Free Essay

Transaction Costs Theory and the Imperfect Markets.

In: Business and Management

Submitted By RaphaelB
Words 1410
Pages 6
Transaction costs theory and the imperfect markets.

Williamson’s successful complementation of the Coases approach of the firm as an alternative to reduce the cost of using the price mechanism, with Herbert Simon’s organizational theory, gave birth to the Transaction Costs Theory (TCT)1. This meant a big step, which evolved the theory of the firm, from its obsolete neoclassical toots and assumptions -of a perfect competitive market and a perfect rationality-, by adding the issues of bounded rationality and opportunism to Coases work2. Williamson opened the path to new ways of conceiving and complementing the theory of the firm in general, and the transactions costs theory in particular. By enabling to the economic theory the enhancing and the building of new connections between cognitive psychology and economics. Connections that have allowed, among other things, the development of a larger view in the roll of the firm, no only as an avoider of costs, but also as a creator of knowledge. All in better accordance with the modern firms logic of making business.
In order to understand the transaction costs theory, one has to comprehend that the competitive market structure, is only a reference to be taken into account, when one analyses the observed structure of markets, which are called “imperfect competitive”,
For the market is not given under a homogenous form to all economic agents, but is continuously changing under agents decisions and behaviours 3 . Further more the neoclassical perfect rationality, which is an essential assumption for the competitive market structure, doesn’t takes into account the problems of processing the uncertainty due to the imperfect information, the limits to the human capacity and the difficulties due to the interdependencies among different agents 4 . Under the neoclassical approach the standard model of the firm, study the “imperfect competitive” markets as through the “violations” of one or more hypothesis of the neoclassical competitive market model, and do not takes into account any real discussion about the nature and characteristics of the participants involved5.
As Walras once said, under the neoclassical view, the transaction cost due to the asymmetries of information, would be to the market, like a friction to a machine. And
“The most obvious sort of friction, and undoubtedly one of the most important, is the cost of transferring assets from one form to another” as John Hicks once said6. In
1940, Tibor Scitovsky introduced the label of “transaction costs” into the economic vocabulary7. And in 1937 Ronald Coase published his paper in which he attributed the existence of the firm as a way to lower the cost of using the price mechanism 8 , considering the firm and the market to be alternative methods of coordinating resource allocation. Coase argued that the cost of using the market price mechanisms could be reduced if agents internalized activities, so the entrepreneur becomes consequently an administrator, who directs and supervises the required activities, in order for the firm to

1 Hardt, 2009

2Hardt, 2009 3 Textbook

4 Textbook 5 Textbook 6 Hicks, John. 1935. A suggestion for simplifying the theory of money. Economica, 2 (5): 1-­‐19. 7 Hardt 2006 8 Coase 1937

allow agents to economize their market costs9.
In 1979 Oliver Williamson’s article “Transaction cost economics: the governance of contractual relations” appears in the Journal of Law and Economics, in it, he opens the way to the study of economic activity as undertaken by agents characterized by limited cognitive capacity, and opportunistic behaviour 10 . In this way he continues the departure from the perfect rationality assumptions initiated in the fifties by Herbert
Simon, who with the insights from cognitive psychology –that is the notion that men can be “intentionally rational, but only to a limited extent” 11 - gave birth to the organizational theory. Williamson then uses Simon’s organizational theory assumptions and combines it with the analytical framework of neoclassical economics12, translating the ideas from organization literature, into concepts observable in the performance of firms and markets, in order to explain that the reasons for vertical integration lie in the behavioural characteristic of contracting actors, and particularly in bounded rationality.
Then and as a consequence of the development of the former insights, he develops the theoretical foundations incomplete contracts, opportunism and merges them with the neoclassical cost minimization into this conceptual framework13.
According to Williamsons work, there are three general dimensions, along which transactions can differ: assets specificity, uncertainty and frequency. Being the first one, the most significant, when considering the firm structure as a better alternative than the market, in order to economize in both bounded rationality and opportunism. In this sense, internal organization is more efficient in the decision-making process for the allocation of resources, due to the elimination of information asymmetries. Due to its internal organization, a class of governance, in which making permanent appointments to a group that has the authority to make efficient decisions, is necessary in order to make gains from comparative advantages. Thus an “elite” is created as the head of a hierarchical organization system14.
This developments embodied in the transaction costs theory, have stressed the need of acquiring a larger understanding in the field of (the new) behavioural economics, which deals with various sorts of cognitive biases characteristic of contracting agents15.
Thus strengthening the most needed bridge (at least from the economics side) between the academic discipline of Psychology and the social science of Economics.
On the other hand, in the beginning of the 1990s, it became evident that in a modern economy what really matters are the knowledge transactions16, because as Daniel Bell pointed out, “post-industrial society is built upon knowledge rather than things”17. So the next step for de TCT, is to be up to the challenges offered by the modern economy and the modern firms logic of making business. In this regard and in spit of the early

