Free Essay

Transgender Rights

In: People

Submitted By bgdc1227
Words 887
Pages 4
Enlgish 101A
Mary Jaffe- Sullivan
1/19/2011
Laura Klein
Let him Dance

The word transgender seems to have stirred a whirlwind of controversy that has everyone burning up the phone lines, blogging, tweeting and using every form of media to argue whether or a not a man should be able to dance with a woman on a national dance competition. Chaz Bono should be able to partake in Dancing with the Stars without ridicule and be judged solely on his dancing technique. Activists are calling for boycotts of this number one rated show because Chaz Bono is one of many contestants this season. The controversy here is Chaz’s right to compete in peace on the show so that he will be judged by his dancing abilities only and not by his transgender identity. What is it that has everyone scared? Is it the fear of the unknown and lack of understanding of what being transgendered means? Transgender by definition is a person who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the persons sex at birth according to Webster’s, or simply put the inside doesn’t match the outside appearance of a man or women. There are a multitude of debates circulating around Chaz Bono dancing on this season’s Dancing with The Stars that it needs to be addressed. The “anti-Chaz” organizations state “he could be contagious to our children”, also that it will affect children negatively and is anti-Christian. These reasons are simply invalid and uneducated. Therefore Chaz Bono should be able to partake in Dancing with the Stars without ridicule and be judged solely on his dancing technique.
Chaz was born a female named, Chastity Bono and grew up in America’s living rooms as the adorable only daughter of Sony and Cher Bono. Now as an adult Chaz realizes that his struggles throughout his whole life have been because he is transgendered. The argument here is should Chaz Bono be allowed to dance on a national program as a man? Christian groups are calling for boycotts of the show stating “it is unchristian and makes a mockery of God’s plan”. While their opinions need to be respected that doesn’t mean they should be agreed with. How many Christians have undergone plastic surgery for their nose, breasts, tummy tucks or other cosmetic augmentations to change the way they were born “in God’s plan”.
Further arguments being thrown out involved parents calling for a boycott of the show stating it would affect the kids negatively and confuse them. Parents feared how they could possibly explain to their children why Chaz would be dancing with professional dancer, Lacey Schwimmer. Bullying was running rampant on every site and the network itself was bombarded with phone calls, letters, and emails calling for Chaz Bono to not be allowed to dance on TV. Chaz reported receiving threats and being harassed by many people who did not want to see him dancing. Facebook, a social network, was overwhelmed with parental groups demanding this not be allowed to happen. The controversy reached a fever pitch all the way up to the moment Chaz Bono walked out onto the dance floor to perform his first dance. What should be scarier is that parents would look to a television program, let alone a dance competition to do their parenting for them. Why have we started using the TV as a babysitter and now as an “educational tool” to guide our children’s moral compass? That says more about the parents than it does about the transgendered community. Why are parents not parenting their own children? Even more concerning is what in the world is so difficult to explain to kids that a man is dancing with a woman during a dance competition. Because that is exactly what is happening….a man is dancing with a woman on a dance show! The children do not know Chaz was born a female and had surgery any more than they realize how much plastic surgery all the judges and contestants have had to look the way they do. Children are just simply enjoying the costumes, dancing and music. . Unintentionally Bono has become the transgender community’s living symbol of hope, strength and defiance against vitriolic hate. This should be the message we send to our children to accept everyone and not judge what we do not know or understand.
In conclusion Chaz Bono should be able to enjoy every experience because it is his right. He is a contestant on Dancing with the Stars and needs to be judged by the professionals on his dancing, and only his dancing. Trangenders simply want to have their insides match their outward appearance. Dancing with the Stars has already had gay contestants compete on different seasons and the world didn’t end, so to believe that a transgendered person can also compete on a dance show and the world will survive is a safe bet. Hate groups need to educate themselves whenever they encounter something new or unknown. The amount of bravery it took for him to stand up for himself by undergoing one of the most drastic surgical and psychological changes in the world is no small thing. After hearing both sides hopefully people will stop protesting and simply say “Let him Dance”.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Transgender Rights

