Premium Essay

To What Extent Does Executive Pay Influence Company Performance?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By carrie507
Words 655
Pages 3
There has been widespread controversy in recent years about the amount of compensation
CEO’s receive. CEO’s financial compensation packages were largely structured to incentivize risk taking in order to increase shareholder wealth (“Restraints on Executive Pay”, 2009). Yet, the 2008 financial crisis was mostly characterized by declining levels of company performance largely due to the increase of risk afforded to CEO’s by the attractiveness of lucrative executive incentives to perform. This essay argues that executive pay and its influence on company performance is both controversial and complex and concludes that executive pay has minimal influence on company performance and, when it does have influence, it tends to be negative.
It is widely believed that companies and their shareholders suffer from poor performance unless the importance of incentives for executives – most notably through monetary and stock compensation – is realized (Jensen and Murphy 1990). The notion that the level and performance sensitivity of pay affects the quality of managers an organization can attract in a competitive labor market for executives seems, on the surface, uncontroversial. However, whether compensation policy is truly “one of the most important factors in an organization’s success” (p.139), as Jensen and Murphy (1990) assert needs further examination
A series of empirical studies from a variety of industry, national, and time settings present evidence contrary to the conventional belief in the effectiveness of performance‐related pay. In a paper exploring the effect of executive compensation policy on the profitability of companies in Japan in 1993‐
1995, Kubo (1995) found very weak linkage between the pay‐performance sensitivity of a company’s compensation policy and its return on capital, prompting the researcher to conclude that “firms with
highly...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

To What Extent Does Executive Pay Influence Company Performance?

...4 million, which was 475 times the blue-collar wage. This phenomenon revealed that companies are putting increasing emphasis on the CEO’s pay packages, holding a belief that better company performance could be achieved from a higher pay packages for executives. In other words, the correlation between executive pay and company’s performance has been underlined by many corporate boards in recent years. With the skyrocketed executive pay in society, there has been an avalanche of debates over the strong bonding between executive pay and company’s performance, especially among shareholders of the companies who doubted if it is worthwhile to invest a significant amount of money on the executive pay package. In fact, despite the fact that executives has been justifying their pay packages with such correlation, still, I agree to a small extent that executive pay does influence company performance. There is no denying that monetary rewards could be translated to motivation for executives to contribute more and to strive for a more lucrative profit for the company. However, there is no guarantee that a higher remuneration for executives would give rise to a more outstanding company performance given that executive pay is not the only key to success for a company. As a matter of fact, there are a wide range of external determinants affecting companies’ performance that cannot be controlled by executives, with opportunities and threats being the most significant one. It would be......

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

To What Extent Does Executive Pay Influence Company Performance

...argument discussing about the impact of executive pay influence over company performance. It is often taken for granted that a company is able to have a better performance when the C-Suite is paid more. Nevertheless, the issue can be unexpectedly complicated in some cases and go way beyond a “more or less” question. Several empirical evidences reveal that an unwise form of payment could easily backfire and lead the company to be derailed, even if the compensation is appear to be highly tempting. In this article, based on the current pay system, the correlation between executive compensation and company performance will be studied, suggesting that although the two subjects are positively correlated from a theoretical perspective, restraints and loopholes indeed exist in the current context of economy. 2 The Current Pay System In the beginning of 1990s, a high level of executive compensation has already been regarded as an effective measure to solve the principal-agent problem within a company, that is, to align the benefit of shareholders and executive managers. It’s believed that the rise in executive pay serves as strong incentives, and conceivably, it could be stronger with a larger sum of money (Jenson, M and Murphy, K). Derived from the previous viewpoints and experiences alike, the current executive compensation usually comprises base salary, performance-based bonus and long-term incentives. The system is supposed to furnish executives not only with a large amount of......

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

To What Extent Does Executive Pay Influence Company's Performance

...Executive pay is often perceived by large as an excess of company compensation. But does it generally provide better results? It is evident that executive pay plays a role in a company’s performance, however the extent of its influence depends on the company’s policy on executive pay. In the essay I will examine how executive pay is dependent on company performance and whether this will affect future company development. The most basic concept is that the amount that executives are paid has a definite effect on performance. If an executive is paid a enormous amount of compensation, he is likely to be overconfident of his business decisions and is likely to take higher risks. This is due to his past performance that led to such high compensation. With such high compensation under the public eye, executives would feel compelled to perform better to live up to his expectations. But firstly, we have to determine if executive pay is performance based. The idealistic policy is to reward executives when they have made positive business decisions and have brought in profit for both the company and shareholders, all the while giving executives incentives to perform better in the next quarter. Some policies are equity-based, meaning bonus’ will link to share prices. This policy will undoubtedly benefit shareholders, because executives will be willing to take bigger risks to drive up the share price. Another reason they would take high risks is because whether the outcome is positive...

