Free Essay

Tragedy Essay

In: English and Literature

Submitted By niamhmilly
Words 1233
Pages 5
I believe that this statement ‘Tragedy shows us the unspeakable to prepare us for the worst’ is very true especially in relation to the films we have watched in the module course; Old boy, Far North and The Grizzly Man. In this essay I will discuss what is meant by the word tragedy, its origins, and what are the characteristics of this genre. I will also examine how the statement ‘tragedy shows us the unspeakable to prepare us for the worst’ is a true statement especially in relation to the module ‘Tragic Contexts’ and the films we have studied in this module. Though the origins of Tragedy are somewhat obscure it apparently started with the singing of a choral lyric in honour of Dionysus. This choral lyric was performed in a circular stage by a group of men who many have impersonated satyrs by wearing masks and dressing in goat-skins. This is why tragedy is derived from the Greek word tragoedia meaning ‘goat-song’. Scholars suspect that at that time a goat was either the prize in a competition of choral dancing, or the chorus danced around the goat before using it for a ritual sacrifice to the God Dionysus. As Dionysus was the Greek God of the grape harvest, winemaking, ritual madness and ecstasy. This is believed by Athenaeus of Naucratis who claims that the original form of the word tragedy was trygodia from trygos meaning grape harvest, as these events were first introduced during the grape harvest. In 335 BCE Aristotle provides us with the earliest surviving explanation for the origin of tragedy as a dramatic art form in his ‘Poetics’. Here he argues that tragedy developed from hymns and dances of praise to Dionysus;

‘Anyway, arising from an improvisatory beginning (both tragedy form he leaders of the dithyramb, and comedy from the leaders of the phallic processions which even now continue as a custom in many cities),[tragedy] grew little by little, as [the poets] developed whatever [new part] of it had appeared; and, passing through many changes, tragedy came to a halt, since it had attained its own nature’

In the same work, Aristotle attempts to provide a scholastic definition of what tragedy is;

‘Tragedy is, then, an enactment of a deed that is important and complete, and of [a certain] magnitude, by means of language enriched [with ornaments], each used separately in the different parts [of the play]: it is enacted, not [merely] recited, and thought pity and fear it effects relief (catharsis) to such [and similar] emotions’

By definition Tragedy is an art form based on real human suffering performed for its audience’s pleasure and enjoyment. The idea itself teaches us a lot more about our selves then we may like to know. The basic truth that we as humans enjoy and find pleasure in tragedy and tragic events - once we are not affected by them. Tragedy describes the roots of agony and is a well established genre. Tragedy is several things at once, and serves a great purpose for our entertainment and growth. What doesn’t’t kill you makes you stronger - so therefore we learn from tragedy. It is ultimately violence for the sake of violence, in its full extent is in wild, ferocious and uncontrollable. We as humans can never capture or control tragedy - unless we are implementing tragic actions on someone else. Tragedy teaches us that our faith is ultimately written. Tragedy was created for the same reasons religion was - as people are afraid of death, and tragedy dramatises moments of utter despair. We humans do not like to admit that suffering exists, we cling to the illusion that something will remain and survive through the tragedy. This can be especially seen in the films that we have studied throughout this module, as these films show us huge degrees of unthinkable and unspeakable scenes and images that prepare us to be able to cope with any greater tragedy that may arise. Each scene shows us a greater, more heightened degree of tragedy than the previous scenes. This technique slowly prepares us for the climax of the film that we would possibly not be able to handle had we not viewed the scenes before. In a sense they are gently easing us into the sheer horror that will unfold before our eyes. This method of filming is not only seen in these films it is somewhat the natural method that the God’s (or mother nature) use for creating tragedy in human life. The tragedy starts off small and escalates into its full potential. Thus either consciously or subconsciously preparing us for the worst that is yet to come. In Far North this idea of tragedy showing us the unspeakable to prepare us for the worst can most definitely be seen. In the first opening scenes if the film we are shown how the women kills one of their pet husky dogs as meat to eat for their dinner, she also does this without any signs of remorse or emotion. This immediately sets the scene for what later occurs in the film. As this brutal scene immediately prepares us that the worst is yet to come. Our suspicions are then confirmed in the final scene where not only does she kill the girl but she cuts of her face and wears it as her own in order to get what she wants - which is to have sex with Loki. She commit’s a crime that is extremely inhuman in order to feel more human. This highlights how brutal tragedy can be and how selfish and cruel people become when they desperately want their own way. Had we not viewed the previous scenes of tragedy we would have found this final scene even more horrific then we do now. By showing us scenes of unspeakable tragedy at the beginning and middle or the film it prepares us for the ending - which in tragedy films tends to be the climax of the tragic events and thus the worst. All the scenes before this are slowing setting the ‘tragic train’ in motion that will finally reach its destination. In Old boy this is also very apparent that the tragedy portrayed in this film is so unspeakable that it prepares us for the worst. From the beginning of this film events just spiral out of control for the protagonist Oh Dae-su, he is truly a man more sinned against than sinning as his live consists of tragedy after tragedy as he tried to find his capturer. His only fault was having spoken ‘the unspeakable’ about his captivator many years previous and thus he is now faced with the consequences. This film shows us many scenes of tragedy that are extremely gory and realistic. Each scene in a sense pushes the visual boundaries of the previous. These actions are all due to the revenge tragedy that has been inflicted on Oh Dae-su. This film shows us how tragedy can be horrific yet simultaneously brilliant. Over all I believe that the statement ‘Tragedy shows us the unspeakable to prepare us for the worst’ is a very true statement, that can most definitely been seen reflected in the films we have studies in this module ‘Tragic Contexts’.

