Free Essay

What Is Going on

In:

Submitted By mdnm999
Words 3259
Pages 14
Actuarial Accounting:
A Cautionary Report
Dan R. Young, Esq.
Attorney at Law
Law Offices of Dan R. Young
Seattle, Washington danryoung@netzero.net Presented the Spring Meeting of the CAS
New Orleans, Louisiana
May 6, 2009

The Story of the AIG Accounting Scandal








The Companies
The Participants
Regulatory Scrutiny Intensifies
The Prosecution Case
The Defense Case
Relevant Laws and Regulations
The Fate of the Participants

The Companies

AIG Overview (2007)









World’s largest insurance and financial services company 93,000 employees
Business in 130 countries
Led by Maurice (“Hank”) Greenburg
Shareholder’s equity 2007: $95.8 billion
Net Income 2007: $6.2 billion
Premium written 2007: $59.8 billion

GenRe Overview








One of World’s largest reinsurers
Established 1921
Headquartered in Connecticut
Owned by Warren Buffet’s Berkshire Hathaway
Led by Ronald Ferguson, FCAS, until he retired in 2002
Premium written 2007: $6.0 billion

The Participants

Hank Greenburg, CEO of AIG







Born 1925
Admitted to NY Bar in 1953
Joined AIG in 1962
Named CEO in 1968
Led AIG for 38 years
Stepped down March 21, 2005

Ron Ferguson, CEO of Gen Re








Born 1942
Fellow of CAS
Co-developer of B-F method
Joined Gen Re in 1966
Named CEO in 1987
1998 Berkshire Hathaway acquired Gen Re
Retired 2002

Others
Christopher Garand, FCAS
 Senior VP and Chief Underwriter of GenRe’s Finite Reinsurance in
US from 1994 to 2005
Elizabeth Monrad, CPA
 CFO of Gen Re 2000 to 2003
Robert Graham, JD
 SVP and Assistant General
Counsel at GenRe until 2005

Others
Christian Milton
 VP of AIG’s Reinsurance until 2005
Richard Napier
 SVP responsible for GenRe relationship with AIG
John Houldsworth
 CEO of Cologne Re Dublin
(CRD)

Eliot Spitzer, JD






Born 1959
Former Attorney General of NY
Notable prosecutions:
 Mutual fund scandals (2003)
 Insurer bid rigging (2004)
 AIG accounting scandal (2005)
Elected Governor of NY in 2006

Regulatory Scrutiny Intensifies

How AIG Came under Scrutiny








2001 – SEC learns that AIG has assisted a client company in bolstering its balance sheet through a bogus insurance transaction
 investigation ensues
2003 – SEC and Justice Department settle with AIG
 $10 Million Civil Penalty
 Independent consultant retained
2004 – Federal Grand Jury begins investigation of AIG’s income smoothing products
2004 – Bid rigging complaint filed against AIG and others

AIG Admits to Improper Accounting





February 9, 2005 – 2004 earnings released
March 30, 2005 – AIG discloses that reinsurance deal with GenRe should have been accounted for as a deposit
May 31, 2005 – Restatement amounted to reduction in 2004 net income of $1.32 Billion

The State Authorities Attack
May 27, 2005 – Spitzer files civil suit against AIG
 Alleges AIG "engaged in misleading accounting and financial reporting, projecting an unduly positive picture of AIG's underwriting performance for the investing public.“  In particular, engaged in "two sham insurance transactions" that gave investors the impression the company had larger reserves for claims than it did.
 Other wrongdoing

Greenberg Fires Back


"For the attorney general to use his office to prosecute, and persecute, people in the press for political gain is wholly against our legal principles," said Greenberg in an interview. "It's outrageous." …



"It's simple: He's running for another office," Greenberg said. "It has nothing to do with right or wrong.“



CNBC’s Charles Gasparino reports that in an interview he previously conducted, Greenberg called Spitzer “a thug.” The Federal Authorities Attack
Feb 2, 2006 – SEC files complaint in US District Court against AIG
 "This case is not about the violation of technical accounting rules. It involves the deliberate or extremely reckless efforts by senior corporate officers of a facilitator company (Gen Re) to aid and abet senior management of an issuer (AIG) in structuring transactions having no economic substance, that were designed solely for the unlawful purpose of achieving a specific, and false, accounting effect on the issuer's financial statements.“

SEC Settlement


Feb 9, 2006 – SEC and Justice Department settlement with AIG
 Total settlement in excess of $1.6 billion
 Related to alleged improper accounting, bid rigging and practices involving workers comp funds
 CEO and CFO replaced

