Premium Essay

Women in Ministry

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By mikeyjm610
Words 1375
Pages 6
Introduction Today, there are many views about women and their role in ministry. Although many people have argued their points, it seems as though there is no clear answer. This critique on Two Views on Women in Ministry will cover the views of multiple contributors. Each contributor, Linda L. Belleville, Craig L. Blomberg, Craig S. Keener, and Thomas R. Schreiner, present their respective views on two sides of the argument: The egalitarian and complementarian views. Each contributor have received their Ph.D and are currently professors at their respected universities.
Brief Summary Two views of Women in Ministry is comprised of two different views written by four different contributors. The two views are egalitarian or complementarian thought. Each contributor explains their stance of what roles women have ministry and each defend their stance with valid arguments. When each contributor gives their argument to the side they take, the other contributors provide a response.
Egalitarian Perspective
Linda Belleville and Craig S. Keener are the two contributors who take the stance on the egalitarian perspective. They both agree that women should not be denied the liberty to operate in certain gifts. Belleville begins by asking numerous questions that many churches have struggles with in the last fifty years. Belleville states that “twenty five years ago only young adult males were challenged with the slogan “Uncle Sam Wants You”, but today women and men alike are encouraged to “be all that you can be”. This statement is where he begins his argument for why women should have a role in ministries. She begins by citing Genesis 1-2. She clearly describes that both male and female are commanded to exercise dominion over the earth, to rule over all of it.
Keener takes the same stance but states that “The Bible permits to women some kinds of

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Women in Ministry

...10/10/12 Women in Ministry Women ministers in the church are a source of deep conflict among Christians. The only way to fully understand this controversy is to understand what God himself said about the issue. Trying to understand what God actually meant can be very difficult since not all Bible passages are to be taken literary. Personally, growing up in a family with a feminist mother, it helps shape my views on women in ministry. Having a feminist mother and a non-feminist dad, however, was very difficult. I believe that God’s ministry is something everyone should be very proud of. Having the chance to serve in His ministry should be a privilege that everyone human being should strive to attain. Limiting the ministry of Christ based on gender is wrong and discriminative. I grow up in a culture were women are not allowed to be ministers. The cultural influence of many individuals in my country is the leading factor to a lot of negative views on women. The interpretation of scripture was highly baize when it comes to issues concerning women. Most women in country are looked down upon and view as objects with no authority. In the mist of all the cultural influences, having a feminist mom was very difficult for me. I was trying to follow my mom’s perspective on women, yet at the same time trying to obey a culture which defined who I am. The only way I was able to build my own perspective was to seek answers from the Bible. For many people who think women are not...

Words: 934 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Women in Ministry

...WOMEN IN MINISTRY BY IMOEKOR OSCAR INTRODUCTION Supernatural manifestations and gifts of the Holy Spirit have played a distinctive role from the origin, development and growth of the Church. From the beginning of creation until now, Spiritual gifting has been evident in the ministries of many outstanding women. Divine enablement has been seen in the spiritual leadership of women in the body of Christ. The true body of Christ-the Church believes that the outpouring of the Spirit is a true fulfillment of scriptural prediction, “Your daughters shall prophecy…and upon your handmaids in those days will I pour out my Spirit” (Joel 2:28, 29). The history and current practice of the true Church give demonstration that God can and does bless the public ministry of women. Yet, there is much debate concerning women in Spiritual leadership and ministry. So, it is appropriate to ask if scripture describes any limits to this public ministry. The scripture must be our final authority in setting questions of faith and practice. As born-again, Spirit filled Christians, following proper hermeneutical principles; let us not be dogmatic in support of one position. We affirm the inerrancy and authority of the Scripture and desiring to know what God expect of us. When we come to sure understanding of His divine Word, we are committed to declaring and obeying those instructions but also exercise caution in giving authoritative importance to interpretation that do not have indisputable...

Words: 2421 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Women In Ministry Paper

...Women in Ministry I grew up in a non-denominational church that possessed hints of a baptist atmosphere in Springfield, Ohio. It was an absolutely male dominated church, especially within the authoritative departments. I now realize that the church has strict complementarian views, they do not believe that women should have any role within the pastoral offices and obtain limited positions on the leadership teams. The only areas where women were allowed to serve were the children’s and mission departments. Women were not allowed to take up a role as an elder or a deacon, they were excluded from all jobs that included authority over adult men. I am now aware of how much of an influence my home church had on my opinion on women in ministry....

