed in December 1997 costs the tools company $50 million in lost sales for the first half of 1998. Orders are delayed, inventory is miscounted. Snap-On’s operating costs soar 40%, mainly to cover costs of extra freight and temporary workers. Franchisees, frustrated because they can’t operate the new software, turn to Snap-On competitors. Company profits for the period sink 22% compared to 1997. FoxMeyer Corp. PROJECT: SAP ERP system WHAT HAPPENED? A bungled enterprise resource planning (ERP) installation in 1996 helped drive FoxMeyer into bankruptcy, the drug distributor claims in lawsuits still pending against SAP AG, SAP America......

Words: 997 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Erp Failure Paper

...Deloitte: Alleges fraud on SAP project The success or failure of implementing ERP software depends on a number of factors. I will look at the case Marin County sues Deloitte: Alleges fraud on SAP project. Marin County filed a complaint against Deloitte Consulting for its role in an over-budget SAP implementation. The lawsuit alleges Deloitte committed fraud and misrepresented its skills and experience. One of the reasons why this ERP system failed was Deloitte knew the County didn’t have any prior ERP or SAP implementation experience and knew it would be depending on Deloitte to guide and manage the project. The complaint also states that Deloitte mishandled staffing, project management, risk management, and testing. When implementing ERP software customers, software vendors, and system integrators typically share responsibility for project success of failure. However, customers purchasing complex systems, such as ERP software, do have a high responsibility that their own projects outcome is successful. In Marin’s contract suggested the County was concerned about its own ability to manage the project properly. Being concerned with your own company’s ability to manage a project in the early stage of implementation is not a good thing and Marin County should’ve controlled the conversation with their system integrators and lead from that premise. It’s up to the customer such as Marin County to lead and drive the result of their ERP implementation project and can’t rely on......

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How to Avoid Erp Failure

...How to Avoid SAP ERP Implementation Failure 1. Introduction Any company which is implementing an ERP either a small scale or large organizations is taking huge risk as they have to invest a lot of money and it is a time taking process with risks involved. Risks and issues are part and parcel of every major IT transformation project. When we place this in point of large transformation projects like SAP or Oracle these risks and issues can be huge which can collapse the entire project if not managed and monitored periodically. SAP frameworks have executed effectively more then 40000+ clients on the planet and most extend disappointments are not identified with the item or programming however basically attached to extend execution and the product usage accomplice. As defined by Rowe ERP as “ERP systems represent the implementation of old managerial dream of unifying and centralizing all the information systems into a combined one”. The existing techniques or process which is being followed during the implementation have failed so we need to be innovative by following the standard process. In this paper we would discuss about the problems while implementing an ERP and how to overcome those to implement it successfully. 2. Statement of the problem In the late 1990-2005 most of the companies which invested in ERP 50-70% of them have faced a huge disappointment and huge losses. . In a survey it is found that 56% of implementation costs over budget, average of that over budget......

Words: 2199 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Erp System Failures

...ERP System Failures Jodie Wittenburg Assignment ACG_5647-12 – Week 11 – Course Project Auditing II March 27, 2015 Instructor: Dr. Maryln Fisher Introduction Major project failure is an unfortunate fact for many organizations, and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) projects are no exception. Whether the project is a few months or a few years long, whether it’s an upgrade or a new implementation, the financial and cultural well-being of the entire organization is at stake, and the associated costs of the failure range from disruptive to catastrophic. Everything possible must be done to ensure success. What is an ERP System? An ERP System is an industry acronym for Enterprise Resource Planning System, referring to automation and integration of a company’s core business to help focus on effectiveness and simplified success (Syspro, n.d.). ERP is business process management software that allows an organization to use a system of integrated applications to manage the business and automate many back office functions related to technology, services, and human resources. ERP software integrates all facets of an operation, including product planning, development, manufacturing, sales, and marketing. By doing so, a single computer system can serve the unique needs of each functional area. ERP systems support a smooth and seamless flow of information across the organization by providing a standardized environment for a firm’s business processes and a common......

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Scm & Erp Software Implementation at Nike – from Failure to Success

...1 - What are the failure factors for the first NIKE-i2 ERP-SCM implementation? The following factors contributed to the failure if the ERP-SCM implementation for Nike which then resulted in a loss of $48 million for the year: • i2 Inexperience: Nike although were aware that i2 was unable to provide all the required functionalities initially, requested i2, who were already inexperienced with the footwear industry, to adjust and provide high level of complex customization. • Integration: Nike failed to hire a Third Party Integrator which could have assisted them in overlooking the entire implementation. The integrator could have advised on any issues as well as act as a means of communication between Nike and i2. Instead, i2 was not even integrated with the current SAP ERP, and was rather set up to perform in complete isolation • Customization: Nike underestimated the complexity of the implementation by demanding i2 high level of customization by having an extremely high level of detailed forecasting in addition to trying to forecast too far ahead. i2 was unable to keep up with the quick changes in the market and seasonal trends and thus creating several delays and inaccurate forecasts. • Pilot Test: Nike underestimated the potential risk of failure in implementing i2 and did not conduct any pilot testing. Having done so, could have prevented or at least minimized their losses. A pilot test would have enabled them to be better equipped and deal......

