Free Essay

The Solution to Ethnic and Racial Civil Conflict

In: Other Topics

Submitted By agaperste
Words 2466
Pages 10
The Solution to Ethnic and Racial Civil Conflict
Jacqueline Zhang
GOVT 150W Introduction to International Politics

Introduction
Within a period of three months in 1994, an estimated five to eight hundred thousand people were killed as a result of civil war and genocide in Rwanda. Large numbers were physically and psychologically afflicted for life through maiming, rape and other trauma; over two million fled to neighboring countries and maybe half as many became internally displaced within Rwanda. This human suffering was and is incomprehensible. Similar ethnic and racial civil conflicts have deeply scarred countries and are threatening to break out in many places around the globe. Too much blood has been shed for ethnic and racial causes and too many have died in ethnic and racial wars. In accordance to the constructivist model of nationalism, identity (re)construction solves ethnic and racial civil conflict.

Definition
For the purpose of demonstrating how identity (re)construction solves ethnic and racial civil conflicts, “solve” can be defined as 1) to explain and 2) to put an end to, settle. In addition, “explain” means to make clear the cause, origin or reason of. Furthermore, an ethnicity is a population of human beings whose members identify with each other, on the basis of a real or a presumed common genealogy or ancestry. The term race refers to the concept of dividing people into populations or groups on the basis of various sets of physical characteristics (which usually result from genetic ancestry.)

Literature Review
In contrast to constructivists who argue ethnic and racial identities are flexible social constructions that can be manipulated by political entrepreneurs and more or less freely adopted or ignored by individuals, primordialists see ethnic and racial identities as fixed by linguistic, thinking and behavioral background. Prominent primordialist theorist Clifford Geertz proposed his famous concept of “primordial attachment” in the article “The Integrative Revolution: Primordial Sentiments and Civil Politics in the New States.” He believed people were born into a particular religion, language, and social practice. Naturally, beyond personal affection, political alignment, practical necessity, and common interest, people are always bound by blood. Geertz argued for inherent ethnic and racial ties, the natural connections among those people and the divisions with others thereof. He coined the term “ancient hatred” to explain the causes of ethnic and racial conflicts and to prove that these ethnic and racial civil conflicts are unavoidable and extremely difficult to solve. However, the primordialist view of Geertz to simplify ethnic and racial hatred down to natural ties is incomplete, if not wrong. The resentment between two geographically close ethnicities and physically resembling races cannot be simply attributed to a natural tendency, and the flexibility of ethnic and racial identities cannot be simply denied because of the strong ties caused by birth. Primordialist statements arguing for inevitability of the mortal conflicts and the desolate impossibility to deter ethnic and racial wars are irresponsible claims. Far from the pessimism prevailing in primordialist view, ethnic and racial conflict can actually be ended via means of 1) suppression, 2) consociational democracy or 3) democratization. Forcible suppression of one side and complete victory for the other will reduce violence and at least temporarily stabilize the region. Consociational democracy, as proposed by Arend Lijphart, achieves ethnic peace through fair and equal share of governmental power. Democratization transforms national identity problems into constructive dialogues between ethnic or racial groups, provides political equality between groups and hands state (the winning government in power through free and fair election) legitimacy to construct national identity. As stated earlier, identity (re)construction also serves to end ethnic and racial civil conflict.

