The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plant

In: Business and Management

Submitted By lucaswq
Words 1042
Pages 5
Case Analysis
The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plan
April 10, 2012











Summary
The case study is talk about job dissatisfaction and high turnover rate at the Lima Tire Plant, which is one of the 8 manufacturing units operated by the Treadway Tire Company. In 2007, more than half of the foremen at the Lima facility had turn over. The turnover rate is the highest one over the past 10 years at Treadway, and also the high foremen turnover rate is the major concern for Ashley Walls who is the Director of Human Resources in the Lima Plant. Her major objectives are cost cutting, increase productivity, and reducing turnover.
The next I will directly show some problems which the Lima Tire Plant had from the case. And then I give the corresponding suggestions and solutions for them,












Main Problems
From the case we could know the exact job dissatisfaction and high turnover situation at Lima Tire Plant. In order to logical analyze these I would discuss from the individual (foremen) to the integration (company).

The foremen:
First of all, I think the daily production evaluations of the Lima Tire Plant were too strict. Some of the variations in the production quantity and quality were not under the foreman’s control, specifically as it relates to machines breaking down. But the executive leaders just focus on daily production. Such as the plant manager Bellinghan thought the most important duty for the foreman is meet performance goals. They gave the foremen too much pressure which affect the foreman cannot use clear brain to deal with daily issues happened in product line.
Secondly, the foremen had too many responsibilities, but they did not have relative authority. Every day the line foreman need to deal with lots of different personnel,…...

Similar Documents

Treadway Tire Case

...The Treadway Tire Company Case Study Introduction The Treadway Tire Company in Lima, Ohio is faced with rather difficult times. These difficulties however are not due to lack of work with a down recession, or even too much demand and not enough capacity to fill it. These issues are deep within the company and effect the organization very seriously every day. Every company of course has issues but in the case of The Treadway Tire Company these are problems that have been haunting them and continuously increasing their turnover rate for consecutive years. Dissatisfaction from one key position in the company is taking a serious toll on the daily operations of the company and causing performance and output to suffer because of it .If the Treadway Tire Company does not begin to make some changes and get a grasp on these major issues then they will begin to see the effects of these problems on their bottom line. In order to make these changes Treadway must first identify what the key issues are and develop an action plan on how to fix these and prevent them from happening in the future. The two major problems that seem to be continuously occurring are 1.) The lack in overall communication throughout all levels of the organization and 2.) The delegation of power and discipline within the company. Finding solutions to these issues is the next major concern for this company and will help them get the plant...

Words: 2842 - Pages: 12

Treadway Tire Case Study

... a high rate of foremen turnover with 23 of the 50 foremen leaving their post. Ashley Wall, the Director of Human Resources, is determined to improve Lima’s 46% turnover rate. She plans on performing a thorough analysis of the root cause complete with corrective actions. Problem Definition There is a low level of job satisfaction at the Lima Tire Plant that is causing a high rate of employee turnover, specifically in the foremen position. Morale and productivity are also suffering as the foremen are under immense pressure to produce results in a sink or swim environment. Relevant Theories and Models An important theory illustrated at the Lima Tire Plant relates to the three components of attitudes. The foremen’s cognitive component of attitude is the belief that they own too many responsibilities within the plant, yet not enough authority to effectively deal with them. They are expected to meet or exceed operational targets regardless of their day to day challenges. An employee satisfaction survey displayed the foremen’s affective component of attitude. They felt powerless against the hourly employees who were protected by the union and felt unsupported by upper management who expected them to just get the job done without the necessary skills and tools to do so. As a result, the behavioral component of attitude from the foremen was to just quit. Of the 23 foremen who left their position, 43% had done so voluntarily. A major job attitude that is affecting...

Words: 1559 - Pages: 7

A Diagnostic Analysis of the Lima Tire Plant

....; Huddleston, Patricia. (2006). Worker morale in Russia. Journal of managerial psychology. 21(5). Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com. ezproxy1.apus.edu/docview/215868077?accountid=8289 Morgan, G. (1998). Images of organization: The executive edition. San Francisco, CA: Berrett- Koehler Publishers Morgan, G. (1989). Creative organization theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Oliver, Stan (2006). How to develop culture in organizations: A multiple case study of large Distributed organizations. Journal of knowledge management. 10(4). Retrieved http://search.proquest.com/docview/230301651?accountid=8289 Skinner, W., Beckham, H. (2008). The Treadway Tire Company: Job dissatisfaction and high turnover at the Lima tire plant. Brief Cases. 2189. Harvard Business Publishing. Zorn, Theodore, E.; Violanti, T. (1996). Communication abilities and individual achievement in organizations. Management Communication Quarterly : McQ. 10(2) Retrieved from http:// search.proquest.com.ezproxy1.apus.edu/docview/ 216296901?accountid=8289 http://www.managementskillsadvisor.com/effective-communication-in-the-workplace.html Retrieved online Feb. 25, 2012...

