Free Essay

Why It Matters?

In: English and Literature

Submitted By leady003
Words 1148
Pages 5
Why it matters? It's a mystery of literature involving a man of words. Words which caused uproar back in 1789. The British readers were captivated by his personal experience of being enslaved at age 11, kidnapped from Nigeria, and brought into slavery of a New World in a terror-filled ship. Equiano's tale is viewed as an authoritative description of the villainous Middle Passage, one of the very first narratives from a slave, a story that gave the hatchling abolitionist movement a buzzing moral influence; except it may not be exact. Therein lays the mystery: Because if the gentleman who penned "The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavas Vassa, the African" was not born in Africa, but rather born into slavery in South Carolina -- as Vincent Carretta suggests -- then who was he? Where did he learn to speak fluent Igbo? And how did he obtain such agonizing details about life aboard an 18th-century slave vessel? The air soon became unfit for respiration, from a variety of loathsome smells, and brought on a sickness among the slaves, of which many died, thus falling victims to the improvident avarice, as I may call it, of their purchasers. This wretched situation was again aggravated by the galling of the chains. . . . The shrieks of the women, and the groans of the dying, rendered the whole a scene of horror almost inconceivable. (Equiano, 1789)
In that lies the controversy: Carretta's findings, detailed in his biography of Equiano, have ignited a blaze in academic life, for the most part among those who have extensively considered Equiano the "black Ben Franklin" all on the weight of his auto biography. Given that Equiano's was in print first, Carretta argues that Franklin should be called the "White Equiano." No one questions that Equiano was the ultimate self-made man, cultured, and intellectual. A slave, who bought his own way to freedom, became a seaman and ran a plantation in Central America where owned slaves. But then he had a change of heart and became an abolitionist. Later, while living in England, he made a fortune off his self-published autobiography, that of which his biracial British daughter inherited. There is, however, considerable argument about the implication of two British documents Carretta has revealed: a 1759 baptismal record and a 1773 ship's muster, which both list Equiano's place of birth as South Carolina. I am extremely doubtful of the presumption of identity on which they rely. What individual doesn’t want to believe in the idea of individual uniqueness on which such memoirs depend? Unfortunately, the possibility that certain aspects of this narrative are not true leaves me apprehensive about it as a whole. As expected the story itself is quite compelling but Carretta’s findings would make rather bland the story of a man who bought his freedom to travel around the world. So much of Carretta’s suggestions make it hard to produce a narrative in which Equiano participated in the slave trade and contributed to a major movement that helped produce the world we know today. Such accounts would not have the same impact as The Interesting Narrative. After doing some research I wanted more discussion of the issues surrounding Equiano’s birthplace. Yet oddly enough, Carretta seems somewhat disinclined to explore this topic, or even to be dynamic in constructing his argument. Undeniably, Carretta provides more than substantial evidence that it can hardly be called a debate. He says on many different occasions that it will never be known for certain where Olaudah Equiano was born. He does note that he has raised “reasonable doubt” about Equiano’s claim of origin is in The Interesting Narrative, “reasonable doubt is not the same as conviction”. (Carretta, 2005) In spite of these credentials, Carretta demonstrates great analytical expertise in his discussion of the feasible symbolic benefit of Equiano’s invention of an African birth. He cautiously and insightfully scrutinizes the first chapter of the narrative where Equiano talks about Africa, and he positions this chapter in relation to other writings of the 18th century with a supremacy and simplicity that are quite inspiring. Equiano’s masterful innovations of an African delivery reveal that Equiano’s “literary achievements have been vastly underestimated” (Carretta, xiv). “If nothing else,” Carretta tells us, he “hopes that Equiano, the African: Biography of a Self-Made Man demonstrates how skillful a writer Equiano was” (Carretta, xv). But more is at risk in declaring that Equiano “made-up” rather than “remembered” an African identity than our assessment of his storybook talents! As mentioned above, Carretta’s case of an American birthplace relies solely on baptismal records and ship’s registers. Whereas he spends a page signifying that he has in fact identified Equiano and then explains that Equiano could very well have listed an African birthplace. He reads these documents with less care than he does The Interesting Narrative. A ship’s register and a baptismal record represent completely different kinds of writing than a devout memoir. Carretta points out how other analyst have treated Equiano’s narrative as a sort of translucent memory of his life while considering the baptismal records with little insight and in need of a meticulous reading in order to be accurately understood. Carretta considers documents as having little rhetorical content worth reading. I would appreciate a more thorough discussion of what would happen if we accepted Carretta’s argument or not. Why is it that people have reacted so passionately to this notion? Granted this narrative fueled the abolitionist movement but why does it matter now? In my opinion I understand if this discovery was made during the movement. It could have destroyed the abolitionist movement from the start. But centuries later I do not see the significance. What stakes are involved in telling the life story of an eighteenth-century slave turned author? I think this is untrue. What could be more undeniable and modern than the implications of where a man of the 18th century, who we now call “black”, was born? From my outlook at least the troubles Carretta raised about Equiano directly confront the issues debated.

