What Makes an Army Leader Practical

In: Miscellaneous

Submitted By DavidR213
Words 452
Pages 2
You will be given a case study where you will have to make a decision on which course of action to take.
Read the case study, apply the ethical decision making method using attached student handout, annotate your results for each step, and arrive at a course of action (COA) that is in compliance with the Army Ethic, Army Values, and Army leadership principles. To submit your answer, click on the title above, "What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise."
*
*
* CASE STUDY
“SFC Sharp and the SECRET Papers”
Recently, you received an assignment as the communications and electronics staff NCO of the 99th Infantry Battalion. You are replacing SFC Sharp who is on the promotion list to master sergeant and is departing for his next duty assignment in two weeks.
SFC Sharp’s welcome was impressive and he has done everything imaginable to ensure you’re getting off to a good start. Your Soldiers appear well trained, and your section sergeant, SGT Day, seems to know just about everything. You know you have big shoes to fill when SFC Sharp leaves because everyone seems to like and respect him. You’ve heard people say that he knows more about infantry operations than most infantry platoon sergeants.
SFC Sharp has cleaned out his desk and tells you to make yourself at home. Later this afternoon he is receiving an award for his service to the 99th. His farewell party is this evening at the club.
As you are setting up your things in your new desk, you discover some papers wedged between the wall and the side of the desk. You pull them out and discover that they are pages from a communication security book and marked “SECRET.” You attach a cover sheet to them and go into the security vault to talk to SGT Day.
SGT Day checks the inventory and destruction certificates and discovers that SFC Sharp certified the destruction of the book these pages came from two…...

Similar Documents

What Makes an Leader

...* What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise * Student Handout 1. Clearly define the ethical problem. a. The ethical problem in this situation is Whether or not I should be honest and do the right thing by turning in SFC Sharp for possibly destroying some “Secret” documents. 2. Employ applicable laws and regulations. a. Each Unit is responsible for coming up with their own SOP’s from Tactical movements to situations such as this one (Security breach), which should state proper disposal of documents that are considered Secret. SOP’s along with the unit’s regulations should also have Army regulations, so I would check my SOP to determine if proper disposal of classified information was conducted and what steps I need to take to ratify this situation. 3. Reflect on the ethical values and their ramifications. a. When I signed on that dotted line I also swore to live by the Army Values. Some Values that I think go with this situation are Loyalty, Duty, and Integrity. I need to be loyal to my country, unit and myself to do the right thing and report this situation. Not doing so is not showing my loyalty to my country and unit. It is also my duty to fulfill my obligations fully and report anything that could hurt my unit in any way, especially in a security breach situation. Never know if it may be some type of terrorist act. By choosing not to report this, it is undermining my Integrity. There should be...

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

What Makes an Army Leader Pe

...1. Clearly define the ethical problem. a. The ethical problem is weather I should do the “right” thing and report SFC Sharp. Who I understand to be an all around good leader. For a possible security breach without talking to SFC Sharp first to get all the facts straight. 2. Employ applicable laws and regulations. a. Every unit should have an SOP for dealing with the handling of secret material. I would check the SOP first and see what AR’s apply then go from there. 3. Reflect on the ethical values and their ramifications. a. The Army values that I find applicable to this situation are duty, loyalty, Integrity, and respect. I will take time to reflect on each of these values as I feel they apply. Duty: I believe that it is my duty to do the right thing here and gather all the facts of the situation from all parties involved. Before developing a course of action that may hinder the careers of both myself and SFC Sharp. Loyalty: My loyalties are both with my unit and the NCO corp. I feel I need to do what’s best for both. Integrity: If I do not take the time and develop the best COA for this situation. My character as an NCO will be compromised. Respect: Knowing that SFC Sharp is a good NCO I owe it to him to discuss this matter with him personally before taking it to higher. Because it may have been a simple mistake. One that may not have to jeopardize his career if it is handled internally first. 4. Consider the applicable morale...