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Executive Pay and Company Performance

...To what extent does executive pay influence company performance Executive pay has a lot to do with company performance. Chief executives, as the leader of a company, can exert some impact on the company’s future. Normally, they get a large amount of payment as well as the severance pay. Except the base salaries, they often get a compensation which is several times of their remuneration. According to CNBC, the average S&P 500 company CEO made 373 times the salary of the average production and non-supervisory worker in 2014, up from 331 times in 2013, according to the AFL-CIO. I would argue that executive pay will effect company performance a lot economically and socially. That kind of high payment could become a motivation for both executives and employees. Just as mentioned by Kubo (2005), in order to get as much pay as executives, employees are more willing to work hard and this is beneficial to the performance of the whole firm. He also showed the evidence from Jensen and Murphy that a high pay-performance sensitivity is better for the company. This means, driven by this kind of system, executives need to pay more attention and put more effort on their daily management, since the payment and the performance are related. Moreover, affected by the sense of equity, executives will see to improve the firm profitability (Fong, 2010). Talented individuals will be attracted to companies which are willing to pay more. And this would make the company more competitive than......

Words: 554 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

To What Extent Do You Think Executive Payment Influence Company's Performance

...To what extent does executive pay influence company performance? Whether there is a relationship between the level of executive pay and company performance is a topic of great interest. The forms of executive pay can be both equity-based compensation which is based on the price of company’s stocks, like stocks and options, and non-equity-based compensation, such as cash compensation- including salary and bonus (Bebchuk & Fried, 2006 ). A company’s performance can be measured by its economic return, in other words, the accounting performance on financial statement (Gulen & Rau, 2009). This essay supports that executive pay may have no significant influence on company performance, because there are some ways that managers can decouple their payments from performance, and this essay will investigate these possible underlying reasons. There are studies examine the relationship between the pay policy and performance, and the results do not support the hypothesis that there is significant link between payment and performance. Kubo (2005) examined this link by investigate a group of Japanese companies and the result showed that companies with high pay-performance sensitivity did not get better performance. Gulen and Rau’s (2009) study on incentive pay also suggested that managerial compensation components such as restricted stock, options and long-term incentive payouts, that are meant to align managerial interests with shareholder value, do not necessarily translate......

Words: 827 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business

...To what extent does executive pay influence company performance? There has been widespread controversy in recent years about the amount of compensation CEO’s receive. CEO’s financial compensation packages were largely structured to incentivize risk taking in order to increase shareholder wealth (“Restraints on Executive Pay”, 2009). Yet, the 2008 financial crisis was mostly characterized by declining levels of company performance largely due to the increase of risk afforded to CEO’s by the attractiveness of lucrative executive incentives to perform. This essay argues that executive pay and its influence on company performance is both controversial and complex and concludes that executive pay has minimal influence on company performance and, when it does have influence, it tends to be negative. It is widely believed that companies and their shareholders suffer from poor performance unless the importance of incentives for executives – most notably through monetary and stock compensation – is realized (Jensen and Murphy 1990). The notion that the level and performance sensitivity of pay affects the quality of managers an organization can attract in a competitive labor market for executives seems, on the surface, uncontroversial. However, whether compensation policy is truly “one of the most important factors in an organization’s success” (p.139), as Jensen and Murphy (1990) assert needs further examination A series of empirical studies from a variety of industry, national...

Words: 809 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Review of Cadbury

...established in May 1991 by the Financial Reporting Council, the London Stock Exchange, and the accountancy profession. • Reasons:  Increasing lack of investor confidence in the honesty and accountability of listed companies.  Financial collapses of listed corporations.  Auditors who signed off a set accounts which turned out be a misrepresentation of the facts, and about losing its self-regulatory role.  Lack of board accountability for such matters as directors’ pay. Corporate Governance  Contemporary corporate governance started in 1992 with the Cadbury report in the UK Cadbury was the result of several high profile company collapses is concerned primarily with protecting weak and widely dispersed shareholders against self-interested Directors and managers   Cadbury Report 1992   The committee on the financial aspects of corporate governance’ The Code of Best Practice’ (1992)  Voluntary code ▪ But for listed companies a compliance statement was required ▪ ‘Comply or explain’ – Principles rather than rules  The ‘principles v rules’ argument (UK v USA)  The following example is a true case, but in a non-financial setting (from China Daily, December 2007) Corporate Governance Parties  Shareholders – those that own the company Directors – Guardians of the Company’s assets for the...

