Free Essay

Traditional Market vs Modern Market

In: Social Issues

Submitted By milalakodil
Words 1262
Pages 6
Traditional Market vs Modern Market

Market is a place where sellers and buyers meet each other to do some economics activities. The role of the market is very important for the economy of Indonesia. The sellers can sell their products to the buyers who need to buy something from the sellers. Instead, in traditional market the buyers can bargain the price of the goods sold by the sellers until they agreed with each other. The government has responsibilities for the activities happen in the markets. Not only for the capital markets but also for traditional market which are used for commerce. Traditional market sells the household’s goods and also foods. The majority of the buyers come from low and middle class. The government has the authority to regulate the implementation of the market in order to avoid people who involved feel harmed from the operational of the market until setting prices which will be sold in the market. Indonesia as a developing countries can be understood its behavior from 6 theories, which are: 1. The theory of Government Siding 2. The theory of Poskolonial 3. The theory of Culture 4. The theory of Authoritarian-Bureaucratic Country 5. The theory of Political Coalition and the Importance of Economics 6. The theory of the Triangular Alliance (Agustino, 2007: 40)
With those 6 theories, we can see how Indonesia regulate the implementation of the market. In this paper, we will discuss about the first theory, “The theory of Government Siding”, which is in Indonesia we call it as Teori Negara Berpihak. From the name of this theory, we know that the government will not be fair to their citizens. In this theory, the government will be more partial to the elite of this country. We can see from the reality life of Indonesia that actually this country also become more partial to the elite of this country. Nowadays, modern market becomes more exist in several cities. It makes the traditional market, which is the majority of the sellers is local citizens, lost their competitiveness and become worse.
Few days ago, I did some research in both market. Mrs. Leni, the 29 years old lady, said that when she wants to buy something she prefer to buy it in modern market because modern market is cleaner and more comfortable compared with traditional market. Although the price in modern market is more expensive than in the traditional market, people tend to buy products from the modern market because the quality of the products are guaranteed. Instead, each product has their own expired date. So customers who buy that products will know when the product become expired. And she said that when she comes to the modern market, it makes no worries to bring her children because modern market is safer than traditional market.
The second interviewee is Mrs. Eka, the 32 years old lady. She also said that she prefer to go shopping in modern market because she is not interested at bargaining goods in traditional market. She prefer to buy some goods which price is already set by the modern market. Also, she choose modern market because it is cleaner and more comfortable than the traditional market.
On the basis of both interviewee, Indonesian citizens are now become smarter for shopping. They prioritizing the clealiness rather than the price of some products. The quality also become the reason why nowadays citizens tend to go shopping in modern market rather than in traditional market.
With the tendency of people who prefer to choose modern market, this situation can make our government become worse because nowadays the differences between low and middle-class can be seen clearly. Traditional market which is occupied by the seller from lower class will faces bankruptcy if modern market spread more widely. If this condition still happen, the rich people will be richer and the poor one will still become poor. Like what Karl Marx had said, the government and the successor of his Marxis culture are an instrument which is used to take care the needs of elite or borjuis-capitalist (Agustino, 2007: 40).
If we see from Karl Marx’s statement, it is fair that finally in Indonesia the modern market is more increase than the traditional market. Modern market usually owned by the businessman. They usually buy a minimarket name from franchising. Then they can build that mini market in the city they want.
As wee see, there are many modern market like Indomaret and Alfamart in Yogyakarta. Instead, modern market also built in the village. It is equipped with air conditioner and cctv for security. Moreover, the fragrant of those modern market become the reason why people prefer to go shopping in modern market. The goods which are sold in modern market come from well-known brand in this country. Also imported brands are sold in this country. Products which are sold are not exceeds the expired date. So the customers will not get the outdated food.
But in my opinion, traditional market still have to be developed. Moreover, the last interviewee, Mrs. Wulan who is already 51 years old, prefer to go shopping in traditional market. She disagree with modern market which is make Indonesian people become individual and more consumptive. According to her, traditional market is more familiar because we can help the poor people who sells their goods. Besides, we can interact with the sellers. That is why traditional market is not individual like modern market.
The condition of traditional market in Yogyakarta is very poor. Pasar Demangan, the place where I did the interview, looks very poor also. It was dirty, smells bad, and hot. The comfortability cannot be felt in traditional market. Instead, there are several sellers who sell their goods until the sideroad. If we think in term of health, the foods which are sold in the sideroad is definitely unhealthy. Because vegetables, fruits, or other foods was already contaminated by the pollution from cars and motorcycles, like carbon monoxide.
In this problem, the government should be fair to its citizens. The government should serve the public from every element, so there will be no citizens who feel harmed. Besides set up the modern market, the government should serve people well who still visiting traditional market. The government should open their eyes and ear so they can fix and preserve traditional market which is already become our characteristic. At least, the government should giving a good image of traditional market. People only need to be served well in the traditional market, like the market should be smells good, clean, safe, and the product quality is guaranteed.
So, according to the Theory of Government Siding, developing country like Indonesia will make a decision by giving an advantage to the capitalist. Because the government wants to take advantages to run their administration. So in this problem they will be on modern market side which is owned by the capitalist. Citizens are now already move to modern market. According to the interviewees, they prefer modern market because it is more comfortable, cleaner, and smells good. The quality of products are also guaranteed and it has an expired date. But, there are many people who still go shopping in traditional market because it is one of Indonesian’s characteristic. In traditional market we can direcly interact with the sellers to do some bargaining until they agreed each other.

