Free Essay


In: Business and Management

Submitted By zaharahabdrahman
Words 1279
Pages 6
According on that, there are facing dilemma of truth in accounting between justification of standard setting and justification of auditing. Difference researcher, have a difference opinion. According to Macintosh (2002), decision usefulness as defined by FASB is myth and truthfulness as defined by AICPA is a reality. Another researcher, Moore (2009) characterized the economic reality the FASB set out to show a myth. Other than that, Williams and Ravenscroft (2010) argue that decision usefulness as defined by FASB is since there is no way to any standard actually improves the prediction of cash flows. That is no empirical means is available to standard-setters to prove predictive ability either for any individual decision makers or for any mechanical method of economic prediction. Unlike standard-setting, auditing is the act of attesting to the veracity of something, an evidentiary process analogous to the legal process of gathering evidence to establish the ‘‘facts of the case.’’
Some countries use the term “truth” in their auditors’ reports. According to Myddelton (1995), under UK Companies Act, United Kingdom used “true and correct” from 1879 to 1947 and they changed to “true and fair view” after that. According to Chastney (1975), for Australia, they have used “true and fair” since issuance of the Financial Corporation Act of 1974. After a detailed comparison between many countries, a report shows that many problems occurred in implementing a term whether they should use “fairly present” or “true and correct”. So many efforts have been made to promote truthfulness but it still cannot eliminate the belief of others where fraud is still considered exist in financial reporting. According to Shaub and Fischer (2008), one of the values central to accounting ethics education is a commitment to tell the truth. Other than that, FASB (1980) has stated that accounting should not mislead and should faithfully represent an economic reality. Under SFAS #2 clearly shows that truthfulness is more to reliability, neutrality and representational faithfulness. It is too complex and problematic to ensure the truthfulness of something but it can give something basic that all participants can understand by doing so.
Decision usefulness is related with the future where the information provided is forecasting relevant outcomes of future phenomena. The usefulness of information will be classified into two categories of information which are the information that is useful for accountability purposes and the information that is useful for decision making purposes, for example in making resource allocation and social decisions. In other word, the information in financial reporting should be useful to present to users such as investors and creditors so that they can make a decision to invest, credit and so on. With the usefulness of that information, users can generate a predictive ability where they can predict and make a decision by assess the amounts, timing, and whatsoever in financial reporting. Ijiri (1975) commented that they are interpreting accounting methods rather than change the fundamental principle of accounting. The interpretation of accounting method will be more to user-oriented viewpoint.
If we look closer about the nature of truth, it is quite difficult to understand from some philosophers. Here are some arguments from researchers how they interpret about truthfulness. According to Kirkham (1997), the concept of justification is the same with concept of truth. Therefore, they do not need a theory of truth but them distinct from a theory of justification. Besides that, some accounting researchers consider the problem of truth complex but solvable. Briloff (1972, 1981, 1990, and 2001), Macintosh and Shearer (2000) said that complaint that such accounting signs as income and capital no longer represent transparently any objective or profound reality. According to Hapwood (2007), accounting is a practice, not a social science. For example, the authorization and control aspects of bookkeeping are self-evident.
In this article, we describe the conflict by relying on McCumber’s (2005) work which he provides a reformulation of the philosophical problem of truth that is more sympathetic with accounting practice’s traditional role. Understanding accounting’s possibilities of objectivity is more useful and a better regulative ideal of truth compare to current standard-setter’s fixation on the coherence to an ideological construct. In McCumber’s (2005) work, he produces six-way interplay between our pasts and our futures. The crucial of situating for accounting is how it helps to situate accounting as a human activity. As a human being, we cannot predict what are going to happen in future, even we cannot know everything what has occurred in past. In my opinion, decision usefulness and truthfulness are related from each other. Decision usefulness is based on conceptual framework whereas truthfulness is based on perception from auditors. Let say, an accountant record the transaction which is not useful for user, therefore the usefulness will not meet the objective of the transaction.
