Free Essay

Welfare Regimes

In: Social Issues

Submitted By deychenc
Words 311
Pages 2
In my opinion, the priority and precedence placed on economic growth and policy over social policy is the key characteristic of the “productivist” welfare regime which translates into the low level of public expenditure on social welfare. Although there are some levels of spending in basic education and health, these are social investments in human capital in anticipation that these investments will make citizens productive, who will then contribute to the economic growth. This highlights the larger role for families and households in providing welfare as the states are focused more on regulation, nation building and legitimizing the regime than actual provision of welfare itself.
Institutional arrangements where there is deep reliance on the community and family relationships to meet people’s security and welfare needs is the key characteristic of informal welfare regime. This reliance on relationship is hierarchical and unbalanced and reinforces patron – client relationships. The power imbalance in the relationship makes the people vulnerable and also breeds inequality in the society. The people are forced into situations of long term dependency for short term welfare and benefit because of which it becomes difficult for other actors like the civil society to step in and pressure for social policy reforms.
Insecurity welfare regime is characterized by high level of instability, conflict and weak state structures and institutional arrangements which impede various forms of stable or informal security mechanisms from emerging. Thus people have no access to formal or informal welfare structures. This characteristic leads to poor welfare outcomes and high levels of insecurity among the people. The people are forced to rely on themselves and their household for support and also forced to negotiate the short term welfare solutions in the absence of any welfare solution that is long term. There is a struggle for state legitimacy and small group of elites and international actors dominate the political system.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Integration and Development

...markets exist, simply taking forward positions in the complementary assets may suffice to capture much of the spillovers. Even after the innovation is announced, the innovator might still be able to build or buy complementary capacities at competitive prices if he innovation has iron clad legal protection (i.e. if the innovation is in a tight appropriability regime). However, if the innovation is not tightly protected and once "out" is easy to imitate, then securing control of complementary capacities is likely to be the key success factor, particularly if those capaci- ties are in fixed supply - so called "bottlenecks." Distribution and specialized manufacturing com- petences often become bottlenecks. As a practical matter, however, an innovator may not have the time to acquire or build the complementary assets that ideally it would like to control. This is particularly true when imitation is easy, so that timing becomes critical. Additionally, the innovator may simply not have the financial resources to proceed. The implications of timing and cash constraints are summarized in fig. 9. Accordingly, in weak appropriability regimes innovators need to rank complementary assets as to their importance. If the complementary assets are critical, ownership is warranted, although if the...

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Essay on Methodology Used in the Article “the Effects of U.S. Foreign Assistance on Democracy Building, 1990-2003”

...providing of democracy funds and following democratic outcomes in receiver countries. Authors assumes that U.S. promotion of democratization in different countries is useful: foreign assistance could be helpful and democratization could be heterogenic. Thus, the first hypothesis suggests that foreign NGO can stimulate democratic development. Although there isn’t proper analysis of specific mechanisms which allows international forces facilitate democratization within countries, authors argue that democracy can be promoted by international forces both indirectly and directly. Concerning the matter of causality, indirect promotion works through changing some of structural parameters, which could be prerequisites for resting or transforming regime while direct promotion is a support of specific agents who will contend with domestic autocrats. Also this work hypothesizes that “democratization need not be a purely internally driven phenomenon”. Authors employ a statistical technique known as “hierarchical longitudinal growth modeling,” also known as "individual growth curves," in order to assess the...

Words: 689 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Is a Revolution?

...society. Revolutions are mainly caused because of social and economic inequalities between classes causing the oppressed masses to become disillusioned with extreme excesses of the ruling classes. They then come together and revolt against the existing ruler or regime, often in a bloody movement. This is certainly true when describing the French Revolution and the Bolshevik Revolution, which not only brought about regime change through violent mass mobilization, but also overhauled the social, economic institutions of the time. So a revolution is essentially a struggle in which the holder of a power loses that power against their will. Aristotle’s view on revolutions was rather confined than its modern day interpretation. He suggested the doctrine of ‘stasis’ as a reason for revolution and decline of institutions, ‘stasis’ being an arrest of the political processes of a healthy polis leading to its political system breaking own and degenerating into violence and internal warfare. For him, the condition that led to all revolutions was the desire of the many for equality versus the desire of the minority for effective superiority. In an overview of Book V of ‘Politics’, it can be gathered that inequalities in a regime such as disagreements over justice, profiteering, fear, contempt, dissimilarity, arrogance of rulers and too much power all led to social conflict. He proposed that, in democracies, revolutions often occurred because of irresponsible behaviour of the popular rulers...

