Free Essay

Tnk-Bp

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Tricolore
Words 688
Pages 3
TNK-BP (RUSSIA) 2008 – (A07-09-0006)
1. Why did BP create TNK-BP? Are the partners equally committed and motivated to create a successful venture?
2. How has the JV performed? Has it met expectations?
3. Why has the JV experienced so many problems?
4. Does the Russian government have a specific agenda for the JV?
5. What options does BP have? What would you recommend?

1. In comparison with its competitors, the production growth of BP was constrained by its mature oil fields. As a result of the constrained production growth, BP’s financial performance was lagging behind compared to the financial performances of their competitors (e.g. ExxonMobil, Shell). Therefore, BP was aggressively looking for new oil reserves (p. 2). Russia was the world’s largest natural gas producer; the proven reserves were ranked 7th worldwide and there were huge opportunities for further exploitation. It seems like the Russian part of the joint venture is less motivated. They have done this deal to improve profits and to increase their benefits and potential growth.

2. For BP, the joint venture worked out quite well. As stated in the text: “TNK-BP accounted for nearly one-quarter of BP’s oil production.” If the joint venture comes to an end, this would have serious (financial) implications for BP. Also, in the period 2002-2006 the net profit grew from 1.5 million dollars to 6.4 million dollars.

3. One of the issues was that the partners were not in agreement as to the level of non-Russian growth. The Russian shareholders thought that BP was “blocking efforts to expand TNK-BP outside of Russia because that would compete with BP’s own operations.” According to the Russians, the CEO (Dudley) only acted on behalf of 50 percent of the shareholders, meaning that he didn’t act in the interest of the Russian shareholders (of AAR). Another obstacle was the amount of foreign managers/expatriates, according to the Russian shareholders there were too many of them. This ultimately led to the visa problems for the BP expatriates, who were not allowed to enter Russia in early 2008. Dudley blamed a TNK-BP executive for setting up this via problem. The Russian shareholders said that TNK-BP should reduce the “venture’s reliance on foreign specialists”. Besides this, there was an obvious cultural gap between the shareholders of BP and the Russian shareholders. Fridman stated beforehand that the difference/cultural gap between the Western style of doing business and the Russian style of doing business would provide the biggest challenge.

4. Russia was confronted with several problems in 2008: a) aging oil fields and poor maintenance. This could be solved by accepting expatriates like those of BP who were willing to invest in modernizing the oil fields. Here I cite Browne, who commented that he knew that “they [Russian Shareholders] are reinforcing President Putin’s agenda of modernization.” b) a tax and regulatory regime that was increasingly viewed as confiscatory by oil companies. c) a dearth of Russian and foreign investments in exploration and development.

5. There are several options available for BP as mentioned in the article:

a) “One option was to take the dispute to the highest levels in the Russian government, perhaps even Putin himself.” However, according to Sechin, this option would have limited value.
b) “A second option was to seek British government help, which had been offered.” The British Prime Mininister Brown was going to visit President Medveded in July.
c) A third option was legal action against AAR for violating the shareholder agreement.
d) “The last option was that BP could sit tight, continue to run the business, and resist the Russian shareholders.” Although BP said Dudley would keep his job, this seems to be impossible.

It would be advisable for BNP to do anything to keep the joint venture TNK-BP alive, since the revenues are high and losing stake in the JV would have serious financial implications for BP. So I would suggest to have a lot of meetings with the Russian shareholders, trying to come to an agreement.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Tnk-Bp

...when one of the world’s largest energy companies, BP, and the Russian state company, Rosneft, unsuccessfully attempted to form a strategic partnership on Arctic development. This failure was caused by the contractual and legal objections of the AAR consortium - BP’s partners in the Russian oil company TNK-BP. In 2003-5, BP and the AAR consortium led by three billionaires with Russian connections - Mikhail Fridman, Len Blavatnik, and Viktor Vekselberg - merged their Russian oil corporate assets - TNK, Sidanko, and Onako and their subsidiaries - under the umbrella of TNK-BP.2 This joint venture was established on a 50/50 basis, the operation of which required mutual joint decision making. The partners also signed a shareholding agreement on TNK- BP’s right of first refusal in relation to potential future oil and gas projects offered to BP or AAR in Russia and Ukraine. This agreement was subsequently used by AAR to stop the BP-Rosneft deal in international courts. Unfortunately, this was not the first time that BP had been unable to change the way it conducted its business in Russia. The first example occurred in 2007-8 when BP was reported to be keen on having Gazprom as a partner instead of AAR. This move would have transformed the TNK-BP joint venture into Gazprom-BP. This did not transpire. Second, in the spring-summer 2008, there was a turbulent ‘misunderstanding’ between BP and AAR, over the corporate governance and future ...

