Free Essay

The James Bulger Case

In: English and Literature

Submitted By Sathanel
Words 972
Pages 4
Give an outline of how the James Bulger Case is presented in texts 1, 2 and 3.
The first text, ”Every parents nightmare”, is a news article written by Mark McKay for BBC in October 2000. The article, in a chronologically and neutrally fashion, objectively describes the James Bulger Case from beginning to end. The text is dense in terms of factual information, as one would expect from a news article.

The second text, “Life after James”, is an article written by Blake Morrison for The Guardian Online in Februrary 2003. The article approaches the presentation of the James Bulger Case in a different way. By peaking behind thick curtains of opinions held by the public, the text man-ages to provoke thoughts and stimulate ideas. Blake Morris succesfully shifts the paradigm of the James Bulger Case by taking a step backwards, which leads the audience to the introduc-tion of the bigger picture, where he explains and examines his view; the James Bulger Case is a problem, but it is not the problem. The issue lies in the society itself.

The third and last text, “James Bulger killing; 20 years on”, is an article written by Amelia Hill for The Guardian Online in Februrary 2013. Arguably, the article is an addendum to the previ-ous text, “Life after James”. Amelia Hill takes the reader back twenty years, where she daringly questions the method of which the public, the media and the politicians used to deal with the case.
Analyse how Blake Morrison presents the James Bulger case in text 2. Here you must use your knowledge of stylistic analysis and give examples from the text to support your analysis.
Blake Morrison’s “Life after James” challenges the steadfast, sardonic and accepted view of the public and the media. By using various stylistic techniques, Morrison succeeds in pointing out that the sympathy shown by the public should not only regard James Bulger and his family, but also Thompson and Venables.
Throughout the article, Morrison makes use of artistic proof; pathos, logos and ethos.

The author uses pathos to emotionally charge sentences to enhance his message. The follow-ing, is a great example of how emotions are being added in a sentence that would otherwise have been completely factual:“That was Sunday, February 14, Valentine's Day.” The act of at-taching feelings to an otherwise inconsequential date prevails.

Another example of the utilization of pathos: "It was an adult courtroom, and an adult trial, despite the hours being shortened to school hours and the dock being raised by three inches so that the boys could see over the rail." By emphasising the age of murderes and the fact that children are able to inflict devastation in an unquantifiable degree, the author appeals to both anger and fear.

Another form of persuasive appeal employed by Morrison is logos. In his article he writes: “sales of toddler reins rose sharply, and in a survey of parents by the children's organisation, Kidscape, 97% of re-spondents put abduction as their biggest worry, ahead of traffic acci-dents, glue-sniffing and Aids.” The journalist and author combines factual data and informed opinions to support his statements.

Because of the fact that the article heavily relies on the appeal of pathos to deliver its message, the formality of the article is average. Based on the appeal of feelings, it is quite difficult to establish a connection with the reader when writing in informal language. However, the level of formality is high enough to maintain and support his ethos, which is very important for a journalist. An example of low formality would be: “Cartoons depicted timid adults kowtowing to giant, tantrumy babies.”, which sounds neat, but ‘tantrumy’ is not a word. Another example of low formality is when Mr. Morris begins a sentence with a preposition: “But evil isn't men-tioned”. A low level of formality is demonstrated when personal involvement is not being avoided. The author, on numerous occasions, uses “we” or “I”.
Taking your starting point in one of the texts, discuss your own view on the James Bulger Case. In your discussion, you must also include the terms natural evil and moral evil.
The human consciousness knows, defines and creates emotions based on the nature of con-trast. In other words, x cannot exist without y. One can apply this eastern philosophy to the bewilderment of modern culture. Evilness, be it natural or moral evil, cannot exist without goodness. Heroes cannot exist without villains. Blake Morris chooses to end his article in re-gards to the James Bulger Case by writing: Time to grow up. Evil won’t do. I agree. Imprisoning two children, pointing fingers and calling them evil is what we’ve done. What good has it done? As written earlier, Robert Thompson and Jon Venables are a problem, yes, but they are not the problem. The problem lies within the question of why did they behave in such way? The Ad-verse Childhood Experiences Study, seven years later, revealed that human behaviour is in fact not genetic. The emotional and social environment shapes the human brain and human behaviour. In other words, these boys have been shaped by traumas throughout their whole life.
Is punishing two suffering children justifiable? Amelia Hill raises the question of punishment and rehabilition, which has been a polarizing topic infiltrating all levels of society recently.
People need to realize that the public crusade, mainly fueled by the media, is being waged against two children who both, in some form or another, have been traumatized or abused throughout their childhood and have mental health problems. There is enough punishment in there that we don’t have to add even more punishment on top of that.