Words: 2977 - Pages: 12

Treadway Tire Company

...QUESTIONS: 1) What is the relationship between line foreman at Treadway’s Lima Plant and other groups within the plant : General supervisors and areas managers, top management, the union, hourly workers, each other? Treadway Tire Company is one of the largest producers of tires. The Lima plant located at Lima in Ohio had 1,120 employees. 970 of them were hourly employees and 150 were salaried employees. They work in 12-hour shifts. Line foremen are salaried floor level managers who supervise hourly employees. 970 hourly workers were supervised by 50 line foremen. Line foremen didn’t have good relationship with hourly workers. They expressed concerns about their lack of authority and adversarial relations with the hourly workers. Several incidents highlighted tension between hourly workers and line foremen. Line foremen were supervised by 13 general supervisors. Line foremen are endowed with lot of responsibilities. General supervisors abused and threatened the line foremen with poor performance review if they are unable to meet the forecasted performance. This indicates poor relationship between them. The responsibilities of the line foremen include documenting the employee disciplinary actions and negotiating the work standards with union reps. The union reps on grievance committee sometimes provides cleared record the hourly employee without providing any explanations to the line foremen. There isn’t...

Words: 925 - Pages: 4

The Treadway Tire Company

...Transcript of Case study 2: The Treadway Tire Company Case Study 2 The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plant -The IT company in this movie has a terrible employee organization, as well as over pressured managers who tend to hassle lower employees, which causes main Character Peter Gibbons to be highly unsatisfied with his job and sabotage the company -Retail and Restaurant industry has some of the highest turnover rates. But the retail stores and restaurants that fully train their employees, are flexible and institute a culture that fosters loyalty are the ones that most overcome job dissatisfaction - Balance hiring policy by adhering to 60% internal hires, 30%college graduates & 10% company transfers - Implement rotating 8 hour shifts instead of 12 hour shifts - Re-institure the month long rotational training program for foremen - As they learn new task they gain higher pay so this month long training doesn't cost company too much - Start an internship program that brings in potential employees without having to pay them unless they are offered a full-time job -Assign area managers as formal mentors to expose foremen to the key processes in the plant as well as inform them on authority and Union issues -Then routinely assess job satisfaction and be ready to change plan when necessary Works Cited How to Keep Your Best Employees: Developing an Effective Retention Policy [and Executive Commentary] Terence R. Mitchell...

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Case Study- Treadway Tire Company

... Treadway tire plants line foremen are salaried paid, floor-level, non-union managers who supervise the hourly paid line-production employees. The Lima plant has 50 line foremen and there are three general supervisors who were managing several of the line segments. There are five area managers at the Lima plant who are responsible for the general supervisors, the hourly tire production team, and the line-foremen in their sector. The plant manager Brandon Bellingham Case Study: Treadway Tire Company 5 had the responsibility of overseeing the entire plant (Skinner & Beckham, 2008). References Skinner, C. W., & Beckham, H. (2008). The Treadway tire company: job dissatisfaction and high turnover at the Lima tire plant. Harvard Business Publishing Brief Cases....

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Treadway Tire Company

... the employee their strong/weak areas and tell them where they stand in the organization. The absence of appraising employees and providing feedback in The Treadway Tire Company has caused motivation issue within the foremen pool as they do not see any advancement opportunity. Under the light of Tom Hamilton statement, “My line foremen just don’t see any way to move up at Lima. I always recommend the guys with the most long-term management potential to Human Resources, but whenever there’s a general supervisor vacancy, someone else, usually some college grad, gets hired” this indicates the major cause of high turnover as foremen are not motivated to work hard and efficiently as they know that there is no room for them to move up the hierarchy. Previous Entry  Machine Bureaucracy Diana Rosemary Sharpe A machine bureaucracy describes a form of organization in which the prime coordinating mechanism in the design of the organization is the standardization of work processes. The key features of a machine bureaucracy include design based on vertical and horizontal job specialization, functional grouping of activities, vertical centralization, limited horizontal decentralization, and efforts to sustain behavior formalization. The concept of a machine bureaucracy was described by Henry Mintzberg in relation to a specific type of organizational structural configuration.  * machine bureaucracies are typically found in the mature organizations, large enough to have the......