Words: 9031 - Pages: 37

Free Essay

Bp's Culture

...internal development or an external development to thrive? What does it imply when it comes to BP? They came to the following conclusion: according to Capron and Mitchell, a company a joint venture (an alliance) should be created only if a company clearly identifies a resource gap. In this case, the company does not necessarily own these resources. The company does not need to have a close relation with the resource provider, nor does it need to come to an agreement about the resources’ value with the provider. Therefore, when it comes to BP, Alfa Group and Access Renova Group, what did urge them into choosing the alliance option? First of all, did BP choose the joint venture option because the company had identified an oil gap? BP’s activity depended directly on the stock of oil and exploited oil and gas fields in UK, in Norway, in Trinidad and Tobago, in the Gulf of Mexico, in Alaska, in Azerbaijan, in Egypt, in Vietnam, in Angola, in Colombia and in Russia. It is one of the largest energy multinational in the world and has operations in over 80 countries. But BP, as well as many other companies worldwide, was hit by the growing demand of oil from China and the Middle East countries. Not to mention that BP had to cope with growing difficulties production-wise and environment-wise because of several catastrophes, gas leaks and oil spills that occurred the past decade. Hence BP had to face this undeniable oil gap. Many figures and statistics support this statement. Before...

Words: 387 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Tnk-Bp a Case

...bullet Licensing and technology transfer. Licensing and tech transfer have been essential in promoting collaboration between the academic and business communities. Ever since legal hurdles were removed that allowed universities to hold title to research and development done in their labs, licensing agreements have helped turned raw technology into finished products that are viable in competitive marketplaces. With some help from a variety of government agencies in the form of grants for R&D as well as other financial assistance for such things as incubator programs, once timid college researchers are now stepping out and becoming cutting edge entrepreneurs. These strategic alliances have had a serious impact in several high tech industries, including but not limited to: medical and agricultural biotechnology, computer software engineering, telecommunications, advanced materials processing, ceramics, thin materials processing, photonics, digital multimedia production and publishing, optics and imaging and robotics and automation. Industry clusters are now growing up around the university labs where their derivative technologies were first discovered and nurtured. Licensing agreements allow companies to take full advantage of new and exciting technologies while limiting their overall risk to royalty payments until a particular technology is fully developed and thus ready to put new products into the manufacturing pipeline. bullet Reciprocal distribution agreements. Actually...

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Tnk-Bp Case Study

...BP in Russia Executive Summary This case study “BP in Russia: Settling the Joint Venture Dispute” goes into the major world energy companies and the formation of joint ventures. This case delves into the 50/50 international joint venture (IJV) formed between British Petroleum (BP) and a group of Russian investors, Alfa Group, Access Industries, and Renova known as AAR. This IJV was formed in September 2003 and was known as TNK-BP.1 TNK-BP’s CEO was Robert Dudley in May 2008. This is when the dispute between the British and Russian shareholders started to escalate. AAR thought that BP was treating TNK-BP as a subsidiary and not a JV. The escalation of the conflict got to the point where BP was seriously considering whether they should walk away from the IJV by selling its stake, acquire AAR’s stake or continue the IJV. This case analysis will explore BP and whether it was a good strategy to enter Russia and pursue an international joint venture with consortium AAR. Next the analysis will look at the evolution of the joint venture and examine the unique challenges faced by the international joint venture. Next the study will detail our recommendations regarding the AAR partnership, their implications and steps to implement this. Lastly the case will be updated to the present time. 1. Did BP pursue the right strategy to enter Russia? There are arguments both for and against BP’s decision to enter Russia. Perhaps the biggest disadvantage to BP’s strategy was...

