Free Essay

Two Views on Hijab

In: Social Issues

Submitted By herpderpp
Words 1026
Pages 5
Two views on Hijab Hijab: that is, wearing a headscarf as a sign of modesty, a common (but not required) act among Muslim women. What do women who observe hijab really think about hijab in America? This essay will compare two women’s views. The first woman, a blogger identified by the moniker Scarf Ace, expresses her personal struggles with hijab in a blog post titled “Miss or Diss?” The second woman, Fatemah Fakhraie, is a Muslim-American activist for the rights of women. Her article “Scarfing it Down,” originally published in Bitch magazine--a feminist news publication--examines hijab bans and the way they effect Muslim women’s rights. While both women participate in hijab, their opinions differ on the view society takes: One woman wishes that society would accept her choice to observe hijab, the other demands it. Scarf Ace speaks out about her decision to start hijab. She begins by stating the difficulties with wearing the headscarf: it’s hot, people look at her, she can’t have a ‘good hair day’, etc. She continues because of her “husband’s high regard for hijab” and because, as a stay-at-home mother, she can choose when to leave the house, thus not having to wear it constantly (488). Her blog is an outlet for dealing with her decision to start hijab; she has very mixed emotions about it, and she wants people to hear her voice – she wants her decision to be understood and accepted by the people she encounters every day. She hears the voices of her insecurities through the eyes of watchful passersby: “… I’ve got her figured out, and it ain’t good” (489). Her difficulties with hijab stem from the fear of being different and being watched and subsequently misrepresented in people’s thoughts. She employs the use of personal storytelling throughout her article. A technique that proves to be a powerful tool in drawing the reader into her narrative; helping them empathize with her. It’s not written as a ‘poor me’ piece, but rather it empowers both the writer and the reader through the clarity of thought gained by better understanding the situation. Her thesis relies on the fact that everyone has been in a situation where they feel out of place, and her piece dredges up those memories in order to help the reader understand her point of view. Fatemah Fakhraie takes a very different approach to the same topic in her essay “Scarfing it Down.” In comparison to Scarf Ace’s personal struggle with hijab -- and the conversational approach that she takes in her writing -- Fakhraie writes a much more politicized, and aggressive narrative directed towards her feminist readership, to incite outrage and protest against the unfair treatment of Muslim women by the media and the Canadian government. She begins with the story of a girl killed by her father for not wearing a hijab (491): right away she lets the reader know that she has a point and won’t waste any time getting to it. Fakhraie claims “Banning a headscarf … is an issue of personal, not religious, freedom,” and that these bans are pointedly targeted at Muslim women (491). She writes angrily that the politicians who pass the anti-headscarf laws, and the media who polarize the issue to sell papers, are taking away the choice for Muslim women without understanding the meaning behind hijab. She uses specific examples of intolerance to substantiate her point -- the murder of the girl, and the disqualification of the young athlete on grounds of inappropriate attire (though she had competed with the same outfit for the three years prior) -- to rouse her readership. To help people understand her view on the hijab bans she likens them to the banning of any other article of clothing (491). Her article is less successful than Scarf Ace’s in drawing in readers; it is written for a reader base that already agrees with her. To someone coming across this article, it’s a harsh, in-your-face, and incredibly biased opinion piece that leaves no room for compromise; there isn’t a fence to sit on. However, that is her point: she is using the article to pose a question. Is the reader okay with the hijab bans, with intolerance, with the targeting of women? If not, they need to speak up in defense of Muslim women who deserve the choice to participate in hijab if they feel they should. This article is Fakhraie’s voice and the reader can hear her yelling. In conclusion, it’s fairly easy to see the differences between the two writers: Scarf Ace’s blog post is just what it claims to be: she is using her writing as a personal outlet to vent her frustrations and ask questions of herself; and her readership is likely to be women going through similar situations – the blog is for their mutual benefit; Scarf Ace gets the weight off her chest, and she is hopefully helping those who read her words and are also struggling with hijab, or even just being a Muslim in a largely Christian country. Contrasting with that is Fakhraie’s piece: a clearly biased opinion on an issue, written for feminists by a feminist. She makes her side clear, she doesn’t mince words, and she has thought about it and come to a conclusion. Both of these articles are meant by the writer to draw attention to hijab, but more importantly they’re trying to get the reader to look beyond the headscarf (metaphorically, of course) to see that there is a person underneath: a person deserving of respect no matter what the reader’s beliefs might be. Ultimately, the thing these two pieces share is the passion behind them: these women want to be heard, they want to shed light on an issue of importance to them, and most of all they both want their beliefs to be respected.