Federal Criminal Action




Federal criminal charges filed against certain officers at
AIG and Gen Re
Alleged violation of 16 counts of the criminal code
 Conspiracy (1 count)
 Securities fraud (7 counts)
 False statements to SEC (5 counts)
 Mail fraud (3 counts)

Plea Bargained


Richard Napier
SVP, Gen Re



John Houldsworth
CEO, CRD



Witnesses for the
Prosecution

The Prosecution Case

The Setting






Oct 26, 2000 – AIG announced that premiums increased in Q3, but reserves fell by $59 million
Oct 26, 2000 – AIG share price dropped from
$99.37 to $93.31 on NYSE (6%)
October 31, 2000 – Greenberg called Ferguson

The Phone Call (Napier)
Greenberg asked Ferguson to temporarily transfer loss reserves to AIG:
 Amount of $200 to $500 million
 To occur by year end 2000
 To last 6 to 9 months
 AIG should incur no losses (i.e., the deal should be riskless)

Initial Steps


Richard Napier
Gen Re point person



Christian Milton
AIG point person

Initial Steps


Parties agree to deal:
 Gen Re to transfer loss reserves to AIG in exchange for a payment of premium
 Two separate contracts transfer loss reserves:








$250 million in 2000 with cap of $300 million
$250 million in 2001 with cap of $300 million

Gen Re “obligated” to pay AIG “premium” of
$500 million ($250 million per contract)
Gen Re to receive $5 million for doing the deal
Contract to last 24 months

Other Issues with the Deal




Accounting problem:
 Deposit or Reinsurance accounting?
 AIG used reinsurance accounting
 Gen Re used deposit accounting
The “North American problem”:
 Statutory reporting requires disclosure of premium and reserves related to each reinsurance transaction
 GenRe’s foreign subsidiary (CRD) not required to file US reports

Issues with the Deal






A paper trail had to be created to appear that
Gen Re proposed the deal
Gen Re had to appear to be on the hook for
$500 million in “premium” without actually paying it AIG had to pay Gen Re’s $5 million fee for doing the deal without attracting the attention of regulators The Loss Portfolio Transfer
How AIG accounted for the Deal
AIG

National Union
Assets
+$10M Premium Paid by CRD
+$490M Premium Receivable withheld by CRD
Liabilities
+$500M Additional Reserves

Impact on AIG’s Loss Reserves
Reported

LPT
Contracts

Actual

4Q 2000

+$106 M

-$250 M

-$144 M

1Q 2001

+$63 M

-$250 M

-$187 M

Reaction from Analysts




“We think this quarter was a good example of
AIG doing what it does best: growing fast and making the numbers…As important was the change in reserves: AIG added $106 million to reserves…” “Finally AIG put to rest a minor controversy from last quarter by adding $106 million to reserves…” How CRD Paid $10M in Premium without Really Paying
Leverage existing contract, in which Gen Re holds $31.8M payable to AIG
 Gen Re pays only $7.5M to commute an existing contract with AIG’s Hartford Steam Boiler (HSB)
 Gen Re pays National Union $9.1M in premium to reinsure the HSB losses that were just commuted
 CRD pays $0.4M in premiums to Gen Re for a “sham” reinsurance contract and receives a loss payment of
$13M shortly after ink dries
 CRD pays LPT “premium” of $10M to AIG
 Gen Re / CRD left with $5.2M to cover the fee

The “Round Trip of Cash”
Commute
for $7.5 M

AIG

Gen Re
Existing Contract with HSB
(Commute Value of $31.8M)

$400K
Rein Prem

Hartford Steam Boiler
(HSB)

Rein Prem of $9.1 M

Sham Loss
Payments
of $13.0 M

Cologne Re Dublin
(CRD)

LPT Prem of $10 M

National Union

Gen Re: $31.8M - $ 7.5M - $9.1M + $0.4M- $13.0M = $2.6M
CRD: - $0.4M + $13.0M - $10.0M = $2.6M

Prosecution Evidence

Napier’s Trial Testimony






Under secret side deal, AIG paid Gen Re $5 million fee, and did not actually pay the $10 million in premium specified in written contract
He, Ferguson, and Monrad discussed draft contract as a no-risk deal
Ferguson discussed terms of contract with
Greenberg, including that AIG would bear no risk

Houldworth’s Trial Testimony
11-14-2000 (recorded):
 Houldworth: There is clearly no risk transfer. You know there is no money changing hands.
 Monrad: [AIG] may have a tough time getting the accounting they want out of the deal that they want to do… They are not looking for real risk…

Houldsworth (Cont.)