Reference:
Agustino, Leo, 2007, Perihal Ilmu Politik, Graha Ilmu: Yogyakarta
Interview with Mrs. Leni, June 10 2012
Interview with Mrs. Eka, June 10 2012
Interview with Mrs. Wulan, June 10 2012

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Market

...anymore. * He has a wide experience of traditional marketing techniques and develops his critical sense * He is subjected to contradictions of hyper selection * He refuses blind consumption, centred on ownership * Consumer is less and less sensitive to mass marketing: towards a new consumption model? The changing marketing landscape: digital age, rapid globalisation, ethics and social responsibility, not-for-profit marketing. Management orientations: these are alternative concept. Today there are different concepts. The don’t replace each other but new concepts appear. 1) Production concept: consumers prefer products that are widely available and affordable. 2) Product concept: Not only the availability of the product but also its quality, performance, innovation…Consumer will favour products that offer the most in quality, performance etc. 3) Selling concept: if you leave alone your consumer, he will not buy enough of your product. You must therefore invest in salesperson. It is used for products you don’t usually think of (donation, insurance) or when you have over capacity + door-to-door selling. Consumer will not buy anough without a large scale selling and promotion offer. 4) Marketing concept: customered centrered. The objective is not to find the best customer to your product but to find the right product for you customer. Focus on satisfying the needs and wants of target markets. 5) Societal Marketing......

Words: 700 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Inefficient Markets vs Efficient Markets

...The Efficient Market versus The Inefficient Market Many professionals have spent an endless time researching about the efficiency of the market. 5 years ago, we experienced one of the worst financial disasters in history and a lot of questions have been asked about the degree of efficiency of the market. Being in a recession has never been more dangerous because of globalization; the whole world can be affected, just like what happened in the crash of 2008. It started in the United States and went viral throughout the world. We could believe that the financial meltdown of 2008 was caused by market inefficiency but a market that is efficient can also be mispriced in some cases. If we follow the hypothesis of the efficient market, the current prices of a security should mirror the information available. The efficient market hypothesis offers three different forms: the weak form, semi strong form and strong form. The weak form states that investors are not to make unusual profits relying on historical prices. The semi-strong form commands that it is not possible to make uncommon profits solely using publicly available information due to the quick adjustment of the market which will prevent those profits. Also, using technical analysis for the semi-strong form will be useless to generate unusual profits. The third one is the strong form. It dictates that it is rarely the case when prices of securities include both the public and private information. However this form is......

Words: 1559 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Market

... Issues and Concerns of Commodity Derivative Markets in India: An Agenda for Research Nilanjan Ghosh 1. Introduction Commodity derivative markets have traditionally been a contentious issue at various policy forums across the world, particularly with the imbroglio created by allegations from various corners that they encourage excessive speculation and are therefore responsible for the recent commodity price escalation. While this suspicion of excessive speculation in the commodity markets has always been there among policymakers in developing nations like India, it has become more widespread since 2008 in the wake of worldwide inflationary pressures on food and energy. The sudden deflation in the value of various assets underlying different derivatives, which includes commodity derivatives, in the wake of the global meltdown has provoked greater apprehension about the economic utility of futures markets. The suspicion has reached such a high that even the U.S., the biggest proponent of market forces with the most active commodity exchanges in the world, is considering new modes of regulation, and is also investigating the role of commodity derivative trading in the steep rise in prices of wheat, rice, and crude oil. On the other hand, ever since commodity derivative trading was allowed in India in the new millennium, there has always been a hue and cry against such markets, with the alleged notion of excessive “speculation”, though there has rarely been any evidence for it....