Words: 1724 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Becks Book Two Views on Women in Ministry

...Becks book Two views on women in ministry Our conclusions coincide with these recent studies. We have found that the biblical witness is consistent with regard to the divine ideal for headship/submission/equality in man-woman relationships. Before the Fall there was full equality with no headship/submission in the relationship between Adam and Eve (Gen 2:24). But after the Fall, according to Gen 3:16, the husband was given a servant headship role to preserve the harmony of the home, while at the same time the model of equal partnership was still set forth as the ideal. This post-Fall prescription of husband headship and wife submission was limited to the husband-wife relationship. In the divine revelation throughout the rest of the Old Testament and New Testament witness, servant headship and voluntary submission on the part of husband and wife, respectively, are affirmed, but these are never broadened to the covenant community in such a way as to prohibit women from taking positions of leadership, including headship positions over men. Increasing numbers of women are entering the ordained ministry of the Christian Church. Whether they embrace or challenge traditional female roles, clergywomen are changing some aspects of the ministry, not least through their skills at counselling and their person-centered focus. By comparing British and American data, this paper argues that female ministers differ from their male colleagues in terms of their personal characteristics, their...

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Book Critque: Two Views on Women in Ministry

...LIBERTY UNIVERSITY BOOK CRITQUE: TWO VIEWS ON WOMEN IN MINISTRY A PAPER SUMBITTED TO DR. SIMON GONCHARENKO IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE COURSE THEO 530 LIBERTY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY BY REGINALD TOWNSEND HATTIESBURG, MS SATURDAY, JULY 26, 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS Thesis................................................................................................................................1 Introduction......................................................................................................................1 Brief Summary.................................................................................................................1-3 A Critical Interaction........................................................................................................3-6 Conclusion........................................................................................................................7 Bibliography.....................................................................................................................8 THESIS My view on ministry has roots in both complementarianism as well as egalitarianism. It is my goal to show how these two views have led to my understanding of women in ministry in association with the review of Two Views on Women in Ministry. INTRODUCTION The debate of women in ministry is ongoing. This is one that has divided some churches and is split between two views...

Words: 2161 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Theo 530

...VIEWS ON WOMEN IN MINISTRY A Paper Submitted to Liberty Theological Seminary Dr. Garry Graves In partial fulfillment of the requirements For completion of the course Systematic Theology II THEO 530 By Vernon L Langley July 26, 2012 Beck, James R. Two Views on Women in Ministry: Revised ed. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2005. ISBN: 978-0-310-25437-9. Thesis Statement: in view of the fact that my own outlook on women’s responsibility in ministry is in between social equality and Complementarian; however I will attempt to show that women have a part in ministry, through the assessment of these two differing points of views as offered in the principal book Two Views on Women In Ministry and as contrasted with other academic books. Introduction: Dr. James R. Beck has assembled four academic assessments which present the egalitarian and complementarianism / hierarchical analysis regarding women in ministry with unprejudiced supplementary counterpoints to completely enlighten the one who reads. The arrangement of analysis appear to evaluate and distinguish in a reasonable, impartial way that supply the one who reads with a good insight of the dispute, with opposing opinions offered at the conclusion of every article. However, the reasonable approach to the arrangement of both components regarding women in ministry do not completely disclose God’s genuineness; thus, the Two Views on Women in Ministry presents...

Words: 2283 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

The Master Plan of Evangelism

...ENGAGMENT GLST 650 BY Walter A. Culup JANURARY 26, 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………………..….3 SUMMARY……………………………………………………………………………………….4 CRITICAL INTERACTION……………………………………………………………………...6 CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………………………........9 BIBLIOGRAPHY……………………………………………………………………………….10 INTRODUCTION One of the debates which arises when we examine Christian ministry is: What is the role of women in the ministry? What does the Bible say about this topic? While no conclusion or consensus has been reached on the topic there are two view points and positions which have arisen to the forefront of the debate. First we have the egalitarian view which holds the position that ministerial opportunities should be equal for both men and women. Then we have the complementarian view which presents the belief that ministerial roles should be differentiated by gender. James Beck’s book TwoViews on Women in Ministry explores both of these positions by examining four articles, two of each opposing viewpoints along with three critical responses to each article. The goal of the text is to compare and contrast both positions, thus giving the reader enough information to form their own opinion and position on the topic. The editor of the book Dr. James Beck is a faculty member of Denver Seminary in the counseling department. Beck is a senior professor of counseling and a licensed...