Words: 2106 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Oil and Gas Management I

...TNK-BP, also known as Tyumenskaya Neftyanaya Kompaniya, Tyumen Oil Company), used to be a one of the biggest vertically integrated Russian oil company, which had its headquarters in Moscow. It was rated Russia’s third largest oil producer, in addition it was amongst the top 10 largest private oil companies in the whole world. However, it was bought by another Russian oil company known as Rosneft, in 2013. History of TNK-BP It was confirmed by DeGolyer and MacNaughton that since 31 December 2009 all of TNK-NP’s proved reserves added up to 11.667 million barrels which is the equivalent to 1.8549×109 m3 oil, applying PRMS criteria. The proved reserves account for a total PRMS reserve replacement of 329%. BP and a group of Russian businessmen, whom were represented by the AAR, announced a strategic partnership which was designed to jointly hold their oil assets and the creation of TNK-BP in Russian and the Ukraine, on 1st September 2003. AAR’s holdings in TNK international, ONAKO, SIDANCO, RUSIA Pretrolum; whom held license for Kovytka and Verkhnechonsk fields), and Rospan field located in West Siberia, were all contributed towards TNK-BP. On the other hand BP’s holdings in SIDANCO, RUSIA Petroleum and its BP Moscow retail network, all contributed towards TNK-BP. BP and AAR reached an agreement to consolidate AAR’s 50% stake in Slavneft and into TNK-BP, in January 2014. ARR and Sibnett (now known as Gazprom Neft) previously joined Slavneft. Slavneft has operations in...

Words: 2516 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Tnk-Bp Case Analysis 2011

...Strategic Management : Principles and Practice Case study « TNK-BP » 1) Explain based on i) the type of partners (competitors or not), ii) the contribution of resources (which resources?) and iii) the nature of the alliance (what is both partners’ purpose?) whether TNK-BP is a scale or scope alliance. The TNK-BP joint venture is an alliance between two competitors(i): the oil British giant BP and the consortium of four Russian billionaires behind AAR. On the hand, BP is the second largest private sector oil company in the world. On the other hand, AAR is a very diversified group; it has interests in banking, retail, telecommunications, and medias but also in oil, notably through TNK which owns oil reserves and facilities. Those two companies contribute differently (ii) to the joint-venture. BP brings its know-how and expertise to exploit oil reserves, as well as the required investment (6,8$ billions of equity). AAR provides oil production in Siberia, oil refining, gaz interest and 1400 filling stations in Russian and Ukraine. One could argue that BP needs natural resources and is ready to pay a premium for it, whereas AAR needs the technology and expertise of BP. This alliance (iii) is a joint venture between BP and AAR because TNK-BP is a new entity that is owned equally by BP and AAR without any mergers or acquisitions from BP to AAR or vice versa. This alliance is a scope alliance since it is driven by complementarities in competence and assets, and because...

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Bp Stock Analysis

...Business Summary |   | BP is also BO (Big Oil). It is the world's third-largest integrated oil concern, behind Exxon Mobil and Royal Dutch Shell. BP explores for oil and gas in 30 countries and has proved reserves of 18.3 billion barrels of oil equivalent. BP is the largest oil and gas producer in the US and a top refiner, with stakes in 16 refineries, processing 4 million barrels of crude oil per day. BP markets its products in more than 80 countries and operates 22,400 gas stations worldwide. The company's reputation took a major hit in 2010 when one of its deepwater rigs, working less than 50 miles south of Louisiana, exploded and killed 11 workers. Millions of gallons of crude gushed into the Gulf of Mexico for months. Following the disaster in the Gulf of Mexico, BP stock lost more than half its value, until recovering a bit in July. The company's dividend has been suspended and the CEO replaced. The company is creating a $20 billion fund over the next three-and-a-half years to cover claims from the Deepwater Horizon catastrophe,and to pay for that and other costs, BP announced it would be selling $30 billion in assets over the next 18 months. The company also took a $32 billion pretax charge against second-quarter earnings to cover potential liabilities.BP p.l.c.was founded in 1889, has headquarters in London, the United Kingdom. The company provides fuel for transportation, energy for heat and light, retail services, and petrochemicals products, operates through two...