Words: 6878 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Free Market vs Planned Economy

...Question Compare & contrast a market economy and a planned economy in terms of the following; provision of public goods, production and consumption of merit and demerit goods, consumer sovereignty and equity in income distribution. (30marks). A market economy is an economic system where the factors of production, are privately owned, consumers and producers are motivated by self interest, the level of competition in the markets is very high and resources are allocated through the price mechanism. The definition is supported by Lipsey (1992) who also state that decisions about resources allocation are made without any central direction but instead as a result of innumerable independent decision taken by individual producers & consumers hence in the market economy the individuals or market makes the ultimate decision in allocation of resources. Whereas the planned economy is one in which the coordination of economic activity so essential to the viability and functioning of a complex social economy is undertaken through administrative means commands, directives, targets and regulations rather than by market mechanism. The dictionary.com defined this economic system as a socialist economic system in which production and distribution of goods and services are controlled by the government and industry is mostly publicly owned. Provision of public goods These are goods that are non rivalry in consumption and non excludability as alluded by Stanlake (2000) He also......

Words: 1296 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Traditional vs Modern Science and Technology.. .

...The traditional meaning of science and technology is viewed in different ways. In its broad term technology is dealing with the use and knowledge of humanity’s tools and crafts. It is also a knowledge of using tools and machines to do tasks efficiently. We often use technology to control the world in which we live and it is developed to extend human capabilities. Technology is an innovation, change, or modification of the natural environment to satisfy perceived human needs and wants. we can also view technology in four aspects. First, technology is defined as technics which refer to material products of human making or fabrication. It refers to all material artifacts produced by a person or group in society. Second, technology is viewed as a technology which refers to the complex of knowledge, methods, materials and constituent parts used in making certain kind of technic. it means that not only one technology is use in making a certain kind of technic. technology is also a form of human cultural activity so it is viewed as a distinctive form of human practice like other proffesions which is pratice by technologists like mechanists and engineers. Lastly, technology as a total societal enterprise is the complex of knowledge, people, skills, organizations, facilities, technichs, physical resources, methods,and technologies that taken together and in relationship to one another are devoted to the research, development, production, and operation of technics. in this sense......

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Oreo: Us vs China Market

...Oreo: US Vs China Market Oreo is a sandwich cookie that is made of two outer chocolate round biscuits filled with cream. The “Oreo Biscuit” was first introduced in the United States in 1912 in New York City by The National Biscuit Company, now known as Nabisco. Currently, Nabisco is a division of the Mondelez International brand. In its long history, the Oreo has been known by various different names including the “Oreo Sandwich”, introduced in 1921, the “Oreo Crème Sandwich” in 1948 and finally the “Oreo Chocolate Sandwich Cookie” in 1974. The very first Oreo design was a simple wreath around the embossed word Oreo. In 1952, William A Turnier, created the Oreo design that is still used today, complete with the Nabisco logo and much further embossing around the cookie. In the 1990's, concerns about the health of Oreo's, regarding the lard in the cream filling, sparked a change in the recipe. The cookie filling was now made with partially hydrogenated vegetable oil. In 1997, following a three year recipe development, Oreo made their cookies Kosher and many consumers were over-joyed by this change. Later, Oreo suffered some criticism still, and in 2006 the recipe was changed again, only with the use of non-hydrogenated vegetable oil. This put Oreo on the “accidentally vegan” list on Peta.org and has since changed its previously negative views on the cookie's health to very positive, in moderation. On March 6th 2012, Oreo celebrated it's 100th anniversary in......

Words: 452 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Market

...services industry. Its founders formulated their own blend of 3-in-1 instant white coffee and commenced manufacturing in 1999. The same year, they successfully commercialised the instant 3-in-1 coffee mix under the ‘OldTown’ brand name for the retail sector. By end of 2009, the OldTown 3-in-1 instant coffee mix was sold at 1,348 retail outlets in Malaysia, 550 retail outlets in Singapore and 2,100 retail outlets in Hong Kong. In 2005, it expanded vertically into the food services sector by opening a chain of café outlets based on the traditional Ipoh coffee shop setting and ambience under the ‘OldTown White Coffee’ brand name. Since the opening of its first café outlet in Ipoh in 2005, its chain of café outlets has expanded to around 160 café outlets in Malaysia and Singapore. This includes fully and partially owned, and franchised café outlets. The management has successfully mixed tradition with modern conveniences, revamped and revived the traditional café concept into a successful working model with outlets conveniently located and easily accessible to customers. http://www.bfsmagazine.com.my/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=165:oldtown-white-coffee&catid=88:food-and-beverage&Itemid=678 History of Oldtown White Coffee Established in 1999, the co-founders and Executive Director, Mr Goh Ching Mun and Mr Tan Say Yap are the incorporation of White Café and provide quality white coffee to Malaysian households and the food services industry.......