Works Cited:
Scarf Ace. “Miss or Diss?” Ramage, John D; Bean, John C; Johnson, June Writing Arguments: a rhetoric with readings. Boston: Pearson. (2012): 488-90. Print.
Fakhraie, Fatemah. “Scarfing it Down.” Ramage, John D; Bean, John C; Johnson, June Writing Arguments: a rhetoric with readings. Boston: Pearson. (2012): 488-90. Print.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Islamophobic Beliefs

...Design 30 Participants 30 Materials 30 Procedure 30 Analysis 31 Potential applications 33 Limitations and future directions 34 Conclusion 36 References 37 Abstract This research study will aim to measure the Islamophobic beliefs in non-Muslim people living in the West in multi-cultural, multi-ethnic and multi-faith societies such as London. To conduct this study, I will be replicating a study that has been produced by Everett et al (2015) called ‘Covered in Stigma? I will be conducting this research project to test Non-Muslim responses towards Muslim appearing people such as men in traditional clothes, beards and women in head coverings. I will use quantitative analysis to test my hypothesis, using two questionnaires, the Islamophobia scale and the Communication Scale as well as images of Muslim men and women in Islamic clothing depicted in an affirmative light or a poorly to prime participants beforehand. Introduction Prejudice and inequity towards the Muslim community has risen largely over the last few years. There is great proof indicating that Muslims are experiencing different categories of prejudice and discrimination (Pew Research Centre, 2007). Also, this pattern has increased greatly particularly after the terrorist attack of 9/11 in America and the 7/7 attack in the United Kingdom (Pew Research Centre, 2007). Straback & Listhaug (2008) examined...

Words: 6742 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Women Veil

...Muslim Women and the Veil by Katherine Bullock, will be purely academic. Both these articles share similar views of the concept of veiling and portrayal of the female body by opposing the monolithic and secular views given to the veil by the majority of the world. The view given to the veil is simple and is explicitly cited in Rethinking Muslim Women and the Veil, it is that "the popular Western notion that the veil is a symbol of Muslim women's oppression is a constructed image that does not represent the experience of all those who wear it." My stance on the subject of veiling will be in support of: those who wear the Veil (or as I will interchangeably mention it in this paper, "Hjiab" - Arabic term for head scarf) do it so by their own will and not to represent the view of oppression that has been deemed on it, also, to reiterate that the Qur'an or any other Islamic text do not support the views of oppression of women. Through my investigation of the two given articles, I will support my view with the help of three different articles that share the same type of commentary on the issue of Veiling. My inclusion of the article Eastern Veiling, Western Freedom by Nancy J. Hirschmann will bring about the realities of the Islamic practice of veiling 'in terms of the notion of freedom', another concept that is mentioned several times in resemblance is how the Westerners view the Veil as the 'ultimate symbol, if not tool, of gender oppression'. The next article I am using to......

Words: 2393 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Headscarf Controversy

...outside of Paris, three girls were expelled for wearing hijabs. The girls were in no way disruptive, or incapable academically, however, the event became a significant media event which the hijab was framed as a ‘veil’ or misrepresented as a chador. Furthermore, public intellectuals in the media promoted concerns regarding “Iran-type” mobilisation in France. A similar incident occurred in 1994, 69 girls were expelled for wearing what was continually labeled in the media as a veils, as in 1989 the ‘veil’ became a point...

Words: 1134 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Pcd vs. Muslim Culture

...PCD vs. Muslim Culture One thing America prides itself on is the freedom it allows its citizens, men and women; the freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of choice—the freedom to live. As we have learned through media and even through school, there are cultures that don’t allow the same freedom and opportunity. In my project, I want to discuss gender roles, sexuality and the ways it could affect an individual’s life. In this specific video that I chose, these women are overtly sexy, they appear confident and their words are not words that an oppressive man would approve of, I’m sure. I don’t believe that these ladies are in full control of their actions on stage or their look; I want to see what affects the performance could have on not only American viewers, but Muslim viewers, as well as the performers, themselves. The Pussycat Dolls famous record “Don’t Cha” includes words that could be considered all kinds of things; they could definitely be considered unladylike if put in the wrong hands. In today’s society, women have a different kind of power that some cultures- -and simply some men- -are not accustomed to. “Don't cha wish your girlfriend was hot like me? Don't cha wish your girlfriend was a freak like me? Don't cha? Don't cha? Don't cha wish your girlfriend was raw like me? Don't cha wish your girlfriend was fun like me? Don't cha? Don't cha?” (Pussycat Dolls) How many guys really like a woman that is that direct and forward? I am fully aware that......