Bibliography:
 http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0056%3Asection%3D1449b
 POETICS IV , 1449a 10-15 Janko 1987,6

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Essay On Medieval Tragedy

...During the Renaissance period, which spanned between 14th century and 17th century, an old genre of literature was reinvented into a newer form that was closer to the mentality and the social development of the time, that being the tragedy. This type of literature has its origins in the Ancient Greek and Roman tragedy, which emerged around 2,500 years ago, in the 6th century BC. Tragedy, by its definition, is “a form of drama based on human suffering that invokes an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in audiences” (qtd. in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy). Tragedy is considered to have been invented for the worshiping of Dionysus , which they considered to be one of their deities . In Greek, “tragedy” is called “tragodia”, which means goat song, being composed of the words “tragos” which means “he-goat” and “aeidein” which means “to sing” which is believed to make a reference to an old custom of offering a goat in competitions of choral dancing or using it for ritual sacrifices, but not before dancing around it. The three big representatives of Ancient tragedy are Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides. Their work further represented the inspiration for the medieval tragedy which developed during 14th century Middle Age, inside cathedrals, a highly...

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Essay on Corruption in the Revengers Tragedy and Hamlet

...Orezina Sonoiki With “Revenger’s Tragedy” being set in Italy, it is almost inevitable that the book will not revolve partly around corruption amongst many other themes. Middleton starts this play on a strong note as corruption starts to flow right from the beginning of the text. Vindice a character filled with anger and bitterness opens the play holding the skull of his fiancée who the Duke poisoned upon her refusal to sleep with him. His hatred of the Duke is shown as he describes him saying: “Duke, royal lecher; go, grey-haired adultery.” Vindice talks about lustfulness, which is a form of corruption. His anger and harsh tone towards the Duke is expected as he feels hurt and he even goes as far as to call the Duke myself, adultery. Vindice is also angry about the discrimination his father faced before his death. Middleton uses his character as an immediate way to reflect the unjust treatment during that period and how corruption was almost seen as the norm. It equally shows how power drunk kings got. Lustfulness is a form of corruption present in the play. The first time we come across lust is when Vindice pours out his feelings towards the Duke. He first of all refers to the Duke as committing adultery as quoted earlier on. He also refers to Spurio, the illegimate son of the Duke as “thou his bastard,” which identifies him as being born of wedlock. This reflects the Duke’s lustfulness even further. Hippolito is another character who draws attention to the......

