Utilitarianism in Health Care

In: Other Topics

Submitted By gdot80
Words 1729
Pages 7
Grade Received - "A"

You are a paramedic arriving at an emergency scene. A group of scouts have entered a cave that is now filling with water. They were led into the cave by a rather large scoutmaster. Unfortunately, while leading them out of the cave, the scoutmaster somehow managed to get stuck in a narrow opening with only his head and shoulders protruding out. With his upper torso stuck outside the cave, it appears the scoutmaster will survive, but all the boys below will drown if they cannot escape.

After you have checked all possible escape routes and have attempted to extricate the scoutmaster, it becomes clear that the only way to save the boys is to sacrifice the scoutmaster and remove him from the hole so the rest of the scouts can escape.

What is the correct action for this case? Justify your decision using each of the following:

Duty-oriented reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs)
Consequence-oriented reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs)
Virtue-ethics reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs)
Based on your analysis, consider what might be the ultimate dilemma of ethics and include your answer to each of the following questions:

What happens when people apply differential standards (all valid) to health care decisions? Explain with supporting examples. (2 to 3 Paragraphs)
How does an individual determine who is ultimately right when different decisions are reached? (2 to 3 Paragraphs)

Abstract
I am a paramedic who has arrived at an emergency scene or a group of scouts enter the cave that is filling with water. The scoutmaster is stuck between a narrow opening with his head and shoulders protruding out. The way the scoutmaster is positioned gives him a good chance of survival but all the boys will drown if they cannot escape. After checking all possibilities of escape routes and attempting to extract the scoutmaster, the only way the boys will survive is if the…...

Similar Documents

Health Care

...Health Care around the World Health care systems are designed to meet the health care needs of target populations. The goals for health systems are good health, responsiveness to the expectations of the population, and fair financial contribution. In some countries, health care system planning is distributed among market participants, whereas in others planning is made among governments, trade unions, charities, religious bodies. Health care providers are trained professional people working self-employed or as an employee in an organization. Examples are doctors and nurses, paramedics, dentists, medical laboratory staff, specialist therapists, psychologists, pharmacists. There is a wide variety of health care systems around the world. In most countries, the system divides itself into state and private. In Australia the current system has its own private health system. All legal permanent residents are entitled to free public hospital care. Treatment by private doctors is also free. In Cuba the system does charge fees in treating elective treatment for patients from abroad, but tourists who become ill are treated free in Cuban hospitals. In France, most doctors remain in private practice. In India, the hospitals are run by government, charitable trusts and by private organizations. Apart from the modern system of medicine, many traditional medicinal systems are put to use. All persons resident in the Republic of Ireland are entitled to health care through the public health...

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Health Care

...Rural Health Care By: Lurhonda Maxwell, Amanda Hacko, Laura Bottom, Patricia Delaughter, Tamara Boyd and Ta Rhonda Thomas HCS/440 Professor: Chuck Sigmund Due: September 12, 2011 Individuals and families of rural populations are confronted and struggling with the same challenges and care issues as everyone else in the nation-such as large numbers of uninsured and underinsured, high rising health care costs, and overextended health care infrastructure. Jon Bailey states that, “there are numerous unique health care issues facing rural people and rural places. Despite an array of health care differentials between urban and rural people, there is evidence that the ultimate health status of rural people has much to do with health insurance coverage and the type of health insurance coverage”. Evidence show people in rural areas with health insurance provided by there employers get more or less costly health care provided services then those who have purchased health insurance privately. Insurance that was purchased at lower cost resulted in health care services that were presumably regular and better. As discussed, people in rural areas lack coverage. People in rural areas are being denied coverage and have higher premiums because of their...

Words: 718 - Pages: 3

Health Care

...Health Care Management Healthcare is a very large, complex, and inefficient industry. This field is one field that will always require attention and there will always be a need for improvement because it will be in dynamic state always. This is due to the human health, coverage and technology. These are all things that we cannot control or are working hard to get under better control. Furthermore, health care touches everyone. There are families who worry about their children and aging relatives; employers who must provide health insurance to their employees and the employees who need the benefits. In addition, there are the government officials and politicians who are concerned about the rising cost of health care; and, of course, the hospitals and doctors who are responsible for delivering health care. Having adequate health care is extremely important to people. Even successful medical treatment can involve pain, anxiety, risk, and, inevitably, lots of money. The last thing a patient in a hospital wants to think about is "how am I going to pay for all of this?" Ideally, instead of worrying about money, a patient should be concentrating on getting well. So the main question is how to measure the cost of the health? Of course human life is the dearest. But financial sides must also be taken into account. Healthcare system must provide health for all legal law abiding country citizens, regardless of their income, financial ability, and past health history. Everyone deserves...