To relate between ethics and truth we use McCumber’s argue that it need to focus on rightness and wrongness of actions that is state in accounting ethics. McCumber’s viewing is to act ethically; we must defined what the situation we are in and must satisfied ourselves what is happening. A question from ancient Greek “How is it necessary to live?” The answer is based on vertical and horizontal dimension. Based on vertical, the relationship between the multi-level of human world such as individual, community, society and biosphere and based on horizontal, financial accounting professions code of conduct prescribe the proper behavior. In order to support the argument McCumber’s state that ethics then comprises the general principals in particular how individuals and communities should make their way through human world. Other than that McCumber state that exchange among the edges are ethically more significant than action occurring on each level separately. Other than using McCumber ideas, the article also using ideas from May that describes the notion of the responsibility that focuses on edges in terms of sharing responsibility. Bunge adds that, thou shall search for the truth, pursue it wherever it may lead, and communicate it to whoever may interest in it. A few standard relating to its core ethical principles of honesty. First, IMA with four standards of conduct that is competence, confidentiality, integrity and credibility. Second, AICPA code professional conduct is mandates CPA independence in fact and appearance conducting audits. And lastly, GOA with their core values are accountability, integrity and reliability. According to McCumber’s, what salient facts are omitted by accountants in the narratives they provide about entities will depend on how much accountant devotes to focusing on edges of ethics. It is related to Enron; certainly the accounting narrative about Enron omitted important facts and was the organization itself.
A real problem for accounting raised by truth where it cannot easily finessed by appeals to decision usefulness. McCumber (2005) also shows how truth and ethics are interconnected from the concepts of truths. Accountants’ relationship to management is engaged in conflict, not as an enabler. The dilemma of independent auditor or corporate management involves two powers which are the management’s financial temptation to encourage the auditor to allow defective and the integrity of auditor to against the temptation. Actually the dilemma comes from the standard because the standard is quite general so there are many different perceptions about the standard. Accounting standard setters have replaced an accountability of truth with decision usefulness to escape from this dilemma. By let the decision usefulness still vague, it can release them from being accountable for the consequences of their actions. The relationship between truthfulness and ethic in accounting are more to people action has been focus on. Have a few standards for accountant to make an account but that entire are depends on their ethic to follow it or not.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Honesty and Integrity Honesty Being truthful, straightforward, and candid are aspects of honesty. Truthfulness is required. Deceptions are usually easily uncovered. Lies erode credibility and undermine public confidence. Untruths told for seemingly altruistic reasons (to prevent hurt feelings, to promote good will, etc.) are nonetheless resented by the recipients. Straightforwardness adds frankness to truthfulness and is usually necessary to promote public confidence and to ensure effective, efficient conduct of operations. Truths presented in such a way as to lead recipients to confusion, misinterpretation, or inaccurate conclusions are not productive. Such indirect deceptions can promote ill-will and erode openness, especially when there is an expectation of frankness. Candor is the forthright offering of unrequested information. It is necessary according to the gravity of the situation and the nature of the relationships. Candor is required when a reasonable person would feel betrayed if the information were withheld. In some circumstances, silence is dishonest; yet in other circumstances, disclosing information would be wrong and perhaps unlawful. Integrity Being faithful to one’s convictions is part of integrity. Following principles, acting with honor, maintaining independent judgment, and performing duties with impartiality help to maintain integrity and avoid conflicts of interest and hypocrisy. “Do what’s right legally and morally”, these are the words......

