Premium Essay

Term Limits In Congress

Submitted By
Words 448
Pages 2
According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 15 states have imposed term limits on legislators since 1990. Inevitably, this shift has raised an important question on whether similar limits should apply in Congress. However, based on the effects of limits on state governments, both chambers of Congress should remain free from term limits. In a New York Times article, B. Drummond Ayres wrote that the average member of the California Assembly “now has three years of experience, less than half the average before term limits.” Eliminating term limits excuses the most experienced members from state legislatures. Less experience and expertise make it more difficult to efficiently pass legislation. Congress needs experienced legislators …show more content…
However, in a 1995 survey of 3000 state legislators, Carey, Niemi, and Powell found that legislators in term limit states have “equally strong career ambitions” as legislators in states without term limits. Imposing term limits will not solve the issue of careerism in Congress.
Those in favor of term limits also claim that women and minorities are better represented in state legislatures with term limits, but this is not backed by data. A study by Susan J. Carroll and Krista Jenkins in the 1998 and 2000 state legislative elections found that the number of women decreased in term-limited state houses. Other methods and attitudes must be adopted for women and minorities to be more equally represented in Congress. The history of term limits in states show that term limits will not help.
Although many of its aspects are appealing to voters, term limits ultimately harm the state legislatures in which they are imposed. Many promising benefits have been discussed in debates on term limits, but these benefits prove to be less beneficial in practice than in theory. For these reasons, Congress would not benefit from term limits, and both senators and representatives should remain free stay in Congress as long as the constituency allows

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Should Congress Have Term Limits Essay

...Currently, Congress does not have term limits. Members of the House of Representatives are elected for two years per term. Members of the Senate are elected for six years per term. The main problem with not having term limits is having the same people being in office for decades. “Rep. John Dingell of Michigan became the longest-serving member of Congress on Friday with 57 years, five months, 27 days and counting on Capitol Hill.”#1 Having these same individuals in office for this long means there is no new ideas or perspectives. “The current Congress is a dismal failure and is desperate need of new ideas, procedures, and influence.”#2. With no new ideas or different perspectives on issues, there is no progression. With having term limits, we can get new people with different opinions and concepts. We can then help change our great country for the better. We, as a country, need a new amendment that would limit Congressmen to four full terms in office. Being a congressman is not a career, though many see it as one. It is a privilege given to very few to have the ability to represent the people of our country in...

Words: 1102 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Congressional Term Limit Analysis

...Congressional Term Limits. Retrieved October 6, 2015, from http://www.cato.org/publications/congressional-testimony/congressional-term-limits This article was written and submitted to the constitution committee as an argument for term limits to be set Congress. Mr. Crane addresses one of the main issues the opposing side has with putting term limits on Congress which is amending the constitution. I think this would be useful for my research paper because it is a normal citizen’s point of view. This piece helps to solidify my argument for why term limits should be an amendment. While this source is biased he does help argue the opposing viewpoint. Gest, T. (1995). Term limits: Detour ahead. U.S. News &...

Words: 977 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay On Congressional Term Limits

...Congressional Term limits is a pending topic which has received a lot of attention from the media: it has garnered public and political support from many individuals; Democrats, Republicans, and third parties. Limiting the term of U.S House and Senate representatives is a tedious constitutional battle involving a lot of loopholes. Creating term limits for U.S House Representative and Senates sounds easy, with Congress support, but the problem is how to gather and maintain Congress support despite the incongruous nature of Congress. U.S House of Representatives currently serve 2-year terms and Senators, 6 years changing this would require the approval of the majority of Congressmen: this is very elusive. Instituting a congressional term limit on the House and Senate requires 2/3 votes from both parties (the House and the Senate) but gaining such support has been difficult due to bipartisanship and Congress’s refusal to adhere to public demands. Congress’s refusal to constitutionalize term limits raises the issue of how to bypass Congress and create an Amendment that would limit U.S House of Representatives and Senate terms which would give other individuals the opportunity to be involved in Congress. Congress decreasing the term a U.S Senator serves as a way to...

Words: 573 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Congressional Term Limits In The United States

...Congressional Term Limits The United States Constitution is the supreme law of the land (U.S. land). Empowered with the sovereign authority of the people by the framers and the consent of the legislatures of the states, it is the source of all government powers, and also provides important limitations on the government that protect the fundamental rights of United States citizens. Professor Larry J. Sabato introduced a number of proposals for Constitutional revisions in his book, A More Perfect Constitution: Why the Constitution Must Be Revised: Ideas to Inspire a New Generation, all of which worthy of consideration, but one stands out to me as the most deserving candidate to become a new Amendment to the Constitution…Congressional Term Limits....

