Treating Juveniles as Adults

In: Other Topics

Submitted By liz1210
Words 1165
Pages 5
Lizbeth Padilla
DeVry University
Lance Arnold
Intro to Criminal Justice
02/07/2013

I believe treating juveniles as adults is a good law to ensure that they can go to jail and receive time for a crime they committed. I think no matter what age a person is they should learn a lesson by doing their punishment or do hour services for the community. If a child that can pick up a dangerous weapon and harm an innocent person they knows what is right or wrong. They know that they can get in trouble for it. They should expect the consequences are going to be giving to them. My offer, point of view to prevent things like this is that children and adults should take delinquency programs. They can get counseling, get other services where they can get help to get their life straighten out, and prevent them from getting in trouble in the future.
During the 1990s, nearly every state passed more punitive justice laws making it easier to try juveniles in adult court. More and more teens are doing time alongside adults in prison. This represents society’s recent shift towards taking a harsher view of adolescent’s culpability. When a juvenile is charge with certain felony offenses, his or her case may be transferred to the adult criminal division where a juvenile will be prosecuted in the same way as adults charge with laws violations. When a child is found guilty or pleads guilty in adult court and is sentenced as an adult, that child is forever considered an adult for the future violations of state law.
In some cases, minors can be tried as adults. There three strikes that the law says, “Some serious or violent crimes committed by minors can count as strikes in the future”. This can happen even if the records are sealed. A child who is 14 years old can be tried in adult court for some serious crimes. Here are some examples of a child can make these offenses and can be…...

Similar Documents

Compare the Adult and Juvenile Criminal Justice Systems

...There are many significant differences between the juvenile and adult Justice systems. There has been speculation that the leniency found within the juvenile courts is not always the best option for all cases. In the juvenile courts, rehabilitation of the individual is the primary focus. Within the adult courts due process and retribution are considered more so than the latter. One of the main differences in the juvenile and adult courts is the terminology which is used. For juveniles who are brought into court, the terminology refers to the situation as an "act of delinquency". In the adult court the term "crime" is used. Another difference is the way in which the juvenile offender's background is taken into consideration. For instance, the juvenile's academic record and family background are taken into consideration for the case. This is not always true in the case of the adult offender . The juvenile courts tend to focus on the individualized rehabilitation of the offender. The adult courts tend to focus on the "expression of the community's disapproval for the illegal behavior with an appropriate amount of punishment for every conviction. The next stage is even more complex pertaining to the juvenile. Juvenile offenders are not arrested like an adult; they are instead taken into custody. While an adult would be indicted the juvenile has a petition filed against them. In the juvenile court they agree to a finding or deny the petition. Adult offenders must plea, either...

Words: 535 - Pages: 3

Juvenile System vs Adult System

... punishment. 5. no long term confinement release at the age of 21. 6. separate facilities for juveniles. 7. broad discretionary alternatives at all points in the process.” (p.499) The overall goals are protection and treatment; this obviously is all designed with the hope that the juvenile with all the programs is that they will be steered in a different direction. The desired result is they will not be offenders as adults, I believe this a good thing because if there is any chance for a change it would be at the younger age. From a web page by the Yale- New Haven Teachers Institute in an article by Cynthia Roberts on Juvenile Delinquency is interesting information about the history of juvenile justice, where it was and why it needed to change. “ In the U.S. Juveniles are treated differently from adults. However, this has not always been the case. In earlier times, children were thrown into jails with adults. Long sentences were common and some children were sentenced to death for their crimes. Reformers concerned about the harsh treatment of children urged the establishment of a separate court system for juveniles. The idea was that juveniles should be helped rather then punished; the court would act as a parent or guardian interested in protecting and helping the child. In 1899, Cook County, Illinois, set up the country’s first juvenile court. Today every state has a separate court system for juveniles.” (www.yale.edu) This change was a good thing with the......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Juvenile

