Free Essay

Unskilled and Unaware

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By gtrain2560
Words 1883
Pages 8
1

Activity Assignment: Unskilled and Unaware of It
John Smith, Michael Anderson, Joshua Jones, Tamika Brumfeld, Ronnie Evans
Barksdale College

Abstract
Self-esteem is an individual's estimate of one's own self worth, the extent of individual views of good, competence, and decent. Within this activity paper we will discuss why self esteem is important, and why there are discrepancies between the actual self and the ideal self. This paper will discuss the theory of cognitive dissonance in regards to the self-evaluation theory, self-affirmation theory and the realization trap while defining the self-discrepancy theory. The need for high individual self-esteem may lead to irrational logic and individual actions against their own best interest as will be theoretically supported throughout this paper. Concluding that our teams position, will support the theory that individual competence may be inaccurate at times to maintain individual self-esteem.
Self-esteem is defined as an individual’s estimate of his or hers own self-worth and the extent of individual views of what is good competent and decent. This activity paper will discuss the importance of self-esteem and explore any discrepancies between the actual self and the ideal self. The theory of cognitive dissonance as it relates to the self-evaluation theory, self-affirmation theory and the realization trap will be covered while also defining the self-discrepancy theory. This paper will theoretically support the concept of the need for high individual self-esteem and how it may lead to irrational logic and individual actions that work against a person’s own best interest. It will conclude with the team position that individual competence may be inaccurate at times to maintain individual self-esteem.

