Premium Essay

“We Are Sparta”

In:

Submitted By arlo74
Words 831
Pages 4
Freedom is an ambiguous concept that has different meanings to various citizens; however, most people expect a certain level of security to be provided by their country. Freedom is defined as the right power of self-determination attributed to the will; the quality of being independent of fate or necessity. As citizens of the United States, we have fought several wars to complete our unique experience of practicing democracy; the mission of our Founding Fathers. Immigrants still risk their lives by scaling fences, swimming brisk waterways, and leaving their families to participate in this ambiguous concept called “freedom”. In order to protect freedom, someone has to pay the toll; subsequently it is the soldiers that often pick up the checks. I believe all men should support the military by serving two years (minimum) as a rite of passage, career exploration, and for the privilege of voting. Presently, we need soldiers all over the world, thus the need for manpower is uninterrupted. In fact, a show of numbers is an important strategy in deterring global conflict. Many cultures practice a metaphysical ceremony to acknowledge a conversion into adulthood. For example, the Spartans had what they called Helot Killing. In the Spartan society, all males had to go through fighter training. Spartan boys were ripped from their mothers at the age of seven, and attended warrior training until they were seventeen. When they turned eighteen, they would be sent off into the wilderness with knives, and had the mission of assassinating state-owned slaves (called helots). If they returned, they were men. If not they were not fit to live in a civilized society, and those mothers would be ashamed. The government can do the same by turning the draft into a rite of passage for males eighteen to twenty five years of age. However, it would not be as brutal as life

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ancient Sparta and Athens

...Kubik 1 Lubos Kubik Dr. Carlisle Composition II March 5, 2014 The ancient Athens and Sparta In times, long before Jesus, when thousands of people were dying for there lands and where women and men had very different roles were two unique cities, Athens and Sparta, with very different politics, beliefs and day to day life. These ancient times were very popular for their wars and heroes as likely for their politics and beliefs, which were very untraditional at that time. 100 years of one of the biggest rivalry in history of human kind Athens and Sparta put their names on the map of the modern world with lessons we can learn and bravery and courage to be admired. Athens and Sparta were always compared with their distinctions. They both had very different ideas how women should be threated in the society, also the politics and beliefs in these two cities were very diverse as the final outcome of their history and their decision-making in important life or death situations. Athens is of the oldest cities in the world, which has been populated for the last 7000 years, which Sparta cannot compare to that, because Sparta became city around 3000 years ago. Athens and Sparta are both know for their government and religion, but one of the biggest conflicts, even in recent history, was women rights and their position in society. Athens, as most of the ancient cites and states, took away women rights even before they were born. They were at the bottom of the society. The purpose of...

Words: 794 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Greek Civilization

...essays on Greek civilization Introduction This booklet is a collection of essays that were written for academic purpose. The essays are centred on Greece. Particular emphasis is placed on the states of Athens and Sparta. The aim of the essays is to show the contributions that Greek states made to the modern world. The world has learnt a lot of aspects from Greece, being they direct or indirect. One of the things that Greece brought to the world is the democratic system of government. Together with lessons from ancient Rome the world has learned much. Essay1: Differences in terrain and climatic conditions between Athens and Sparta Greece has many cities and towns, however probably the main ones in ancient times were Sparta and Athens. These two cities shaped the political life and history of Greece for quite a long time. The influence mainly centred on land and agriculture. For, about 90% of Greece production was agricultural in nature, with grain production as the dominant area. Incidentally, grain was a staple product and food of Greece. As a result the land that was used for grain production was a vital part of wealth and a valuable asset, for which citizens compete for. This essay is going to explore the difference in terrain between Athens and Sparta and how it affected agriculture and political rights, including democracy as well as how agricultural production had an impact on the distribution of political rights and the powers invested in various category of the...