Words: 934 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Challenges Implementing Erp

...reasons for ERP Implementation failures Written by:adminWritten on:April 24, 2013 Comments Add One 3 It is a common saying that technology should work for human and not the other way round. In similar way a company’s Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system is like its central nervous system of the body. If it is healthy, it provides the sensory input to management so they can understand what is happening with customers, suppliers, and employees. It helps management respond, by coordinating the company’s resources to win customers, battle competitors, and reduce cost, just like muscles in a body. Implementing an ERP system for your organization is the best investment a company can think of. ERP systems are the basic sales-to-cash, accounting, reporting, compliance, human resources, supply chain, customer, and sales IT systems that companies rely on every day. Yet, despite this critical role ERP systems play, most companies fail when in it comes to implementing or upgrading their ERP system. Negative’s attracts eye balls The horror stories of failed ERP projects are now the stuff of legend. According to one recent report, more than 29% of ERP implementations fail to achieve even half the planned business benefits. Some well known examples include Waste Management suing SAP for $500 million for a failed ERP implementation, Hershey Foods’ 19% drop in profits from a failed SAP implementation at Halloween time a few years ago, the complete bankruptcy of FoxMeyer......

Words: 1630 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Was Drug Control in the 1900's Effective?

...In 1911, Dr. Hamilton Wright, the United States Opium Commissioner, at the time, stated that “of all the nations…  the United States [consumed] most habit-forming drugs per capita.”1 This branded America as a drug lord, and future generations would continue to uphold the atrocious title and reputation, demonstrating that the United States’ drug control system was poorly enforced during the 1900’s. Neglectful physicians, contraband traces in food and medicine, utter ignorance in part of the American government, and social retaliation led to America becoming a leader in illicit substance distribution and use.   One would think that medical professionals should be dedicated to ensuring patient health and safety, but history reveals ethical mishaps and disappointing facts dictating quite the contrary. Heroin, a substance extracted from the seed pod of certain poppy plants,2 was once a primary component for medications that treated cough-inducing illnesses. Bayer, a major pharmaceutical company, widely advertised heroin and its concoctions, such as heroinhydrochloride, to the general public. It was claimed as, “the cheapest specific for the relief of coughs,” which would appeal to any customer (see page 11, Figure 1). However, heroin is derived from morphine, which is highly addictive and even toxic in large quantities. Morphine caused crisis among civil war veterans, who became dangerously addicted to the pain reliever.3 Even with these previous events in......

Words: 3137 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Erp Failure

...ERP lmplementation Failure at Hershey FoodsCorporation Case study Reference 908-001-1 no This case written InduPerepu, was by under direction Vivek the of Gupta, lcFAl center Management for Research. intended be used thebasis lt is to as for class discussion rather thanto illustrate either effective ineffective or handlinq of a management situation.The was case compiled published from sources. @2008, ICFAI Center Management for (ICMR). Research Nopartof thispublication be copied, may stored, transmitted, reproduced or distributedanyformor medium in whatsoever without permission the of thecopyright owner. DlrtÍibuted by sch,UK and USA NoÍth AmcÍie RestoÍth. woÍld GE - thecase learninqffiffI;ïi" for ;ïl;:llï;:ï a ;ïillll;:Íïiï; € ê PÍinted in UK and UsA 908-001-1 ERP IMPLEMENTATION FAILURE AT HERSHEY FOODS CORPORATION "The Hersheydebacleis not an indictmentof ERPsper se, but it should caution any company that choosesto implementsuch a broad suite to make sure that systemwill function smoothly beforeenteringa peak salesperiod."l - Chain StoreAge, in 1999. "There is no doubt that 1999was a most dfficult and disappointingyear for Hershey Foods Corporation. llhile the year got off to a slow start due to excessiveretail inventories, we fully of expecteda strongfinish in the secondhalf of the yea.r.Instead, the implementation theJinal phase of the Corporation's enterprise-wide information systemcreatedproblems in the......

Words: 5652 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay


...Bankruptcy Examiner’s Report in Auditor Malpractice Suits A bankruptcy examiner’s report may provide a roadmap to auditors’ negligence, breach of contract, gross negligence, and / or cooperation to cover up fraud committed by the debtor management. A bankruptcy examiner is appointed by the court to investigate the debtor and the debtor’s estate for the purpose to determine if fraud, dishonesty, misconduct, incompetence, and irregularity by the debtor management has occurred before and during the filing of the bankruptcy. The judge call for an examiner based on a request from the trustee, the creditors, major shareholders, and / or his personal judgment. The parties who utilize the finding of the examiner’s report to sue the auditor for malpractice are the trustees, creditors, major shareholders of the debtor, and any other party that may find joining the lawsuit is in the best interest of the society. The examiner’s investigation- first- focuses on many aspects of the debtor’s assets, liabilities, equities, and how the operation is carried out in compliance with rules and regulations. The examiner gathers, verifies, tests, and interprets information from different sources (employees, customers, vendors, lenders, and other professionals who provide service to the entity under investigation). Second,......

Words: 1260 - Pages: 6