...Transgender Rights, Equality, and Respect Jamie Hogan Transgender issues and rights seem to be at the forefront of media for the first time ever. While Caitlyn Jenner has been met with excessive criticism, she is the main reason this topic is so popular in the media this year. Many people seem to be frustrated with hearing about her, but I will use her as an example to make the topic more easily understood. Every time I see an article about her, it is followed by countless comments calling her “Bruce” and using the incorrect pronoun. This also happens on every other article I have seen about anyone who is transgender. While some people are doing this intentionally, there are many people that identify transgender people inaccurately simply due to lack of knowledge. It is not a common topic and so I wanted to help educate as many people as I could about what it means to be transgender. Transgender rights were already an important part of my life. I was friends with three people that are transgender. My best friend from high school is one of those people. I remember when she told me she wanted to become a girl. I did not react in a surprised way. I just told her “Do whatever you need to do to make you happy. That’s the only thing that matters.” She told me she loved my reaction because I did not act like it was a crazy idea. She said it was like she told me she like pasta, like it was a totally normal thing to say. Although she was my first transgender......

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Transgender's Roles In Modern Society

...chains.” – Jean Jacques Rousseau Termed as the ‘Third Gender’, Transgenders are often mistreated and mocked at. Let’s first take a look at the definition of the term ‘Transgenders’. According to Oxford “Denoting or relating to a person whose sense of personal identity and gender does not correspond with their birth sex.” Transgenders, many people assume came to this world only recently and out of nowhere. But in fact they have existed since the beginning of time. During the Mughal Era of 1500 – 1600s Transgenders had powerful roles in the administration, but the British striped them off their roles and status in politics and the society. According to the SWTEN report “85% of Transgenders knew by the time they were 8 years of age that their gender identity deferred from that at birth and of what the society expected from them.” As technology has now advanced to unimaginable levels people can now medically change their gender if they wish to or feel like they belong to a different gender. One such example in recent times is that of Caitlyn Jenner. Biologically born as a man named Kris Jenner, Caitlyn decided to undergo a sex change operation...

Words: 1144 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Transgender Gender Roles

...Awareness, Support, and understanding are crucial for general acceptance. Transgender youth face a great deal of hardships as a result of who they are. With general acceptance, transgender youth has a better chance of living a happier life. "Awareness is the key to fostering understanding and gaining general acceptance," notes Brynn Kellett. As acceptance for gay rights continues to progress in the United States, some advocates believe that the "T" in LGBT has been forgotten. Bewilderment normally occurs over what "transgender" means, and how it is not the same as gay, lesbian, or bisexual. Transgender is an umbrella term for those individuals whose gender identity and/or gender expression does not correspond to the sex in which they were...

Words: 1353 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

When It Comes to Transgender

...When It Comes To Transgender Everyone is assigned a gender when born. It is how we act and look like, and it also revolves around everything that we do in life. Gender is what describes the characteristics that a society or culture depicts as masculine or feminine. Today, most countries define gender by the genetic reference at birth. Transgender: according to Merriam-Webster, the definition of being transgender is: of, relating to, or being a person (as a transsexual or transvestite) who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the person's sex at birth. People who identify as transgender have to go through serious procedures to be the person they are. They first have to go through therapy to be identified as transgender and also be diagnosed with Gender Identity. After therapy they have to go through hormonal therapy, and from there some people get surgery. Society discriminates the transgender community because they will not conform to society. Most people who identify as transgender, but cannot pursue treatment because they either cannot get accepted for health care or cannot afford it go through the extreme just to try to be happy. According to Amy D. Ronner from the article Let’s get the “trans” and “sex” out of it and free us all, some people who identify as transgender die because of a lack of resources. They either perform risky procedures on their own, or are so unhappy with themselves that they cannot live with...

Words: 829 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Tought Road

...negative response from the public. This is just one of the challenges transgender people face on a daily bases. I remember growing up and hearing things such as “why can’t they just except who they are and move on” or “all they want is attention if they don’t watch out they are going to get the kind they don’t want”. Sadly some of these things I heard growing up came from people that I loved, respect and even admired. Transgender people are constantly under fire, they are accused of being mentally unstable, morally bankrupt, and even misguided souls by delusional parents. People who are born naturally male and views themselves as female or born as a female but views themselves as male are not the same as gay or lesbian. According to Kathy Kreitler in her article “Top 10 Myths About Transgender People” she shares with us that sexual orientation is defined as the preference an individual is attracted to but gender identity is what a person actually believes what their gender is (Kreitler, 2012). One does not have to be engaged in a homosexual act or even passed the age of puberty to be considered transgender. Many people who consider themselves homosexual love the gender they were born with and wouldn’t change it for the world. While transgender people feel trapped in a body that they feel they are not. Some people find transgender people as a group of people with a mental disorder. The only cure for a transgender person is to give them what they want which is surgery to......