Works Cited
Perkins, Barbara and George. “Reason and Revolution.” The American Tradition in Literature. Vol. 1. Toledo: Mcgraw-Hill Humanities, 2008.
Equiano, Olaudah. “The Interesting Narrative of the life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavas Vassa, the African, Written by himself.” New York: Norton, 2001.
Carretta, Vincent. “Equiano, the African: Biography of a Self Made Man (University of Georgia Press, 2005)
Carretta, Vincent. “Olaudah Equiano or Gustavas Vassa? New Light on an Eighteenth-century Question of Identity’, Slavery and Abolition, 20, 3. (December 1991), pp. 96-105.
Carretta, Vincent. “Introduction in The Interesting Narrative and Other Writings, edited with an introduction and notes by Vincent Carretta (London and New York: Penguin, 2003), pp. x-xi.
Egan, Jim. “Olaudah Equiano: The Problem of Identity.” Brown University. http://ecti.english.illinois.edu/reviews/46/egan-carretta.html

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Why Race Matters

...Race and Why It Is UNimportant Race plays a very important role in our lives. It seems like everyday there is another story on the news that reiterates the idea that someone's race is what makes them who they are. It is their identity. Their soul. And any attack or privilege that happens to them, stems from their race.But what about someone's work ethic, attitude, or intelligence. Could these not also explain the reason why a person is successful or a failure? Or is race the only factor that plays a part in the success of someone? With so many opposing arguments it is hard to understand what is fact and what is fiction, when it comes to discussions on race. With that being said, I believe that race does not matter because leading african-americans...

Words: 1517 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Why Migration Matters

...What is "women's migration"? Why does it most often occur? Women’s migration is now more than just joining their partners, today they do so more independently. It occurs due to the fact that women are the primary breadwinners for their families. The global demand for women has drastically increased and more and more jobs are available to them. Explain in three or four sentences the reasons for migration during the 18th, 19th, and 20th centuries. During the 18th and 19th century the majority of emigration was through the transportation of slaves. Because of the European expansion in the 19th century migration for laborers increased. After the European expansion the next period was due to industrialization in the United States. Postwar economies were also in need of labor in countries such as Europe, North America, and Australia. What is the author's definition of irregular migration? Irregular migration are the people that migrate and are classified as “illegal,” “undocumented,” or “unauthorized.” Entering a country to work without a permit or without a visa would mean that a migrant is irregular. More often than not a migrant enters a country for work and the majority are within the United States. However, some migrants are smuggled or trafficked across boarders. What does the author say that migration matters today? Immigration could be classified as a factor in how our economy is within a demographic crisis. Migrants come in young and hardworking......

