Free Essay

Pollan

In:

Submitted By LeaSava1707
Words 1776
Pages 8
After an exhausting game of basketball on my Playstation two it was time to eat. As my search for food was coming to an end I came across a bag of potatoes. So using the cooking skills that I have acquired in my many years I decided to make french-fries. As I cut my potatoes I started to think about Michael Pollan’s essay “Playing God in the Garden”. This essay is about the creation of “genetically engineered” potatoes that produce their own insecticide right inside their leaves. I began to wonder if the potatoes on my plate were the same “New Leaf” potatoes that Pollan talked about. I started to change my mind about eating the fries that I had already melted cheese on but they looked to good to give to my roommate so I continued thinking while eating. The government does not require New Leaf potatoes to be labeled in stores so it must mean they feel it will have no harm on people. One of the many reasons that government exists is to look over the wealth fare of its citizens. Think of some of the things that a company must put on their products, labels on alcohol and cigarettes tell the dangers that come from using them, and all foods packages must have the ingredients printed on them. The government also sets up programs like family first to help people in need. Even in high school a person needs four years of gym. Peter Drucker touches this subject in his essay “The Age of Social Transformation” as he talks about a changing society. The government made the decision that using the knowledge that Monsanto found was the right thing to do for the farming industry. The best times will come when the knowledge that people have is used to enhance their lives. What good is knowledge if it is not used? There is no point in learning new things if the only reason for learning them is to prove a point or to know more than someone else. Knowledge should be used and the New Leaf is just a potato that has had knowledge applied to it. The potato helps farmers because they no longer have to bathe their fields in harmful chemicals. Imagine living on a farm and someone offers a job that pays more, has fewer hours and is easier than farm work. Any person would leave, it just makes sense. This is the start of the industrial worker. In Peter F. Drucker’s essay “The Age of Social Transformation” he talks about the next social change, the move into the knowledge society. Unlike the move from farmer to industrial worker this move will be much more difficult. “The rise of the class succeeding industrial workers is not an opportunity for industrial workers. It is a challenge” (Drucker 253). Not everyone will be able to move into knowledge work the way people moved into industrial work. In Drucker’s new society the organization has a big role. It will not only be a person’s place of employment but were they can contribute to their community. “Playing God in the Garden” an essay by Michael Pollan is about “genetically engineered” (Pollan 459) potatoes that produce their own insecticide. This potato makes farmers jobs easier and safer “from where a typical American potato grower stands, the New Leaf looks very much like a godsend” (Pollan 468). Some people feel that it is wrong for these potatoes to be on the market and are angry that they are not labeled as being genetically engineered. Both essays “Playing God in the Garden” and “The Age of Social Transformation” are related because the potato in Pollan’s essay is a product of Drucker’s knowledge society. The company that created the potato is called Monsanto and they signify the kind of knowledge work Drucker saw as the future. The “knowledge worker” (Drucker) that Drucker talks about will be required to have a formal education. They will be the center of this new society. The knowledge worker is going to change what it means to be an employee. We are already moving into a kind of knowledge society, one were having a formal education is necessary. Unless someone is on the cleaning crew a formal education is the only way to work for Monsanto, it is therefore a knowledge company. “With the advent of biotechnology, agriculture is entering the information age” (Pollan 461). Pollan knows Monsanto is trying o be the leader in the new age of biotechnology. Moreover, as a leader they will get complaints from everywhere. “Uncertainty is the theme that unifies much of the criticism leveled against biotech agriculture by scientists and environmentalist” (Pollan 464). Like the first to do anything they will be criticized by many people. Monsanto fits Drucker’s image of a knowledge company that does not care about anything but its own purpose. That is exactly how Monsanto treats itself, they are about making money and that is what they do. Phil Angell a Monsanto executive who Pollan asked the safety of the New Leaf potatoes said, “Our interest is in selling as much as possible. Assuring its safety is the F.D.A.’s job” (Pollan 468). Drucker knows that a company’s main goal is and will always be to make money. “In the society of organizations each of the new institutions is concerned only with its