9 Textbook

10 Hardt, 2006 11 Simon,

1957 1999 13 Hardt, 2006 14 Textbook 15 Foss 200 16 Starbuck, 1992 17 Hardt, 2006 12 Allen,

literature on the TCT, (in which firms exist in order to avoid the market costs of coordination, implicitly assuming that knowledge can be equally well shared on the market and within the firm18), it should also be noted as Lukazs Hardt points out, that even in the pre-Williamsonian theory many claimed that knowledge can be more easily transmitted within the firm, because of the fact that it often needs a stable environment to be efficiently shared19.

Therefore because of this new requirements of modern economy the role of the firm is to produce and to transfer knowledge, as a consequence there most be continuity between the Williamsonian approach and the more recent developments in the TCT, as the so-called knowledge governance approach (KGA), which focuses on the problem of how to organize transactions to efficiently generate knowledge and capabilities20. The KGA analyses four dimensions of knowledge transactions: tacitness versus explicitness, system quality versus standalone, teachability versus nonteachability, and complexity versus noncomplexity21. In this sense so TCT opens the door for a new kind of theory of the firm, in which an enterprise is treated not only as minimizer of costs, but also as a creator of positive value, being the KGM literature which is still of part the TCT-, the one which analyses the organizational structures of firms that facilitate these processes.
In conclusion, as we can see it has been a long journey, from the neoclassical assumptions of the competitive market structure and perfect rationality, to the modern transaction costs theory, which not only takes into account the information asymmetries, the bounded rationality of the agents and their opportunistic behaviour, but also is beginning to see the Firm as a creator of positive value (Knowledge), instead of just a minimizer of costs in response of the necessities of modern economy.
And on the other this advances have opened the path for new assimilations of the many insights of cognitive psychology, which are most needed for the further development of the TCT and the theory of the firm. In ordered that we can truly and better comprehend the interactions amongst the agents in the economy.

18 Hardt, 2006 19 Hardt, 2006 20 Nickerson
21
Nickerson

and Zenger 2004 and Zenger 2004

References
Hardt, Luksz, (2009). The history of transaction cost economics and its recent developments. Warsaw, Poland: Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics
Nickerson, Jackson, and Todd Zenger, (2004). A knowledge-based theory of the firm: the problem-solving perspective. Organization Science.
Textbook

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Competitive Strategy

...Members: Abhishek Rana, Matthew Ross, Michele De Simon, Mohit Kumar How would the different theories discussed by Conner (1991) explain differences in performance among firms? Conner has discussed the differences in performances amongst firms by analyzing the following list of theories: 1. Neo-Classical Theory: Performance is the same across the industry because the industry is characterized by ‘Perfect Competition’. Perfect competition comprises of the following assumptions – Larger number of buyers and suppliers, Homogeneity of the demand, Mobility of resources and Rationality of complete market information. Therefore in such a market setting firms cannot achieve economic profit. 2. Bain-type IO Theory: Above normal performance could be achieved only through collusion encouragement, which in turn leads to monopoly. In an industry characterized by collusion and monopoly, the largest firm has the power to set prices and expand its own market share further, leading to above normal performance. 3. Schumpeter Theory: The core of this theory states that the performance of a firm is driven by Innovation. Monopoly is a more favorable condition for process of innovation because it decreases inherent investment risks involved. Through innovation a firm can achieve indistinctive competence and edge over competitors leading to higher returns and performance. 4. Chicago Theory: This theory is driven by efficiency in production and distribution. Costly information is required...