Origin of Ethnic and Racial Civil Conflict
Identity construction explains ethnic and racial civil conflict. It is not only possible but also prevalent, and it makes clear the reason of ethnic civil conflict. Officials in power use artificial propaganda to widen the differences and narrow the similarities between various ethnic and racial groups to create large-scale ethnic or racial conflict that was not there before. According to constructivist scholars Robert Donia and John Fine, distinct ethnic identities did not exist until late 19th century when the nationalism movement began. Despite the pre-modern world was limited and not as “global” as the world today, it was nevertheless consisted of ethnically diverse groups and had wars based on territories, religions, wealth, power etc. However, when religious communities and dynastic realms were prevailing, the need and condition for culturally similar people to form a “nation” were not present. No matter how the borders changed, almost all the countries would tolerate ethnic diversity and practical compromises. Ethnic rivalries and violence were not part of pre-modern world’s heritage. For centuries, the world had developed a rich tradition of diversity, pluralism and toleration that had flourished until recently. Despite the late emergence of ethnic identities, many people nowadays strongly identify themselves as a member of one ethnicity and many more died because of it. In his book Imagined Communities: Reflection on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, Benedict Anderson raised the question of what makes people live, die and kill in the name of nations. He then proceeded to answer by defining the state as something different from an actual community because “it is not (and cannot be) based on everyday face-to-face interactions between its members.” With the erosion of religious communities, the declining of dynastic realms and the rise of print capitalism in the late 19th century, nationalism took form in Europe and arose. “Nations” became the imagined objects of affection. Through mass propaganda such as vernacular poems, songs, war monuments and memorials, the political but “natural” love for the nation and thus willingness and readiness to die for it were also widely accepted. As seen with nationalism, the construction of ethnic and racial identities was through organized, propagandized manipulation. The non-existence of distinct ethnic and racial identities and its construction thereof can be demonstrated through the example of Rwanda Genocide. Before they were colonized, ethnic and racial differences between Hutus and Tutsis were not very clear; they shared the same language, respected the same traditions and inhabited the same land. There was also no cultural or folkloric custom specific to either Hutus or Tutsis. Before the German and Belgian colonization, the Hutus and Tutsis lived together for hundreds of years. The colonial period had a distinct role in creating and exacerbating the differences between Hutus and Tutsis. Originally, the denotation of Hutu and Tutsi’s social distinction was only a division of task, not a separation of ethnicity. It was the Germans and Belgians who created “tribes” based on aesthetic physical impression and told the Tutsis that they were superior to Hutus. During the period prior to the genocide, Rwanda’s Prime Minister Kambanda, had sanctioned a climate of hatred and paranoia and incited violence, and ultimately sanctioned mass murder. Because of the 1963 and 1990 invasions by the Tutsis, Kambanda wanted to create a Hutu state without Tutsis. In addition, the journal Kangura openly called for ethnic hatred and the ethnical genocide. Furthermore, a large portion of the military or militarized Hutus was also using this massacre of Tutsis as an opportunity to take revenge on the socially powerful people. They could now steal and kill elite Tutsis at will and be awarded for it. As demonstrated here, the construction of Hutu-Tutsi identities led to the civil war that eventually caused at least 750,000 people’s lives.

Solution to Ethnic and Racial Civil Conflict
Identity reconstruction puts an end to ethnic and racial civil conflict. Keeping in mind of the constructivist model, which asserts that 1) individuals have multiple ethnic (and potentially racial) identities and 2) the identity with which individuals identify fluctuates depending upon a particular causal variable, reconstruction of identities can put an end to ethnic and racial civil conflict. This can be achieved through the deconstruction of the xenophobic myth about ethnicity and race and the reconciliation of the differences and hatred through reconstruction of identities. Being the famous theorist in the primordialist camp, even Stephen van Evera proposed to solve ethnic and racial conflict through the removal of xenophobic myth about ethnicity and race by encouraging honest histories of inter-group relations. Oftentimes, as a result of a long period of negative experience, opposite sides in the ethnic and racial conflict portray the other as monstrous and murderous. However, they cannot forget they share similar, if not the same, geographical, cultural and linguistic root. If only they would be willing to sincerely discuss histories and trace their footsteps, then they might realize what they have in common is more than they do not. Van Evera also proposes to use economic leverage to promote peaceful conduct. In this way, outside powers can enforce peace temporarily in the hope that reduced security threats would permit moderate leaders within each group to facilitate honest dialogues about their inter-group histories instead of launching untruthful propagandas. In addition, constructivist Holly Williams concluded ethnic and racial identities are both fluid and endogenous. Through the case of increasing immigration and participation of ethnic minorities and empirically examining 20 countries in Latin America, Williams proved the reconstruction of identities to be possible and the constructivist model to be valid. Contrary to primordialist opinions, Williams’ study demonstrated that countries with more immigrants showed less ethnic-linguistic and racial fractionalization because immigrants do in fact reconstruct their identities, assimilate and inter-marry. She attributed this phenomena to three causes: 1) immigrants accept the duty to compromise their own cultures 2) individuals who leave their homeland voluntarily have weaker ethnic identities and 3) states that allow more immigration have more liberal and tolerant cultures. This demonstrated that as long as each side has successfully deconstructed the xenophobic content of one another, they would embrace and emerge to have new identities reconstructed. The plausibility and effectiveness of identity reconstructions to racial civil conflict is shown with South Africa. The National Party legally enforced a system of racial segregation, apartheid, from 1948 to 1990. The apartheid government formalized and expanded segregationist policies that had existed less formally under colonial rule. Institutionalized racism stripped South African blacks of their civil and political rights and instituted segregated education, health care, and all other public services, only providing inferior standards for blacks and other non-Afrikaans. Internal resistance was met with police brutality, administrative detention, torture, and limitations on freedom of expression. However, after a most peaceful transition to a democracy with the 1994 election, the newly elected government was able to resolve this racial conflict through identity reconstruction. As proposed by the Truth and Reconciliation Committee, besides economic reparations to the victims and their families of gross human right violations, symbolic reparations were also implemented through 1) individual benefits such as exhumation and reburials 2) community benefits such as renaming streets and facilities and 3) national benefits such as a day of remembrance and reconciliation. As described by Archbishop Desmond Tutu and President Nelson Mandela, South Africans were reconstructed to identify themselves as citizens of a Rainbow nation. In this rainbow nation, black and white alike are entitled equality. Today, South Africa remains the most advanced country in Africa, with thriving cities that are integrated into the global economy. Millions of blacks have been educated and risen out of poverty and there has been no significant racial conflict since 1994. As demonstrated through the reconciliation in South Africa, identity reconstruction indeed puts an end to ethnic and racial conflict.