Individuals are motivated to maintain a sense of consistency among their beliefs and perceptions about themselves. When there is a discrepancy between the actual self and the ideal self, an individual experience distress. As human beings we have a need for positive self-esteem; to feel good about ourselves, Can this need be so strong that it overpowers our logic and lead us to act in ways that are not to our own benefits? Individuals are motivated to maintain a sense of consistency among their beliefs and perceptions about themselves. Carl Rogers surmised there are three sides to the “self”. They are the actual self (how we really are), the ideal self (how we wish we were) and the perceived self (how we see and feel about ourselves). When there is a discrepancy between the actual self and the ideal self, an individual will experience distress. As human beings we have a need to be rid of this distress and to have a positive self-esteem; to feel good about ourselves or to perceive ourselves in a positive manner. Can this need for a positive self-perception be so strong that it overpowers our logical thought processes and lead us to act in ways that are not to our own benefit? "Unskilled and Unaware of it." The focus of this article is the following: “We argue that when people are incompetent in the strategies they adopt to achieve success and satisfaction, they suffer a dual burden: Not only do they reach erroneous conclusions and make unfortunate choices, but their incompetence robs them of the ability to realize it” (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p. 2). In other words, when people are assessing themselves as to their abilities do below average people have the knowledge and ability to realize that they are not competent? Another focus of these studies is if competent individuals would also overestimate their abilities or would their competency give them the knowledge to realize what their abilities are? The researchers made four predictions about the relationships between an individual’s ability to perform in certain situations, their self-knowledge about those abilities and whether or not the individuals overestimated their abilities to perform these tasks. From studying previous research and the conclusions of others, the researchers were able to produce the four predictions discussed in the article. From these predictions, the researchers acted upon these predictions by conducting four studies to test the veracity of the experiments. The four studies completed were done to test the veracity of the four predictions made by the researchers. These studies dealt with the areas of humor, logical reasoning, grammar and how competence leads to calibration. The first study dealt with humor in which, “Incompetent individuals grossly overestimated their ability relative to their peers”, while the “top scoring participants underestimated their ability relative to their peers”, (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p. 5). The second study conducted involved logical reasoning and the results were much the same as the first. When asked about the number of questions the participants had gotten correct, once again the bottom scoring individuals overestimated the amount of correct answers as compared to their actual scores. Study three was conducted using grammar as the domain. Kruger and Dunning reported participants overrating their abilities and functioning as compared to unbiased benchmarks just as they had done in the first two studies (1999, p.8)
A second phase of this part of the study was to gauge if participants could be able to look at the action of others and learn about their own shortcomings in the same actions. The results concluded that bottom scoring individuals “failed to gain insight into their own performance after seeing the more competent choices of their peers and if anything they tended to raise their ability inflated self-estimates, although not to a significant degree” (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p.10). In study 4 a short training session was given to half the participants in order to asses if training would give those who were incapable with the metacognitive skills required to comprehend that they had not done a good job and hence assist them in realizing the restrictions of their abilities. The results were that the individuals who did receive training were more accurate in assessing themselves (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p. 13). So how does this relate to the questions of if the need for individuals to maintain a sense of consistency among their beliefs and perceptions regarding themselves can be so strong that it overpowers our logic and leads us to act in ways that are not to our benefits? According to the study incompetent individuals most often do not even realize the level of their own incompetency while competent people often underestimate theirs. “In a phrase, Thomas Gray was right, Ignorance is bliss, at least when it comes to assessment of one’s own ability”, (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p. 15). If ignorance to one’s abilities causes an individual to try and achieve something they are not capable of, then it may lead to unbeneficial behavior in order to less one’s own cognitive dissonance. But according to the study most incompetent people do not even realize that they perform below average and not only that “they reach mistaken conclusions and make regrettable errors, but their incompetence robs them of the ability to realize it” (Kruger, Dunning, 1999, p. 18). If incompetent people are not capable of logic then their need to maintain a consistency in their beliefs about themselves cannot be over powered by it. This does lead to acts that are not beneficial for the individual. A theory of cognitive Dissonance defined as “a drive or feeling of discomfort originally defined as being caused by holding two or more inconsistent cognitions and subsequently defined as being caused by performing an action that is discrepant from one’s customary, typically positive self-conception.(Akert, Aronson, and Wilson)” – When using the cognitive dissonance theory displaced logic may be used to make sense of why we did not perform to what we set as our standards. We use creative justifications such as excuses, it was harder than I thought, or denial, I really did know the answers they used sketchy wording, as to why we failed to meet expectations that we originally set forth. Self-Evaluation Maintenance Theory defined as “research on self-evaluation dynamics has taken several forms. A self-evaluation maintenance (SEM) model of social behavior focuses on the consequences of another person’s outstanding performance on one’s own self-evaluation. It sketches out some conditions under which the other’s good performance bolsters self-evaluation, i.e., "basking in reflected glory", and conditions under which it threatens self-evaluation through a comparison process.(Plous)”—
When the need to boost self-esteem is evident, one aspect of the SEM theory comes to mind is, the process of reflection which is the use of a friends’ accomplishments to raise or maintain the level of self-esteem desired.
Self-affirmation theory defined is a way of reducing dissonance by reminding oneself of one or more of one’s positive attributes. When the need for positive self-esteem is so great in a person logical thinking and behavior is almost always left out of actions. When this theory is in use the person could and usually does flat out deny the negativity in the action by alleviating it with a positive attribute, or justifying the action as not being as negative as portrayed. Rationalization Trap is defined as “when we act to reduce dissonance it can end up as a whole set of justifications and rationalizations that lead to ridiculous or even immoral actions.("Changing Minds.org")”
The need for a positive self-esteem could become so great that in the act of desperation that someone would act in an embarrassing or offensive manner that it would require them to be deceptive in their explanations of their behavior Self-Discrepancy Theory is “The greater the magnitude and accessibility of a particular type of self-discrepancy possessed by an individual, the more the individual will suffer the kind of discomfort associated with that type of self-discrepancy.(Higgins 1987)”
In the Activity Discussion Statement, if the SDT does not make changes to its ideal-self to come more to what it’s actual-self is then self-esteem would suffer. With that then dejection related emotions such as disappointment and sadness would be triggered, these could lead to serious depression. This paper has supported the theory that self esteem is defined as an individual's estimate of self-worth with regards to good, competence and decent. The supporting theories within this paper confirm that individual self-esteem may be distorted at times and may also be subjective to discrepancies involving conflicting ideas known as cognitive dissonance. Using various theories stated within, may bring forth individual understanding of how misconceptions happen and a better way of avoiding them. Concluding our teams position that because of the need for high individual self-esteem, individual actual self and ideal self may be inaccurately portrayed.

