Free Essay

University Health Services

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ninaswie79
Words 1270
Pages 6
1. With the help of process flow diagrams, compare the pre-triage and the post-triage systems in terms of total system time and total waiting times. Is the new system an improvement over the old?

2. Look at the patient arrival rates and compare them to the available MD and NP capacity. An hour-by-hour or day-by-day analysis will show some interesting patterns. Based on what you have learned about waiting lines and utilization, comment on the current assignment fitness between supply and demand?

| | | |Patients waiting |Patients waiting | | | | | | | |67% |33% |MD |NP |Availability | |Patients per hour treated | | | |Arrival |MD |NP |Beg of HR |Serviced |End of HR |Beg of HR |Serviced |End of HR |MD |NP |MD |NP | |8am - 9am |18.2 |12.194 |6.006 | - | 6.19 | 6.01 | - | 3.66 | 2.35 |2.0 |2 |3.0927835 |1.8292683 | |9am - 10am |17.6 |11.792 |5.808 | 6.01 | 7.73 | 10.07 | 2.35 | 7.32 | 0.84 |2.5 |4 | | | |10am - 11am |16.8 |11.256 |5.544 | 10.07 | 14.85 | 6.48 | 0.84 | 7.32 | (0.93) |4.8 |4 | | | |11am - 12 noon |15.2 |10.184 |5.016 | 6.48 | 9.90 | 6.77 | (0.93) | 7.32 | (3.24) |3.2 |4 | | | |12 noon - 1pm |11.8 |7.906 |3.894 | 6.77 | 8.04 | 6.63 | (3.24) | 4.57 | (3.91) |2.6 |2.5 | | | |1pm - 2pm |16.9 |11.323 |5.577 | 6.63 | 8.66 | 9.29 | (3.91) | 4.57 | (2.91) |2.8 |2.5 | | | |2pm - 3pm |16.2 |10.854 |5.346 | 9.29 | 10.52 | 9.63 | (2.91) | 7.32 | (4.88) |3.4 |4 | | | |3pm - 4pm |15.9 |10.653 |5.247 | 9.63 | 12.37 | 7.91 | (4.88) | 7.32 | (6.95) |4 |4 | | | |4pm - 5pm |11.6 |7.772 |3.828 | 7.91 | 8.35 | 7.34 | (6.95) | 4.57 | (7.70) |2.7 |2.5 | | | |5pm - 6pm |2.8 |1.876 |0.924 | 7.34 | 3.09 | 6.12 | (7.70) | 3.66 | (10.43) |1 |2 | | | |

An hour by hour analysis shows that there is an excess demand for MDs (positive numbers) and excess supply of NPs (negative numbers). Also, demand is not aligned with supply at the beginning of each day as arrival rates are highest between 8:00am – 10:00am yet the supply (MD’s on staff) is at the lowest for the day - at just 2 and 2.5. Currently, there is not a strong correlation between supply and demand as proper staffing levels are not assigned to accommodate demand needs on an hour by hour basis. Demand clearly calls for highest staffing levels at the beginning of the day and then right after the lunch hour whereas the availability of MDs and NPs is all over the board throughout the day. Also, NPs are underutilized as there are no patients waiting after 11:00am while MDs are a bottleneck as they have too many patients waiting for them throughout the day. In addition, day of the week needs to play a factor in staffing levels as the first half of the week is clearly busier than the second.

3. A desired outcome of the new triage system is to off-load work from MDs onto NPs. How cost-effective is this strategy, considering the different service rates of MDs and NPs? (Use salary data given in case. Make necessary assumptions.)

This strategy is cost effective given the hourly rates of NPs compared to those of MDs. However, the current process does not effectively leverage that as they are not off-loading enough patients to NPs given the wait times for MDs. Essentially, they need to find a way to move more patients to the NP queue. One way to do this would be by expanding upon the 13 categories currently deemed treatable by an NP. Also, they need to make sure the triage nurses are assigning patients to NPs (if eligible) vs. NP or MD in order to free up MD’s queue.

