Free Essay

The Benefits of Farmers Markets

In:

Submitted By stewart212
Words 1521
Pages 7
Food for Thought Farmers markets are places where consumers purchase fresh, locally grown produce directly from the farmers. The number of farmers markets in the United States has grown a whopping 250% since 1994. The increasing prevalence of local farmers markets is an important step towards a much needed transformation of our country’s food system. There are numerous environmental, economic, nutritional, and ethical benefits to supporting local farmers markets as opposed to major corporations and supermarkets. There are copious environmental advantages of supporting local farmers markets as opposed to large industries. Farmers markets provide locally grown produce, reducing the resulting amount of “food miles”, or travel distance. Statistics show that produce from supermarkets, on the other hand, travel an average of 1,300 miles before reaching the shelves. “Only about 10% of the fossil fuel energy used in the world’s food system is used for production. The other 90% goes toward packaging, transporting, and marketing of the food” (Norberg-Hodge). The smaller travel distance for produce from farmers markets greatly reduces carbon dioxide emissions, contributing towards a healthier environment. Farmers markets have also been proven to produce less waste than their supermarket competitors. “Farmers in the USA report that an average of 22% of their crop could not be marketed if farmers markets were not available…There is less wastage because good food is not discarded because it doesn’t fit supermarkets’ packaging requirements, or because the supermarket changes its order at the last minute” (Friends of the Earth). In addition to environmental benefits, farmers markets provide large economic opportunities and advantages for both farmers and consumers. First off, farmers receive more money from farmers markets because they cut out the “middle man” – retailers, wholesalers, and transporters who all receive a cut of the earnings in large industries. Farmers markets allow money to circulate locally and provide a large number of jobs to local citizens, rendering them a great economic opportunity for every community. “A dollar spent locally usually generates twice as much income for the local economy” (DeLong). Supermarkets, on the other hand, result in a loss of jobs for the local community. “The National Retail Planning Forum found that there was a net loss of 270 jobs on average each time a superstore opens. A trend towards farmers markets, strengthening local links, can be expected to have net job gains” (Friends of the Earth). Locally grown produce from farmers markets provide a wide range of nutritional benefits to the consumer. Primarily, the customer is much more able to find out where their food came from and how it was harvested, which is very important, and often hard to discover about produce from farmers markets. Secondly, large industries often harvest fruits and vegetables long before they are ripe, and then proceed to gas them to make them ripe prior to putting them on the shelves. This process alters both the taste and nutritional value of the food! “Once produce is picked, the vitamins, minerals, and fibers start to break down naturally. Supermarkets take an average of two weeks before their produce ends up on the shelves, so the nutrient loss is significant” (Norberg-Hodge). Produce from farmers markets have been given ample time to ripen and develop prior to harvesting, and therefore contain a higher level of vitamins and minerals and great nutritional value. “These farmers markets are bringing Americans healthy food so we can be a healthy nation, instead of the undernourished and obese kids and adults that President Obama worries so much about us becoming” (Ayers). In addition to being more nutritious, produce from farmers markets have been proven to taste better, too! “At least six taste test studies cited by Hughes and Mattson have shown that consumers typically prefer produce sold at farmers’ markets to that from other sources. Consumers cite freshness, taste, appearance, and nutritive value as reasons for preferring farmers market produce” (Friends of the Earth). Many customers of supermarkets and large industries claim that buying food from farmers markets is “just too expensive.” However, research shows that this is simply a widely held misconception. Bard College graduate student Jake Robert Claro produced a study for the Northeast Organic Farming Association of Vermont to