References
Abraham Tesser& Janet Moore (1990): Independent Threatsand Self-Evaluation Maintenance Processes, The Journal of Social Psychology, 130:5,677-689
Akert, Robin M, Elliot Aronson, and Timothy Wilson. Social Psychology. 8. New York: Pearson, 2013. Print.
Plous, Scott. "Abraham Tesser." Social Psychology Network.Wesleyan University, 02 11 2013. Web. Feb 2013.
"Rationalization Trap." Changing Minds.org. Changing Minds, n.d. Web. Feb 2013.
"Self-Discrepancy Theory." Psychwiki.com. Mediawiki, 06 29 2010.Web. Feb 2013.
Kruger, J., & Dunning, D. (1999). Unskilled and Unaware of It: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(6), 1121-1134. Web.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Self-Esteem

...have done was the right thing to do in the moment (2010). For example, a female student chooses to take a job stripping in a night club after spending three months looking for a job. She struggles with this decision mentally because she was raised in a strict, religious household. Her up-bringing and the need to pay tuition become two points that challenge her positive self-esteem. The female student will make concessions to her beliefs to keep her self-esteem high saying things like “this is my only choice so I can pay for college” or “this is not going to be a forever job”. In evaluating the article, “Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One’s Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments” written by Kruger and Dunning (1999), the theory of cognitive dissonance comes into play. First, the authors cannot title their paper as “unskilled” for that means useless. If an individual feels they are useless then that leads to the imbalance of the self-esteem which puts into motion the theory of cognitive dissonance. It is in the security of a person’s mental state and well-being to have a high self-worth. If the person was unable to do this, it could lead to depression, anorexia or other health issues related to low self-worth. Second, early on children’s lives, most parents and teachers, promote a healthy self-esteem by supporting achievements or lack of, with great grades and positive reinforcement or rewards. Every child gets an award or......

Words: 2112 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Greenfield Projects in India

...people (PAP) is an obligation. Irrespective of the qualification & educational background, industry needs to employ plant affected people which consists mainly raw hands. Being new to the industry and its requirement, they invariably lack industrial safety and behavioural safety as well. ITPC has experienced 3 fatal accidents and 32 Lost Time Incidents (LTI) which back laid the organization and the plant was required to shut for almost a period of 24 days in totality. Operating a plant with Safety is of paramount priority and with this vision inculcation of safety culture among workmen coming from PAP (Project Affected People) in a Greenfield project is a big challenge. In Indian Thermal Power Company (ITPC), hundreds of unskilled, semi-skilled & unskilled people were engaged. 98% of them are from rural background. Some of them were first generation learner. They have never seen industrial work culture. Operating plant with such raw hands was challenge for ITPC. ITPC top management was in dilemma that to improve the safety work culture where majority of the work force is not even familiar with the ABC of safety. Background: ITPC is renowned power generating public limited company and started a new power plant in Chhattisgarh state. Being a green field project in the remote location, getting skilled man-power is one of the biggest challenges. As a part of inclusive growth approach, employing plant affected people (PAP) is an obligation. Irrespective of the......

