Free Essay

Utilitarianism, Ethical Egoism, and Moral Relativism

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By kooltom777
Words 1382
Pages 6
Utilitarianism, Ethical Egoism, and Moral Relativism
Tom Gardner

Ethics is a branch of philosophy that attempts to answer the questions; what’s right? What’s wrong? And why? Moral relativism is an ethics position that essentially states that people have disagreeing moral beliefs and therefore you must but tolerant of other's morals. This position leads to the problematic realization that if this is the case there can be no objective moral truths nor can there be any universal principles. Act utilitarianism and ethical egoism are two different ethics theories that attempt to respond to this challenge of moral relativism in different ways.
Ethical egoism attempts to respond to the challenge of moral relativism by justifying that there is a universal principle for what actions are right and what are wrong. It is a form of consequentialism, which means it looks solely at the consequences of action to see if it is right or wrong. The defining sentence of egoism is as follows, “What's good for you is right and what's bad for you is wrong.” This phrase can be interpreted in a number of ways, the most popular one being: every person should act in their own self-interest. This means that when deciding on whether an action is good, any effect on others (mental or physical) by said action has no merit. An egoist that is measuring or justifying an action's goodness is only examining the possible positive or negative effects this action will have on him.
The majority of the justification arguments for ethical egoism stems from both psychological egoism and rational egoism. Psychological egoism is the belief that all people, whether they believe so or not, always seek their own self-interest in actions and this behavior is unavoidable because it is human nature. Rational egoism is the similar belief that it is rational to do something in one's self interest and therefore irrational to do something against their self-interest.
Three good arguments for the justification of ethical egoism are the human nature, self-knowledge, and intrusion arguments. The human nature argument is just psychological egoism. It argues that humans naturally operate by means of self-interest so why fight it. Ethical egoism will serve as a more intelligent way to support the natural order of things. The self-knowledge argument states that because we have a better knowledge of ourselves then that of others, we are better qualified in doing good actions for ourselves rather than for others. An example of this argument is the fact that a person has better odds of buying a good gift for themselves compared to buying a good gift for another. The intrusion argument simply argues that you have no right to bud into other people’s business and whether you think it is good or not you are simply over stepping your bounds.
The ethics theory utilitarianism, like egoism, is also a form of consequentialism. Yet it attempts to answer the challenge of moral relativism, through consequentialism, in a very different way. Utilitarianism looks at the amount of pleasure present and pain absent in a consequence, also known as its utility. The fundamental rule of utilitarianism is the, “Greatest Happiness Principle.” This principle states that actions are right in proportion to which they create the greatest happiness for most people. So adverse to ethical egoism, this theory gives more merit to the collected effect of action on all (others & the do-err) compared to just the effect on the do-err.
When a utilitarian is deciding on whether an action is good they are calculating the utility (pleasure present & pain absent) of the action, for all, and comparing it to the utility of other possible actions that could be taken at that time. The utility of an action is calculated by examining a number of aspects related to the pleasure involved and it is measured in hedons, a unit of pleasure. These aspects of calculation are the pleasures intensity, duration, closeness to action, purity, certainty, extent of affected people, and multitude of kinds of pleasure produced.
Utilitarianism is justified on a number of beliefs/arguments, the first being that all people only desire happiness, which is just another word for pleasure. In this belief the desire for things like money, virtue, and friends are actual just a means to an end, which is happiness. Utilitarianism is also based on the argument that the feelings of pain and pleasure are in facts natures guide to what ought to be. Finally, utilitarianism is based on the belief that by keeping the happiness of the community in mind you are in fact acting in the best interest of your own happiness. In this belief the community is seen as a fictional body that is made up of the sum of individual interests within that body. The best way to increase the body’s happiness is to increase the majority of individual happiness’s and transversely the happier the body gets the more likely the increase of the individuals happiness will happen.
Ethical egoism and utilitarianism are similar in that they are both trying to solve the same challenge of moral relativism. Both theories are attempting to solve the problem of not having a universal standard that constitutes what actions are right and what are wrong. They are also similar in that they both use consequentialism as a means to create a universal standard. The main difference between the two theories is the merit they place on the parties affected by the consequence. Ethical egoism puts a higher value on the consequences' effects on the person doing the action and almost disregards the effects on others. This means an egoist could murder someone if it proved beneficial (i.e. not getting caught and gaining something of worth). Utilitarianism on the other hand puts a higher value on the consequences' effect on the community majority rather than the individual. This means that a utilitarian could justify the existence of slavery it created more pleasure in the majority than pain. Another argument could be made that ethical egoism is based on rewarding the value of completing ones desires while utilitarianism is based on rewarding the creation of happiness. This over course can be refuted by the idea that receiving desired things is simply a means to creating happiness.
So which theory is superior? Both seem to be well justified and yet both, it seems, contain major flaws, like in my examples of the justification of slavery or murder. When comparing theories it is often best to compare the merit of their counter arguments rather than the theories themselves. The first of three major arguments against ethical egoism is that it leads to immorality. Many philosophers object that because it allows for any action to be justified it promotes humans in weak moments to be immoral. The second major argument is that an individual cannot truly objectively decide what is beneficial to them. For instance a person who is emotionally distraught might think it beneficial to sleep all day and eat gallons of ice cream when in actuality these actions are disadvantageous. The last major argument questions the justification of the importance of the individual. This argument asks what qualifies the individual as more important than the majority.
The first of three major arguments against utilitarianism is that it ignores the individual’s natural rights. An example is a person's right to life, which can be trumped in utilitarianism if there person's death creates more happiness then pain. The second argument points out that the measuring or pleasure is near impossible. How can one quantitatively measure something so abysmal? The final argument is that of the problem of scope affected. This argument is encapsulated by the example of a butterflies wing flapped causing a tornado miles away and brings forth the idea of it being truly impossible to see the full scope of things affected by a certain occurrence.
In the end ethical egoism, because of its allowance of each person to essentially justify all of their actions as good, can be seen as a blurry descendant of moral relativism and for that reason does not solve the original problem. It is for that reason that utilitarianism is the superior theory, in that it solves the challenges of moral relativism.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Philosophy