put this myth to the test. He and his team compared the prices of food items from ten different farmers markets against those from large-scale supermarkets, and came to a surprising conclusion. “The findings of this study have shown that prices at farmers markets are in many cases competitive with prices at grocery stores” (Estabrook). The majority of produce from farmers markets was actually 10 to 20 percent cheaper than those from supermarkets, with the exception of cantaloupe, cucumbers, lettuce, and peas (which were cheaper at the supermarkets). Incredibly, eggs were 43% cheaper at farmers markets, and potatoes were 58% cheaper than those from supermarkets! In a similar study conducted by SCALE, Inc., farmers markets in the states of Virginia, Tennessee, West Virginia, Kentucky, North Carolina, and South Carolina were investigated. “In 74% of the states examined, produce was actually less expensive at farmers markets than supermarkets, on average by 22%. In 88% of the areas surveyed, organic produce was less expensive at farmers markets than supermarkets on average by 16%. The overall conclusion was that farmers markets were the same or less expensive than supermarkets 74% of the time” (Norberg-Hodge). Despite the fact that farmers markets have been proven to be on average less expensive than major supermarkets, some families maintain the belief that such fresh food still doesn’t stand within their budget. However, over half of the farmers markets in the United States accept food stamps! Similarly, the Seniors Farmers Market Nutrition Pilot Program was established to make fresh food from farmers markets more available to low income or unemployed senior citizens. The program distributes coupons to be used at local farmers markets and roadside stands to senior citizens meeting the requirement. The fact of the matter is that the view of farmers markets as elitist, expensive establishments is an extremely easily disproved myth. Supporters of large industries and supermarkets also argue that farmers markets have a limited supply, restricted by what is in season. However, it has been scientifically proven that produce that is in season has greater health benefits. It is common sense that the presence of produce that is not currently in season in supermarkets means that the produce has either been chemically or genetically altered or has traveled a long way to get to the shelf. Last but certainly not least, there are enormous ethical benefits to supporting local farmers markets and avoiding industries and corporations whenever possible. “The system of agricultural production our society has created is designed to shield major corporations from any legal responsibility for their actions or inactions. The layers of subcontracting built into American agriculture are designed to shift responsibility downward from the largest firms to the smallest” (Rodriguez). Major corporations in the food business implement practices of slave labor to maintain low prices. Workers are harshly underpaid, overworked, and ignored basic human rights. Such large corporations prey on the vulnerability of their farmers, particularly those from foreign countries whose desire for work and unfamiliarity with our legal system render them easy targets. These farmers are denied health insurance, breaks, sick days, vacation days, job security, and basic human rights. “Drinking water and sanitary conditions – basic rights most American workers take for granted – are denied to farmworkers [for large corporations] on a daily basis” (Rodriguez 603). Farmers for large corporations in the food industry such as Wal-Mart are in great need for stricter protection under the law and monitoring of salaries and working conditions. The government’s failure to successfully control the situation places the burden in our hands. Something desperately needs to be done to change this process. Supporting such monster corporations reinforces this disgusting practice of modern day slave labor and human rights abuses all too present in our country’s food industry. It is our duty as human beings to take steps to put an end to such injustices, and we can do so by supporting local farmers markets whenever possible. In conclusion, farmers markets provide a variety of benefits, ranging from economic, environmental, nutritional, and ethical spheres. The power to better our health, local economy, environment, and the lives of millions of underpaid farmers rests in our hands, and the means to do so is simple: buy produce from local farmers markets.

