Free Essay

What Matters More to My Kids’ Future:

In: Social Issues

Submitted By trelawney
Words 1280
Pages 6
What matters more to my kids’ future: Their school or quality time with their parents?

1] On countless mornings over the past year, I stood with my 3-year-old son, James, in our driveway, watching our next-door neighbor trudge off to fifth grade. As she’d disappear around the corner, I’d think ahead to the kind of school James might attend when he starts kindergarten in two years.

2] My wife and I are in our early 30s, living in Ann Arbor, Mich., where she is finishing her training as a demographer. Over the next year we’ll figure out where we’re going to live for the long haul. Where we choose will depend to some extent on the job market, but it will also depend heavily on where we want James and his brother, Oscar, 1, to go to school.

3] We can’t afford private-school tuition, so living in a city would probably mean chancing it on a subpar public school system. And although I loved growing up on the coast of Maine, the limits of my public high school education became clear when I got to college and immediately felt like I was behind. I would like my boys to be better prepared for college.

4] But if my wife and I wanted to do everything we could to give James and Oscar the best possible K-12 education, we’d have to make some big changes. We’d have to choose more lucrative careers than hers in academia and mine as a writer so we could afford urban private schools or a house in an affluent suburb where the public schools are better. But between the longer hours and the longer commutes such changes would entail, we’d see much less of our kids. James and Oscar might be in the best schools, but we’d rarely be home before bedtime to hear what they’d learned all day.

5] Would this trade-off be worth it? When I look at the research on child development, I think it might not. Where our kids go to kindergarten or high school might matter a lot less than most parents think.

6] Social scientists have long tried to determine why some children grow up to be successful adults and others don’t. The causes are hard to untangle. High school dropouts tend to attend underperforming public schools and to come from poor families with unmarried, undereducated parents. Ivy League graduates more often attend good K-12 schools and come from well-educated, affluent, two-parent families. Because these characteristics cluster together so frequently, it’s hard to determine which attributes drive success or failure — and which are just along for the ride.

7] In a 2001 study, Greg Duncan, now a professor of education at the University of California at Irvine, measured the impact that the people in a child’s life — siblings, neighbors, classmates, best friends — have on how well the child does in school. Duncan and his team found almost no relationship between how students did on the test and whom they sat beside in class, whom they hung out with after school and who lived on their block. The only meaningful link they found was between siblings, and identical twins in particular.

8] “Schools and neighborhoods might have some effect,” Duncan says, “but I think it’s pretty clear that a lot more of the action around child development takes place at home.”

What is it about home that matters?

9] For a long time, scholars and policymakers thought that a family’s income heavily affected how well kids did in life. This is why decades of federal welfare policy were based on transferring cash to poor parents. Data from “Expenditures on Children by Families,” an annual report by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, show that as families get richer, a lot of that extra money goes into their kids. Low-income and middle-income families spend similar amounts — about $9,000 and $13,000 per child, respectively, per year. But families making more than $100,000 spend about $22,000 per kid per year. (I assume most of the increase goes to private-school tuition.) Given that the children of higher-income families typically do better in school and earn more as adults, it would be reasonable to conclude that the more my wife and I spend on our kids, the brighter their futures will be.

10] But that might not be the case. When Susan Mayer at the University of Chicago looked at the relationship between family income and lifetime achievement, she saw that many of the character traits that allow some adults to make a lot of money — a strong work ethic, honesty, reliability, good health — also make them good parents. Mayer wondered whether it is those traits, rather than the money that results from them, that really counts.

11] That makes sense to me. It seems that my impact on my kids has much more to do with who I am and how much time I spend with them than how much I earn.

12] In an influential book, "What Money Can't Buy: Family Income and Children's Life Chances," Mayer put her hypothesis to the test. She ran a series of experiments that measured the relationship between family income and a range of life outcomes, such as a child's likelihood of dropping out of high school or getting pregnant as a teenager. In one study after another, she found that such outcomes weren't caused by income.

13] Mayer's study was based primarily on low-income families, but her results apply even more powerfully to middle- and high-income families. If money doesn't make a big difference in the lives of poor children, its impact is even smaller for kids who are already well provided for.

14] Mayer found that the things that make a difference are relatively inexpensive: the number of books a kid has or how often his family goes to museums. She argues that all the other stuff — summer camps, tutors, trips to Paris — are like upgrades on a Lexus. They're nice to have but immaterial when it comes to getting from one place to another.

15] If private tutors or the right address is unlikely to change a child’s life, the relationships kids have with their parents just might. This is the argument that University of Pennsylvania professor Annette Lareau advances in her groundbreaking ethnography “Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life.”

