Free Essay

Napoleon Bonaparte and Hitler

In:

Submitted By Genius9904
Words 834
Pages 4
Napoleon Bonaparte and Hitler were very significant figures in history and are well known for their military triumphs. Napoleon is most known for his military genius and his ability to defeat immense armies with smaller forces or to simply outwit his opponents. Hitler is best known for his atrocious human rights violations and his genocide of the Jewish during World War 2. However, Hitler was another gifted military commander who was able to take Germany from a small nation in poverty to a world power that rivaled the United States and the Soviet Union. A blemish on both Napoleon and Hitler’s military resumes is that both of them failed to conquer Russia as their invasions failed. Napoleon’s invasion of Russia was similar yet different to Hitler’s invasion of Russia. Napoleon invasion of Russia was similar to Hitler’s invasion of the Soviet Union for many reasons. One reason that the invasion was similar was that both Napoleon and Hitler failed in their attempts. When Napoleon invaded Russia he had brought as many as 650,000 soldiers to overwhelm the Russians. However, during the invasion “The French Army barely existed as a fighting force. Napoleon watched as his army slowly died… What remained of his defeated army straggled towards safety.” Hitler also suffered a defeat when he attempted to invade the Soviet Union during World War 2. “The tremendous strain of that winter campaign, on armies which had not been prepared for it, had other serious effects. Before the winter ended, many German divisions were reduced to barely a third of their original strength, and they were never fully built up again.” This clearly shows that Hitler’s German army was defeated and decimated as well be the Soviets. Another similarity between the two invasions is that the deciding factor was the bitter Russian winter. When Napoleon invaded Russia the Russian winter arrived early and his troops and animals were battered. The Russian winter had arrived early. “Temperatures fell to twenty-two degrees below zero. Napoleon's soldiers froze in the open countryside. Horses were dying in droves, and the Grande Armée’s flanks and rear guard faced constant attacks. To top it off, an unusually early winter set in, complete with high winds, sub-zero temperatures and lots of snow." The Russian winter caused Napoleon’s army to be in disarray.
When Hitler invaded Russia, his troops were not sufficiently prepared for the bitter cold and the lack of food. “His decision exposed his troops to awful sufferings in their advanced positions facing Moscow, for they had neither the clothing nor the equipment for a Russian winter campaign; but if they had once started a general retreat it might easily have degenerated into a panic-stricken rout.”2 This means that the Russian winter caught the German army by surprise and it severely weakened them, which influenced the tide of the invasion. These are the similarities between Napoleon’s invasion of Russia and Hitler’s invasion of the Soviet Union. Despite the vast amount of similarities between Napoleon’s invasion of Russia and Hitler’s invasion of the Soviet Union, there were many differences as well. One of the differences was that Hitler knew of the risks involved in invading Russia but he still continued with it. “Hitler forbade any retreat beyond the shortest possible local withdrawals.”2 This showed that Hitler had knowledge of the Russian winter but he refused to sanction a retreat.
Another difference between the two invasions was that Napoleon’s invasion made him lose his power. “On April 12, 1814, Napoleon picked up a pen and renounced his throne. Once master over an empire of seventy million people, he would now become the emperor of the tiny island of Elba.”2 Napoleon’s invasion of France coincided with his loss of power in France. However, Hitler did not lose any power or control after his failure in the Soviet Union as his people supported him when he engaged in the war of the Pacific. These are the differences between Napoleon’s invasion of Russia and Hitler’s invasion of the Soviet Union. Hitler and Napoleon were revered military leaders who struck fear into the hearts of their opponents. However, neither Napoleon nor Hitler were able to defeat Russia or the Soviet Union. The similarities between the two invasions are that: both invasions were failures and the deciding factor was Russia’s bitter winter. The differences were that: Hitler knew the dangers of the Russian winter and the invasion ended Napoleon’s rule of France. These are the similarities and differences of Napoleon’s invasion of Russia and Hitler’s invasion of the Soviet Union. Works Cited Page
Greenspan, Jesse Napoleon’s Disastrous Invasion of Russia, 200 Years Ago, History.com. June 22, 2012. http://www.history.com/news/napoleons-disastrous-invasion-of-russia-200-years-ago.