Sent to Ferguson email on 11-15-2000, with draft LPT contract, stating “[Gen Re] will not transfer any losses under this deal”
 Ferguson’s former secretary identifies his handwriting on email
AIG did not ask Gen Re for information necessary to perform actuarial analysis of risk

Houldsworth (Cont.)
12-08-2000 (recorded):
 Monrad: We told AIG that there would not be symmetrical accounting here.
 Houldworth: Okay, fine.
 Monrad: We told them that was one of the aspects of the deal they would have to digest.

Evidence of Ferguson’s Knowledge
12-11-00 (recorded):
 Houldsworth: We’re going to ask . . .
Ron [Ferguson] to sign off on the reputational risk. I think it’s Ron’s deal so he’s the one that ought to.
 Garand: Yep.
 Houldsworth: I mean he’s effectively done that by being involved but we may as well follow the rules.
 Garand: Sure. Make him sign in blood.  Houldsworth: Well, I don’t care what he signs in as long as I know it’s him.

Other Evidence
12-22-2000 (email)
 "[T]he AIG project continues. It is now a two step loss portfolio deal between [CRD] and National Union. . . .
Our group will book the transaction as a deposit. How
AIG books it is between them, their accountants and
God; there is no undertaking by them to have the transaction reviewed by their regulators. Ron [Ferguson] et al. have been advised of, and have accepted, the potential reputational risk that US regulators (insurance and securities) may attack the transaction and our part in it.“ - Robert Graham

Other Evidence
3-7-01 (recorded):
 Graham: We [GenRe] aren’t going to pay them [AIG] the fee [premium] yet. You know, we don’t intend to pay them until we get the cash. If they turn around and start kicking up a fuss, I don’t think they really want this made public, this transaction. I would be very surprised.
There’s a whole pile of things.

Other Evidence
3-7-01 (recorded):
 Graham: Well, and their [AIG’s] organizational approach to compliance issues has always been pay the speeding ticket, so, which is different than our [GenRe’s] organizational approach to compliance. So I’m pretty comfortable that our own skirts are clean but they [AIG] have issues.

The Defense Case

Defense Case Overview




Two days
Five character witnesses testified
Defendants did not testify

Defense Strategy




Attacked reliability/credibility of Napier and Houldsworth
 Conversations and meetings that never occurred
 Insufficient evidence of side deals
Also argued that
 LPT had minimal effect on AIG financials
 AIG share price not affected after AIG disclosure
 Common industry practice
 Absence of financial motive
 Recordings were taken out of context
 Buffet knew of and approved of LPT deal

Warren Buffet’s Involvement
Email from Ferguson to Buffet
 “Warren, just a quick note to let you know why I hesitated a moment when you mentioned the $5,000,000 fee on the reserve transaction. We are indeed charging a 1% fee but for some reason A.I.G. decided to split the deal in to two $2,500,000 tranches one to be registered in 2000 and one in
2001.”

Relevant Laws and Regulation

Relevant Laws & Regulations
US Code
Security Investor
Protection Laws
Conspiracy Laws
Mail Fraud Laws

Code of Federal
Regulations

Manipulative and deceptive devices
(15 USC §78j)

Security Investor
Protection Laws

It shall be unlawful …
 (b) To use or employ, in connection with the purchase or sale of any security registered on a national securities exchange … any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in contravention of [Rules 10b-5,
12b-20, etc.]

Rule 10b-5

Code of Federal
Regulations

Employment of manipulative and deceptive devices.
It shall be unlawful for any person, directly or indirectly, by the use of any means or instrumentality of interstate commerce, or of the mails or of any facility of any national securities exchange,
a) To employ any device, scheme, or artifice to defraud,
b) To make any untrue statement of a material fact or to omit to state a material fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in the light of the circumstances under which they were made, not misleading, or
c) To engage in any act, practice, or course of business which operates or would operate as a fraud or deceit upon any person, in connection with the purchase or sale of any security.

Rule 12b-20

Code of Federal
Regulations

Additional information


In addition to the information expressly required to be included in a statement or report, there shall be added such further material information, if any, as may be necessary to make the required statements, in the light of the circumstances under which they are made not misleading. Rule 13b2-1

Code of Federal
Regulations

Falsification of accounting records


No person shall directly or indirectly, falsify or cause to be falsified, any book, record or account subject to section 13(b)(2)(A) of the
Securities Exchange Act.