If punishment is chosen rather than rehabilitation, then who has the right to call the other evil?

Similar Documents

Free Essay

How Do the Theories of Emotion, Motivation and Development Explain the Events and Public Response to the James Bulger Case of 1993?

...How do the Theories of Emotion, Motivation and Development explain the events and public response to the James Bulger case of 1993? Theories allow people to see the world in a clear manner and allow them to perform actions based on what is rational. There are many theories that have evolved over the past century in Western cultures that attempt to explain how personalities develop, why people behave in certain ways, the type of environmental conditions that motivate them into acting in specific ways, and how these factors are interrelated. Some of the theories base their explanations on the social and emotional circumstances in the early years of an individual. This Essay aims to analyse the theories of emotion, motivation, and development and apply them to the events and public response to the James Bulger case of 1993. “ ‘I can never forgive Thompson and Venables for the horrendous, calculated, cold blooded murder of James.’ Said Denise Fergus the mother of the boy.” (Day. 2008). In an act that shocked the world, two ten year old boys, Jon Venables and Robert Thompson kidnapped and murdered James Bulger aged just two. The murder of James Patrick Bulger took place in Kirkby, Merseyside, England, on the 12 of February 1993. Bulger was a victim of abduction, torture and murder by two 10-year-old boys, named Robert Thompson (born 23rd August 1982) and the other one named Jon Venables (born 13th August 1982). It started with Bulger's disappearance on the 12 of February 1993...

Words: 2960 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Whitey

...Whitey the Mobster James Bulger was born on September 3, 1929, in Dorchester, Massachusetts. One of six children born to Catholic Irish parents, “Whitey” (so-named for his white-blond hair) grew up in a South Boston housing project. His father worked as a longshoreman. Bulger was a troublemaker and even lived out the childhood fantasy of running away with the circus when he was ten years old. “Whitey” Bulger was first arrested at age 14 for stealing, and his criminal record escalated from there. As a youth, he was arrested for larceny, forgery, assault and battery, and armed robbery and served five years in a juvenile reformatory. James had two brothers, Senator William "Billy" Bulger was a Korean War veteran and formerly an influential leader of the Democratic Party in Massachusetts. Senator Bulger rose to become President of the Massachusetts State Senate.his second brother Judge John "Jackie" Bulger, a retired Massachusetts court clerk magistrate who later was convicted of perjury. “Whitey” Bulger fathered one child that died at the age of 6 from Reye's syndrome after having a severe allergic reaction to an aspirin injection. Upon “Whitey’s” release from the reformatory, he joined the Air Force where he served time in military jail for assault before being arrested for going AWOL. James received an honorable discharge in 1952. James had a life of crime, being gang leader and being a fugitive. James Bulger returning to Boston after being discharged from the Air Force, embarked...

Words: 775 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Assignment 2

...Discuss one real life criminal case, taken from current events, identify the court that took jurisdiction. Explain why the court that took the case was the appropriate one for the particular circumstances. One of the fundamental questions of law is if a given court has the jurisdiction to preside over any given case. The jurisdictional question can be broken down into three components: whether there is over the person, whether there is jurisdiction over the subject matter, and whether there is jurisdiction to render the particular judgment sought. There are also different courts that have jurisdiction depending on the case. State courts have general jurisdictions, meaning that they can hear any controversy except those prohibited by their specific state laws. Federal courts have limited jurisdiction , meaning that they only exercise powers granted to them by the Constitution and Federal Laws. The criminal case I chose for this assignment is the case of James “ Whitey “ Bulger a crime syndicate head With a larger than life history that includes bank robbery, and being a gun supplier for the Irish Republican Army the one time F.B.I informant and head of Boston's Winter Hill Gang after being tipped off by an F.B.I agent of a pending racketeering indictment Bulger fled Boston in 1994 becoming ...

