Free Essay

Training Is the Answer...but What Is the Question

In: Business and Management

Submitted By dbf895
Words 919
Pages 4
Article Critique
Training is the Answer…But What Was the Question
The author’s main objective of this article is to ask the question of whether training really works or not. Mr. Rosner looks at how managers were being trained in order to develop the employees that they managed. This article also speaks about the mindset of personnel that attend training. Rosner states, in the words of Bob Pike, president of Minneapolis-based Creative Training Techniques, “Most people come to training with one of four mindsets: as a learner, a networker, a vacationer or a prisoner” (Rosner, 2009). These mindsets that people possess can make the training better or worse for the people attending it. If they come in with a learning mindset then they tend to more focused on what they are about to learn. They are more involved in the training and understand what they are there for. The networker mindset person is there for learning but they want to network with other people within the class. They are looking to make connections in order to have more connections for a later date, maybe for a better job or for something they may need in their current company. The vacationer mindset person is there to get away from everything not to learn. They want to get away from the office and enjoy their time away. The prisoner feels as if they were forced to be there and they come in mostly with a closed mind about the training they are attending.
Rosner also speaks about some problems that people have within their organizations and how some of these problems are misdiagnosed because the proper people are not in the proper positions with the proper training. Rosner quotes from Valerie Oberfie, a former vice president at Disney University that has done business consulting and training for corporations. She says that to avoid misdiagnosing a problem businesses should do their homework (Rosner, 2009). First thing they should do is identify the stakeholders involved, secondly, interview those stakeholders, and lastly test the stakeholders solutions to the problems. If this is done they can get to the root of the training problem and not waste training dollars where they are not needed. By doing this they will find out whether or not training is the best solution to their problems or is there something else that needs to be done, perhaps they may have the wrong people in the positions in the first place.
The things that support the main point in this article is how this corporation is looking at training and who really needs it. They have to look at the problem then ask the questions within the article to determine first is the training worth having and if so, what stipulations they will have to follow in regards to the training. Things like whether or not they should use in house trainers or source out for trainers, what type of training should be conducted, how to deliver the training, etc. The type of opportunities the training will provide to the employees is important too, so that they get the best learning environment. All of these things have to be put into consideration when a training package is put together for a corporation in order to get the best training for the money they spend.
I think that the article has some validity to it. The reasons I say that is many corporations just train personnel and never really look at what really needs to be trained or how it will be trained. This waste money for those corporations because they end up having to retrain people in another task after they have trained them in something else. The Army does this a lot in some instances. Some programs in the Army provide training that should be given to certain people but the wrong people get sent to training and it is never disseminated down to others. One instance would be sexual harassment training where everyone in the Army should be receiving it but some do not because of deployments or other training that is conducted. In corporations sexual harassment training is provided also, in both instances there are still multiple sexual predators still prevalent. Is the training done correctly or could it be done in a better manner to get the words across better? A survey of U.S. organizations indicated that more than 80 percent provided some type of sexual harassment training (Blanchard and Thacker, 2010). The Army has the fairly new sexual harassment/assault response and prevention (SHARP) program which it is working on. Both are trying to eliminate the same thing for many years but it is still out there in those organizations.
This article supports this course because it speaks on the aspects of training in the workplace. Training is an important part of doing a job. Without it people would not know what needed to be done in their particular departments. That is why it needs to be relevant to what the job is and learnable by all of the people participating in it. The course as well as this article lays those things out that should be looked at when developing training in order to get the best training for the best cost.
Blanchard, P. Nick and Thacker, James W. (2010) Effective Training, Systems, Strategies, and Practices. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Rosner, Bob (2009) Training Is the Answer…But What Was the Question? Workforce; May99, Vol. 78 Issue 5, p42, 8p

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Listening Comprehension

...this monthly training tool to help you plan group training sessions for your CDA candidates. These sessions can be counted as seminar training hours. Training Module* Listening Comprehension PURPOSE To explore the meaning and importance of listening comprehension as it relates to young children ages two to five. DEFINITION Before we begin, let’s take a minute to discuss the term listening comprehension. This skill can be observed when you read to the children. Listening comprehension can be defined as “the ability to recall and understand information which is presented orally.” This information might be presented through a book, filmstrip, video, or felt board set. EXAMPLES Mr. Fields, the preschool teacher, is reading the book Goldilocks and the Three Bears to the children. After he finishes reading, Mr. Fields asks the children, “How many bears lived in the house?” Rosie shrugs her shoulders and looks confused, but Jeremy exclaims, “Three!” Mr. Fields says, “That’s right, Jeremy. There were three bears in the story. Let’s count them together.” Mr. Fields turns the pages of the book until he comes to an illustration that contains the three bears. The children and Mr. Fields count the bears together. Mr. Fields then asks, “How did the bears know that someone had been eating their porridge?” Albert responds, “Because Baby Bear’s bowl was empty.” Jeremy says, “Because someone told them.” Mr. Fields then uses the book to help the children discover the correct answer. In......