Works Cited
Ayers, Jane. "300,000 Organic Farmers Sue Monsanto in Federal Court." Nation of Change. 15 Feb. 2012. Web. 5 Mar. 2012.
DeLong, Katie. "Eat Local Challenge: Can You Do It?" Today's TMJ4. 2012. Web. 14 Mar. 2012.
Estabrook, Barry. "The Farmers' Market Myth." The Atlantic. 10 May 2011. Web. 8 Mar. 2012.
Friends of the Earth. "The Economic Benefits of Farmers' Markets." Friends of the Earth Newsmagazine 2000. EBSCO. Web. 15 Mar. 2012.
Norberg-Hodge, Helena. "Thinking Globally, Eating Locally." Totnes Transition Town Guide 56 (2007). Web.
Rodriguez, Arturo. Cheap Food: Workers Pay the Price. Elements of Argument: A Text and Reader.Boston, MA: Bedford/St. Martins, 2012. 601-18. Print.
.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

King Corn

...programs: corporate agribusiness. Why are farmers dependent on subsidies? New Deal Forced Agribusiness to Pay Farmers Fairly. As King Corn outlined, the government during the New Deal attempted to bring supply into line with demand, an approach known as “supply management.” This was accomplished thru the use of conservation set-asides, a price floor guaranteeing a fair price for corn (similar to a minimum wage), and a grain reserve to deal with overproduction. Farmers did not need to rely on the government for a fair income. They received it from the marketplace. Prior to the New Deal, the “free market” approach to agriculture caused economic booms and busts as farmers suffered continued depressed prices for their crops. This led to the rise of the Populist Party and other agrarian movements whose ideas were finally implemented with the New Deal. Agribusiness Had Lobbied for Decades to Allow the “Free Market” to Determine Prices. Beginning in 1973, policy changes promoted by Nixon Secretary of Agriculture Earl Butz deregulated the corn market. He dismantled supply management policies, selling off government storage bins used as food security reserves and implemented “fencerow to fencerow” planting. Butz believed any overproduction should then be dealt with thru exports and “free trade.” The Russian Wheat Deal and the World Food Crisis of the early 1970s gave Butz the chance to promote the false notion that free markets would be good for farmers. Butz and agribusiness giant, Cargill...

Words: 2688 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...Term Paper BHUPESH MANOHARAN (0086/49) ACNOWLEDGEMENT I would like to express my special thanks of gratitude to Professor Nimruji Prasad J. for providing me with this opportunity and helped me in doing this term paper. It was her able guidance and constant appraisal of the paper that led me to have holistic view of the subject and improvise the paper. Table of Contents ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................... 3 INTRODUCTION: ............................................................................................ 4 ORGANIC AGRI-BUSINESS: HOW IS IT DIFFERENT?............................ 4 METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................ 5 LIMITATIONS OF THE METHODOLOGY .................................................... 5 SUSTAINABILITY ISSUES IN ORGANIC AGRIBUSINESS ........................ 5 ENVIRONMENTAL/ECOLOGICAL SUSTAINABILITY ........................... 5 ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY: ................................................................. 6 SOCIAL SUSTAINABILITY: ....................................................................... 7 OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS IN ORGANIC AGRIBUSINESS ........ 7 OPPORTUNITIES ......................................................................................... 7 CONSTRAINTS ............................................................................................. 8 SUSTAINABLE PRINCIPLES...

Words: 6580 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Organisational Structure and Processes Amenable for a Sustainable Zero Budget Organic Farming Entreprise

...Term Paper Bhupesh Manoharan ACNOWLEDGEMENT I would like to express my special thanks of gratitude to Professor for providing me with this opportunity and helped me in doing this term paper. It was her able guidance and constant appraisal of the paper that led me to have holistic view of the subject and improvise the paper. Table of Contents ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................... 3 INTRODUCTION: ............................................................................................ 4 ORGANIC AGRI-BUSINESS: HOW IS IT DIFFERENT?............................ 4 METHODOLOGY ............................................................................................ 5 LIMITATIONS OF THE METHODOLOGY .................................................... 5 SUSTAINABILITY ISSUES IN ORGANIC AGRIBUSINESS ........................ 5 ENVIRONMENTAL/ECOLOGICAL SUSTAINABILITY ........................... 5 ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY: ................................................................. 6 SOCIAL SUSTAINABILITY: ....................................................................... 7 OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS IN ORGANIC AGRIBUSINESS ........ 7 OPPORTUNITIES ......................................................................................... 7 CONSTRAINTS ............................................................................................. 8 SUSTAINABLE PRINCIPLES OF ORGANIC INTEGRATED AGRIBUSINESS...

Words: 6575 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Penetration of Ict in India

...Marketing Research Project 2015-2016 Study on mobile phones contribution in better agricultural decision making by Indian Farmers. Report Submitted By- ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We wish to express our sincere gratitude to Dr. Jogendra Kumar Nayak, Assistant Professor, for providing us opportunity to pursue work on the project “Study on mobile phones contribution in better agricultural decision making by Indian Farmers” and also for providing us with necessary facilities, freedom of thoughts and actions, and guidance for efficiently conducting our work. We sincerely thank our respondents and our colleagues from the course structure of Marketing Research and all other who were directly or indirectly involved in the project, for entrusting us with the project meanwhile mentoring and guiding us and helping us conduct our work with utmost proficiency. This project gave us an insight in the applications of mobile phones in providing best agro based information to our farmers. Through our study we came to the understanding that exploiting the technological advancements in the agriculture sector can help our producers to a great extent. Group 2|Page Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ................................................................................................................................... 2 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................. 5 ...