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ethical Making

... Ethical Making Decision Digital Foot print Question 1: Which of the perspectives of the four members of the G-BioSport Ethics did you find to be persuasive? Find the perspectives of the four members of the G-Bio Sport Ethics. I found that the most persuasive perspective to be was from Mark Tatum. His values are truthfulness and honesty. He also values the right of each individual to think about how they will follow their conscience. If more people in our community thought like Mark it would be a better place. Mark perspective is the Rights/Responsibilities lens. Aimee Binder perspective is perspective is the Relationship Lens. Alex Smith’s ethical perspective is the Results Lens. Lastly Carol Byrne’s ethical perspective is the Reputation Lens. Question 2: Did the perspective you found persuasive mirror your result from the Ethical Lens Inventory? Where did you see similarities and differences? Yes it did mirror my Ethical Lens. Mark and I both share the Rights/Responsibility Lens. We share similarities in we both truthfulness and honesty. Our differences are that Mark focuses on responsibly following the rules. Sometimes following the rules isn’t always the right choice. You have to think out your options. Financial Responsibility Question 1: As you reflect on the experience of self-talk, did you find the process useful in helping you make more ethical decisions? What were the strengths...

Words: 416 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Tares Test

...with increased profits or increased visibility. It is, rather, concerned with what one ought to do—or ought not to do. Thus, it’s easy to persuade others but it will be tough when once involve by the ethics.  Ethical persuasion is the practice of influential communication that respects the dependence of the audience by presenting truthful and relevant information. It enables audiences to make voluntary, informed, rational and reflective choices. Sherry Baker and David Martinson propose a five-part to test how ethical a persuasion should be, including methods for guiding ethical persuasion have been identified and to check and determine the ethical worthiness of the message. TARES is an acronym for Truthfulness, Authenticity, Respect, Equity and Social Relevance. Truthfulness pertains to the message of the persuader where the persuader should tell the truth and nothing more than a truth, a fact with reliable sources and should not be fall into deception. Second is authenticity which means that living in reality makes our life worth living. It compromises the integrity and personal virtue that requires the persuader should act decently, sincerity and genuineness is love the persuadees and sincerely giving assurance on the product, and loyalty and independence must engage with moral judgment. Third is respect that’s concern to one’s or overall emotion. We humans are created with emotion and the persuader should consider that. Then fourth is equity refers to fairness,......

Words: 1111 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Procedures on the Administration of Information Disclosure of Listed Companies

...Article 2: Persons with information disclosure obligations shall disclose information truthfully, accurately, completely and timely and there shall be no falsehood, misleading representation or major omission. Persons with information disclosure obligations shall make public information disclosure to all investors at the same time. Where companies that issue and list securities and their derivatives in domestic and overseas markets disclose information in the overseas market, such information shall also be disclosed in the domestic market. Article 3: The directors, supervisors and senior management personnel of issuers and listed companies shall perform duties faithfully and diligently and ensure the truthfulness, accuracy, completeness, timeliness and fairness of the information disclosed. Article 4: No person with knowledge of insider information shall make public or divulge such information nor utilize such information to conduct insider trading prior to disclosure of insider information in accordance with the law. Article 5: Information disclosure documents shall mainly include share prospectus, offering prospectus, listing announcement, periodic reports and ad hoc reports. Article 6: Where listed companies and other persons with information disclosure obligations disclose information in accordance with the law, they shall submit the announcement text and the relevant......

Words: 6439 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Yeah my friend for what I did but I feel even she accepts it, I know she has a hard feelings to me. So I went home and make the day past and I went back to my friend’s home to ask again for her forgiveness and I also say sorry again to her mother. My friend accepts my sorry that day and I am very happy on it. 7. What is your idea honesty, loyalty, fidelity, faithfulness and truthfulness? (This will tell you the degree of a person’s grasp of what is morally right and wrong) For me honesty, loyalty, fidelity, faithfulness and truthfulness are the characteristics of a person you don’t ask to give to you but are naturally given to you by a person. Honesty is that when a person tells the truth even if he/she hurts people that can lead to a good result or outcome of the problem. Loyalty is that when people shows trust to a specific thing or person even if there is a bad comment about it. Fidelity is when the person shows dedication and commitment about his or her work. Faithfulness is the characteristics that you believe and trust a person on what he/she is telling and showing to you. Truthfulness is the state of saying the truth no matter it will end up with a good or bad outcome. 8. How would handle a customer that does not believe in your product? ( test of ingenuity, creativity and salesmanship) If the customer doesn’t believe in my product, first thing that I will do is to discuss again what my product is. Then I will ask about his/her hobbies and likes......