Conclusion
As identity construction explains ethnic civil war, identity reconstruction also settles ethnic civil war. As demonstrated, distinct ethnic identities are artificial products of propaganda and their creations are the cause of terrible wars. Deconstruction of xenophobic myth about ethnic identities and reconstruction through shared social, cultural and political roots can actually solve the conflict and return stability.
Clearly, identity (re)construction solves ethnic and racial civil conflict.

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. David Millwood. "The International Response to Conflict and Genocide: Lessons from the Rwanda Experience." Steering Committee of the Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda. http://www.oecd.org/countries/rwanda/50189764.pdf.
[ 2 ]. “Solve,” and “explain,” Oxford English Dictionary.
[ 3 ]. Diffen. "Ethnicity vs Race." - Difference and Comparison. http://www.diffen.com/difference/Ethnicity_vs_Race.
[ 4 ]. Chaim Kaufmann, “Possible and Impossible Solutions to Ethnic Civil Wars,” International Security, Vol. 20, No. 4 (Spring, 1996), p. 140.
[ 5 ]. Clifford Geertz, "The Integrative Revolution: Primordial Sentiments and Civil Politics in the New States," In Old societies and new states: the quest for modernity in Asia and Africa, (New York: The Free Press of Glencoe, 1963), pp. 105-157.
[ 6 ]. Ibid.
[ 7 ]. Ian Lustick, “Stability in Deeply Divided Societies: Consociationalism versus Control,” World Politics, Vol. 31, No. 3 (April 1979), pp. 325-344.
[ 8 ]. Arend Lijphart, "Consociational Democracy," World Politics, Vol. 21, No. 2 (January 1969).
[ 9 ]. Marjolein Bomhof, "Democratization: Resolution of National Identity Issues." Social Cosmos (October 2002).
[ 10 ]. Robert J Donia, and John V. A. Fine, Bosnia and Hercegovina: a tradition betrayed, (New York: Columbia University Press, 1994.)
[ 11 ]. Benedict R. O Anderson, Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism, Rev. and extended ed., (London: Verso, 1991..); print capitalism: printing began in 15th c, aimed at Latin readers, but this market was saturated after 150 years, and focus shifted to vernaculars. Between 1820 & 1920 national print-languages were of central ideological and political importance in Europe. The concept of “nation”, once invented, became widely available for pirating, and was imported to a diverse array of situations and ideologies.
[ 12 ]. Anderson, Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism.
[ 13 ]. Alain Destexhe, Rwanda and genocide in the twentieth century, (New York: New York University Press, 1995.)
[ 14 ]. John Mueller, “The Banality of Ethnic War,” International Security, Vol. 25 (Summer 2000), pp.42-70; Linda Melvern, Conspiracy to Murder: The Rwandan Genocide, 2004 (London: Verso), p. 1.
[ 15 ]. Viera Bacova, "The Construction of National Identity on Primordialsm and Instrumentalism," Human Affiars, Vol. 8, pp. 29-43.
[ 16 ]. Stephen Van Evera, "Managing the Eastern Crisis: Preventing War in the Former Soviet Empire," Security Studies, pp. 361-381.
[ 17 ]. Ibid.
[ 18 ]. Holly Williams, "Ethnicity Reconstruction: The Effect of Immigration on Ethnic-Linguistic Fractionalization in Latin America."
[ 19 ]. United States Institute of Peace. "Truth Commission: South Africa." United States Institute of Peace. http://www.usip.org/publications/truth-commission-south-africa (accessed May 7, 2014).
[ 20 ]. Truth and Reconcilation Committee. "A SUMMARY OF REPARATION AND REHABILITATION POLICY." REPARATION & REHABILITATION COMMITTEE TRANSCRIPTS, POLICIES & ARTICLES. http://www.justice.gov.za/trc/reparations/summary.htm (accessed May 7, 2014).
[ 21 ]. Greg Myre . "20 Years After Apartheid, South Africa Asks, 'How Are We Doing?'." NPR, May 6, 2014, http://www.npr.org/blogs/parallels/2014/05/06/310095463/20-years-after-apartheid-south-africa-asks-how-are-we-doing edition.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

