Free Essay

State Reorganization

In:

Submitted By aishwarya1993
Words 3312
Pages 14
“At the stroke of the midnight hour, when the world sleeps, India will awake to life and freedom.

A moment comes, which comes but rarely in history, when we step out from the old to the new,

when an age ends, and when the soul of a nation, long suppressed, finds utterance…”1

When the First Prime Minister of India, Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru, gave his speech, he must have

been prepared with the various post-independence hurdles, the infant democracy would have

to undergo. Certainly, India, exemplifies the phrase, ‘Unity in Diversity.’ It is thus, astonishing

to see a country with innumerable divisions and differences, managed to stay united for the 65

years of independence it has seen. Post independence the main motive of the Indian Government

was to ensure that the Indo-Pak partition incident isn’t repeated.2

as many as 136 small and large states were acceded to the Indian Union. The states were

reintegrated soon to form the Union. However, people in various states have been from the time

of independence, till date, extremely vocal of territorial autonomy and political independence.

One such demand relates to the demand of ‘Reorganization of states’3

ethnic differences, and economical differences.

This movement, thus led to what we see today, ‘The Union of India’, with 28 states and 7 Union

territories.

On the eve of independence

on the basis of language,

Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru’s speech, at the time of Independence, 15th

1

2Majeed A. (The Changing Politics of States' Reorganization). 2003 Publius Vol. 33, No. 4, Emerging Federal

Process in India (Autumn, 2003) (pp. 83-98)

The Seventh Amendment to the Constitution, 1956, which bought about changes in- Articles 1, 49, 80, 81, 82,

3

131, 153, 158, 168, 170, 171, 216, 217, 220, 222, 224, 230, 231 and 232.

Inserted articles 258A, 290A, 298, 350A, 350B, 371, 372A and 378A.

Amended part 8.

Amended schedules 1, 2, 4 and 7. Also changed the composition of council of states thereby changing the

representation of the different states in Lok Sabha also.

August 1947, New Delhi, India.

5

HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES AND LEGAL EVOLUTION OF THE

MOVEMENT

Typically, the term ‘State Reorganization’, relates to the alteration of the state boundaries

and creation of new states, both being by sanction of the Union Government. The state

reorganization movement has been one of the movements which has deep penetrated roots

since the pre-independence time. The first committee formed in this regard was in the pre

independence time, comprising Motilal Nehru and Jawaharlal Nehru. The Committee submitted

its Report in 1928. The Report clearly laid down that after independence, the Country could

be reorganized on the basis of languages. However with independence as the frontline agenda,

this recommendation took a back seat, but evidently did not disappear from the mainstream.

Post independence, the First Committee formed in this regard was the Dar Commission headed

by S.K.Dar. This committee did not recommend division of states on linguistic basis. In the

year, 1948, an unofficial committee was first formed in this regard, called the J.V.P Committee,

named after its members, Jawaharlal Nehru, Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel, Pattabhi Sitaramayya,

which did acknowledge the possible division on the basis of language, yet suggested that it

could be postponed. However, it suggested that Andhra Province could be formed provided

the Andhraites gave up their claim to the city of Madras (now Chennai). Post independence,

Government’s sole motive was administrative pragmatism and maintaining unity. Thus it could

not accept the domination of a region by giving it the status of a state.

The then Prime Minister, J.L Nehru, and his colleagues aimed at the creation of large,

heterogeneous states because such composite states could discourage prejudiced identities.

However, this was just a mere, wishful thinking. The states were discontented, dissatisfied,

fuming, for even a democracy was not able to give what they really wanted. It was the death of

the iconic leader, Sriramulu Potti of Andhra Pradesh, which set the ball rolling for the movement

to begin. The Andhra leader whose ‘fast unto death’4

of people was the trigger event behind the never ending protests, starting from protests in Andhra

i.e. ‘Madras Manade Movement’ which gave birth to many other, similar movements, Samyukta

, left a really strong impression in the minds

Sriramulu fasted for 59 days, and on the midnight of 15th

4

population and huge protests ultimately led to the ‘Madras Manade’ movement, meaning, “Madras is ours”

December 1952, passed away. This agitated the telugu

6

Maharashtra, Mahagujarat Andolan, Punjabi Suba5

various Indian states. The government finally had to give in to the demands of the people and

they formed the SRC, i.e. the State Reorganization Commission comprising, S. Fazal Ali, K.