Words: 2341 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

How Credible Is the Hypodermic Needle Theory with Regards to the Effects Debate?

...The hypodermic needle theory regards the audience as passive and the power of media messages strong and that media influences people to behave in a certain way. The effects debate is the argument that the media has the potential to influence an audience, to affect them in negative ways, and that there is a need to protect people from material which might cause harm of one kind or another. The messages in the media are injected into the audience like a drug, but they don’t notice the effects that it has on them. The effects of messages in the media tend to be associated with bad behavior, and negative actions, especially regarding sex and violence. An example of this is the Sandy Hook Shooting, where the boy’s ruthless actions were blamed on the influence of the game Call of Duty by the New York Times, which he supposedly spent a lot of time playing alone in his basement. The hypodermic needle theory is also known as the hypodermic-syringe model of communications, and is referred to as the magic bullet theory. It implied mass media had a direct, immediate and powerful effect on its audiences. The mass media in the 1940s and 1950s was perceived as a powerful influence on behaviour change, yet according to Katz and Lazarfeld (1955), the model is rooted in 1930s behaviorism and is concerned by many to be obsolete today. The hypodermic needle model suggests that media messages are injected straight into a passive audience which is immediately influenced by the message. The study known...

Words: 792 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Black Mass Movie Essay

...and biography based on a man by the name of James Joseph Bulger, also known as “Whitey”. He and his Irish-American mob were notorious in Boston during the late 1970’s for protecting their infamous name and desired territory. The mob would go to any extreme to intimidate and frighten anyone who would interfere with their success. Cooper is credible for producing a movie that shows in-depth scenarios that happened to Whitey and his mob during the time. He also elaborates on the explicit confrontations the mob...

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Why Boys Become Vicious Summary

...In the newspaper article “Why Boys Become Vicious”, William Golding discusses the complexity of cruelty and the situations and cases in which cruelty can flourish. First, Golding begins to point out that there’s a simplicity that can be found in great moral leaders of Western civilization and then continues by comparing some evil people of the twentieth century to them, while pointing out that there was nothing simple about people like Hitler who committed terrible deeds. He then goes on to describe the crime committed by two ten year old boys, he explains that the older boys led James Bulger a two-year-old boy out of a shopping center and then proceeded to beating him and dumping him on train tracks. The author then says, “to contemplate that...

Words: 291 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Crime and Media

...instances of inaccuracy through the research. There are many on-going debates into Mass Medias influences on crime and violent crime in particular, but is this a true reflection of the current culture crisis or a fabrication to sell copy, taking for instance the Murder case of James Bulger in 1993, after the then 10year old boys Robert Thompson and Jon Venable led 2year old James away from a shopping centre in Liverpool to a brutal /senseless and pointless murder the Media was instantly ‘all over’ the case , even though a murder of children by children was extremely rare the reporting of and style of reporting throughout the case was reflecting to the public all that was now wrong in Britain, The Sun instantly called for ‘a crusade to rescue a sick society’, a ‘breed’ of violent children , single mother parenting , and dysfunctional underclass families where being painted as those whom would bare these types of violent monsters creating one of the most widely advertised Moral panics of the 20th Century (Cohen, 2002). Television and video games where two other forms of education for these child killers with many media organisations reporting that video nasty’s where the influence to the brutal murder of James...

Words: 2088 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Sociology

...belief of some psychiatrists that showing violent films to the disturbed individuals may help them to express their anger harmlessly. Also, they argue that television can have a pro-influence on children. They stated that ‘these portrayals of kindness, generosity, being helpful and socially responsible have been known to exert both short-term and long-term influences on similar behaviors among children. This provides us with a positive effect and shows that media violence does not produce violent behaviour. As the hypodermic syringe model suggests, children copy what they see and behave more aggressively in the real world. The James Bulger case supports this. Two ten year old boys killed a 3 year old toddler (James) after watching the movie ‘Child's play 3’. Evidence suggests that the boys copied the content within the film and performed similar acts on James. However, they do not have any proof that this is true and results try to generalise every child and suggest that they are all easily manipulated. Therefore it can not prove that media violence produces violent behaviour, as they do not have enough research evidence. Evidence suggests that there is no effect on violent behaviour through media violence. Hagell and Newburn compared the viewing of reading habits of 78 young offenders aged 12-18 years old with 500 school children of varied socioeconomic backgrounds. They found out that offenders did not watch more television or chose more violent programmes than...

