Free Essay

Title Ix Paper

In: Historical Events

Submitted By mhorras92
Words 1851
Pages 8
As Title IX approaches its 40th anniversary, its policies and impacts on both men’s and women’s sports is still greatly debated and argued. While it is proven fact that it was tremendously successful at providing women far greater opportunities both in sports and outside of sports, the topic of how it is negatively affecting men’s sport is often debated. The five articles that I gathered advocate for Title IX. They express its positive impacts through narrative accounts and personal experiences of well-known female athletes who prospered due to Title IX not just in sports, but in their educational and professional careers. They also disprove the myths commonly associated with Title IX that lack evidence about how it is responsible for negatively affecting men’s sport opportunities and potentially ruining the programs currently in existence.
Title IX is generally associated with women’s opportunity in sports to the point where its other positive implications tend to be forgotten. Title IX isn’t just about providing an opportunity for women to participate in sports in high school and at the college level, it is about providing young women the skills needed to achieve greater successes later on in life. Pugmire’s (2013) article quotes Women’s basketball legend Anne Meyers Drysdale saying the following:
“According to the Women's Sports Foundation, 80% of women in Fortune 500 companies played sports. It teaches you so much -- confidence, failure, success, courage, how to get along. That's the business world. That's life. It's important for us to be continuing those lessons as long as we can”.
He focuses his article around one of the great female athletes of the Title IX era to exemplify the positive outcomes of Title IX in order to advocate for the laws existence, why it should and why it has been around for the last 40 years. Pugmire (2013) also goes on to quote Drysdale saying: “We didn't have enough money for me to ever attend UCLA, but because of Title IX, I got an education at UCLA”. So while Drysdale decided to continue her career in athletics, these scholarship opportunities provide many women the chance to attend top tier schools and receive a high quality education as well as broaden their future career possibilities outside of sports.
The progression of women’s equality and opportunity in sports is only part of the battle to overcome the inequities they still face in society. According to Brown (2012), while Title IX has completely reshaped the way women are able to participate in society there is still progress to be made. Now that the opportunities are there, we as a society need to continue to make progress and work towards overcoming the issues of women’s inequalities in this country’s overall social, economic and political schemes. Cynthia G. Brown, like many others in support of Title IX’s purpose, agree that while the progress for women’s sports made so far is important for equal rights amongst women, more needs to be done. As stated by Schulte (2013):
The Women’s Sports Foundation noted that Girls make up 50 percent of high school enrollments, and have 41 percent of the spots on sports teams. Women in college have 60,000 fewer sports participation opportunities and received $176 million less in scholarships in 2010-2011. Women sports also make up 8 percent of all television and print sports coverage, just ahead of horses, dogs and fishing.
Of these four statistics listed, the amounts rewarded for scholarships are the foundation for granting the opportunities to young women. Making the sports program available is only half of the solution. If these young women can’t afford to pay for tuition at the schools where these programs have been made available then the point of their implementation is then useless. These articles aren’t just targeted towards making all the sports that are available to men available to women, they focus on the solution needing to be multifaceted. Women athletes rely on scholarships just as much as male athletes. In order for women to have equal opportunities in sports, schools not only need to make the athletic programs available to women but they also need to allocate equal scholarship funding to provide the same amount of personal monetary support to women athletes as male athletes.
In regard to equality in women’s funding versus men’s, this is where the controversy over Title IX’s policies is the most present. There are two examples of myths that are negatively associated with Title IX that these articles touch upon. The first being that, by adding women’s sports you are subsequently cutting nonrevenue men’s sports. While the second pertains to the general accusation during the laws proposal that Title IX would ruin sport as we know it to the point that some even compared it to communism.
