Premium Essay

Volstead Act Dbq

Submitted By
Words 945
Pages 4
Why Did America Change Its Mind?

The 18th amendment, or also known as the Volstead Act, was a great change in the United States. Many people had described the Volstead Act as a dreadful time for the alcohol industry, this caused the United States to get crazy and from then on many illegal acts of crime were all going down at once for the same cause. The United States government had passed the law that selling, transporting, or manufacturing alcohol was illegal, but just because the government had all agreed, didn’t mean that the United States agreed. The question, “Why did America change its mind?” went around many times during the era of the 18th Amendment. This caused much backlash from the government. Document B of the DBQ shows the homicide/murder …show more content…
Looking throughout the timeline it shows a great increase throughout the same years as the 18th Amendment was in action, coincidentally. The crest or peak of the homicides per 100,000 people was around 10 people, which is around 0.10% of the 100,000 people. The increase in violence began after the amendment was passed and after the amendment was withdrawn the homicide rates went from 10 people to 5 people within 10 years after the bill was recalled. With this evidence it could greatly show how the Volstead Act had affected the United States, with homicides and murders. The cause of those homicides consisted of corruption of government officials inside the United States Government or from immigration bootleggers that were involved in retrieving or accessing alcohol which were also related to people in the mob, or criminals. In Document B of the DBQ it shows the homicide/murder rates of every 100,000 people, it also shows its peak and its descent. The 18th amendment or the Volstead Act lasted from 1919 to around 1933. Within that time period, the homicide rates had increased higher than both World Wars had ever reached. Within the 13 years that the Amendment was forced from the law, the peak of homicide was around 10 people in every …show more content…
At the time, the peak also happened to be the start of the Great Depression, which ultimately is when the 18th amendment was revoked and no longer existed. After that law the homicide rates went from 10 people every 100,000 people to around 5 people within 10 years. In Document A, there is an illustration of what I can only describe as 5 men holding hands while simultaneously taking a step in the same direction. On the floor there is a large “depression” on the floor, as well as having labels on all five of the men; the labels being “Gangster, Racket Prohibition, Bootlegger, and Dope Seller”. In the illustration as well it shows how Prohibition was larger than all the other men which shows how he is able to take a big step. We think that the image is trying to showcase how Prohibition is a much greater cause of Depression. Therefore, it is a larger man and taking a larger step than the others. In Document C, it explains in the text some events that occurred during the Prohibition Law. It also mentions people called “bootleggers” which are people that illegally sell products or items that are not allowed. For this time period, it would be considered alcohol. These bootleggers had a great impact on crime against the

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Differences Between 18th And 21st Amendments

...18th and 21st Amendments : The 18th Amendment was ratified on January 16, 1919 to forbid the making, transporting and selling of alcoholic beverages. In the 1830s, it was estimated that the average American of over 15 years of age drank 7.3 gallons of pure alcohol a year. This resulted in many religious groups promoting the idea of outlawing alcohol throughout the nation. The religious groups considered alcohol and the drunkenness as a threat to the nation. The prohibition of alcohol was known as the Noble Experiment. People believed the national experiment would reduce crime activity, improve health, decrease the need for prisons, solve social problems, etc. Unfortunately, the experiment backfired. Instead, the law encouraged large, pervasive...

Words: 327 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Prohibition In The 1920's Essay

...“Prohibition goes beyond the bounds of control a man’s appetite by legislation and makes crimes out of things that are not crimes” said by Abraham Lincoln. (patheos.com) “One vigorous clash between small-town and big-town and big city Americans began. In January 1920, the Eighteenth Amendment went into effect. This amendment launched the era known as Prohibition, during which the manufacture, sale and transportation of alcoholic beverages were legally prohibited”. (The Americans) Prohibition had both positive and negative effects in the 1920’s. Prohibition had a number of successes. For example, “wife beating and lack of family support decreased 82%, drunkenness decreased 55.3%, assault decreased 53.1%, vagrancy decreased 52.8%, disorderly conduct decreased 51.5%, delinquency decreased 50.0%”. (prohibitionists.org) Inmates in jails and crime rates lessened as well. “The number of inmates in jails and prisons decreased 75% ; and many correctional institutions were closed entirely. The national crime rate (excluding Chicago) declined 38% ; in Chicago, the crime rate declined 25% (despite some well-publicized criminal events)”. (prohibitionists.org). In Prohibition, there were a lot more positive aspects. “General domestic complaints decreased by two-thirds”. (prohibitionists.org) There were positives in the local areas in the 1920s during Prohibition as well. “Attendance at churches and schools became more regular, county hospital death rates were historically low, real estate...

Words: 680 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The1950

...banned alcohol. World War 1 also supported for temperance it seemed unpatriotic to use corn, wheat and barley to make alcohol when soldiers overseas needed bread. In 1919 the states then ratified the Eighteenth Amendment to the constitution, which was the banning of alcoholic beverages. It forbade the manufacture, distribution and sale of alcohol anywhere in the United States. This amendment had been passed largely on the strength of rural votes. Then congress passed the Volstead Act a law that officially enforced the amendment. People that said the ban of alcohol was the right thing were advocates of prohibition. They were called “dry’s”. They said it improved individuals; strengthen families and then society on a whole. It was also that liver disease and so forth declined during this prohibition. The “wets” also known as the opponents of prohibition countered that the ban of alcohol did not stop people from drinking. They said prohibition created hypocrisy and increased organized crime. The Volstead act did not stop Americans from drinking but it did stop them from buying it legally. So instead people made homemade alcohol or smuggled it in from other countries. Bootleggers sold illegal alcohol to consumers. In different cities they were secret establishments known as speakies , attracted eager customers for alcohol. The government tried their best to stop illegal alcohol but it got too out of control, the demand for alcohol was too great, and there weren’t enough policemen...

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Scopes Trial In The 1920's

...Throughout the decades, we suffer through individual cultural challenges. About 95 years ago, the conflicts America experienced had a lot do with new developments. These were revisions such as prohibitions, immigration conflicts, and differences in beliefs. Prohibitions that involved alcohol was in effect. Women had new roles, which was more of an advancement than a challenge. The Scopes Trial was also significant in the 1920s, which was in relation to the theory of evolution. Although, as time progresses, we still face cultural challenges to this this present day. During the 1920s, a majority of the people in America believed that alcohol devoted to society’s corruption and immoralities. Therefore, individuals and/or groups began to work in unions to outlaw alcohol. Religious groups and conservatives especially favored the liquor ban due to their beliefs. With this reasoning, they characterized immigrants as alcoholics to favor their cause. Therefore, a great number of states passed the anti-alcohol law. Although in the other hand, people that were against this liquor ban somewhat compromised with the law. They started smuggling alcohol, which followed to being a criminal empire inclusive of gangsters. New opportunities were finally achievable for women in the 1920s. Women were finally allowed to do most jobs that were already possible for men. The 19th Amendment was also passed, allowing women to finally vote and run for office. Although they were compensated less money for...

Words: 557 - Pages: 3