Premium Essay

Tyler Clementi Case Study

Submitted By
Words 442
Pages 2
Tyler Clementi Case - What Punishment Is Justifiable?
Monday, Apr. 2, 2012 You've probably heard about the case of Tyler Clementi - a freshman at Rutgers University who committed suicide after his roommate, 18-year-old Dharun Ravi, secretly filmed and broadcasted Tyler having a homosexual encounter with another man. Three days later, Tyler committed suicide. Now, convicted of invasion of privacy, bias intimidation, witness tampering, and hindering arrest, Dharun faces 10 years in jail or deportation (Dharun, although living his whole life in the US, is technically native of India). He will be sentenced in May.
What punishment do you think fits the crime? How is it fair, and if so, why? Does it bring justice to Tyler? Does it serve some …show more content…
19th 2011: Tyler asked Dharun for the room to himself. Dharun then left the webcam of his computer on while he went over to a friend’s room to watch the live stream. He then posted on Twitter to his 150 followers, “Roommate asked for the room till midnight. I went into molly's room and turned on my webcam. I saw him making out with a dude. Yay”.
Sept. 21st 2011: Tyler read Dharun’s Twitter post and complained to his resident assistant and two other officials, requesting a room change.
Sept. 21st 2011: Another attempt was made by Dharun to film his roommate. And having contacted numerous people via text messages (one saying, “Yeah, keep the gays away”), an open iChat session was set up by Dharun accompanied with another Twitter post, this one saying, “Anyone with iChat, I dare you to video chat me between the hours of 9:30 and 12. Yes, it's happening again.” However, Tyler noticed the webcam and unplugged Dharun’s computer to prevent the filming.
Sept. 22nd 2011: Tyler posts his intention to commit suicide and then goes through with the intention.
Sept. 22nd 2011: Five minutes after Tyler’s post (although Dharun claims he didn’t see Tyler’s post until the next day), Dharun sends two apology emails within 15 minutes of one another. The first expressed his guilt and “good-natured” intentions in filming the first night; the second expressed his lack of bias against

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Cyber Bullying

...offenders directly insult their victims through intimidating and hostile messages. In the more public form, cyber bullying can include actions such as posting embarrassing or nude photographs of victims without their knowledge or permission. These photos are often adulterated to depict the victim in compromised or defaming poses. Cyber bullies also spread lies and rumors via texts, instant messages, and Facebook posts. Additionally, perpetrators often steal passwords to victims’ online accounts and post humiliating remarks while posing as the victims themselves. Various studies attest to the pervasiveness and severity of cyber bullying in society. The Cyber bullying Research Center surveyed 4,441 US subjects from the ages of ten to eighteen in February 2010. The study assessed the prevalence of information and communication technology among the subjects, as well as the subjects’ history with cyber bullying. The study concluded that 83% of the subjects use cell phones, 31.5% use their cell phones for online access, 47.1% use their cell phones...

Words: 1860 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Exploring Legal Issues in Higher Education

.... NORTHCENTRAL UNIVERSITY ASSIGNMENT COVER SHEET Learner: | | | |Course Number: |Faculty Mentor: | | | | |Course Title: |Assignment Number: | |Exploring Legal Issues in Higher Education |4 | | | | Learner’s Comment: Student Rights or Student Rights in Academic Dismissal Faculty Use Only Student Rights or Student Rights in Academic Dismissal Student Rights are highly protected with higher education through “Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). The FERPA Law applies to all schools or universities that receive any funds from the Department of Education by federal or state government. The law protects the privacy of students and graduates education and student finance records. Furthermore...

Words: 1361 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

When Lying Is Justifiable

...When Lying is Justifiable Lying is an inevitable behavior, although we may all agree lying is not right, we fall into this behavior many times in our lives. Everyone lies; whether it is to protect, obscure, place blame, or manipulate. As children, most individuals were taught that lying was wrong. From hearing parents say common quotes like, “the truth shall set you free”, or from the many consequences received for lying, people were meant to be have honesty enforced their minds. There is no doubt truth actually is enforced in our minds, according to a study by expert of Developmental Science, Dr. Fu Genyue, Ph.D, “Children of all ages categorize lies as lies and truth as truth” (499). Research in the medical field shows that “deception is judged as justified in some contexts involving the prevention of harm” (Freeman 2274). Of course lying is not acceptable when speaking under oath or at confessions with a priest, but lying is definitely justifiable in certain situations were it can be used as a protection factor to protect the feelings, securities, and lives of others. We are all put into very awkward situations at some points of our lives where we may feel lying to spare one's feelings was the best option. One common situation is being asked, “Do I look fine in this outfit?”. If the person does look fine it is okay to say so, but it is when that person may not that we produce what is called a “white lie”. While many people may recognize the words “white lie”, there...

Words: 1652 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Cyber Bullying

...Studies indicate that cyber-bullying incidents have quadrupled in past five years (Ross). Cyber-bullying has become a huge issue recently. Every time you turn on the news there is another bullying, or a suicide related to bullying, incident being reported. “Love is louder” has been a common phrase among celebrities and influential figures lately. They are trying to send out a message to their followers saying that bullying is not right and should not be tolerated. The expansion of communication technologies is widening the way bully’s can torture their victims. The fact of the matter is, technology is not going anywhere, so we need to figure out a way to put an end to cyber-bullies. Cyber-bullying is becoming a major problem and we all need to do our parts in figuring out what can be done to stop cyber-bullies in their tracks. Cyber-bullies will continue to be a threat to today’s youth until we take preventative measures against them. Before putting a stop to cyber-bullying we must understand why and how a cyber-bully works. After researching and analyzing informative articles on the topic, this research paper aims to inform and answer questions such as: what a cyber-bully is, how they work, whom they target, and how to stop them. By understanding how a cyber-bully works we will be able to better protect youth populations as technology grows. Approximately half of  U.S. students are impacted by traditional bullying each school day (Ross). Cyber-bullying is technology powered and...