...Juvenile Shoplifting Jean Powell Wayland Baptist University Abstract Juvenile shoplifting is becoming a serious crime. Juveniles commit this crime for many different reasons. Social influence plays a big part in why most juvenile commit the crime of shoplifting or also knows as stealing. Influence from peers can become overwhelming to where a person feels as if they have to steal to feel accepted. Economic reasons can also cause a juvenile to shoplift. Families today are struggling and juveniles don’t understand that their parents just don’t have the money for the certain things that they want. This often leads them to shoplift so that they can have the items like their peers have. There are also psychological influences that play a part in juvenile shoplifting. There is a disorder called Kleptomania, which causes the juvenile to shoplift. Shoplifting can become an addiction and this causes the person to commit the crime more often so that they can receive the rush. There are many factors why juveniles commit the crime of shoplifting. Juvenile Shoplifting Juveniles today are under more pressure than ever. The pressure to fit in and to be accepted among their peers is very important. This causes many juveniles to commit the crime of shoplifting. What are the common reasons that juveniles shoplift? Social influence can cause a juvenile to shoplift so that they feel accepted or to get attention from their family and friends. Negative influence...

Words: 2661 - Pages: 11

Juvenile vs Adult Justice System

...Adult Justice v Juvenile Justice System There is no question that if a person is involved in any type of crime they will at some time make their way through the justice system. However, when that person is an adolescent they will go through the juvenile justice system, as an adult would go through the adult justice system. Even though the crimes of each can be of the same manner or hold the same severity the punishment results can differ. The main reason for having the two different justice systems is that children cannot be held to the same punishment levels as an adult. Even though a child has committed the same crime an adult may commit, not every child has a mental understanding to make mature adult like decisions. The juvenile justice system was made in effort of saving children. (Siegel, pg281) The thought that a child has suffered from abuse or neglect among other factors; they could be rehabilitated into productive members of society. Much like an adult justice system a juvenile justice system also has different stages of the process. Whether it is an adult system or juvenile system the parties involved will have the right to an attorney, the right to cross examine witnesses, be notified of charges, and the prosecution must prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.(legalmatch,2014). This is known as Due Process, which for many years’ juveniles did not have the rights to. This was due to the fact that juveniles were not being punished but yet rehabilitated...

Words: 995 - Pages: 4

Trying a Juvenile as an Adult

...THE IMPACT ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM There are strength and weakness in trying a juvenile as an adult. One weakness is that adult prisons are more focused on incarceration. The juvenile will be treated as an adult within the prison walls and the crimes they committed are proportional to the offense that is committed. The juvenile is sent to prison and is required to serve their time without being offered programs that may prevent them from reoffending. Once that juvenile is an adult and enters back into society, he will most likely reoffend within three years of his/ her release. Another weakness is the juvenile being exposed to hardcore criminals. The juveniles are learning from the adults and learning new behaviors in which hardcore adult offenders expose them to. Conversations on crime, being tough and how to respond to violence are ways juveniles emulate adult behavior. In most cases these juveniles are not being watched and are being raped and taking advantage of. They have to learn to protect themselves from someone that is twice their size and eventually end up needing protection while in prison. These juveniles do what they can to survive in adult prisons with many committing suicide because of the everyday pressures they are faced with while in the adult prisons. Finally, the juvenile now has a permanent record and their livelihood when they reenter society is difficult. When the juvenile was tried as an adult, the court proceeding were not only...