Code of Federal
Regulations

Other Rules



§ 240.13a–1 Requirements of annual reports
§ 240.13a–13 Qrtly reports on Form 10–Q

Periodical and other reports
(15 USC §78m)

Security Investor
Protection Laws

(b) Form of report; books, records, and internal accounting; directives
(2) Every issuer which has a class of securities registered pursuant to section 78l of this title and every issuer which is required to file reports pursuant to section 78o (d) of this title shall—
A. make and keep books, records, and accounts, which, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the issuer;
B. devise and maintain a system of internal accounting controls sufficient to provide reasonable assurances that …transactions are recorded as necessary … to permit preparation of financial statements in conformity with generally accepted accounting principles or any other criteria applicable to such statements, …

Security Investor
Protection Laws

Penalties (15 USC §78ff)


(a) Willful violations; false and misleading statements Any person who willfully violates any provision of this chapter (other than section 78dd–1 of this title), or any rule or regulation thereunder the violation of which is made unlawful or the observance of which is required under the terms of this chapter, or any person who willfully and knowingly makes, or causes to be made, any statement in any application, report, or document required to be filed under this chapter or any rule or regulation thereunder or any undertaking contained in a registration statement as provided in subsection
(d) of section 78o of this title, or by any self-regulatory organization in connection with an application for membership or participation therein or to become associated with a member thereof which statement was false or misleading with respect to any material fact, shall upon conviction be fined not more than $5,000,000, or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both, except that when such person is a person other than a natural person, a fine not exceeding $25,000,000 may be imposed; but no person shall be subject to imprisonment under this section for the violation of any rule or regulation if he proves that he had no knowledge of such rule or regulation.

§ 371. Conspiracy to commit offense or to defraud United States


Conspiracy
Laws

If two or more persons conspire either to commit any offense against the United States, or to defraud the United States, or any agency thereof in any manner or for any purpose, and one or more of such persons do any act to effect the object of the conspiracy, each shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than five years, or both.

§ 1341. Frauds and Swindles

Mail Fraud
Laws

Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, … for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice or attempting so to do, places in any post office or authorized depository for mail matter, any matter or thing whatever to be sent or delivered by the
Postal Service, …or knowingly causes to be delivered by mail …any such matter or thing, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both...

Fate of the Participants

Ron Ferguson, FCAS
Convicted of:

Conspiracy (1 count)

Securities fraud (7 counts)

False statements to SEC (5 counts)

Mail fraud (3 counts)
Sentence:

2 years in prison

2 years supervised release

$200,000 fine

Personal recognizance pending appeal

Christopher Garand, FCAS
Convicted of:

Conspiracy (1 count)

Securities fraud (7 counts)

False statements to SEC (5 counts)

Mail fraud (3 counts)
Sentence:

1 year & 1 day in prison

1 year supervised release

$150,000 fine

Christian Milton
Convicted of:

Conspiracy (1 count)

Securities fraud (7 counts)

False statements to SEC (5 counts)

Mail fraud (3 counts)
Sentence:

4 years in prison

2 years of supervised release

$200,000 fine

Robert Graham, JD
Convicted of:

Conspiracy (1 count)

Securities fraud (7 counts)

False statements to SEC (5 counts)

Mail fraud (3 counts)
Sentencing pending

Elizabeth Monrad, CPA
Convicted of:

Conspiracy (1 count)

Securities fraud (7 counts)

False statements to SEC (5 counts)

Mail fraud (3 counts)
Gives pre-sentencing interview

Monrad’s Reaction to Conviction
Monrad’s response
 “I know I’m innocent”
 Plans to appeal
Misgivings
 Expected to testify but was persuaded it wasn’t necessary  She was afraid that her testimony would be used to try to harm innocent co-defendants
Buffet’s ongoing involvement gave her comfort that the transaction was acceptable
Gun to the Head
 Plead and cooperate and get probation or go to trial and risk prison for the rest of your life

Monrad Sentencing Hearing





Prosecutor refers to interview as lack of respect for judicial system
Children, husband, colleagues address the court
Monrad begged the judge for mercy: "My life is in your hands.“
Judge Droney’s comments:
 "There were many opportunities for her to come to her senses and shake this shady deal, but she never did,"
 The fact that she didn't benefit personally from the scheme
“doesn't excuse her conduct.”
 Her involvement with the fraudulent transaction "was central to its success,"  She knew the harm her conduct could cause.
 "She was the financial expert for General Re in this transaction."
 “A message must be sent to the business and financial communities that this kind of conduct will not be tolerated."