16] In the mid-1990s, Lareau began one of the most in-depth observations of American parenting ever conducted. She spent a month each with 12 families (six middle- and upper-middle-class and six poor or working-class) and observed how these parents interacted with their children. Lareau concluded that middle-class parents convey substantial advantages to their children in three ways: by cultivating their interests, enriching their thinking and speaking skills through informal conversations, and teaching them how to navigate institutions such as colleges and workplaces that serve as de facto gatekeepers for success in America. Success in those areas is much more related to the amount of time parents spend with their children than where they send them to school.

17] “I think it’s very reasonable for parents to choose to work less in order to have more face time with their children, even if that means their children attend a school where they’re not challenged as much as the parents might like,” Lareau told me. She added: “Many parents I interview are anxious about their children’s economic futures. But I think they have an exaggerated sense of the risks involved if they don’t give their children ‘the best’ of everything.”

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Child Neglect

...According to Kids Matter Incorporated, child neglect is the most common form of child mistreatment. It is important for all people to be able to recognize when a child is in the troubled path of neglect. Whether it is physical abuse or emotional abuse, it all needs to be reported and the child needs immediate help. Is neglect just as serious as other, more obvious forms of abuse such as sexual, physical and emotional? Child neglect is a continuing problem because of the lack of knowledge people know about it. People need to be aware of the signs and when a child is in danger and when to step in a get them help. Child neglect is detected in different ways. According to Kids Matter Inc. Recognizing physical abuse can be done by noticing a child’s poor hygiene, seeing a child inappropriately dressed for certain weather occasions, unmet medical or dental needs, malnutrition, or staying late at events such as school or extracurricular activities to avoid home. Emotional signs could be anywhere from a child taking extreme measures to please, always being on the lookout for something bad to happen, or simply just having poor learning abilities. Any of these signs from the physical or emotional abuse are very concerning and are a reach out for help. This topic should be suitable for a short research paper because I am finding great answers to the questions that I have, plenty of research material is available from good sources, and I am perusing my future in the social work......

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Dream Job

...provide whatever they can for their family. It’s hard to compete in today’s occupations with more and more people striving to get to the top, to be the boss with the newly remodeled home, 2.5 kids, golden retriever, cabin in the mountains, and Mercedes Benz. People feel a great achievement when they have reached the point where they can provide these material things to their families no matter how they do it or what they have to go through to get it, whether it be working long hours or cheating the stock market. Unfortunately it’s the same people who forget who got them to the point where they can afford their Mercedes Benz. I feel that credit should not only be given to family, friends, and pastors, rabbis or priests, but also to teachers. Any school could always use another good teacher, one who truly cares about what they teach and who they are teaching to, which is why I want a job that will not only fulfill my life but also the lives of others around me. My dream job is to become a teacher. I come from a long line of teachers, my great grandmother, my grandmother, mother, older sister, and soon my older brother. A part of me has also always wanted to be a high-powered, kick-butt businesswoman. But, I always knew that no matter now big my office was or how much I got paid would never match the feeling I could get at the end of the day when I know I made a difference in a child’s life. It’s my dream to help make a difference in people’s lives at an early age where it will......

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Mathu

...whatever they can for their family. It’s hard to compete in today’s occupations with more and more people striving to get to the top, to be the boss with the newly remodeled home, 2.5 kids, golden retriever, cabin in the mountains, and Mercedes Benz. People feel a great achievement when they have reached the point where they can provide these material things to their families no matter how they do it or what they have to go through to get it, whether it be working long hours or cheating the stock market. Unfortunately it’s the same people who forget who got them to the point where they can afford their Mercedes Benz. I feel that credit should not only be given to family, friends, and pastors, rabbis or priests, but also to teachers. Any school could always use another good teacher, one who truly cares about what they teach and who they are teaching to, which is why I want a job that will not only fulfill my life but also the lives of others around me. My dream job is to become a teacher. I come from a long line of teachers, my great grandmother, my grandmother, mother, older sister, and soon my older brother. A part of me has also always wanted to be a high-powered, kick-butt businesswoman. But, I always knew that no matter now big my office was or how much I got paid would never match the feeling I could get at the end of the day when I know I made a difference in a child’s life. It’s my dream to help make a difference in people’s lives at an early age where it will......