Smith, John Invasion of the Soviet Union, 1941, Britannica.com. http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/648813/World-War-II/53552/Invasion-of-the-Soviet-Union-1941

The Russian Campaign 1812 http://www.pbs.org/empires/napoleon/n_war/campaign/page_14.html

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Napoleon Bonaparte and Adolf Hitler

...someone’s judgment. Adolf Hitler and Napoleon Bonaparte both concord countries. They both had a military back ground and their father’s both died when they were young. The difference is that we see one as a hero/leader and the other leader/monster. According to Biography.com he was “the first emperor of France, Napoleon Bounaparte was born August 15, 1769 in Corsica.” His father Carlo Bounaparte was a lawyer and supported the nationalist’s side. But once that leader he supported fled the island, Carlo switched his allegiance to the French. Napoleon father was appointed assessor of the judicial district of Ajaccio in 1771. This job gave Carlo the opportunity to send his two sons Joseph and Napoleon to college. Napoleon took a different route and went to military college of Brienne. He studied for five years and moved to Paris. His father past away in 1785 of stomach cancer. He graduated early from military school as a second lieutenant of artillery and return to Corsica in 1786. He found himself following his father’s footsteps without even realizing it. When he went back home he followed Corsica’s resistance to the French occupation. But just like his father, he had a following out with his father’s ally and relocated to France. Once moving back to France, he assumed is last name as Bonaparte. Since his return to France he return to service in the French military. He was assign to Nice on June 1793. Feature in the PBS.org website, Napoleon: The Man & the Myth, on...

Words: 2419 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Napelon

...Napoleon Bonaparte was a military general who became the first emperor of France. His drive for empire changed the world. Napoleon Bonaparte was born on August 15, 1769, in Ajaccio. By the time around Napoleon's birth, Corsica's occupation by the French had caused local resistance. His father Carlo Bonaparte had at first supported the nationalists siding with their leader, Pasquale Paoli. But after Paoli was forced to flee the island, Carlo switched his allegiance to the French. After doing so he was appointed assessor of the judicial district of Ajaccio in 1771, a plush job that eventually enabled him to enroll his two sons, Joseph and Napoleon, in France's College d'Autun. Eventually, Napoleon ended up at the military college of Brienne, where he studied for five years, before moving on to the military academy in Paris. He graduated five years early from military school, he become second lieutenant of artillery, and returned to Corsica in 1786. Back home Napoleon got behind the Corsican resistance to the French occupation, siding with his father's former ally, Pasquale Paoli. But the two soon had a falling-out, and when civil war in Corsica began in April 1793, Napoleon, now an enemy of Paoli, and his family moved to France. After Napoleon moved back to France, he return to service with the French military. Upon rejoining his regiment at Nice in June 1793, the young leader quickly showed his support for the Jacobins, a political movement and the most well-known and popular...

Words: 1451 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Nationalism In Russia

...Nationalism does have its good points. It brings people together under one government or flag. Napoleon Bonaparte was dedicated to bringing so many countries under his rule, until he got to Russia. He had thousands of troops ready to fight, but Russia’s army didn’t feel the same way. Napoleon engaged the Russian forces, and the Russian forces backed away. Napoleon rushed again, and again the Russians backed off, afraid of this army’s nationalism. This happened all the way to Moscow. Napoleon didn’t want to give up. Or his pride didn’t want to give up. When his army got to Moscow, there was no one to fight. Deep in the cold recesses of Russia, Napoleon retreated back to his home low on supplies and with less than a third of his original army alive. Now just examine Adolph Hitler. One major goal for him was to unite all Germans under one flag, that they would become an unstoppable force, ruling with an iron fist and taking anyone on; that Hitler’s ideas would be fully executed so that no being save God himself would dare raise a feeble hand in disagreement. A tool he used to unite all of his people and to fulfill that goal was to be proud to be Germans, and to look back on German history and to be proud of it. Hitler succeeded, but ultimately took his life. His accomplishments were ruined when the U.S. and Russia split Germany in two with the Berlin wall “conveniently” built right through the middle...