M. Panikkar; H. N. Kunzru.6

southern states must be separated. However, the demands for a Marathi and a Gujarati speaking

state was not granted taking the Gujarati and Parsi business communities (who lived in Bombay),

in consideration. Nor was the demand for a separate Punjabi-Suba granted. As early as 1956,

14 states were formed based on linguistic differences. These were the southern states and the

states of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, and a new state of Bombay (which included the regions of

present day Gujarat).78

, and many others that started taking place in

The Committee came up with the recommendations that the four

MAHAGUJARAT ANDOLAN & SAMYUKTA MAHARASHTRA-

-Two different sides of the same coin

(The Mahagujarat Andolan and Samyukta Maharashtra movement were intrinsically linked

to each other. Both, Maharashtra as well as Gujarat wanted separate states to attain their own

autonomy over the linguistically homogenous territories.)

5

Sant Fateh Singh and Master Tara Chand, the two key leaders fought for a separate ‘Suba’ or state.

6

Guha R. (2011). Thinking Beyond Telangana. The Telegraph. 15th

beyond-telangana-2.html, retrieved on 1st

7

The state of Andhra Pradesh was formed by merging Andhra with part of Hyderabad. Bombay was formed by

merging Kutch, the Saurashtra union and part of what had formerly been Bombay. Kerala was formed by merging

most of the Travancore-Cochin union and part of Madras. Madhya Pradesh was formed by merging Bhopal and

the Vindhya Pradesh union. The state of Mysore was formed by merging Coorg and Mysore as well as parts of the

former states of Bombay, Hyderabad and Madras. Punjab was expanded by adding Patiala and the East Punjab

states to its former territory.

8

Article 3 of the Indian Constitution states that the parliament can alter the boundaries, increase or diminish the

areas also, alter the name and may create another state as well.

January http://ramachandraguha.in/archives/

March, 2013

7

“An All-India Radio announcement of Bombay as 'a separate city state' by Jawaharlal Nehru

on November 20, 1955 was the trigger for the tense situation. The first bout of firing started on

November 21, 1955 and continued for days in parts of Bombay.”9

The movement was spearheaded by Acharya Atre, Senapati Bapat and Prabodhankar

Thackeray10

Desai, in his weekly, Navyug, titled “Jantecha Kasai: Morarji Desai.” Literature and large scale

dissemination of information had a positive and a major impact on the Samyukta Maharashtra

Movement and thus was an integral part1112

It was soon realized that giving Bombay to Maharashtra was vital for the survival of the

Congresss base in Maharashtra.

However, this wasn’t a peaceful movement. The entire period from November 1955 to January

1956 saw several attacks and deaths.1314

While Maharashtra knew no peace, Gujarat too was simmering. The Mahagujarat Andolan15was

spearheaded by Indulal Yagnik16

The Congress government under Morarji Desai, supposed to have taken pernicious moves, solely

concentrated on how to prevent Maharashtrian population from taking over Bombay.

. Acharya Atre, who was arrested for having writing an article against Morarji

.

.

, Brahmakumar Bhatt17and Harihar Khambholja18

9

An All-India Radio announcement of Bombay as 'a separate city state' by Jawaharlal Nehru on November 20, 1955

was the trigger for the tense situation among communities who supported Bombay as part of Maharashtra and

objected to the formation of a bilingual state. The first bout of firing started on November 21, 1955 and continued

for days at parts of Dadar, Lalbaugh, Parel, Kalachowkie.

10

Father of late Shivsena Leader, Bal Thackeray

11

Atre continued to write articles in the Arthur Road Jail

Samyukta Maharashtra was important because the demand for linguistic statehood was in Mumbai combined

12

with a popular movement against rigid class hierarchies in an industrial city dominated by big business interests.

13

The records show 103 people lost their lives in the riots for Samyukta Maharashtra, 71 of them succumbed to

bullet injuries

14

Id.

