Free Essay

When Cultures Clash

In: English and Literature

Submitted By boston4
Words 1709
Pages 7
In, Bend it Like Beckham, the main character Jess, lives in a Panjabi immigrant community and is not alone in the challenges she faces as she tries to balance her cultural heritage with the western influence that she encounters in the surrounding English community. Jess must deal with the wants and restrictions of her family while trying to be a part of the western culture she is exposed to at the soccer league. I lived the past two years in Hong Kong and I watched my fellow students struggle with the same dilemma. My classmates and friends tried to blend their culture and parental expectations with their own goals and desire to adopt many elements of western society. Nowhere was this more evident than in my acedemic improvement. Chris, a close friend of mine in Hong Kong, went through a similar experience as he tried to pursue a career in acting and yet live up to the expectations of his father who wanted his son to follow him into the family business. He had to juggle the norms of his traditional Chinese parents with his own wants.

I moved to Hong Kong two years ago with my family where I attend the Canadian International School. It was quite an experience. We moved into an area where many of the tycoons of China live. All the children who live there attend private school and many are enrolled in the international schools because their parents want them to become more worldly and to be ready for the global society that Asia is fast becoming. For many of the students, they are the first generation to grow up with money and western exposure at a young age. I quickly realized that many kids are westernized, or “Americanized” as some phrase it, but the problem is their parents and elders are not. Although they want their children to become modern and westernized so that they can compete globally, they still want the fealty and submissiveness that comes with the traditional parent/child relationship in Asia. The result is a huge culture clash between the generations similar to what Jess experienced in her Indian Community. In Jess’ culture she fancied an English guy which was taboo in her culture. In Western culture miscegenation is more common and accepted. The Chinese are very family oriented and my friends were always going out for big family dinners, on a weekly basis. Since Friday nights are usually dedicated to family, their family commitments clash with the typical western Friday night, which is to socialize with friends. I saw the guilt my friends experienced when they chose to go out with friends and ignore their parents desire to see them on weekends

Apart from being family oriented, the children’s schedules are much more regimented than that of a typical American student. Although I went to an international school, the name is a bit misleading because 90% of the student body is Chinese or Hong Kongnese as they call themselves. I was truly able to see their daily routines. I recognized and observed their work habits and the tremendous amount of pressure their parents put on them on to excel in school. There was a glimpse of this in Bend it like Beckham when Jess was accepted to study medicine in university. In the film we could see the tension around Jess’ academic future. Jess was the only one not excited about her acceptance into medical school. She wanted to play professional woman's soccer in America. The problem that I saw in Hong Kong was the stress these kids were under. Many of my Asian friends had grey hair already. I admire their dedication, but some students looked like they were about to explode. These students grew up with school and tutors their whole life. It is not unusual for the wealthy Hong Kong to enroll their children in pre-pre-school in order to compete for spots in the most competitive international schools. While this may be common in some parts of American society, it was not my experience. I am used to the intensity found in football down in the South or in Texas, . In America, especially in some schools, sports is a huge part of school culture and life that sometimes comes before academics. You never see this in Hong Kong. Sport is considered a diversion if you have some extra time- but it never takes priority over academics. It was common for Hong Kong students to skip practice or even games because of school work.