Words: 2593 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

My Veil, My Identity

...of all identity,” he said to rolling applause. “The burqa is not a religious sign, it’s a sign of subservience, a sign of debasement – I want to say it solemnly: It will not be welcome on the territory of the French Republic” (“Sarkozy speaks out against burka”, 2009) is what French president Nicholas Sarkozy said on March 2004, according to BBC News. What happens if the ban is applied is that women who are seen wearing the veil in public will be fined 15o euros (£119). 30,000 euros and a one-year sentence to jail will befall men who force their women to wear the veil (“French Senate Votes to Ban Islamic Veil in Public”, 2010). The word people use to describe the veil differs from a group to another. Muslim women in France refer to it as Hijab, French refer to it as foulard, English refer to it as headscarf, and the media refers to it as veil (voile). The veil itself has no meaning, since it is just a piece of cloth, just like a shirt or a trouser. It is the symbolic meaning that matters. Since 2004, France has become known for targeting Muslim women wearing the veil...

Words: 2398 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Us Health and Administrative Law

...Preference: In a 21st century explosion of the media is the greatest revolution in fashion. Fashion is an indicator of class status, and monopolized by the aristocracy. A lower status group sought to acquire status by adopting the standards of the higher status. Media can be considered as a first medium to disseminate the fashion in public. In this assignment, we will study about the role of the modern media in shaping current fashion. The various elements of media involved in spreading of fashion information in the audience. What a person chose to carry reflects his personality or interest. A person’s choice more or less gets influenced by trend. Fashion is a popular style or practice, especially in clothing, footwear, accessories, home decoration etc. History: Fashion has been in the society since the human started with the clothes themselves. Back in the late 16th century and the early 17th century fashion denoted to the class. In ancient times Fashion Plates were engraved and colored with watercolors. In 1880 color printing and a method for making multi colors prints become stylish. In the same period of time magazines were published that played an important role in popularity of news about fashion. With the development of half tone printing process, which enables photographs to be printed on the same page as text without affecting the image clarity, fashion photograph has generated the most widely recognizable and enduring imagery of the time. Fashion television......

Words: 3115 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay


...Moral absolutism is related to human rights and stands against social topics such as war, sexism, rape to be absolutely and undoubtly immoral, regardless of religious beliefs that may believe these practices are acceptable depending on a situation. In a nutshell, moral absolutism follows the belief that there are set universal principles that are distinctively moral or immoral no matter what. For example, females being paid less than men due to their gender can be considered acceptable in some societies; from a absolute point of view, individuals should be treated equally regardless of their gender, age and religion. Moral absolutism has been shaped by human rights. After all, every indivudal is human, therefore the laws of humanity and its nature should be treated fairly. Moral absolutism can be explained through several perspectives such as rule utilitarianism. Rule utilitarianism states that an action can be moral, just only if it leads to happiness for all individuals (Schefczyk, 2009, Chapter 5, para. 8) Rule utilitarianism relates to absolutism in the sense that the moral absolute principles which individuals abide by benefit them in terms of happiness. Universal absolute principles such as treating others the way you wish to be treated, can be shown through rule utilitarianism; by treating another individual the way you would like to be treated ultimately leads to greater happiness for all people. As a whole, moral absolutism along with rule utilitarianism creates a......