...Philosophy Exam * When is a deductive argument conclusive? All the premises are true, No fallacies are committed, and it is valid. Which of the following is one of the criteria a deductive argument must meet in order to be conclusive (good)? -the argument must be valid * What are the 3 criteria that must be met for an appeal to experts to be legitimate? 1. Must be an expert in the relevant field, expertise on the issue 2. Consensus of experts in the field must agree. 3.Expert must be liable and agreeable, reliable and credible Suppose you decide to appeal to experts to answer a question. Which of the following is NOT one of the three criteria discussed in class that must be met for your appeal to authority to be likely to get you the truth? -the expert appealed to must have published work in the field. * What are the ways discussed in class to determine what the consensus of experts believe about an issue? Professional Journals * Why is it important to rely on a consensus rather than individual experts views? Some experts just start drama, past experts have been wrong. Why is it important to rely on consensus rather than individual experts views? -a consensus is more likely to be correct * How is truth defined in class? As defined in class, a statement is true and only true if it matches up with the way things are. * What are the main points of each of the Quickie Arguments? Morality does not equal legality...

Words: 2864 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Ethical Egoism

...Ethical Egoism We will be discussing the strengths and weaknesses of ethical egoism, but before we begin we first must understand what ethical egoism is and what is involved. Ethical egoism is the normative ethical position that moral agents ought to do what is in their own self-interest. It differs from psychological egoism, which claims that people can only act in their self-interest. Ethical egoism also differs from rational egoism, which holds that it is rational to act in one's self-interest. Ethical egoism contrasts with ethical altruism, which holds that moral agents have an obligation to help others. Egoism and altruism both contrast with ethical utilitarianism, which holds that a moral agent should treat one's self with no higher regard than one has for others as egoism does, by elevating self-interests and the self to a status not granted to others, but that one also should not as altruism does sacrifice one's own interests to help others' interests, so long as one's own interests (i.e. one's own desires or well-being) are substantially equivalent to the others' interests and well-being. Egoism, utilitarianism, and altruism are all forms of consequentialism, but egoism and altruism contrast with utilitarianism, in that egoism and altruism are both agent-focused forms of consequentialism (i.e. subject-focused or subjective), but utilitarianism is called agent-neutral (i.e. objective and impartial) as it does not treat the subject's (i.e...

Words: 433 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...Abstract Business Ethics is the application of general ethical concepts to specific situations confronted in a business. The main question asked when analyzing business ethics is what is right and what is wrong as far as someone’s behavior in a business. What principles or what rules can be used a guidance in certain business situations. Some people feel that business and ethics should not go hand-in-hand. They feel that there is no room for ethics in business. While others feel that businesses need to practice good ethical and moral values within their company. Ethical questions can range from a company’s obligation to be honest with its customers, to a company’s responsibility to protect employee’s rights. There are several concepts and approaches that businesses can refer to in helping them make moral business decisions. Business Ethics Business Ethics studies and evaluates business decisions according to moral concepts and judgments. Business ethics has two main characteristics. One, it tells people what they should and should not do. Two, it sets a list of principles or rules to be followed. Deciding how we behave towards ourselves and others is a matter of making choices. Making the right choices can be extremely crucial in a business environment. Why Ethics is Important in Business When business people think about business ethics they are usually thinking about one of three things. The first is to avoid breaking the law in a work related activity. The second is...