The Colonial Period: the Root Cause of the Politically Unstable State of the Sudan

...becoming independent meant something far more than simply gaining back territory. For some, it was the beginning of a stable government, a local economy and a cultural comeback. For others such as the Sudan, it was the start of tragic consequences driven by political conflicts and civil wars. Through the process of decolonization that began, African leaders worked to shape the character of their postcolonial state, usually either against the continued European cultural and political predominance, while others worked with European powers in order to maintain an economically and politically stable state. As the success of each nation and region of Africa widely varied after their independence, their progress also varied. Unfortunately, some are still struggling to overcome these crucial instabilities preventing them from being at peace within their own state, and internationally. By examining Sudan and the decades leading up to its current political, social, and economic state, this paper will highlight the ways in which colonialism has effectively shaped the state's current context. It will give an overview of the current conflict in the western region of Darfur within Sudan's political instability, civil wars, and crisis of identity. More specifically, it will aim at showing how colonialism left the state of Sudan...

Words: 3381 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Racial Conflict

...John Powers Global Connections Mackey 22 Oct 2015 Racial Conflict Differences between races will always be based on biological factors. All homo-sapiens on earth are human, however it is the social structures created by the different physical attributes that differ between us where prejudices appear. The history that racial and ethnic groups already have between one another also is a primary reason for conflict between racial and ethnic groups. While racism in America seems to be less of an issue now, than during the early years of the country, the simple fact that racism was present before is a motivating factor for conflict between whites and African-Americans today. What we see today in America are conflicts of prejudice between law enforcement agencies and the citizens they police over. Most notably within the past 3 years are the Ferguson riots incited by the supposed police brutality that has been extensively talked about through news coverage and blown out of proportion through social media. Michael Brown was supposedly wrongfully killed by police which created the toxic environment of constant police brutality related to racism. In the US, racism is a well known issue. From racial profiling to other issues such as affirmative action, police brutality against minorities and the history of slavery and the rising resentment against immigrants. Racism in America is not only against the black community but among many other races as well. Since the horrific......

Words: 1344 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Social Justice and Equality: Racial Profiling

...Justice and Equality: Racial Profiling Galina Shlikht, Nicole Gordon and Becky Overstreet City University of Seattle Author’s Note Galina Shilkht, Student, City University Nicole Gordon, Student, City University Becky Overstreet, Student, City University Social Justice and Equality Team Outline (All) Conflict and Solutions 1. Faulty communication Sometimes criticism can be given inappropriately. This can result in hurting the feelings of group members leaving them feeling devalued. When this happens, we as a team believe the first thing that must be done is to be honest and let the group know how you feel. So we must acknowledge the conflict. The next appropriate step would be to discuss the conflict with all of the team members. After this, we should try and understand the situation and reach an agreement. One of the agreements could be that criticism be given appropriately and constructively. 2. Time management With work, kids, and living in different time zones it can be a challenge to find the time that works best for the three of us to discuss the details, questions, and/or concerns about our essay together. Our solution to this is to set up exact times and day, sort of like an online appointment, for when the three of us can be available via Facebook group message. 3. Personality clashes We all have our own way of doing things. Our styles of working might be different and sometimes this can cause a conflict with each other......