Words: 2841 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Buying Locally

...these well-known companies such as Walmart and Target did not exist. Instead people would buy food at farmers markets, produce stands, or butcher shops. They would go to the corner store to buy hygiene products and the pharmacy for their medicine. Americans eventually realized that traveling to multiple locations for the bare necessities was a bit of a hassle and so they created grocery stores. Now, costumers do not have to travel to multiple places for their dinner, shampoo, and detergent; instead they can travel to one place. Grocery stores quickly grew into large franchises that have scattered across every state in the US. Though grocery stores make shopping convenient, efficient, and less of a hassle; they also create multiple dilemmas for communities, the environment, and consumers. Consumers can help limit such issues by shopping as if we were still in the days when supermarkets were not around, to the days when people bought locally. The food that Americans eat does not come from the local farmer anymore. Instead it ships to the United States from across the country or even across the world. Since America is importing food instead of buying it from a farmer, the farming population is decreasing. According to the internet article, “Why Buy Locally Grown?” less than 1% of Americans rely on farming as their primary occupation which means there are fewer than 1,000,000 farmers in the United States. A main reason for the decrease in the farming population is that for every retail...

Words: 2097 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Echoupal Initiative

...concept of the present Choupal system wherein farmers gather at a meeting place at the end of each day to discuss daily happenings. Seeing that soybeans and its derivatives account for two-thirds of ITC’s agricultural export business, his focus was placed on that area. ITC’s supply chain for soybean was from local farmers to mandis to ITC’s factory and this process was significantly hampering the IBD’s performance. The supply chain was suffering from the lack of resources and a reliable channel for information flow, which resulted in a very unproductive cycle. In order to meet the company’s target, it had to identify ways in which a new method could be introduced so that the issues would be corrected. Technology was at the forefront but going that route also had its challenges. It would have been introduced in an environment that was underdeveloped and the general population was not exposed to computer technology. In India where ITC’s corporate offices are located, there is a rich culture and also the industry is governed by politics hence determining a method to effect changes, these factors have to be considered. Historically, the farmers would know happenings in the market place via the Choupals and ITC saw this culture as a good model for introducing the technology they had in mind. ITC introduced its new initiative termed eChoupal. Its main purpose was to gather and share information for the benefit of the farmers...

Words: 2400 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Itc Echoupal Initiative

...Recommendation & Implementation 7-9 Monitor and Control Part Six Monitor and Control 9-10 Part One – Executive Summary ITC is one of India’s largest private sector companies and is well diversified. It has business units operating in multiple industries including soybean, tobacco, paperboard, retail, hospitality and foods among others (The ITC eChoupal Initiative). Although ITC is extremely profitable and one of the most respected companies in the world, they do face margin issues within their International Business Division (IBD). The IBD is ITC’s exporting agricultural commodities division, which is operated out of India. India’s agricultural sector is home to 72% of the population and 60% of their workforce creating a market with extreme profit potential. However, the 100 million the IBD made in 1998 is a nominal contribution when compared to the 2 billion in revenue ITC collected from all divisions. In March of 1999 Chief Executive S. Sivakumar was approached by ITC Chairman, Y.C. Deveshwar, to generate a new business plan for IBD that would make the division more profitable. There were many factors hindering India’s supply chain for agricultural goods, which would have to be dealt with if the new business model was to succeed. After a brainstorming session with ITC management in May of 1999 Sivakumar decided to implement digital technologies within the supply chain (The ITC eChoupal Initiative). This way the entire supply chain would...