4. Assuming 5 MDs on duty at an average (each with a service rate of 3.1 patients per hour) and that all patients (143 per day) see an MD, calculate the effect of a 4% increase in the arrival rate on the expected wait time in queue: Wq (use Queuing Formulas, assume uniform arrival across 10 working hours per day, note that it’s a multiple server system drawing from a single line – M/M/S). Comment on this effect.

5. If you were a healthcare administrator such as Ms. Angel, how would your staffing decisions be different if your customers were college students versus business executives? Justify your answer.

If our customers were college students versus business executives our staffing decisions would differ in that we would operate under the assumption that college students are typically more tolerant of longer wait times as their schedules are more flexible than those of executives. Also, college students may not be as concerned about the quality and personal care received by a specific MD (who is familiar with their medical history) as executives might be. That said, we would operate more cost effectively by keeping our MD levels to a minimum and routing all eligible visits through NPs. In addition, we would not allow walk-in requests to see a specific MD as college audience would not find as much value in this as an executive might. Lastly, if you are a college student, you will likely use the most convenient walk-in clinic to you – the one right on the campus (even if they have longer wait times) while executives have many more options. So, there will be many more competing clinics that executives could go to in order to wait less and get better and personal care from an MD of their choice.

6. Why are "walk-in appointments" a problem if the students asking for specific providers are willing to wait longer? What should Ms. Angell do about them, if anything?

Ms. Angell could either increase the cost of a visit to a specific MD (to discourage this practice) or eliminate this option altogether in order to free up more MDs and reduce wait times for other patients which would increase customer satisfaction for majority of patients at the cost of potentially losing the 24.5% who do request seeing a specific MD.

7. What other actions, if any, would you recommend to Ms. Angell? Try to classify your actions in three categories: (1) managing capacity, (2) managing demand, and (3) managing the waiting experience.

a) Capacity: Proper staffing levels – assigned according to arrival rates each day of the week and each hour of the day. This should optimize capacity and reduce waiting times.

b) Demand: Control demand by assigning certain day of the week or time of the day when walk-in requests for a specific MD would be honored. Or, assign walk-in request times to each MDs daily schedule – limiting it to only 1-2 hours per day. Offer special discounts or advertise low waiting times to patients with non-emergency visits during Thursdays and Fridays or towards and of each day when there is most capacity.

c) Waiting: This can be improved by controlling the demand as suggested above. Also, triage nurses need to control the number of patients they put in the MD queue by always placing them in the NP queue if their diagnosis falls under one those that can be treated by an NP.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

University Health Services

...University Health Services: Walk-In Clinic Pre-triage organization Organization: - 12 treatment rooms: 4 for nurses and 8 for doctors where 3 of these were permanently assigned to physicians as their UHS offices - Average of 143 patients a day the clinic was staffed on the basis of past experience with peak periods. Complaints: - Too long waiting time between sign-in and treatment - Length of wait not related to nature of visit - Inconsistency and too much variation in treatment between the different nurses - Duplicated efforts for patients who were seen by a nurse and a doctor Consequence: patients avoid visiting the Walk-In Clinic The triage system Differences with before: - Patients fill in an identification form which includes the reason for the visit - 2 triage coordinators briefly visit the patient and then conclude if the patient is more urgent than others: patients were only triaged to a nurse practitioner if their ailments fell under one of 13 categories. System didn’t work as well as they expected reasons? - Triage coordinators classified patients as MD/NP to maintain the flow - For one-third of the physicians more than 40% of their clinic patients requested them - Two of the five doctors are 100% occupied with walk-in appointments - Patient expects an atmosphere reminiscent of the country doctor’s office Angell’s dilemma: How can she improve the system? How to reduce waiting times and reduce complaints?...