Monrad’s Sentence




18 months in prison
3 years supervised release
$250,000 fine

Unindicted Co-conspirator



Hank Greenberg
“Took the 5th”

Down in Shame


Eliot Spitzer
 Stepped down as Governor in 2008 amid allegations of patronizing a prostitution ring

Code of Professional Conduct
PRECEPT 1. An Actuary shall act honestly, with integrity and competence, and in a manner to fulfill the profession's responsibility to the public and to uphold the reputation of the actuarial profession.


ANNOTATION 1-2. An Actuary shall not provide Actuarial Services for any Principal if the Actuary has reason to believe that such services may be used to violate or evade the Law or in a manner that would be detrimental to the reputation of the actuarial profession. 

ANNOTATION 1-4. An Actuary shall not engage in any professional conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation or commit any act that reflects adversely on the actuarial profession.

CAS Action


CAS has requested ABCD to investigate whether Garand and Ferguson violated the
Code of Professional Conduct

Similar Documents

Free Essay

What Keeps You Going?

...Jessica Mae B. Fernandez BSM21 What keeps me going? Sometimes, life can be tough. There are days that I get tired, hopeless, or that I am on the verge of giving up, but I tend not to. This is because I am surrounded with people and things that inspire me to get going. Through them, I am able to move forward. Let’s put first things first. Of course, my greatest motivating factor would be my family. They are always there to encourage and support me in my decisions. As an only child, I am the only one who will take good care of my parents when they grow older, that’s why I must be successful so that I can provide them what they need. And at the same time, I don’t want to disappoint them. So when the time comes that I have achieved my goals, I would gladly share my success with them, because success-- when you don’t have someone to share it with-- is totally worthless. Aside from my family, another thing that motivates me to keep going is my goals. It is just fascinating to know that there are still better things ahead of us, and some of our best days haven’t happened yet. Great things are bound to happen if we just choose to go on and work harder. Maybe, there would be ups and downs, but that’s a part of life. If we give up just because of a little rain, how can we enjoy the rainbow that appears after that? This college, I just made a bucketlist for all the things I want to accomplish just like places to visit, books to read, bands to watch, extreme activities to experience--...

Words: 397 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

You What Going with Ghnana

...Technology: Friend Technology is very much a part of modern life. Many people see technology as force that has escaped from human control. Technology helps improve the quality of life. By doing many of mundane tasks, so that people can spend more time.   In today’s world, three modern technologies have become a major part in people`s everyday lives: the computer, cell phone and GPS device. Society uses the computer for a myriad of things from looking up facts to shopping online, but one of the biggest uses of the internet is social networking. The cellphone allows people to talk to any one of their friends. Because the GPS device is automated, it lets the driver focus on the road instead of the map. Although those three technologies may seem quite different, each one gives us convenience, speed, and freedom. Out of all the technology we have come across through the years, mobile telephony has become the most explosive development. It has added the convenience of reaching anyone no matter where they are. It has revolutionized long distance communication and has made the lives of generations easier through constant connection. Cell phones allow a college student to consult with peers and teachers about uncertainties on a project. A cell phone can save the life of a ten year old woman in a car accident, who is able to dial 911 from the seat of her car. As cell phones exploded in today’s lifestyle, so did the programs that come with it. Text messaging became popular...

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Cvs Caremark: What Is Really Going on

...CVS Caremark What is Really Going On Before we get to the major concept presented by Chapter 2, we must define one of the main contributors to the concept, whistleblowers. Whistleblowers are people who decide to report unethical or illegal activities, usually activities under the control of their employers. According to Halbert and Ingulli, “What unites all whistleblowing is the urge to bring a disturbing situation to light, the urge to bring about some corrective change” (Halbert & Ingulli, 2012, p. 46). This brings us to the concept highlighted in Chapter 2, loyalty to the company, and their views on employment-at-will and their rules for and against whistleblowing. Looking at CVS’ policies and Caremark’s Code of Conduct, and I quote, “A provision of the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 requires CVS Caremark to provide its colleagues, and certain contractors and agents, with information regarding the federal and state false claims acts, whistleblower protections and CVS Caremark’s process for detecting and preventing fraud, waste, and abuse.” The protections that are said above include “protecting the employee involved in whistleblowing from being laid off or fired by the company, demoting from their current position, denying any overtime or promotion, disciplining in any way, failure to hire or rehire, intimidation and threat-making, delaying any chance for promotion, and reducing pay or hours,” (OSHA, 2013). This code of conduct in the policy itself shows that CVS takes...