Words: 1932 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Aristotle- Tragedy Essay

...Aristotle’s definition of a tragic hero can be seen in many works of Literature, and has verified its importance towards a lot of authors. His definition basically states that the character comes from a noble figure, occupies a high position in his/her society or kingdom and epitomizes a tragic flaw that ultimately leads to his or her downfall. The term Hubris is defined as excessive pride and self-confidence. It indicates that the person who exhibits it has lost contact with reality and always overestimates his accomplishment, which can lead to his/her downfall. The downfall could be anything from mental disturbance to even death. The concept of a tragic hero can definitely be seen in Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex and Shakespeare’s King Lear. Even though there are differences in both the writing, they also have some similarities. In Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex, the title character was the king of Thebes, and his city was infected with a poisonous plague. To discover the source of the plague and to get rid of it, the Oracle of Delphi was called. It turned out to be that the only way to get rid of plague would be to banish the killer of the former ruler of Thebes, Laius, from the city-state. Oedipus was Laius’s and Jocasta’s son, which was given to shepherd and was order to kill Oedipus, because it was found out that he would kill his father and sleep with his mother. He was very shocked after hearing this because he did not believe that he would ever do something like that. Jocasta......

Words: 1999 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Pica

...characteristics that constitute a tragedy have evolved since the time of the Greeks. Recently, in the 20th century, Arthur Miller published an essay that gives a modern definition of what a tragedy is and lists the properties and characteristics that a play must contain to actually be considered a tragedy. Miller states that a play is recognized as a tragedy when it presents a character that is willing to “lay down his life, if need be, to secure one thing–his sense of personal dignity.” This character is trying to find his “‘rightful’ position in society,” but is eventually destroyed by shame that is caused by what is perceived as unfair treatment. Therefore, according to Miller, tragedy is the consequence of a man’s need to evaluate himself fairly (Miller “Tragedy”). The three dramas being evaluated, The Tragedy of Othello, Oedipus Rex, and Death of a Salesman, all fit this definition of a tragedy to some degree. The degree to which the parameters of dramatic tragedy are fulfilled in each play increases from The Tragedy of Othello to Oedipus Rex to Death of a Salesman. Out of the plays being analyzed, The Tragedy of Othello is the least tragic of the three. Othello, as a character, is a tragic hero that does actually give his own life in order to secure his sense of personal dignity (Shakespeare 1542). Othello feels that, despite the influence of Iago, he himself caused Desdemona's death as well as much of the other damage and tragedy that has occurred, and the......

Words: 608 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Poetry

...meant royalty. He is 'universal,' meaning that everyone everywhere can relate to the kinds of problems or sufferings or emotions that the hero experiences. He has a 'tragic flaw' - this could be a personality trait (like greed, lust, ambition, jealousy, etc.), OR an error in judgement (a bad decision). This 'tragic flaw' leads to his downfall - usually ruins his career, reputation, power, etc. He is enlightened at the end of the story, meaning he realizes where he went wrong, he is humble, and he accepts the consequences . A tragic hero is a character in a work of fiction (often the protagonist) who commits an action or makes a mistake which eventually leads to his or her defeat. The idea of the tragic hero was created in ancient Greek tragedy and defined by Aristotle (and others). Usually, this includes the realization of the error (anagnorisis), which results in catharsis or epiphany. Aristotelian tragic hero Characteristics Aristotle once said that "A man doesn't become a hero until he can see the root of his own downfall." An Aristotelian tragic hero must have four characteristics: Nobility (of a noble birth) or wisdom (by virtue of birth). Hamartia (translated as flaw, mistake, or error, not an Elizabethan tragic flaw). A reversal of fortune(peripetia) brought about because of the hero's Hamartia. The discovery or recognition that the reversal was brought about by the hero's own actions (anagnorisis). Other common traits Some other common traits......