Words: 546 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Are Moral Panics

...6/8/12 What are moral panics? What are 'moral panics'? Hayley Burns If we do not take steps to preserve the purity of blood, the Jew will destroy civilisation by poisoning us all. (Hitler, 1938) Surely if the human race is under threat, it is entirely reasonable to segregate AIDS victims, otherwise the whole of mankind could be engulfed. (The Daily Star, 2 December 1988) Although an extreme illustration, the above quotes serve to set up the creation of a 'moral panic'. Just as Hitler's 'facts' were unfounded, so too were The Daily Star and what resulted from both incidents was, in effect, the persecution of two minority groups within society. Hitler's quote stemmed from the use of propaganda, and although it would be fair to say that the essence of what is termed 'propaganda' does not exist in such a force today, it is nevertheless evident that what was quoted from The Daily Star is tantamount to propaganda. Throughout history, the mass media industry has been utilised as a tool to appeal to the public at large, particularly in the field of politics, where people in a position of power can tempt society into believing what they want them to believe. As Eldridge describes "The media, wittingly or unwittingly, reproduce the definitions of the powerful." [Eldridge 1997: 65] This document will examine not only the essence and origin of the term 'moral panic' but the very important nature of the media's involvement in the whole process of creating a 'moral panic'. It was Stanley...

Words: 3362 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

When Children See Too Much

...When Children See Too Much While violence is not new to the human race, it is an increasing problem in modern society. With greater access to firearms and explosives, the scope and efficiency of violent behavior has had serious consequences. We need only look at the recent school shootings and the escalating rate of youth homicides among urban adolescents to appreciate the extent of this ominous trend. While the causes of youth violence are multifaceted and include such variables as poverty, child abuse, family psychopathology, exposure to domestic and community violence, substance abuse and other psychiatric disorders, the research literature is quite compelling that a child's exposure to media violence plays an important role in the origin of violent behavior (Watson). While it is difficult to determine which children who have experienced televised violence are at greatest risk, there appears to be a strong correlation between media violence and aggressive behavior within vulnerable "at risk" segments of youth. Children spend more time in front of the television every week than they do on any other activity except sleeping (Muscari 31). Exposing children to violence can desensitize them to violence and cause them to act more aggressively. To understand human attraction to violent entertainment, it is necessary to look not only at, but beyond, the mass media. Depictions of violence, bloodshed and death are not new, and they certainly are not a product of the electronic...

Words: 3991 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Crime

...Prior to this, wartime rape and the provision of kidnapped 'comfort women' for soldiers had been regarded simply as a by - product of war. While legal sanctions hold, there is reasonable understanding about what constitut es crime, but this understanding tends to vary according to historical, cultural and power dimensions which may rule different behaviours as criminal at different times. Obvious examples of this are when laws change, so for example attempting suicide was regarded as a criminal offence until 1961, while incest was not classed as a crime until 1908. Similarly, female circumcision is acceptable in some cultures though not in the UK, while in contrast male circumcision has never been against the law, though in both cases genital mutilation occurs without the consent of the individual concerned. Age and mental state also influence whether someone is regarded as having committed a crime. The age of criminal responsibility varies considerably from country to country, so in the UK it is 10 while in Norway it is 15. The murder of two small children by other children in both countries in 1993 and 1994...