Words: 776 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Describe and Discuss Research Into Social Facilitation (10 Marks)

...arousal only increases with performance until an optimum point, where it will then decline; this is called the ‘inverted U hypothesis’. This theory states that a well skilled player needs a lot of arousal to get started in the first place, where as too much arousal for an unskilled player leads to a quicker optimum point, where it will then decline (due to too much arousal). A study by Michaels et al is evidence to this theory. The aim was to see if the presence of an audience would facilitate well-learned behaviours and inhibit poorly learned ones. Students were observed playing pool, and 6 above average and 6 below average students were chosen. Next, 4 passive observers stood and watched their pool game. The above average players’ accuracy increased by 11%, however the below average players’ accuracy decreased by 9%. This supports Zajonc’s dominant response theory, as the dominant response of the skilled pool players is to improve in the presence of an audience, whereas the dominant response of the unskilled players is to do worse. To evaluate this study, it has many positives as the behaviour was studied in its natural setting, increasing ecological validity. Additionally, the participants were unaware of their participation in a study, meaning reduced demand characteristics. However this leads to ethical concerns of invasion of privacy and lack of informed consent. Additionally, this theory does not acknowledge the role of cognitive processes. For example, some......

Words: 1046 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Right to Abortion

...With the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act coming into effect in 1972, India conveyed a strong message that it cared for the health of pregnant women who wanted to safely terminate their pregnancies. Yet, even four decades later, many women are still unaware that abortion is legal. Even access to safe abortion centres is severely restricted, especially in rural areas. As a result, there is a great mismatch between the number of abortion seekers and MTP-certified providers and centres. According to a 2008 study in Contraception journal, nearly three-quarters of abortion-certified facilities are in the private sector. Add to this the stigma and discrimination that women seeking abortion face, and it is not surprising that a large number of women still turn to unskilled providers to perform abortions using unsafe methods in unsuitable settings. In 2010-11, over six lakh abortions took place in government-approved institutions. The number of unsafe abortions taking place every year is not known. According to a 2008 WHO report, about “two thirds of all abortions” that take place in the country are outside authorised health facilities. As a result, abortions cause an estimated eight per cent of maternal deaths in India — a majority of which are due to unsafe procedures — according to the Registrar General of India’s data. To complicate the situation further, the Pre-natal Diagnostic Techniques (Regulation and Prevention of Misuse) Act, 1994 meant to prevent sex......

Words: 453 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Condition of Consruction Workers in India

...CONDITION OF CONSRUCTION WORKERS IN INDIA The construction industry in India consists of migrant, unskilled men, women and children. The conditions of the workers have many factors pushing it towards a very wretched condition. A few of the main factors are listed below 1. Weak Legislative policies and non enforcement of current policy’s 2. Knowledge and literacy among workers 3. Globalization of the construction industry India 4. Frequency of change in government officials 5. Wages Weak legislative policies The current structures of the construction consist of the landowners, the builders, contractors (building, labor, etc). The landowners lease or have a contract with the landowners to construct a structure on the land, the builders further subcontract different parts of the construction to contactors and the labor for different subsections are given to labor contractors to procure the required labor force. The current labor laws exempts the principal (landowners and the builders) from any liability for wages, living conditions, safety of the labor force. The involvement of unions and human right organizations for the rights of the laborers is nonexistent and so there is no one to enforce the current minimal regulations of safety and living conditions. The workers, due to the migrant nature are completely unaware of their rights since it changes from state to state and this helps the contractors exploit the monetary need of the workers. There are no unions or......

Words: 1244 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

When to Apply Rational Choice Theory

...When to Apply Rational Choice Theory A widely used model to study human behavior, called Rational Choice Theory, helps to simplify social phenomena by assuming these properties: utility maximization, consistency, expected value, individuals as relevant agents, homogeneity, and equilibrium. Almost all social scientists, especially economists, use this model to predict human behavior, and sometimes their results may contradict the actual phenomenon; in other words, they were unaware that their experiments failed to meet one or more of the Rational Choice Theory assumptions. For example, in situations like enlisting in the military and eventually going to war, where individuals fail to maximize utility and contradicts the assumptions of the Rational Choice Theory, applying the theory would be nonsensical. However, when dealing with situations in which individuals behave rationally like sex workers in the prostitution industry, whereby all Rational Choice Theory assumptions are met, the theory explains phenomena exceptionally well. The example of soldiers going into battle clearly contradicts the assumptions necessary for the Rational Choice Theory to hold. By definition, a rational human being would choose the option that gives him the highest level of utility. In deciding to join the military and fight in war, the costs of making this decision heavily outweighs the benefits. Comparatively, this problem resembles the “Voter’s Paradox” in which Anthony Downs explained using a...