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Utilitarianism in Health Care

...Grade Received - "A" You are a paramedic arriving at an emergency scene. A group of scouts have entered a cave that is now filling with water. They were led into the cave by a rather large scoutmaster. Unfortunately, while leading them out of the cave, the scoutmaster somehow managed to get stuck in a narrow opening with only his head and shoulders protruding out. With his upper torso stuck outside the cave, it appears the scoutmaster will survive, but all the boys below will drown if they cannot escape. After you have checked all possible escape routes and have attempted to extricate the scoutmaster, it becomes clear that the only way to save the boys is to sacrifice the scoutmaster and remove him from the hole so the rest of the scouts can escape. What is the correct action for this case? Justify your decision using each of the following: Duty-oriented reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs) Consequence-oriented reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs) Virtue-ethics reasoning (1 to 2 Paragraphs) Based on your analysis, consider what might be the ultimate dilemma of ethics and include your answer to each of the following questions: What happens when people apply differential standards (all valid) to health care decisions? Explain with supporting examples. (2 to 3 Paragraphs) How does an individual determine who is ultimately right when different decisions are reached? (2 to 3 Paragraphs) Abstract I am a paramedic who has arrived at an emergency scene or a group of scouts...

Words: 1729 - Pages: 7

Health Care

...Universal Health Care Tamesha Mallard Comm/215 10-01-12 Jennifer Benoist Do you have health insurance? There are millions of people in the United States that would say no. The people that do not have health insurance are not just the homeless or unemployed, but they are the working class too. That means it could be you, your neighbor or even your co-worker that is uninsured. “Nearly 44 million Americans — about 15 percent of the U.S. population — have no health coverage, including 8.5 million children. And eight out of 10 uninsured Americans are in working families (Leydig)”. All citizens of the United States should have health care insurance, because multiple countries have universal healthcare, it will help detect life threatening diseases, and decrease financial hardship. As citizens of the United States, we all have rights; we have the right to bear arms, we have the right to a public trial, and we should have the right to health coverage. First of all, all countries should provide health care insurance to their citizens. The countries that do provide health insurance to all of their citizens call it Universal health care coverage. “Nearly 50 countries have attained universal or near-universal health coverage by 2008, according to the International Labor Organization. Several well-known examples exist like the UK, which has the National Health Service, and the Canadian public health care system. (Park, 2012)” Our country is already torn and divided by...

Words: 786 - Pages: 4

Health Care

...Liberals, Conservatives and Health Care 18,000 people die in the United Staes each year because they are uninsured. These people were not only denied a chance to live, but denied the right to have proper health care. This denial is a direct cause of the vast controversies over health care by liberals and conservatives. Liberals and conservatives are on two different sides of a broad hemisphere of philosophies that run rampant in The U.Ss’ government, especially on the view of health care. The recession has made the gap between these two margins more vast than ever before. Liberals on the far left of the spectrum believe that health care should be provided to all Americans regardless of their income. They assert that a universal health care system or even single-payer system would be the best form of health care to put in place. Now that health care has become increasingly unaffordable for many families and businesses, the turn towards a universal or single-payer plan could be the right move. Conservatives on the other side of the spectrum, the far right, tend to lean towards the government having minimum involvement in providing health care for the public. They believe health care should be privatized and based on a free market. By increasing competition and trying to keep insurance companies honest, conservatives claim health care system would be fixed. This idea is clearly inconsistent because many people in the US cannot afford to pay for privatized health insurance...

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Health Care

...Health Care Utilization August 19, 2013 John Q is a fulltime employee with a few health issues, because of his low income John qualifies for the Medicaid program in his city. With the health issues that John has he recently called around his city to see if he could locate a provider that accepted his insurance. John found a provider, he has also discovered that the closest primary care physician that accepts Medicaid is a 40 minute drive and appointments must be made 2 weeks in advance due to the number of patients at the practice. The provider that John located does not offer weekend appointment, and John relies on public transportation and he occasionally gets a ride from a friend. Looking over John’s circumstance with his health care needs and his transportation needs looks like he will need to go ahead and make the appointment for the next month that way John will have enough time to get his transportation needs in the correct order. When we think about the word utilization and what factors this may play in john’s health care needs. First the word utilization which means the primary method by which asset performance is measured and business success determined. In basic terms it is a measure of the actual revenue earned by assets against the potential revenue they could have earned. So looking into John’s healthcare issue and his family history of health issue John might need to call the physician office and see if he and talk with them about utilization...