own purpose and mission. It does not claim power over anything else” (Drucker 268). However, Drucker feels that every company also needs to do more to help the community; they need to take responsibility for their own actions. The question is why should they? Monsanto has a responsibility to society, because their employees are a part of it. Pollan could be wrong, maybe Monsanto really thought about the effects that their New Leaf’s could have on the Earth’s ecosystem and that it was not a problem. Because it is up to the scientists as knowledge workers to take into account their own actions. In the knowledge society it is possible for an employee to have a commitment to society because “knowledge workers – own the tools of production” (Drucker 260). If the scientists were to leave Monsanto they would take their knowledge with them and since Monsanto relies on them, they can decide if it is the right decision to create the potatoes or not. There probably is a chance that these New Leaf potatoes could create a change in the Earth’s ecosystem and because of that chance Monsanto owes it to the world to make sure that there are no problems that can be caused by their potatoes. Besides that, they have to care because they live here too. Drucker feels that in order for someone to get the most out of knowledge they must be part of an organization. “Only the organization can provide the basic continuity that knowledge workers need to be effective” (Drucker 259). The organization gives a person something to use their knowledge on. Monsanto puts people to work, people who have a formal education and gives them something to accomplish. If Monsanto had not put their scientists to work, the New Leaf potato probably would not have been created. “The surgeon needs the operating room of the hospital and all its expensive capital equipment” (Drucker 260). Even if a scientist had the idea for the potato he probably would not have the money to try to make his idea a reality. Drucker believes that people need an organization to make their knowledge useful, but the organization needs them more than they need it. Even though Monsanto gives the scientists somewhere to use their knowledge if they disagreed with the company they can always leave and find work elsewhere, giving some other company the New Leaf potato. “Increasingly, the true investment in the knowledge society is not in machines and tools but in the knowledge of the knowledge worker” (Drucker 260). The investment a company like Monsanto makes is in the knowledge that the scientists they hire possess. So all the actions of the company are supported by their employees, everything Monsanto does and can do falls on the morals of the people who work there. Drucker would say that the other important part of Monsanto is the management. “Management is the distinctive organ of all organizations. All of them require management” (Drucker 261). It is the job of the manager to bring people together for one goal. The management also has to have an “understanding of the organization itself – its purposes, its values, its environment and markets, its core competencies” (Drucker 262). Therefore, it is up to the management to make sure the company reaches its goals. When Pollan asks questions about the New Leaf potatoes it was up to the executives to answer his questions and make him feel secure about their product. If management does a good job making people feel secure about their product then the criticism will stop. Drucker acknowledges that the knowledge society will have to be able work and cooperate with people who are not knowledge workers, and that this will be one of the hardest things to do. “People with knowledge will take responsibility for making themselves understood by people who do not have the same knowledge base” (Drucker 258). For example, it is Monsanto’s responsibility as a knowledge company to make sure everyone understands what they are trying to do. It is in their favor to have the people who are buying their product understand why it is necessary for this New Leaf potato to be available to commercial farmers and it is their responsibility to answer any other questions that people might have. The question that Drucker raises about the knowledge society is what will happen to the communities. Who or what is going to do tasks that the community should be doing. Drucker feels that the old community cannot, the business cannot, and that the government has failed: “But as the agency to run social services, it has proved almost totally incompetent” (Drucker 263). He feels that the answer is a new social sector. This social sector will give a person a way to connect with their community, let them feel as though they are making a difference. They can make a difference by helping in their neighborhood or helping with something bigger. And in the case of Monsanto just by caring about what they are doing. If their scientists feel that they should not create a genetic potato than they should not, it will make them feel better as people if they do what they feel is right.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Hurst & Pollan