Words: 754 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Organisational Behavior

...well-established local construction companies and from foreign companies entering the market but also from unskilled individuals who offer poor workmanship in exchange for very low prices. One advantage Sandstone Construction has is that they seek to source material at competitive prices and so provide reasonable rates to their customers. Additionally, their good name has benefitted them in a line of credit offered by a major hardware which allows them to continue working whilst waiting for banks to release bridging loan lending. DISCUSSION 2.0 The management style at Sandstone Construction Ltd was a mixture of both Democratic and Laissez-Faire which led to some projects being delayed and to cost overruns as the manager was not always on site to supervise and direct employees. The management of Sandstone Construction also encouraged ideas and opinions from the employees because they needed to give the employees a sense of being part of the decision making process and by extension being a valued member of the company. This however backfired because of the fact that most of the employees were accustomed to a more Autocratic leadership style and were in many ways not ready to accept such a shift in management style that gave them some say in how the company operated. Some employees viewed this as weakness on the management’s part and believed that the management was unaware of what is to be done. The management however was highly trained in the field of construction and most of......

Words: 889 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Human Lies

...tasks. Core Time is in a flextime plan. It is the period when all employees are expected to be at their job stations. 3. An example of a craft union is the cordwainers or shoemakers that were established in Philadelphia. They were one of the first formal labor organizations in the United States. A craft union is an organization of skilled specialist in a particular trade. The Knights of Labor was the first national labor force formed in 1869. The American federation of Labor is an organization of craft unions that championed fundamental labor issues, founded in 1886, led by Samuel Gompers. United Mine Workers are an industrial union, which are labor organizations of unskilled and semiskilled workers in mass-production industries. Congress of Industrial Organizations is a union organization of unskilled workers. The broke away from the AFL in 1935 and rejoined it in 1955. 4. A union is an employee organization whose main goal is representing its members in employee-management negotiation of job-related issues. The Norris-LaGuardia Act is one major legislation that affects labor unions. This legislation prohibited employers from using contracts that forbid union activities such as a yellow dog contract. A yellow dog contract required employees to agree as a condition of employment not to join a union. Another major legislation affecting labor unions is The Wagner Act, which expanded labor’s right to collectively bargain by obligating employers to meet at reasonable......

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Extension of Downing Effect on Estimating Population Mean

... References 1. Hoorens, Vera (1993). "Self-enhancement and Superiority Biases in Social Comparison". European Review of Social Psychology (Psychology Press) 4 (1): 113–139.doi:10.1080/14792779343000040. 2. Dunning, David; Judith A. Meyerowitz, Amy D. Holzberg (1989). "Ambiguity and self-evaluation: The role of idiosyncratic trait definitions in self-serving assessments of ability". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (American Psychological Association) 57 (6): 1082–1090. doi:10.1037/0022- 3514.57.6.1082. 3. Kruger, Justin; David Dunning (1999). "Unskilled and Unaware of It: How Difficulties in Recognizing One's Own Incompetence Lead to Inflated Self-Assessments". Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 77 (6): 1121–34.doi:10.1037/0022-3514.77.6.1121. 4. Katherine A. Burson; Richard P. Larrick; Joshua Klayman; YUTAO (2006). "Skilled or Unskilled, but Still Unaware of It: How Perceptions of Difficulty Drive Miscalibration in Relative Comparisons".Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90 (1): 60–77.doi:10.1037/00223514.90.1.60 5. Morris, Errol (20 June 2010). "The Anosognosic's Dilemma: Something's Wrong but You'll Never Know What It Is (Part 1)". New York Times. Retrieved 7 March 2011. 6. Grubbs 1969, p. 1 stating "An outlying observation may be merely an extreme manifestation of the random variability inherent in the data. ... On the other hand, an outlying observation may be the result of gross deviation from......

