Free Essay

Beatrice, Much Ado About Nothing

In: English and Literature

Submitted By wendycbee
Words 1365
Pages 6
Beatrice is a strong-willed, independent woman. How far do you agree with this statement?
I would agree for the most part with this statement. Beatrice is indeed strong-willed, but her independence has its limitations. As with many Shakespearean characters, appearance can be deceptive, and what we see is only a facade, a mask to hide their true character or feelings. I believe that Beatrice uses her cleverness and quick wit to hide her real feelings, and that although she is independent to a certain extent, she is aware that she has limitations because of her gender. Although Beatrice states ‘I would rather hear my dog bark at a crow than hear a man swear he loves me’ she is ultimately fooled into believing that Benedick loves her. The fact that she is tricked so easily, and subsequently admits her reciprocal love, tells us that she views marriage in a more favourable light than she had previously led us to believe. Whether she gave in to the ‘social construct’ demanded by the patriarchal society in which she lived is questionable. What we do know is that Shakespeare has presented her as a wilful, self-confident, autonomous woman who appears to revel in her single status. In contrast we have Hero, the antithesis of Beatrice. She is meek, obedient and completely dominated by the men in her life. She is the perfect foil for Beatrice, her willingness to please further enhancing Beatrice’s character.
It is clear from the start of the play that Beatrice is not an ‘acceptable version of the feminine’. She is strong-willed, and full of confidence, even to the point of interrupting a male conversation. Her mocking comment: ‘I pray you, is Signior Mountanto returned from the wars, or no?’ is the first thing she says in the play and gives us an immediate insight into her character. This play on words refers to Montanto, an upright thrust used in fencing, and this comment directed towards Benedick indicates her lack of faith in his swordsmanship. The fact that nobody berates her for it gives us an insight into just how accepted she is in spite of the male characteristics that she displays. She believes herself equal to men, at least on an intellectual level, and argues with Benedick despite his status. The ‘merry war’ between the two of them showcases Beatrice’s quick wit and self-assurance. She seems happy to stay single, and even appears to wish that Hero could be free from patriarchal repression. Although everyone else in the play is united in arranging the marriage of Hero, Beatrice urges Hero to please herself rather than her father:
... let him be a handsome fellow, or else make another curtsy and say, ‘Father, as it please me’