Words: 7325 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

What Are the Advantages of Going to Westwood College

...WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES OF ATTENDING WESTWOOD COLLEGE With the recent downturn in the nation’s economy, many businesses have downsized, relocated or just shut down. The results of this downward trend are high unemployment, and shrinking numbers in our job pools. Employers have become more selective in their hiring practices due to the high number of applicants. A job that once took only a high school diploma or GED now requires a bachelor’s degree or at the least some college coupled with experience in that specific field of work. The demand for a more educated employee has caused colleges from all over the nation to solicit individuals to become a part of their institution. One of these colleges vying for the attention of serious applicants is Westwood College. Two advantages that make Westwood the higher learning institution of choice are its fast track system to obtaining a bachelor’s degree and the commitment to Westwood alumni after graduation. Westwood has adopted a system of learning in which a student can acquire a bachelor’s degree within three years. To the student hungry for success, the appeal of gaining a bachelor’s degree in such a short period of time serves as a catalyst that drives them to graduation. This system is particularly appealing to those who are currently employed and are seeking advancement in their present field. It is equally advantageous for the student fresh out of high school seeking an edge into the job market. Westwood prides itself...

Words: 400 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Rosetta Stone Going Public?

...Rosetta Stone What are the advantages and disadvantages of Rosetta Stone going public? The main advantages of Rosetta Stone going public are that an IPO would allow them the capital to expand their business into new markets as well as build on the Rosetta Stone brand. The IPO would also help them establish business credibility as a public firm. As a public company, Rosetta could enhance their image and reputation with newfound capital. It may also be advantageous to proceed with an IPO as the market has shown encouraging signs after the crisis of 2008. Changyou.com, a video game developer recently went public at 6.5 times EBITDA. Likewise, Bridgeport Education has recently considered going public and estimates that they could do so at a range of 10-12 times EBITDA. This may indicate that an IPO would behoove Rosetta Stone as it would be a successful business decision. Furthermore, the language learning industry largely consists of self-study learning as it counts for $32 billion of the $82 billion industry. Going public would allow Rosetta to be a major market presence in a booming industry. Another advantage of taking Rosetta Stone public is Adams’ concern of a takeover. Adams is worried that the limited amount of capital and resources they could get from private sources leave them vulnerable to a takeover. An IPO would quell those fears. There are, however, a few disadvantages associated with going public. For one, the process is quite arduous and would take...

Words: 901 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Enron: What Ever Happened to Going Down with the Ship?

...The Senate Commerce Committee Hearings finally found the right metaphor for Enron's fate when Chairman Byron Dorgan (D-ND) compared the company to the Titanic. "In the Titanic," he said, "the captain went down with the ship. And Enron looks to me like the captain first gave himself and his friends a bonus, then lowered himself and the top folks down the lifeboat and then hollered up and said, 'By the way, everything is going to be just fine.'" But there is, in the Titanic cast of characters, a good analog for the Enron leadership. While the captain, the first officer, and the Titanic's designer did go down with the ship, there was one honcho whose behavior was more like the Enron executives': J. Bruce Ismay, director of the White Star Line, which built and ran the Titanic. Ismay was a passenger on that fateful voyage, and some said he encouraged the high speeds that contributed to the collision with the iceberg. Yet he hopped into a lifeboat early on in the disaster. Shades of former Enron CEO Jeffrey Skilling, and Enron Chairman and former CEO Kenneth Lay. At the same time as these gentlemen were shouldering their way into the lifeboats, they were interfering with the evacuation of their workers. At this week's hearing, Senator Barbara Boxer played a videotape from a 1999 employee meeting where Skilling smiles and nods at the suggestion that employees put all their 401(k) retirement money into Enron stock. That was certainly not Skilling's own strategy. He sold 39 percent...

Words: 742 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Get Your Team to Do What It Says It’s Going to Do

...Get Your Team to Do What It Says It’s Going to Do by Heidi Grant Halvorson Say you’re in the early stages of planning your department’s budget for the next fiscal year. Your management team meets to establish short-term priorities and starts to think about longer-term resource allocation. You identify next steps and decide to reconvene in a week—but when you do, you find that very little progress has been made. What’s the holdup? Your to-dos probably look something like this: Step 1: Develop a tentative budget for continuing operations. Step 2: Clarify the department’s role in upcoming corporate initiatives. Those steps may be logical, but they’re ineffective because they omit essential details. Even the first one, which is relatively straightforward, raises more questions than it answers. What data must the team gather to estimate requirements for continuing operations? Who will run the reports, and when? Which managers can shed additional light on resource needs? Who will talk to them and reconcile their feedback with what the numbers say? When will that happen? Who will assess competing priorities and decide which trade-offs to make? When? Creating goals that teams and organizations will actually accomplish isn’t just a matter of defining what needs doing; you also have to spell out the specifics of getting it done, because you can’t assume that everyone involved will know how to move from concept to delivery. By using what motivational scientists call if-then planning...