My classmates are extremely dedicated and proud of what they achieve in school. Many of these students have no time for anything but school. Extracurricular activities are a much smaller part of their life than for students in the US. Because of the pressure to perform at an A+ level, there was a lot of competitiveness among the students. It was every student for themselves in the classroom. My classmates do not share notes often, let alone study together. The school attempted an after school study group once, but with little success. The teachers found that the students would come into the class and end up studying by themselves. The competitiveness in the class room was my culture shock. Having come out of a public high school in the suburbs of Washington DC, I was not use to the hard edge competition for class ranking that was the norm in Hong Kong. No one in Hong Kong wanted to be a B student, let alone a C student. The students went to tutor as often as needed to insure high grades. Students pull consecutive all nighters to finish their homework and projects. I sometimes refer to the classroom as a war zone; every student trying to beat his or her enemy for victory- the highest grade on the test. Students would try and be more western but would often have to hide it from their parents. . Many parents were conservative and more traditional, but the children would like to dress and act more western. So the kids would bring extra clothes to change when they left the house. The idea was to have the parents think they were only being westernized a little bit. A good friend of mine at school in Hong Kong was very down-to-earth and westernized. The problem was, his parents were not. He was from a traditional Chinese family. He wanted to pursue an acting career. He had spent his life acting, doing school plays and local productions. I must say he was quite good: a well rounded performer. My father and I met him one afternoon at a local grocery store. The three of us started to talk about college and summer plans. My father was fascinated to hear that my friend was applying to acting school and had to audition for his acceptance. My father was very impressed because he knew acting was hard and would take a lot of work. Moments later we met his parents. My father naturally congratulated his parents on their son’s ambition to try acting. We instantly knew his father was not happy with his son’s choice to pursue a career in acting. Neither of his parents said anything positive about the subject. Instead, his father emphasized that he wanted his son to go into business and be a tycoon like himself. Finally, my dad changed the subject and the two started talking about the economy, a more neutral topic

I felt badly because I knew this was happening all over Hong Kong.Luckily his parents allowed him, to pursue his dream, but with much resentment. Jess’s situation was very similar to Chris’. Both wanted one thing while their families wanted them to stay traditional and pursue a “real” career as defined by their parents. Jess wanted to pursue her passion for soccer while Chris wanted to act. Chris told me how he would constantly have to take business classes even though he didn't want to. His father at first kept insisting that he would become a business man like him. He was always busy running around, going to rehearsal, school, and juggling the extra business classes demanded by his father. Like Jess’s parents, his parents did not approve of his son’s career goal and the embarrassment put on the family. Despite what his parents thought, they did allow him to pursue his western dream of being an actor. They saw that he really wanted it. Just like Jess, my friend never gave up and now he is attending acting school in Canada.. Living in Hong Kong for two years gave me a better understanding of why Asian students excel in school and take their academic career so seriously; it is driven mainly by their parent’s goals and aspirations for their children. Some of their parents and most of their grandparents come from humble backgrounds and it was education that brought them wealth. As a newcomer to Hong Kong and attending an international school with a student body that was mostly Chinese, I always felt a bit like an outsider. I did not mind, because I felt was mixing the best of two different cultures. I was as Americanized as you can get and all my classmates knew that. Although they wanted to be Americanized, they were not ready or able to fully adopt the American way. I admired their diligence in the pursuit of academic excellence but, I was not ready to abandon my lifestyle to get the perfect score. I did however, take school more seriously that when I lived in the US and my grades showed it. My focus changed a bit primarily because everyone took school more seriously so I adopted some of the local culture. Like Geertz I was able to witness and better understand a culture that was very foreign and could not fully comprehend. I adopted some of the aspects of Hong Kong life and culture that I believed made me a better person. Other parts I ignored. Like my Chinese friends that wanted to be more western, they picked some aspects and ignored others and in a way we both adopted what we wanted from each others’ culture.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Problem Definition Culture Clash Is a Condition That Occurs When the Rules and Norms of an Individual's Culture Conflict with the Role Demands of Conventional Society. Justification for Problem Definition a Culture

...Problem Definition Culture clash is a condition that occurs when the rules and norms of an individual's culture conflict with the role demands of conventional society. Justification for Problem Definition A culture clash is when two cultural groups get together and differences in their values or beliefs create misunderstandings or other problems. Merged companies are an excellent example of culture clashes, which clearly observed on salaries rate, dress code and perks Alternative course of actions    Describe clearly the current merge and how everything is going to be. Try to understand the other side different culture. Altering organizational practices and procedures. Evaluation of Alternatives  Describe clearly the current merge and how everything is going to be , this can be achieved by clearly and honestly identify the current merge and try to get a feedback , listen to the others who mainly faced that conflict , this may help to find a solution that may decrease this conflict. Try to understand the other side culture , how things was and how it’s going be and try to predict their response to be able to get ready for better solution , and if possible try to keep things that can be in the middle of both cultures i.e. compromise solution . Altering organizational practices and procedures, often the organizational structure reflects the norms of just one culture and inherits the cultural conflict. In such cases, structural change becomes necessary to make......