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bender's Notes: The Two Definitions Of Nationalism

...the death for it. Liberal Louis-Phillipe had reached his limits for tolerance of change, which led to the abolition of the monarchy of France The French workers were unsatisfied with social and economic reforms in France in 1848 and were protesting in the streets.. Louis Napoleon Bonaparte was eventually declared Emperor in 1852 which led to a strong authoritarian regime. His program of industrial development and public works modernized Paris and France and led to improved economic circumstances demanded by radicals. Nationalism is used to have countries break away from empires. After WWI, Austria-Hungary broke into several different nation-states due to nationalistic views. Nationalism is used to unify countries. Italian nationalists looked to leadership from Piedmont-Sardinia, the most powerful Italian state. The prime minister, Count Cavour, set out to gain control of Northern Italy. In the South , Garibaldi conquered Sicily, then marched North to combine and unite the southern areas to the northern areas of a newly unified Italy. Italy was previously made up of 9 different states. Italians are very proud of their heritage, including the Italian renaissance. The previous conquests of Napoleon led to Italy not wanting to be conquered again, which led to their unification. They had a constitutional monarchy in Italy. Both Austria and Prussia wanted leadership of the Germans. Nationalism helped to unify Germany while ethnic groups in Austria-Hungary tore that area...

Words: 1128 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Ap World History Dbq Essay

...the basic principles of law were established that would be used by nearly every western system of law after: innocent until proven guilty, right to defend yourself in front of a judge, and the judge had to research all evidence carefully before making a verdict. 4. In Classical Greece (480-330 BC), homosexuality was widely practiced and accepted. Intolerance grew mainly due to increasingly strict religious beliefs. It would become outlawed in some nations. In 1972, the modern LGBT rights movement began, to allow LGBT individuals the same rights as everyone else. 5. In 1066, William the Conqueror invaded England in the Battle of Hastings. This would be the last successful invasion of England, and the last time anyone would try until Adolf Hitler in 1940 during WWII. 6. The Mesopotamian calendar was composed of 12 months. Every few years, an extra month would be added to re-align the calendar with the lunar cycle. Julius Caesar would use the ‘Leap Year’, or adding a day to February every 4 years, to keep the calendar in line. 7. During the 100 Years’ War (1337-1453), the longbow and cannon became widely used, changing warfare and making England the dominant military power. The American Civil War (1861-1865) introduced new technologies such as mobilization (use of railroads to transport troops) and the rifle that would permanently change warfare. 8. In England in 1358 and 1381, two Peasants’ Revolts took place due to inflation and taxes from the 100 Years’ War. American colonists...

Words: 3274 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Psyop Quotes

...victories in one hundred battles is not the supreme of excellence. To subdue the enemy without fighting is the supreme excellence. Sun Tzu "The first casualty of war is truth. Rudyard Kipling One need not destroy one's enemy. One need only destroy his willingness to engage. Sun Tzu There are but two powers in the world, the sword and the mind. In the long run the sword is always beaten by the mind. Napoleon Bonaparte In War, the moral is to the material as three is to one. Napoleon Bonaparte We were as hypnotized by the enemy's propaganda as a rabbit is by a snake. General Eric Von Ludendorf, German General Staff, 1918 The British bombarded our front not only with drum-fire of shells, but also with a drum-fire of printed paper. Besides bombs which kill the body, they drop from the air leaflets which are intended to kill the soul. Fieldmarshall Hindenberg, 1918 All propaganda has to be popular and has to adapt its spiritual level to the perception of the least intelligent of those towards whom it intends to direct itself. Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf ("My Struggle"), Vol. I ...there was no point in seeking to convert the intellectuals. For intellectuals would never be converted and would anyway always yield to the stronger, 'and this will always be the man in the street.' Arguments must therefore be crude, clear...