Words: 4053 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Kennedy Doctrine

...What are the reasons for ethnic conflict and what are the solutions for their resolve?  Reasons for ethnic conflict are “internal strife tied to cultural such as values, goals, and practices, tribal animosities between Nigeria and Rwanda, religious conflicts between India and Lebanon, and other ethnic animosities such as racial prejudice with in South Africa.” (2011, p.94-95) A solution for their resolve is “democratic, mature, and enlightened political leadership, a spirit of compromise, and the implementation of politically negotiated solutions such as federalism (“a system of government that emanates from the desire of people to form a union without necessarily losing their various identities.” 2011, p.119) and consociational democracy. “(“A careful division of political power designed to protect the rights of all participants. Which involves: The leaders of all important ethnic groups must form a ruling coalition at the national level, Each group has veto power over government policy, or at least over policies that affect them, Government funds and public employment, such as the civil service, are divided between ethnicities, with each receiving a number of posts roughly proportional to its population and Each ethnic group is afforded a high degree of autonomy over its own affairs.” 2011, p. 120) (2011, p.130) What conditions must be present for a state of relative concord to exist? The conditions are for them to “establishing a basis for coexistence between these......

Words: 467 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Concepts Paper

...Films mimic the human experience in a way that other visual mediums cannot. Cinema’s basis in fiction and fact is what makes for an excellent lens through which to view the human experience. Over the course of the semester, we were instructed to watch two films. “Food Inc.”, a harsh look inside America’s corporate controlled food Industry, while “The Vernon John’s Story: The Road to Freedom” is a film that portrays the inspirational story of Martin Luther King Jrs’ successor as he interminably campaigns for Civil Rights. While seemingly different themes, each film portrays two issues important in sociology. After all, sociology can be defined as the scientific study of human social behavior and its origins, development, and organizations. Sociologists use many ways to analyze subjects from a sociological perspective. These ways are known today as the symbolic interactionist perspective, the functionalist perspective, and the conflict perspective. Each perspective uniquely conceptualizes society, social forces, and human behavior. The purpose of this essay is not so much as to narrate each film but rather to illustrate a better understanding for three commonly misunderstood perspectives. Although a daily occurrence, the consumption of food can also be associated with important moments in our lives. In the context of society, our nation’s food system is at the core of numerous social movements, political issues, and economic debates. After watching “Food Inc.”, we see that......

Words: 1149 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

New in America

... African American and Hispanics are two immigrant groups that have become assimilated into American society. Assimilation, as referred to in the text, is changing or adopting new customs and beliefs to fit in or become apart of a major or dominant culture. The United States, unlike any other country, has many races, ethnicities, nationalities, religions, and opportunities. Other ethnic groups believe that the only way to advance in life is by adopting new cultures and becoming apart of the norm. A vast majority of Mexicans and Puerto Ricans arrived in America to flee hardship and to find a way to make a living. California and Texas combine for more than half of the Hispanic residents in America (Guisepi, n.d). There are about two thirds of Puerto Ricans that reside in the U.S. who are currently in the New York City area, including nearby New Jersey. Most Cuban Hispanics live in the state of Florida, with the greatest population in Miami (Guisepi, n.d.). Second-generation Puerto Ricans generally have a distinct orientation than first-generation immigrants, which is the inland culture instead of the......

Words: 1252 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Amazing!

...responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. • Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly different depending on the modality in which you attend class. If you have recently changed modalities, read the policies governing your current class modality. Course Materials Harvey, C. P., & Allard, M. J. (2009). Understanding and managing diversity (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. Schaefer, R. T. (2011). Racial and ethnic groups (12th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. All electronic materials are available on the student website. |Week...

Words: 2546 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Affirmative Action

...AFFIRMATIVE ACTION   What is affirmative action?               As your advisors, paid handsomely to represent the issue of Affirmative Action in the United States to you, we have gathered and analyzed the core considerations surrounding the issue. We see that there are immense difficulties in reconciling opposing moral views, and that empirical data does not reveal an obvious truth.  But there can be much gained in way of a better understanding of the issue in spite of these obstacles if we can take a holistic approach to the problem. Affirmative action is a two-pronged effort that includes “the right of all persons to be accorded full and equal consideration on the basis of merit” (K.U Medical School) and, concurrently, a policy of actively “hiring and promoting qualified individuals in protected groups such as minorities, disabled veterans, Vietnam-era veterans and women” (U. of South Dakota). It was created to focus on education and jobs, and the policies were put in place to take active measures, under the framework of non-discrimination, to ensure that disadvantaged groups that had prevalently suffered discrimination have the same opportunities as whites. The U.S. Department of Labor describes affirmative action as the “ban[ing of] discrimination and requir[ing of] contractors and subcontractors to take… action to ensure that all individuals have an equal opportunity for employment, without regard to race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability or status......