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should the Minimum Age of Responsibility Be Raised

...Should the minimum age of criminal responsibility be raised? ‘Boys will be boys’, but at what age does this no longer apply? At what age is a boy expected to take on the responsibilities of a man? The Children and Young Persons Act 1963 (s.16) provides that ‘It shall be conclusively presumed that no child under the age of ten years can be guilty of an offence’. This means that once a child in the UK reaches the age of ten they are as exposed and liable to the full weight of the law the same as any adult. The UK currently has the lowest minimum age of criminal responsibility (except Scotland at 8 but cannot be prosecuted until 12) within the European Union. This places the UK significantly below the average of 14 years old. There seems to be little justification for this deviance from the norm in regards to the minimum age of responsibility in the UK and there have been considerable publications pushing for the UK to raise the minimum age of criminal responsibility in the last decade, providing substantial evidence in favour of doing so. The evidence supporting the need to raise this minimum age can be found not only in psychology and scientific research regarding the brain development of youth and autonomy of children at this age, but also the severe social implications of criminalizing our youth. In order to argue that the minimum age of criminal responsibility (MACR) should be raised it will be necessary to identify and evaluate this evidence, as well as identifying...

Words: 4575 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Anti Social Behaviour

...Without a single definition of the term anti-social behaviour, what is, and what is not classified as anti-social behaviour, is an ongoing debate. The wide spectrum of behaviours which can be covered under the expression anti-social behaviour, differ greatly in levels of intensity. This is seen through The Scottish Executive, 2003, which states anti-social behaviour can encompass anything from dog fouling and littering, to sexual harassment and violence. The Home Office and the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 give different, yet both extremely vague, descriptions of anti-social behaviour; while the Home Office defines it as ‘any aggressive, intimidating or destructive activity that damages or destroys another person's quality of life,’ the 1998 Act expresses it as behaviour that ‘causes or is likely to cause alarm or distress to one of more persons not of the same households’. People hold different views on anti-social behaviour, due to how and where they were brought up, just as can generation and cultural differences cause diverse perceptions. Due to the vagueness of the term anti-social, it can allow anybody to be accused by anyone of being anti-social. This gives many problems as how to tackle anti-social behaviour, as the area of trouble is so large, and as society and technology is changing, new policy developments need to be continually made. A distinctive characteristic of anti-social behaviour is the insignificance of whether the criminal law has actually been broken....

Words: 1468 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

If Mass Society Didn't Exist, Would There Still Be Mass Media?

...In today’s time and age, mass society and mass media is a massive cultural wave that more or less plays a large role in society. Like it or not, mass society and mass media is largely intertwined with one another. In this essay, it will be discussed whether mass media is influenced by the presence of mass society. Mass society is a social system that is determined by mindless standardisation, the weakening of religion, a sense of alienation and moral emptiness, strained family and community ties, political indifference and the replacement of refined and high culture such as art and literacy with low culture which gives way to bland and unsophisticated tastes. The society concerned in this context is born from the modern, industrialised era where factory-produced, mass consumer goods precede home-grown goods which are produced on a smaller scale. The Industrial Revolution that took place in the 19th century contributed to the ‘soulless’ uniformity of the society and paved a way for the decline of traditional and aristocratic ways of past societies. Mass society is largely related to mass culture in which consumerism tendencies play a dominant role. It can also be defined as the young society which has been transformed from having individualistic, communal and pluralist characteristics to one which are of the total opposite of these values. Mass society is often seen as a threat to the American social, cultural and political life because it has changed American mass culture from...

Words: 1572 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Heightened Social Anxiety; Moral Panics and Deviancy Amplification Loops.

...paper assess’ Cohen’s’ ‘moral panic’ as a useful notion for explaining increased social anxiety about criminal behaviour using his work on ‘mods and rockers’ and Wilkins (1964:90) ‘Deviancy Amplification Feedback Loop’, a cyclic process that alienates perpetrators and increases sensitization to their actions creating more frequent arrests and often harsher punishments. Moral panics come and go and more often than not the ‘problem’ has been around for many years before it becomes accepted as a phenomenon that requires attention and reform. Often these moral panics are scapegoats of bigger issues in society (Goode & Ben-Yehuda, 2002:26). Such as Dungeons and Dragons (D&D) in the 1980’s being blamed for youth suicide in America after James Dallas Egbert III and Irving Pulling shot themselves in 1980 and 82 respectively, leading Pulling’s mother to set up B.A.D.D...

Words: 2385 - Pages: 10