Words: 821 - Pages: 4

Case Study Unit 5: the Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plant

...Case Study Unit 5: The Treadway tire company: Job dissatisfaction and high turnover at the Lima tire plant Strategic Human Resources Management April 20, 2014 Case Study Unit 5: The Treadway tire company: Job dissatisfaction and high turnover at the Lima tire plant Case Study Unit 5: Prepare a case analysis on the topic of Traditional versus Strategic HRM and Its Effectiveness for Organizational Success. Case Analysis Criteria: Your Case Analysis should consist of: * A brief analysis of the situation and pending-decision problem, as presented in the case, and as relevant to your answer. This should be exceptionally brief and you should assume the person reading the Assignment is familiar with the details of the case. * Identification of the major issues surrounding the organization or individuals involved with the organization. * Identification of alternate courses of action to address the issues identified. * The decision or recommendation for action, with the appropriate supporting arguments. * The Case Question is designed to guide the direction of your analysis in the case. Your analysis should address and ultimately answer the question. Analysis: The tire plant in Lima is going through some rough time as its profits and margins are declining due because of the rising cost of raw materials and also due to intense global competition. Not much can be done with the increasing cost of raw materials but to reduce the overall company’s cost...

Words: 1256 - Pages: 6

Lima Tire Company

...://www.ilr.cornell.edu/healthcare/our-research-and-publications/index.html Finkin, M., & Kochan, T. (2014, January 20). The Volkswagen way to better labor-management relations. Los Angeles Times. Retrieved from http://articles.latimes.com/2014/jan/20/opinion/la-oe-finkin-vw-work-councils-20140120 Mello, J. A. (2009). Labor relations. In Strategic Human Resource Management (4th ed.), (pp.539-567). Stamford, Connecticut: Cengage Learning Skinner, W., & Beckham, H. (2008, June 12). The Treadway tire company: Job dissatisfaction and high turnover at the Lima tire plant. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from http://hbr.org Southwest Airlines. (2014). Labor relations. Retrieved on October 11, 2014 from http://swamedia.com/channels/labor-relations/pages/labor-relations#chart...

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5

Case Study of Treadway Tire Company

... tangible goals with hourly workers for an explicit time period. In addition, the top management should also set goals with the foremen. More people participating in the goal setting ensure that the goals are attainable. This will also ensure that the foremen are not overburdened by heavy tasks. Regular meetings will provide an opportunity for salaried workforce and representatives from each department to discuss issues and concerns. Lower management can also express their demands and ideas which may help the company to improve the productivity. 4. Establishing an effective communication system Communication is a big problem in this case. Employees should be encouraged to express their ideas within the company. The foremen deal with the hourly workers and face many work-related issues. So, they are in the best position to communicate with both top management and hourly workers. Appropriate communication system will enable them to collect the feedback from the hourly workers and understand their demands and problems. The top management should also give their feedback to hourly workers and the foreman so that the ideas and problems will be considered. 5. Reduce shift hours for hourly workers In order to save cost, the current shift is 12 hours. However, it will cause negative impact on the plant. The performance will be declined after working for a long time because some workers feel sick and the foremen have to look for substitute workers at the last moment (Skinner &......

Words: 581 - Pages: 3

Treadway Tire

...Executive Summary The Treadway Tire Company operates many different plants throughout North America that manufacture and sell tires to a variety of markets. The plant located in Lima, Ohio is currently experiencing high turnover rates among line foremen and Ashley Wall, Director of Human Resources, has made it a priority to solve the problem. To deal with an increased workload, the plant runs continuous operations, requiring employees on site 24 hours a day. There are 50 line foremen at the Lima plant that supervise the hourly personnel and maintain daily operations. Out of these 50 foremen, 23 positions turned over in the current year. This, nearly 50% turnover rate, made it clear that something needed to change in order to retain workers. Line foremen deal with a variety of job duties during each 12 hour shift. They are faced with everything from personal problems to maintenance issues, all while attempting to appease the hourly workers and general managers. The stress and frustration placed on the foremen has taken its toll on employee morale and company production. The company recognizes a need for formal training to combat the problems with the foremen position, but the plant lacks the financial resources to implement this idea. As an alternative, it is recommended that the plant implement an employee mentorship and training program to help aide line foremen in their roles. Losing and replacing employees is time consuming and costly, making it imperative that...