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Democracy

... Democracies are on average richer than non-democracies, are less likely to go to war and have a better record of fighting corruption. More fundamentally, democracy lets people speak their minds and shape their own and their children’s futures. That so many people in so many different parts of the world are prepared to risk so much for this idea is testimony to its enduring appeal. Yet these days the exhilaration generated by events like those in Kiev is mixed with anxiety, for a troubling pattern has repeated itself in capital after capital. The people mass in the main square. Regime-sanctioned thugs try to fight back but lose their nerve in the face of popular intransigence and global news coverage. The world applauds the collapse of the regime and offers to help build a democracy. But turfing out an autocrat turns out to be much easier than setting up a viable democratic government. The new regime stumbles, the economy flounders and the country finds itself in a state at least as bad as it was before. This is what happened in much of the Arab spring, and also in Ukraine’s Orange revolution a decade ago. In 2004 Mr Yanukovych was ousted from office by vast street protests, only to be re-elected to the presidency (with the help of huge amounts of Russian money) in 2010, after the opposition politicians who replaced him turned out to...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Migration Towards Eu: Welfare Magnet

...Academic year 2014-2015 Migration towards Europe and the “welfare magnet”: “Determinants of Turkish Migration to EU-15” Master dissertation Student Kristýna Jedličková Home institution Vysoká škola ekonomická v Praze Supervisor prof. Claire Naiditch Submission date September 2015 Acknowledgment I would like to express my sincerest thanks to prof. Claire Naiditch for her guidance, support, patience and valuable recommendations. Declaration of authorship I, Kristýna Jedličková hereby declare that the thesis Migration towards Europe and the “welfare magnet” was written by myself and that all presented results are my own, unless stated otherwise. The literature sources are listed in the Literature Review section. Prague, September 30th, 2015 ........................................................ Signature Key words Migration, welfare magnet, public social spending, inflows of migrants, EU’s migratory policy, European welfare system, Turkish welfare system, Turkey, EU-15, gravity model, fixed effect, random effect, Hausman test, country specific fixed effect, time specific fixed effect. Abstract The purpose of this thesis is to analyse which factors drive migration from Turkey towards Europe and whether the welfare benefits play a major role in the decision making process. The analysis is based on a gravitation model of migration in log-log form. The FE and RE methods were employed as estimation techniques and the Hausman test enabled to distinguish them. The present...

Words: 14837 - Pages: 60

Premium Essay

1. It Has Been Claimed That Social Welfare Is Not About Promoting the Recipients’ Wellbeing but About Promoting Their Compliance with Particular Standards of Behaviour. Critically Discuss This Claim with Reference to

...Some have argued that social welfare should be about promoting recipient wellbeing. However, others have argued that in recent times welfare programs are more about controlling the behaviour of welfare recipients. This essay will examine the history of welfare programs to women since the initiation of the post-war welfare state under Labour Prime Minister Chifley to ascertain whether recent development in these programs are more about providing for recipient’s wellbeing or rather about trying to make them comply with certain standards of accepted behaviour. Chifley argued that it was the “duty and responsibility of the community, and particularly those more fortunately placed, to see that our less fortunate fellow citizens are protected from those shafts of fate which leave them helpless and without hope”. He continued the labour movement would fight to ensure a future “free from want, insecurity and misery” (Chifley, quoted in Beilharz, 1994). Chifley was stating that those in need should be the recipients of welfare without them having to comply with any requirements to perform to certain behavioural standards. This approach set the scene for the expansion of the welfare state from the post-war period through its expansion in the Whitlam years until its principles were challenged by the Howard Government in the 1990s. During this time welfare benefits grew and were extended to new groups of people considered in need. The labour party supported the notion of deservedness...

Words: 1713 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Book Review of Tbodr

...Stability and Performance 3 THE BREAKDOWN OF DEMOCRATIC REGIMES: CRISIS, BREAKDOWN & REEQUILIBRATION Introduction Many existing literature on the collapse of the democracy concentrated on rises of nondemocratic political powers or the fundamental structural tension that lead to the breakdown of democratic institution. In this publication, author, Juan J. Linz is giving attention to dynamic of the political process of breakdown by referring to tragic consequences of democratic collapse in German, Spain and Chile. This attention has begun during the author childhood where he was concerned with the fate of Spanish democracy, the fate his as citizen. This concern later had shared with Alfred Stepan who writes a dissertation on the breakdown of democracy in Brazil. Both of them get support and attention from many people and agencies. The focus firstly gets attention at the Seventh World Congress of Sociology at Varna, Bulgaria in 1970. In year 1973, with the support from the Concilium of International and Area Studies of Yale University, and the Joint Committee on Latin America of Social Science Research Council and the American Council of Learned Societies, Linz and Stepan chaired the conference. With the contribution of their publication later on has influence other contributors to give attention to the related issues. In year 1978, Linz individually had published a book regarding The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes: Crisis, Breakdown & Reequilibration. In this publication...