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Human Resources Management to copy exam questions or answers to or from other applications. 2. You should click the Save Answers button in the exam frequently. This helps prevent connection timeouts that might occur with certain Internet service providers, and also minimizes lost answers in the event of connection problems. If your Internet connection does break, when you reconnect, you will normally be able to get back into your Final Exam without any trouble. Remember, though, that the exam timer continues to run while students are disconnected, so students should try to log in again as quickly as possible. The Help Desk cannot grant any student additional time on the exam. 3. See the Syllabus section "Due Dates for Assignments & Exams" for due date information. 4. Reminders • You will only be able to enter your online Final Exam one time. • Click the Save Answers button often. • If you lose your Internet connection during your Final Exam, log in again and try to access your Final Exam. If you are unable to enter the Final Exam, first contact the Help Desk and get a ticket number, and then contact your instructor. • You will always be able to see the time remaining in the Final Exam at the top right of the page. 5. Submitting Your Final Exam • When you are finished with the Final Exam, click on the Submit for Grade button. • Please note: Once you click the Submit for Grade button, you will not be able to edit or change any of your answers. 6. Exam Questions • There are......

Words: 1470 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Aar Lesson

...|DATE |PARA/ | | | | |PAGE | | | | |NO. ALL | |TC 25-20 |A Leader’s Guide To After Action Reviews |Sept 93 |All | |TC 25-10 |A Leader’s Guide To Lane Training |Aug 96 |Chapter 5 | Student Provide Slides to students one day prior to the start of class. Students Study must be prepared to discuss the Slides during class. Scan TC 25-20. Assignments Instructor One instructor, familiar with TC 25-20, Requirements Additional None Personnel Requirements Equipment Overhead Projector, Screen Required Materials INSTRUCTOR MATERIALS: After Action Review Transparencies Required STUDENT MATERIALS: None Classroom, One Standard Classroom Training Area, and Range Requirements Ammunition None Requirements Instructional Note: Before presenting this lesson, instructors must thoroughly prepare by...

Words: 4137 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Participant/Training Manual

... Participants Manual/Trainee Manual | HN2150 – Managing Performance through Training and Development | | This assignment provides the Participants/Trainee Manual that NL Safety Co. will utilize in the delivery of training to Summit Appliances Inc. | Health & Safety Training Summit Appliances Inc. Developed & Administered by NL Safety Co. TABLE OF CONTENTS WELCOME3 EXPLANATION OF TRAINING SESSION4 LEARNING OBJECTIVES5 AGENDA6 LEARNING NOTES7 APPENDICES19 BIBLIOGRAPHY30 Welcome We would like to welcome you to our training session on behalf of NL Safety Co. and we would like to thank the management and executives of Summit Appliance Inc. in recognition of the time and resources set aside to facilitate this very important training session. I would like to call upon Mr. Sid Lawrence, your CEO, to say a few words on behalf of Summitt Appliances Inc. Housekeeping Items Identification and review of housekeeping rules/points as follows; * Sign-in sheet is provided at the front of the class. Ensure you have filled out the information and signed-in. Please print clearly as this information will be used to complete your course certificates at the end of the day; * the location of washrooms just outside and to the left of the classroom entrance; * cell phones are to be turned off or placed on silent during training sessions; * Fire exit is to the right of the classroom entrance, down the stairwell......

Words: 3288 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Bus 407 - Quiz 5

...• Question 1 5 out of 5 points Which of the following terms is used to reflect maximizing the similarity of the training to the job? Answer Selected Answer: Identical elements Correct Answer: Identical elements • Question 2 0 out of 5 points Trainees with _______ learning style remember material best if they are given the opportunity to think about the new information before discussing it with others. Answer Selected Answer: Active Correct Answer: Reflective • Question 3 5 out of 5 points The process of relapse prevention was Answer Selected Answer: More effective when combined with goal setting. Correct Answer: More effective when combined with goal setting. • Question 4 5 out of 5 points “…. read an altimeter with an error of no more than 5 feet” is an example of what part of a learning objective? Answer Selected Answer: Standard Correct Answer: Standard • Question 5 5 out of 5 points ____________ learners like to learn facts and solve problems using well-tested methods. Answer Selected Answer: Sensing Correct Answer: Sensing • Question 6 5 out of 5 points _____ is particularly valuable for tasks that are not used frequently or if the opportunity to practice them is limited. Answer Selected Answer: Over learning Correct Answer: Over learning • Question 7 5 out of 5...