Words: 1753 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Hamlet Essay

...Perceiving Tragedy A tragedy is considered to be an event causing great suffering, destruction, and distress. Arthur Miller's essay, 'Tragedy and the Common Man', contributes many different ideas on how he perceived tragedy. Trying to fulfil one's lives and personalities is usually how a tragic story happens. Hamlet tries to get revenge on Claudius when he find out what really happened to his father, starting his tragic story. He feels betrayed and is working hard to get his rightful position back. There is always the possibility that Hamlet is going to succeed in his mission. Tragedy is something that happens to everyone that is trying to fulfill themselves as a person, someone that is on a mission to get what they want. Hamlet starts with the plan of trying to get revenge on Claudius when he find out what the complete truth of what happened to his father. This is explained when he says, "As meditation or the thoughts of love, may sweep to my revenge." (Act 1, Scene 5, lines 30-31). He is a tragic hero, in which he goes on this mission of trying to get revenge for himself and his father, and ultimately succeeds, but then dies. He had a plan throughout the play, had many chances to fulfil the plan, but never went through with it. In Arthur Miller's essay, this is explained when he says "The tragic feeling is evoked in us when we are in the presence of a character who is ready to lay down his life, if need be, to secure one thing--his sense of personal dignity." (Miller,......

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Philosophy

...Hamartia in Oedipus the King According to the Aristotelian characteristics of good tragedy, the tragic character should not fall due to either excessive virtue or excessive wickedness, but due to what Aristotle called hamartia. Hamartia may be interpreted as either a flaw in character or an error in judgement. Oedipus, the tragic character in Sophocles’ Oedipus the King, certainly makes several such mistakes; however, the pervasive pattern of his judgemental errors seems to indicate a basic character flaw that precipitates them. Oedipus’ character flaw is ego. This is made evident in the opening lines of the prologue when he states "Here I am myself--you all know me, the world knows my fame: I am Oedipus." (ll. 7-9) His conceit is the root cause of a number of related problems. Among these are recklessness, disrespect, and stubbornness. Oedipus displays an attitude of recklessness and disrespect throughout the play. When he makes his proclamation and no one confesses to the murder of Laius, Oedipus loses patience immediately and rushes into his curse. Later, he displays a short temper to Tiresias: "You, you scum of the earth . . . out with it, once and for all!," (ll. 381, 383) and "Enough! Such filth from him? Insufferable--what, still alive? Get out--faster, back where you came from--vanish!" (ll. 490-492) If an unwillingness to listen may be considered stubbornness, certainly Oedipus would take advice from no one who would tell him to drop the matter of his...

Words: 4487 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Hamlet Tragedy

...Hamlet Essay Tragedies commonly involve disasters, horrible mishaps and death. The great Greek philosopher Aristotle believed that a tragedy must have action which is pushed along by the character flaw of a “great” man. This idea of a “great” man or a person of high ranking being the protagonist in a tragedy is perpetuated in all of Shakespeare’s work. This leaves to speculate on the average person. The average person is not completely safe from the misery of tragedy. A supporting character is just as likely as any main character to experience tragedy. According to Arthur Miller, the “common” person is just as suitable for tragedy as any “great” person. The ideas of Aristotle and Miller contrast each other however both elements are noticeable in the play Hamlet. When a “great person” or the main character goes through a tragedy, it is rather evident. Ophelia and her father Polonius are considered “common” characters in the play that also experience great tragedy. In Miller’s essay, he outlines three main aspects that a “common” person would exhibit in a tragedy which makes their circumstances tragic. Firstly is the presence of a character that is ready to lay down their life to secure their personal sense of dignity. Next is the fear of being displaced and torn away from ones chosen image of their self. Lastly is being capable of victory. Ophelia and Polonius have chosen images of themselves and what their lives should be like and are willing to lay down their lives for......

Words: 353 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Research Paper of King Oedipus

...Oedipus The King ” by Sophocles. Research essay over ” Oedipus The King ” by ... the integration of sources into your paper; organization ... - Research PaperOedipus the king research paper. To convey your essay perfectly, calm down and be sure youll get a nice opportunity to change the situation with a friendly and ...Sample Research Paper. The first theme is the free will and fate. Fate as a theme has been a part of all Greek writings in particular. A factor of inevitability that ...A 7 page research paper that examines the various ways that Sophocles classic tragedy has been interpreted. The writer argues that the Freudian interpretations are ...Essays for Oedipus Rex or Oedipus the King. Oedipus Rex (Oedipus the King) essays are academic essays for citation.Professional Help with Writing Oedipus Essays. ... How to write Oedipus essay: First is to conduct research by finding out about the story, ... Research Paper Help.Get Instant Access to Research Paper On Oedipus The King at our eBook Library. 5/11 Research Paper On Oedipus The King [PDF] class 8 social science guide ncertOedipus the king. Oedipus the king. English and Literature. Paper instructions: Essay Question: What are Oedipus’ main personal qualities, good and bad, and what in ...Oedipus the King In research papers on Oedipus the King by Sophocles, there is the example of the classic tragic hero in the character Oedipus.accessing Research Paper On Oedipus The King Books on your computer, your have found the......