Words: 2447 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Icts for Better Marketing of Agricultural Produce in Bangladesh

...lower tier people has decreased, widening gap between the richest and poorest [3]. According to PRSP, 2005, agriculture must grow yearly by at least 4-4.5%. It is apparently possible through increasing agricultural productivity based on modern agricultural technology and a supply chain linking farmers with consumers in the domestic and global markets [1]. In a market economy framework, access to information is crucial in terms of having access to market and getting price advantage in the production process. Unfortunately, there is no separate market for the poor producers of goods and services. Accordingly, access to information may drastically change the situation in favor of the poor producers within and outside the country. Country like Bangladesh where most of its population live in villages and depend on agriculture as their main occupation, accurate and timely information about market prices of agricultural produce has extreme significance. Agricultural Marketing in Bangladesh is undergoing a steady but significant change because of economic liberalisation and globalisation. Advancement in Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) has made the world a smaller but larger market. The availability of prompt and...

Words: 6871 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

E-Volution: Technology as a Driver of Rural Retail in India – a Case of Itc’s Foray Into the Rural Market.

...ITC’S FORAY INTO THE RURAL MARKET. | Ms Smita Singh, Research Scholar, Department of Business Administration, University of Lucknow, Lucknow(M) 098395-01035e-mail: smita_saggi@rediffmail.com | Ms. Smita Singh Ms. Singh is a visiting faculty at Institute of Management Sciences, University of Lucknow and Distance Learning Centre for Punjab Technical University. She has been associated with academics for the past 2½ years and is enrolled for PhD research at the Department of Business Administration, University of Lucknow. She has worked with Wigan and Leigh College, Lucknow as Programme Manager and Academic Head, Management. A NTSE (NCERT) and HRD Ministry scholarship holder, she has qualified SLET in Anthropology. With over 8 years of industry experience, her current affiliation as Human Resource Consultant is with the Lucknow based project centre of Johns Hopkins University of Public Health and Hygiene, which she earlier served for 4 years as Manager HR and Research Associate. DECLARATION I hereby declare that the paper/case is original and is authored by me. The paper/case has not been published elsewhere ABSTRACT E-VOLUTION: TECHNOLOGY AS A DRIVER OF RURAL RETAIL IN INDIA – A CASE OF ITC’S FORAY INTO THE RURAL MARKET. 70 % of India's population lives in rural areas in its 627000 villages. Technopak’s estimated size of the Indian rural market at USD 300 billion shows...

Words: 6685 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Lion King

...The problems and benefits of fair trade The many benefits of fair trade are clear once one learns that its main goal is to alleviate poverty in developing countries and inculcate the value of sustainable development. Fair trade aims to create more opportunities for producers facing economic disadvantage over multinational companies. Because it also aims for sustainable development, both workers and producers are being offered much better trading conditions than before. There are five main benefits of fair trade that can easily be seen. The first is that it increases the income of the producers of the farmers. This is achieved through two steps. The price of the good is paid upon at an agreed and guaranteed fair price. The distribution channels involved in marketing the good is also reduced thus the producers get a larger share form the price of the good. Second benefit is that because they now have a larger share of the pie, both farmers and workers have extra income with which to improve their lives. The price of a specific good is typically computed to cover the cost of both sustainable production and livelihood. A premium is also added to the price to be used as investment for development projects. These projects include building schools, funding scholarships and even used to fund low-interest loans for farmers and workers. Third of the five benefits of fair trade is that is involves greater environmental protection. The certification being used to market fair trade products...

Words: 457 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Fair Trade

...Fair Trade- Benefits and criticisms Important to note that the fair trade economy is diverse ranging from agricultural products to handicrafts from all over the world. Benefits and costs vary by product, historical context of market, geography, etc. It is also important to note that fair trade occupies only a small sliver of the global trade. Some Benefits of Fair Trade: At its core, fairtrade guarantees a decent price for producers by requiring traders to pay a premium, which is passed on to the consumer. This premium insulates the poorest of farmers from fluctuations in the market, disasters, and other extreme events Small-scale Farmers and Workers: The Fairtrade system benefits approximately 1 million workers and farmers in 60 developing countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America. Including their dependents, five million people are affected. Fairtrade certification allows them to achieve economic independence and empowerment while improving their standards of living. Beyond being paid a fair price for their produce, Fairtrade Premiums enable producers to better their communities by providing: • Improved access to low or no-interest loans • Technical assistance for building infrastructure to improve production • Communications systems, and collectively-owned transport and processing equipment • Better health care and education • Technical training and skill diversification for cooperative members and their families A recent...