Words: 4179 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Discussion on Canadian Ethnic Problems and Multiculturalism

...Discussion on Canadian Ethnic problems and multiculturalism Abstract: The history of Canada has gone through various events, some of which produced a nightmare for the country and from which the people as well as the leaders are still trying to awake, while making sure that such events do not take place ever again. In this essay I discuss the Canadian Ethnic problems and it's multiculturalism by mainly focus on two typical examples :the aboriginal people and the Chinese who have suffered injustice through out the history in different aspects such as politics and cultural. And later ,by looking at the current situations of the Canadian ethnicity in general and going over the past decisions that the government had made, I try to suggest the possible solutions. Introduction: As we all know, Canada is a country with large immigrants. Therefore , the history of Canada is largely the history of the meeting of different cultures. As its early settlers are mostly immigrants from Central and Western Europe, European culture is playing a dominant role in Canada's culture. Since the eightieth of the twentieth century, as the number of immigrants from different parts increased significantly, the new immigrants brought in their own culture with them as well. Thus, people are now feeling more of the tensions between those cultures and of prejudice felt among these groups toward one another. For this reason, how to deal with the......

Words: 2058 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Conflict and Resolution

...causes of Africa internal conflicts (1000 word) INTRODUCTION Conflict usually occurs primarily as a result of a clash of interests in the relationship between parties, groups or states, either because they pursuing opposing or incompatible goals. Although the term war is sometimes used as a synonym for conflict, it is more usual to restrict the meaning of war to violent conflict, involving armed forces. But like war, conflict is and has been throughout history a normal way of conducting disputes between political groups within human society. As David Weeks puts it, “conflict is an inevitable outcome of human diversity and a world without conflict is not desirable, because it would mean a world without diversity.” Africa is a diverse continent – diverse in ethnic, religious and socio-cultural terms. The 1990s saw no diminution in the number of conflicts in Africa, and most forecasts predicted further increase. While Africa has had its share of inter-state wars, the majority of its conflicts were internal, and these internal conflicts appear to be increasing, as elsewhere. A tragic factor in this is that the civilian populations bear the brunt of the casualties in such conflicts, estimated at some 80-90 per cent of total casualties across the world. These conflicts cause not only casualties and refugees but contribute vastly to the spread of disease, malnutrition and starvation, social and economic decline and moral deterioration. AFRICAN CONFLICTS AND VIOLENCE There......

Words: 1673 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Genocide and Human Rights

...The instances of genocide in the late 20th century stand as a testament to how unreliable the nation state can be when inalienable and human rights are concerned. As is shown in the case of Rwanda, non-state actors have taken steps to trample on these rights even when the victim technically has citizenship in a country. Additionally, the nation-state can reinforce the actions of the non-state actors through either sponsorship, or even inaction in the face of genocide. Civil society actors have taken steps to act where the nation-state has failed to do so out of what Ayers identifies as labeling the conflict as internal or a civil war. Ultimately, both Ayers and Power agree that labeling genocide as what it is, and taking other steps outside of raw military force can go a long way in preventing the atrocities of the 20th century. More specifically, since the nation-state alone cannot be trusted to handle these situations, civil society must take steps to better the diplomacy of the nation-state, along with creating an international community that can work together to remedy the problems of human and inalienable rights violations. In her article “Raising the Cost of Genocide,” Samantha Power examines the historical response to genocide by discussing the ways in which western powers have avoided responsibility for 20th century atrocities. She begins her article by explaining the invention of the word genocide as a word meant to “send shudders down the spines of those who heard......