Words: 2183 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Ministries and Departments

...Ministries and Departments 1. Ministry of Revenue 2. Ministry of Finance 3. Ministry of Prime Minister 4. Ministry of Communication and Information Technology 5. Ministry of Works, Transport and Infrastructure 6. Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment 7. Ministry of Women, Community and Social Development 8. Ministry of Justice & Courts Administration 9. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade 10. Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries 11. Bureau of Statistics 12. Office of the Controller and Chief Auditor 13. Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Labour 14. Ministry of Education, Sports and Culture 15. Ministry of Police and Prisons 16. Office of the Electoral Commission 17. Legislative Assembly 18. Ministry of Health 19. Office of the Attorney General 20. Public Service Commission 21. Ombudsman’s Office   b) Estimates of Payments for Ministries and Departments for year ended 30th June 2012 Estimate % 1. Ministry of Education, Sports & Culture 2. Ministry of Works, Transport & Infrastructure 3. Ministry of Health 4. Ministry of Finance 5. Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment 6. Ministry of Police & Prisons 7. Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade 8. Ministry of Commerce, Industry and Labour 9. Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries 10. Ministry of Women, Community and Social Development 11. Ministry of Revenue 12. Ministry of Justice and Courts Administration...

Words: 257 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Population Police in Bangladesh

...INTRODUCTION Socio-economic development for all citizens is the cornerstone of Bangladesh’s constitution. According to the articles 15, 16, 17 and 18 of the constitution, the state has the responsibility to ensure to its citizens certain basic needs such as health, education, food and security. In order to translate these constitutional goals into reality, the Government had undertaken a wide array of public policies. The Policy stands out as one of the most remarkable achievements of the government. Since 1976, this policy emphasis has been reflected in all successive 5-year plans and programs. The population of Bangladesh is likely to grow up to 172 million by the year 2020 and will stabilize at 210 million by the year 2060, even if replacement level fertility (i.e. Net Reproductive Rate-NRR=1) is achieved by the year 2010. 15 MAJOR OBJECTIVES OF THE NATIONAL POPULATION POLICY: The objectives of the National Population Policy are to improve the status of family planning, maternal and child health including reproductive health services and to improve the living standard of the people of Bangladesh through making a desirable balance between population and development in the context of Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (IPRSP). The following major policy objectives will help address the future challenges: 1. Reduce Total Fertility Rate (TFR) and increase the use of family planning methods among eligible couples through raising...

Words: 1571 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Advrtising

...WOMEN IN POLITICS AND PUBLIC LIFE IN GHANA By Beatrix Allah Mensah AUTHOR: Beatrix Allah-Mensah Department of Political Science University of Ghana, Legon ISBN: 9988-572-87-5 © Copyright Friedrich-Ebert-Foundation, Accra Published in 2005 Printed & designed by O´Mens Graphix, Accra, Tel.:021-238098 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I wish to acknowledge the contribution of all those who made this project a success. First, I give glory to the Almighty God for bringing me this far in my academic and professional pursuit. Secondly, I express my thanks to all my lecturers in the Department of Political Science, University of Ghana, who have nurtured me onto this path of professional and academic life. Thirdly, I am grateful to all our key informant interviewees from all the institutions/ministries/political parties who gave us their time and valuable information used for this study. Fourthly, I wish to sincerely acknowledge the contribution of my research assistants, Alfred Appiah and Nimingah Beka, national service personnel of the Department of Political Science for their dedicated service during the data collection. Finally, I would like to express my thanks to the Friedrich Ebert Foundation (FES) for commissioning this study and giving me the opportunity to carry it out with financial and institutional support. I would like to state that, except for quotations or references which have been dully acknowledged, this is the result of a research I conducted personally. God Bless all...

Words: 36172 - Pages: 145

Free Essay

Book Review of: Two Views of Women in Ministr

...Book critique: two views on women in ministry ___________________ A Paper Presented to Dr. Dietmar Schulze Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary ___________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Course THEO 530 Systematic Theology II ___________________ by Peter Heikkinen February 17, 2013 TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………………..….1 SUMMARY…………………………………………………………………………………….1-3 EGALITARIAN EQUALITY…………………………………………………………..1-2 COMPLIMENTARIAN ROLES…………………………………………………….…2-3 CRITICAL INTERACTION……………………………………………………………………3-6 CONCLUSION………………………………………………………………………………....6-7 BIBLIOGRAPHY………………………………………………………………………………....8 Introduction Within Christian controversial topics that divide the Church as a whole Woman in Ministry is one of the most divisive. The two main sides of this debate are; egalitarian’s who believe there are no role differences in gender to authority or teaching in the church biblically. The complementarian view also known as the traditional view holds that men have a position of authority before God in church teaching and authority in the church and home governing. James Beck gathers four New Testament scholars two for each side on the issue and sets out to show case two arguments for each side and room for rebuttal in consideration of the New Testament scripture dealing with woman in ministry. With my own view being that of a soft complementation; women have a role in teaching and authority...