Words: 360 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

University Health Services: Walk-in Clinic

...University Health Services: Walk-In Clinic Pre-triage organization Organization: - 12 treatment rooms: 4 for nurses and 8 for doctors where 3 of these doctors were permanently assigned to physicians as their UHS offices - Average of 143 patients a day the clinic was staffed on the basis of past experience with peak periods. - Every patient has to go to a nurse first before seeing physician Complaints: - Too long waiting time between sign-in and treatment - Length of the wait not related to nature of visit - Inconsistency and too much variation in treatment between the different nurses - Duplicated efforts for patients who were seen by a nurse and a doctor Consequence: patients avoid visiting the Walk-In Clinic The triage system Differences with before: - Patients fill in an identification form, which includes the reason for the visit - 2 triage coordinators briefly visit the patient and then conclude if the patient is more urgent than others: patients were only triaged to a nurse practitioner if their ailments fell under one of 13 categories. System didn’t work as well as they expected reasons? - Triage coordinators classified patients as MD/NP to maintain the flow - For one-third of the physicians more than 40% of their clinic patients requested them - Two of the five doctors are 100% occupied with walk-in appointments - Patients expect an atmosphere reminiscent of the country doctor’s office Angell’s dilemma: How can she improve the system?...

Words: 384 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

University Health Services Case Study

...The main problem was a lack of coordination in service delivery. This lack of coordination caused excessive wait times on the order of anywhere from 23 to 40 minutes to see a nurse, 40 to 50 minutes to see a doctor, and as long as 55 minutes to get a prescription filled. The practice of all nurses being involved initially in seeing all patients caused duplication of efforts, including repeated questions and examinations, and resulted in procedural bottlenecks. Additionally, there were inconsistent levels of service and extreme variation in treatment because of the different experience and skill levels of the nurses. Overall, the view by patients was that the clinic was inefficient and impersonal. The triage system was introduced in September 1979 to overcome these problems. One of the immediate changes was to establish a preliminary evaluation and referral system which dedicated two triage coordinators, which are highly experienced nurses, to evaluate the patients and assign them to the next appropriate step in the treatment process. Unfortunately this process did not result in greater procedural efficiency. Wait time for a patient to see a triage coordinator was about 20 minutes, with an additional 38 minute wait to see the nurse or physician. In fact, according to Exhibit 5, the wait time to see physician actually increased from 10 minutes to 25.2 minutes. The wait time for those seeing a specific provider increased from 24.5 minutes to 33.8 minutes....

Words: 748 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Name of School

...Related Programs, and Social Sciences Quinnipiac University Health Professions and Related Programs, Business, Management, Marketing, and Related Support Services, Communication, Journalism, and Related Programs, Psychology, and Social Sciences University of South Florida Finance, Criminology, Biomedical Sciences, Psychology, and Elementary Education and Teaching Full Sail University none...

Words: 544 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Group Cno

...| | |Previous Post | | |Assistant Professor - Nursing Service...

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Dasd

...Guidance on writing Job Descriptions & Person Specifications These notes are designed to assist you when completing the Job Description & Person Specification templates. Before you start The job description and person specification should be completed by someone who has a good knowledge and understanding of the role and is able to identify the appropriate criteria to select the best candidate. If it‟s helpful, your HR Advisor can work with you to ensure all the key areas are captured. Tips to help you create a good Job Description & Person Specification o Create a Business Case This is essential when creating a new role or changing an existing role as it is needed as part of the Vacancy Control Procedure, and allows you to focus on what you want the role to actually achieve. o Don‟t focus on grade at this stage This is likely to detract from thorough consideration of the actual job. o Create a Structure Chart This shows where the job sits in the team and how it relates to other roles, clearly showing reporting relationships etc. Again try not to focus on grades. This is also an essential part of the Vacancy Control Procedure. o Write in plain English Use clear and plain English and think carefully about how you describe the job. Formatting & Layout (See Example Later) The design and layout of the Job Description & Person Specification template has been specifically set and agreed. Therefore sections, boxes and key headings should not be removed or added. The font...