Words: 1196 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

International Finance

...reasons behind this (Wells & Wint, 2000). The biggest of all these reasons is to gain access to international markets and perhaps invest in economic zones that have high investment returns as compared to home countries (Fu, 2000). The trend of globalization has made most firms become multinational corporations. The most common method for MNCs is through franchises (Jones, 2005). In line with this, economists have put up theories explaining why businesses expand beyond their national boundaries (Hicks, 2000). My primary objective in this paper, therefore, is to discuss international finance and other macroeconomics policies. To foresee this goal, I will delve into foreign exchange market and operations of multinational corporations (MNCs). Theories Explaining Why Corporations Expand to become Multinationals a). Financial economists have brought forward three key arguments that enumerate why companies expand their operations to global markets. These theories are; the imperfect markets theory, the comparative advantage theory and the product cycle theory (Levi, 2004). i).The Comparative Advantage Theory This theory is among the most important concepts in international trade. It states that economic welfare increases when countries specialize in producing lower opportunity cost goods. It is far from looking the monetary value of producing goods as in the theory of absolute advantage (Bishop, 2004). A comparative advantage arises when a corporation realizes larger sales margins...

Words: 5206 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Economy

...Eco Course Period: Fall Semester, 2010 Lecturer: David Emanuel Andersson (PAM) Email: david@faculty.nsysu.edu.tw Office hours: Wednesday 12-2 pm; Thursday 12-2 pm Literature:  A.E. Andersson and D.E. Andersson (2006), The Economics of Experiences, the Arts, and Entertainment, Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.  Background requirement: Example: Mulhearn, C; H. R. Vane and J. Eden (2001), Economics for Business, Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 1-172. (or any other undergraduate textbook in microeconomics) |Week | | |1-4 |Introduction and lectures | |5 |Exam 1 (October 11) | |6-8 |Lectures | |9 |Exam 2 (November 8) | |10-12 |Lectures | |13 |Exam 3 (December 6) | |14-17 |Lectures | |18 |Exam 4 (January 3) | Attendance: 40% Exams: 60% Economics (with a focus on experience goods such as art, entertainment and other services) • Economic approach → utilitarianism → individual subjective valuations of consumer goods • Economic approach → individualism: interpersonal utility comparisons inadmissible • Aggregated individual valuations → social valuations...

Words: 525 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Corporate Fi

...B) shareholder wealth; shareholder wealth C) short-term earnings; sales volume D) short-term earnings; shareholder wealth 3. For the MNC, agency costs are typically: A) non-existent. B) larger than agency costs of a small purely domestic firm. C) smaller than agency costs of a small purely domestic firm. D) the same as agency costs of a small purely domestic firm. 5. The valuation of an MNC should rise when an event causes the expected cash flows from foreign to _______ and when foreign currencies denominating these cash flows are expected to _______. A) decrease; appreciate B) increase; appreciate C) decrease; depreciate D) increase; depreciate 6. Which of the following theories identifies specialization as a reason for international business? A) theory of comparative advantage. B) imperfect markets theory. C) product cycle theory. D) none of these. 7. Which of the following theories identifies the non-transferability of resources as a reason for international business? A) theory of comparative advantage. B) imperfect markets theory. C) product cycle theory. D) none of these. 8. Which of the following theories suggests that firms seek to penetrate new markets over time? A) theory of comparative advantage. B) imperfect markets theory. C) product cycle theory. D) none of these. 10. Due...