Words: 1367 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Dancing

...attempts to answer the questions; what’s right? What’s wrong? And why? Ethical relativism is the thesis that ethical principles or judgments are relative to the individual or culture. Ethical egoism attempts to respond to the challenge of moral relativism by justifying that there is a universal principle for what actions are right and what are wrong. It is a form of consequentialism, which means it looks solely at the consequences of action to see if it is right or wrong. Utilitarianism is one of the best-known and most influential moral theories. Like other forms of consequentialism, its core idea is that whether actions are morally right or wrong depends on their effects. This paper lists This paper also explores numerous studies conducted on various facts behind the three disparate moral theories, aiming at providing a an adequate or workable foundation for ethics. To begin with, ethical egoism is an inadequate moral theory as moral conflicts are not resolved in ethical egoism. This theory is based upon a nature shared by human beings, i.e., people are self-interested. People are generally motivated to reap benefits for themselves. To fully understand the inherent flaw in ethnical egoism, certain principles behind the theory are explored. As a normative theory, ethical egoism sets the principle of how we ought to act, and somehow, it encourages a sense of selfishness. According to Lawrence Hinman, ethical egoism asserts that everyone should always act in their own self-interests...

Words: 1321 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Intellipath Philosophy Unit 1

...limit, and takes the extreme position by arguing that moral choices, judgments, and resolutions are so subjective that discussions, contemplation, and  deliberations on morality are useless is called a  _______ subjectist Cynical A______truth is dependent on the subject’s own experience. Subjective A person who believes that whatever an individual says is right for that particular individual is called a _____ Relativist Hume believed that the only kind of truth that can be known is a _____ Truth Subjective The notion of ethical  _________which is often mistaken and confused with Ethical relativism, doubts that any acts are right or wrong. | | Skepticism Moral decisions, determinations, and judgments are acknowledged and established in a cultural context, and these positions are subject to change depending on one’s cultural  Relativism ______is the notion that there is no concrete certainty the sphere of knowledge and truth. Relativism An objective______ is a truth that is independent of an observer. Truth _________ is the notion that truth depends on context—the time, place, and the identity of the observer. Relativism The certainty of Descartes’ rationalism leads to the idea of absolute  truth In the never-ending debate between relativism and dogmatism, most people agree that the solution for inclusivity is moderation People who argue that ethics and morality are subjective, and moral choices should be made on individual assessment, or societal...

Words: 1397 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ethical Theories

...evil. The person defines these. You bump into a car at the mall. You could leave a note, but since there were no witnesses and the owner is not around, you decide not to because you recognize that the damage is low (probably only a couple of hundred dollars). The car owner probably has insurance, and it would be such a hassle for the owner to contact you and your insurance company. You may have to end up paying higher premium, the owner may think ill of you—all of which are nonmoral reasons that may be unpleasant for you. Ethical egoism state that you should always act so that your actions produce what is in your own best long-term interests. Personal egoism states that an individual should always act in his or her own best long-term interests, but that does not say how others should act. Impersonal egoism states that an individual should always act in his or her own best long-term interest. 2. Values Clarification (Philosophical Relativism) teaches that the most important aspect is not what one believes, but being aware one’s own feelings, beliefs, and values systems. People thus consider alternative models of thinking and acting. By acting thusly and making one’s own choices, one develops one’s own values. In this setting, a value is what a person likes to do. It is NOT an ought-to-do, but rather a want-to-do. Values clarification puts a heavy emphasis on feelings—so much so that it virtually equates...

Words: 1547 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Affirmatve Action

...affirmative action using logical arguments ethical theories, and perspectives. This paper will examine in what way a Utilitarian, Deontologist, Virtue Ethicist, Relativist and an Ethical Egoist would debate against the use of affirmative action. The case will be made by demonstrating why this practice is unquestionably unethical and discriminatory. Affirmative action is frequently used to give subgroups a benefit when applying for jobs, colleges or other organizations. In some cases, companies are financially incentivized to be racially diverse and in other instances extra points are given for test results. The result of these practices enables candidates, which could be less experienced to satisfy a position, to be chosen in order to achieve minority quotas. Affirmative action was passed to push back opposed to racism after segregation was viewed unlawful in order to get the government and employers to employ minorities; however, it is twisted by issues. In order to comprehend how an ethical perspective or theory would deal with affirmative action, it is necessary to first comprehend the view or approach. Utilitarianism is acknowledged as an important ethical theory, which only means that it centers on the expected result of an act, instead of the principles of the act itself or the agent involved in the action. The Utilitarian may endorse using the motto, “the ends justify the means”. The most fundamental evidence of Utilitarianism is that the agent must choose the course of...