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Mergers

...Problem Definition A lot of mergers lead to culture clashes, but although there were differences between the cultural of MBNA and the culture of BOA which was seemed a recipe for disaster, it appears, judging from the reactions of BOA and MBNA employees, that the merger has worked. Justification for Problem Definition The primary factor preventing clashes is attributed to the way management handled cultural transitions. BOA had the foresight to know which MBNA practices to attempt to change, and which to keep in place. Especially critical was BOA's appreciation and respect for MBNA's culture. To try to manage the cultural transition, executives of both companies began by comparing thousands of practices cover¬ing everything from hiring to call-center operations. In many cases, BOA chose to keep MBNA's cultural practices in place. In other cases, BOA did impose its will on MBNA. For exam¬ple, because MBNA's pay rates were well above market, many MBNA managers were forced to swallow a steep pay cut. Some MBNA employees have left, but most have remained. In other cases, the cultures co-adapted. For example, MBNA's dress code was much more formal than BOA's business casual approach. In the end, a hybrid code was adopted, where business suits were expected in the credit-card division's corporate offices and in front of clients, but business causal was the norm otherwise. While most believe the merger has been successful, there are tensions. Some BOA managers see MBNA......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Globalization

...trait/aspect that he may have overlooked? Why was this potential "trait" not included among Huntington's original five? (c) In what three ways may non-Western civilizations potentially "respond" to the powers and values of Western civilization? Please choose two responses and provide and briefly describe/explain One specific real-world example depicting each of the two selected "responses." (d) In Huntington's view, why will civilizations clash? Please discuss in detail the six reasons Huntington uses to explain why a clash of civilizations is seemingly inevitable. (e) Do you agree with Huntington's argument as to why civilizations will clash? Why or why not? Provide at least ONE specific real-world example to support your answer. (HINT: In answering "why or why not," please consider whether Huntington overlooked and thus forget to add an important "reason" or whether he should omit/take-out one of his "reasons." Yao Jingjing Globalization and International Affairs October 9, 2012 Dr. Richardson Chapter 5 introduces a theory, “the clash of civilizations”, proposed by Samuel P. Huntington. According to this theory, “the fundamental source of conflict” after Cold war will be people’s cultural and religious identities. Based on Huntington’s hypothesis, my assignment will discuss about the features of the conflicts among the major civilizations mentioned in the article. And I also would like to point out what aspect is forgotten in analyzing the conflicts of these......

Words: 1188 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Implications of Lack of Cultural Awareness

...University Vellore, India Report on lack of awareness of different cultures and its implications The whole world has become a global village with the advent of scientific development. Even though it might seem a good opportunity for the business and for several other areas as well, a lot of contradictory issues still rise up every now and then. There have been regular clashes in different countries regarding the values, ideas, beliefs, traditions, acceptance, getting along and getting used to new things. Some are not ready to change, some are not even willing to adjust with the change while there are some who try everything in their hand to suppress the change or torment people related to the transformation. Globalization is bringing different nations closer but are we ready to respect all of the cultures equally and not be ethnocentric? Are we ready to open our arms and welcome other traditions and cultures in every aspect when we come across them? Or are we ready to support the other religion just enough so that they can be freely followed in public without any fear of harassment? These are the questions which have become prominent after the cases being filed and lost by Sikhs and Muslims in France to follow their tradition. Another jaw dropping incident that describes the cultural clash perfectly well is what happened to twelve year old Suzannah. Suzannah was born and...

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Clash of Civilizations

...Clash of Civilizations In 1993 Samuel Huntington wrote an article titled “Is there a clash of civilizations”. The thesis was very much born in the context of the end of the cold war. The idea of “clash of civilizations” suggests that twenty-first century global order will be characterized by growing tension and conflict between rival cultures or civilizations, as opposed to the political, ideological or economic conflict of old. Huntington furthermore argued that the world was split into 9 different civilizational orders, and the West would clash with all of them, but in particular it would clash with the Islamic world, Japan and Russia. The realists have given little attention to the issue of identity or cultural politics. They focus on the behavior of states. However the liberals have recognized this thesis to some extent. Huntington’s view that the West would clash with the Islamic world was vindicated after the September 11th terrorist attacks, neoconservatives looking for a response distanced themselves from Huntington’s rhetoric. Neoconservative George W Bush was keen to emphasize that not all Muslims were to blame for 9/11, and indeed it was just a tiny minority of extremists holding the Islamic world back. Whereas Huntington had argued that the Islamic world was hostile to western ideas of liberal democracy, George W Bush ignored this insight and fought two wars to try and bring democracy to the Middle East, ignoring Huntington’s claim that there would be a......