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Cost Theory

...THEORY OF COST Economists have developed a comprehensive set of theories concerning cost, which they use to describe, explain, and predict the behavior of firms and individuals (e.g., consumers). The field of economics thus provides the underlying theory of costs, while accounting generally supplies most of the data that allow this theory to be applied in practice. The economist's idea of cost is more useful in analyzing the critical decisions made by management and government. In order to develop an appropriate costing methodology for a telecommunications service, it is important to understand both the underlying economic theory (and associated terminology) of cost, and the accountant's practical measures of cost (which do not directly correspond to elements of the theory). Assumptions of theory of cost Theory of cost rests upon several key assumptions about human behavior and environmental characteristics (Williamson, 1979; Williamson & Ouchi, 1981; Williamson, 1985). These assumptions elucidate why firms may face superior costs for market-based transactions and why firms may be relatively more efficient than markets at organizing transactions. The firm will select the governance form, from the various alternatives amongst the organizational menu, that minimizes transaction and production costs. Assumptions about human and human behavior Opportunism with guile. In neoclassical economics, humans are viewed as self-interested; individuals pursue their own self-interest...

Words: 2044 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Theories

...The Portfolio Theory also known as Modern Portfolio Theory was first developed by Harry Markowitz. He had introduced the theory in his paper ‘Portfolio Selection’ which was published in the Journal of Finance in 1952. In 1990, he along with Merton Miller and William Sharpe won the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences for the Theory. The theory suggests a hypothesis on the basis of which, expected return on a portfolio for a given amount of portfolio risk is attempted to be maximized or alternately the risk on a given level of expected return is attempted to be minimized. This is done so by choosing the quantities of various securities cautiously taking mainly into consideration the way in which the price of each security changes in comparison to that of every other security in the portfolio, rather than choosing securities individually. In other words, the theory uses mathematical models to construct an ideal portfolio for an investor that gives maximum return depending on his risk appetite by taking into consideration the relationship between risk and return. According to the theory, each security has its own risks and that a portfolio of diverse securities shall be of lower risk than a single security portfolio. Simply put, the theory emphasizes on the importance of diversifying to reduce risk. Early on, investors stressed on individually picking high yielding stocks to earn maximum profits. So if one particular industry was offering good returns; an investor would have landed...

Words: 8380 - Pages: 34

Premium Essay

Market Failures

...Market Failures by Erik F. Meinhardt This section sets out to define and describe market failures, how government intervention prevents them or minimizes their effects, and the arguments against government intervention. I. Definitions and descriptions Market failure occurs when free markets do not bring about economic efficiency, that is to say when a Pareto sub-optimal allocation of resources exists in a particular economy. Market failures remain one of the best reasons for government intervention within an economy on moral and economic grounds, arguably, in the best interest of the public. The following are detailed descriptions of several market failures in no particular order: A. Public goods—Public goods are goods wherein the consumption of them does not necessarily prevent another person from also consuming it, nor does that consumption make less of the good available for consumption by others. Scholars commonly present breathable air as an example of a public good for virtually everyone has access to consume it and its consumption does not limit the amount available. Public goods pose a problem for the market because by their nature it cannot provide for them. The private sector will not make a profit from a good which everyone can enjoy whether or not they pay for it. The lighthouse example comes to mind: no matter who pays for the construction of a lighthouse on a particular island, every passing ship will benefit from the protection it provides and...

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ibus 410- Midterm Review

...factors of production- land labor capital * Endowment theory * Lower overall cost * Markets- merging markets * Economies of scale * Institutions * Drivers- decline in barriers, tech changes * Implications: * Lower barriers: optimal location * Tech changes: lower costs * 4 trends in changing demographics * MNE- types of companies involved * Democratic politics, free market economies The World Is: * Prusak- distinguish information from knowledge (difference) * IMPORTANT- the issue of access to info- but no knowledge * Ghemawat- 10% presumption, factors of time zones, languages, proximity shows that distance does matter, the world isn’t flat Opportunities & Challenges of globalization for managers * Differences of managing international vs. domestic * Boeing: benefits of globalization maximize efficiency of production but actually caused problems; lack of planning, communication, not simple for this industry (knowledge intensive industry) better for in house Localization * Standardization is ending, consumers are diverse- customization for local * Data analysis & innovation * Centralized vs localized * SWOT analysis National Differences * Political economy- system of gov. Political, economic & legal influence each other. Collective vs individualism * Economic system- three types: market command, mixed * Legal system- rules that regulate behavior...