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Schools and There Rules

...Schools and their rules Kids are meant to enjoy their childhood and play around and have fun. Parents only want the best for their children, but it’s their children’s education that always come first. There are always controversies and arguments about which schooling benefits the student’s learning the most. Most kids are put into public schools because it doesn’t require much money unlike homeschooling or private school. Many families struggle with poverty so public schools are the only options left for them. Money isn’t the only problem that people are facing, but whether or not the students are learning going to school. Does the different type of schools really determine how much the students learn? What are the pros and cons of public schools, private schools and homeschooling? What type of school is the ‘right’ school? According to the Institute of Education Sciences, folks reported having state funded school decision, more or less 25 percent went to a picked government funded school, while 67 percent went to their allocated school while the other 9 percent went to a non-public school. When it comes to how much the students are learning, is the school really the most important factor? Parents are the ones who mainly makes the decision in what schools are better for their child. Usually, private schools are mainly for religious purpose. They are quite strict, but I have Ngo 2 read articles in the newspaper that they have a better teaching system......

Words: 2002 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Bus 309 Second Assignment

...Family and career There are so many things that matter in people’s life, but the most important ones are family and career. People always have a hard time to balance between each one. It’s hard to build a family relationship and also work on having a good education and career. Balancing between both will be a struggle for some people. I want my life to be fair and balanced between my family and career. I’m single right now but for sure I’m planning on getting married in a couple of years and having kids in the future, I’m planning on having two to three kids maximum so I can provide them with a good life whether if its education wise, money wise, or family wise. In addition I want to balance between my family and give them the time they need and my career life to be a good mom who’s fair between her being a good mom and a successful women in her career. I believe that the mindset corporate America conducive to the type of work and family because most jobs have flexible schedules. Also they have holidays off, days off some of them have their weekends off let’s not forget the vacations that most jobs have for their employee for a week or two that are already paid for. However, all this depends on what kind of a job the person is having. Let’s say doctors most likely will not be able to spend a lot of time with their families as much as a business manager who could go in anytime and leave anytime. The United States should assist mothers and fathers during the......

Words: 1387 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why in College

...2014 My reasons to be in college are probably just like anyone else. My two main reason for be in college is that I wanted my dream job of becoming a teacher and to get the whole college experience. Since I did not really have that whole high school experience, so this was my chance, to make up for it. A job can be simply defined as a regular activity performed in exchange for payment. I believe that today you have to be extremely gifted at a job in order to be able to stay with it your entire working career. Nowadays many people are thrown from job to job seeking stability in their lives. Almost everyone enters the workforce to try and provide whatever they can for their family. It’s hard to compete in today’s occupations with more and more people striving to get to the top, to be the boss with the newly remodeled home, 2.5 kids, golden retriever, cabin in the mountains, and Mercedes Benz. People feel a great achievement when they have reached the point where they can provide these material things to their families no matter how they do it or what they have to go through to get it, whether it be working long hours or cheating the stock market. Unfortunately it’s the same people who forget who got them to the point where they can afford their Mercedes Benz. I feel that credit should not only be given to family, friends, and pastors, rabbis or priests, but also to teachers. Any school could always use another good teacher, one who truly cares about what they......

Words: 882 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Better Way, Homeschooling

...A new and better way to learn ~Bobbie H.~ “No, I’m not going to do it. You can’t convince me, there is no way I’m going to put her through that. There is no way I am going to home school my daughter,” says Regina Lowenstein, 34. “I want my daughter to have every opportunity and Homeschoolers have no future.” For many people, homeschooling is seen as bad thing, depriving children of experiences and leaving them without a diploma. For several reasons, many people believe that home schooling is bad for their children. They say that it prevents their kids form socialization, their children don’t do as well in school, and that home schooling is too time consuming and costly, yet that is far from true. In truth, homeschooling is a great opportunity for your children and can actuality improve your child’s learning abilities. First of all, one of the main reasons parents say no to homeschooling is time. Most parents don’t have the time to be sitting at home all day and teaching their kids. For them, public schooling is much more convenient, since children can be in school when parents are at work. Yes, home schooling can be time consuming at first, but that is only as you are getting used to the switch. In truth the younger your kids are, the more time you spend with them, so why not spend that time helping them learn and having fun. Many homeschooling programs are a lot of fun for both the parent and the child, involving many fun and enjoyable activities, like art or playing games...