Words: 449 - Pages: 2

Juvenile and Adult Courts: a Comparative Analysis

...Juvenile and Adult Courts: A Comparative Analysis Introduction Juvenile and adult courts have different language barriers that separate the two. Juvenile courts tend to use words such as detention hearing, petition, and adjudication to make things seem less harsh. Adult courts use words such as bail hearing, complaint or indictment, and the verdict. Adult courts deal with a stricter sentencing than juvenile courts do. Juvenile courts take the approach of a more controlled approach. Adults are taught to live a healthy and productive life, unlike minors. Juveniles have been reinstated so that they can be released back into society with a fresh start. The languages for juvenile courts are different than that of adult courts. Here are the different languages that separate juvenile courts from adult courts: Adult Courts • Bail Hearing • Trial • Complaint or Indictment • Defendant • Verdict • Guilty Juvenile Courts • Detention hearing • Fact-Finding Hearing • Petition • Respondent • Adjudication • Delinquent or Involved In juvenile courts they don't get a jury; instead the judge is the only person who determines if a minor has broken the law and what his or her punishment will be. The courtroom is closed to the media as well as to the general public. Juveniles are more prone to probation for longer times than adults. (#2)A juvenile's conditions of them being on probation tend to be obnoxious, including having a curfew, getting adequate...

Words: 1478 - Pages: 6

Juvenile in the Adult Prison

...Juvenile Delinquency December 3, 2014 Juveniles in The Adult Prison Children as young as 14 years old have been tried as adults and are sentenced to die in prison without considering their age and the factors that led the individual to commit the offense. Society believes that a juvenile should be tried as an adult because it will help them understand the consequences of their actions, however, children and teenagers that commit crimes are too young and they don’t have the mental ability to understand the consequences of their actions. These juveniles are not aware of what they are going to face behind the adult’s prison bars. According to the National Juvenile Justice Network, it states, “ 200,000 youths are tried, sentenced, or incarcerated as adults every year across the United States.” Studies have shown that juveniles that are sentenced to adult prisons are more likely to commit crimes again after being released from prison. Juveniles are more likely to be sexually assaulted, abuse, neglect, suicidal, and depressed in adult prisons. The adult prison has shown failures to rehabilitate these juveniles. Laws like the Felony Murder rule has to shown to be cruel and unusual punishments towards teenagers and children. Society does not bothered to look into factors such as the juvenile’s brain, mental disability, and their living environment that causes them to commit the crime. “Children are five times more likely to be sexually assaulted in the adult prisons than in...

Words: 1351 - Pages: 6

Drug Courts: Juvenile and Adult

... court programs came into place to try and push the success of the adult drug courts into the juvenile justice system. There are two main goals that are mentioned when these programs were launched. First is to provide “intensive and continuous judicial supervision over delinquency and status offence cases that involve substance abusing juveniles”. The second is to provide “coordinated and supervised delivery of an array of support services necessary to address the problems that contribute to juvenile involvement in the justice system”. The second goal is reached through services of mental health care, family care, and substance abuse treatment. In 2007 the center for Criminal Justice Research obtained a grant to fund a research study on the outcome and process evaluation of juvenile drug courts. Overall two of the nine courts scored as being effective, four scored low enough to need improvement, and three were claimed as ineffective. The referral agencies were scored as well and over 10 were found either highly effective or effective, and 12 were noted as needs improvement, and the last 13 were found ineffective. Juveniles were found to complete the drug court programs 1 percent less than traditional probation. When calculating the results for recidivism for drug and alcohol offenses the juveniles in the drug court programs had worse results when compared to youth attending standard probation after the program was finished. Follow up from both groups however tell us that drug...

Words: 1367 - Pages: 6

Juvenile

... Juvenile Criminology Student’s name Institution My discussion question Adult prison system is unsuitable to meet the needs of young offenders as shown by various research studies. The process of maintaining public safety, successful integration of young offenders to the community, rehabilitation, skill development and treatment are the main goals of the juvenile system. As suggested by Howell, (2003), justice can never be served by forcing juveniles through a system never intended to process teenagers, moreover transfer laws have worsened the implications they intend to address. Juvenile justice system was essentially established because many teenagers were subjected to awful violations in adult jails and prisons hence resulting to the society as more hardened criminals. Placing young offenders in adult prisons heightens criminal behaviors after release according to the findings. There is well founded fear that several number of young offenders slated to be placed in adult jails are more likely to be assaulted ,commit suicide and raped. Juveniles are driven to desperation and abused regularly in adult prisons because they are not specific measures to protect the young offenders from the adult prisoners. My completes work Case summary Issue Roper v. Simmons’ main issue is whether the application of Death penalty on a person who committed murder at age 17 amounts to “Cruel and Unusual” sentence and thereby barred by the 8th and 14th Amendments (Dinkes, et al 2009...