It is not uncommon in the least for people to promote the myth of Title IX funding women’s sports at the cost of cutting non-revenue men’s sports to justify why it shouldn’t exist. Schulte (2013), Brown (2012) and Erskine (2012) argue that instead of just blaming Title IX for the lack of funding to men’s minor sports, the gross spending on Division I football and basketball programs needs to be considered. According to Schulte (2013):
A statement made by The National Council for Women and Girls in Education, in their Title IX report, argue that “Instead of allocating resources among a variety of sports, many college administrators are choosing to take part in the basketball and football “arms race” at the expense of other athletic programs. In Division I-FBS (formerly Division I-A), for example, basketball and football consume 80% of total men’s athletic expenses. Average expenditures on football alone in this division ($12+ million) exceed average expenditures on all women’s sports ($8+ million).
As a result of the refusal to allocate the men’s spending budget away from basketball and football, these articles make the argument that cuts must then be taken from the minor sports within the men’s overall sports budget. This is the point where the blame on Title IX comes into play. To summarize the quote by Christine Brennan in the article by Brown (2013); spending should be split between men and women equally, football players are not an exception to gender so the decision to spend copious amounts of money on these programs should rightfully come out of the men’s fund. As mentioned earlier this causes grounds for blame to be placed on Title IX which Brown (2013) goes to say, “It is to Title IX’s credit that fair play is enforced”.
The other myth as previously mentioned, was that the law would seriously weaken the programs currently in existence (Erskine, 2012). Just as Erskine also mentions, 40 years after the bill was passed, sports in America have thrived. While the number of men’s sports programs and male athletes are still greater, compared to the numbers before Title IX came into effect, women’s sport has never been more prosperous. Erskine uses the argument that just like the integration of African Americans into popular sports back in the early 1900’s, everyone thought their participation would ruin the game when in fact it did the exact opposite. Especially with men and women not even competing in the same sports for the most part. There is nothing that would cause the quality of men’s sports to decrease just because women’s sport is also increasing.
Barbara Winslow takes a slightly different route than the other authors and talks about the discrimination, prejudice and ridicule women faced who played sports back in the 1900’s. Physical activity was seen as masculine, therefore any woman who played was depicted as unattractive and told they were damaging their reproductive organs. Despite these claims women played on in the sports they loved. As the 1960s approached the debate for gender equality started becoming more popular. Just like the other authors Winslow talks about the backlash the women’s movement faced. People were worried about how it would have a negative impact on sports and society in the future. 40 years later, she and many others are able to present the numbers and prove that because of Title IX, women’s participation in sports has exploded in addition to participation and popularity amongst men’s sport also increasing. Thus making her point that for the past 40 years, people will make assumptions without evidence. That something they disagree with will only have a negative impact. In reality the numbers show the opposite, just like the first arguments against women playing sports and how it would damage them internally, facts don’t lie and women’s sports can only benefit women and society.
Of the five articles that were collected all of them portrayed the positives of Title IX in different ways. Many used cold hard facts and statistics to show that what Title IX is doing is helping sports in America. People tend to blame Title IX for cuts in men’s sports but a few of these authors argue that instead of blaming title IX we should take a look at where the majority of the money is going. In other words, the large scale football and basketball programs. If schools want to use the majority of the funding for men’s sports on these programs then they believe it shouldn’t come at the cost of women’s sports. Others also used the accounts of various successful female athletes that have Title IX to thank for their opportunities. However, almost all can agree that Title IX isn’t just about allowing women to play sports, it is about giving them the chance to excel in their professional lives and not be held back by the status quo.
* Schulte, Brigid (2013, June, 27). Does Title IX equality for females come at males’ expense?. retrieved October 24 2013, from The Washington Post Web Site:

* Brown, Cynthia G. (2012, June, 27). 40 Years After Title IX, Men Still Get Better Sports Opportunities. retrieved October 24 2013, from U.S. News Web Site:

* Erskine, Chris (2012, Spetember, 03). n Title IX has benefited anyone who loves sports. retrieved October 24 2013, from Los Angeles Times Web Site:

* Pugmire, Lance (2012, June, 25). She should have her name above the Title. retrieved October 24 2013, from Los Angeles Times Web Site:

* Winslow, Barbara The Impact of Title IX. (n.d) retrieved October 24 2013, from The Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History Web Site:

Note: For the last reference, in order to be able to read the article without being forced to make an account, just go to the actual Gilder Lehrman website and search “Title IX” the article/essay I used should be the fourth one down.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Title Ix

...The Title IX Education Amendments of 1972 (Title IX for short) broadly prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex in any education program or activity receiving federal financial assistance. Most of the time, people speak about Title IX when referring to gender equality in college sports, but it actually covers a wider range of sexual discrimination. In the NCAA, the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) would analyze a university’s decision to eliminate one of their team sports. They would determine if that school was compliant with Title IX. Some schools cite financial reasons for taking sports out, but that alone is not enough for the OCR. “Title IX requires that the percentage of male/female student-athletes should closely represent the student body population at the university and that the proportion of student aid should closely resemble the participating male/female ratio” (Cranney, 2013). Therefore, the athletic department’s male to female ratio has to be similar to the student body’s ratio as well. One of the reasons that Temple University took away seven of their sports was to balance their athletic department’s male/female ratio, and it would also save the school between $3 to $3.5 million yearly (Cranney, 2013). If the ratio at the athletic department of a school is acceptable, they would have to really show that keeping up certain sports is hurting the school significantly. For the OCR, they will find every reason for a school not to drop any of their sports,...

Words: 296 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Title IX Gender Equality

...On the day of June 23, 1972 Title IX of the Education Amendments was enacted by Congress and signed into law by United States President Richard Nixon. On this monumental day, women across the entire United States would no longer be discriminated on the basis of sex. Thirty-seven that would change everything, "No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance." This landmark federal statute was considered the most important step for gender equality since the right to vote given in the 19th Amendment.  Hawaii congresswoman, Patsy T. Mink worked tirelessly by...

Words: 1183 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Title Ix

...------------------------------------------------- Subject: Self-Audit of Title IX in Athletic Program Broadwater Academy PURPOSE AND AUTHORITY The Headmaster and Board of Directors want to be proactive, they would like the athletic department to conduct a Title IX audit. This audit is to ensure the Broadwater Academy is in compliance with all Title IX criteria for athletics. SCOPE AND METHODOLGY To help understand why this audit is being conducted, it is necessary to have some history: “The original legislation, Title IX of the Educational Amendments of 1972, 20 U.S.C 1681 et seq., is a Federal statute that was signed into law by President Richard Nixon on June 23, 1972.” (NIAAA, 2011) “Title IX regulations provide that: No person shall on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, be treated differently from another person, or otherwise be discriminated against in any interscholastic, intercollegiate, club or intramural athletics offered by a recipient, and no recipient shall provide such athletics separately on such basis.” (Justice) Justice, T. U. (n.d.). Retrieved from Title IX Legal manual: NIAAA. (2011). Leadership Training LTC 506 Legal Issues II; Title IX and sexual Harassment . NIAAA. This process will begin with the development of a committee to evaluate, manage, and supervise the compliance of Title IX......

Words: 2151 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Wrestling at the U

... Your excitement is overwhelming. You have spent your entire life working up to this point; you are a college athlete. You are being paid to attend school and play your favorite sport for it. Your coach walks in with an upset look on his face. You think to yourself that it’s just going to be a difficult practice. Your coach actually tells you that you do not have practice today. You wont have practice ever again. Your entire life work gone, just like that. With your heart crushed, you cannot understand why the sport is just, canceled. You walk up to your coach and ask what the problem is. Your coach, as disappointed as you, tells you that the University board of athletics has decided to drop your “life” from the program to abide by the Title IX requirements and for not being a profitable program. This actually happened here at the University of Utah 50 years ago and it’s because there is a problem going on at Universities like The U and it is that men’s non-revenue sports, like wrestling, are being impacted negatively. Wresting is beginning to fade from colleges that are not in the Big Ten or the Ivy League, and Colleges like the University of Utah are participating in letting the sport diminish. In an article written by Coyte G. Cooper, “Involving the core product” “While there were 363 NCAA wrestling programs in 1981, the number of men’s wrestling programs offered by the NCAA had diminished to 234 in 2005.” Schools should stop making excuses for dropping the sport and......