Words: 2283 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Kingdom Play

...CHMN 201_B04 October 9, 2013 The Part I Play in the Kingdom Paper The Part I Play in the Kingdom Paper PART ONE: My Fit in Ministry (Before): I fully understand what my position in my ministry now. Serving on the youth ministry, the women ministry, evangelism ministry, and the loss prevention ministry. I feel that my ministries are the ministries destined for me, because I served effectively on all of them and I love during so. Being able to give back and to helping other to come to Christ is what a good servant of God should be able to do: not just quoting scriptures but actually being out there getting down and dirty with the lost ones .Helping them to find what they have been seeking for in their lives and how they can reach out to God. Going to the nursing homes, the women shelter and youth group homes spreading the word to the women and men in there that feel that their love ones have walked off and forgotten them. In the women shelter who never knew Jesus as their personal Lord an Savoir, but knew drugs, sex and other things that was keeping them from getting closer to God. In the women shelter who never knew Jesus as their personal Lord an Savoir, but knew drugs, sex and other things that was keeping them from getting closer to God. Youth, who that have be abused and abandon: not train or taught who God was. After taking this class I am sure that these are my calling .Being in your class has given me a love for...

Words: 1283 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Industrial Law in Srilanka

...4 History of Labor Law of Sri Lanka • • • • • • • • • • • 1815 - Captured by British, 1823 - Started Estates Immigrant workers, Wage Labour Newly emerged working class, Unskilled, born to work Ordinance No 5 of 1841 – Contract for hire and service Ordinance No 14 of 1872 – Medical and Health Care Ordinance No 13 of 1889 – Estate Labour (indian) Ordinance No 1 of 1923 – Indian Immigrant Labour Ordinance No 27 of 1927 – The Minimum Wage 5 Ministry of Labour – History in Brief • • • • • • • • • 1931 – Ministry of Labour, Industries & Commerce 1947 – Ministry of Labour and Social Service 1952 – Ministry of Labour 1956 – Ministry of Labour Housing & Social Service 1959 - Ministry of Labour 1960 - Ministry of Labour Industry and Fisheries 1961 - Ministry of Labour & Nationalized Services 1963- Ministry of Labour & Social Services 1965 - Ministry of Labour, Employment and Housing 6 Contd.. 1970 - Ministry of Labour •1989 - Ministry of Labour & Social Welfare •1990 - Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training •1997 - Ministry of Labour •2001 -...

Words: 1411 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Marketing Reserch

... Bachelor in Business (Sem.4) Date: 6th August 2015 Content Executive summary---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------3 Introduction-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------3 Problem discovery stage---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4 * Background of tourism and women in Maldives-----------------------------------------------------4 * Discussion with decision maker--------------------------------------------------------------------------5 * Discussion with expert -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 * Discussion with local women-----------------------------------------------------------------------------6 * Secondary data analysis------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 Problem definition----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------7 * Management...

Words: 1826 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Macarthur Reading Report

... LEAD 635 Pastoral Theology by Shonda M. Curb September 30, 2013 John MacArthur Reading Report Introduction Pastor John MacArthur and the Masters Seminary Faculty provide a unique manual for the aspiring pastor or church leader in "Pastoral Ministry: How to Shepherd Biblically". The major theme of the writings focuses on the character and development of pastors in accordance with New Testament scripture including: Acts 6, 1 Timothy 2-4, Titus 1, 1 Peter 5. The authors demonstrate through biblical reference and personal experiences the model and character of one prepared for pastoral ministry. The aim of the text is to validate the biblical authority of the ministry, to educate in the biblical qualifications of pastoral ministry, and to outline priorities for the pastoral ministry. Summary John MacArthur and his panel at the Master’s Seminary Faculty separate the twenty chapters presented in the book into four major categories that are designed to provide the reader with a dynamic portrayal of what it takes to be an effective biblical pastor. The four categories transition the reader from the biblical perspective of pastoral ministry to the practical. They include: biblical perspectives of pastoral ministry, the preparatory perspectives of pastoral candidates, personal perspectives of the life of a pastor, and pastoral perspectives for shepherding the people of God. Through the text, we recognize several prominent and consistent themes including: accountability...

Words: 1415 - Pages: 6