Words: 1402 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Communication

...ethical corporations, and Fluor is on that list. Clearly their ethical practices have landed them on several ethical practices listings which include World’s Most Ethical Company, Greater Dallas Business Ethics Award, and Government Contractor Ethics Rating (2013). CEO David Thomas Seaton has been quoted as saying “I run my company with honor, promise, and make ethical decisions.”(Putnam, 2013). I am certain his ethical decisions include integrity, which is written in the company’s code of conduct, truthfulness, and fairness. Fluor has also reported an increase in all quarters of 2012 revenue. I think Thomas Seaton says it best when he states, “Questions of right and wrong arise whenever people communicate. Ethical communication is fundamental to responsible thinking, decision making, and the development of relationships and communities within and across contexts, cultures, channels, and media. Moreover, ethical communication enhances human worth and dignity by fostering truthfulness, fairness, responsibility, personal integrity, and respect for self and others. "(Putnam, 2013). Resources Ethisphere-Ethics Report. (2013). Retrieved November 10, 2013 from Putnam, Mark. Global Ethics University. (2013). Retrieved November 10, 2013 from

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...through a broad range of emotions, which include fear, surprise, excitement, and upset as I witnessed the ups and downs of the story. Being the storyteller as well as the filmmaker, Jonathan opened the whole personal world to us and shared all his views about life with us without doubt. “Tarnation” is a man’s bold expression to tell the story of his own life, and for me, it just shook my heart and my mind. As with Renov’s first thesis about autobiography and documentary where “the very idea of autobiography reinvents the VERY IDEA of documentary”, Jonathan brought us a very unique, bold, creative, and extremely stylish way to watch the documentary films. “Tarnation” differentiated itself from most other traditional documentaries in its truthfulness root from the inner self – “private truth and inner realities” (Renov). Unlike documentary films, which rely on different sources of interviews and researches to enhance their arguments and facts, autobiographical films rely on audiences’ judgment and confidence on how people tell the stories about themselves. In traditional documentaries audiences are forced to listen to the narrator’s voice, telling you what is happening, what did happen, and what will happen. In this film, Jonathan employed the visual texts to give us more attention towards the images on the screen. With these words displayed on the screen, we focus on Jonathan, his mother, the other characters, and the environment that is around him. The author tried to record......

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethics Case Study

...universal, because of the company must be in trouble if everyone do this. According Kantian’s ethics, everyone should tell the truth, that is the universal consistent law. For the respect part, he would fail it. Tom’s behaviour is telling lie, which is not showing the respect to the company. Overall, truth telling is a vital factor in Kantian’s theory. So Tom cannot meet both principles of universal acceptability and respect because of telling lie. He does not follow duties and against categorical imperative as well. Virtue ethics For virtue ethics, I am going to apply sincerity in expression (truthfulness) in Tom’s dilemma. Tom’s action is against the virtue in terms of truthfulness, he is not telling truth when he exaggerating. Moreover, Tom’s action turns him into means rather than ends, because he telling lie in order to get a job. Telling lie is actually against truthfulness and is not a virtuous person in this situation would do. In brief, Tom’s action is not ethical under virtue ethics. Ranking of ethical theories In my opinion, the most useful for resolving my own ethical dilemmas is virtue ethics theory, and then is Kantian ethics theory and the least useful theory is utilitarianism. In comparison with Kantian ethics theory and utilitarianism, virtue ethics theory can address most ethical dilemmas, and also can meet other two theories in most situations. I think most of time I just need follow a virtue and take the consequence and be honest into account,......

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Truthfulness as a Factor in the Language of Advertising / Supersexualize Me! Advertising and ‘the Midriff’

...Truthfulness as a Factor in the Language of Advertising There is a possible relationship between truthfulness and the language of advertisement is difficult and hard fact for most advertisers to believe in the world of communication. This has to do with freedom of expression associated with the use of figures of speech such as simile, metaphor, hyperbole, and euphemism (Crystal 1997). To those who hold this belief, there is no relationship we between ethics (from where we conceived the virtue of truthfulness) and the language of advertisement. Some do ask: what does truthfulness have to do with advertisement since it is persuasive? And, that what has truthfulness need to do with persuasion because persuasion often involves cajoling, coaxing, convincing, enticing and inducing. All these as a matter of fact involve exaggeration, falsehood, puffing, and embellishment and over estimation.These raise the question of morality in business. In the field of advertisement, we ask the question of professional ethics, and ethical codes of conduct in relation to advertisement practices. In the field of language, the society also seeks for truthfulness, because language be it of advertising or otherwise, is an instrument for action used to promote our purpose in dealings with others, and in communicating ideas that are divorced from emotion. Truthfulness simply refers to the act of giving true information or facts (in exact manner) about something. Therefore, true statement is based...