Words: 2215 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Markets

...deliberation. Initial market entry decisions have typically focused on country evaluations based on macro-economic data. While appropriate in providing an initial screening of countries, other factors, notably contextual factors, can provide important insights in assessing international market opportunities. The purpose of this paper is to examine the impact of context at four distinct levels. Design/methodology/approach – The literature on the influence of context on consumption and purchase behavior is reviewed to provide a framework to understand contextual factors as a means to refine entry strategy and develop effective segmentation strategies. Findings – A wide range of contextual factors exert influence on consumption choices and contribute to within-country heterogeneity. These are typically examined at the macro-level, but also need to be examined at the meso-level, micro-level and situational level to fully assess market opportunities and establish viable market segments. Practical implications – Examination of contextual factors provides a richer and deeper understanding of which international markets to enter and which segments to target. Within-country cultural diversity, dramatic economic and regional disparities and marked differences in the infrastructure need to be assessed. In particular, examination of contextual factors helps to shed light on heterogeneity within countries not only in customer behavior, but also in the nature of the market infrastructure.......

Words: 6454 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Market Economy vs. Market Society

...Tiffany Coulam December 11, 2014 Business Ethics Professor Kitanov Market Economy vs. Market Society Market is defined as an area or an arena in which commercial dealings are conducted and is from the Latin mercatus which means ‘buy.’ This is absolutely appropriate for the environment where economic transactions take place. But is this same arena appropriate for the facets of life that have traditionally been governed by more spiritual and moral beliefs? Many intellectuals have posed the question, “Should everything in this world be up for sale?” In the book, What Money Can’t Buy, Michael J. Sandel states that we have morphed from a market economy into a market society. He argues that the market has entered into areas that moral law should reside over and there are, or should be, ‘moral limits’ to markets. In the wake of the worst economic crisis since The Great Depression, it is time to rethink the notion that markets values are the end all and be all of our society. Americans tend to believe that the market’s invisible hand is the greatest caretaker, the best in producing the greatest good for the greatest number of people. The recent financial crisis could not even shake this mentality. The people “discredited the government more than the banks” (Sandel 12). For decades, industrialism and market triumphalism have prevailed over this nation. There are strong arguments for the capitalist markets and their benefits. The finer things in life such as,......

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Market

...Evaluating Competitiveness Using Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process - A Case Study of Chinese Airlines Abstract With the development of a national market economy, the Chinese aviation industry is now confronted with international competition. Therefore, it is necessary to research the competitive status of Chinese national aviation, as well as advice on how to enhance the competitiveness of the Chinese aviation industry. The main objective of this paper is to propose FAHP as an effective solution for resolving the uncertainty and imprecision in the evaluation of airlines’ competitiveness. In this paper, we review the research of industrial international aviation competitiveness at both home and abroad, discuss a theoretical framework for the study of aviation competitiveness, establish an index system with 5 first-order indicators and 17 second-order indicators, set up a Chinese aviation competitiveness model based on simple fuzzy numbers from the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process, and evaluate the competitiveness of 5 major Chinese airlines. The results show that this model and these indicators are scientific and practical, with a wide range of application prospects for the purpose of improving and increasing Chinese airline competitiveness in the international market. The effective approach presented in this paper is especially applicable when subjective judgments on performance ratings and attribute weights are not accessible or reliable, or when suitable decision......

Words: 7415 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Capital Markets of Philippines vs. Hong Kong

...Overview of the Hong Kong Capital Market Located in the heart of Asia, Hong Kong positioned itself to be a major international financial center of the continent. Its capital market is comprised of integrated network of institutions and markets which provide a wide range of products and services to local and international customers and investors. Hong Kong’s financial markets are characterized by a high degree of liquidity and operate under effective and transparent regulations, which meet international standards. The Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR) abides by the principle of keeping intervention into the way in which the market operates to a minimum and has endeavoured to provide a favorable environment in which business operates. Its policy of low and simple taxation allows maximum room for business initiatives and innovation. There is a strong emphasis on the rule of law and fair market. There are no barriers of access to the market by foreign businesses and no restrictions on capital flows into and out of Hong Kong. Hong Kong’s privileged location in the Northeast Asia, on the other hand, makes it a gateway to China. Moreover, Hong Kong is situated at appropriate time zones that allow 24-hour continuous trading of foreign exchange and gold when the two markets in New York and London are closed. II. Financial Players and Intermediaries in Hong Kong Preview:A closer look at the financial markets As of July 2010, there were......