...Hurst and Pollan Close Reading After reading Craft of Research chapters 3-4, read the articles in EE by Pollan (91-106) and Hurst (23-30). Then type your responses to the following questions and bring a completed hard copy to class on Monday. This assignment will help you find research problems as you read your sources, as it explains in CR p. 63. 1. Reverse outline Pollan’s article, which is a complex piece because he talks about many different positions before explaining his own. Reverse outlining means making a list of the main points he makes, in order—list 5-10 of these. * Animal liberation and how does intelligence entitle humans to exploit nonhumans * Speciesism & how it could just be like racism * Animal suffering and pain and not necessarily the killing is the issue * Vegetarian utopia & how it would make us more dependent on industrialized food chain * Polyface farm & animals with respectful deaths 2. Write Pollan’s main argument in the form of an enthymeme (E): claim because reason. It is alright to kill animals for their meat because it is moral right as long as we treat them with respect when they are alive. 3. Write Hurst’s main argument the form of an enthymeme (E): claim because reason. Farmers should not be criticized for using “industrial” farming methods because all farmers have reasons for their actions through their knowledge and experience of farming. 4. What evidence does Hurst give for his position? Remember to use...

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Summary Of Omnivore's Dilemma By Michael Pollan

...Samuel Benson Mrs.Vermillion AP L+C 19 February 2018 Omnivore’s Dilemma Summary Michael Pollan, an average American journalist, paid no attention to where his food came from as everyone else did prior to the writing of his book, Omnivore’s Dilemma. That was until he was sent out to cover a story on genetically modified foods and was surprised to see how complicated and contrived the food manufacturing system was. His findings prompted Pollan to set out on his own quest to discover what he really was putting in his mouth. His journey carried him all across America and taught him the importance quality food has on all other aspects of life. Pollan started out uncovering the modern farming machine and how it ticks. All of agribusiness is run...

Words: 538 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Michael Pollan

...Hefei Yang English 1001-23 Jeff Scott Analysis of Michael Pollan’s article Michael Pollan’s essay, The Food Movement, Rising, is separated into three parts which are “Food made Visible”, “Food Politics” and “Beyond the Barcode”. Pollan mainly discusses the cheap food politics and some of these food safety scandals, the environment and health problem problems, the appearance of obesity in America, and fast and junk food compared to local food. I agree with Pollan that health is the most important thing all the time. However, people in our modern economy need convenient and cheap food at the present, although sometimes the quality and health cannot be ensured. As far as I am concerned, what we can do is to try our best to make healthy food with the environment in mind. Producing food for a reasonable price, health, safety, and low pollution should be the best choice for modern society. Cheap food accompanied with the reform of food production is required because of the modern economy and society. As Pollan states, “Cheap food has become an indispensable pillar of the modern economy. But it is no longer an invisible or uncontested one” (2). As we know, the most important thing for people to survive is eating. Most people in the world are not wealthy and full of ability. The recession affecting unemployment has swept across the whole world in recent years. It has influenced how much family’s income is spent on food. The decline of family income makes the United State family want...

Words: 1235 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Analysis on Michael Pollan's Essay

...Analysis of Michael Pollan’s Essay “The Food Movement, Rising” Michael Pollan wrote an article entitled “The Food Movement, Rising”.  This article talks about how food impacts many facets in the nation including politics, society and family. In this article he shares how food is not just about food and is a much larger issue than meets the eye. He talks about how the issues of food have impacted the country and therefore the world (Pollan). Then, he breaks the issues down on macro and micro levels, focusing on the impact of food on politics, society, and family. Finally, he points out the real cost of food, directly and indirectly. I agree with Michael Pollan about the ongoing issues with food and I am against industrial agriculture too. Americans have not had to think very hard about where their food comes from, or what it is doing to the planet, their bodies, and their society. (Pollan) Pollan points out the exact current problems about food. He believes that people should eat better food. However, Pollan neglects to mention that it was a problem hundred years ago, and it is still a problem today. He points out in his article that food in America has been invisible as an issue until the early 1970s, when food price inflation pushed the topic to be an important national agenda. He mentions that “before this food was never an issue to be discussed in America because it was available at cheap prices”. Also, Americans were completely ignorant of what was the bigger cost they...