Words: 1503 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Culture Clash: Opportunity or Conflict?

...Culture clash: Opportunity or conflict? By - Judah L. Ronch, PhD We talk a lot about culture change, but what is it about the culture that needs to be changed, and which culture are we talking about? In all community care settings, there are actually a few cultures that come together and, sometimes, collide. We have examined culture before and used Edgar Schein's definition, which we have loosely summarized as “the way we do things around here.” 1 This definition applies to both the culture in the community where we are giving care and to the culture of the family from which this person has come, and sometimes these are the cultures that clash. 2 CONFLICTING CULTURES The culture of many healthcare environments, including residential care for elders, often follows traditionally hierarchic models in which the patient's schedule is determined by the schedules of the workday and shifts, task lists and power structure. In contrast to this, many families follow a more collaborative style of care, where family members consult with each other about how best to meet the needs of the elder. When the family member comes in and, because of a prior caregiving relationship or simply because they know and are concerned about the elder, assumes he or she is part of the care team in the community, we sometimes find ourselves with a problem. Perhaps we bristle at having a professional opinion questioned; perhaps we assume the family member is an adversary, taking time from......

Words: 1076 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Bizzell (1986) Suggests That Students Face Particular Clashes When Beginning Higher Education. Explain and Critically Discuss These Clashes Using Tlc120 Sources.

...When beginning Higher Education, students at University face some unique clashes. According to Bizzell (1986) those three clashes are Clashes of Dialect, Clashes of Discourse and Clashes of worldwide views. For new students who have never encountered University life before, it is said to be a completely different environment, one which can be very intimidating. Students find themselves out of their comfort zone and facing new challenges which can be very overwhelming. Angela Thomas-Jones (2012) stated “beginning your own studies at university requires a culture adjustment in order to succeed. It is a new culture that needs to be given time to adapt to. Becoming familiar with the knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, values and practices of the university culture is the key to successful acculturation”. Some of the reasons why these clashes may have meaning to many students is due to the pressure individual students put on themselves to achieve good grades, be successful and be accepted amongst peers. Throughout my essay I will discuss in detail each of the three clashes outlined by Bizzell (1986). The first clash mentioned by Bizzell (1986) was the Clash of Dialect. This refers to the language being used by students within the university community. The basic writers are those students who experience the greatest distance between their home dialects and Standard English, the preferred dialect in school (Bizzell 1986). The dialect within university is something that students need to......

Words: 1158 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analysis of Chameleon

...Chameleon It is always difficult for two cultures to meet and have a mutual understanding. Things like religion, traditions, food etc. are all values which have to co-operate in order to make two cultures work together. In ‘Chameleon’ there is a clash between Indian culture and English culture. The clash happens between an Indian girl, named Rita, and her family. Rita is very well integrated in the English culture. She is so well integrated that, until she is twenty-four, she sees herself as white even though she is Indian. “I was white in every way, apart from my skin colour – I listened to white music, wore white clothes and ate white food; and I was white enough to marry Mark.” She believes she is white, because she lives and acts as a white person would do. When Mark tells her that his mother doesn’t approve her as a girlfriend, she is shocked and confused. Mark tells her that it is because she is not a Catholic, when she asks him that she maybe could convert, the real problem hit her. “It doesn’t matter that I’m not a Catholic, does it?” She realizes that she is not anymore white as her skin colour allows her to be. She is bewildered about Mark’s parents’ decision. “Your parents are liberal, middle-class people – they’re not supposed to be racist.” She can’t believe that his parents could make such a decision. The group which Rita has tried so hard to be a part of has rejected her. Rita despises her family’s traditions and doesn’t accept the fate which her......