15

Kanaiyalal Munshi, eminent litterateur, coined the word Mahagujarat at the Karachi meet of Gujarati Sahitya

Parishad

16

Vashi A. (2010). Common man who never became CM. The Times of India. 30th

http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-04-30/ahmedabad/28113912_1_navjivan-trust-satyagraha- separate-state 17

Brahmakumar Bhatt passes away [Internet]. The Times of India, Ahmedabad, January 7th

articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2009-01-07/ahmedabad/28052740_1_state-assembly-leader-new-party

18

Dave J. & Desai K. (2012). Revolution in Gujarat’s blood. DNA. 4th

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/slideshow_revolution-in-gujarats-blood_1684431-4#top

April, from

May.

8

Thus, the government was putting in their best efforts in this regard. They worked out various

propositions19

decided to make Bombay a bilingual state. This angered the Gujarati population and this led to

the ‘Mahagujarat Andolan’ had to give in to the demand of Bombay being made the Capital City

of the new, Marathi speaking state, ‘Maharashtra’.

One of the striking features of Mahagujarat Andolan was the involvement of Dalits in large

numbers20

the rest of the state, Indulal Yagnik, and other leaders of the movement, made an effort to

connect to the region culturally.2324

Ultimately, they got a state which had language and customs as a commonality, in 1960, which

they could have got in 1956, had they conceded to the demand of the Maharashtra state in 1956.

Inspite of the immense effort, this was one of the most futile movements.2526

. However, to their detriment, nothing seemed to work out and Congress

and the involvement of women21

. Since Dang22

was considered to be detached from

OTHER STATES AND ISSUES

19E.g. Bombay being made a separate territory, or a centrally administered state or being jointly administered by

both the states

20

Shinoda T.(2002). The Other Gujarat. Popular Prakashan, retrieved from

http://books.google.co.in/books?

id=KZNfS7mikMoC&pg=PA35&lpg=PA35&dq=mahagujarat+andolan&source=bl&ots=s9XKja37gO&sig=safUzi2zQP

M3UMNtGM6GOJllpaQ&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ThI7UdacK4r5rQeAs4DgBA&sqi=2&ved=0CFMQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=

mahagujarat%20andolan&f=false

21

Indulal Yagnik, asked the women volunteers of the andolan to participate and called for a ‘Jail Bharo Andolan’.

The women leaders (Ranjanben Dalal and Shardaben Bhatt), then went from place to place and spread a word

about the movement. They were arrested and put in the jail for 21 days.

22

Dang, in South Gujarat is dominated by the tribal population. Agitation reached its peak when Morarji Desai

claimed Dangs to be a part of Maharashtra.

Gujarati Sabha also formed a committee comprising painter Ravishankar Raval, Pandit Omkarnath, Professor

23

Yashwant Shukla, renowned linguist Madhusudan Modi and others to get in-depth details about history, culture,

art, customs and language of people of Dang. Moreover, the sabha also started agitating about the state

government's statement to create awareness among people. in 1960, when Gujarat was founded on the basis of

its language and Dang was part of it.

24

Dave J. & Desai K. (2012). Revolution in Gujarat’s blood. DNA. 4th

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/slideshow_revolution-in-gujarats-blood_1684431-4#top

25

Shinoda T.(2002). The Other Gujarat. Popular Prakashan, retrieved from http://books.google.co.in/books?

id=Ubk4qXLI9AQC&pg=PA21&lpg=PA21&dq=mahagujarat+movement&source=bl&ots=BD0s-OofMx&sig=6jXHpA-
Giwb6iH1cV8pv3Zoar2U&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ZhM7UfXRGZCsrAfmj4GIDg&ved=0CE4Q6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=mahag

ujarat%20movement&f=false

26

Hundreds of people laid down their lives and thousands were injured because of police brutality during the 226-

day agitation.

May.

9

Punjab Suba27

different from the rest of the movements with formation of Khalistan and violent activities

coming to forefront. 28The issue of Chandigarh remains unsolved. The 1956 amendment

brought about a change only in Assam in the north east, with rest being formed in the 1960s

and 70s.29

Kuki(Mizoram) and the Naga groups still are at loggerheads.31

The Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand divide, based on economic differences and empowerment,

sets a precedent for the Telangana issue32

The fight over the division of the state of Andhra Pradesh is based on economic differences.3334

The new millennium began with a change in the Indian Map again. Three new states were

formed. However, the three new states of Uttarkhand, Jharkhand and Chattisgarh were mainly

formed on ethnic differences and language had no role to play. Movement for the disintegration

Chattissgarh was relatively peaceful compared to the other two states. Uttarakhand presented

a unique case of division on the basis of topography, while the tribal population of Jharkhand

aimed at preserving their identity. The main contention of all the three states was the economic

neglect and lack of development in the agitated regions.

movement led to the division of Punjab. However, its consequences were

30However, the viability ranking of the north eastern states continues to be low as the

.