Words: 669 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Intermedoation

...“complete markets” paradigm of Arrow and Debreu. As we describe in this lecture, the reasons why intermediaries such as banks exist is related to the various market failures which vitiate the complete markets paradigm. In particular, there is the key issue of imperfect information which makes financial institutions such as banks key channels for intermediating between savers and borrowers. We cover the key concepts of liquidity insurance and delegated monitoring in this context Why intermediation? Definition: Intermediate between providers and users of financial capital Besides banks - pension funds, insurance companies, securities firms (differ in terms of assets. liabilities, matching). - But in an Arrow-Debreu “complete markets” world, financing of firms and governments by households occurs via financial markets – no transactions costs, full set of contingent markets, no credit rationing, Pareto optimal allocation and no role for intermediaries - Moreover, (Modigliani-Miller) financial structure is irrelevant as households can construct portfolios offsetting actions of intermediaries and intermediaries cannot add value - Corollary - markets are not strong form efficient or banks would not exist. Banks rather assist market efficiency as their information spills over. Why do intermediaries exist? (1) Transactions costs restricting scope for direct financing, or incomplete information means financial markets cannot be complete in an Arrow Debreu sense (theories of intermediation)...

Words: 1369 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Math 500

...production( i.e., manufactured goods…desk..markers…) * Entrepreneurship- person who starts a business; combines land, labor, and capital to produce a business * LIMITED RESOURCES = LIMITED PRODUCTION OF GOODS AND SERVICES * ALLOCATION: * Market system * Command system TEN PRINCIPLES: GROUPS A. How households (people) make decisions B. How households (people) interact C. How the economy as a whole works A. How households make decisions: 1. People face trade-offs: a. Personal—doing more of one activity and doing little to none of another activity b. Production—producing more of one good and producing less of another good Most money spent towards: * Defense * Social security * medicare c. Efficiency/Equity—society chooses b/w being efficient or equity; more efficiency= less equity ~ more equity= less efficiency * Efficiency—exists when the society gets the most from its resources * Equity—exists when societies output is distributed fairly among its members * Redistribution: among members of society, i.e, social security (OASDI), unemployment, welfare (TANF= food stamps, housing), compensation 2. Opportunity cost: : What you give up to get more of something (can put an actual value or measure on action) What you give up: (if you start your own business) . Income given-up >> $50,000/yr . Interest given-up >> $5,000/yr . Rental income...

Words: 859 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Lelep

...than other tangible assets, such as commodities or real estate, and may be traded on financial markets. In contrast, a tangible asset is an asset that has a physical form. Tangible assets include both fixed assets, such as machinery, buildings and land, and current assets, such as inventory. 3. Describe the two principle roles of financial assets. The principal economic function of financial assets are: (1) to transfer funds from persons who have surplus funds to those who need funds to invest in tangible assets( e.g. mortgage funds lending to homebuyers); (2) transfer funds in such a way as to redistribute the unavoidable risk associated with the cash flow generated by tangible assets among those seeking and those providing the funds (seekers of funds ask others to share the risks in their undertakings). 4. a. Explain the three factors that have led to the globalization of financial markets. Globalization has led to an expansion and integration of global financial markets. Prior to the 1980’s, the US financial market was the largest in the world but with the advent of new technologies and globalization, many markets have emerged and indeed the majority of them have been integrated to form a global financial hub. The growth of global financial markets can be attributed to lower transaction costs; in particular, an availability of new technologies for real time transactions and an ease with which the funds can be transferred across borders. This has led to an increase...

Words: 3412 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Financial Accounting Issues

...free-market stress that market forces will optimise the allocation of resources and as such regulation is not necessary. Whilst those opposing this view believe that markets are imperfect and as such outside intervention in the form of regulation is required. Both sides hold valid arguments as to why regulation is or is not necessary and this paper shall examine these opposing views before providing an informed opinion. The anti-regulation or free-market approach to accounting is one that has been subscribed to for many years. The main thrust of the American Institute of Accountants in 1934 was anti-regulation, they stressed that, “no attempt [should be made] to restrict the rights of corporations to select detailed methods of accounting deemed by them to be best adapted to the requirements of their business” (May 1934, 80). The argument behind this notion is that the natural market forces or the “invisible hand” of the market will ensure self-regulation. Ross (1979, 379) implies this when he writes, “…disclosure regulations are generally neither required nor desirable, since left on their own, firms will have incentives to report accurately”. The belief that firms have internal incentives to report accurately is the crux of signalling theory. This theory holds that firms can increase their value through full disclosure and firms that fail to disclose will be seen in a negative light. Hence, every firm has reason to engage in financial reporting in order to lower its cost of...