Words: 887 - Pages: 4

Juvenile and Adult Crimes

... processing and then most likely be held.  It is against the law for adults and children to be held in the same place therefore a separate and secure room will be given to the juveniles (OJJDP). The juvenile probation department takes over the custody of the child.  At this point the prosecutor would make the determination to either set the child free by dismissal or take the child to court or handle the situation informally (OJJDP).  In this particular case the prosecutor will definitely take the route of trial because there is enough evidence to convict the child of grand theft auto.  The child will not be held in the secure room or section of the police station the entire time.  Most likely the child will be sent to a juvenile detention center to be held there (OJJDP). There is the possibility that after adjudication the child may be remanded back to the same detention facility that he or she was held in during the trial process.  The prosecutors can either take this matter through juvenile court or adult court.  In this particular case the child was only 15 years old and no deaths were involved so the juvenile court would be the best bet (OJJDP).  There is two choices delinquency or waiver. In this particular case there will not be a waiver so the case will be scheduled for hearing.  The next step is the disposition plan basically an assessment of the youth’s situation and then the next step in the process.  The evidence is presented to the judge for his or her...

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Juvenile and Adult Courts

...Juvenile and Adult Courts: A Comparative Analysis Paper Cristal Irvin CJS/245 April 7, 2015 Samantha Brown Juvenile and Adult Courts: A Comparative Analysis Paper At one point in history there was only one system of justice for the people of the United States. As time went by, the justice system shifted into two structures which are known as the Juvenile and Criminal Justice System. It was recognized that children and adults were not committing the same crimes. The states responded to this issue by establishing a system that differentiates juveniles from adults by creating the juvenile court system. The Juvenile Court is a complex structure that in order to understand it, one needs to know the process of when a juvenile enters the system. The American Juvenile Justice System is put into place to focus and manage juveniles who are caught and convicted of crimes. The system is formulated by agencies that consist of police officers, prosecutors, juvenile courts, probation officers, and the Department of Juvenile Corrections. The system functions by agencies taking various steps when dealing with a juvenile. The first step is determining who is a juvenile. In most states a juvenile is considered a child between the ages of ten and eighteen and in some states they can set the maximum age as sixteen. When a police officer encounters a juvenile that has committed a crime the police officer has several options on handling a juvenile who has committed a delinquent act...

Words: 1391 - Pages: 6

Juvenile

...Assignment 1 Identify the topic you selected and explain two reasons for using it and include thesis statement: Juveniles and the justice system is the topic chosen for my research paper. According to the FBI “Juveniles (< 18 years) were arrested for murder, 2,198 for forcible rape, and 35,001 for aggravated assault,” these are all actions that sound horrible and reap even more horrible consequences. “When juvenile cases get transferred to adult criminal court through a process called a ‘waiver’—when a judge waives the protections that juvenile court provides” (Kathleen Michon, 2016). Usually, juvenile cases that are subject to waiver involve more serious crimes, or minors who have been in trouble before. Ever since more states have begun trying juveniles as adults in certain situations, the crime rate among juveniles has dropped significantly. Thesis statement: The frequency of juveniles committing horrendous crimes has been on a steady rise for the past couple of decades and even though fewer varieties of punishments, juveniles should be tried as an adult because it would deter and minimize crimes committed by minors and brings justice to the victims. Describe 3 major characteristics of your audience: My intended audience will include my professor and classmates, lawmakers, judges, prosecutors, lawyers, and parents. I will try to persuade readers to agree with my stand on juveniles and violent crimes and why I feel so strongly that juveniles should be tried as an...