Words: 2418 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Thermal Contact Conductance

...BP From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia This is the latest accepted revision, accepted on 2 October 2010.Jump to: navigation, search This article is about the energy corporation. For other uses, see BP (disambiguation). For information on the oil spill from the Deepwater Horizon rig, see Deepwater Horizon oil spill. BP p.l.c. Type Public limited company (LSE: BP, NYSE: BP) Industry Oil and natural gas, alternative fuels Founded 1909 (as the Anglo-Persian Oil Company) 1954 (as the British Petroleum Company) 1998 (merger of British Petroleum and Amoco) Headquarters London, United Kingdom Area served Worldwide Key people Carl-Henric Svanberg (Chairman) Tony Hayward (CEO) Bob Dudley (Director, CEO (appointed)) Byron Grote (CFO)[1] Products BP petroleum and derived products BP service stations Air BP Aviation Fuels Castrol motor oil ARCO gas stations am/pm convenience stores Aral service stations solar panels Revenue US $246.1 billion (2009)[2] Operating income US $26.43 billion (2009)[2] Net income US $16.58 billion (2009)[2] Total assets US $236.0 billion (2009) Total equity US $101.6 billion (2009) Employees 80,300 (Dec 2009)[3] Website BP.com A 1922 BP advertisement.BP p.l.c.[4][5] (LSE: BP, NYSE: BP) is a global oil and gas company headquartered in London, United Kingdom. It is the third largest energy company and the fourth largest company in the world measured by revenues and is one of the six oil and gas "supermajors".[6][7] ...

Words: 11889 - Pages: 48

Premium Essay

Bp Hire

...BP plc,[5][6] also referred to by its former name, British Petroleum, is one of the world's seven "supermajor" oil and gas companies.[7] It is a British multinational company, headquartered in London, England, whose performance in 2012 made it the world's sixth-largest oil and gas company, the sixth-largest energy company by market capitalization[8] and the company with the world's fifth-largest revenue (turnover).[9][10] It is a vertically integrated company operating in all areas of the oil and gas industry, including exploration and production, refining, distribution and marketing, petrochemicals, power generation and trading. It also has renewable energy interests in biofuels and wind power. [dated info] As of December 2013, BP has operations in approximately 80 countries,[4] produces around 3.2 million barrels per day (510,000 m3/d) of oil equivalent,[1] has total proved reserves of 17.9 billion barrels (2.85×109 m3) of oil equivalent,[11] and has around 17,800 service stations.[12][13] Its largest division is BP America in the United States. In Russia BP owns a 19.75% stake in Rosneft, the world's largest publicly traded oil and gas company by hydrocarbon reserves and production. BP has a primary listing on the London Stock Exchange and is a constituent of the FTSE 100 Index; it had a market capitalisation of £85.2 billion as of April 2013, the fourth-largest of any company listed on the exchange.[14] It has secondary listings on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange and the New...

Words: 691 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bus 499

...the link below, do not cut & paste the article. See our Ts&Cs and Copyright Policy for more detail. Email ftsales.support@ft.com to buy additional rights. http://blogs.ft.com/energy-source/2010/03/02/bps-strategy-presentation-growth-cost-cuts-biofuels-ma-and-more/#ixzz3AHpONpiH Overall, the theme from Tony Hayward, the CEO, is that BP has great assets, in part thanks to the deals of the past decade, such as the takeovers of Amoco and Arco and the creation of TNK-BP, but is still not managing them as well as it could. Having lagged well behind the pack of oil majors when Hayward took over, as measured by return on capital, BP is now about average, but it would like to get closer to the leader, Exxon. That is the context for all the plans B The key points of that plan are: 1. $3bn to be saved through cost-cutting and efficiency improvements over the next 2-3 years. 2. Roughly $2bn from refining, putting the emphasis on efficient operations rather than just getting the refineries running, which has been the priority. A further $1bn from better project management, resulting from the creation of a new global development unit to manage big projects, which have a tradition of over-shooting their budgets at BP, as they do at many other companies. - As a small part of that, BP is pulling out of its marketing business in Namibia, Malawi and some other southern African countries. - Production growth expected to average 1-2 per cent per year during 2008-15, and hopefully for...

Words: 1759 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Management Planning

...British Petroleum (BP) is a worldwide oil as well as gas establishment whose roots can be traced in British. The company’s headquarters are based in London, United Kingdom. The company has been ranked as the third biggest energy establishment as well as fourth biggest establishment in the world measured by 2011 profits. The company functions in all sectors of the oil as well as gas business ranging from examination in addition to manufacture, purifying, supply in addition to advertising, petrochemicals, power generation as well as exchange. The corporation has as well diversified its core operations to integrate renewable energy actions that bio fuels in addition to wind power. Operating over 80 nation states it’s biggest union remains BP US in where it remains the 2nd biggest manufacturer oil as well as gas in the US. The company be situated both registered with London’s Stock Trade primarily with minor list with New York Stock Exchange. In British Petroleum planning is critical and it helps the company to forecast the future as well as chalk out actions to be taken. Planning can be viewed as a preparatory step that determines when, how as well as who is going to perform a specific job Internal and external factors in management of British Petroleum Company The British Company has several internal factors that can be corrected within these categories that can drive the company to its success; on the other hand they also come with external factors that are further than the company’s...