Words: 3710 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Title Ix and Women’s Role in Sports

...women’s movement was the enactment of Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972. Title IX of the Educational Amendments of 1972 is the landmark legislation that bans sex discrimination in schools, whether it is in academics or athletics. It states: "No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving federal financial assistance" (Storm 320). Before Title IX, few opportunities existed for female athletes. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), which was created in 1906 to format and enforce rules in men’s football but had become the ruling body of college athletics, offered no athletic scholarships for women and held no championships for women’s teams. Furthermore, facilities, supplies and funding were lacking. As a result, in 1972 there were just 30,000 women participating in NCAA sports, as opposed to 170,000 men (Simon 92). Title IX applies to educational institutions that receive any federal funds and prohibits discrimination in all educational programs and activities. Athletic programs are considered educational programs and activities. Title IX gives women athletes the right to equal opportunity in sports in educational institutions that receive federal funds, from elementary schools to colleges and universities (Poertner 92). There are three parts to Title IX as it applies to athletics programs:......

Words: 1703 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Title Ix Court Case

...Running Head: Title IX Court Case Research on Title IX Court Case FIRST M. SURNAME INSTITUTIONAL AFFLIATION TITLE IX Court Case Introduction Title IX is a part of the Education Amendments of 1972. The amendment protects the citizens from discrimination from academic programs on the basis of their gender(Carpenter & Acosta, 2005). It provides that persons of either gender can be granted an opportunity in any education program within taking into consideration their gender. Title IX protects all the students enrolled in government sponsored institutions from discrimination. As much as the code of Civil Rights caters for the protection against such there are still areas where discrimination can arise (Boland, 2002).. For instance, enrollment in some degree programs or some sporting activities might be based on discriminating nature. The Amendments also guard the student against sexual harassment. This paper will look at the process of filing a Title IX lawsuit. It will analyze based on a sample case study on how to overcome the case based on the current provision of the Education Amendments as well as other relevant laws that pertain to that case. It will observe the consequences of the outcome of the case to the participants of the case. The evaluation will consider all the other external factors that are involved in the process of the filing process and representation in the court of law. Statement of the Court Case The case to be analyzed for the purposes......

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Title Ix

...Angie Kraft Title IX Paper September 27, 2015 Title IX has impacted the world as we know it in so many ways, and to think that some people have never even heard of the matter. Title IX states, “No person in the United states shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be defined the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.” The law was passed in 1972 by Richard Nixon and has been celebrated for 43 years. The purpose of Title IX is to get rid of discrimination on the basis of sex in any program that is federally funded. Before Title IX was passed women were very limited when it came to playing sports. They mostly played for physical fitness rather than competition. They were recreational and noncompetitive. In the early 1900s is when woman started to become more interested in playing sports and started forming athletic clubs; those clubs were informal of course. College sports for women before title IX was a little different. They would let women play certain sports but only against their fellow classmates, not outside of the college. In the late 1800s the first intercollegiate competition between women was scheduled and then canceled because one of the schools did not allow their female athletes to compete between colleges. Schools must go through a 3-prong test to use as evidence to the legislation of Title IX. The first part of the test is proportionality...

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Effects of Equal Employment Opportunity and Affirmative Action in Women Sports

...THE EFFECTS OF EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY AND AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IN WOMEN SPORTS March, 2007 TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Page i Table of Contents …..……………………………………………………………………2 Section I. Introduction 3 Section II. Review of Literature 4 Equal Employment Opportunity Laws 4 Affirmative Action 6 Effects of EEO and AA on Women Sports 7 Effects on EEO and AA on women playing sports 7 Effects of EEO and AA on women coaching sports 9 Effects of EEO and AA on women in administration………………...11 Section III. Summary and Conclusions 14 References ............... 17 INTRODUCTION Women in sports have indeed come a long way. Years ago it was socially unacceptable for women to do anything other than cook and clean. Men dominated the work place and the sports industry. But eventually women got fed up with being treated less significant than their male counterparts and began protesting. Not until the mid-1950s and early 1960s did nondiscriminatory employment become a strong social concern (Bohlander & Snell, 2004). While women were just beginning to make a name for themselves, the government began regulating Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) by passing a series of laws, in an attempt to correct social problems of interest to particular groups of workers, including women. EEO laws have made a major impact on women in all industries, but especially on women in sports. While EEO laws focused on non-discrimination, affirmative action went......