27

Master Tara Singh v. Singh vs State Of Punjab And Anr. 1961 CriLJ 547

28

Punjab was disintegrated from the old, Hindi speaking conglomeration to the new, Punjabi speaking resent day

Punjab state.

29

Nagaland was formed in 1963, and Meghalaya in 1972 with Tripura and Manipur.

http://www.ide.go.jp/English/Publish/Download/Jrp/pdf/133_3.pdf

30

31

http://books.google.co.in/books?

id=v44gVIFltgQC&pg=PA39&lpg=PA39&dq=state+reorganization+of+north+eastern+state

s&source=bl&ots=6KYHPxUx2H&sig=fUAP1FKjekCrn3BBOpHzzV_Bu-

0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=WHY8UaHGNMqmrAfdt4DoAQ&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=state%20reorganization%

20of%20north%20eastern%20states&f=false

32

Srikrishna Commission gave 6 recommendations in 2012.

Telangana and Andhra speak the same language but have contrasting economic interests. In fact, the latter is

33

accused of exploiting the former‟s resources. Telanagana gets the least amount of funding but gives best returns.

Rayalseema, on the contrary uses more funds but gives lesser returns.

34

K Chandrasekhara Rao, a leader of the Telangana Rashtra Samiti (TRS), used his 11-day fast to force the

government into announcing a separate Telangana state. In Telangana, where socioeconomic deprivation and

political exclusion were causing much frustration, this demand for a separate state had been continuously

expressed for over fifty years. It is economics which now determines the dynamics of Indian federalism. The

different regions contest on the resources consumed in comparison with the returns provided.

10

Conclusion and Legal Analysis

It is not unknown that the road to this achievement is far from being termed as ‘smooth’.

Thus, it is inspiring for a country to endure and acknowledge the differences that exist and

promote the varied interests of the various communities. It was essentially a bottom-up approach

movement, with people demanding, protesting and ultimately getting what they wanted. This

movement saw a large scale uprising and spread like a forest fire. Social Change is dependent

upon Political change and vice versa.35

Tracing the evolution and the very concept of state reorganizations, it is important to note

that the Government, by postponing division and deliberation created huge problems. The

amendment which should have been brought before the independence to set the things clear,

was brought 9 years after that. By this time, the people had a feeling of dissatisfaction and

unhappiness. In the process of nationalism of India, language was understood as a uniting factor.

By denying the amendment, the government was overlooking the homogeneity that people

shared. It is illogical to put people of different cultures and aspirations together. The amendment

and the allied acts that were passed provided a respite, if not to all, at least to some states. The

composition of council of states and Lok Sabha participation underwent a substantial change.

36This change aimed to ensure maximum representation which could be ensured by changing

the composition. The provision in article 81(1) (b) that "the States shall be divided, grouped or

formed into territorial constituencies" will no longer be appropriate, since after reorganization

each of the States will be large enough to be divided into a number of constituencies.37

35

Punjab post reorganization proved to be more volatile and violent, the sociology of Punjab underwent a change

by a legal change. On the other hand, with clear demarcation of states like Gujarat and Maharashtra, the economy

too has witnessed a boost. The same applies to the case of Uttarakhand as well.

Clause 3 of The Amendment, which brought about a complete change in the fourth schedule, which provided a

36

change in the composition of the council of states.

37

Under the Seventh Amendment, the existing distinction among Part A, Part B, Part C, and Part D states was

abolished. The distinction between Part A and Part B states was removed, becoming known simply as "states". A

new type of entity, the union territory, replaced the classification as a Part C or Part D state.

A further Act also came into effect on 1 November, transferring territories from Bihar to West Bengal.