Words: 3269 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Benevolent Assimilation

...is the heritage of free peoples, and by proving to them that the mission of the United States is one of benevolent assimilation substituting the mild sway of justice and right for arbitrary rule.[1] The proclamation was sent to General Elwell Otis, U.S. military commander and Governor-General in the Philippines. Otis sent Emilio Aguinaldo a version of the proclamation that he had bowdlerized by removing mention of U.S. sovereignty "to stress our benevolent purpose" and not "offend Filipino sensibilities," by substituting "free people" for "supremacy of the United States," and deleting "to exercise future domination."[2][3][4] General Otis had also sent an unaltered copy of the proclamation to General Marcus Miller in Iloilo City who, unaware that an altered version had been sent to Aguinaldo, passed a copy to a Filipino official there. The unaltered version eventually made its way to Aguinaldo. Otis later explained, After fully considering the President's proclamation, and the temper of the Taglos, with whom I was daily discussing political problems and the friendly intentions of the U.S.A. Government toward them, I concluded that there were certain words and expressions therein such as "sovereignty," "right of cessation" and those which directed immediate occupation and so forth, which though most admirably employed and tersely expressive of actual conditions, might be advantageously used by the Tagalog. The ignorant classes had been taught to believe that certain......

Words: 1558 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The Perils of Obedience

...monstrous acts. Following the Second World War - and in particular the Holocaust - psychologists set out to investigate the phenomenon of human obedience. Early attempts to explain the Holocaust had focused on the idea that there was something distinctive about German culture that had allowed the Holocaust to take place. Stanley Milgram set out to test the research question 'are Germans different?' at Yale University just one year after the trial of Adolf Eichmann. He conducted an experiment focusing on the conflict between obedience to authority and personal conscience. Volunteers were recruited for a lab experiment investigating “learning” (re: ethics: deception). Participants were 40 males, aged between 20 and 50, whose jobs ranged from unskilled to professional. At the beginning of the experiment they were introduced to another participant, who was actually a confederate of the experimenter (Milgram). They drew straws to determine their roles – leaner or teacher – although this was fixed and the confederate always ended to the learner. There was also an “experimenter” dressed in a white lab coat, played by an actor (not Milgram). The “learner” (Mr. Wallace) was strapped to a chair in another room with electrodes. After he has learned a list of word pairs given him to learn, the "teacher" tests him by naming a word and asking the learner to recall its partner/pair from a list of four possible choices. The teacher is told to administer an electric shock every time......

Words: 1105 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Structure and Firm Strategy

...from selling one cookbook or unit to the next level and so on. “Companies in a competitive market tend to operate at the point at which marginal cost equals marginal revenue, or where they break even on the last unit produced” (Richards, 2013). The selling of online cookbooks falls under a competitive market because each firm would be selling cookbooks that will not change from one company to another. Also, neither the consumers nor the sellers have any control over the price at which the cookbook is to be sold; you either take it or leave it. With a market structure being competitive as the online market, consumers are able to shop around and know what is offered at what price. “If consumers don't know about all of their options or are unaware of price differences between different firms in a certain industry, firms are less able to compete for their business” (Hamel, 2013). In addition, selling cookbooks online can be offered to just about anyone, and you can pretty much stop selling them if needed be. Of, course it would be extremely hard to guarantee success in such a market, however one way is to stay competitive with my prices and also not let my total revenue fall below my total cost of the business causing a loss instead of a profit. Lastly, in considering a pricing strategy to use, I would first look to the four P’s of marketing. The four P’s of marketing are promotion, production, product, and placement. In order to consider the proper pricing strategy, I would......