Words: 4585 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Gender Equity in Sports

...Gender Equity in Sports Colleen Iardella American Military University Gender equity in sports describes an environment in which fair and equitable distribution of overall athletic opportunities, benefits, and resources is available to women and men and in which student athletes, coaches, and athletics administrators are not subject to gender-based discrimination. Title IX, passed in 1972 at the pinnacle of the women’s rights movement, banned sex discrimination in any federally financed education program. It threw into quick relief the imbalanced treatment of male and female athletes on college campuses. Ever since Congress passed the federal gender-equity law, universities have opened their gyms and athletic fields to millions of women who previously did not have chances to play. But as women have surged into a greater part on campus in recent years, many institutions have resorted to deception to make it look as if they are offering more sports to women. Throughout this paper I will discuss the issues of gender equity in sports. I will mention what equal opportunities women have to play sports and how they can develop the psychological, physiological and sociological impact from sports participation. Females are playing team sports more now than they were a decade ago and far more women will play team sports in the next decade. In the Sporting Goods Manufacturers Association's (SGMA) study, the authors analyzed many team sports and the role that......

Words: 2350 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Title Ix

...Katie Higgins Mr. Mishou English IV 12 April 2013 Title IX “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance” (Primer). These thirty-seven words make up the civil rights law Title IX, which is widely known for reforming athletics, although it is never directly mentioned. First, the detailed history shows how many people worked rigorously to get the law passed. Furthermore, Title IX’s numerous tests show how verify schools complying with the law. Lastly, Title IX has increased the participation of women in athletics significantly over the past forty years. Title IX, the controversial federal civil rights act, has shaped athletics to how they are today by creating equal opportunities for female athletes. Flashback forty-one years to before Title IX changed the lives girls and women forever. Girls were not encouraged to play sports at a young and scholarships were not available for women to play athletics in college. People like Pat Summitt, arguably one of the best women’s basketball coaches ever, was not receiving fair treatment while playing collegiate basketball. In 1972, before Title IX was signed, Summitt played basketball for the University of Tennessee-Martin. The team was given uniforms that were used in the Physical Education classes and placed numbers on the back with tape....

Words: 2712 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Women in Sports

...Kaitlyn Daignault Professor Waters Philosophy Women in Western Ideas May 2nd, 2013 Assignment: Women in Sports Final Paper Notwithstanding WE CAN DO IT Women have always been, and continue to be, discriminated against. This is especially true in the realm of sports. Although this is fact, it does remain to be a particularly controversial topic. Activists have worked hard to supply rights to women, and other divisions of society, in demand to make just as many opportunities obtainable to this faction, as there are available to the ‘common white man.’ Perpetuated thoughts against this argument have branched from days as early as Aristotle and other celebrated philosophers. Times are progressing toward more equality in this area, however; in order to present these basic human rights to women, a specific law had to be put in affect. The passing of this edict also came along with many misinterpretations, which still inhabit stubborn minds today. Apart from this ordinance, many women partook an enormous influence on proving woman can actually compete and challenge men on the playing field, court, etc. From the beginning of time, women have existed right alongside with men. Many questions were conjured up as to why the physical existence is so distinct from each body. Many different philosophers constructed their own unique views on this matter. Aristotle believed that women are absolute subsidiary to men, thus establishing, anything women can do, men can do......