11

Constitution seeks to promote the interest of linguistic, economically backward sections and

minorities.3839

citizens. With a large state, the population will also be huge which makes the approachability of

the government functioning even at the state level tough inspite of a federal structure, healthy

competition among smaller states40

promote and with territorial animosity and conflicts, fraternity cannot be ensured. Even after

provisions in the constitution of India, there are still demands for new states. The committees

formed in this regard, must carry out viability test, present day situation and consequences

For some, government has appointed a committee41

loom in uncertainty42

smaller state implies more inter-state disputes and infrastructural challenges for the new states,

besides battling a feeling of disintegration.43

commission at this time.4445

being in consistency with the principles of democracy and unity, at the same time ensuring equal

opportunities and empowerment.46

The preamble to the constitution specifically seeks to ensure ‘Equality’ for all its

. Fraternity is something that the constitution seeks to

to look into the matter, while the rest still

. The government should act before it gets too late. At the same time, a

There is a severe need for a second reorganization

Ultimately the advantages and disadvantages can be weighed by

38

Article 29, The Constitution of India

39

Ahmedabad St. Xaviers College v State of Gujarat &Anr. 1974 AIR 1389

40

Punjab and Haryana being an example.

41

It is recommended that the members of the committee should hail from the place in dispute. This would ensure a

better, and a more subjective analysis of the situation.

Harit Pradesh in western Uttar Pradesh, Vindhyachal in Madhya Pradesh, Telengana in Andhra Pradesh, Vidarbha

42

in Maharashtra, Kodagu in Karnataka, Gorkhaland and Kamtapuri in West Bengal and Bodoland in Assam.

43

Indian Polity latest developments and related basics, reorganization of states [Internet]. Available on: http://

www.jeywin.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/General-Studies-Indian-Polity-1.pdf, last visited on March 2nd

44

Singh R. (2010) Need for the Second States Reorganisation Commission, Mainstream Weekly February 27th

http://www.mainstreamweekly.net/article1921.html

45

Also, the government must ensure that the majority doesn’t rule over the minority like Sri Lanka, nor should the

government appease minority rule. It should be, as far as possible an unbiased approach.

46

http://www.forumfed.org/libdocs/Federations/V1N3-in-Bhattacharyya.pdf

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

April Morning By Howard Fast Analysis

...realistic fiction that gives readers insight on the beginning of the Revolutionary War through fifteen-year-old Adam Cooper’s eyes. Protagonists, Adam Cooper, and the nation, seem to work alongside each other in the fight against the antagonists, the Red Coats. Adam states, “We had won the battle, but there is less joy in winning a battle than the history books tell you” (Fast 169). Although the colonists are successful, there is more beneath the surface of the American victory. While conflict arises with the Red Coats, Adam Cooper’s life and the nation consist of order, chaos, and reorganization. Before the British disrupt the peacefulness of Lexington, Adam works to maintain order in his life by completing tasks, and the nation sustains order by having meetings to make decisions on important issues. One of the chores Adam completes is retrieving water from the well for his mother (Fast 3). It is routine that every evening someone brings water into the house. Not only does Adam have a routine to follow, but Adam’s father, who is a representative of the nation, has tasks to complete. After supper, Adam’s father attends a Committee meeting (Fast 28). The Committee...

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

ISIS Case

...activities on US soil, few actions to deal with this issue must be taken into consideration, such as the need to define ISIS, reorganization of the Counter Terrorism Bureau, and the coordination of intelligence for the Syrian refugee management crisis. The White House has not done a great job in defining ISIS . Thus, there are no clear goals in dealing with them. Clear goal is needed to produce efficient tasks . For example, the goal could be “defeating” ISIS, which in this case is a vague mission. A vague mission is going to provide constraints in managing governmental agencies. It is more difficult to answer the next question, which is how to “defeat” ISIS because the White House does not have a clear definition of what ISIS really does . Thus, in defining ISIS, a committee should be established. This committee should consist of people who are familiar with the culture...

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Contemporary Ethics

...Terrorism and US Intelligence The United States Intelligence Community has had to change the way they run in order to prevent a future terrorist attacks like the one on the fateful day of September 11th 2001, when our nations security was severely attacked. To be able to understand more clearly the challenges of our intelligence agencies having stronger capabilities, it is important to note that many of today’s issues are well grounded in the past and we can find many examples of this in history books today. One great example is when the United States transitioned from just focusing solely on our nation to a more global view as a result of the attack on Pearl Harbor. Also, Sputnik was a huge reason for the United States to totally redefine their approach to space. These events and many more often serve as examples that changes should have and still must be be made within our intelligence communities and they helped prompt the largest reorganization of the intelligence community since 1947. Had these changes been made sooner, prevention of these and many more tragedies may have been a success. Beginning from the time when Pearl Harbor was stroked, the government sought to blame the Japanese Americans for the tragedy. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt made no hesitation to sign the executive order authorizing an internment of all “Japanese Americans” to proceed. This of course was during a time when racial prejudice was open, but their was a deeper issue within our intelligence...