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

To What Extent Does Donne Present the Lovers as Equal in "To His Mistress Going to Bed"?

...To what extent does Donne present the lovers as equal in “To His Mistress Going To Bed”? According to the Platonic formulation, beauty is ranked in several stages where we begin by being attracted to a single beautiful person, then beautiful minds, on to beautiful ideas, and finally, to beauty itself. In the poem, it appears that the narrator is stuck on the first rung. He is simply blinded by his mistress’ beauty; unable to describe anything other than her appearance and subsequently treats her as an object as opposed to an intelligent being. Unlike much of Donne’s other poetry which tends to prefer pure and platonic love as opposed to lust, making this poem unusual amongst his other works. This may seem to establish the narrator as subjectively superior and thus the lovers unequal. However on closer analysis this may be found not to be the case as the poem points to the mistress having an unassuming power over the narrator. The woman’s role is established even before the poem begins as Donne describes her as “His Mistress”. The use of the possessive “His” implies ownership and foreshadows the domination that the narrator will lord over her throughout the poem. The term “mistress”, because it is not clearly defined who the woman is in relation to Donne, forces readers to make assumptions about the connotations behind the word and how it reflects upon the unknown woman. To a contemporary audience the word would most likely be interpreted as her having a sexual role in the play...

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

“the Ontological Argument Does Not Succeed in Going Beyond Defining God” to What Extent Is This True?

...“The ontological argument does not succeed in going beyond defining God” to what extent is this true? The ontological argument, originally proposed by Anselm in his book ‘The Proslogion’ and later adapted by philosophers such as Alvin Plantinga and Descartes, defines God as “a being that which nothing greater can be conceived”. In my opinion the argument does not only fail to go beyond this definition, but we cannot be sure than it defines God correctly either. Firstly we cannot argue that the argument goes beyond the definition of God because as Kant points out the argument has a major flaw, the ontological argument is based on an assumption that to exist is a property of perfection. He uses the analogy of money saying that 100___ that existed in reality were no different in value to 100___ that existed hypothetically as both, in theory were worth the same and therefore equal. Bertrand Russell makes a similar point, he claims that the ontological argument uses the word ‘exists’ incorrectly and that existence is not a property of things, but of the idea of those things. Russell uses the example of dragons, saying that if someone says a dragon does not exist what they mean is of all the things that exist the word dragon refers to none of them, however this fact is not part of the definition itself and changes nothing about the description of the features of a dragon, therefore existence is an extension of an intention and not a definition. Alvin Plantinga attempts to redeem...

Words: 429 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Candy Land: What Happens When Children Lack Subconscious Maps of the Real World as Seen in Oates’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?”

...Kaitlyn Ray Mrs. Jennifer Burkett Pittman Composition II 12 February 2014 Candy Land: What Happens When Children Lack Subconscious Maps of the Real World as Seen in Oates’ “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” Researchers have said for years that reading is good for you. It encourages the thought process and can relays methods of working through situations one has never encountered before; that reading is the difference between a smart well-prepared child and one set in stone for failure. This resonance is similar to that of Gretchen Schulz’s and R.J.R. Rockwood’s belief asserted in “In Fairyland, Without a Map: Connie’s Exploration Inward in Joyce Carol Oates’ ‘Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?’” that, “The society depicted in ‘Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?’ has failed to make available to children like Connie maps of the unconscious such as fairy tales provide, because it has failed to recognize that in the unconscious, past and future coalesce, and that, psychologically, where the child is going is where he or she has already been” (1453). The point Schulz and Rockwood are making is that Connie’s generation and many following it, are neglecting to read fairy tales as bedtime stories and are consequently inhibiting the child’s ability to experience and work through problems he will encounter...

Words: 1306 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Health Promotion Program Tool

...To reduce the number of teenagers developing respiratory infections within 2 years Key Messages (to be delivered) Stop smoking Importance of hand washing Need for Influenza and Pneumococcal immunisations Target Group Teenage males and females Time of activity March / April Name of the Health Promotion activity Objective One Obtain and disseminate appropriate educational tools regarding respiratory infections Strategies How to achieve objective one Actions Tasks to do Resources required Who will do it? What is needed? Cost? Time frame When will be done? Evaluation How is it going? What will be measured? Participant feedback? 1. Provide appropriate educational and promotional material Discuss suitable strategies and tools with local teenagers recently affected with respiratory problems Contact Respiratory Council of Australia re assistance in provision of educational tools Discuss options Record responses 1 week How is it going? What will be measured? Participant feedback? Provision...