Words: 2186 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Charismatic Leaders

...See Characteristics of a Charismatic Leader Charismatic leaders are known to attract followers and inspire people to new heights (Basu). Attracting followers and inspiring people takes a certain type of personality or certain characteristics. People just don’t follow any single person. Something draws people in and once in these people can be inspired to do things. Some people, like Charles Manson, drew in followers and inspired them to murder; while some people, like Gandhi, drew in followers and inspired them to be better people. (Rosenberg, Charles Manson) (Rosenberg, Gandhi-Biography of Mahatma Gandhi) Manson and Gandhi had certain characteristics that drew people to them in the first place. These may have included maturity, communication skills, humility, and substance. Other traits include not just leading but being liked, care for others before you care for yourself, celebrate life and inspire enthusiasm, see the best in people and channel it, deal in hope and spread the goodies (Alain, 2011). Charismatic leaders do not necessarily have all of these traits but these would be what to look for when choosing a charismatic leader. Charismatic leaders need to be mature. This does not refer to age. This maturity is a buildup of wisdom over years through experience. This wisdom can be in business it can be in whatever are the person excels. Manson new how to draw in women and used that knowledge to start a cult. Communication is a key characteristic. Leaders...

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

A Politically and Economically Europe

...during their heyday, desired to conquer the entire European continent, and nearly succeeded. Between then and now, there have been other attempts to unify the European continent under one ruler - people such as Charlemagne, Napoleon and Hitler. It is only now that the unification of Europe seems to be possible, but in such a way as has never been thought of in the history of civilized man. No longer is the move towards a single ruler or a conquest of land. Today's unification is one of political and economic borders, in which the "conquered" nations gain a seat in an international High Authority and all people involved prosper. At least, this is the goal of the growing organization in Europe. In the course of history many famous people have spoken or dreamt of a United Europe, ranging from George Washington, Napoleon Bonaparte, or Giuseppe Mazzini to Richard Coudenhove-Kalergi. But probably the clearest, most concrete vision was articulated by the French writer Victor Hugo. This vision can only be understood against the background of the historic upheavals in nineteenth-century Europe that Victor Hugo experienced at first hand: several wars between France and Germany, Victor Hugo’s enforced exile in the Channel Islands because of his opposition to Napoleon III, the traumatic annexation of Alsace-Lorraine by Germany after the war of 1870/71, and lastly his involvement in the laborious birth of the Third Republic in France. Understandably Victor Hugo yearned then for peace...

Words: 1593 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Should Pope Benedict Xvi Have Resigned

...Should Pope Benedict XVI have resigned? For the first time in over 600 years, the Pope has stepped down from his holy position and abandoned his role in the Roman Catholic Church. In history, only four other Popes have resigned. Every Pope for the past 600 years has lived through their issues, personal matters, and problems to serve the Roman Catholic community and has died in their position. The Pope of the Roman Catholic Church, which values tradition, should have kept with the tradition of dying in his seat of holy power. However, in his resignation statement, Benedict states; “In today’s world … both strength of mind and body are necessary, strength which in the last few months, has deteriorated in me to the extent that I have had to recognize my incapacity to adequately fulfill the ministry entrusted to me.” The Pope argues that, with his deteriorating strength, he can no longer carry out the responsibilities of the papacy. It is also true that Pope Benedict XVI is leaving the church in a more troubled state than when he first received the grand position. For years, controversy has plagued Catholicism. The controversy has only intensified since his coronation. The Pope no longer signifies true morality, especially after sex scandal controversies appeared in recent years . An increase in religious disregard and apathy has brought a societal shift in perspective of the church. The position of The Pope, and the church in general, promotes backwards moral values from a...