Words: 626 - Pages: 3

Health Care

...Education, Health Care, and Immigration are three very controversial issues prevalent in American society. I believe that all three of these issues are difficult for American citizens and society to come to public judgment, but of the three, I think health care is the most difficult. To start off, Health Care has been an ongoing problem in the United States since the end of World War II. Over these past sixty years, there have been numerous attempts to come to public judgment and fix the system but America has yet to come up with a successful plan to please and supply the appropriate care for all its citizens. Due to the amount of time Health Care has been an issue in American society, reflects just how tough it has been to come to public judgment. Health Care is also an issue that affects the lives of every American citizen directly. No matter what age, race, class, or gender a citizen will play a role in the system because every American has “health.” Compared to Health Care, Immigration and Education either indirectly or directly affects the lives of American citizens, which in my opinion makes them slightly easier for American society to reach a public judgment. Immigration is an issue that has been in and out of the spotlight throughout the history of the United States. There have been more important issues that the American public and government chose to address first. The issues concerning immigration are that many Americans are upset that foreign born...

Words: 744 - Pages: 3

Health Care

...HEALTH CARE Introduction Health care (or healthcare) is the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of disease, illness, injury, and other physical and mental impairments in humans. Health is delivered by practitioners in allied health, dentistry, medicine, nursing, optometry, pharmacy and other care providers. It refers to the work done in providing primary care, secondary care, and tertiary care, as well as in public health. Access to health care varies across countries, groups and individuals, largely influenced by social and economic conditions as well as the health policies in place. Countries and jurisdictions have different policies and plans in relation to the personal and population-based health care goals within their societies. Health care systems are organizations established to meet the health needs of target populations. Their exact configuration varies from country to country. In some countries and jurisdictions, health care planning is distributed among market participants, whereas in others planning is made more centrally among governments or other coordinating bodies. In all cases, according to the World Health Organization (WHO), a well-functioning health care system requires a robust financing mechanism; a well-trained and adequately-paid workforce; reliable information on which to base decisions and policies; and well maintained facilities and logistics to deliver quality medicines and technologies. The delivery of modern health care depends on groups...

Words: 3106 - Pages: 13

Health Care

...Martina Santos Prof. Crowe ENG 82 25 November 25, 2013 Would obesity be less of a problem if the government paid for health care?  Obesity is a medical condition in which excess body fat has accumulated to the extent that it may have an adverse effect on health, leading to reduced life expectancy and/or increased health problems. Obesity increases the likelihood of various diseases, particularly heart disease, type 2 diabetes, obstructive sleep apnea, certain types of cancer, and osteoarthritis. Dieting and physical exercise are the mainstays of treatment for obesity. Diet quality can be improved by reducing the consumption of energy-dense foods such as those high in fat and sugars, and by increasing the intake of dietary fiber. Anti-obesity drugs may be taken to reduce appetite or inhibit fat absorption together with a suitable diet. Obesity is something that is a big issue in America today. Not only is it found in adults but now kids, even toddlers. Some may say it’s in their jeans, or they will grow of it. Will they really? Instead of facing the fact that they are not choosing the right food choices, but you can’t completely but the blame on parents the government health benefits options also take a big role in today’s obesity.  Obesity is killing more people than smoking. Some say the government should take charge of the situation like in the cases of seatbelt and smoking laws. Others say that it is the responsibility of the private sector. People are responsible...

Words: 414 - Pages: 2

Health Care

...Jennifer Rasmussen 121.151 Basic Argument: Final Draft June 20, 2014 Health Care: Profit Motive “Is the physician a healer of the sick or a maker of money?” In book 1 of Plato’s The Republic, Socrates questions about the physician being a healer, or a maker of money and trying to balance the two is much easier in our time than it was in Plato’s (www.literaturepage.com). The famous Hippocratic Oath affirms that doctors should protect the sick, and not only just from being sick, but also from injustice and harm, and instructs physicians not to prey on patient’s vulnerability for their own gain (medterms.com). Today, few medical schools require their students to take the oath, the principle of placing the benefit of the sick above one’s own self-interest remains at the center of the medical profession, so we think? Treating the sick and offering quality care to those who suffer are acts of compassion, which to this day are being destroyed by profit driven health care. We ask ourselves how could there be over 45 million people in the United States who do not have health care. Well, first let’s see how we can actually define Universal Health Care, which is also known as Universal Health Coverage, is a specific type of health care where everyone is provided coverage regardless of their income, race, age, pre-existing conditions, gender, or wealth. If you are a legal resident of the United States you are eligible for universal health care. When we think of the purpose of...