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Should Bullies Be Punished

...kids just being kids has now evolved into explosive tragedy in some cases. This horrendous act is such a widespread problem, that students are ready to go up against the government in order to get harsher punishment enforced in the school system. In a research article by Morais, C. (2012), two specific questions were asked that helped guide the course of study. First, were the actions of the teen warranted of a felony charge, because in the state of Massachusetts where this article is referenced from. The two crimes that the teens committed if they were tried as an adult would carry a maximum prison sentence of 10 years. So what age limit that an adolescent can no longer be tried in the juvenile court? Second, should the status of the victim weigh-in on the punishment? Case in-point, the victim ultimately committed suicide from the constant badgering and tormenting. The focus of this article case study was on the torture that 15-year-old Phoebe Prince was subjected to from her high school classmates. This young lady was stalked and harassed by fellow students for an excessive period of time. Feeling of isolation and withdrawal, she committed suicide. The students that were involved with her tormenting were initially arrested, and charged on two felonious counts of stalking and harassment which caused depraved indifference, resulting in the death of another human being. However, due to their age, the case was reassigned to the juvenile court, which subsequently believed that...

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Computer Ethics

...person’s view on computer ethics may differ from another person’s view, one basic idea should always be kept in mind when making ethical decisions, “Do unto others as you would have done to you.” If everyone obeyed this “golden rule” we would not have nearly as many issues with computer ethics. To better understand some of the computer ethics issues surrounding us today, I will explore the ethical issues dealing with software and social networking sites that have plagued the cyber world in recent years. Software Issues Ethical use of software is overlooked by many. Purchasing software does not mean that one owns the software and can use it anyway they want. You do not own the software. The only thing purchased in this case is a license to use the software. Upon using the purchased software, the purchaser accepts the terms and conditions that apply. By accepting the terms of the copyrighted material, one is agreeing not to use the software for anything other then the intended use and not to make and distribute copies to others who have not paid for the license. The only exception for making copies of software is for backup purposes. This type of exception is known as a “fair use” provision (Hames, 2010). Under this provision one can make a backup copy for their personal use only and cannot loan or give the disk to a friend or colleague (Hames, 2010). A lot of people view software as just computer programs, but software can also be CDs and DVDs. ...

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Bully

...even a political topic above the rest. When you see a classmate 5’2” and 131 lbs. be harassed for his appearance and be taunted for his lack of “vertical stature” it may seem like a common case of teasing. But when the actions become physical such as my classmate being stuffed into trashcans because he is “compact-able” what then would you describe it as? Did I have the proper tools to notifying someone or the education to know what I might be able to do to stop it from happening? There were no publicized programs and or institutes for help posted for students that were easily accessible. And the bullies just kept bullying with no repercussions. Is this something you would allow your child, friend, family member, or student to endure? Bullying has become a nation-wide issue that has many avenues that are in place for combating the problem, providing services for both the bullied and bullies and prevention and review committees to stop it before it happens, investigate and review the act(s). With programs, websites, and groups popping up all over the country there are people standing by the push and have started the dominos for all of the efforts to truly pay off for this epidemic. So what is this bullying epidemic all about. What are today’s students saying about bullying? Well in a recent study conducted by a bullying statistics website “there are about 2.7 million students being bullied each year by about 2.1 million students taking on the roll of the bully.” (Bullying Statistics)...

Words: 2152 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

It and More It

...Kim Kell Craig Boswell Bullying and Cyber Bullying November 29, 1983 Bullying is a very unfortunate situation that has been around for generations. The world may have not of had a term for it back in those days however making a individual or individuals feel as if they are not equal or less than them has always been an unfortunate situation humans have had to fight rough whether in school, at the park or over the internet. Bullying is around and is getting worse the more the Internet expands and links individuals through social networking. In history there has been billions of bullying situations, not all have been documented and broadcasted through the web and news. In 2010 Tyler Clementi killed himself after his roommate at Rutgers University filmed him kissing another man. Phoebe Prince a 15-year-old innocent young girl moved from Ireland and not even after living in the United States for a year killed herself because of bullying in a Massachusetts school. These are just a few of the innocent lives that were taken resulting from being bullied. The most unfortunate bullying results can be when multiple individuals gang up on one person. In Tampa Florida for over a year 15 girls ganged up on an innocent 12 year old named Rebecca Ann Sedwick. Not only did they physically abuse her bullies harassed her online sending her messages saying “why don’t you go kill yourself” and “You should die”. Soon after she could not take the cyber bullying any longer and changed her...

Words: 1638 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethic - Ritz Carlton Case

...identifiable, and sensitive information to many people rapidly. In this era of revelation—dominated by portable electronics, intemet social media, reality television, and traditional talk radio—^many of us are losing our sense of privacy, our taste for privacy, and our willingness to respect privacy. Is this set of losses a bad thing? If it is a bad thing, what can be done about it? My refiections on these questions begin with a series of diverse examples from the past several years. The examples illustrate the emergent ethos of our revelatory era. The first and second examples portray voluntary self-revelation for amusement and monetary gain; a third and fourth example depict revelations conceming others, motivated by a desire for amusement in one case and geopolitical justice in another. Former Congressman Anthony Weiner was a Democratic member of the United States House of Representatives elected by the people of New Anita L. Allen, J.D., Ph.D.,...

Words: 7837 - Pages: 32