Words: 2890 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Leadership

...ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR ASSIGNMENT (WMP13- SECTION-A) TOPIC: NARCISSISM A PERSONALITY DISORDER OR EFFICIENT LEADERSHIP STYLE GROUP MEMBERS: MAHENDRA PRATAP SINGH ABSTRACT: Narcissism- a personality trait encompassing grandiosity, arrogance, self-absorption, entitlement, fragile self-esteem, and hostility- is an attribute of many powerful leaders. Narcissistic leaders have grandiose belief systems and leadership styles, and are generally motivated by their needs for power and admiration rather than empathetic concern for the constituents and institutions they lead. However, narcissists also possess the charisma and grand vision that are vital to effective leadership. We should also critically review the traits of Narcissists Leadership, productive Narcissism, Unproductive Narcissism, it’s pros & cons, behavior of Narcissists leaders in crisis management & organizational recommendations. We can say that no leadership style is pure & have side effects of each other in small proportions among themselves, predominant constituent will be the main style & others will also be in small fractions. So, there is a little bit of narcissism in every individual. Narcissistic Leadership an Assessment Narcissism is a term used to describe a focus on the self and self-admiration that is taken to an extreme. The word "narcissism" comes from a Greek myth in which a handsome young man named Narcissus sees his reflection in a pool of water and falls in love with it. Narcissistic...

Words: 3742 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Paris History

...ITESM Campus Querétaro Dinámica de Sistemas Profesor. Joaquín Galarza Andrea Carrillo Flores // A01123885 Octavio Martínez Zamora // Mauricio Martín Colín Rodríguez // A01201929 Félix Negrete Pliego // A01206890 Actividad 2: Crecimiento de la población desde el punto de vista sustentable 19 Marzo 2015 París París es la capital de Francia con una población actual de 2, 265,886 personas, sin contar los suburbios que rodean a la ciudad. Cuenta con 20 municipios, dentro de los cuales la población está distribuida de la siguiente manera: Municipio | Población | Paris 1er canton | 17,268 | Paris 2e canton | 22,558 | Paris 3e canton | 36,727 | Paris 4e canton | 28,068 | Paris 5e canton | 61,080 | Paris 6e canton | 44,154 | Paris 7e canton | 58,166 | Paris 8e canton | 39,409 | Paris 9e canton | 60,293 | Paris 10e canton | 95,436 | Paris 11e canton | 156,831 | Paris 12e canton | 146,527 | Paris 13e canton | 184,235 | Paris 14e canton | 142,535 | Paris 15e canton | 240,723 | Paris 16e canton | 170,239 | Paris 17e canton | 171,945 | Paris 18e canton | 202,780 | Paris 19e canton | 187,799 | Paris 20e canton | 199,113 | De los datos históricos obtenidos la siguiente gráfica representa los cambios en la población del área de París, sin contar con sus suburbios: Marco Histórico de París. Para explicar el porqué del comportamiento de la gráfica, creemos necesario mostrar en marco histórico sobre el cual...

Words: 2872 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Ap Euro Notes

...AP EUROPEAN HISTORY NOTES- Filled with silliness and inside jokes, enjoy at your leisure :) If something is in [] brackets, it is only written in there for our pleasure, ignore it if you are looking for actual information. Key: • 7: The Renaissance and Reformation- 1350-1600 UMSUniversal o Georgio Vasari- Rinascita=rebirth (like Renaissance) painter/architect Male Suffrage o Individualism: People sought to receive personal credit for achievements, unlike medieval ideal of “all glory goes to god” Names Ideas o Renaissance: Began in Italian city-states, a cause de invention of the printing press, laid way for Protestant Reformation Events Books/Texts Italy: City states, under HRE (Holy Roman Empire) o For alliances:  old nobility vs. wealthy merchants FIGHT P-Prussia  Popolo: third class, “the people”, wanted own share of wealth/power R-Russia A-Austria  Ciompi Revolts: 1378 Florence, Popolo were revolting [eew], brief period of control over government B-Britain  Milan taken over by signor (which is a tyrant) • o Under control of the Condottiero (mercenary) Sforza- Significant because after this, a few wealthy families dominated Venice (e.g. Medici) Humanism: Francesco Petrarch (Sonnets), came up with term “Dark Ages”, began to study classical world of rhetoric and literature  Cicero: Important Roman, provided account of collapse of Roman Republic [like Edward Gibbon], invented Ciceronian style: Latin style of writing...