Words: 825 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Cultural Clash in the Movie Gua Sha

...Culture Clash in the Movie Gua Sha Analysis A Chinese immigrant (Datong Xu) has great accomplishment in his career and a loving family, however, just because of a trivial matter, his life has gone differently. His father has come along to America to visit him. Dennis, who is the child of Datong, feels sick and undergoes a traditional Chinese treatment- Gua Sha by his grandfather. The treatment leaves marks on the child’s back and it is found accidentally by doctors and so, Datong is accused of child abuse. A number of culture clashes have been brought up in the movie. It is not the clash between Gua Sha and Western culture, it is the cultural values of Chinese and Westerners that clash. First of all, the clash between Americans and Chinese is conspicuous, particularly, their different perspective towards the concept of hitting children. At the beginning of the movie, Dennis gets in a fight with an American child who is the son of John (Datong’s boss). Datong is really angry and he hits Dennis in front of his boss publicly. In the middle of the movie, Datong quarrels with John. John says ‘I don’t understand why you hit your son.’ Datong replies ‘I hit him to give respect to you! To give you face!’ However, it is totally inconceivable to a Westerner because a westerner would never hit his/her children just to please the boss. That is why John replies furiously ‘What a twisted Chinese logic!’ In Chinese, there is a saying that goes ‘fighting is petting, scolding is loving.’......

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analysis Outline

...Presentation Outline The Joy Luck Club: Culture Clash and Identities I/ Introduction to The Joy Luck Club * About 4 mother-daughter (Lindo - Waverly, Ying Ying - Lena, An mei - Rose, Suyuan - June) duos living in America * 4 mothers were immigrants from China with tragic past * 4 daughters are American born and raised * A movie with many layers of intercultural and intergenerational communication (miscommunication) between mothers and daughters, as well as the daughters’ struggle with their cultural identities II/ Relevant literature and intercultural communication term * High context/ Low context Cultures * Collectivism / Individualism * Cultural Identity III/ Language barriers Even though the mothers speak understandable English, there are differences between the mothers’ English (alternative version of English with different accents and dialects) and the daughters’ English (American Standard English) Analysis: Analyses scenes where the differences are prominent Ex: [The title of the movie] The word “Joy Luck” does not exist in English. It is a poor, fractures version of English [Clip 01: The opening sequence (family/ friend gatherings)] Even though they are both speaking English, when spoken in groups (of mothers and of daughters), the languages used in each group seem different => Analyze differences in grammars, vocabulary and accents IV/ Communication style * High/Low Context China (high context) vs US (high......

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Clash of Cultures

...“Clash not Culture” Cultural differences in a post-Cold War era will not empirically lead to more frequent and violent conflicts between civilizations, regardless of their relationship or proximity to each other. As proven through history, conflict is inevitable and today theorists continue to debate where and why the next war will occur. Our world is a mist a diverging global society with non-state actors competing for new world order. Many states are suffering great turmoil, while others are gaining economic strength and power. Although the world has reached a point that we are poised for conflict, there has actually been a decline in conflict among civilizations. Among those that are geographically positioned for a border dispute, there has been no significant increase in conflict. Many would argue that clashes between western civilizations and non-western civilizations should be at the top of the list, but this has not been the case either. Conflict and war has occurred since the beginning of man and has been recorded right along religious strife. Conflict occurs for several basic reasons including: an attempt to increase a standard of living, to prevent a decrease in a standard of living, greed-more power and territory, religious idealism, and corrupt governments. When developing an analysis to determine the next confrontation, there are several points that must be considered: relative power of......