Words: 2250 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Business Ethics

...The existence of Ethics has been acknowledged for quite a long time as a part of philosophy study of human conduct. In the past few decades, Business Ethics has become such an important issue that it was added into business majors’ curriculums in business schools and studied and applied widely in firms. As people become more aware of all the right – wrong – good – bad relating to the world of business, Ethics comes to set the guidelines for behaviours and conduct within an organization. However, unethical behaviours still exist despite all attempts to fight misconduct and can be at any level of management. In my opinion, if I were in the situation of being encouraged to inflate my expense account, it would be my moral philosophy that most impacts my decision rather than the cultural values of the organization for which I work. The term Business Ethics is defined as a set of rules, principles and standards that guide behaviours in the world of business, with an emphasis on determining what is correct and what is incorrect. Unethically leads to financial misconduct. For the past 15 years, businesses have been faced with the arisen of false accounting frauds which caused significant damage and losses to companies. It was reported in the 2012 Report to the Nations on Occupational Fraud and Abuse by The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners that approximately 14.5% of all asset misappropriations investigated involved expense reimbursement frauds. Employee’s inflating their...

Words: 1755 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Ethics

...Ethics The field of ethics (or moral philosophy) involves systematizing, defending, and recommending concepts of right and wrong behavior. Philosophers today usually divide ethical theories into three general subject areas: metaethics, normative ethics, and applied ethics. Metaethics investigates where our ethical principles come from, and what they mean. Are they merely social inventions? Do they involve more than expressions of our individual emotions? Metaethical answers to these questions focus on the issues of universal truths, the will of God, the role of reason in ethical judgments, and the meaning of ethical terms themselves. Normative ethics takes on a more practical task, which is to arrive at moral standards that regulate right and wrong conduct. This may involve articulating the good habits that we should acquire, the duties that we should follow, or the consequences of our behavior on others. Finally, applied ethics involves examining specific controversial issues, such as abortion, infanticide, animal rights, environmental concerns, homosexuality, capital punishment, or nuclear war. By using the conceptual tools of metaethics and normative ethics, discussions in applied ethics try to resolve these controversial issues. The lines of distinction between metaethics, normative ethics, and applied ethics are often blurry. For example, the issue of abortion is an applied ethical topic since it involves a specific type of controversial behavior. But it also depends...

Words: 6480 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Management

...1. Discuss the market system and the need for ethics in business and distinguish it from the law and concepts of virtue and morality. 2. Discuss ethics in the context of relativism, psychological egoism, utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics. 3. Discuss the ideas of character ethic, female ethic, human rights, and ethical action. 4. Discuss the factors influencing employee issues including the right to work, employment at will, due process and employee participation, health and safety standards, family responsibilities, the right to privacy, and substance abuse testing. 5. Discuss the professional ethics and responsibilities of intermediaries, managerial responsibility and loyalty, and employee responsibilities to the community. 1. Discuss the market system and the need for ethics in business and distinguish it from the law and concepts of virtue and morality Ethics are important for everyone and in the corporate sector it can play animportant part. The decision to behave ethically is a moral one and workers must decide what they think is the right way of doing an action. At present most of the businesses feels that the need for ethics has increase as it can have a major impact on the performance of the business. Ethics can be inside the business environment like the way employees behave and manage relations with each other and outsidethe business surroundings like how the business is treating its customers and otherstakeholders. There is need of ethics in the...

Words: 1132 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Ethical Treatment of Prisoners

...and are often regarded as "unworthy" in the general community. This paper will identify the ethical issues and problems prisoners face in the areas of harsher punishment and abuse, and how utilitarianism and relativism plays a vital role in resolving some of the ethical issues in prisons. Imprisonment as punishment for crimes was first used during the sixteenth century in Europe. Prior to that, criminal correction usually consisted of enslavement or swift physical punishment such as whipping or execution. According to Michael Hardy (1998) prison was conceived as a more humane response to criminal behavior. Europeans established colonies in America in the seventeenth century and they continued the practice of imprisoning those convicted of crimes (Hardy, 1998). During the colonial era, the number of Americans in prison made up a small, barely noticeable segment of the population. Today, this has changed dramatically. According to statistics from the Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice, if incarceration rates continue unchanged, 1 out of every 20 Americans alive today will be imprisoned at some time in their lives. This is due in part to new crime laws such as “three strikes and you’re out” and tougher sentencing for drug-related offenses (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2009). The question that needs to be addresses is, has the government ensured a universal, consistent, ethical protection for prisoners and are they provided with what’s needed to assure a fair rehabilitation...