Words: 1602 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

A College Degree

...Education” where she states no matter how much college is worth, in the end its worth going the extra mile, even for the people that can’t afford it. Never say never because dreams are always worth chasing for. In the other hand Linda Lee in “The Case Against College” she objects a strong belief towards a college degree. She argues that a college degree or higher education isn’t right for everyone and that there are other possibilities to be successful in life. Students should strongly agree with Porter’s position. In which a college degree is worth having, because its benefits are having a higher paying salary, having a better future for oneself/being successful, and meeting up to the requirements. A higher paying salary will benefit you in the long run. Katherine explains that college graduates who take the time and dedication to study and achieve what they want to be in life will be successful. Having a college degree will grant you a high paying job. For example if you want to pursue a career in the medical field such like myself, I would need a degree, and not only will that degree grant me happiness but also the income that I will be earning. Having a degree will always put you on top of a well paying job. Containing a better future for oneself wants to be a better person in the life. Most students today, as Katherine Porter states enroll in public four-year colleges or a two-year college but 80 percent of those students have no idea what they want to do in life......

Words: 860 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Legal

...Abuse in the U.S. College Composition 2 CM220-1107 Stephanie Singh In the United States, abuse is a huge issue that needs to be recognized. Abuse is one of the most under-reported crimes with such cruelty and so little is being done to put this matter to a halt. Children and adults should never have to be put through anything like this, and it is a shame anyone has to be a victim. Not many people look at the statistics of abuse and try to find ways to help those in need of help. The more people come together, the better this world would be. We need to reach out to our victims and prove to them there are places we can be safe. Sadly to say, we may never be able to put abuse completely to a stop, but we can help those who have to deal with this issue and make sure everyone knows that nobody is alone. In the United States, there needs to be systems, such as classes in schools and groups to better educate those who are or may become a victim of abuse. Thinking about all of the stories there are out there in our world today that we hear and read about, the number of inmates is quite low for this matter. In the United States itself, there are four-thousand five hundred and seventy-five prisons with 2.2 million prisoners. Only 1.2 percent of them are rapists or child molesters. “One in five violent offenders is molesters and only about 6 percent of rapists serve time in jail. Rape and child molestation is......

Words: 3018 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Breakfast Club

...located in Northbrook, Illinois, that’s the high school my father attended for all four years of schooling). The five teens that show up for Saturday detention are all different in many ways. The first, of the teens is Bender a trouble making punk rock kid who likes to give everyone a hard time. The second is Andrew a wrestler jock who doesn’t like to take crap from anyone. Third, is Brian a nerdy kid just trying to fit in with the rest of the group. Fourth, is Claire the popular rich princess that has to have her way and puts herself on a pedestal. Lastly, is Allison the weird girl who doesn’t talk much. They all think they are totally different and in completely different social groups, and at the start of the movie they are right. Bender the troublemaker is messing with everyone including the principle and all the kids don’t understand why he is doing this. All the kids seem to start to get over the fact that Bender will be doing this the whole time. The movie starts to progress when they seek out of the library and are disobeying Mr. Vernon’s rules. All the kids have there fun, but when the movie really starts to get down to its true purpose is when it really starts to get interesting. The main scene in the movie all the kids are sitting around in a circle talking and the talk starts to get deep. They all start to talk about the problems they are having with school and with their family life. Emotions fly and the kids butt heads at first but they all start to see......

Words: 1331 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Introduction to Me

...Self-Introductory Speech: The One Thing in My Life That Changed My Career Goal without Me Even Knowing Till Now. Lucrecia Paige Mosley Public Speaking March 3, 2014 Mrs. Nicole Harmon INTRODUCTION: Learning is fundamental. Where would we all be without all of the great teachers who spent their time helping us learn about ourselves and the world? Good Evening ladies and gentlemen my name is Lucrecia Paige Mosley. Lucrecia, Yes I know a lot of people find that as an odd name but I got it from my pastor’s wife whom is also; my mom’s childhood friend. I am from Banner, MS and I am the third of five children. I have three sisters and one brother along with them I have two nieces and two nephews. I will be speaking to you today about the one thing in my life that changed my career goal without me even knowing till now. BODY: In my eleventh grade year of high school I was offered a job at the First Baptist Creative Learning Center. My mom is the one who told me about it when I got home from school. The daycare was the same daycare I went to as a kid and where I graduated from. I went the next day to meet with the lady that runs the center. I walk into the door the smell hit me like a memory train wasn’t a stinky smell it was like a clean mixed with baby lotion aroma. The director Mrs. Rosemary came out of her office minutes after I entered the door. She showed me all the classrooms, the lunch room, bathrooms, and finally my room. It was a four walled room......