Words: 13954 - Pages: 56

Premium Essay

Market

...OVERVIEW OF MARKETING OVERVIEW OF MARKETING 1 LEARNING OBJECTIVES After reading this module, students should: Know why marketing is important Know what is the scope of marketing Know some of the fundamental marketing concepts Know how marketing management has changed Know what are the necessary tasks for successful marketing management Know scope and importance of marketing Know what are the recent trends of marketing Know what are the different levels of market segmentation Know how a company can divide a market into segments Know how a company should choose the most attractive target markets Know what marketing mixes are. SUMMARY From a managerial point of view, marketing is an organizational function and a set of processes for creating, communicating, and delivering value to customers and for managing customer relationships in ways that benefit the organization and its stake holders. Marketing management is the art and science of choosing target markets and getting, keeping, and growing customers through creating, delivering, and communicating superior customer value. Marketers are skilled at managing demand: They seek to influence the level, timing, and composition of demand. Marketers are involved in marketing many types of entities: goods, services, events, experiences, persons, places, properties, organizations, information, and ideas. They also operate in four different marketplaces: consumer, business, global, and......

Words: 8049 - Pages: 33

Free Essay

Traditional Chinese Method vs Modern Medicine

...Traditional Chinese Medicine Vs Modern Medicine Name Department Module Date History of medicine Medicine is a field of great scientific importance and interest; it has been practiced by experts and professionals throughout different eras of time. Over different time eras and periods, many societies and civilization made discoveries adding to the achievements. Ancient Egyptians and the ancient Indians are known for their advances in medicine. They together gave the concept of diagnosis and examination in medicine. The Hippocratic Oath has been taken by physicians to follow an ethical code while practicing medicine since the 5th century BC; this oath was written by the Greeks (Zhang 2009). The Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) made some great discoveries and led the medicine forward with their newly found discoveries and understanding of the human body. Furthermore, methods of trauma treatment were further created and public health services were provided. Medicine has seen a systematic growth over the years, and even now, discoveries are made and new insights are revealed. This has been due to various machines and equipment’s that the doctors have designed making diagnosis and treatment much easier. Discovery of new drugs and Nano-particles has brought health care come a long way. (Zheng, Chang and Chen 2014) The Chinese Myths of Medicine The traditional Chinese medicine revolves around a number of different practices which share similar grounds. These medicinal......

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Market

... | | |Hax and Majluf, Resource Allocation and Portfolio Management, Chapter 17, The Strategy Concept and Process-A Pragmatic Approach, 1996, pp. | | |276-322. | | |Collis, D.J. and Montgomery CA, Creating Corporate Advantage, Harvard Business Review, May-June, 1998, pp. 71-83. | | |Yip, G.S., Global Strategy: In World of Nations, Sloan Management Review, Fall 1989, pp. 29-41. | | |Yip, G.S., Loewe, PM, and Yoshino, MY, How to take your company to the global market, Winter 1998, pp.37-48. | | |Michael, E. Porter, The Five Competitive forces that shape Strategy, Harvard Business Review, January, 2008, pp.78-97 | Relevant websites: |S. No |Web address (Exact page address) |Salient Features | |1 |http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_management |Detailed description about Str. Mgt | |2 |www.emeraldinsight.com |Case studies | |3 ......

Words: 2548 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Market

...------------------------------------------------- SWOT Analysis(Eureka Forbes)------------------------------------------------- | Strengths-Spends Rs 120 million on all sales activities.- The most established competitor in the water Purifier market.- A well established brand name Aquaguard. -Recent introduction of a second brand of water purifier called “Pureslip”. - No electricity required for Pureslip.- Broad line of modern lifestyle products including water purifiers, vacuum cleaners, and mixers/grinders. -Huge sales force was, highly motivated, and well managed.-Television commercials, advertisements in magazines and newspaper supported the personal selling efforts. | Weakness-Aquagurad will not function without electricity. -Consumers mistakenly used it to refer to other water purifiers or to the entire product category.- Its product contains small amounts of activated carbon that cannot remove strong odors or inorganic solute.-Overall, the product has no storage capacity and a slow flow rate for consumers. -This product can only be mounted on the kitchen wall and requires electricity of 190 volts or higher.-Overall, the product has the weakest strategic component.- Enormous fixed cost & limited sales efforts to large urban areas. | Opportunities-Market is focused on one or two of India’s 25 states-Reduce Fixed costs.-Well established company with a broad line of products. - 85% of Indian’s population lived in rural areas , where water quality was......

Words: 527 - Pages: 3