Words: 944 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay On Congressional Term Limits

...Term limits, which basically is the idea of putting boundaries on the time holders of political office that are permitted to serve. Term limits will cause well respected politicians. Term limits are necessary to avoid unfair advantages given to officeholders and to permit a multitude of extra benefits. I do agree that there should be Congressional term limits. New blood needs to enter Congress more frequently, in order to prevent the highly affected Congress that is filled with old people with old ideals. In the Articles of Confederation, a turn in office system was depicted, so that no individual could stay in a position for quite a long time. However, this was deserted in the Constitution since it was considered unnecessary. At the time of...

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Are The Pros And Cons To Term Limits

...The 22nd Amendment sets a two-term limit on the office of the President. The limit on the President’s tenure was inspired by George Washington, who established the custom of Presidents voluntarily leaving the office after two terms. The move was seen as an important safeguard against tyrannical power. In 1947, a Republican-controlled Congress sent a 22nd Amendment to the states for ratification, and on February 27, 1951, the amendment was finally ratified. Congress and the president are very different however, one branch being controlled by one person, and the other controlled by hundreds. Many Americans argue that term limits could bring in more ideas and get more done in the shorter time congressmen would have. On the other hand, many feel that longer serving members bring experience to the table that new members lack. Pros to term limits includes new ideas constantly being brought to the table and a better lack of corruption, while cons are lack of experience and the fact that they are seen as unnecessary. One positive of term limits would constantly be bringing in new ideas to the Senate and the House. With a constant shuffle of new members, congressmen would be fresher and more “up to date” on the current issues facing America. Cycling leaders in...

Words: 698 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Congressional Elections

...Churchill once stated, “Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all others” (Langworth). Democracy is not a perfect form of government but all forms of government have their shortcomings. In order to overcome flaws, the three branches of government are charged with using their power and resources to find resolutions. According to Thomas Patterson in We the People, of the three branches, Congress possesses “the greatest of all the powers of government, the power to make the laws” (328). The significant role of Legislators necessitates the need for immediate reform before the other branches due to their unique power. Currently, Congress is “the only form of elected office in American government not regulated by term...

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Why Americans Should Serve In Politics Research Paper

...When we are electing the people to serve us we should know their skill set and their history of politics. They should be skilled enough to serve and learn fast. They also should have many connections from their past experience in politics. It's not going to be the easiest job ever, but one of the most rewarding because they are serving the people that support them. I believe if there is congressional term limits we will be placing new leaders that are inspired to serve in office that will do best for our country. Congressional term limits will improve our country’s government by placing the passionate and inspired leaders to serve. This will reduce the chance of corruption and greediness in our government. This will give us citizens a chance to have our voice hear and an opportunity for our country to move forward for the future. Congressional term limits in the United State’s congress will be more of a benefit than a harm it will decrease the amount of corruption by career...

Words: 774 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Pol201 - Week 5

...America's Democracy: Your Report Card Jermaine Rucker POL201: American National Government (ACK1544E) Instructor: Allison Sloan November 30, 2015 The American national government has numerous upsides and downsides. There are numerous routes in which these can be altered with a specific end goal to make less issues for the national government. The key structures, frameworks, parts, and procedures that encapsulate our national government are extremely point by point and need exceptionally pivotal consideration while deciding the upsides and downsides of the administration. It is anything but difficult to take a gander at another nation and think about the legislatures together, as I would see it as taking a gander at America's administration contrasted with that of different nations, our own is in fact the most grounded paying little mind to the negatives that it has. There are many important written documents that we as American language look onto. Probably, one of the most important document that our country does utilize on a daily footing is the United Commonwealth United States Constitution. When the institution fathers created this document, the three watchword probably are “We the Hoi polloi,” this show that the US Constitution is deeply important and that the people are the ones that are protected with this. This is figure on the idea of: lifespan, shore leave and freedom. I believe that the US Constitution has been extremely important because it has lasted for so...

Words: 1899 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Argumentative Essay: The Power Of Congress

...One power of Congress is “to make all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into execution the foregoing powers.” This compliments Lee Hamilton’s statement as the power allows Congress make laws for the people as new situations arise. From this, it is agreed with Hamilton that “Congress is the most important link between the American people and their national government.” Congress takes new opinions and problems from citizens and applies them when making laws. Also, the stipulations for a member of the legislature ensures the bond between the people and the government. Members of the House have short two-year terms, while Senators have six-year terms, allowing new members to appeal modern policies to Congress to service recent...

Words: 915 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ap Governemtn Chapter 11

...Notes: Chapter 11 “Congress” I. Introduction 1. The Congress that the U.S. and most Latin American countries has is different from the Parliament that most European nations have because in Europe, a person who wants to run for office must persuade his party to nominate him, while in America, politicians can run for themselves. i. In Europe, people vote for parties; in America, they vote for individuals. ii. In primaries, people vote especially for a “person” (and his qualities, traits, etc…), and in general elections, this is sometimes true also. iii. In parliament, legislators can support their leaders or not, and if they don’t then new leaders (prime minister and various cabinet members) must be elected. a. This ensures that more action can occur, since the parties of the executive and legislative branches are practically always the same. iv. Congress is free from the turmoil of possible collapsing executive branches and is more powerful to make decisions; Congressmen don’t have to worry about easily losing their positions come another election. a. In Congress, there is less cohesion in bill passing, and less stuff can get done. v. Parliaments members usually engage in debate, are poorly paid, have little independent power, and receive little power as well. vi. Meanwhile, Congressmen are much better paid, have more power, do many things...