Words: 2139 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Crimes And Misdemeanors Themes

...Philosophy in Literature and Films (HS3033) Assignment Sashank K EE11B124 3 November 2014 1 1 An Introduction to Moral Philosophy and some of its Theories Most humans judge the moral consequences of what they and others do. They classify everything as good or bad. Thus, ethical philosophy is a branch of philosophy which is relevant at some level to even laymen, who are not philoso- phers. All of us make moral judgments based on some preconceived or preexist- ing moral principle. Investigation of how such a principle came about, whether it is right or wrong and such discussion on the principle constitutes the branch of ethics or moral philosophy. Ethics is further subdivided into three areas. These are meta-ethics, normative ethics and applied...

Words: 1603 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Ethics and Moral Philosophy

...Applying Moral Philosophies to Business Ethics Moral philosophies - present guidelines for determining how conflicts in human interests are to be settled and for optimizing mutual benefit of people living together in groups. --There is no one correct way to resolve ethical issues in business. -- Each type of philosophy has a distinct basis for deciding whether a particular action is right or wrong. -- Ethics issues analyzed using different philosophical theories generally have the same appropriate outcome. Role Morality — people have a moral responsibility to fulfill their role in the organization Do employees have a moral responsibility to “do their jobs?” What are their responsibilities? Do employers have a moral responsibility to “do their jobs?” What are their responsibilities? How do employers handle conflicts in the different roles they perform? What if your superior wants you to carry out some responsibility, and your workgroup thinks this is unfair? What if some personal role conflicts with a work role? (Others roles include: student, parent, child, organization member, etc.) Moral Philosophy Perspectives 1. Teleology — egoism - enlightened egoism - utilitarianism 2. Deontology 3. Relativist Perspective 4. Virtue Ethics I. Teleology — consequences (consequentialist theories) egoism — right behavior is based on good consequences for the individual enlightened egoism — some basic “rules”...

Words: 1277 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Nice

...human rights on the decision of a governing body, human rights are more securely based on __________, which can be traced back from the works of modern thinkers such as Locke & Jefferson to medieval & Roman thinkers back to Plato & Aristotle. (a) communitarian theory, (b) natural law theory, (c) egalitarian theory, (d) civil rights theory. 2. The type of virtuous social order envisioned by Plato is called a __________. (a) democracy, (b) plutocracy, (c) meritocracy, (d) elected monarchy. 3. One of the basic ways in which one develops a virtuous character is from _______. (a) role-modeling, (b) having “peak experiences” & moving on to a higher stage, (c) just conforming to one’s culture, (d) studying philosophy. 4. Aristotle’s moral theory argues that _________________ is the primary end of human action. (a) following one of two extremes, (b) promoting utility, (c) acquiring virtues, (d) the happy life. 5. Another way of describing the end referred to in question 4 above is to___________________. (a) follow one’s duty, (b) contribute to human flourishing, (c) being civic, (d) fulfill the need for moderate pleasures. 6. In the long line of thinkers who have contributed to Natural Law theory of rights, one of the principles first put forth by Plato as both a natural & rational basis of justice/virtue is the principle of ________. (a)...

Words: 1034 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

To Stay or to Leave

...To Stay or to Leave? Christine Amargo SOC 120 Intro to Ethics and Social Responsibility Denise Antoon April 21, 2014 In the United States of America, we face many different ethical problems each and every day. Some of the ethical problems that we have to deal with are hunger, war, poverty, crime, and terrorism, but the biggest ethical issue the United States has to deal ethical with is immigration. There are many issues dealing with immigrations, such as immigration laws. Many questions come up about this topic in today's society, like how do we stop immigration or do we even stop it? Not all immigrants are bad some are useful to the United States; we have to remember that the first people in America were immigrants. We do not have the right to deport others back to their native land. Many people from different countries try so hard to get to United States looking for a better life. There are many reasons why immigrants migrate to different countries, especially the United States of America home of the free. Some reasons are employment opportunities or careers that are not available in their native land, improved quality of life, and refuge from war. Most immigrants focus on making sure their children have a better life they had; those people show the theory of utilitarianism. "Utilitarianism argues that, given a set of choices, the act we should choose is that which produces the best results for the greatest number affected by that choice" (Mosser, 1.6). These immigrants...

Words: 2483 - Pages: 10