Words: 753 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Minimum Support Price in Indian Economy

...Increases Inflation 10 4.2 Low MSP – Farmer’s Income Affected 10 5 Critical Analysis of MSP Policy 12 5.1 Consumer Surplus 12 5.2 Producer Surplus 12 5.3 Deadweight Loss 13 5.4 Other Effects 14 5.4 Measures to minimize MSP expenditure 16 Bibliography 18 1. Introduction 1.1 What is Minimum Support Price (MSP)? Minimum Support Price is the price at which government purchases crops from the farmers, whatever may be the competitive equilibrium price for the crops. A price floor, which is also referred to as a minimum price, sets the lowest level possible for a price. Price floors/minimum prices only have an effect if they are set above the actual market clearing price. There are many instances of governments in the real world setting price floors, such as setting a national minimum wage for labour to ensure that individuals are able to earn a ‘living wage’. In addition, given the instability of agricultural prices and the need to ensure food security, farm prices may be set which guarantee a minimum price to farmers. 1.2 What is the need for MSP? The main reason why the government fixes minimum support prices or MSPs is...

Words: 4528 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

The Big Wind

...first conduct market research. Market research has a variety of purposes and a variety of data collection methods that can be utilized for each purpose. What Urs needs to understand is that no small business can succeed without understanding who the potential customers might be, how those products and services affect the customers, and the market in general. Competition is often fierce, and operating without conducting research may give competitors an advantage. There are two ways to do market research, primary and secondary research. ("Market Research," 2010) As a general rule, a thorough research of the secondary data should be undertaken prior to conducting primary research. Using information gleaned from secondary sources, the owner can uncover all kinds of demographic information, including detailed income data and spending patterns. The secondary information will provide a useful background and will identify key questions and issues that will need to be addressed by the primary research. Performing secondary market research means obtaining information from sources such as trade journals and magazines where published papers, directories and even market statistics can be found. Useful qualitative data can be found in trade association figures, government and industry forecasts, white papers as well as in research reports.  All these will help the business owner ask the fundamental questions; what are the current dynamics of the market, what are the...

Words: 1995 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Nestle Business Case Analysis

...one of Nestles major markets. Therefore, it is imperative for Nestlé to be aware of the social, environmental and financial circumstances surrounding its business. Social: From the social perspective, the main circumstances that concerned Nestlé were local infrastructure, Fairtrade payment and the avoidance of child labor. In connection to that, products marked with Fairtrade label were described as “ethical” and “sustainable” conveying a broad message that farmers of these products have been given fixed price or have met ethical standards. Environmental: From the environmental perspective, there is a growing market trend in the U.K. for environmentally-friendly materials and therefore recycled materials in the packaging would have a big impact in consumers purchase decision. In addition, ecological washing systems have been built by Nestlé initiatives in order to expand water distribution within communities. In 2004, there were 1000 Fairtrade products from 150 companies available in most of the super market stores in different product categories. Finally, improvements in nutrition, environmental standards and agricultural supply chain have been discussed as circumstances. Financial: On the financial side, given the volatility of coffee prices as a result in changes on the supply, farmers have been negatively impacted. Also, the cost of certification from Fairtrade organization needs to be considered, along with what it might do to the farmers, as they are getting a...

Words: 1967 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Economics

...output. Agriculture plays an important role in the economic development of India. To increase the revenue of the agricultural commodities export division, ITC decided to create the eChoupal. 2. Agricultural supply chain was ineffective The second, soybeans comprised the main of ITC’s agricultural export business, but “both the input and output sides of the agricultural supply chain in India were still far from efficient” (Upton and Fuller, 2004, p.2). Traditionally, ITC had a value chain from procuring soybean from farmers and processing the beans, to exporting the soymeal to other countries such as China, Pakistan, and Arab etc. However, due to the lack of technological resources in India, ITC’s agricultural supply chain was ineffective. Farmers did not have quality inputs and financial benefits. In fact, farmers lost 60-70% of the potential value of their crop. On the output side, middlemen clogged the supply chain in order to reduce profit margins for farmers and ITC. Unfair...

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5