Words: 531 - Pages: 3

Identify What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise

...First the ethical problem I see here is clear, both do not care about their duties as nco's. SFC Sharp did not think about his actions and the consequences that came with it. Does paper are secret and may have a lot of sensitive information. He suppose to destroyed but he failed. He preferred to hide it and do not say anything about it. With his actions he failed to accomplished the mission, he lost his Integrity and Honor. When the paper were found one of his soldier took the same approach as his leader SFC Sharp. His actions were the same hide it out, failing to apply the army values. They did the wrong thing because nobody were supervising, and do not accomplish the unit mission in accordance with AR 600-100. SFC Sharp can be punished by UCMJ ART. 92. Failure to obey order or regulations. The same for SGT Day, and also ART. 77. Principals. SFC Sharp failed to apply the Army values came with consequences, his soldier SGT Day did the same thing trying to cover for him having no Integrity at all. A true leader suppose to lead by example and SFC Sharp failed that too. The best actions to solve this situation is to talk to SGT Day first and explain to him the gravity of the situation. Talk about the Army regulations and also the Army values. Take the papers to the proper change of command and explain the situation to them with all the details involved. After a replace SFC Sharp I will gather everybody talk about Army values and what they mind and also give them a......

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

What Make an Army Leader

...1. Clearly define the ethical problem. Ans: The ethical problem is that SGT Day willingness to be dishonest and not report the security breach. 2. Employ applicable laws and regulations. Ans: . I would inform my supervisor of the findings and situation and while adhering to JER and Army regulations for dealing such issues. 3. Reflect on ethical values and their ramifications. Ans: I would counsel SGT Day for just wanting to cover up the findings, reminding him that not reporting the finding of the pages immediately could jeopardize our own career. 4. Consider other applicable moral principles. Ans:  I would to talk SFC Sharp and ask him why the pages weren’t destroyed two week ago and find out how to destroy them at this time. 5. Commit to and implement the best ethical solution. Ans:  I would then come up with a plan so that we can put in place a tracking system so that this situation doesn’t happen again. 6. Assess results and modify plan as required. Ans: Even though the civilian cleaning team doesn’t even clean our area and only our people ever come in here and the pages are from an alternate communications security book and were never used it’s still a Security risk.  After talking with SGT Day and having him check the inventory and destruction certificates and he discovered that SFC Sharp certified the destruction of the book these pages came from two weeks ago and also that there were no more pages. I would to talk SFC Sharp and ask him why the pages......

Words: 380 - Pages: 2

L304 - What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise

...What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise ■ Step 1: Clearly define the ethical problem There are documents marked as secret wedged between the wall and the side of the desk. Also, the documents were marked for destruction 2 weeks ago. This action was certified by SFC Sharp himself.  There is the possibility that the documents may have fallen off accidentally and subsequently overlooked. There is also the possibility that SFC Sharp was hiding these documents for dishonorable reasons. I also believe that SGT Day's opinion is flawed by the fact that he has worked with SFC Sharp for a while. I believe that he too is reacting unethically as he should be looking further into the issue as well instead of ignoring it. ■ Step 2: Employ applicable Laws and regulations FM 6-22: 4-32. If leaders inadvertently pass on bad information, they should correct it as soon as they discover the error. Leaders of integrity do the right thing not because it is convenient or because they have no other choice. They choose the path of truth because their character permits nothing less. AR 600-100: Chapter 2 - Responsibilities: 2–1. General Every leader will— a. Set and exemplify the highest ethical and professional standards as embodied in the Army Values. b. Accomplish the unit mission. Unit SOP's can also offer more policy's that should be followed ■ Step 3: Reflect on the ethical values and their...