Words: 4132 - Pages: 17

Treadway Tire Company

...Introduction: Ashley Wall the director of Treadway’s plant located in Lima, Ohio who is previously the Human Resource manager would like to correct a problem of high turnover rate of foremen reported by her plant manager Brandon Bellingham before the plant re-opens for New Year, 2008 closed for re-tooling (Skinner & Beckham, 2008). Background: Treadway Tire Company is one of the illustrious tire manufacturing companies with almost 9,000 staff who work either hourly or salaried. With updated equipment and technology the Treadway’s branch at Lima has became top in quality and productivity. By continuous operation and doing long shifts the company achieved cost savings but lost employee satisfaction (Skinner & Beckham, 2008). Problem: The line foremen often experience conflicts in all directions from management, hourly workers and union causing fretfulness and low morale. Lack of training and the stress due to long shifts makes their daily jobs more challenging (Skinner & Beckham, 2008). Opportunities: The firm should breakdown their long 12hr shifts to 8hr shifts, heir the newly graduated students and train them to handle any sort of issues. The supervisors should motivate their team members and improve their performance (Skinner & Beckham, 2008). Recommendation: Implementation of Positive KITA motivational methods and enriching the job with motivational factors like achievement, recognition, challenge, and advancement ameliorate the employee......

Words: 310 - Pages: 2

Treadway Tire Company

...The Treadway Case September 11, 2014 Relationship between line foremen at Treadway’s Lima Plant and other groups within the plant: general supervisors and area manager, top management, the union, hourly workers, and each other. The relationship between the Treadway’s Lima Plant foremen and other groups within the plant can only be described as insanity. One could easily say that insanity is repeating the same behavior over and over again and expecting a different result. The line foremen are required to work 12 hour shifts, solve a multitude of personnel, resource, and administrative issues and still meet daily production goals. Now add a union environment, no formal training for foremen, no chance of upward mobility, and a lack of communication between management (foremen, general supervisors and area managers), and you end up with a high turnover rate. According to the Plant manager, “Meeting performance goals is the most important duty of a line foreman.” This statement has caused the foreman to only focus on line metrics. Foremen have been threatened with poor performance reviews if production numbers are not met. This behavior has created a hostile work environment and isolated the foremen from the rest of the plant. They feel that their contributions are undervalued and their concerns ignored. There is no formal training process in place to familiarize foremen with the different aspects of their role within the plant. There was a month-long rotational...

Words: 1340 - Pages: 6

Treadway Tire Company Case

..., computer skills, customer service, diversity, ethics, human relations, quality initiatives, safety, and sexual harassment (McNamara, n.d.). Often companies specialize their training programs to what their company specifically needs. Another training aspect to consider is cross training their employees. This leads to flexibility and decreases the likely hood of boredom on the job. They could also implement a mentor program, so that employees are more confident and feel better about their job. Disadvantages of a Job Training Program Training is very costly and time consuming. Companies often don't have the resources to allocate to an efficient amount of training for their employees. Training is also a continuous process, which relates to not only the money aspect, but also time. Another downfall of training is if there is a faulty training program set in place. This can destroy a company culture, and potentially make the company not as profitable. Recommendation #3 Human Resource Improvements In addition to implementing a training program to solve the mass turnover rate at Lima Tire Plant, an on staff Human Resource coordinator should be hired. This human resource coordinator will handle all grievances, act as a mediator between employee issues, handle all the hiring/firing/promoting/demoting and be an unbiased representative for the plant. The current situation at Lima Tire Plant is consequent from a serious morale issue which stems from poor leadership...

Words: 2044 - Pages: 9

The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plant

...Case Analysis The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plan April 10, 2012 Summary The case study is talk about job dissatisfaction and high turnover rate at the Lima Tire Plant, which is one of the 8 manufacturing units operated by the Treadway Tire Company. In 2007, more than half of the foremen at the Lima facility had turn over. The turnover rate is the highest one over the past 10 years at Treadway, and also the high foremen turnover rate is the major concern for Ashley Walls who is the Director of Human Resources in the Lima Plant. Her major objectives are cost cutting, increase productivity, and reducing turnover. The next I will directly show some problems which the Lima Tire Plant had from the case. And then I give the corresponding suggestions and solutions for them, Main Problems From the case we could know the exact job dissatisfaction and high turnover situation at Lima Tire Plant. In order to logical analyze these I would discuss from the individual (foremen) to the integration (company). The foremen: First of all, I think the daily production evaluations of the Lima Tire Plant were too strict. Some of the variations in the production quantity and quality were not under the foreman’s control, specifically as it relates to machines breaking down. But the executive leaders just focus on daily production. Such as the plant manager...

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5