Words: 871 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Aaabbccdd

...Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 17, Number 3—Summer 2003—Pages 71–92 Executive Compensation as an Agency Problem Lucian Arye Bebchuk and Jesse M. Fried E xecutive compensation has long attracted a great deal of attention from financial economists. Indeed, the increase in academic papers on the subject of CEO compensation during the 1990s seems to have outpaced even the remarkable increase in CEO pay itself during this period (Murphy, 1999). Much research has focused on how executive compensation schemes can help alleviate the agency problem in publicly traded companies. To understand adequately the landscape of executive compensation, however, one must recognize that the design of compensation arrangements is also partly a product of this same agency problem. Alternative Approaches to Executive Compensation Our focus in this paper is on publicly traded companies without a controlling shareholder. When ownership and management are separated in this way, managers might have substantial power. This recognition goes back, of course, to Berle and Means (1932, p. 139) who observed that top corporate executives, “while in office, have almost complete discretion in management.” Since Jensen and Meckling (1976), the problem of managerial power and discretion has been analyzed in modern finance as an “agency problem.” Managers may use their discretion to benefit themselves personally in a variety y Lucian Arye Bebchuk is the William J. Friedman......

Words: 17317 - Pages: 70

Free Essay

Human Resource Management

...“What are the factors at play in determining the pay and conditions of London train drivers, top company executives and investment bankers, and how large differences in pay have impact on employee morale and employee relations.” The study is divided into two parts based on the following issues: (1) What are the factors at play which determine the pay and conditions of    London underground train drivers Top company executives Investment Bankers (2) To what extent may large differences in pay within an organisation impact upon employee morale and employee relations? If so what can be done to address the issue? 1.Introduction: From our basic knowledge, we know that for a job, there are different factors that help in determining the salaries and bonuses of an employee, job criteria and other work related issues. Similarly, to determine the pay and conditions of the London underground train driver, top company executive and investment bankers, there would be pay determining components/factors. However, since the above mentioned three jobs are different and unique, there pay determining factors too would be different. For the purpose of the study, Dunlop model has been considered. Now we will be having a close look at each of these pay determining factors one by one: 1/13 | P a g e Inputs Transformation Outputs Actors (Employers, Employees, State) Contexts (Technological, Market, Power) Ideology      Bargaining Conciliation Arbitration......

Words: 3817 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Compensation Management

...characteristics of executive compensation and its determinants; l understand the principles and practices of compensation administration; and l identify the major components of wage structure in India. Structure 17.1 Introduction 17.2 Compensation Issues 17.3 Compensation Function 17.4 Compensation Policies and Objectives 17.5 Compensation Administration 17.6 Compensation Determinants 17.7 Compensation Survey 17.8 Compensation Structure 17.9 Job Evaluation System 17.10 Pay Equity 17.11 Executive Compensation 17.12 Compensation Trends 17.13 Wage Structure in India 17.14 Case Study 17.15 Summary 17.16 Self-Assessment Questions 17.17 Further Readings 17.1 22 INTRODUCTION One of the most difficult functions of human resource management is that of determining the rates of monetary compensation. It is not only complex, but significant both to the organisation and employees. Employee compensation decisions are crucial for the success of an organisation. From a cost perspective alone, effective management of employee compensation is critical because of the total operating costs. Another reason for studying compensation from the organisation’s perspective is to assess its impact on a wide range of employee attitudes and behaviours and, ultimately the effectiveness of the organisation and its units. Compensation may directly influence key outcomes like......

Words: 6295 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Trader Jobs

...7- Eleven style store they had and they became top competitors to Whole Foods and Dean and Deluca giants. The case gives a description on the history of the retail chain and various aspects of its unique business practices. The retail store offered a selection of exclusive, which were mostly private-labeled products, and replaced poorly performing products with new ones. Trader Joe’s is a small supermarket chain which offers a limited selection of unique food products at reasonable prices. It sales most of its products under the private label 'Trader Joe's' and its variants. T.J. targets its stores at highly educated and travelled, but not necessarily wealthy, segments of the population. Trader Joe has a team of experienced buyers, who does extensive traveling and research before bringing new products into the stores (Palmeri, 2008). Trader Joe also avoids the middlemen in its supply chain, preferring to deal directly with suppliers and manufacturers by contracting early and by locking down prices. This has been able to ensure them strict control over the price and quality of the products it offers. Furthermore, Trader Joe’s competitive advantage also comes from its human capital, they have created a culture of...