Words: 382 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Which Play Is More Tragic: Hamlet or Agamemnon

...Which Play is More Tragic: Hamlet or Agamemnon In my opinion, the play Hamlet is more tragic than Agamemnon. They are both tragedies as they both fulfill Aristotle’s definition of tragedy as they both depict the downfall of a basically good person through some fatal error or misjudgment, which produces suffering and insight on the part of the protagonist and arousing pity and fear on the part of the audience. They also have all the elements of Greek tragedy such as hubris, catharsis, peripeteia, anagnorisis, and hamartia (“Ancient Greek Tragedy”). The most important reason that Hamlet is more tragic, in my opinion, is because the protagonist, Hamlet, is an integral part of the play and his character is much more developed. In Agamemnon , the protagonist, Agamemnon, is a secondary character to his wife who, in my opinion is the main character. Hamlet is a tragic hero, as is Agamemnon, following Aristotle’s criteria for the elements of a tragic hero. For example, they both evoke the audience’s pity and fear, have a major flaw of character and are destined to fall in some way (“Tragedy in Drama”). However, because Hamlet is the main character, we see, hear and understand more of his character. When Hamlet delivers his many dramatic soliloquies about mortality, betrayal, and the futility of life, he shows us his tortured world and the anguish, grief, and uncertainty which eventually takes over his life, leading to his death (“Hamlet Tone”). As the reader, I felt so much......

Words: 567 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Death and Everyman

...1500-words (about 5–7-pages) essay that addresses one of the plays from the Drama Unit. A minimum of six citations, including the primary source and at least five secondary scholarly sources, is required for this assignment. Before you begin writing the essay, carefully read the guidelines for developing your paper topic that are given below. Review the research paper Grading Rubric to see how your submission will be graded. Gather all of your information, plan the direction of your essay, and organize your ideas by developing a one-page thesis statement, outline, draft, and bibliography for your research paper. Format the thesis statement and the outline in a single Word document using MLA, APA, or Turabian style (whichever corresponds to your degree program). You have the opportunity to receive helpful instructor feedback if you submit your thesis, outline, draft, and bibliography by the end of Module/Week 7. The research paper is due by the end of Module/Week 8, and should include a title page, thesis statement, and outline, followed by the research essay itself and your correctly documented sources page. Guidelines for Developing Your Paper Topic Chapters 40 and 41 provide helpful pointers for writing about plays and for developing research papers. Be sure to review both chapters thoroughly before you begin doing any further work for this assignment. Choose one of the prompts below to address in your paper: 1. Write an essay explaining how Sophocles’......

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

To What Extent Is Eddie Carbone the Tragic Hero of the Play

...New York, 1915. He started to write plays while he was at University of Michigan, and even carried on after graduating. Miller grew up in Brooklyn; this was where the play was set. As Miller was trying to make a name for himself, he worked at a shipyard for two years. He heard stories form his Italian friends he works alongside about how some men coming over to work illegally and being betrayed. This is where ‘A View from the Bridge’ was first inspired. Tragedy: it is a dramatic event where the main character is tested in certain circumstances in which the characters real form becomes unmasked. Aristotle was a famous Greek philosopher and writer, who defined the word tragedy. He said it should represent ‘terrible and piteous’ and lead the audience to experience ‘catharsis’ or feel sorrow. Miller used this technique to create a modern equivalent of a Greek tragedy. In addition, Aristotle also said that every tragedy must have a tragic hero; the protagonist of the play. Aristotle also talks about how a “Tragic Hero” This essay will be exploring how Eddie could be the “Tragic Hero” of the play – “A View from the Bridge”. Aristotle’s definition of a “Tragic Hero” should be good at the beginning but not entirely as this unrealistic. The character should be “appropriate” – meaning men should be manly and women to be feminine. The characters should be believable and lifelike which results to having a “Tragic Flaw”. This “Tragic Flaw” will lead to the “Hero’s” destruction.......