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

I Am Assignment

...I Am Assignment Ahlam Gulaid Thursday July 7, 2016 I have maintained Academic Integrity in my work by adhering to the values of honesty and integrity. I declare that this work respects APA requirements as well as policies within the School of Health Sciences. Student Signature:_______________________________________ Student Number: N01185523 As humans we are all innately different. Our differences stem from cultural backgrounds, ethnicities, race, gender, but sometimes from something as fundamental as personality. As such we are always defining what is considered to be “normal” in every aspect of our lives. The definition of normal as it relates to any one category is subjective and varies from individual to individual. That being said, I believe that sometimes in our quest to be “normal” an individual may conform to a group’s widely accepted standard, as a result forfeiting or losing a unique aspect of his or her identity (which sometimes could be a relative cultural practice). I believe for us to achieve total tolerance and acceptance as a society, while maintaining our diversity we must expand our definitions of normal repeatedly as the composition of our society changes with time and we as people evolve. As I was once a newly arrived Immigrant I know how hard the culture shock can be when someone first sets foot in Canada. Coming from the Middle East to Canada it was such a culture shock for me because I’m coming from a country in which the women & men......

Words: 1372 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Religion in the Workplace

...Kelly Young SOC 120: Introduction to Ethics and Social Responsibility April 7, 2013 Week 3 Assignment Rough Draft Religion in the Workplace When one begins to talk about religion, everyone tends to be quite. Religion has and will always be a controversial subject to address. In society today with so many different religions available to practice one should not be attacked or treated differently for their religious beliefs when they enter the workforce. Under the First Amendment, Americans enjoy two freedoms with respect to religion: the right to be free from government-imposed religion and a right to practice any religion they choose to. Religion is a matter or belief and practice, and religious beliefs will rarely affect the duties of job employment. State and federal laws require that employees not be treated on the bias of religion. In deontology, the golden rule is to treat others as you would have the treat you. I know that if I respected someone’s beliefs to be atheist, I expect them to have the same respect for me and my belief in God or whatever religion I choose to place my faith in. Deontologist insist that actions should not be evaluated on the basis of the action’s consequences. The main thing about religion in the workplace is the fact that anyone can find something wrong in it. After all the different things that our nation has been through in the last few years, instead of find things wrong......

Words: 592 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Western View: Are Muslim Women Really Oppressed

...Western View: Are Muslim Women Really Oppressed? Jacque Brotherton George Fox University 20 June 2013 Abstract The Western world attributes the oppression of women in Islamic society to the religion itself but before that can be done the religion has to be fully understood. The mistreatment of Muslim women is justified as the accurate interpretation of what is stated as Shari ‘a law about their role in life. This paper examines the view of the western world and its belief in that Muslim women are oppressed. Muslim women are not allowed to work, receive limited education, and are often denied health care. The use of the veil is viewed as a sign of oppression and backwardness. This paper will also address the Qur’an and how it portrays women. Finally, the view that the Muslim women have of the western world will be discussed. On September 11, 2001, a spotlight was placed on the world of Islam. After the events of that day, there was an immediate increase in interest of the Islamic way of life. The western world has formed the opinion that Islamic society is oppressed by its religion and government, which tend to work hand in hand in its mistreatment of Muslim women. While Muslim women themselves do not feel oppressed, western bias and society portray them as such (Awde, 2005). This is because of their racial differences in regards to the way they live their lives. ......

Words: 2358 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Star Spangled Banner Analysis

...The state would be softer with kids than when they are older. There are plenty of kids who have no idea what they are doing, they do it to keep their parents along with authority peaceful. They could pray, or wear the clothes, attend the morning assembly, dance and perform without knowing what any of it means. There is a high possibility that that’s the case. For example, yes the hijabs are a choice when they are younger, but “In this city it would be difficult to remain an unveiled woman in the long run” (Adely 74). The clothing symbolizes a vital part of their culture no disagreement on that, except traditions change. This specific tradition might have been less important when these girls are young, however as time passes it becomes more important to them if they wear it or not. Chapter two discusses culture more in depth. An important lesson to grasp is that people learn culture through norms, values, symbols, as well as mental maps of reality (Guest). It is not permissible to assume these girls know what they are doing right away, being taught is different from understanding. A student can sit in class all day learning about their country’s history, little do they learn about how they can relate what they learned to their own lives. As mentioned before the school, parents, and the state enforces the students to...