Words: 287 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why Diverstiy Matters

...Why is diversity important in the work place? Diversity in the workplace is described as the differences that each employee in the company brings to the table. Not one person is alike in a company. A person ethnicity, religion, sexual preference, and gender can set you a part from the individuals that you work with. Diversity impacts every part of the company.If diversity is accepted in a company the company will surely succeed. A company that creates a diverse environment shows its employees that no matter how different we are that we can all work together as a team. Employees should feel accepted by its company and fellow coworkers. In my research on diversity I came across an article about diversity in the New Zealand workforce or should I say the lack thereof. This article gave me further insight of the troubles that this countries workforce faced. These problems included migrant workers, the process of hiring employees, immigration process, and social partnership. The article is called Why Diversity Really Matters by Ruth Le Pla. The article gave me a understanding of exactly why their workforce was failing and how companies did not practice diversity. The article talked about Catherine Taylor who is the president of the Human Resources Institute of New Zealand. Ms. Taylor surveyed many companies just to see the problems with their diversity. The results shocked me. New England’s workforce is in trouble and their labor pool is shrinking. Companies are not making it......

Words: 1427 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why English Matters

...Annika Czizik English 11 Honors 4B Why English Matters Response Due 09/10/14 Understanding English is one of the most useful skills one can obtain. There are immense benefits of having impressive knowledge pertaining to such a wide ranged subject. Abilities such as critical thinking and close reading are important for handling everyday tasks and problems effectively. Communication through writing and speech can be enhanced through vocabulary and grammar as well as appreciation for the language. Being proficient in English increases the amount of opportunities one can have throughout a lifetime. English class plays a crucial role in ones education and contributes essential skills used frequently in the real world. Throughout history, language has been proven to be powerful enough to both bring nations together, but also completely destroy them. It is fascinating to see world altering events such as the Holocaust and creation of the Declaration of Independence, along with countless more turning points be influenced by language. Proper diction and rhetoric allows one to clearly express ideas and thoughts, but also be purposely misinterpreted in order to control and take advantage of the subject. On a smaller scale, language is necessary to solve problems and think critically. Analyzing situations and concepts prevents one from getting taken advantage of or wronged by someone with corrupt intentions. It was surprising to discover that vicious advertisements rely on and......

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Why Students Matter

...Learning Styles Journal 3 Why Students Matter The effective teachers are perceived to be fully equipped naturally and professionally to lead their students to success in competitive standardized tests, as well as inculcate in them, values that would make them exhibit behaviors that are generally desirable and acceptable.  On the other hand, the ineffective teachers do not care about the success of their students in examinations and in some cases students who pass through such teachers, especially in terms of emulating their life styles, tend to exhibit behaviors that are detestable by the society Teacher effectiveness influences students’ academic performance. It is not however, very easy to investigate the area of effectiveness in teaching because many hold the view that the concept has. Even, from among those who hold the views that teacher quality should be assessed by student outcomes however, arguments could be made for an emphasis on different types of student outcomes. Teacher quality can be gauged by short- term outcomes such as students’ performance on state standardized tests at the end of the period prescribed for a given academic programs.  Long-term outcomes may be much more difficult to measure but some might argue that the best teachers are those who somehow improve students’ educational trajectories in some important ways. In other words, teacher quality is multi-dimensional and complex in nature and can be measured. Perkins (1974) said that,......

Words: 2411 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Adultery and Why It Matters

...Running Head: ADULTERY AND WHY IT MATTERS ENGL126-Sound Writing Skills Instructor: x Final Author May 09, 2011 The gimmick filled reality television and high-speed internet has spun us for a loop and left people so dizzy, they have forgotten which way is up. In an article from Time, Caitlin Flanagan explains why marriage matters and Olivia Stren from Flare discusses why women are optimistic about being given the opportunity to have an affair. As if it is now fashionable to cheat on your wife or husband, adultery has become a socially accepted “norm” as a result of changing demographics and its prevalent nature. This moral regression will leave our society scarred if left unchecked. Adultery cannot be dissected and understood without first understanding the institution of marriage and what it stands for. Let us forgo the typical, contract idea, “in sickness and in health” and the whole “love” thing and settle with the belief, for this argument, that marriages are the beginning of a new generation. Marriage is intended to raise the children, to protect, and instill in that new generation the teachings we want them to take into the future to make our world the best it can be (Flanagan, 2009). With that said, what is marriage as it stands today? If children are watching the moral fabric of society, one of the oldest traditions in the history of our people, melt away and be replaced with selfishness and depression? We are creating the ultimate “Me-Generation”......