Words: 1061 - Pages: 5

Health Care

...Home Health Aide Job Responsibilities: Enables patients to stay in their homes by monitoring and recording patient condition, providing support and personal services, teaching families. Home Health Aide Job Duties: * Monitors patient condition by observing physical and mental condition, intake and output, and exercise. * Supports patients by providing housekeeping and laundry services; shopping for food and other household requirements; preparing and serving meals and snacks; running errands. * Assists patients by providing personal services, such as, bathing, dressing, and grooming. * Helps patients care for themselves by teaching use of cane or walker, special utensils to eat, special techniques and equipment for personal hygiene. * Helps family members care for the patient by teaching appropriate ways to lift, turn, and re-position the patient; advising on nutrition, cleanliness, and housekeeping. * Records patient information by making entries in the patient journal; notifying nursing supervisor of changing or unusual conditions. * Maintains a safe, secure, and healthy patient environment by following asepses standards and procedures; maintaining security precautions; following prescribed dietary requirements and nutrition standards; * Updates job knowledge by participating in educational opportunities. * Protects the home care agency by adhering to professional standards, home care policies and procedures, federal, state, and...

Words: 1061 - Pages: 5

Health Care

...Health Care System Stacy Welk Hum/114 July 06, 2015 Deeadra Albert-Green Health Care System Most people don’t realize that the health care system helps cut down health care coast. Health Care Many don’t know this but the United States is the most costly for health care compared to other countries. We also lack to accomplish better health care outcomes than the other countries. The United States doesn’t doesn’t have broad health care coverage, which is not completely put into effect. Rather than accomplishing a national health care service, a single-payer or multi-payer, the United States is known as a hybrid system. In 2010 the United States spending came from an off the record fund. When 2012 came, over 263.2 million people had health care insurance and 101.5 million people were covered through the government and 48 million had no health care coverage. Obama Care Obama Care is the type of health care that is reformed and provides fair information that people want to know. It also is a powerful program with many respects and with this kind of health care it makes sure everyone gets an honest shake in their health care rights. This type of health care makes it affordable for lower and middle class Americans and small business employers. Reliable or Non- credible The information about health...

Words: 413 - Pages: 2

Health Care

...Jamaican Health Care Name: Institutional Affiliation Table of Contents Jamaican Health Care 1 1.0 Introduction 3 2.0 About Jamaica 3 3.0Accessibility 4 4.0Health care financing 4 5.0Rationing 5 6.0Quality of health care 6 7.0Programs 6 8.0Conclusion 7 References 9 1.0 Introduction In Jamaica, Quality medical care is one of the basic concerns for many years. In Jamaica health care to every citizen as well as legal residents at clinics and government hospitals. The free health care is extended to the prescription of drugs. One of the drawbacks of this free health care in Jamaica is long queues in the facilities that have no appointments being accepted by the physicians. There have been a lot of complaints about people visiting the hospitals early morning and leaving the facilities late hours without being attended by a doctor. Additionally, obtaining a prescription from the health care facilities is not easy as many thinks. The paper, therefore, seeks to analyze Jamaica healthcare delivery system. The paper will address the history of Singapore, accessibility to the health care facilities, quality, programs as well as their effectiveness. 2.0 About Jamaica Jamaica is an island that is located in the Caribbean Sea, and it is the third largest island in the Greater Antilles. The island is about 10,990 Sq. in the area and lies 145 Sq. South of Cuba. In the Caribbean, it is the fourth...

Words: 2021 - Pages: 9

Health Care

...Legislative Health Care Policy and Processes Syeeda Daniels Baker College Abstract The United States legislative health policy process is very complex, it has a chain of command it has to follow before policies are set in place, this paper will explain what the legislative health policy is in the united states, and how its process is related to the principal features of united states health policy. I will discuss the critical policy issues related to the access to care, cost of care, and quality of care. Legislative Health Care Policy and Processes The legislative process is not a simple process, it begins when a member in congress determines that a problem exist, then a proposed solution to the problem “a bill” is presented to the committee that handles the issues presented in the bill (Singh, 2015, p. 524). Once the bill is amended it is forward to the house of representatives and the senate to vote on whether or not to pass the bill (Singh, 2015, p. 524). If they don’t agree the bill is not considered. If the bill is pass by the house of representatives and the senate it goes to the President of the United States, who either signs the bill or vetoes it (Singh, 2015, p. 524). Congress then has the power to override the veto (Singh, 2015, p. 524). Health policy as defined by the CDC are laws, regulations, procedures, administrative actions, incentives, or voluntary practice of governments and other institutions that influence the health of society (CDC...

Words: 797 - Pages: 4