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Bp Oil Spill

...BP OIL SPILL Under the Deepwater Horizon, an offshore drilling ring of British Petroleum (BP) caused an oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The incident occurred on April 20th 2010, where equipment failed and caused the explosion sinking the ring, and causing the death of 11 workers and more than 17 workers injured. The British based energy company also faced other problems at the site of the oil spill. More than 40 million gallons (estimated data) of oil spewed into the Gulf of Mexico. Oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is a very serious threat for the wildlife as it causes water pollution. The oil spill effected many coastal areas in the US, like the Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi and Florida. The oil spill disaster strongly damaged wildlife cycle in the Gulf of Mexico, and many species were thrown into extinction. Similarly, thousands of businesses were thrown into extinction. Many people has questioned the ethical decisions and core value system that BP used to cut corners with the accident; namely, the race to maximize profits at all costs. We are all aware that one of the main causes that let to the disaster were the result of bad decisions, in which a less expensive option (whether to run a test or use a particular kind casing pipe, for example) would save lives. There has been “zero dollars spent on research concerning how to handle oil spills for off-shore drilling by BP despite the company's NET profits - above and beyond all salaries, bonuses, or overhead costs- of...

Words: 822 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Telecommunications

...This paper describes the situation at the United States (US) based company, Global Communications (GC) in the telecommunication industry. Different challenges and opportunities at GC are discussed. The paper continues by discussing the different stakeholders' perspective/ethical dilemmas and continues by framing a problem statement for the Global Communications situation. An expected end state situation is then described for GC scenario. The paper continues by analyzing different alternative solutions to the Global Communications situation , the risk for each solution is described and an optimal solution from a numbers of alternative solutions is selected. An implementation plan for the selection solution for the Global Communications situation is described and a metrics to monitor the plan is presented. This paper concludes by reviewing the selected solution to the situation and discussing the expected result. Issue and Opportunity Identification As a result of competition from cable companies, the United States based company, Global Communication (GC) is losing market share and profitability in the telecommunications market. The traded stock value has dropped from $28 to $11 in a two year period and stockholders are receiving diminishing returns (University of Phoenix, 2006). The stockholders have lost confidence in the management. Management is under pressure to renew stockholders confidence by increasing returns on the stock and the traded stock value. Senior management...

Words: 2824 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

British Petroleum (Bp)

...William J. McLeod Dr. Etido Akpan BUS 508: Contemporary Business 10 February 2012 British Petroleum (BP) is one of the world's leading international oil and gas companies, providing its customers with fuel for transportation, energy for heat and light, retail services and petrochemicals products for everyday items. In its global business, the company has several family brands: BP, ARAL, ARCO, Castrol, am/pm and Wild Bean Café. BP's global business is divided into three distinctive organizations to deliver energy products (Upstream, Refinance and Marketing, and BP Alternative Energy). Global Business: Created in September 2010, Upstream consists of three distinct Divisions – Exploration, Developments and Production. Within the Developments Division there are two Technical Functions the Global Wells Organization and the Global Projects Organization. Within the Production Division there are also two Technical Functions Operations and Subsurface. A Strategy and Integration organization led by a fourth Executive Vice President, (including HR, Finance, IT and Technology) and ensures integration across the Divisions and Functions. The downstream business segment converts crude oil into useful products such as fuels, lubricants and petrochemicals. It also stores and distributes these products to where they are needed, and markets them to customers in more than 70 countries. BP’s Refining and Marketing operations are carried out...

Words: 1489 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cvhhdg

...and ecological impact * Fisheries * Tourism * Individual impacts on states * Louisiana * Florida * Alabama * Unaccounted Oil * Commercial Law Suits * Damages paid * Long term effects * Reference Company Background * Name – British Petroleum * Founded- 1909 as the Anglo-Persian Oil Company 1954 as the British Petroleum Company 1998 merger of British Petroleum and Amoco * Industry – Oil Natural Gas Alternative Fuels Low carbon Energy Alternative Energy * Headquarters – St. James’s , City of Westminster , London (U.K) * Core BP brands * British Petroleum * Castrol...

Words: 2809 - Pages: 12