Words: 980 - Pages: 4

Juvenile

... assault. These crimes had a 10-year decline from 1994 to 2004, but increased from 2004 to 2006, then declined 2 years later. Arrests for rape and aggravated assault among juveniles is the lowest it has been in 2008 since 1980s, but arrests for murder increased yearly from 2005 to 2007 before taking a five percent decline in 2008. Both arrest rates for simple assault and drug offenses declined. The simple assault declined for two consecutive years for a total of seven percent since 2006. Juvenile aggravated arrests declined as well. From the mid-1990s to 2008 it fell a total of 43%. The drug offenses began to decline after 1997 after a rapid increase of drug arrests during the early 1990s. Between 1990 and 1997 the juvenile arrests rate for drug abuse violation increased 145%, but declined between 1997 and 2008. However, the rate was still 78% higher than the rate in 1990 (Puzzanchera, 2008). When comparing the arrest rates between juvenile male and females, there were a total of 629,800 arrests of females in 2008 under the age of 18. Female arrests accounted for 30% of juvenile arrests in 2008 and decreased from 1999 to 2008 in most categories except for simple assault larceny, theft, and DUI when compared to males. According to " Crime In America.net (2010), “female numbers have increased but they are a small portion of the delinquency caseload nationwide. When compared to the number of cases involving males in 2007 (1,217,100) was just 30 percent more than...

Words: 983 - Pages: 4

Juvenile & Adult Courts

...The Juvenile justice system is very similar to the criminal justice system, which is made up of several different agencies. The juvenile system is mostly aimed at rehabilitating teenagers, rather than punishing them. With the juvenile system, they have a limited jurisdiction that is up to age 17 in most states and informal proceedings, which for the most part are handled through local county systems being either juvenile or family courts. Many juvenile crimes go unreported because no arrest has been made, and if they are arrested they are only able to be booked for committing the highest level of crime. Most crimes committed by teens are theft, drug abuse, basic assault, disorderly conduct, and curfew violations. The most common offense among juveniles is theft followed by drug abuse. Although the juvenile system is used more for rehabilitation than punishment, there is a movement called “get-tough” which is for juveniles that break the law it would give them a harsher punishment, rather than just rehabilitation. The Illinois juvenile court act was approved in 1899, making it the first juvenile court. This act would in fact, include all juveniles under the age of 16 that violated any law. In the same year, Colorado passed the compulsory school act, which was for juveniles who were usually absent from school or wandered the streets during school hours. This act was to try to help teenagers destroy their deviant behaviors, while they are still young. Juveniles had special......

Words: 302 - Pages: 2

Juvenile and Adult Crimes

...Juvenile and Adult Crimes CRJS300 By Erika.Esquer1 American InterContinental University   Abstract This essay will focus on specialized juvenile justice’s cases, particularly in the cases of Mrs.I’s son who was arrested for driving without a license and crashing into a storefront. How the lawyer will respond to Mrs. I. What steps the lawyer will take to defend Mrs. I’s son and opinion of the judge and how the judge would sentence the case.   Introduction There have been numerous cases of car theft and careless driving in United States. With effective criminal justice in US, these felonies have not failed to be punished. The judgment on these cases has seen most culprits get confined to a maximum of six years. Statistics show that most of the culprits of these crimes are adults, with adolescents being responsible for only a small fraction of the incidents. The penalties for committing these crimes are clear and the jurors have not hesitated on imposing them on the misdemeanors. Whilst most people accept the penalties inflicted on such culprits, there are numerous questions raised on how courts handle juveniles involved in such crimes. Should these youngsters face penalties similar to adults? Judges should determine if juveniles should be treated equally as adults when arbitrating on cases where adolescents commit crimes similar to adults, particularly on the case of Mrs.I’s son. The son of Mrs. I who is 15-years old was apprehended by law enforcers after he was...

Words: 1329 - Pages: 6