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

What Makes a Leader

...What makes a leader? What is the outline or process as to how a person gains the characteristics of a leader? Throughout the history of America in hard times we have called on a leader. Traditionally this leader has come in the form of the president; Abraham Lincoln, Franklin D. Roosevelt, John F. Kennedy, Ronald Reagan, and now Barrack Obama. Is Obama, as an individual ready and capable of leading the country to another boom or will this new “American Jobs Act” plan implode beneath him? “You can talk the talk, but can you walk the walk?” Cliché as it may be, this statement holds much weight when thought about in regards to the “Jobs” speech, this statement or mindset must be followed. For an individual to be swept away with competent word command and a humble tone is concerning. What do individuals charge themselves when it comes to learning about political topics? We tend to have an over reliance on media, letting rhetorical style and safety blanket terms comfort us into feeling informed. The reality is not every person is honest, whether it’s the postman or the president we as humans possess a flaw, in that we are not perfect. I am not stating that the “Jobs” plan is deceitful, but that as citizens we must inform ourselves so that we do not misjudge information given to us. To achieve similar success to days past, we as a country need to start participating. Without the citizens there is no government, we operate as government for the people, by the people. Barrack...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

To What Extent Do You Think a Leader Can Make a Significant Difference to the Achievement of a Business’ Corporation Aims?

... leadership is often based on listening to the workforce. Employees whose contributions are valued are happier and more productive. Increased production leads to increased profits and achieving corporate aims. Richard Branson has been practically a household name in the U.K. for the past 20 years and is also well respected in the business world. He is the founder of the Virgin Group, known for record labels, mobile phones, airlines, and many other business ventures. He is responsible for a $5 billion empire consisting of over 200 different companies around the world. Branson is also known for his unique character and leadership styles, one who is not afraid to take risks, and believes that people are the foundation to his company's success. He appears to be a democratic leader. He truly feels that getting other peoples input and listening to what people have to say are a core value to him. He carries a notebook in his pocket all the time just in case he hears something interesting from people that he interacts with on any level. Whether it is an employee, friend, business partner or complete stranger, for him he knows that good ideas can come from anywhere and anytime. He has said before, "Virgin Group is an organization driven on informality and information, one that is bottom heavy rather then strangled by top level management", giving the impression that he listens to his people well below the management level. Branson will still ultimately make the top decision......

Words: 1969 - Pages: 8

Army Leadership Practical Exercise

... disloyal to SFC Sharp? If I was the SFC, how would I want the situation handled? I must also take into consideration that there may be more to the story. Perhaps this is an opportunity for me to instruct SGT Day on proper procedure and help him learn what is the right thing to do. The last Army value is "Courage". Do I have the courage to do what is right even if the SFC and the SGT will disapprove of the decision I have made? Yes. Yes I do. 5. Commit to and implement the best ethical solution. Before SFC Sharp leaves, I would go to him with this information and discuss with him how he would like this problem handled. 6. Assess results and modify plan as required. If I discuss the situation with SFC Sharp, I am adhering to all the Army values that I have listed above. I am still being loyal to my unit and I am fulfilling my obligations. I'm not taking shortcuts as SGT Day suggested and I am still trusting that others have done their jobs. I am also putting myself in the situation to learn if there are other circumstances that I'm not aware of; an explanation. If SFC Sharp refuses to do anything, and chooses to sweep this situation under the rug, I know that I have done the right thing and I will be able to go up the chain of command knowing that I have adhered to all the relevant Army values....

Words: 514 - Pages: 3

What Makes a Leader

... you and says, “Sergeant, I don’t know about you, but the way I see this is that our section area is secure every evening. The civilian cleaning team doesn’t even clean our area. Only our people ever come in here. From the look of these pages they’ve been behind that desk for some time. These pages are from an alternate communications security book and were never used. The schedule shows them scheduled for destruction two weeks ago, and as far as I’m concerned SFC Sharp destroyed them two weeks ago.” STEP 1: Clearly define the ethical problem. The problem is that I found documents that were supposed to be destroyed and were not. STEP 2: Employ applicable laws and regulations FM 6-22 4-32. If leaders inadvertently pass on bad information, they should correct it as soon as they discover the error. Leaders of integrity do the right thing not because it is convenient or because they have no other choice. They choose the path of truth because their character permits nothing less. AR 600-100 Chapter 2 Responsibilities 2–1. General Every leader will— a. Set and exemplify the highest ethical and professional standards as embodied in the Army Values. b. Accomplish the unit mission. Also check Unit SOP and find out what applies here. STEP 3: Reflect on the ethical values and their ramifications Army Values “Loyalty” I have to ask myself am I being disloyal to Sgt Day and Sfc Sharp because I want to do what is right and report this security violation...