Words: 949 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Victimless Crimes

...First, I never really realized the many debates and issues America really has until this course. Some issues may seem like common sense on how to solve the problem but not everyone may be happy with every result because of their “beliefs” moral and values. I know that wearing seat beats is state regulated. The government can legally require us to wear a seat belt. Especially, if their major concern is about cutting cost and saving the lives of others. Many feel that when we allow the government to enforce these kinds of laws, we are surrendering our ability to think and act for ourselves. To be honest we have some people that seem to have no brain and this is why such laws have to be in place. It may not be fair and it may infringe on our rights a bit but it is here to balance things. Most of the time it is not very easy to determine in specific cases the right thing to do and no solutions seem obviously correct. As adults, we have experienced many situations to where we are able to decide whether we would like to follow particular rules, but for children it is undetermined in which case it is safe to let some adults decide for them. So rules like having child restraint are put into place for them so that they are protected in every measure. I know that my children will jump in the car without putting a seat belt on and I have to remind them to put it on because when they are in the back seat. I prefer them to be in a car seat with their seat belt on for my own safety reason as...

Words: 339 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Funding Memo

...Subject: Funding for Business Writing Course The purpose of this memo is to request funding for a business writing course being offered at Briarcliffe College. This course will not only benefit me; it will benefit the company in many ways by giving me the tools necessary to be more capable at doing my job. At the end of this course I should feel more confident in my ability to write in a more professional and understandable manner. In my position, I am constantly writing, whether it’s an email to an individual’s family or formal billing summaries for the state. How many times have billing summaries been returned from the state because they are not clear on how a service was run or because of senseless grammar errors? There have also been issues where a family didn’t understand a routine notice and call the supervisors for clarity. This does not create a very professional image for our company as a whole. Each time this happens it takes up valuable company time that can be spent on more productive tasks. Below are a few benefits the company will experience: Save time and money more productive and proficient business meetings A more professional image for the company. As I stated above, the course is being offered at . It will begin on October 15, 2011 and run till December 3, 2011. The total cost is $650; $500 for tuition, $75 for technology fees, and $75 for the book. This is a small investment to the future of this company. We will be able to set ourselves apart...

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Death Penalty

...Death penalty is a bigger discussion, even though I just live here in safe Denmark. I will try to make it about 300 words. The first and maybe even what I think is the stupidest thing about death penalty is the “Eye for an eye” philosophy. Most of all this philosophy can chock me in civilized parts of this world. Like some of the states in the US, that chooses this. But if you turn this around and think, it’s not as expensive for the state as it is to have these criminals in jail, and give them space, food, water, warm bathes, electricity, and so on. It’s cheaper, and easier, just to ‘take them away’. But what about the chances, the chances that someday they will have a new Black Magic, and the idea about the part where they see you ass guilty until the opposite is proven. It’s seen before that someone who’s not guilty lost their life. And how can a state, how can normal people feel raised above everything, and think who has the right to live or die? It’s not only the court I’m thinking at, at this point. It’s also the criminals, who kill. Well, sometimes I also think that death is the only thing a person can deserve, if they done something so awful. But isn’t it just an easy way for them? I won’t mention an example, but think of a criminal who has done something so awful. And when they could come out of jail, the next many years they can’t have a safe live, their life will never be normal, and they will ALWAYS be judged, get the looks, and hear people whisper. Family and friends...

Words: 306 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Drug Testing for Welfare

...Cons Of Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients Norman Zeitunian BCOM/275 Business Communication October 30, 2012 Todd Keller Cons Of Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients There are many states that have attempted to introduce or have laws on their books for drug testing when individuals who are applying for state benefits. Some of the states are Kentucky, Florida, Virginia and Washington. The overall purpose of this testing is to better prepare individuals for employment purposes. Although that is a good sounding intention, there are many aspects that will be flawed and not viable. The most powerful argument against drug testing for welfare benefits stems from the constitutional standpoint. Organizations such as the ACLU have argued that the Fourth Amendment protects citizens from being searched without probable cause ( Bowler 2012). This issue is the main stopping point for creating this program in states’ is that there are many legal issues and will be challenges in the court systems. This leads to the costs related to dealing with the legal ramifications and potential lawsuits that are filed against states agencies that impose drug testing. Another point that was stated in the same letter was that mandatory drug testing was an "ineffective" and "fiscally irresponsible" way to deal with drug abuse. Instead of drug tests, which cost an average of $42 each not including the costs of running the program, the money would be better spent on training government workers...