Words: 3017 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

The Peloponnesian War

...allies in the Persian war; Athens and Sparta. The Persian war was a war fought between the Persians and the Greeks; these two Greek city states fought together to successfully defeat Persia. Many believe tensions arouse between Athens and Sparta during the Persian war due to opposing war tactics; quite simply they did not trust one another. This led to Athens and Sparta forming allies after the Persian war, Athens formed the Delian league while Sparta formed the Peloponnesian league. The Delian league funded their own naval army to guard and protect the Aegean from invasions from the Persians; this ultimately created a very powerful Athenian navy and Athenian empire. The first undeclared flames of war was when Sparta’s main ally, Corinth invaded Attica. Athens then taking precautions formed what is known as the long walls, which enclosed and connected Athens capital to its ports, which meant land based armies had little chances of starting war on Athens soil. This action sent fear and suspicions to Greek city states especially Corinth. Corinth was very important in commercial trade because it linked northern and southern Greece. The first outbreak of real conflict was when the Athenian navy dispatched a fleet to assist Egyptian rebels escape the Persian Empire. Rebellions in Athens then broke out, which led to Sparta invading Attica. A treaty known as the Thirty Years Peace was formed to prevent an official war between Athens and Sparta. Years went by before the treaty defected...

Words: 730 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Sparta

...also held their own, and were trained just as hard as the men. Spartan girls were not brought up to perform such tasks as spinning and weaving – these tasks were fit only for slaves – but partook in a certain amount of physical training with the boys (although they were excluded from military training), took part in various singing and dancing competitions, played instruments and recited poetry.[1] Spartan women were very unique in the ancient world, particularly in the areas of education and training, their roles and positions in Spartan society and their place in public life. EDUCATION AND TRAINING The women of Sparta were highly valued and respected, particularly for their roles as mothers and nurses. Spartan women also had a reputation for fitness, physical beauty and a strong, independent character. The purpose of a girl’s education in Sparta was to produce healthy bodies, so that, according to Lycurgus, ‘the fruit they conceived might take firmer root and find better growth, so that they, with this greater vigour, might be more able to undergo with the pains of childbearing’.[2] According to Plutarch, the girls were organised into bands, similar to the boys groups. He also states that they sometimes exercised together in a large group, participating in such sports as running and wrestling. The girls exercised with the boys to not only increase their physical resilience and make them tougher, but also to encourage competitiveness and equality, and to promote...

Words: 1203 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Athens and Sparta Essay

...Athens and Sparta existed from 2000 B.C. to 404 B.C. Sparta came around when the helots were conquered in a village that was named Sparta which became their capital. Athens were sea traders and were big on trade, which might have been a reason why their city-state came about. Sparta was located in a village down in a valley. They were a rigid and highly militarized society. Their location may have helped explain why Sparta developed different from Athens. Athens was an attic peninsula that was built inland. Their city-state was built around the rocky hill of Acropolis. Sparta was ruled by two kinds. One king led the army, while the other took care of the matters at home. The Council of Elders were made up of 28 male citizens over 60. They were usually wealthy and high in power. They proposed laws and served as a criminal court. An assembly consisted of all male citizens over 30 voted on those laws proposed by the Council of Elders to accept or reject them. The helots in Sparta hated the Spartans and what they did, because they had no say and were treated as a low class. Athens was a democracy ruled by Cleisthenes. What he first did was divide Athen’s citizens into 10 tribes. Then each tribe chose 50 men. And those men formed what we call the Council of Five Hundred. The members served for one year and couldn’t be chosen more than twice. They proposed laws to the assembly, but the assembly had the final word. The court became more democratic also. Jurors were citizens chosen by...

Words: 1303 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Peloponnesian War Athens Vs Sparta

...One of the most historical wars was the Peloponnesian war. Fought between Athens and Sparta, the two leading city-states. From 431-404 BC. The fighting covered the entire Greek world. Although Athens and Sparta were at war for numerous years they have many similarities and differences. One of the similarities is women were oppressed in both societies. An example is women weren’t allowed to take part in government. Both also had Polytheistic religion. They worshipped gods of nature and emotions such as Zeus, Athena, Hades, Aphrodite, and Poseidon. They both held an event we still enjoy today, the Olympic games. Many events were held, including pentathlon, running, jumping, wrestling, boxing, pankration, equestrian events, and discus throwing....