Words: 1245 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Econmics

...level of their capabilities, lack motivation, and may be dissatisfied. This chapter describes what leadership is and examines major leadership models and theories that have been developed by various researchers. It also describes how managers engaging in transformational leadership can have a dramatic impact upon their organization and discusses the impact of gender on leadership. Learning Objectives 1. Describe what leadership is, when leaders are effective and ineffective, and the sources of power that enable managers to be effective leaders. 1. Identify the traits that show the strongest relationship to leadership, the behaviors leaders engage in, and the limitations of the trait and behavior models of leadership. 2. Explain how contingency models of leadership enhance our understanding of effective leadership and management in organization. 3. Describe what transformational leadership is, and explain how managers can engage in it. 4. Characterize the relationship between gender and leadership. MANAGEMENT SNAPSHOT: EFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP STYLES FOR TOUGH TIMES: LESSONS FROM HOWARD SCHULTZ, RICHARD SCHULZE, DAVID FARR, AND LOU GERSTNER Each of these persons is a current or former chairman or CEO. Their companies compete within different industries. What they have in common is that as leaders, they developed effective strategies that helped their respective companies to deal successfully with the challenges that it faced. Each focused on building their......

Words: 8219 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Jextra

...instructed to pursue a strategy of “aggressive growth” within this budding market.After eight months of employment,Chong begins to discern an undercurrent of unethical behavior surrounding Jextra and is forcedto contemplate what actions if any he will take to address two precarious situations. Chong’s initial concerns pertain to his meeting with the mayor of a Malaysian town called Klang, which is located near the country’s capital. Klang is not yet zoned for commercial purposes, but otherwise represents a seemingly perfect location for expansion. During a meetingregarding this potential store site, the mayor proposes that Jextra should contribute to a local primary school fund and incur some of the costs associated with road and electricitydevelopment near the Klang lot. Chong is unsure about the legality and logistics of these requested donations, and he doesn’t know if they are a prerequisite to gaining zoning permission. His suspicions are further aroused when he learns that the mayor’s sister is the leading championof the primary school fund, and that the road development planning was underway months before Jextra expressed interest in breaking ground in Klang. According to Jextra’s Business Conduct Code, “it is illegal to pay or receive a bribe inten ded to influence business conduct,” so Chong should have no qualms about denying the donations if they are a precondition of doing business in Malaysia. Furthermore, the code instructs employees not to partake in “any......

Words: 1161 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Motivation Theories

...Taylor & Francis G K Compensation, esteem valence and job performance: an empirical assessment of Alderfer's ERG theory CA. Arnolds and Christo Boshoff Abstract Improving the job perfomiance of employees has been the focus of many motivation theories, especially the need theories. These theories have however been questioned because of a lack of research on the causal relationship between need satisfaction and job perfonnance. Research on the link between the need satisfaction-job performance relationship and individual personality differences among people has also been neglected. This study addresses these research gaps as far as the intervening influence of personality variables on the need satisfaction-job performance relationship is concemed. The present study investigates the influence of need satisfaction (as suggested by the Alderfer theory) on self-esteem (the personality trait) and the influence of self-esteem on perfonnance intention (the surrogate measure for job performance) of top managers and frontline employees. The empirical results show that esteem as a personality variable exerts a significant influence on the job performance of both top managers and frontline employees. These and other findings provide important guidelines for managers on how to address the motivational needs of top managers and frontline employees in order to improve their job performance. Keywords Job performance; esteem valence; existence needs; relatedness......

Words: 5445 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Reward System

...Canadian Social Science Vol. 6, No. 5, 2010, pp. 102-123 ISSN 1712-8056 [Print] ISSN 1923-6697[Online] www.cscanada.net www.cscanada.org The Effect of Reward System on Job Satisfaction in an Organizational Chart of Four Hierarchical Levels: A Qualitative Study L'EFFET DU SYSTÈME DE RÉCOMPENSE SUR LA SATISFACTION AU TRAVAIL DANS UN ORGANIGRAMME DES QUATRE NIVEAUX HIÉRARCHIQUES: UNE ÉTUDE QUALITATIVE Ekaterini Galanou1 Georgios Georgakopoulos2 Ioannis Sotiropoulos3 Vasilopoulos Dimitris4 Abstract: Rewards systems are one of the most significant issues of the human resource management. Throughout the literature, it is obvious that theorists and academics, as well as practitioners and managers emphasize the important factor of rewards. Additionally, job satisfaction is another crucial term within the same body of literature. Job satisfaction is likely to provide employees of all levels with feelings of fulfillment, achievement and even pleasure for their job. Thus, such feelings can make people more productive, creative and therefore more profitable for the organization. Furthermore, feelings of job satisfaction can strengthen the commitment and loyalty of employees with the organization, which is very necessary in present times where all firms are looking for competitive advantage and especially through their people. The objective of this study is to examine the correlation of the rewards systems and job satisfaction, based on a qualitative research. An attempt is......

Words: 12803 - Pages: 52