Words: 708 - Pages: 3

The Army Sexual Assault Prevention and Response Program Practical Exercise

... camping trip. While there, SSG Long makes sexual advances towards Mike. SSG Long and Mike then engage in consensual sex. a. Does the scenario describe a sexual assault? Yes b. If so, what type? Rape c. If rape, what type? Sagitory Rape d. Who is the victim? Mike e. Who is the alleged perpetrator SSG Long Scenario 3Sergeant Major Wayne and his wife have been married for 4 years and have kept busy with their individual careers. With their busy schedules, the Wayne’ s have a tradition of going out on a date at least once a month in order to spend quality time with each other. Mrs. Wayne has been going through some hard times at work and has lost her sex drive. While out to dinner, Sergeant Major Wayne slips some rohypnol in her drink when she goes to the ladies room. After they finish dinner, he drives them home and helps her get ready for bed. He proceeds to have sex with his wife. Sergeant Major Wayne feels what he is doing is okay because this is his wife, and it is her duty to make love to him. a. Does the scenario describe a sexual assault? Yes b. If so, what type? Rape c. If rape, what type? Marital Rape d. Who is the victim? Mrs. Wayne e. Who is the alleged perpetrator Sergeant Major Wayne Scenario 4CPT Monk and CPT Ross have become close friends since they started working together about a year ago. CPT Monk and his wife have been having marital problems for the past six months, so he......

Words: 716 - Pages: 3

What Makes an Army Leader Practical

...You will be given a case study where you will have to make a decision on which course of action to take. Read the case study, apply the ethical decision making method using attached student handout, annotate your results for each step, and arrive at a course of action (COA) that is in compliance with the Army Ethic, Army Values, and Army leadership principles. To submit your answer, click on the title above, "What Makes an Army Leader Practical Exercise." * * * CASE STUDY “SFC Sharp and the SECRET Papers” Recently, you received an assignment as the communications and electronics staff NCO of the 99th Infantry Battalion. You are replacing SFC Sharp who is on the promotion list to master sergeant and is departing for his next duty assignment in two weeks. SFC Sharp’s welcome was impressive and he has done everything imaginable to ensure you’re getting off to a good start. Your Soldiers appear well trained, and your section sergeant, SGT Day, seems to know just about everything. You know you have big shoes to fill when SFC Sharp leaves because everyone seems to like and respect him. You’ve heard people say that he knows more about infantry operations than most infantry platoon sergeants. SFC Sharp has cleaned out his desk and tells you to make yourself at home. Later this afternoon he is receiving an award for his service to the 99th. His farewell party is this evening at the club. As you are setting up your things in your new desk, you discover some...

Words: 452 - Pages: 2

Army Leadership Practical Exercise

...Practical exercise for Module 1 1. Define the ethical problem- The problem is should he turn in SFC Sharp for the Security papers or just keep his mouth shut. 2. Identified and accurately applied all relevant laws and regulations- I’m assuming that they have regulations for security breaches that they must follow for incidents like this. Theirs procedures for destroying secret documents that must be followed at all times. 3. Identified all appropriate ethical value. * Loyalty- Loyalty to SFC Sharp who everyone respects and love. * Respect- Respect the job that you do and the responsibility that you have in that position. * Selfless Service- * Integrity- That no matter what you will do the right thing. * Personal Courage- The courage to do the right thing no matter what people say. 4. Determined all relevant guiding moral principles from the ethical values chosen. * Duty- Duty to do the right thing for your country and to not take short cuts while performing your duty. * Honor-To always do what is right no matter what the outcome will be. 5. Identified and accurately applied all other relevant moral principles to the ethical problem- 6. Chose a course of action which reflected sound judgment and a thorough analysis of steps one through five.- Its obvious of what you as a soldier has to do. Everyone has policies and procedures that they must follow, plus the Army Values. You as a soldier must report the incident through your......