Words: 1773 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Democracy

...to its enduring appeal. Yet these days the exhilaration generated by events like those in Kiev is mixed with anxiety, for a troubling pattern has repeated itself in capital after capital. The people mass in the main square. Regime-sanctioned thugs try to fight back but lose their nerve in the face of popular intransigence and global news coverage. The world applauds the collapse of the regime and offers to help build a democracy. But turfing out an autocrat turns out to be much easier than setting up a viable democratic government. The new regime stumbles, the economy flounders and the country finds itself in a state at least as bad as it was before. This is what happened in much of the Arab spring, and also in Ukraine’s Orange revolution a decade ago. In 2004 Mr Yanukovych was ousted from office by vast street protests, only to be re-elected to the presidency (with the help of huge amounts of Russian money) in 2010, after the opposition politicians who replaced him turned out to be just as hopeless. Between 1980 and 2000 democracy experienced a few setbacks, but since 2000 there have been many Democracy is going through a difficult time. Where autocrats have been driven out of office, their opponents have mostly failed to create viable democratic regimes. Even in established democracies, flaws in the system have become worryingly visible and disillusion with politics is rife. Yet just a few years ago democracy looked as though it would dominate the world. In the second half...

Words: 618 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Why Did Enlightenment Philosophes Want to Reform the Ancien Regime

...Enlightenment philosophes want to reform the ancien regime? The philosophes believed that the ancient regime was unjust and inefficient at creating a fair society, and thought the application of rational analysis to all activities would help reform the system that created such an unequal distribution of wealth and power. Their particular ideas of reform focused around those at the top of the hierarchal structure, such as the church and the king, as well as abolishing the structures based upon superstition. One reason the philosophes wanted to reform the ancien regime was that they believe it gave the church undue power. As the clergy withheld the position of the first estate-being at the top of the hierarchal society only under the king- they thought that the group were wealthy, corrupt and intolerant. Despite only owning 15% of the land, they still took in a vast amount of money through obligatory tithes and rents, despite not having to pay any tax themselves. The only money they did have to give was Dons Gratuits, meaning payment to the crown that they set the figure for themselves. Corruption throughout the church was rife, with plurality and consequently absenteeism occurring throughout France and leading to Bishops earning two incomes, whilst a vast majority of the population lived a poor, peasantry life. The philosophes saw this unfair behanviour as a result of the churches highly regarded position within the ancien regime, and saw this as a necessary point of reform. This...

Words: 662 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

To What Extent Have Gender Inequalities Been Reinforced, Rather Than Reduced by Social Policy in Germany and Sweden

...radically improved the position of women, mothers and single parents in economic forerunners such as Germany and Sweden, with the gender gap being arguably non-existent if compared to previous generations. However, it is still apparent that there are startling differences between the two countries in terms of welfare benefits and social policy affecting men and women, with neither achieving the desired goal of an egalitarian society. Within his ground-breaking study on welfare state regime-types, Gøsta Esping-Andersen argues that gender imbalances within social policy is the outcome and production of the specific welfare-regime type the state possesses, suggesting that whether traditionalist or socialist in their views, welfare states dominate policies, consequently determining which social group benefits such as the bourgeoisie or proletariat, the majority or minority or men or women for example. (Esping-Andersen, 1990: 24) The first chancellor of Germany, Otto Von Bismarck created a social insurance system in 1873, of which became a pioneering model for the basis of the German welfare state, which to this day is still dominated by his ideas on welfare benefits. “Bismarck was motivated to introduce social insurance in Germany both in order to promote well-being of workers in order to keep the German economy operating at maximum efficiency, and to starve off call for more radical socialist alternatives.” (SSA, 2012) Bismarck emphasised the importance of a...

Words: 4597 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Social Welfare

...Social Welfare: Pros and Cons Melissa Pugh Post University Online Social Welfare: Pros and Cons The ever-winding tendrils of hardship are impacting individuals who through the ups and downs of life; have become disabled, unemployed, or perhaps senior citizens. Social welfare is available for those who may find themselves in these unfortunate positions. While working at a Milwaukee University, Julia Doyle’s mother was killed by a senseless drunk-driving accident in 1990. Driven by determination, Doyle saw to it that justice was served however this required many requests for leave and because of this; she was terminated although she had invested ten years at the university. Julia Doyle went on to have a total of three children with little or no support from the father; deprived of many necessities, she became a recipient of welfare. She also admits to drug usage during her fall from grace. Nevertheless, for many, social welfare provokes dependency and others like Julia Doyle (Pomeroy, 2008) utilized its benefits to gain a life of financial stability. According to Flynn (2013), “Welfare is a term used to describe systems by which government agencies provide economic assistance, goods, and services to persons who are unable to care for themselves. Welfare is a form of social policy. Welfare programs serve as social safety nets.” Provision is made for member via social policy, social programs, and welfare enterprises. Upon the transfer of...