Words: 6015 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

101 Chambers Review

...James Taylor 10/15/12 State and Local Government Review of 101 Chambers written by Peverill Squire and Keith E. Hamm Squire and Hamm begin their writings with introducing the reader to the historical lineage of American legislatures and their evolution from colonial days to the modern government. The colonial institutions "have greatly influenced the design of the new Congress under the Constitution" (Squire and Hamm 34). The bicameral system had its originations in colonial governments and the original colonial constitutions had a large impact on the future constitutions. The bicameral legislation structure that is now common in the United States began in the colonial era. The original colonies has systems that greatly resembled that of the English system during the Tudor reign with an unicameral system made up of the governor, the councilors, and the general assembly that was made up by the colony's freemen. Massachusetts became the first colony to separate into two chambers, one made up of the council and the other made up of the general assembly. In the 1630s "the councilors and the members of the assembly developed different interests and concerns, and these differences led to conflict between them" (Squire and Hamm 34). State constitutions became more prevalent as the idea of independence from the crown grew stronger. The states wanted to have control over who would be appointed to represent them in their legislatures. Many of the structures had not been changed...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Liberty Amendments Book Critque

...seems like him and I have a lot of the same views. Throughout this report I will list some examples of what I am talking about and compare them to how I feel about them. In the early parts of the book he mentions of manipulative Congress can be with all of the bills, laws, and benefits the try to pass “under the radar” I agree with him on most of that, they do try and pass a lot of bills through Congress but I don’t think they are under the radar. Everyone has access to pretty much anything the government tries to pass the problem is they do not even try to put them in terms we can understand. They put it in all technical terms that I’m not even sure they know what it means. I feel as if the Congress should have to try and put anything they try to pass in laments terms. In the upcoming pages of this paper I will explain to you some of the amendments of the constitution known as the Liberty Amendments that will hopefully help our country in its time of need during what is known as a convention process. I will let you know if I agree or disagree with what Mark states and tell you why we both feel the way we do. I will start as he did with the amendment for term limits. Mr. Levin says he feels that there should be term limits with any member of Congress rather it be the House or the Senate. He feels that no member should be able to serve over twelve years in the House or Senate or combination of the...

Words: 1754 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

'More Imperilled Than Imperial' Discuss This View of the Us Presidency.

...power for the US President. There are many limits on the powers of the President, however many could argue that these are not enough in preventing the president from being imperial from the other branches of government. One argument that the Presidency is imperilled is that no President has been able to exert the same amount of power that Franklin D Roosevelt did during the 1930s and 40s. Roosevelt remains the President to have increased the role of the executive branch of government with his New Deal policies which created organisations such as EXOP. He also broke the convention that a President only stood for two terms, becoming the only President to be elected for four terms. However, once his presidency was over, the powers of the President were soon limited to prevent the President from becoming too powerful. The 23rd amendment ensured that a President would serve no more than two terms. Thus all the Presidents following FDR have been unable to demonstrate as much power as he did. Even his successor, President Truman, could not do as much in office as FDR, despite having to deal with the fallout from the end of World War Two. In contrast however, some Presidents have been able to show a large amount of power overseas, rather than in domestic affairs. The President’s power overseas may derive from his Constitutional role as ‘Commander in Chief’ and makes it difficult for Congress to interfere with his dealings abroad. Congress may have the power to declare war, but has...

Words: 1488 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Imperial vs Imperilled Presidency

...argument – imperial and imperilled are greatly dependent upon political time as Skowronek suggests, as well as the political climate surrounding the incumbent president. The scope for being ever being ever a solely imperial or imperilled president is hugely limited in practice, demonstrated by the now considered bifurcated presidency. * Imperial – term comes from Schlesinger in 1973 when referring to Nixon. It is linked to the assertion of presidential power, especially in foreign policy, in presidencies from Truman to Nixon – term used to criticise the increasing dominance of the President in relation to Congress * Imperilled – refers to a reduced level in Presidential authority and power as a resurgent of Congress occurred – increasing its authority over the executive through a number of legislative policies, thus practically capping the President’s role domestically and abroad. Paragraph 1 – YES – could be considered to be more imperial due to the use of executive agreements * Use of executive agreements means that the president is able to bypass congressional approval – and so acts as an aid to circumvent congress * Obama has used a combination of executive agreements, memoranda, public declarations and press statements to push past constitutional restraint – which facilitates Kernell’s theory of ‘going public’ * EG – Exec agreement order 13687 in 2015 with sanctions on N.Korea * Obama & Cuba – ‘USA is changing its relationship with people of...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5