Words: 17289 - Pages: 70

Free Essay

Politic History of France

...Course: European Political History Required Sources: A History of Modern Europe 1789-1981, 7th Edition, H.L. Peacock (available at GAU library) The Pneguin History of the World, 3rd Edition, by J.M. Roberts (available at GAU library) Recommended Sources: Donald Kagan et al: A Political History of Europe, since 1814 by Charles Seignobos, S. M. Macvane, The Western Heritage, Brief Edition, 2003 Websites: The course focuses on European history from the early 17th century to the end of the Second World War. The following aspects of political history of five selected countries - France, Germany, Great Britain, Italy and Spain- are covered : early kingdoms, unification, nationalism movements, political philosophies, conferences, alliance systems and conflicts which had an impact on Europe during the 17th, 18th, 19th and 20th Centuries.Topics such as the Enlightenment, the French Revolution, the Concert of Europe, and the two world wars will also be discussed. Special emphasis will be placed on the relationship between the rise of liberalism and nationalism, the industrial revolution, and the emergence of modern political systems in Europe. Contents Introduction Chapter 1 Political history of France : Chapter 2 Political history of Germany: Chapter 3 Political history of Great Britain: Chapter 4 Political history of Italy: Chapter 5 Political history of Spain: Introduction In studying political history of European states, we put a focus on the beginning of...

Words: 24910 - Pages: 100

Free Essay

Ndjwnfc

...I. “REVOLUŢIA GLORIOASĂ” 1. ORIGINILE REVOLUŢIEI ENGLEZE Anglia secolului XVI cunoscuse o rapidă dezvoltare industrială bazată pe meşteşuguri, comerţ, minerit şi transporturi, concomitent cu apariţia fermei de tip capitalist bazat pe fenomenul „împrejmuirilor”. In 1603, la moartea Elisabetei I, tronul englez a revenit regelu Scoţiei, Iacob I Stuart. Ocuparea tronului de către Stuarţi aducea modificări importante în Anglia, unde Tudorii guvernaseră ca monarhi absoluţi, graţie abilităţii şi personalităţii lor. Stuarţii urmăreau instaurarea unui absolutism de drept, ceea ce contravenea realităţilor politice din Anglia, unde Parlamentul - format din Camera Comunelor şi Camera Lorzilor - împărţea puterea cu monarhia. Atât Iacob I, cât şi fiul său, Carol I (1625-1649), au încercat să guverneze fără a convoca Parlamentul, cu ajutorul Consiliului Privat, pe ai cărui membri îi numeau sau revocau după bunul lor plac. Ei legiferau prin proclamaţii regale şi exercitau puterea juridică prin Camera înstelată şi Curtea înaltei Comisiuni. Stuarţii agreau catolicismul într-o ţară anglicană, unde se dezvoltase mişcarea numită puritanism, care urmărea înlăturarea oricărei rămăşiţe a catolicismului.Apar contradicţii între absolutismul monarhic al regilor din familia Stuart(Iacob I şi Carol I), susţinut de vechea aristocraţie şi regimul parlamentar susţinut de Londra, burghezie şi noua nobilime. În plan religios biserica anglicană se confruntă cu curentele radicale protestante ce solicită înlăturarea...

Words: 51192 - Pages: 205

Premium Essay

Roman Influence In Ancient Rome

...Florence, Siena and many others had citizens take control of the government in their own hands and create democracies in each commune. The rich and powerful citizens of these cities began manipulating the government inside the walls and revert back to ruling like a dictatorship. Various parts of Italy came to be invaded by different countries like Spain and Greece due to political turmoil in the region. Spain took the region of Sicily and Austria ruled in the north. All this changed however when Napoleon Bonaparte arrived in 1796. By 1809, every part of the Italian peninsula was under the rule of the French. The Italian peninsula was back to its original and exact status prior to 1813, when Napoleon's army was defeated at Leipzig in Germany. At the beginning of the 20th century, a man named Mussolini began a long rise to power which ultimately led to his dictatorship over Italy. His lust for power led him to invade Ethiopia and Albania in 1936 and began an alliance with Adolf Hitler in Germany. The disastrous campaigns in Northern Africa during World War II led to the loss of all Italian colonies in the region due to the advances from the Allies....

Words: 3152 - Pages: 13