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dumbotron

...change with political ambition, power struggles internal and external which change with time; as we are witnessing today with the collapse of the Soviet Empire, emergence of Putin and China onto the global stage. The rise and decline of Athens, Persia and Sparta and emergence of Macedonia involved many such alliances, pacts between states. By 478 BC Athens emerged as the dominant power with Sparta disadvantaged despite being the dominant force in the Delian League not helped by internal strife and a devastating earthquake ,resulting in asking Athens help. It was the resulting consequence of involving Athens that a further 30 years of skirmishes between them which neither gaining the upper hand. The Second Peloponnesian War as the Greek historian Thucydides who lived through these events states :what made war inevitable was the growth of Athenian power and the fear this caused in Sparta: The constant power struggles and alliances, skirmishes resulted in both Athens and Sparta being weakened undermining both. Athens second attempt to take Sicily was a disaster Thucydides......for they(Athenians) were utterly defeated; their sufferings on an enormous scale, army navy, everything was destroyed and out of many only a few returned. This defeat in Sicily was the turning point in this Peloponnesian War. From 413 BC the war was no longer a struggle between Athens and Sparta as others saw it as an opportunity to get involved and gain an advantage among them the Persians....

Words: 313 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Great Athenians: The Peloponnesian Battles

...I guess Sparta is starting another battle again we have to go respond Athenians. The Peloponnesian battles were mainly fought by Sparta and Athens or at least those two were the main focus, but the two armies had some allies. The Great Athenians named themselves the Delian league and the Spartans were named the Peloponnesian league. The first fought battle between the two main armies was in 460-446 BCE. The second battle between the two was in 431-404 BCE. The battles weren’t fought in a specific spot in Greece because there were so many allies to the two of the armies. The main reason why the first battle got started was when Athens needed some wood for a project, but one of the allies of Sparta wouldn’t allow that to happen. When...

Words: 300 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Sparta vs Athens

...Thomas Curran February 15th, 2014 Western Civilization Spring 2014 Rashmi Chilka Sparta and Athens, the two greatest city states in all of Greece could not be more different. One is the yin the other is the yang, one is the great center of politics while the other a hard working oiled war machine. No two greater powers have ever lived so close to each other and coincided peacefully. Yet peace is a short term idea and one thing you can be certain of is that humans will always war with each other and these two super powers of ancient times were no different so every Greek eventually had to pick a side, Democracy or a Monarchy, philosophy or fighting, Athens or Sparta. Athens was like the California of the ancient world, always so innovative and open minded to a great many ideas. Athens was one of the first places to introduce democracy into a world full of feudalism and monarchies, not that all of the monarchs across the world were bad but overall the lifestyle was much fairer for the average citizen in Athens. The power came from the people and this made the people happy which is the goal of any government no matter what it is. Now Sparta was a little different, Sparta was a city focused on martial prowess, discipline and simply being physically better than all other. Spartans were the pinnacle and prime example of the Warrior. Every Spartan dreams of a glorious death in battle and to them dying any other way would have been seen as cowardly or weak. Once a Spartan...

Words: 1085 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Why Is Athens Better Than Sparta

...Athens and Sparta are both city states of Ancient Greece, but have you ever wondered which is better? .Athenian boys are homeschooled from when they are born to when they are the age 6. Then they graduate at age 20 but if there family is rich, they graduate at age 25. They have also have had way more cultural achievements then Sparta has ever had. Athens is the smarter and more educated city state. Athens was the superior city state because they were more educated. One reason they were a first-rate city state because they were more educated, for example they sent kids to school when Sparta left them alone in the cold. This shows that Athenians was more educated than Spartans.In conclusion I think Athenians were smarter than Spartans. They...

Words: 341 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sparta Dbq Analysis

...Sparta is great! They are kind to all of their people, they are all very educated, and they spend a lot of time as families together. That’s exactly what Sparta is, but the exact opposite. A few reasons why the weaknesses outweigh the strengths are that Sparta is actually very violent and abusive, Spartans lack education severely, and the boys were taken away from their families at a young age To begin with, the Spartans were very abusive. They have trained for war for years upon years, and are very successful, that is if they survive the training. If the training children did something wrong, they got whipped sometimes to the point of death. On document D, paragraph three, it says: ”The boys of Sparta were lashed with whips during the entire day at the altar of Artemis Orthia, frequently to the point of death, and they bravely endured this, cheerful and proud, vying with one another.” They didn’t treat each other well, and they usually die because of such events. Secondly, the Spartans lack education. On document D, paragraph 1, it says:”[The Spartans] learned to read and write for purely practical reasons: but all other forms of education they banned from the country, books and treatises being...