Words: 1334 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Omnivore Review

...Review | A review on Michael Pollans “The Omnivore dilemma” | | Cody Windsor Harrington | DeVry University | The Omnivore Review As agriculture technology continues to advance in the new world most of us have lost our pre historic skills of basic survival when it comes to hunting and gathering. America’s agriculture logistics are so well developed that most Americans relay on this system to stay alive. A small portion of people out there still remain intact with their pre historic agriculture skills. That is what Author Michael Pollan writes about In Part 3, Chapters 15, 16, and 17 of The Omnivore’s Dilemma. Michael Pollan talks about looking for different foods, the ethics of hunting animals and harvesting the meat as well as giving a brief look into what brought about the paradox of The Omnivore’s Dilemma.   Chapters 15, 16, and 17 bring up a lot of good points about foraging and hunting. Pollan provides in depth detail and research on the topics. The difficult part is staying focused on the story the author is illustrating. Pollan tends to bounce around on different topics and drags out details making it difficult to keep the reader entertained. Chapter 15 of Omnivore's Dilemma discusses how Pollan is preparing to make a meal from all of the foraging groups. Fruits, vegetables, fungi, and meat were the components that made up this meal. His goal was to find and gather enough from each group to make his first meal from nature. Pollan discusses his recent move to...

Words: 930 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Omnivore's Dilemma A Natural History Of Four Meals Summary

...The Omnivore’s Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals Scrutinizing the ethical factors concerning the “eating of animals,” Michael Pollan asserts that “most domesticated animals cannot survive the wild” (Pollan 310) and “without us eating them, they simply wouldn’t exist at all.” (Pollan 310) Furthermore, he makes an attempt to refute Peter Singer’s cultural and philosophical affirmations about the “exploitation of non-humans,” (Pollan 309) especially when Singer endeavors to show the “speciest” mentality (as Pollan calls it) that our society has towards non-humans, thus raising the question on whether the “principle of equality” (Pollan 308) can be fairly utilized between humans and nonhumans. A vegetarian lifestyle is, by all means, no...

Words: 570 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Omnivore's Dilemma Chapter Summaries

...Isabelle Gaylor Mrs. Vermillion AP 11 English 02 November 2015 The Omnivore’s Dilemma Summary The Omnivore’s Dilemma was written by Michael Pollan, a journalist, who had no prior knowledge of where his food came from and how it was made. This book goes through each step and learning process Pollan went through on his journey of “food enlightenment”. In the first chapter, Pollan brings up a very true and slightly terrifying point almost right away. Everything we eat has something to do with corn. Chips made from corn flour, beef from corn fed steers, and even sodas are made sugary with corn syrup. There is virtually no escape from the circle of corn that makes up our diets. Corn is also made into fertilizer both by being mashed into the ground by wandering cattle and through the feces of chickens, cows, etc… In the third chapter, Pollan explores the heart of the industrial food chain. Bombs from World War II hold a large amount of ammonium nitrate. Ammonium nitrate also happens to be a great supplier of nitrogen which is used to grow plants. Although Hybrid corns eat up a lot of nitrogen, it is still way more than they can take. The excess nitrogen seeps into the ground and eventually becomes run-off, that causes major nitrogen pollution....