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Analysis of a Survey

...survey is an excellent way to gather essential feedback. The exponential growth of businesses asking for survey input has saturated the market. Customers are routinely asked to respond to survey questions on everything from retail experiences, funeral home offerings, and cell phone plans. As a result, it can be challenging to encourage customers to respond to a survey, and harder still to wade through the false or negative responses to gather legitimate feedback. When designing a survey, it is essential that the survey be worded clearly and directly. It needs to have specific questions that target exactly what the company needs to know: what the customer liked about their experience, what they disliked, and what they would like to see changed. By asking about likes/dislikes/needs, companies target the three ‘B’s of customer experience: beliefs, belonging, and behaviors. In other words, a good survey asks about the customer’s preconceived or confirmed beliefs about a company, what demographic group they belong to, and what behaviors the customers exhibit based on the way they respond to the survey questions. While these general question categories will result in an insightful customer feedback survey, it is useful to look at a specific survey recently received via email to evaluate what factors determine a successful or unsuccessful survey approach. Company Profile The company that sent the email customer survey is Purolator Inc. This is a courier and freight delivery......

Words: 2083 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Interviewing Process

...trainers are going to have some input on how best to proceed and how best to teach different subject matters. They also need to let us know which courses they are qualified to teach and which ones they aren’t qualified to teach. If they’re not qualified, we need to make sure they can get qualified. Natalie Ward and Sam Esposito – Systems Analysts. It would be difficult to imagine moving forward on this project without getting some input from our systems analysts. They should be able to help with logistics and some of the details needed for this training center. Lyle Newhart and Dawn Hill – Network Engineers. I figured since we don’t have a network configuration designed for the training center yet, our network engineers could help fill in some of the blanks there. Mark Martin, Ho Lee, and Bill Loos – Web Designers. Certainly our web designers are going to have some ideas as to which kind of interface layout works best for a training environment. Once we know who we’re going to interview, we then need...

Words: 964 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Article Critique

...article examines the different applications of training and how effective or ineffective training can be for organizations by providing the reader with several examples about trainers and trainee settings. Furthermore, the author offers the reader with the appropriate tools to analyze the type and cost relate to training. Training is the answer…but what was the question? Article Critique. “The point of training isn’t to create an “information dump”- it’s to change the way people behave” (Rosner, 1999); this is an accurate description on how people perceive training as an “information dump” in my opinion. Too often training is perceived as a punishment rather than opportunity to grow; I have experience this reaction as a trainee and as an instructor in my organization. In this article the author Bob Rosner outlines training situations and provides examples of the “good” and the “bad” of training outcomes and how important is to have experienced trainers available for training in order to, gather and prepare an effective training section and, to main maintain an appropriate audience’s attention. It is important to mention and the particularly of the article that is outlined in 20 questions with an opening summary that introduce the importance of training to the reader, perhaps with the intention of changing one’s approach to training not the necessity of training. The main point of the author is to target the training need of the employees of any organization by......

Words: 863 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Assignment 2: Designing a Training Program BUS 407 Strayer University Professor O. Boateng Milla Brewer July 27th 2013 An important part of any business is the ability to adequately train new employees in all aspects of the job requirements. A good orientation program will help to ensure new employees are up to speed faster and will better align them into positions in the organization in that the need is greater. With this in mind, I have designed a two day training and orientation plan to completely and effectively train new salesclerks. Training will start at 8:00a.m. and last until 5:00p.m. every day for a period of two days. When new hires arrive, they will be given an outline of the training process that briefly describes items to be covered during training, an employee handbook, and all required paperwork. Each section of the training process will be explained in detail by the supervisor. Below is an outline of a two-day orientation and training session that is to be handed out to each new employee before the orientation and training process begins. New Hire - Orientation Process Orientation - Day One New......

Words: 1461 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Gt Reading GENERAL TRAINING MODULE PRACTICE TEST 3 GENERAL TRAINING LISTENING PRACTICE TEST 3 SECTION 1 Questions 1 - 10 Questions 1 - 5 Complete the form below. Write NO MORE THAN ONE WORD OR A NUMBER for each answer. WESTLEY PUBLIC LIBRARY MEMBERSHIP APPLICATION FORM Example NAME FIRST NAME ADDRESS Answer Camden Peter Flat 5 53 (1) _________________________________ Finsbury (2) ____________________________________ 8th July (3) _____________________________ None (4) ____________________________________ (5) ____________________________________ POSTCODE DATE OF BIRTH HOME TEL MOBILE TEL PROOF OF RESIDENCE PROVIDED General Training Test 3; Page 1 © Questions 6 - 8 Circle THREE letters A - F. What type of books does Peter like? A B C D E F Wildlife books Romance books Travel books Historical novels Science Fiction novels Mystery books Questions 9 and 10 Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS OR A NUMBER for each answer. 9 How much does it cost to join the library? _________________________________ 10 How much does it cost to rent a DVD? _________________________________ General Training Test 3; Page 2 © SECTION 2 Questions 11 - 20 Questions 11 - 14 List FOUR reasons given for people needing blood transfusions. Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS OR A NUMBER for each answer. Write your answers in boxes 11 - 14 on your answer sheet. 11 12 13 14 ____________________________________________________________......