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case Analysis

...stating that a purchasing manager would give us their first order, expecting that we will agree to make a donation of P2, 000 to his favorite charity, a local youth sports team. By applying principle of double effect we would not accept this kind of order. The situation here is that if we follow one condition the other is ours automatically. The thing with this case is that the manager is expecting something in return to the first order he would give to us. A donation is given by a person freely and willingly. From all the reasons stated above, we do not agree to have an order by the purchasing manager who is expecting us to make a donation of P2, 000 donations to his favorite charity. 3. Sales Expense Reimbursement This case states that an agent of the Southeast Asia wants us to reimburse the customer executive from the Southeast Asia for all his expenses, including some which violates are company’s policies. The agent assures us to reimburse the expenses later. By applying the principle of truth and loyalty we would never accept to go against our company rules. We would choose to go on the right path than to follow the wrong one. Being disloyal to our own company would be a big disgrace to our inner conscience because this very company gives us money...

Words: 696 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Letter to Government

...Dear Local Government and State Officials: I have been experiencing a wonderful winter in the state of Maryland. We have not had a bad winter however, on the days expecting snow it always turns into a disaster. My husband called me on the phone this morning stating that he was unable to take my friend to the airport due to the snow plows blocking the driveway completely with snow. I had to leave my work that morning to try and make calls to make sure that the situation would not happen again. This is not the only time that this has happened. It happens very often when we get snow. I spoke with the men driving the truck at the time of the incident and advised him that my friend needs to get to the airport right away or she will miss her flight. He advised me that I needed to plow out my driveway because he needed to be somewhere else. I did not take that lightly at all. I contacted his boss who stated that I need to speak with the local government and make a complaint. I became irate at this point and began to scream and throw a fit which was not good at all. After several times of trying to contact you I kept running into a hard rock. I have left several messages and still have yet to receive a phone call back due to this matter. I am writing you this letter to explain my situation. My friend came in town to visit for a few days. Not knowing that we were expected to get snow at the time we received it. She was only to be here for a weekend. Due to the snow we received we were...

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Policing

...David Bayley and Clifford Shearing: The New Structure of Policing: Descriptions, Conceptualization and Research Agenda Policing is being reconstructed worldwide. Its distinguishing features are (a) the separation of those who authorize policing from who do it and (b) the transference of both functions away from government The change in policing cannot be understood in customary terms. It is often mischaracterized for example as privatization. Because the distinction between public and private domain becomes problematic in the new policing, the more appropriate description for what is occurring is multilateralization—as host of non governmental groups have assumed responsibility for their own protection, and a host of nongovernmental agencies have undertake to provide security services Crucial distinction is made between the auspices and providers of policing. Auspices are groups (and sometimes individuals) that explicitly and self-consciously take upon themselves the responsibility for organizing their own protection. Providers are groups that actually do the policing. In the old paradigm of policing government had responsibility for articulating security needs and for developing institutions to meet them. This has changed auspices can either be public (govt) or private (nongovt) Governments were the organizational auspices for formulating demand for policing, and they were the providers who supplied it. These two functions have become separate it has become acceptable for...

Words: 811 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Euthyphro

...it takes a prominent position in the conversation between Socrates and Euthyphro. In the Euthyphro, the concept of holiness emerges as Socrates and Euthypho are discussing how Euthypho’s father is accused of murder. They start off my discussing if the murder was just or not. If the murder was just then Euthypho has a duty to let the matter be. If the murder was unjust then action should be taken against him. Euthypho then states that “A son is impious who prosecutes a father. Which shows, Socrates, how little they know what the gods think about piety and impiety.” (Plato, ND) After which Socrates questions what piety and impiety means. This then spurs the conversation towards their concepts of holiness. 2- Present the three definitions that Euthyphro uses in his response to Socrates, and then explain how Socrates refutes each of Euthyphro’s definitions. The first definition that Euthyphro uses is that piety is doing as he is doing, by persecuting any one that is guilty, whether it is of murder, sacrilege or anything that is similar to that. He states that impiety is not punishing those that are guilty of murder or sacrilege. Socrates feels that this is not a definition and isn’t dealt with properly. Socrates refutes this by stating those who prosecute are an example of a holy act and not a definition. He thereby urges Euthyphro to give a more general definition that can be identified as a standard that all other holy deeds could be recognized by. The second definition that...