Words: 981 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Gay Identity Research Paper

... gay, bisexual, and transgender community is one of the most unique subcultures out there because it focuses on something that most people take for granted: their identity. For most in this community, questioning that identity starts at a young age. They will notice that something is different about them, and some know right away how they are different. For others, it can take years to find themselves. Even if someone does know from a young age who they are, they can be met by obstacles in the form of society, their culture, and even their parents. Though LGBT community has faced a lot of discrimination and prejudice, through the building LGBT community and positive media representation, the community has seen a lot of improvement....

Words: 1569 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Role Of Gender Non-Conformity In America

...Abstract The world of a person who identifies as transgender is complex and challenging. In today’s America, when a person’s gender identity, gender expression or sexual orientation deviates from their biological make-up, they are at risk of rejection or physical harm. Many will struggle with the challenges as a result of a world that medicalizes and stigmatizes gender non-conformity. The transgender population needs more understanding, support and protection as they face the many psychological, social and economic issues during their life time. Our Federal and State governments are reluctant to pass laws that protect the rights of transgender people. Far too often, given this lack of legal protection, society is able to discriminate against...

Words: 706 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Summary: The Ideal American

...Far worse than rejection by society, some transgenders faced rejection by their families. One transgender woman hid her gender identity from her parents. She told her mother that her drag ball trophies were from men’s basketball games. When the transgender woman’s father found out the truth, he revealed the truth to the mother. The mother burnt all of the transgender woman’s clothing out of devastation and embarrassment. This story provided personal insight into the pain and hardship that transgenders faced within their families — a place meant to provide comfort and safety. Although the people could not control the way they were born, they were forced to deal with the unpredictable reactions of their loved ones. The circuit ball provided...

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gender Neutral Bathrooms

...Bathrooms are a place where an individual uses everyday with little to no thought. As for people who don't identify by gender lies a whole world of complications. Transgender people get harassed and bullied everyday because they use the "wrong" bathroom but which bathroom is exactly the "right" one? In a recent poll, 59 percent of Americans believe that transgender individuals should use the bathroom that corresponds with the gender they were assigned at birth, while 26 percent are comfortable with self-determination when it comes to choosing which bathroom to use. Some people believe that if you are born a girl but identity as a man, you should still use the room based on your genitalia. Others believe if you identify as a man, you should use the men's room. Either way, someone in either bathroom is upset. Stereotypes from the past as well as what genitals people are born with are major contributors to the labeling of bathrooms. This presents a problem in today’s society where gender and sex is no longer the same thing. This is where the controversy lies. Until not too long ago, the racial separation of bathrooms was an important civil rights issue in the United States. Since there were unlikely to be four separate bathrooms, only white women and men could depend on having someplace to pee when traveling (Cooper and Ruth, 1999, Pages 12-13). People of other races had no where to use a restroom and were seen as wrong if they were to ever use a whites only bathroom. Twenty......

Words: 1747 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Conversion Therapy Research Paper

...Natalie Duran Frisone Period 3 5 May 2015 Conversion Therapy “More than 50% of the transgender youth will have had at least one suicide attempt by their 20th birthday” (Youth Suicide Prevention Program). For anyone transgender, gay, or one who identifies on the LGBTQ spectrum, a range of sexualities and gender identities, living and surviving in the world blissfully is challenging. Without support or acceptance within your kin it could lead to even more complications or even an unwanted and forced response, being sent to conversion therapy. Conversion therapy is an option a great deal of parents or legal guardians use in an attempt to change one’s gender or sexual orientation they don’t agree...

Words: 1552 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Working Across Difference with Transgender and Transsexual Individuals

...------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Assessment 3 ------------------------------------------------- Working Across Difference With Transgender ------------------------------------------------- And Transsexual Individuals ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Student Name:------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- Clare J Clayton | ------------------------------------------------- Student Number:------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------- S2847347 | ------------------------------------------------- Date Submitted: | ------------------------------------------------- 1st June 2015 | ------------------------------------------------- Working Across Difference With Transgender ------------------------------------------------- and Transsexual Individuals Transgender, transsexual and trans individuals have long experienced multi-layered non-acceptance and need support to work across difference to......