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pollen, Micheal

...praises Michael Pollan’s book, which follows the food chain of four meals back to their sources, including a McDonald’s lunch and a dinner of supposedly wholesome items from Whole Foods market. She finds Pollan to be a good writer and thorough researcher, not a “preachy” activist. Her brief review is positive, which is why Pollan probably has it posted on his website. This would be a useful source if contrasted against a more critical evaluation of Pollan’s work. Pollan, M. (2002). The botany of desire: A plant’s-eye view of the world. New York: Random House. Pollan outlines the history of four crops-- apples, tulips, marijuana and potatoes. He discusses how humans have influenced their evolution and how crops have influenced our cultures. He recounts real stories, rather than myths, about such characters as “Johnny Appleseed,” an eccentric loner who helped colonize various apple crops across a new America. As a result, we do not have as many varieties of apples as once existed, and the ones we have are less resistant to pests.   Pollan, Michael. (2008). In Defense of Food: An Eater’s Manifesto. New York: The Penguin Press. ISBN 978-1-59420-145-5 Pollan’s book can be summed up in his introductory statement: “Eat Food. Not Too Much. Mostly Plants.”  Pollan explores the roots of the current American food system and details how government regulation of the food industry has been affected by pressure from agriculture interest groups and corporations.  Agencies...

Words: 480 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Organic Is Possible

...lifestyle given the right amount of motivation. Eating organic stands bold with its reputation of failure; what people don’t comprehend is the transition from an unhealthy lifestyle should not be immediate and must be handled with patience. There are many secret tricks and concealed knowledge about organic produce that most individuals never unfold due to their own frustration. Allen, concerned mainly with the cost of healthy food and ignoring the health needs of her family, puts herself in distress while contemplating what is truly important for her family. Of course she cares about her family’s diet and wishes to nourish it the best she can, preparing a meal from scratch with no added pesticides or fillers must be an exception. Michael Pollan, a writer for the New York Times and a...

Words: 1454 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Yhe Omnivore Review

...The book, The Omnivores Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals, by Michael Pollen, is a much more tangled and thought provoking treatise on American cuisine, than the title even begins to suggest. In chapters 15-17, Pollan skillfully brings us along as he explores the good, bad, risk, and reward of our choice to eat as a Hunter-gatherer. He delves into relationships of this choice that are normally unimagined by the vast majority. He paints the emotion mental turmoil of this decision with illuminating facts and masterful language in a way that exposes somewhat humorous paradox’s that keep us hungering for more of this insightful and exhilarating book. In these chapters Pollan explores the dilemmas facing us through his own experiences in choosing to eat as a Hunter-gatherer. Using poignant language that unfolds naturally he depicts the risks of gathering or hunting foods from various perspectives. His flowing logic in making his choice is laced generously with support from sources such as Walden, Thoreau, Leopold, Shepard, and others, thus giving credence to the entire process. This thorough, well supported reasoning frequently gives rise to subtle ironies making the American dilemma of eating somewhat laughable and the book all the more fascinating. Pollan keeps the reader mentally engaged and yearning to learn what absurdity the next round of reason might expose regarding our eating dilemma. In his treatment of mushroom hunting you can see his mother warning him that some...

Words: 530 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Omnivore's Dilemma: the Forest

...The Omnivore's Dilemma written by Michael Pollan is a book that helps show how our cultures have changed in choosing what to eat and how how easy we are convinced to change what we eat. The last section of the book called The Forest the author points out the ethical and moral dilemmas and how far we have changed from our ancestors days of hunting and gathering for our meals to buying our meals from supermarkets or fast food restaurants.. The author opens this last section with how he wants to make one last meal with all the elements of this meal are to be hunted and gathered by his own hands and flows the into the topic of how we have changed from not knowing what is and isn't safe to eat and finally into the moral dilemma of eating meat. In the first part, The Forager the author's introduction pulls you in and entices to to keep reading to find out if he was successful in his mission. By using his personal history to explain his lacking experience in hunting and little experience with gathering leaves you hoping that he will ultimately be successful in preparing his meal. The common expectation that the hero or good guy will be successful in his mission is a frequent occurrence in media today. In this case the hero is the author and his quest isn't to save a princess but to be successful in hunting and gathering his own meal that is free from the industrialized food that is around every corner. The author does a great job in flowing between topics with continuing from his...