Words: 826 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Antigone and Macbeth

...era and the theatres were always crowded during a play. Shakespeare wrote mainly tragedies by the end of the 16th century, including Hamlet, Othello and Macbeth. Aristotle's definition of a tragedy is that a tragedy is an imitation (mimesis) of an action that is morally admirable. Aristotle is a philosopher who wrote about poetry, poetry being epic, drama, and lyric for Aristotle, in his work “Poetics”. He said in his work that a tragedy should be composed by an introduction, a middle part and an ending. According to Aristotle the fable (mythos) is more important than the characters in the play. It is so because the purpose with the tragedy, according to Aristotle, is to make the audience feel pity (eleos) and fear (fobos) and as a result achieve an emotional cleansing(Catharsis). In order to bring those feelings to the audience the tragedy must be complex. The tragedy must involve a peripeteia, meaning that a great person experiences a turning point, a reversal of fortune. This turning point must be caused by a mistake, the tragic hero's mistake (hamartia). This reversal of fortune cannot be prevented but it is an unforeseen result of the mistake the tragic hero makes. The tragic hero must during the play achieve a revelation(anagnorisis) that means that the hero will go from not knowing to knowing, and that could be about anything. All these elements are what makes a tragedy a good tragedy according to Aristotle. In 1963 Gustav Freytag, a...

Words: 1243 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hamlet Essay

...example of a tragedy. The primary reason it is considered a tragedy is because he dies in the end and is unable to see the full outcome of his actions. However, the reason for his death was his tragic flaw of error in judgment. According to Aristotle a tragic hero must have certain characteristics that make him a tragic hero. For example the definition of a tragic hero is, “A character of noble stature and has greatness. They must occupy a high status position but must also embody nobility and virtue as part of his innate character.” (Litonline) This is exactly the type of person that hamlet portrays to be. Another characteristic of a tragic hero that Hamlet has is his downfall that is his own fault. This is a result of his free choice, which in fact was triggered by some error of judgment or some character flaw that contributed to his lack of perfection. Although Hamlet is depicted as being predominantly great, it is clearly evident at the end that he is not perfect. Although his fall is considered tragic because it resulted in death, his fall is not pure loss. Since there was some increase in awareness, gain in self-knowledge, and discovery on his part, his reason for doing what he did was not a waste of time because it had meaning that other people were able to learn from his errors. Although Hamlet arouses solemn emotion because of his death, tragedy is not meant to leave its audience in a state of depression. Aristotle argues that one function of tragedy is to......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

A Response Paper on Drama

...29.09.2012 ‘Tragedy is an imitation of an action’ is what Aristotle said about the theater genre, tragedy. I have been curious about the ‘imitation of an action’ part and asked myself question such as what could the’ imitation of an action’ as a phrase in this context of tragedy mean so, under the light of the emphasis our instructor put on the chapter ‘the definiton of tragedy’ in ‘Aristotle’s Poetics’ reading that we were assigned to read and since I wanted my question to be cleared and I also wanted to understand the foundation of tragedy and prepare myself, base knowledge wise, for readings that were to come, I started my reading with that particular chapter. Through the chapter I partially understood, through my own reading without anyone’s help, the combination of artistic beauty of changing the places of the words, harmonious rhythms of songs that provide an emballishment to the ongoing play on the stage and the crucial components such as ‘the soul of tragedy’ and another component as important as the plot that I am not too confident about whether I absorbed its meaning and relation with other parts of a tragedy, that element is thought. I think through the chapter I found an answer to my question of what is imitation of an action, let me expand my question for beter understanding and my own answer through the information I gained through my reading . I think my question of what imitation of an action is pretty straightforward to understand, in literal base I......

Words: 4388 - Pages: 18