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Advice for Newly Engaged Couple

...My Past and Future Arlene Moore PSY202 Mrs. Nancy Egelko March 14, 2011 Outline 1. Where are you from? a. Born in Nicholasville b. Raised in Sunny South c. Live in Thomasville 2. What did you do after you left school? d. Worked e. Had kids f. Got married 3. What are your educational experiences? g. Graduated high school h. Took college courses i. Classes on-line 4. What are your personal, professional, and academic goals? j. Better home k. Daycare owner l. Get a degree 5. What are your greatest achievements so far? m. Becoming a mom n. Living for Christ 6. What would make you happy in the future? o. Better economy p. My kids getting married q. Having grandchildren During my life, I’ve always had a lot of hopes and dreams for my future. As it is known, in life, choices don’t always turn out the way that we, as humans, expect them to. Regardless of this, I have no regrets in my life. I am writing to explain my journey through life as well as all my decisions I had to make as a person. I was born in a small town called Nicholasville, Alabama on July 23, 1966. I grew up there until the age of five, and I was the third of five children. I have two sisters and three brothers. My father worked in the logging business as a saw man while my mother was a stay-at-home mom. Our home wasn’t very fancy, but it was...

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Traditions

...something better... I finally went back down to NWA and spent my IRS refund on a Martin "Lynx" with all the upgrades, bells and whistles. Shot at the range regularly, and hunted with that bow for many years. Hanging around NWA, I was exposed to "Traditional Archery" Listening to stories from Glenn StCharles and others in the shop, hunting Elk with Joe StCharles, and other "Traditional" archers, I became immersed in the history of archery, especially its history in the U.S. I read every book I could get on the subject, the Thomson brothers, Ishii, Saxton Pope, Art Young, Chester Stevenson, Howard Hill, Roy Case, Kore Duryee, and others were my heroes. I set down the "training wheels" and began using recurves. I collected them, enjoying the craftsmanship evident in the individual bows. One of my hunting companions was Don "Bowdoc" Ward, who also had gone back to traditional after hunting with a compound, even restoring bows he found at garage sales, swap meets, etc.. I embraced the "Traditional" archery life, and involved my whole family. I have little fiberglass bows, a few wood longbows in 8#-18#, a 20# maddog "pup", a 30# Pearson recurve, and a few other "kids" bows, just so my own kids and their friends can shoot with me. To me, "Traditional Archery" is more than it roots, it is the spirit. Encouraging our children to participate is part of it. In my desire to be able to share archery with my own kids, and their friends, I decided to see about......

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Inspired People

...Me, Mario and our “teachers” How many people in their lives have had someone who inspired them? I think everyone has that kind of person. In the article “Poppa and the Spruce Tree” by Mario Cuomo, the author was inspired by his father. Like Mario, I too was inspired by someone to be better. That person was my best friend. At that time, Mario Cuomo former governor of New York, had a problem with his political campaign. He was discouraged. “I was ready to quit a political campaign I was losing,” he said. He needed support at that moment and suddenly he found it in his father’s desk drawer. He turned up Poppa’s old business cards and it’s helped him to remember very clearly one episode of his life. And his father, Andrea Cuomo, taught him a lesson through it. He remembered every detail of a Spruce Tree story which happened a long time ago in his childhood. They had just moved from their old apartment to Holliswood, New York. They were so lucky because they had property around the house and trees. Especially, Mario remembered one big blue spruce tree. Right after they moved in, it stormed heavily and the beautiful tree fell. The tree crashed down and no one but his father believed that it could grow again. “Shut up, we gonna push’im up, he’s gonna grow again,” he said. Without a doubt they saved that tree, because today you may go there and see a gorgeous gigantic blue spruce tree standing and “pretending” that nothing happened with it in the past. His father......

Words: 808 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Video Games and Negative Effects

...Exploratory: Do Video Games Have Negative Effects on Users? The form of entertainment is always changing with the shift in culture and advances in technology. One of the most popular forms of entertainment today is the use of video games. Video games have gotten more and more popular over the years. The use of them over a period of time can have a timely effect on the user just like any drug someone uses or any sport someone plays. Can they be positive effects or negative effects? Some people believe that video games are a bad influence and do nothing but harm to the gamer, which is the person who is playing the video game. Media in the news usually focuses on the negatives of video game use, completely leaving out the positives of it. If someone were to go up and ask ten parents if they think video games were bad or good for children or adolescents they would probably say bad, but there is actually some benefits to playing video games that can be determined. In a blog called “10 benefits of Playing Video Games” it shows a list of the ten benefits a person can get from playing video games such as boost cognitive health, improve hand eye coordination, and have sharper image (http://www.tastyhuman.com/10-benefits-of-playing-video-games/). I was very surprised to see such a long convincing list of benefits from video games. The reason why video games help cognitive health is because the majority of games require players to think tactically and make quick decisions. The......

Words: 2552 - Pages: 11