Were Other Employees at Bill Garbo’s Company Impacted by His Decision to Hire Amber? Explain How.

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ehabzerieni
Words 313
Pages 2
Name : Ihab Ali Al Zarieni
Student #: 1982
Subject: Human Capital Management in Organizations

An Ethical Dilemma – Case Study – Week 3

1. From an ethical standpoint, was Mr. Garbo wrong to hire Amber? Was Amber’s father wrong to ask Mr. Garbo to help out his daughter?

Ans 1 :

From an ethical standpoint Mr. Garbo and Amber's father both of them were wrong because Mr. Allen Davis should not use his position as a EVP to find a job to his daughter which may effect and reflect on future relation with Mr. Garbo from business point at the same time Mr.Garbo hire her aiming to have more business in future for his company and he did not follow the regular recruitment processes .
Noting that both of them were not looking for his company benefits, and it might be reflected negatively on their company and their relations too

2. Does Amber have an ethical responsibility in this case? If so, explain

Ans 2:

Amber from beginning knows that Mr. Grabo hire her not for her qualification and he did not follow the proper processes for recruitment , beside the salary was higher than her colleague who were more experience and more qualified than her but with all this factors she did not try or to give efforts to learn more about the new job or trying to improve her skills and knowledge to handle the new task and play her role on the company
But in return she had ruined the internal and external relation of both the firms. Due to her unorthodox activities, she had spoiled environmental relationship among employee-employer relationship. And a result of her nature of taking things lightly and irresponsibility in the work would spoil the business and friendship between her Dad and her company. And eventually she would become a danger for her dad’s job…...

Similar Documents

How Religion Is Impacted by Science Extending the Lifespan of a Human

...Table of Contents Abstract 2 Introduction 3 The Impact Medical Technology has on Religion 6 How Religion Will Respond Given Their Principles and Doctrines 7 The anti-aging therapies are raising controversies in science and religion 12 Conclusion 13 References 14   Abstract People figured out early on that living longer would be beneficial if they had the chance to do so. They would be able to spend more time with their friends and family, have more time in life to accomplish things they set out to do, and they could simply enjoy more of what life has to offer. This is a great mindset for anyone to have since life is a beautiful thing and worth living. With all of the advanced medical technology on this specific subject and the new findings that are constantly being done to prolong the human lifespan, we start to enter into the area of what is ethically right and wrong and wonder how much is too much? There are many different forms of medical treatment that can save someone’s life. This will vary from medicine to surgery and many things in between. Not everyone will agree on some of the techniques used, but most people understand why someone would want to save their life. Since people will try to save their own lives if they are dying, many scientists believe that there is no difference in trying to extend a life through medicine, or trying to create a life from another person through a cloning system. This is where the tables turn from helping mankind,...

Words: 3538 - Pages: 15

Explain How You Would Communicate This Decision to Your Employees or to Your Supervisors (Depending on the Decision You Have Selected) to Ensure That Future Situations Like This Do Not Occur Again. in Your Answer,

...The NLRB has made findings regarding the use of employee posts on Social Media sites to discipline or terminate those employees. Typically these cases occur when an employee posts “negative” information about their current employer or boss. Sometimes these are “public” and other times the employer uses “spies” or “fake friending” to see the Facebook page of the employee. Find at least one case or article online regarding this topic, and briefly explain the facts of the case, and the determination of the NLRB as to whether the employee was properly or improperly disciplined or terminated as a result of their use of Social Media to complain about, criticize, or publicly bash their company or boss. Provide the citation to the article you discover. (Use the term “concerted activity” in your query or search to help you find one of these cases.) (20 points) 2. Do you agree with the decision of the NLRB or court in the case you describe in question #1 above? Why or why not? (1-3 paragraphs). (10 points) 3. Assume this case happened at a place you have worked in the past, or where you work now (or want to work.) Give an example of how the decision in the case above could lead to better or worse employee relations in your company. (5 points) 4. Explain how you would communicate this decision to your employees or to your supervisors (depending on the decision you have selected) to ensure that future situations like this do not occur again. In your answer, determine whether......