Words: 3507 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Ernest Hemingway, Men Without Women-from the Undefeated to the Killers

...MEN WITHOUT WOMEN by Ernest Hemingway (1928) - The Undefeated - In Another Country - Hills Like White Elephants- The Killers 1-THE UNDEFEATED This short story reflects the courage, or rather recklesness, of a bullfighter called Manuel Garcia. As the title of the collection infers, none of the characters (which are all men) appear to be in touch with, engaged or married to any female. The setting is in Spain, which is indicated by the use of pesatas as currency and Madrid as a road to success according to the bullfighters. So, we may guess the author took his experience from his professional travels as a journalist. This tale is mostly about the way poor and unskilled men cope in a society ruled by corrida organizers as Don Miguel Retana. “If you stand in with Retana in this town, you're a made man” […] “If you aren't in with him you might just as well go out and shoot yourself” (cue from a waiter of the café before the Puerta del Sol) is a sign of the brutality of a community within which everybody ought to abide by Retana's rules. It is also a way to emphasize upon some sort of injustice set up by few men acting almost as mafia bosses. And Manuel, and his late brother, are victims of the system. The former already started getting rejected on the grounds of his being too old and therefore unpopular (as his aging weakens his abilities on the bull ring). However, not being able to make two ends meet, Manuel is compelled to fight in a nocturnal. He requires the help of a......

Words: 1814 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Case of Ian Chetum vs. Knarles and Barkley

...his residents. Yet, he stubbornly ignored their warnings to replace the equipment. Moreover, another employee had been with the plumber at the time of inspection. It is assumed this employee was “qualified” to perform the maintenance work they were contracted to perform. This employee could add that he concurred with the plumber’s assessment of the faulty boiler. Therefore, adding credence to the plumber’s ability to assess and fix the boiler despite being unlicensed at the time. Essentially, the maximum remedy that should be given to Chetum is the remaining monies withheld from the first month’s check for work already performed. This is based on the fact that the plumber was unlicensed at the time of inspection. Moreover, Chetum was unaware of this when the work was being performed. He could further claim that the plumber didn’t have the necessary skill to assess the defective boiler. Therefore, his advice to buy a new boiler should not be taken at face value and not have agreed to allow the plumber to do a “quick fix” on the boiler. He could claim the “quick fix” added to the likelihood of the carbon monoxide incident. If Chetum were to claim intentional negligence on the part of the plumber’s work, could Knarles and Barkley countersue? The answer is would be two-fold. On one hand, if Chetum were to make claims that the plumber’s warnings were invalid or his workmanship was “shoddy” or “careless”, they could sue for slander. Slander refers to the defamation of......

Words: 2406 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Hiring Ex-Offenders

...giving the support need to stay out of trouble during the first year of their release. It is hard for the ex-offender having a record of arrest or conviction. Their backgrounds generally give employers the perceptions that ex-offenders are untrustworthy and insurance companies the view that they are not bondable for job honesty. There are several federal and state programs that are offered to employers to encourage them to hire ex-offenders. Some employers are unaware of such programs and others are skeptical due to the misconception that once a criminal, always a criminal. Many ex-offenders are happy to have the opportunity to gain a fresh start and to become productive member of society. The employments of these ex-offenders not only benefit the individual, the employer but society as well. Employing ex-offenders makes them contributing tax-payers. Ex offenders comprise a significant group in the job market. It is estimated that ex-convicts make up one third of the job force. Most employers are unaware of the tax incentives, bonding programs, and intermediary organizations currently in place to facilitate employment of returning offenders. Early work experience sometimes leads to wage growth over time, though this has not been particularly true among welfare recipients and others. Employers generally seem interested in the support system that seek to bridge the gap between ex offenders and prospective employers, but need to know more about the programs and how......

Words: 3226 - Pages: 13