Words: 3763 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Uhs Case

...Improving Access to University Health Services A Case Study ► Process Improved: The system for triage and making appointments for students utilizing University Health Services ► Unit (s): Student Affairs – University Health Services ► Customers of the Process and Their Needs: UW-Madison students were the users of the process, although the problem impacted R.N. and Program Assistants (PAs) staffing University Health Services ► Problem/Opportunity Statement: Students were dissatisfied with access to medical services at UHS. Specific complaints included prolonged waiting times on hold or getting the “busy signal” when calling UHS. The limited capacity of the system for incoming calls meant that people waited a long time or were disconnected. All medical/illness-related questions were referred to one nurse. (When the nurse was on the telephone with a caller, messages were taken from ill students or those seeking same-day appointments. The messages stacked up and often, by the time the nurse was available to call the patient back, the patient would not be available. Many opportunities for contact were missed. Getting an appointment was very much a matter of luck.) The long waits for the nurse meant that students were “triaged” by PAs who were non-medical personnel. More students came in for care without appointments. (“I couldn’t get through on the phone, so I came in.”)...

Words: 901 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Course Sylabus

...|[pic] |Syllabus | | |College of Natural Sciences | | |HCS/490 Version 2 | | |Health Care Consumer: Trends and Marketing | Copyright © 2010, 2007 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description In this course, students will have the opportunity to examine the traits, trends, and needs of today's health care consumer. Students will examine current consumer information for readability, implications for the selection of products and services, and differentiation of health care web sources. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: • University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. • Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class....

Words: 2200 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Business Continuity Plan

...Business Continuity Plan Under Development (May 2006) California State University, Stanislaus CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, STANISLAUS BUSINESS CONTINUITY PLAN May 2006 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION I. II. III. IV. V. Incident Command System Business Impact Analysis Risk Assessment Business Plan for Localized Business Disruption Business Plan for Pandemics Page 3 Pages 4-7 Pages 8-11 Pages 12-13 Pages 14-15 Pages 16-17 Pages 18-19 Pages 20-36 Appendix IV-A: Power Outage Business Continuity Plan Appendix V-A: Pandemic Flu Business Continuity Plan 2 Final CP 5-30-06 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, STANISLAUS BUSINESS CONTINUITY PLAN May 2006 INTRODUCTION A Business Continuity Plan (BCP) is developed by an institution to plan for and describe how it will respond to and recover from disruptions. These disruptions can be localized threats (e.g., earthquakes, fires, floods, bombs, etc.) or global threats (e.g., Flu Pandemic). As part of the overall Emergency Operations Plan, California State University, Stanislaus has developed, and continues to refine and enhance, a Business Continuity Plan (BCP) for the University. This plan is about maintaining, resuming, and recovering the University’s activities as an educational institution. It considers human factors along with operational issues....

Words: 10523 - Pages: 43

Premium Essay

Collaboration to Build Healthier Communities

...Rausch, M.P . .P Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Minneapolis, Minnesota With support from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation June 2013 Creating Healthy Communities Cross-sector partnerships are sparking widespread action to improve community health COATESVILLE , PA SEATTLE, WA Access to healthy foods Access to preventative care and healthy housing LOS ANGELES , CA Quality early child care and education CHICAGO, IL Data and evidence to build health into all policies and practices MIAMI , FL Opportunities for physical activity and healthy living health community development • community development finance • community planning • early child care/education • human services • housing Introduction “ Building a healthier America is feasible in years, not decades, if we collaborate and act on what is making a difference.” —Robert Wood Johnson Foundation In 2008, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation convened a commission of nonpartisan leaders to identify opportunities to improve the health of all Americans by creating environments that protect and actively promote health. Their report, Beyond Health Care: New Directions to a Healthier America, included 10 recommendations for improving the health of our communities, several of which focused specifically on the health of children....