Words: 326 - Pages: 2

How the Imf Impacted the Caribbean Business Environment

...THE UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST INDIES (CAVE HILL) CAMPUS FACULTY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS FINA3010 – SUPERVISED RESEARCH PROJECT How Has The International Monetary Fund Impacted the Caribbean Business Environment? Student Name: William Franklyn April 1st, 2014 ID#:407002804 Professor: Mr. Wilberne Persuad Contents Introduction: 3 Literature Review: 4 Background: 4 Further look at the IMF: 4 The World Bank: 5 Loans facilities offered by the IMF: 5 Definition of Caribbean Business Environment (The Small Open Economy Model): 6 Characteristics of the Caribbean Business Environment: 6 Definition of a Financial Crisis: 7 What causes a Financial Crisis to occur? 8 Conclusion: 9 Descriptive analysis 10 Methodology 15 Conclusion 16 Social Instability: 16 Further look at the impact of the IMF’s procedures/objectives: 16 Potential Threat 17 Policy Responses: 18 Internally: 18 Externally: 18 Bibliography: 20 Introduction: This research paper aims to analyze the process of The International Monetary Fund in Barbados and how the country was affected by their guidelines. Barbados has been said to be one of the developing countries within the Caribbean Business Environment. However due to external shocks as well as weak domestic policies, Barbados was forced to ask the IMF for their aid as a last option, to stabilize the country’s economy. This research paper intends to......

Words: 3669 - Pages: 15

Ethical Dilemma

...wrong to hire Amber? Was Amber’s father wrong to ask Mr. Garbo to help out his daughter? Mr. Garbo considered hiring Amber keeping in view the commercial benefits attached with it but from ethical standpoint he was wrong in doing so. We further noticed in the case study that his decision in long run turned out to be more damaging than beneficial for the organization. • Amber was over paid that means extra burden for the company. • Amber realized that the biased decision was made under pressure of maintaining the sales generated due purchases from Mr. Garbo’s organization by her father’s company and this led her to be lazy and commanding in her work. • She started taking longer lunch hours and develop habit of arriving late for work and leave early. Mr. Allen Davis is also to be blamed equally for the situation because the influence used by him was not only ethically wrong but also jeopardize the business relationship between two organizations and also put the career and development of Amber at stake. • Amber started taking work for granted. • Mr. Allen created a wrong example for her that she might practice for rest of her life. • Mr. Allen’s help resulted in her daughter not paying attention and hence not learning from her work and that would eventually result into a career block for her. Q1) Does Amber has any ethical responsibility in this case? If so explain. Amber being an intelligent individual soon realized that she got the job due to his father’s...

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Case Study

...3 Q1. From an Ethical standpoint, was Mr Garbo wrong to hire Amber? Was Amber’s father wrong to ask Mr Garbo to help out his daughter? Ans1. From an HR perspective, both were wrong. First of all, Mr Allen Davis being a responsible person who was positioned as Executive Vice president shouldn’t have utilized his business relation for his own betterment. Secondly, though Mr Garbo was aiming for future retention of his client. He shouldn’t have offered a job to Ms Amber without following regular recruitment process. As a result Mr. Garbo created a none equality among his employees which would lead to non-retention of productive & profitability work force. In short, shortcuts in doing business would not be favourable to any organization Q2. Does Amber have an ethical responsibility in this case? If so, explain. Ans2. As Ms Amber was very well aware about the reason behind her intake. And the intention of Mr Garbo to hire her in a higher pay scale. At least she should have made an attempt to prove herself as a better employee and retain the confidentiality. But in return she had ruined the internal and external relation of both the firms. Due to her unorthodox activities, she had spoiled environmental relationship among employee-employer relationship. And a result of her nature of taking things lightly and irresponsibility in the work would spoil the business and friendship between her Dad and her company. And eventually she would become a danger for her......

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

How Has the Nsa's Surveillance Impacted the Economy?