Words: 1355 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Why Preschool Matters

...In recent years, the debate over whether or not preschool is important has gained momentum and there is increasing awareness to the argument. Preschool is important because children that attend a quality preschool program are much more prepared for kindergarten and obtain a more effortless transition into kindergarten. The article “Why Preschool Matters” published in Parenting Magazine, outlines the importance of preschool, benefits that children acquire by attending a quality preschool program, and the differences between childcare versus preschool. The article discusses many differences between Childcare and Preschool. The article also states that children attending a quality preschool program will develop many skills to assist their transition into the first experience in a grade school setting. (Kanter, 2007)...

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Why Titties Matter

...Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vivamus at pellentesque leo, sit amet porttitor nibh. In condimentum pharetra erat ut imperdiet. Integer molestie quam et leo blandit, vitae vehicula ante ultricies. Donec nec urna consequat, vulputate nisi vitae, laoreet diam. Curabitur commodo arcu vel mi fermentum faucibus. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Etiam convallis porta odio in lobortis. Maecenas scelerisque adipiscing enim nec euismod. Duis in porttitor nisl. Etiam et quam fringilla, pharetra ligula sit amet, placerat tellus. Ut vehicula metus eu mi ullamcorper faucibus. Praesent non porta arcu, id iaculis augue. Praesent vitae massa gravida, malesuada magna eu, laoreet eros. Cras nec elit a sem sodales congue ultricies a eros. Curabitur eget pulvinar nulla. Nulla dui tellus, accumsan ut varius nec, accumsan eu neque. Quisque lobortis malesuada lobortis. Morbi nec ultricies massa, sed imperdiet nisl. Sed blandit eget quam et hendrerit. Phasellus elementum lacus orci, quis fermentum turpis volutpat sit amet. Pellentesque habitant morbi tristique senectus et netus et malesuada fames ac turpis egestas. Sed scelerisque erat sed dui condimentum dignissim. Vestibulum gravida mollis quam, ut fringilla quam tincidunt id. Fusce ultrices, ipsum eu eleifend molestie, lectus augue iaculis elit, id sodales libero diam in elit. Phasellus eget tempor leo. Donec feugiat, arcu a euismod vulputate, orci eros......

Words: 1755 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Why Voting Matters

...Voting Matters! Freedom is an appealing reason to vote. Having a democracy in which citizens elect their officials should be reason enough to vote. The mere fact that each election citizens can travel to the polls an elect their official of choice, and not have to share whom they selected is what makes voting important. Voting is a way for citizens to let their voices be heard, and express their opinion on how the government should operate. In order for citizens to let their concerns be heard or vote they must first register to vote. To become a register voter is important. First, a citizen can register through the application process at their local courthouse or DMV office. A citizen has to be 18 year of age by the election date, a U.S....

Words: 335 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why Black Lives Matter

...Black lives matter is a very controversial topic. Some may see it is a ‘terrorist’ group, while others see it as an activist group. BLM has recently become a huge debate in the United States due to all of the police brutality that has been going on in many areas. The people that believe in this group understand that most of the events that lead to this movement were executed because of the color of one’s skin. Although there has not been a policeman or woman to admit that this brutality has occurred strictly because of race, there are many stories that seem to prove that the police definitely abuse their power when it comes to people of color. In the past, it has been said that, in specific, white people are killed by the police more than black people. People have gone off of that assumption for years. But according to Wesley Lowery’s article, “Aren’t more white people than black people killed by police? Yes, but no., after the population was adjusted, blacks were 2.5...