Words: 1281 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients

...Drug Testing Welfare Recipients It is assumed by many that people who are receiving public assistance funds are using this money to support their alcohol and or drug addictions. Is drug testing to receive public assistance an answer to this problem? Would making this a condition of eligibility actually push people with serious substance abuse and or dependency problems farther away from the help and treatment they need? Federal Welfare Reform The Federal Welfare reform act which, was passed in the mid 1990’s has changed the way our system addresses these issues. PRWORA (Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act) provided some distinctive features to address the issues, and changed the idea that there was universal entitlement for all, and helped to reinforce the notion that there is a class of the deserving poor. In 2001 California implemented the policies required and created our version of the TANF (Temporary Aid to Needy Families) called Cal-WORKS (California’s Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids program.) This program has allowed for rules to be implemented such as time limits, work requirements and the availability of substance abuse treatment. (Newell, 2011) The population and the substances. According to the National Poverty Center (2004) the numbers have been overstated and the number of people that are on welfare and are abusing substances are lower than originally estimated. The studies have varied widely in their...

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Hurts in Racism

...The hurts in Racism Racism is like a disease, an epidemic that afflicts people to varying degrees. Some suffer from acute racism; others suffer from moderate racism and mild racism. Vanessa and Helen being both African-Americans suffered a kind of racism. Vanessa suffered mild racism while Helen suffered an acute one. In Vanessa’s presentation, she expressed that research on stereotypes has shown that black American women are viewed as being lazy, and live on welfare. This is not the case for everyone as this does not describe her. She grew up in a middle class family. These stereotypes certainly still exist. It is no surprise that, the GOP presidential candidate, Rick Santorum, speaking on African-Americans and welfare benefits, recently declared (and later denied) that “I don’t want to make black people’s lives better by giving them somebody else’s money; I want to give them the opportunity to go out and earn the money.” The NAACP blasted Santorum for “inaccurate and outrageous” remarks that “lifts up old race-based stereotypes about public assistance.” On the other hand, Helen suffered racism in the school system by the inappropriate card that was passed around the school. She failed to keep quiet and voiced her concerns about the negative perception of her race. Traumatized by this experience she decided to leave the teaching job that she loves. She lost her trust and hope in the school system. This also brought memories of her father’s negative experience...

Words: 324 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sociology

...director at the Department for Work and Pensions. Concern was expressed that Ingeus had underbid more experienced providers: price was a clinching factor in the official scoring system, whereas bizarrely previous performance was not scored at all. 2: The greatly disappointed voluntary sector will be relegated to sub-contracting. The big companies will hand down their difficult cases, such as addicts, ex-prisoners or the mentally ill – creaming 20%-30% off the top in "management fees" 3: Among the winners is A4E (Action for Employment) – hardly surprising as its founder, Emma Harrison CBE, was named by David Cameron as his workless families tsar. As the Observer revealed, she and her husband have a joint income of some £1.4m from their welfare-to-work empire. 4: The verdict was pretty damning. Not only did contracted companies miss their targets by miles – but the DWP's own Jobcentre Plus outscored them easily. The committee's report is remarkably trenchant: " The performance by the mainly private-sector providers was universally poor … £94m was spent on employment support that did not deliver additional jobs … Private providers have seriously underperformed against their contracts and their success rates are worse than Jobcentre Plus even though private contractors work in easier areas." Despite that, the clamour has begun for jobcentres to be outsourced to private companies. That would put a stop to embarrassing comparisons between the two sectors. There...

Words: 753 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Taxation References and Bibliography

...html [Accessed: 22 Feb 2013]. Newstatesman.com (2012) The benefit cap: what does it mean and why is it unfair?. [online] Available at: http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/the-staggers/2012/01/benefit-cap-children-support [Accessed: 22 Feb 2013]. Ramesh, R. (2012) Poorest 400,000 families worse off under universal credit, finds report. [online] Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/nov/22/poorest-families-worse-universal-credit [Accessed: 22 Feb 2013]. UK, T. (2012) Universal Credit Could 'Backfire' On Poor People, Think-Tank Warns. [online] Available at: http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/09/17/universal-credit-could-backfire-on-poor-people-think-tank-warns_n_1889449.html [Accessed: 22 Feb 2013]. Welfare reform | The Housing Executive. 2013. Welfare reform | The Housing Executive. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.nihe.gov.uk/welfare_reform. [Accessed 22 February...

Words: 253 - Pages: 2