...How Has the NSA'S Surveillance Impacted the Economy? Southern New Hampshire University English 123: Composition II How Has the NSA'S Surveillance Impacted the Economy? Introduction The Guardian aired a report on the surveillance programs of the National Security Agency over one year ago. The report based on leaked information from one of the agency’s contractors named Edward Snowden. The national opinions from several interested parties concentrates on simplistic debates evaluating the tradeoff between individual privacy and national security. However, it is an important time for the government and other stakeholders to begin weighing the benefits and costs associated with the surveillance more carefully. In spite of the strong defense by intelligence officials in favor of the NSA programs, the officials fail to table any credible evidence in support of the benefits they suggest. In fact, some initial analysis of the programs indicates that the benefits are dubious. It is true that the United States is a target for terrorist and other malicious groups, state officials often use the threat as an excuse to conduct and promote the activities of the National Security Agency. It may be beneficial in the context of security, but the surveillance programs also jeopardize the activities and operations of other organizations and individuals within the United States. The impact of the activities of the NSA on other parties is a cause for an analysis of the economic effects......

Words: 1851 - Pages: 8

How to Effectively Merge Employees

...How to Effectively Merge Employees Shane Santiff Shane.santiff@comcast.net GM 591 Leadership & Organization Behavior Hajar Sanders May 19, 2011 Overview of Organization: The organization that I will be doing my project on is Targa Resources LLC. Targa is a publically held organization that is in the Upstream and Downstream segment of the Oil & Gas Industry. Targa main processes are fractionation, wholesale and logistics. Targa was formed in 2004 when it purchased two plants from Conoco Phillips. In late 2005 Targa purchased the whole midstream division from Dynegy Inc. With Targa’s purchase of Dynegy Midstream Services, Targa went from a company with 150 employees to over 1500 employees overnight. With this they needed to create a cohesive environment for both of the employees, without having much turnover. During the whole process as Targa met with the Dynegy employees that were part of the sale, they had promised many things ranging from benefits, awards, employee relations and incentives. When the purchase was complete and the Dynegy employees came over to Targa it was realized that all of what Targa’s management had said about the company and what they promised to do was inaccurate. Targa’s management was not impressed with Dynegy employees and treated them as if they had no clue what was going on. My career began at Dynegy in 1999 and I was a part of the sale to Targa. At Dynegy I was in charge of the accounting for......

Words: 2910 - Pages: 12

How to Merge Employees

...whole midstream division from Guilty Inc. With Rabit’s purchase of Guilty Midstream Services, Rabit went from a company with 150 employees to over 1500 employees overnight. With this they needed to create a cohesive environment for both of the employees, without having much turnover. During the whole process as Rabit met with the Guilty employees that were part of the sale, they had promised many things ranging from benefits, awards, employee relations and incentives. When the purchase was complete and the Guilty employees came over to Rabit it was realized that all of what Rabit’s management had said about the company and what they promised to do was inaccurate. Rabit’s management was not impressed with Guilty employees and treated them as if they had no clue what was going on. My career began at Guilty in 1999 and I was a part of the sale to Rabit. At Guilty I was in charge of the accounting for a few processing plants. When we moved to Rabit, our department became the Financial Accounting department which was in charge of the final product being produced to the shareholders. When we merged our 2 companies together, Rabit’s financial accounting department only consisted of 3 employees, and we had 5 that came from Guilty. Rabit bought the accounting program that Guilty was using since as we were bigger than they were. The Rabit employees were not impressed with us, and did anything they could to put us down. Problem Statement: Rabit......

Words: 2889 - Pages: 12

How Do You Hire?

...How do you hire? This interview of John M. Doe, the chief executive of the McGraw-Hill Companies, was conducted and condensed by Adam Bryant. Q. How do you hire? A. I hire 100% based on fit. Fit with our company, our values, our mission and vision. Fit with our people and culture. But I don’t just ask the candidate about these things. They may have memorized a script, in which case we are both wasting our time. Instead, I ask them about specific situations in which they must have acted in a way that indicates a good fit with us, e.g., tell me about a time when you had a conflict with a superior. How did you act? What did you do to fix the problem? As they answer the question, I am keenly looking for a story that flows well, that makes sense; I am trying to understand their thought process and why they went from A to B to C, and also how they did it. I have learned through the years that by interviewing candidates this way, it really allows them to shed off their mask, so pervasive in corporate America, and come clean. They know I expect nothing but the truth from them, and they know I am dead serious about the interview. As CEO of McGraw, there are a million other things I could be doing, but instead I have the unique privilege and opportunity of interviewing a fresh-faced 22-year old for one of the most junior positions at our company. Please tell me, why do you want to come work for McGraw?...