Words: 340 - Pages: 2

What Make a Great Fiction

... the plot in the beginning. As the plot unfold, the bride is awakes from a come in the present day. In volume two, the beginning of the plot takes place just before where volume one begins. The plot skips to the present day leads to a point where the bride is buried alive. While buried, the plot travels back into time where the bride was trained by Bill in China for martial arts. She uses her knowledge she obtained there to break through the coffin. The plot then precedes back into the present. Each film was nominated for the Golden Globe Award, and nominations for Best Female Actress and Best Supporting Male Actor were given. This brilliant tool used by Tarantino makes them truly unique and brilliant films. Their nonlinear structures appeal to the viewers and keep them constantly trying to figure out what is going to happen next while presenting them many twists and turns in the plot. These are just a few examples of how narrative structure can effect how the quality of the movie greatness and rarity. Tarantino’s nonlinear structure in his movies promotes his audience to focus on the movie and leaves them stunned and enthralled. Unique narrative structure like this is how authors can create great fictional writing. There are a few things authors need to be careful of when using nonlinear structure in their writings. First, if an author is going to use separate scenes, he needs to make sure he connects them in the end. Ways of doing this are......

Words: 1358 - Pages: 6

Army Leader

...1. DEFINE THE PROBLEM What decisions need to be made in view of the stated problem? SFC Sharp’s basic ethical problem is the pressure to be dishonest and not report this breach of security. Identify the ethical questions of the situation. If I were in SFC Sharp’s place and he in mine, how would I want him to handle the situation? ENABLING LEARNING OBJECTIVE Identify applicable laws and regulations. 2. KNOW THE RULES What specific regulations/guidelines require certain actions for this type of security breach? How would you find out? The Joint Ethics Regulation (JER) (Appendix B,Handout) provides general guidance concerning values that apply to all DOD employees. There are also specific Army regulations on the safeguarding of classified materials. In addition, most units publish internal SOPs dealing with these issues. Identify Military values. Based on case study, what are some ethical implications I can derive from Army values? A. Integrity demands that I do not violate my personal moral beliefs. B. Loyalty is an intangible bond based on a legitimate obligation. It involves the correct ordering of my obligations and commitments. Apply the Army values to the case study. While respect and loyalty to SFC Sharp and SSG Day are commendable concerns, I still have to consider that the Military value of loyalty considers loyalty upheld when one adheres to legitimate obligations. By being honest in this case I am not being disloyal. Identify other applicable moral...

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

What Makes a Leader

...I think for anyone to be a good and successful leader they have to be on the same level as the people below them. You can’t run around big headed all the time and not take anything into consideration from other people. There is no better way to get on that level than what Daniel Goleman describes as emotional intelligence. I don’t think as a leader you can be successful without relating to people especially on an emotional level. I could personally use a little help in all of the areas described in this article. The one that stands out most to me is empathy. I tend to walk around big headed and lack compassion or empathy for other people. I think it stems from where I came from and some of the things I have gone through. Nobody every showed me this type of understanding and so I just grew up thinking like this. I tend to be tough with my kids when something goes wrong instead understanding the problem and feeling sorry for them. I have gotten better over time and I think I am improving. I think in an organizational viewpoint you have to understand people’s lives and understand that everyone is different and everyone’s home life is different. If you can’t empathize with people, than you will never get to know anyone and eventually fail as a leader. The second one that stands out most to me is the self awareness component. I don’t always recognize my mood, whether it’s good or bad, and how it affects people around me. I do know that my wife confronts me when I’m in a bad...

Words: 560 - Pages: 3