Words: 946 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Law Official

...Policing in U.S. Society Response Trimeya Washington CJS/210 Sean Beeler The relationship of the government and the policing has a lack of communication between one another in my eyes. Now the government only makes the rules and leaves it up to the policing to enforce them. Well in my opinion if the government would have more communication with polices or other officials they would see that some of those rules need to be amended/changed/ or a new law needs to be put in place to enforce the rule at question. Many of the government officials have no clue as to what is going on in society today so they really are not beneficial to the public eye because they are not aware of the situations that we face as the public. The police have the first hand view of what is going on in the society because they are out in the streets patrolling and communicating with the people while the government sit high in the offices and just do paper work with no concern of society’s issues. In looking at all that is going on the government has no communication with the police at all so they are not involved with a lot of the cases or problems that may are going on. This has impacted the relationship on the U.S as a whole because the public feels as though their opinion doesn’t matter. Until the government and the police start communicating society may never get the justice and help they is desired or needed to...

Words: 265 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

International

...not how they looked, or should look * They tell world leaders that the most important, should operate is to enhance the security of their states... * Power is a very important thing in IR. * They should be able to harness this power in creative and noble ways. * The world is a complex place. * Strengths in realism.... * What they also argue is that..Money is a currency..Everything is about power. * Allow us to expand our national interest. * Gain power, use that power, and then use it in a robust manner so that you are on top on IR power. * More dominate then change. * Dominate aspects are wars, security dilemma, missiles etc. * IR is a story of wars being fought, wars having been fought in the past and states recovering.., or preparing for future wars. * Realist’s wars are an endemic/... * You can never get ride of war impossible it stays. * They are not interested in changing the world but helping it and creating peace and unity. * They like talking about violence, states should increase their power. * All individual aspects of morality. * Morality is judged by how well “i” the national security adviser insures the survival of their state. * Look after my people. Kept out of arms way, should be ready to die, cheat break promises to keep their territory of their state. * The moment we use our moral values with the dealing of other countries.....

Words: 625 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Does It Matter?

...companies can profit off of using IT. To me the most important assets that IT provides are the ease and convenience of the Microsoft Windows applications as well as the Internet for research. For example companies using Excel to keep organized records of customers, associates, employees, and etc. People using the IT to do research on companies and products that they may have an interest in purchasing. However, I am still firm believer that we should not forget how to use a simple pencil and piece of paper. Yes, the speed and convenience of Information Technology is wonderful, but think about, what would happen if one day everything technological were to crash and be gone, what state would the world be in, what would the people who have become so reliant on IT do? The world would be lost, in a state of anarchy without iphones, computers, ipads, laptops, etc;...

Words: 544 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Changes in Social Work

...frontline managers and clients. * Greater focus on budget management then on clients. * Social worker /client relationship (due to increase workloads) based on control and supervision and not care. The changes that affected social work came about because of a fundamental reconstruction in its relationship to the state and to the social work client. This is because social and political attitudes toward welfare provision and the welfare client changed in the late 1970s with the coming to power of the Thatcher government. Government policy wanted to introduce a move from a Welfare State system to a system of welfare markets and non-statutory providers and also changed the role of the state from provider to regulator. These policies were also followed by “New” Labour when it came to power in the 1990's This has lead to a welfare organisation that is fragmented. The principle of “universalism” i.e.the view that all should be dealt with equally has been replaced by the policy of targetting those most in need which some argue has lead to discontinuities and inconsistencies in provision of social work support. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation, 2008 states this has led to an "inequitable distribution of services and, in some instances, a reduction in quality leading to serious injustice." The multidiscplinary approach affects the practice of social worker because it has led to a "diminution of social work as a central activity in the UK welfare...

Words: 288 - Pages: 2