Words: 1323 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Should College Athletes Be Paid

...Should College Athletes be Paid to Play. C Team BCOM/275 Robert May Should College Athletes be Paid to Play. Should college athletes be paid to play? That is the question and discussion being presented not only in this paper but also across many colleges in these United States. There are many pros and cons to college athletes being paid to play their sport, which makes this is a very controversial topic. Are the sport scholarships and uniforms enough? Should schools really pocket all that money they make in revenue from the sports teams? Many moral, ethical and legal issues can be raised in the idea of paying college athletes to play, on both the pro and con side of the issue. Should an athlete receive a full ride scholarship and also be paid from the school to play? Many big universities may be able to handle such a thing, but what about the small colleges that do not receive such a large amount of revenue from their sports teams? Can or should schools pay all the athletes or only the top players? What about Title IX, how will potentially paying athletes be affected by it? All these topics will be discussed, as well as Team C’s final decision on this matter. PROS In 2012 the athletic revenue reported by University of Texas was $163.2 million, Alabama $143.4 million, Ohio State $142.0 million and Michigan $140.1 million (Berkowitz, Schnaars, & Upton, 2014) Coaches like Nick Saban (Alabama Football) and Mike Krzyzewski (Duke Men’s Basketball) make in excess of $7......

Words: 2122 - Pages: 9

Free Essay


...College hoops' black coaching issue Myron Medcalf [ARCHIVE] | July 18, 2013 When a national sportswriter calls to talk about minority hiring in college basketball, folks of all races seem to get nervous. As I sought feedback following last week's release of the "2012 Racial and Gender Report Card: College Sport" by Central Florida's Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport -- the report excludes historically black colleges and universities -- which states that the current pool of Division I African-American head coaches (18.6 percent through the 2011-12 season) is at its lowest mark since the 1995-96 season, people weren't sure what, if anything, they should say. Multiple administrators passed on the opportunity. The NCAA wanted to see my questions, and then it wanted a pre-interview phone conversation before it ultimately emailed its responses. The coaches who talked on the record always ended our chats with the same concern: "I didn't say anything that will make me look bad, right?" Shaka Smart Andy Lyons/Getty Images To reach Shaka Smart's level, black coaches often have to overcome certain labels. I don't blame them. It's an incendiary issue, because we're uncomfortable with race as dialogue. It's still a subject that makes athletic directors -- 89 percent of whom are white at the Division I level, per the report -- squirm. Minority coaches speak cautiously, because they don't want to be labeled as rebels or militants. That......

Words: 8597 - Pages: 35

Premium Essay

Debate Paper Outline

...Debate Paper Outline 4/19/2015 Brenda Crowe XBCOM/275 Tiffany Bostic Is Cheerleading a Sport? Along with cheering on the sidelines at games, most cheerleading squads participate in heated competitions to show their athleticism. “Although the athleticism of cheerleaders has risen dramatically since Johnny Campbell led the first cheers at a University of Minnesota football game in 1898, what hasn't changed is the primary focus of school cheerleading: to promote school spirit, support other teams in competition and provide leadership within the school and community. Because of the highly athletic nature of modern cheerleading, annual competitions were created to showcase these athletes on their own and away from the sidelines, and the sport-or-not debate began”. (, 2014). I. Pro’s A. Cheerleaders are athletes B. College cheerleading was as physically demanding and mentally challenging as any activity. C. defines a sport as "an athletic activity that requires physical prowess or skill and often a competitive nature." Cheerleading definitely fulfills this criteria. II. Cons A. Sports teams exist to compete, not to perform and entertain or support another group that competes. B. Competitions are not frequently enough to satisfy NCAA, NFHS. C. Under the nation's Title IX regulations, which require universities receiving federal funds to offer equal athletic opportunities to both sexes, a sport must have...

Words: 478 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Final Four Media Coverage

...domain where they can input their interpretations of sporting events and coverage. These domains have become dominated by the 18-34-year-old demographic (Kian, Mondello & Vincent 2009) who use websites such as ESPN, the most widely used website for obtaining sports related news (Lefton, 2006 as cited in Battenfield, Redmond & Ridinger 2014), and Sports Illustrated to read about upcoming games, watch live coverage, or get the low down on games that have already happened. These online sport websites are visited more frequently by males (62%) than females (38%) (Loechner, 2005 as cited in Battenfield et al. 2014) but that gap is slowly dwindling. Opportunities for women to participate in sports has increased dramatically since the enactment of Title IX in 1972, with the number of female participants in college sports at...

Words: 4713 - Pages: 19