Words: 3787 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Business Law

...Declaration of Independence, which proclaims that "all men are created equal" and that they are "endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable Rights" including "Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness”. Yet, it is still legal in 29 states to be fired for just being gay. In 33 of the 50 states of the United States of America, one can be fired for being transgendered. These states do not have legal protections for members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) Community (Solmonese, 2009). So does the “American Dream” only apply to “first class citizens”? This paper explores if the Employee Non Discrimination Act (ENDA) would protect employment decisions, which should be based upon a person's qualifications and job performance, not sexual orientation or gender identity (Solmonese, 2009). For over 50 years when there has been a case of an American being denied employment or promotions for reasons that were unrelated to their skills in the workplace, Congress responded by passing laws which were aimed at designing a system based solely on employee- merit and guaranteeing that subjective considerations do not govern access to employment (Herman, 2009). A specific act that has been brought to legislation, although has not passed, is the Employee Non Discrimination Act. ENDA is modeled after Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which forbids employers from discriminating with regard to hiring, termination,...

Words: 3185 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Discrimination Against Transgender Individuals

...Discrimination against Transgender Individuals Outline I. Introduction A. Opener: B. Thesis Statement: This research paper will be discussing about discrimination against transgender individuals in society, at work, and in marriage as well as in family. II. First of all, there are discrimination against transgender individuals in society. A . Transgender individuals face discriminatory barriers to full equality 1. face difficulties meeting their basic needs 2. having their gender identity respected B. Transgender individuals face more severe discrimination than LGB individuals III. Besides that, there are also discrimination against transgender workers. A. Costs of discrimination 1. transgender individuals were fired without reason 2. transgender workers experienced unfairness A. B.  High risk of unemployment and poverty IV. There are discrimination in marriage and in family. A. Discrimination in marriage 1. cannot stay in a marriage if gender is changed 2. parenting issues after transition B. Discrimination by family members V. Conclusion: Discrimination against Transgender Individuals What is LGBT? LGBT stands for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender. Lesbian stands for a woman who is romantically, sexually or emotionally attracted to woman, gay stands for a man who is romantically, sexually or emotionally attracted to man while bisexual stands for an individual who......

Words: 2812 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

The Ethics of Transgender Medicine

...Ethical Considerations and Implications for Transgender Medicine In Western society gender and sexuality are believed to be binary and there is little room for variance. As the decades progress, more and more sociologists, scientists, and therapists are acknowledging that gender and sexuality are largely a social construct. With this new understanding, physicians are forced to grapple with how to treat gender-variant patients both physically and emotionally. As many patients seek to match their bodies with their minds, at times risky surgical and hormonal treatments must be prescribed. The physician is forced to weigh the risks and benefits to the patient and oftentimes it is the physician's decision that will determine if the transgender patient will complete the medical part of his, her, or hirtransition, allowing the individual to continue living his or her life in a body congruent with his or her gender expression. The psychiatrist’s recommendation for SRS and hormonal treatment is imperative in the process and this paper will examine the ethical implications of the essential causal diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorder (GID) and the recommendation of surgical treatment in order for patients to fit into the Western gender binary. A brief examination of co-morbidity of mental disorders and their affect on consent and provider views on competence and capacity are also warranted. Adolescent transgendered patients under the age of eighteen experience more difficulties with......

Words: 5990 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Trans

...Born This Way - A Research Paper on Transgender Everyone has a gender; it is a thing affects everything in our lives. It affects how we act like and look like every day. However, have you ever thought about what is gender? Gender is the thing that describes the characteristics that a society or culture delineates as masculine or feminine (Nobelius). Today, most of the countries define gender base on the physical and genetic sexuality at birth. There is at least one transgender person, whose self-gender identity is different from the assigned gender sex at birth, in each 100 people (NCTE). Under the rules of our society, there are at least 70 million people living in the world without their identity. Loss of identity also comes with life-threatening discriminations and inequities to them. To solve this serious problem and to improve the harmony of the society, gender’s definition should be redefined to include transgender and not only base on the physical sexuality at birth. Before everything else, the most important question is: what is transgender? From the definition of Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation, transgender is the state of one's self gender identity not matching one's assigned sex which based on physical sexuality at birth (GLAAD). To be easier to imagine, I would use a simple example. Imagine that your name is Tom. One day, while you are sleeping, someone assigns “Peter” as your name. After that, everyone starts calling you “Peter” while you can......

Words: 3916 - Pages: 16