Words: 879 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Important Paper

...land. That was not luck. At the most one could say that his chi or personal god was good. But the Ibo people have a proverb that when a man say yes his chi says yes also. Okonkwo said yes very strongly; so his chi agreed. And not only his chi but his clan too, because it judged a man by the work of his hands.” Overview of missionaries entering Thesis statement describing the elements of each culture, their clash, and how the English destroyed the spirit of an entire culture by imposing theirs. This collapsing culture and broken spirit of the clans led to the suicide of Okondwo. Body Paragraph 1 – Okondwo’s Culture Perception of Masculinity (Gender Roles) “Perhaps down in his heart Okonkwo was not a cruel man. But his whole life was dominated by fear, the fear of failure and of weakness.” “To show affection was a sign of weakness; the only thing worth demonstrating was strength.” “No matter how prosperous a man was, if he was unable to rule his women and his children (and especially his women) he was not really a man.” Traditions & Societal Status Taking titles and marrying multiple wives is the ultimate goal. “Having spoken plainly so far, Okoye said the next half a dozen sentences in proverbs. Among the Ibo the art of conversation is regarded very highly, and proverbs are the palm-oil with which words are eaten.” Spirituality “When a man is at peace with his gods and ancestors, his harvest will be good or bad according to the strength of his arm.” Oracle......

Words: 656 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Change and Culture Case Study I

...Change and Culture Case Study 1 Sharon Reed HCS/514 October 15, 2012 Steve Kovak Change and Culture Case Study 1 In the world of health care organization mergers are common as the pressures of free market drive organizations into combining resources with each other. Not every merger is a success. The health care organizations in most successful in making a merger are characteristics. The characteristics be examined and used to reveal key insights about organizational structure and ways that the free market system operates. The main reason corporate entities are to merger with companies to increase level of competitiveness in the market. A middle manager in a health organization had experience with merged with a previous competitor. Competition result to delivery of poor quality of care. The new organization has in place outpatient and inpatient service whereas one organization does not. Mergers can occur when two different organizations decide to joint together as one. In a merger is often a clash of cultures as two different organizations interact with each other and attempt to become one. Organizations that take advantage of a merger can resolve conflicts of culture and develop new collective attitudes. Each organization has its own ways of doing things and change will be made. Change in any organization comes with conflict and resentment which, management must resolve. In organization culture brings life experiences from each employee. Culture made of morale,......

Words: 1413 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Twentieth-Century Counterpart

... She defines autoethnography as an inferior culture defining itself through the terms of a dominant culture when writing back to them. Transculturation produces autoethnography. Transculturation is the process by which a culture takes certain aspects of another. The interactions between different cultures, the point of view, and the suppression of the inferior culture portrays “Our Time” as a twentieth-century counterpart to the New Chronicle. Multiple cultures interact constantly in “Our Time”. Robby and John represent different cultures. Robby grew up surrounded by crime and violence. He also comes from a lower educational group. John, even though he is Robby’s brother, grew up to be a different culture than Robby. He went to college and people that were vastly different from Robby surrounded him. John describes his struggle with projecting Robby’s voice in the story because of their different cultural backgrounds. They grew to become two separate cultures that interacted with each other throughout the story. 3 1/2 - 4 pgs remove green part show 3 ways it is counterpart from thesis in para 1 Offik 1 One of the more apparent cultural interactions is the racial clash between blacks and whites. John describes multiple times where two cultures interact. When he describes the Homewood community, he points out how it differs when it is the “old Homewood” the way that Robby’s mom describes it to when it changed to...

Words: 1569 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Dominating Forces Post Cold War Era

...Gone is the era when military force was the sole compass in a state’s quest for dominance. The Cold War world order has been lost. What has taken its place is a collision of two opposing forces both competing to materialize as the new, dominant world order. There exists now an overarching battle between the assimilating force of globalization and the emphatic differentiation of cultural identity as a reaction. This structural dissonance in global relations has elevated inherently tense inter-state relationships and cleared a path for the rise of cultural nations within and across states seeking to solidify their distinctiveness and secure a role in the order of the new world. As the United States emerged victorious from the bipolarity of the Cold War era, so came her establishment as the hegemonic state of the world. This triumph of western liberalism symbolized what Francis Fukuyama deemed “the end of history” - the end of conflicting ideologies among the states which would lead to a world of perpetual peace. Fukuyama’s thesis is based on the Renaissance and Reformation of Europe and the Enlightenment experienced by North America and Europe (Packer. 2012.) Essentially, he argues that the progression of human history as a struggle between ideologies ends after the Cold War era; that the entire world will come to accept liberal democracy as the most desirable world order. The major fault in his theory, of course, lies in the simple fact that the Renaissance,......

Words: 1581 - Pages: 7