Words: 473 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Athens Persuasive Speech

...us. We have been acting as though our actions have no real world consequences. We’ve been so caught up in all of this chaos, all of our factions, the agendas, and rhetoric. Don’t you see what it has been doing to us? It has caused us to come out of touch with reality and the rest of Athens. Because of our factions, we come to the Assembly ready to vote a certain way. More times than not, we will not change our vote either. We don’t care what is right. We don’t care what is wrong. We don’t care if someone has made an excellent point or not. Instead, we only vote for that way in favors of our faction’s agenda. Basically, we use rhetoric to debase the others in the assembly. We are here today, my brothers, to discuss more important agenda items. Basically all of you Radical and Moderate Democrats are going to just sit there in your seats and say, “get one with it already”. You’re going to listen to my arguments and points, and then oppose all of my statements and tell my fellow Oligarchs and I your side of the argument. But please, hear me out. The agenda for today is about Athens rebuilding its fleet and recommencing tribute...

Words: 1448 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Thucydides's Historical Record Of The Peloponnesian War Essay

...Last discussion, we focused on Thucydides’ motives and methods for his historical record of the Peloponnesian war. First, we established that Thucydides’ stated purpose was to create a lasting account of the war between Sparta and Athens and to inform future generations of the lessons in history. Thucydides, unlike his contemporary Herodotus, was alive for all of the events he described. As a result, much of his evidence his is based on speeches, which he and his informants were unable to perfectly record. In place of the exact words, Thucydides takes the general sense of the speeches and applies what in his opinion “was called for by each situation” (1.22) This methodology ties directly into Thucydides’ notion that human nature remains constant....

Words: 334 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Sparta Strengths And Weaknesses

...There is a reason Sparta is still known for their military dominates today. Sparta made up the formation called the phalanx. The phalanx consisted of a tight group of soldiers each holding a shield that interlocked with his neighbor’s, each man carrying a short sword and a thrusting spear. Sparta also focused on their military, the boys left their families at the age of seven to twenty-first year of training. The strengths of Sparta outweigh the weaknesses because they respected authority, they had an advanced military, and because the women were respected. To begin, with the Spartans respected authority. In document it says, “The young men were required not only to respect their own fathers and to be obedient to them, but to have regard for all the older men.” How could Spartans be loyal to others if they didn’t respect authority? People should respect authority because now of days people go visit the elderly, and if we didn’t...

Words: 494 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Manal

...STATEMENT DEBATE 1: That Lycurgus’ reforms in Sparta were more successful than those of Solon in Athens. BOOK: Cartledge, P. 2002. Sparta and Lakonia: a regional history, 1300-362 B.C. (New York: Routledge). “Still more dubious is the role of co-founder of the Olympic Games assigned to the Spartan lawgiver Lykourgos by Aristotle (fr. 533 Rose) on the basis of an inscribed discus he had seen at Olympia. Regrettably too the story that Lykourgos was responsible for bringing the Homeric poems from Ionia to the Greek mainland (Plut. Lyk. 4.4) must be dismissed as a fable of the kind which tended to accrete around such legendary figures.” Pg. 103 Chapter 8 (The Lakonia Renascence) “the devoutly pro-Spartan Athenian exile Xenophon could even, by making Lykourgos contemporary with the (Return of the) Herakleidai (Lak. Pol. 10.8), contrive to suggest that there had never been stasis or civil strife on the political plane in Sparta since the Dorian foundation.” Pg 133 Chapter 9 (The Consolidation of Lakonia) “Even Plutarch was unable to keep stasis (civil strife) out of his biography—or rather hagiography—of the lawgiver (Lyk. 5.4f.). More instructive, though, are the sources who were not a party to the mirage. Herodotus (1.65.2) went so far as to say that before Lykourgos’ reforms Sparta had suffered the worst kakonomia (lawlessness) of any Greek state, while Thucydides (1.18. 1), without mentioning Lykourgos by name, agreed for once with Herodotus that there had been stasis...

Words: 532 - Pages: 3