Words: 4724 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Child Abuse

...POSITION QUESTION 1212-04661 Engineer Interview Questions Tell me about the most challenging engineering project that you have been involved with during past year. Describe the most challenging written technical report or presentation that you have had to complete. Describe an experience with a difficult client. How did you handle the situation? What would you have done differently? Tell me about your greatest success in using logic to solve an engineering problem at a previous job. Give me an example of a time when you applied your ability to use analytical techniques to define problems or design solutions. What checks and balances do you use to make sure that you don't make mistakes? Do you have any patents? If so, tell me about them. If not, is it something you see yourself pursuing in the future? Why or why not? What engineering skills have you developed or improved upon during the past year? Which software packages are you familiar with? What is the most interesting thing you know how to do with one of these packages? What are you doing to stay up-to-date with the latest technology? Consultant Interview Questions What kinds of projects do you typically work on? What has been the focus of the last four or five projects you have worked on? What has been your average number of clients at a time? Do you tend to focus on one project, or do you handle a number of projects simultaneously? What......

Words: 4256 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Learning and Development

...was at facing all my learners and that the learners were facing the Smart Board. This was to ensure that when I was addressing the learners then could see and hear me clearly and vice versa. This layout also helped when feeding back or answering questions. ‘In a presentation, the main thing is that the presenter and his or her visual aids can be seen, (Truelove 2006, p147)’. ‘People should be sitting fairly close to each other, ideally in a circle. (Truelove 2006, p151)’. This also ensured that whilst observing the presentation learners were sat comfortably and facing both the Smart Board and myself, minimising the need for too much movement and disruption. ‘The discussion leader controls the discussions by asking questions that are replied to by group members directing the response to the leader. (Truelove 2006, p152)’. ‘Look at your audience from the beginning. Smile at them. Do not, however, fix on one ‘friendly face’, but rather scan the audience. This creates empathy, and also lets you read their reaction to what you are saying. (Truelove, 2006, p137)’. The room was all also set at a control temperature so that the learners were comfortable and not over or under heated. This helped ensure they were focused on my training session....

Words: 1341 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Hrm Case Study

...similar mostly. Nelson wondered about the movements that he should take and the home office steps. The more he thought about the matter, the more perplexed he became. The problem is as much as complex that he couldn’t put his finger on that problem and he did not know the actual place whether to report his findings to the president. * Most of the experts believe that there are five basic functions that all managers perform and that are- planning, organizing, staffing, leading and controlling. These functions represent the management process. In this chapter we are going to focus on one of this function ̶ the staffing, personnel management, or Human resource management function. Human resource management is the process of acquiring, training, appraising, and compensating employees, and of attending to their...

Words: 12223 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay


...UNIT OF COMPETENCY BSBINM501A Manage an information or knowledge management system Student to complete |Student ID: |Date Submitted: | Given Name: | Family Name: | Course Name: |Diploma in Business | I declare that the answers provided are entirely my own work. I have provided full referencing to the work of others. The material in this paper has not been submitted for assessment in any other formal course of study. [pic] For office use only: |Marks: |      |Out of: |      | Trainer’s Comments: |      | | | | ...

Words: 1909 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Hr 400 Designing, Presenting and Evaluating a Training

...Designing, Presenting and Evaluating a Training Designing, Presenting and Evaluating a Training Four Square Company is developing a training program for current employees who wish to become managers, and for people newly in management positions. As a Training and Development Specialist, your task is to develop an overall training plan for preparing managers. In addition, you will prepare a 10-15 minute presentation on the management training topic of your choice. A few suggestions are listed; you may contact your instructor for approval of a different one. • Hiring • Disciplinary actions • Performance reviews • Terminations • Managing Conflict in the Workplace • Leading a Meeting or Committee • Managing Employee Complaints • Managing Sexual Harassment Complaints Your plan will follow the ADDIE model: Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation. More details for each section are given below. When addressing each piece, be as specific as possible, demonstrate your understanding of each relevant concept, incorporate the course material, and show how your choices are relevant to Four Square’s goals. A complete plan will be about 10-15 pages. If your plan is less than 10 pages, then it is likely that you are not writing at the level of detail required by the project. Address each concept in depth with complete explanations supported by what we are learning in the......

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5