Words: 1591 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Institutional Economics Perspective on Meat Industry Ghg

...Who does really pay for our Burgers? Institutional Causes, Effects and Solutions to the Meat Industry’s Contribution to Global Warming WHO DOES REALLY PAY FOR OUR BURGERS? 1. Introduction ‘All across the world, in every kind of environment and region known to man, increasingly dangerous weather patterns and devastating storms are abruptly putting an end to the long-running debate over whether or not climate change is real. Not only is it real, it's here, and its effects are giving rise to a frighteningly new global phenomenon: the man-made natural disaster’ (Obama, 2006). Global warming is one of the biggest threats to the environment and human well-being; today but even more for future generations. Global warming refers to the rise of the average temperature on earth. The greenhouse effect makes earth feasible for life. Without its protecting layer of several greenhouses gases (GHGs) such as carbon dioxide, methane or nitrous oxide, the average temperature on earth would not be a life-sustaining fifteen degree centigrade but minus six degree (FAO, 2006). By trapping part of the infrared radiation which would have otherwise bounced back into the cosmos, greenhouse gases keep the warmth. Adding to an ancient natural level human GHG, emissions have increased the amount in the atmosphere of e.g. carbon dioxide and methane since the beginning of the industrial revolution by 36 and almost 150 % respectively with an increasing tendency (EPA, 2007). While scientific research...

Words: 4812 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Cost of Acpital

...FIRM PERFORMANCE Rahul Kochhar* Abstract Possession of strategic assets is a necessary condition for sustained competitive advantage. This condition is, however, not sufficient. Firms require financial management capability to realize the rents present in their strategic assets. The firm-specific nature of strategic assets implies that they be financed primarily through equity; other less specific assets should be financed through debt. Firms are likely to suffer increased costs and decreased performance if they do not adopt suitable governance structures in their transactions with potential suppliers of funds. INTRODUCTION The recently developed “resource-based view of the firm” seeks to focus the attention of researchers and managers alike on the unique and hard-to-copy strategic assets of the firm [7, 61]. Firms earn economic rents from these assets when there is an initial level of asymmetry in resource endowments, there is imperfect mobility of these assets, the market for these assets is imperfect, and competitors cannot easily obtain similar assets [2, 6, 7, 20, 24, 48]. Strategic assets provide the firm with a source of steady stream of rents so that it gains a sustained competitive advantage over its rivals. While researchers in this area have a general agreement over the characteristics of strategic assets (albeit adopting slightly different terminology occasionally), more rigor is required to understand how firms translate the value of strategic assets to economic...

Words: 8274 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Sdfsdgd

...I. INTRODUCTION The international trade theory experienced several periods of development from Classical to Neoclassical, New Trade Theory, and then the New Classical Trade Theory. The earliest over international trade had its birth in the end of 15th century and initial period of 16th century. That is, during the period of western countries’ primitive accumulation of capital and the main theory is mercantilism. It is claimed of the theory that the only form of wealth is the metal---gold and silver. People can gain them though exchange and for a nation, it is to increase the social wealth. Hereby, the way to gain gold and silver is international trade. II. THE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS OF THE THEORIES: 1. CLASSICAL INTERNATIONAL TRADE THEORY In the late 1790s, the point of mercantilism was challenged by the classical economists. Based on criticizing the mercantilism, Adam Smith proposed the division of labor theory. It has been 41 years from Adam Smith proposed the absolute cost in his the Wealth of Nations in 1976 to David Ricardo proposed the comparative cost in his the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation in 1817. This is the foundation period of international trade theory, that is, the Classical period. The absolute cost of Adam Smith is based on the division of labor theory. Adam introduced the division of labor theory to the field of international trade and established his absolute cost theory, thus demonstrating the fact that a nation can make the sources of each...

Words: 1878 - Pages: 8