Words: 891 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Battle Is for Your Future

...began to talk about his dreams, once he began to talk about his future, their hatred for him increased and they began to question him by asking him “Shalt you indeed reign over us? Shall you indeed have dominion over us?” Josephs brothers were not so concerned about who he was, as a seventeen year old dreamer. Their concern was over who he was going to become. They were not afraid of his present, they were afraid of his future. And they wanted to stop him from becoming who God said he would become and going where God said he would go. They wanted to stop him from entering into his destiny. If there is anything Satan desires to do today it is to keep you from entering into your destiny. He wants to keep you from your future! Satan does not care if you live in your past. It is not even your present that is Satan’s greatest fear, it is your future. He does not want you to have what God said you would have, do what God said you would do, go where God said you would go and become who God said you would become. He wants to keep you from your destiny. He wants to stop you from your future. Everything that the Body of Christ is going through, everything that...

Words: 4351 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

How to Be a Good Manager

...ASIGNMENT REPORT How to be a good manager Student Sunny 05/01/2013 I’ve known that good managers’ attributes that are useful are that they are always on top of what happens in the office. They make sure that the whole office runs efficiently by keeping an organized office. It is very important to be organized and to love what you do in order to make sure that the office is taken care of to the best of their ability. That is a reason why I’m interested in how to be a good manager. Firstly, a manager needs thirty skills to be successed: Communication, Listening skills, commitment for a truth, empathy, persuasion, leadership, focus, division of work, obstacle removal, heat absorption, uncertainty removal, project management, and administrative and Financial Skills. Communication, listening skills, and commitment for a truth are the most significant for a manager. Now, I would like to focus on communication first. There’s a lot of communication when you’re a manager. You have to communicate with each of your employees. You have to communicate “sideways” with your co-workers and customers. And you have to communicate upwards with your own manager or executive. You need some substance in the communication, of course — you need to have something worthy of being communicated. But substance isn’t enough — if you know what you’re doing and can’t properly communicate it to anyone else, then you’ll never be a good manager. Secondly is listening skills. This is a part of communication...

Words: 1273 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Comunication and Crisis Paper Week 5 Hcs 320

...different kinds of communications methods that can be used for a certain matter at the time with a difficult situation that is going on that very moment. Another thing also to is an communication method can be very effective without any type of creating a panic attack about things that are on the radio station and the social media along with the television stations that is dealing with the emergency management office that is getting information about a certain report in the town of the areas That might have life threatening matter at the time. The main purpose of my paper will be covering the contingency plans with many organization and the public as well also to without trying to creating a panic attack with the community also you find in my paper how all groups and individuals are communicating with one another outside of the organization crisis and the potential advantages along with the challenges inside of the public eye of the crisis matter or situations at the time in a certain place or town that can improve a lot more of better communication skills. In the healthcare field today that could be more incorporate when using all of these different types of technology inside of the media crisis that is going on at the moment in the spotlight. While a certain crisis is going or a situation at the time then the emergency management o0ffice is going to be communicating with one another inside of the office and also outside of the organization as well. When dealing with and...

Words: 1605 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Negotation

...since you haven’t read your email I want to try to nip this in the bud and explain what this email is about. She’s accusing me of sexual harassment. What had happened, let me just give you some back history first. First of all, my wife and I are having marital problems and during that time we separated and Abby and I, because we have seen each other, because we have liked each other decided, let’s see what can happen. B: How long ago was this? R: This was 6 months ago. Last 2 weeks it has really become stressed and that’s why production is down. And I know that you know these numbers. But the problem being is that she is fighting everything. She doesn’t want to work with me, she doesn’t want to give me a hand with anything, and I’m managing it all on my own. And then she’s threatening me. Now this is in response to another email that I sent her, which she refers to in there. Now here is that email, and let me explain. Right now I’m just saying if you don’t want to get back together with me, and I had wrote her an email saying why don’t we get back together. Well she didn’t respond positively so I said fine, if you’re uncomfortable on our team, I’ll do everything that I can to help facilitate you moving to a different group. I wanted to help her, I wanted to solve this problem and instead she’s writing me these threatening things like you need to change departments, I’m going to sue you, I’m going to sue the company and take everybody down. B: Ok well whether anybody sues anybody...

Words: 6452 - Pages: 26