Words: 273 - Pages: 2

Cases Where Moving and Storage Companies Were Sued for Some Type of Fraud Against the Consumer and/or Against Other Businesses

...PART I – 5 Cases where moving and storage companies were sued for some type of fraud against the Consumer and/or against other Businesses These group of cases represent consumers in lawsuits against moving companies and/or arbitration. Lawsuits against moving companies may include damages to property, breach of contract, tariff or regulatory violations, and hostage loads. * The Attorney General's Office filed a lawsuit against Moving Max in July 2014, alleging they "engaged in a predatory bait and switch scheme," billed customers for "bogus charges," and then "threatened to drive off and retain the customers personal belongings unless and until payment was made by cash or money order." Under the terms of the Final Consent Judgment (entered February 13, 2015), that concluded a lawsuit filed in State Superior Court in Bergen County, the owner of Moving Max, Inc., a moving and storage company based in Fair Lawn, and the owner’s father, are permanently barred from owning or working in such businesses in New Jersey. In addition, as part of the settlement, 18 consumers who complained that their possessions were held until they paid substantially higher moving costs than agreed to, will be reimbursed for their losses. Case Cite: John J. Hoffman v. Moving Max, Inc., et al. Bergen County New Jersey Case No.: BER-C-203-14 http://nj.gov/oag/newsreleases15/Moving-Max-Oziel.pdf * Shurgard Storage Centers, Inc. (plaintiff) and Safeguard Self Storage, Inc.......

Words: 982 - Pages: 4

Should Companies Monitor Their Employees Social Media

...Should Companies Monitor Their Employees' Social Media? In recent years people have had their lives turned upside down over social media comments, videos, or pictures. Imagine this: A group of friends on vacation and have a good time. They laugh, drink, and take pictures with their cell phones. One of these pictures shows a woman holding a cocktail in each hand and smiling. One of her friends posts this picture on Facebook; her friends share the image. Unfortunately, the woman holding the cocktails in the photo is a schoolteacher. Though her Facebook page is private, she had befriended some of the teachers at her school. When the teacher’s principal finds out about the photos, she is told to resign or face suspension. According to Jeffrey Mello, “Employers face an ethical question relative to whether, as part of due diligence in the hiring process, they should scour online networks and sources to discover information about prospective hires” (168). Reviewing a job applicants’ social media presence may soon become a standard hiring procedure. In the article “Employer Access to Employee Social Media: Applicant Screening, ‘Friend’ Requests and Workplace Investigations”, it mentions a survey of managers and human resource professionals in which over 43 percent of employers used social media sites to research job applicants (Crespo and Lyon 8). It also states that employers’ interest in employees’ social media accounts extended beyond hiring. Many companies seek to leverage......

Words: 1673 - Pages: 7

Describe and Explain How and Why the London Docklands Were in Need of Rebranding

...Describe and explain how and why the London Docklands were in need of rebranding Rebranding is “a change of image through the development of a marketing strategy.” The London Docklands needed rebranding because it in decline and couldn’t get out of the spiral of decay. This was occurring in the 1970s. A major reason why the Docklands were in decline was because of containerisation. This meant that the London Docks and the River Thames were not large enough for the sheer size of the new ships. As the ships couldn’t get into the docks trade and transport were restricted. Furthermore, the export and import opportunity ended up with other areas such as Felixstowe and Tilbury so therefore the Docklands were making massive losses. So since this industry was lost for the Docklands, the spiral of decay began, many people became unemployed. In 1985 there was 7600 people unemployed which was more than the half the population as the population was only 15500 people. This clearly shows how much the Docklands has suffered due to decline because the population in 1900 was 21000. Further factors of why the Docklands needed rebranding was that there were many narrow roads and high levels of congestion meaning that accessibility and transport was poor. Also the high levels of unemployment lead to an increase crime as people didn’t have disposable income. This also meant that poverty levels were at an all-time high above 50%. This further leads to fewer people leaving education with......