Words: 10523 - Pages: 43

Premium Essay

Operations

...Specialized MBA Programs General MBA Programs Accounting Programs Finance Programs Health Care Management Programs Human Resource Programs Marketing Programs Project Management Programs Public Administration Programs Operations Management Programs Technology Management Programs Operations MBA Programs Le arn wha t typica l sala rie s a re for O pe ra tions Ma na gem e nt ca re ers a cross the state s. Typical Career Salaries for MBA graduates With a Global marketplace increasing levels of competition, organizations need to be fiercely efficient and effective in their efforts to gain their share of profits. Operations Manager career prospects appear relatively bright. How ever, growth for this occupation should only mimic growth in the careers the Operations Managers oversee. Operations Manager salaries are going to be seeing the greatest rise. Along with competition in other industries comes a need for the most competent and highly trained. A valuable Operations Manager is current with technological advancement as well as skilled in the area of creating successful business strategies w hen it comes to quality management and continuous improvement of operations. Based on other industrys' benchmark strategies and sound business theory, the Operations Manager is expected to be able to cometently design a company's production and service operations. Companies that employ the most motivated and knowledgable individuals to run their operations w ill experience the...

Words: 1341 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Good Marketing Strategies in South Africa Dept of Health

...GOOD MARKETING STRATEGIES CONTENTS 1. Introduction …………………….……..……….………………………………..…….3 2. Relationship Marketing…………………………………..………………………..….3-4 2.1 The Extent to Which It Is Practise.……………..………………………..….4 -5 2.2 Appropriateness of Relationship Marketing …………………………….….5-7 3. Customer Satisfaction …………………………………..………………………..….7 3.1 Measuring Patient Satisfaction…………………………………………....…..8 3.1.1 Patient Satisfaction Measures…………………………………………...…..8-9 3.2 Managing Patient Satisfaction………………………………………….……..9-10 4. Communications Mix…………………………………………………………………...9 4.1 Informative Promotion …..…………………………………………….….….10 4.2 The Communications Mix…………………………………………….…..….10-11 4.3 Successes……………………………………………………………………..11-12 5. Advertising………………………………………………………………………..…..13 5.1 Social-Cause Advertising……………………………………………….....…14 5.2 The Message ………………………………………………………………….14 5.3 The Medium……………………………………………………………….…14-15 5.4 Measuring Advertising Effectiveness…………………………………….….15 6. Conclusion………………………..……………………………………………………..17 7. Recommendation………………..………………………………………………………17 8. References……………………………………………………………………………….18 1. INTRODUCTION Every organisation has various strategies to market their organisation. For an organisation to be successful, they have to develop a marketing strategy. In my report I will analyse four marketing strategies in relation to my......

Words: 4094 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Enhancing Customer Service

...The two health care organizations that I will use for a comparative analysis are St. Peter’s University Hospital and Robert Wood Johnson University; the reasoning behind my choice of hospitals are they’re presumably on two different ends of the spectrum in terms of customer service being their missions, visions and...

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Public Health

...Moreover, North South University is having academic collaboration with leading North American Universities and International organizations and offers the Master of Public Health (MPH) which is completely parallel program to the best Universities of the world. As a leading private university in Bangladesh, the Department of Public Health in North South University is dedicated to ensure quality education in...

Words: 3215 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Eng 221

...OLS Services As a member of University of Phoenix there are many options and services that are offered. These services can range from requesting waivers, life resources, and finding testing centers. In order to get to the services page within the Universities portal a student needs to login to their account, select the program tab at the top of the page. This is where you will be able to find the services heading as the section option. Within the services tab you will find: (a) Student Workshops (b) GPA Calculator (c) Order Transcripts (d) Commencement (e) Office of Dispute Management (f) University of Phoenix iGrad (g) Letter Center (h) Course Waiver Request (i) University Disability Services (j) SASWeb- Doctoral Dissertation (k) Request FERPA Release (l) Life Resource Center (m) Health Insurance Election Form (1) Credit Assessment Services (i) Prior Learning Assessment Center (a) Who is eligible to submit to Prior Learning Assessment?...

Words: 514 - Pages: 3