Words: 1893 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Marketing Management

...Marketing Management 1.0 Executive Summary The main objectives of this study was to choose one determinant that have influence on consumer behavior. There are three sub sections of this study based on the main objectives. First is to discuss the origin and how the determinants influences the consumer. Second is the usefulness of the determinants for marketer in explaining consumer behavior. Third, the specific product that suited the determinant chosen. Next sections will explain in details work undertaken in completing each sections 1.3 Suitable product for the factors Last topic of this study is too choose suitable product based on the factors. In order to decide the product, I will analyze the factor in details to identify the most important aspect. Based on the analysis, I will choose the most suitable product. The aims for this sections is to analyze the relationship between the products and the determinants. In additions, I will choose product from Malaysia industry. This is done through sales and report status on Malaysia news and article. 1.4 Evidence To support subject and topic above, several examples will be given. This examples will be the supporting arguments to either denies or confirm the subject. Evidence will be collected from past research, event and study. Evidence will used to covers all sections of the study, especially on proving the theory and practicality of the determinant. 1.5 Observations and Commentary Observations and commentary will be......

Words: 4240 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the Relationship Between Gender and Religion

...Using material from item A and elsewhere, assess the relationship between gender and religion (33marks) Many feminists view religion as a patriarchal institution that reflects and perpetuates this inequality. There is much evidence of this female subordination in religion; They are male dominated and in Orthodox Catholicism and Judaism women are forbidden to become priests. Also Christianity teaches that men made in ‘the image and glory of God’ and women made ‘for the glory of man. This is supported by the Old Testament which states ‘...for the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church.’ There are many female characters in the biblical texts and some are portrayed as acting charitably or bravely, however the primary roles are reserved for males and most female roles are either evil (Eve) or subordinate (Mary). Similarly in the Quran, the sacred text of Islam contends that ‘men are in charge of women’. Even Christianity and Buddhism are dominated by a patriarchal power structure in which the feminine is mainly associated with the secular, powerless, profane and imperfect. Even women’s bodies and sexuality are felt to be dangerous by many religious. Because women menstruate and give birth, they are considered to have the capacity to ‘pollute’ religious rituals. The presence of women is seen to distract men from their important roles involving worship. Even though there is evidence to suggest that religious institutions have patriarchal values, it...

Words: 921 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Jp Morgan Chase

...------------------------------------------------- Report on Religious Field Research By: Lionette C. Alston Religion 212 Strayer University White Marsh Campus March 18, 2013 Religious Field Research Religion may be defined as a way of life. Religion has a variety of features. This is why often misconceptions of some religions are formed. Normally through observations and research some of the misconceptions may be corrected. Recently, I interviewed two Muslims that are married they were both converted into the Islam religion. They both have been living as Muslims for over 20 years. After our interview, I had a better understanding of the Islam religion. The religion is Islam. A person that consciously follows Islam is called a Muslim. One major misconception that I had about the Islam followers is that they were confrontational. I have always viewed the Muslims as a group of aggressive people that communicated with their fist. I also thought that they only socialized amongst each other. However, I was wrong. Islam comes from the Arabic root word meaning “peace” and submission”. Islam teaches that an Islam follower can only find peace by submitting to Allah through the heart and soul. Allah is the Almighty God, God the Creator, the Compassionate and the Sustainer. “Salaam Alaykum” a term that is used amongst Muslims which means peace be with you. The Islam religion guides towards practical ways of achieving righteousness and eliminating evil from individual/s......

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...when I joined the organization, I wasn’t too sure of what to expect so, I decided to visit one of their facility on a lovely weekend for four hours between 11am and 3pm. Apparently, on getting there, most of the residents were just getting up while others were walking towards there lounging area for their lunch. I sat with them to discuss issues within the facility. Interestingly, a lot of valuable information regarding this diverse community was shared. Specifically, the issue with the religion code of conduct between the employees and the management. The board of management has just accommodated the Muslims female employees to use hijab within the facility but unfortunately, some of the residents find it offensive because of their misconceptions. I totally understand how our society view Muslims, especially Muslim women who wear the veil or hijab since the past decade and particularly since the September 11th terrorist attacks, the Muslim community in the United States has experienced an increased level of social and religious scrutiny. The diverse group and people that we work with has shown how easy it can be to stereotype one another based on background, race, culture and belief. I have always thought Nursing home (Rehabilitation centers) were only for the elderly but I later came to realize that it’s not only for the elderly. Perhaps, anybody of any age group can end up in nursing home and there are various kinds of aliment each individual battles with and some......

Words: 901 - Pages: 4