Words: 2873 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay


...advertisements on the application pursuit process in Pakistan Farida Saleem Institute of Engineering and Management Sciences, Foundation University Rawalpindi, Islamabad, Pakistan. E-mail: Accepted 22 September, 2010 Recruitment ads play a very important role in generating pool of applications. The aim of all recruitment ads is to attract as many as possible applications for generating hiring options. This study investigates the impact of specificity of information on application pursuing process. Four recruitment ads were used (two general ads and two specific ads) to check their impacts on application pursuing process. The results showed that three variables including ad information, ad appropriateness and ad truthfulness have significant differences for specific job ads and general job ads, while application pursuing process is generally the same for both specific and general job ads. Key words: Specific recruitment ads, general recruitment ads, application pursuing process. INTRODUCTION Marketing is a communication of something which is specifically directed to some one. The target audience of any marketing activity can be its customers, competitors, employees or even potential employees, these communications can be in a direct form like marketing of a new or existing product by a company or it can be in an indirect form such as recruitment advertisements (Ryan et al., 2000). As the major aim of marketers is to analyze consumer......

Words: 1949 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

The Relationship Between Critical Thinking and Ethics

...beliefs and information and the intellectual commitment to use those skills to guide your behavior. There are six levels of the critical thinking process. The first level of critical thinking is remembering. This process is the simplest level because it only requires you to remember key terms, facts or events. The second level is being able to have an understanding of the learned information and be able to explain it in your own words. The third level is applying the learned information to get the desired result. The fourth level is analyzing the learned material, with this step you should be able to break down the learned material into parts. The fifth level is evaluating. Evaluating means that you can determine the usefulness and truthfulness of material and be able to give supporting reasons for your choices. The sixth and last level is creating. On this level you should be able to produce a new product from the learned information. My blind spot is having the belief that motive justifies method or the overconfidence in the process. It has a lot to do with wanting equality for all. I do believe that it is the motivation behind the action that gives you better understanding or perspective of the action. However, I do not trust the process for all because there are too many factors that come into play with every situation. My preferred lens is the Rights and Responsibility and Relationship Lens. I was very impressed with the results of my Ethical Lens Inventory. ......

Words: 554 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bp Communication Problems

...points that will explain in detail on how British Petroleum had bad communication and how it ended up creating history’s biggest oil spill in the United States in the Gulf of Mexico. The 3 main points include: 1. Pre-Event Planning a. Anticipate, Prepare, Practice b. “Safety” Not a Core Value c. Responsibility of Employees 2. Expressing Concern and Wrongful Focus a. Slow in Expressing Concern b. Lack of Sympathy to Affected People c. Accountability 3. Company Truthfulness a. Alarm Negligence b. Learn From Mistakes Table of Contents Introduction 5 Figure 1: BP Oil Spill Statistic………………………………………………………………….5 Purpose
 5 Procedure 5 Organization 6 Pre-Event Planning 6 Anticipate, Prepare, Practice 6 "Safety" Not a Core Value 6 Repsobsiblty of Employees 6 Expressing Concern and Wrongful Focus 7 Slow In Expressing Concern 7 Accountability 7 Figure 2: BP Heirarchy of Accountability (Locke, 2010) 7 Lack of Sympathy to Affected People 8 Company Truthfulness 8 Alarm Negligence 8 Learning From Mistakes 8 Summary 9 Recommendations 9 References 10 List of Figures Figure 1: BP Oil Spill Statistics 
 5 Figure 2: BP Hierarchy of Accountability
 7 Introduction On April 20th 2010, the United States of America encountered the largest maritime oil spill in its history. The explosion occurred from a gas release on the Deepwater Horizon oil rig while working on the Macondo exploration well from BP in the......