Words: 6387 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Genocide

...of genocide, power and resources are usually the propagators of this vice. In a state in which the availability and distribution of resources is anything short of equal, negative ethnic traits such as tribalism, nepotism and even clanism, in other cases, can easily result in the onset of genocide. Greed is also a consistent feature of many genocide-stricken states. The more worrying issue, apart from the killing of millions of innocent civilians, is the prejudice with which many of the leaders of these factions plan and coordinate these atrocities. The notion that leaders are well above the law is characteristic of states that have felt the iron grip of genocide. The case of Darfur is one of the most disheartening. Darfur has been embroiled in the throes of genocide for the better part of the 21st Century. Having been the first genocide of the 21st Century, the mention of Darfur does not resonate well on the global landscape. Upon the realization of freedom from the British, Sudan had little time to pause and draw a clear and concise roadmap that would spearhead development. For the large remainder of the 20th Century, Sudan suffered civil wars as the Northern Muslims fought with the Southern non-Muslims. The fact that Northern Sudan was more commercially viable than the South sparked off the civil wars, with both sides...

Words: 2199 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Where Do You Want to Be

...Study of Race and Ethnicity? What Leads to the Creation of Subordinate-Group Status? What Are the Consequences of Subordinate-Group Status? How Does Change Occur in Race Relations? ISBN 1-256-48952-2 2 Racial and Ethnic Groups, Thirteenth edition, by Richard T. Schaefer. Published by Merrill Prentice Hall. Copyright © 2012 by Pearson Education, Inc. Exploring Race and Ethnicity Minority groups are subordinated in terms of power and privilege to the majority, or dominant group. A minority is defined not by being outnumbered but by five characteristics: unequal treatment, distinguishing physical or cultural traits, involuntary membership, awareness of subordination, and ingroup marriage. Subordinate groups are classified in terms of race, ethnicity, religion, and gender. The social importance of race is derived from a process of racial formation; any biological significance is relatively unimportant to society. The theoretical perspectives of functionalism, conflict theory, and labeling offer insights into the sociology of intergroup relations. Immigration, annexation, and colonialism are processes that may create subordinate groups. Other processes such as extermination and expulsion may remove the presence of a subordinate group. Significant for racial and ethnic oppression in the United States...

Words: 17357 - Pages: 70

Premium Essay

Diversity

...in the way that was taught in this course; people come from many backgrounds and have rich and full cultures who live right here in my own community. Now that I see these cultures in a different light due to this course I can enjoy them more and not feel like they are so different from me and when they are different I can embrace those differences. Growing up in an urban area I was part of a very diverse neighborhood. The south side of town where I grew up was mixed with many races. There were African Americans, Hispanics, Asians, Caucasians, and many mixed races. As children I don’t think we paid too much attention to the racial tension that went on around us. I had friends of different races and for the most part we all got along. I remember times were some of the kids in the neighborhood would get into fights and you could see the racial divide that would unfold if those fighting were of different races. You would see kids taking sides of their own race because they probably feared that they wouldn’t be accepted by their own people. Over these years I think more people have become accustomed to living in such diverse communities and have accepted people for who they are and what they have to offer to the community. Over the last 30 years of my life I have witnessed discrimination, racism, stereo-typing, and...

Words: 1285 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Hate Crimes

...Nazi solution for the Jews. More recently we have experienced the ethnic cleansing in Bosnia and genocide in Rwanda. Racial and religious bias seems to be the inspiration for most hate crimes in the United States. Even as the United States was being settled in the 16th and 17th centuries, the Native Americans were the victims of intimidation and violence. During the last two hundred years, examples in the United States include lynching of African Americans, cross burnings to dive black families out of white neighborhoods, assaults on gay and lesbian people, and painting swastikas on Jewish synagogues. In the United States, over 8, 000 hate crimes were reported in 1995. Over one third were against African Americans, while the others were motivated by biases anti white, anti Jewish, anti gay, and anti Hispanic. Nearly 7 years ago a former Ku Klux Klansman, Thomas E. Blanton Jr. was convicted for blowing up a church in Birmingham and killing four young black girls in 1963. Also in 1963, Alabama Governor George C. Wallace ordered National Guard Troops to block black students from entering public schools. Birmingham safety commissioner Eugene “Bull” Conner turned German shepards and fire hoses on peaceful demonstrators. These are just a few examples of cases less than 50 miles from Ragland. Hate crime laws fall into several categories: (a) specific bias motivated acts as distinct crimes; (b) criminal penalty enhancement; (c) creation of a distinct civil......

Words: 1207 - Pages: 5