Words: 657 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Why CLIA Matters To Patients

...Week 2 Healthcare Compliance homework: Why does CLIA matter to patient? It matters to a patient because Laboratory tests have to be done properly and they have to be certified by the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services. The accuracy of the Lab tests that are done could be life or death for the person they are doing them for. If the test is done wrong or the measurements off then it could affect the person for whom is being treated. These tests are being done for diagnosis, treatment, and prevention. Laboratory tests like blood sugar and H1C if done wrong can result in the patient getting a wrong dose of insulin or counting them as not being diabetic if they are and then if they go back to the lifestyle they had before the diabetes then they could possibly die. The CLIA also allows certain tests to be waived. These tests are waived by the CDC or the FDA are they are considered so simple that there is very little margin and risk for errors. There are some methods of testing for cholesterol and blood glucose that are waived at the same time as pregnancy tests, some urine tests and fecal occult blood tests. There have been about 40 tests approved for the certificate of waiver also known as a COW. Patients as well as person representatives of the patient, can request their lab results and reports...

Words: 763 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hesmondhalgh's Why Music Matters

...In my lifetime I have been exposed to many artists, many genres of music and lots of different live performances. I have always enjoyed going to concerts ever since I was 10 and my mother took me to the Hilary Duff concert. Some say I am insane since I like to attend at least 5 concerts a year, but there is something about the atmosphere at a concert that entices me to continue to return. This past month I attended the Ariana Grande concert with two of my closest friends and this is the concert that I am going to analyze. There are three distinct points that Hesmondhalgh outlines in his book Why Music Matters. He talks about music creating status, the function of music evoking emotion and the capacity of dance that music embodies and these...

Words: 862 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Does History Matter

...“Why does history even matter?” is one of the most common questions asked by modern-day kids and teenagers taking a history course. “It’s just stuff that’s already happened, we need to focus on the now.” Thinking that they sound inspirational and smart. However, history plays a much larger role in the way we run our country and the way teens live their lives than they might realize. People are constantly learning from history; they learn from previous mistakes, they learn about truly inspiring people who greatly affected their country, and they are able to learn about all the privileges they have in their lives, because they were not always present. “You must learn from your mistakes.” (First said by Unknown) A quote every student has heard in their lifetime. Some kids are able to learn the meaning of this the first time around, but it takes others time after time. History teaches kids about both times. Whether it be America dropping 2 atomic bombs on Japan, whereas if we did that again it would most likely cause the end of history, or when the European leaders kept believing Hitler’s lies and false promises until he almost destroyed Europe and they finally stood up...

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Guns In US: Why It Matters

...Guns in US: Why it Matters Imagine a horror movie where you and your group of friends hung out together to celebrate the night of Halloween then eventually got trapped with a serial killer in a house without lights and communication devices. However, your group were still able to find some stuff for self-defense. Every single hour, there would be one person mysteriously disappeared and found dead in some eerie places. The number of people who survived was getting smaller and smaller. You had no idea who would be the next one and when would it happen. Your groups became more and more frightened and started to doubt each other. That was when you realized the fear of death perhaps was worse than the death itself. Apologies for such a long introduction,...

Words: 878 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Is Fecal Matter Bad?

...Feces, or faeces, also known as excrement, is waste product from an animal's digestive tract expelled through the anus or cloaca during a process called defecation. Etymology The word faeces is the plural of the Latin word faex meaning "dregs". There is no singular form in the English language, making it a plurale tantum. There are many colloquial terms for feces, of which some are considered profane while others are not. Terms such as dung, scat, spoor and droppings are normally used to refer to non-human animal feces. Stool is a common term normally used in reference to human feces. For example, in medicine to diagnose the presence or absence of a medical condition, a stool sample is sometimes requested for testing purposes. The term "stool" can also be used for that of non-human species. Ecology After an animal has digested eaten material, the remains of that material are expelled from its body as waste. Though it is lower in energy than the food it came from, feces may still contain a large amount of energy, often 50% of that of the original food. This means that of all food eaten, a significant amount of energy remains for the decomposers of ecosystems. Many organisms feed on feces, from bacteria to fungi to insects such as dung beetles, which can sense odors from long distances. Some may specialize in feces, while others may eat other foods as well. Feces serve not only as a basic food, but also a supplement to the usual diet of some animals. This is known......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4