Words: 721 - Pages: 3

Organizational Behavior - Explain How Encouraging Engineers at Rwe Npower to Think Outside the Box Has Led to Increased Motivation for These Employees.

...performance to diagnose the possible causes of the unacceptable behavior. Q6. Has the captain considered all possible solutions to the problem? If not, what else might be done? Q7. Identify the stressors in John Breckenridge’s life. Which ones could he have prevented? Q8. What were the results of the stress? Would you consider these to be typical to stress situations and lifestyle choices John made, or was John Breckenridge unlucky? Q9. Assume you are a career coach retained by John Breckenridge to guide him through his next decisions. How would you recommend that John modify his lifestyle and behavior to reduce stress? Should he change jobs? Do you believe he is capable of reducing his stress alone? If not, where should he seek help? Q10. What type of team was formed here? Was it necessary, in your opinion? Q11. Use the team effectiveness model in Chapter 9 and related information in this chapter to identify the strengths and weaknesses of this team’s environment, design, and processes. Q12. Assuming that these four people must continue to work as a team, recommend ways to improve the team’s effectiveness. Q13. What barriers to effective communication existed in Aluminum Elements Corp? How did the author deal with these? What would you do differently? Q14. Identify and discuss why John was upset at the end of the case. What should the writer do at this time? Q15. Identify the different conflict episodes that exist in this case. Who was in......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Were Other Employees at Bill Garbo’s Company Impacted by His Decision to Hire Amber? Explain How.

...1982 Subject: Human Capital Management in Organizations An Ethical Dilemma – Case Study – Week 3 1. From an ethical standpoint, was Mr. Garbo wrong to hire Amber? Was Amber’s father wrong to ask Mr. Garbo to help out his daughter? Ans 1 : From an ethical standpoint Mr. Garbo and Amber's father both of them were wrong because Mr. Allen Davis should not use his position as a EVP to find a job to his daughter which may effect and reflect on future relation with Mr. Garbo from business point at the same time Mr.Garbo hire her aiming to have more business in future for his company and he did not follow the regular recruitment processes . Noting that both of them were not looking for his company benefits, and it might be reflected negatively on their company and their relations too 2. Does Amber have an ethical responsibility in this case? If so, explain Ans 2: Amber from beginning knows that Mr. Grabo hire her not for her qualification and he did not follow the proper processes for recruitment , beside the salary was higher than her colleague who were more experience and more qualified than her but with all this factors she did not try or to give efforts to learn more about the new job or trying to improve her skills and knowledge to handle the new task and play her role on the company But in return she had ruined the internal and external relation of both the firms. Due to her unorthodox activities, she had spoiled environmental......

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

An Ethical Dilemma

...Amber Davis had recently graduated from college with a degree in general business. Amber was quite bright, although her grades might lead a person to think otherwise. She had thoroughly enjoyed school—dating, tennis, swimming, and similar stimulating academic events. When she graduated from the university, she had not found a job. Her father was extremely upset when he discovered this, and he took it upon himself to see that Amber became employed. Her father, Allen Davis, was executive vice president of a medium-sized manufacturing firm. One of the people he contacted in seeking employment for Amber was Bill Garbo, the president of another firm in the area. Mr. Davis purchased many of his firm’s supplies from Garbo’s company. After telling Bill his problem, Allen was told to send Amber to Bill’s office for an interview. Amber did as instructed by her father and was surprised that before she left that day she had a job in the accounting department. Amber may have been lazy but she certainly was not stupid. She realized that this job was obtained because of the hope of future business from her father’s company. Although the work was not challenging, it paid better than the other jobs in the accounting department. It did not take long for the employees in the department to discover the reason she had been hired—Amber told them. When a difficult job was assigned to Amber, she normally got one of the other employees to do it, inferring that Mr. Garbo would be pleased with......

Words: 397 - Pages: 2