Words: 2420 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Conrad Critical Analysis

...experience and truthfulness in one’s life. At various points throughout the story the descriptions of Kurtz by a wide range of characters proves how the darkness is representative of these traits of knowledgeability. For example when Marlow is just arriving at Kurtz’s compound and is talking to the harlequin about Kurtz, the harlequin says in regards to Kurtz, “You do not talk with that man−you listen to him…this man has enlarged my mind” (Conrad, 122). In the description of Kurtz, the harlequin proves how Kurtz has an overpowering sense of experience in which he tells the truth about human nature. This is evident of how Kurtz is knowledgeable and has found the truth about his inner self, which he commands to control the people around him. Similarly, the harlequin later on in describing his experience with Kurtz to Marlow, explains how Kurtz talks about everything and anything (Conrad, 124). It is evident through this explanation that Kurtz is clearly knowledgeable which is representative of how ironically he is a symbol of darkness. Now, within the book as said by Florence H. Ridley, “Forced by wilderness to recognition of his kinship…Kurtz succumbs completely” (Ridley, 46). Here Kurtz is proven to be a symbol of darkness as he is surrounded by the overpowering forest and the darkness within it, which he eventually becomes part of. This once again is how Conrad ironically indicates how light represents ignorance and darkness, experience as well as truthfulness. Conrad in......

Words: 1460 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Confucius and Aristotle on Virtue

...improving the moral state of the human state. To him, being virtuous is a form reverence to the gods. Confucius has a similar take on piety noting that by following the ‘dao’ in heaven embedded in ‘li’, human beings act in accordance with the wishes of the gods(Yu, 1998). Aristotle has different set of key virtues to Confucius. Aristotle believed that the main virtues were courage, generosity, magnificence, high mindedness, gentleness, friendliness, truthfulness, wittiness and wisdom. On the other hand, Confuciusbelieved that the major virtues are propriety (li), filial piety (hsiao) and humanity (jen). Humanity can be achieved by practicing earnestness, liberality, truthfulness, diligence, and generosity (Peimin, 2009). Based on these virtues, the two philosophers differed in what they believed to the most important virtue. Aristotle believed that friendship or friendliness was the most important virtue. It allowed people to be kind to one another and even facilitated people to have other virtues such truthfulness and generosity. On the contrary, Confuciusbelieved that propriety, which is obedience to the set laws and regulations, was the greatest virtue. It allowed people to exist peacefully. He indicated that it is by the rules of propriety that the character is established…….Respectfulness, without the rules of propriety, becomes laborious bustle; carefulness, without the rules of propriety, becomes timidity; boldness, without the rules of propriety,......

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...sales view. Gaming is the ethical dilemma that the personal banker is confronting, as they are manipulating and misrepresenting the sales. The personal banker violated the code and did not understand that honesty, integrity and trust is essential for the business. This situation is hurting the customer, and the only person working for his benefit is the personal banker. Evaluating this unethical situation under the Six Pillars of Characters, we found that trustworthiness which includes the qualities of honesty, integrity and trust, is not met here. Honesty includes the dimension of truthfulness. “There is no more fundamental ethical value than honesty. We associate honesty with people of honor, and we admire and rely on those who are honest. But honesty is a broader concept than many may realize. It involves both communications and conduct”. (Josephson, Making Ethical Decisions 20) .And “Truthfulness is presenting the facts to the best of our knowledge”. (Josephson, Making Ethical Decisions 21). The personal banker is not presenting the information as it is, and prefers not to disclose all the details about the accounts in order to get his benefit. The customer is the external stakeholder for this case, and the one affected by the dishonesty of the personal banker, because it is not really receiving the service and product that he is asking for, on the contrary is getting a product that he does not know and what is worst, a product that the customer does not meet the......

Words: 574 - Pages: 3