Words: 675 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Omnivore's Dilemma Summary

...The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan talks about the food chains that keep America sustained and the effects that we have made on the environment. Pollan tries to convey that the good treatment of animals and their environments is beneficial to the quality and taste of the food. My favorite part of the book was when Pollan went to Polyface farm and learned about grass farming. The farmer at Polyface wanted his farm to mimic a natural ecosystem where all the animals and plants would live mutualistically to better the environment around them. The biggest takeaway from this book was that every single thing in the food chain has an effect on the food on our plates. How the animals or plants are grown, killed, and shipped all matter to the...

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Forager

...The Forager’s Dilemma Christopher K. Johnson DeVry University The Forager’s Dilemma In the book, “The Omnivore’s Dilemma”, which was written by Michael Pollan, I read a story about a man’s journey to find a meal he could call his own. Part III, “The Forager” is about reconnecting with the earth and its nature. From pages 277-286, the text will give the reader a taste of what it is like to forage. Pollan is a self-proclaimed “Great in-doors man” and only has a few fond memories of dealing with nature. He has never owned or shot a gun nor has he ever hunted mushrooms due to his fungi phobia. Even with all his lack of natural experience, he is set on showing the reader how different it was to hunt, gather, and grow our own foods rather than depend on the present day agriculturalist. After struggling with everything that has happened throughout the story, he never gives up, even though his doubt gets the best of him in the end. In the first three chapters of Part III were well written and a good read for anyone interested. The purpose of this review is to give you my point of view in hopes to provide a good evaluation for my fellow readers to compare their notes with. There were quite many facts in this reading that caught my attention. One fact in particular was how agriculture brought about infectious disease and malnutrition. Anthropologists venture to say that the typical hunter-gatherers work week was about 17 hours long. These work ethics...

Words: 923 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Not so Grrreat

...Not So Grrreat! Cereal is the most popular breakfast choice today. However, the cereal aisle is a parent’s worst nightmare of bright colors and cartoon characters floating in a sea of sugar. Cereal boxes are littered with promises of health and nutrition; but these are just empty promises used to trick parents into believing they are feeding their children the right foods. Cereal companies use catchy tunes and slogans to grab the attention of young children. The children then proceed to beg and pester their parents until they get the cereal they want. Most parents strive to feed children nutritional foods but cereal companies have been making it harder and harder. Cereals that are marketed to children have little nutritional value and can lead to poor performance in school; this can be solved by marketing the nutritional cereals to children and parents removing unhealthy cereals from their children’s diets. First, cereals marketed to children have little nutritional value. Cereal companies are required to self-regulate the nutritional value of their products, but this self-regulation only gives the cereal companies the right to fill cereal boxes with whatever they want. In an article by Georgina Gustin in December 2011, Jane Houlihan, vice president for research at the Environmental Working Group, states that cereals don’t belong in your breakfast pantry, they are desserts. Houlihan’s group assessed 84 cereals to make a report focusing on the larger cereal makers, the big...

Words: 1574 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ethical Relativism

...Sean Ruhlman Ms. Rooney ENC-1101 19 November, 2013 Ethical Relativism At what point do we need to refocus our priorities as a civilization? Ethical relativism can best be understood by focusing on the juxtaposition of the benefits of biotechnological advancements in the food industry with the synergetic natural relationship of all living organisms. The argument supporting our technologically enhanced farming is often overlooked by the idealists of our society vying for the end of world hunger. Is it realistic to believe that without these processed foods which make up over two thirds of the world’s diet; the population would be remotely similar in size to that of a population using non-biologically engineered or enhanced foods? Has our society grown to such magnitudes merely as a result of our ability to produce food as quickly and efficiently as we currently do? At what point will humanity’s demand, exceed the Earth’s carrying capacity? This then raises the question of morality. Is it ethically right to turn our backs and deny a portion of our ever-growing population the ability to eat knowing we are beginning to challenge global sustainability? Arguably, it is reasonable to assume that if you were to take away our overly processed, biologically re-engineered foods in order to reach equilibrium, there would be a proportionate loss of human life. This however, may be the only way to ensure humanity’s survival. This is where ethical relativity has to be decided as a...

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5