This comment indicates her belief that women should have the power to take their lives into their own hands, to be independent as she herself is, and not succumb to the ‘unequal power relations’ between men and women. She is strong-willed enough to openly compel Hero thus, even though Hero’s father is present.
In contrast to Beatrice, Hero is happy to conform to the ‘gender role’ expected of her. Hero is a main character in the play, integral to the plot, yet she has very few lines. Almost all of her actions are as a result of male influence, whereas Beatrice is influenced by men in no way. Her uncle’s comment ‘well, niece I trust you will be ruled by your father’ refers to important decisions like finding a husband. This appears to be Hero’s only purpose in life, regardless of her own feelings, while Beatrice is staunchly independent. Even when she does succumb to the idea of marriage, it is on her own terms. Hero has feelings for Claudio, yet she agrees to a match with Don Pedro, and she even goes as far as feigning her own death in order to win back Claudio after he rejects her at the altar. Her ultimate role in the play is to be married, and she goes through hell to get there. Even her own father would rather she were dead than bring shame upon him by jeopardising her chance at marriage. His comment:
‘Do not live, Hero, do not ope thine eyes’ when she faints after being falsely accused of being a ‘wanton’ is a shocking testament to his eagerness to ensure that his daughter is married off. Hero’s obedience and meek attitude proves to be almost her undoing.
Contrastingly, Beatrice’s confidence and forthright manner, coupled with her quick tongue, provide entertainment for the audience, and those around her. Don Pedro is so impressed by her that he says ‘Lady Beatrice, I will get you one’ after Beatrice is talking about the fact that she will not have a husband. Don Pedro also proposed marriage to her. Beatrice, who ‘cannot endure to hear tell of a husband’, rejects his proposal. I don’t believe that she does this to maintain her single independent status, or because she does not like Don Pedro. Her heart lies elsewhere, having been won by Benedick ‘with false dice’. This proves that although she still has feelings for Benedick, her wilfulness and need for independence do not allow her to act on it.
Beatrice does not conform to the social expectation in the play of finding a good husband, and rails against it on more than one occasion. She is indulged by those around her, especially her uncle, although he still hopes to see her ‘one day fitted with a husband’. He despairs of her ‘shrewd’ tongue, and reminds her that it won’t get her a husband. Beatrice is more than happy to be without, and says so frequently. I believe that her protestations are a front for her unhappiness regarding her previous relationship with Benedick that she alludes to with her comment: ‘You always end with a jade’s trick: I know you of old’.
When she realises that her character could prevent her from finding true love, her question ‘Stand I condemn’d for pride and scorn so much?’ shows how horrified she is that her attitude might cost her the love of Benedick. Her apparent scorn and ‘disdain’ presented throughout the play is, I believe, an act. It is a defence mechanism used to cover the fact that she has been hurt by Benedick in the past, and suggests that her will is strong enough so that she would rather be alone than give up her independence to the man who broke her heart.
Beatrice ultimately realises that her independence will only get her so far. When Hero is publicly humiliated at the altar, Beatrice wants revenge, and looks to Benedick to exact it. Her command ‘Kill Claudio’ said with such vehemence reveals just how strong-willed she is, but it also reveals that she is limited in what she can do because of her gender. Her comment: ‘O that I were a man’ tells us that she is aware of her limitations, and when she repeats the comment during her conversation with Benedick it serves to underline her feelings of inadequacy, as a woman she cannot avenge Hero’s undoing, she cannot ‘eat his heart in the market-place.’ This is a very masculine comment to make, in keeping with Beatrice’s character. The fact that she is unable to carry out this act does not detract from her strength of character. Beatrice is undeniably strong-willed, and because she is such an interesting and likeable character, her forceful nature is overlooked by those around her. Her independence is not given a strongly negative connotation; in fact it is Hero’s dependence that is not shown in a flattering light – notwithstanding her ultimate marriage, she has to go through a lot of heartache before it happens. Beatrice also gets married, but only to save Benedick from ‘a consumption’ as she jokingly puts it. The fact that everything she does is on her own terms promotes self-assertiveness in women, instead of encouraging the more traditional behaviour of Hero. 1334 words Bibliography: www.sparknotes.com www.onlineliterature.com www.shakespeareonline.com

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Much Ado About Nothing (1993) directed by Kenneth Branagh

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Much Ado About Nothing Beatrice Foil

...Have you ever dreamed of reading a thrilling book about awesome characters and a devious plan involving death? Then “Much Ado About Nothing” by Shakespeare is the perfect book for you. In the enthralling play, there contain multiple couples. One is based solely on looks, one denies their love for each other, and one simply got together for the sake of a devious scheme. It also involves a plot that a kind character look scandalous, when really, they’re not. It’s a great story about love, evil, and forgiveness. In the play “Much Ado About Nothing” by William Shakespeare, Beatrice and Hero are foils of each other because of their interactions with others, how others feel about them, and their personality traits. Beatrice and Hero are major character foils in the play “Much Ado About Nothing” because of their...

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hero And Beatrice In Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

...smooth.” The novel “Much Ado About Nothing” by Shakespeare is about two people, Claudio and Hero, who meet and end up falling in love, and eventually decide to get married. At their wedding, Claudio found something out and shamed Hero about it, which ended up killing her. There was also another couple that were in love, Benedick and Beatrice, they never got along until they realized that they were falling in love with each other and eventually express how they feel about each other. In “Much Ado About Nothing” by William Shakespeare, Beatrice is a foil to Hero, because of their different views on love, their actions, and their thoughts. Beatrice and Hero have completely different...

Words: 773 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Theme Of Deception In Much Ado About Nothing

...“Much Ado About Nothing” is a comical play centered around scandals, love, and witty jokes. The antagonist of the play, Don John, schemes to make other characters suffer because of his on mishaps of being a bastard. As for the other characters, they play matchmaker to create happy relationships.Although “Much Ado About Nothing is depicted as a comical play, aspects of star-crossed lovers and deception  reveal relevance to the moral of the story. In “Much Ado About Nothing,” deception, with the inherently evil connotation, reveals to have both negative and positive outcomes. Don Pedro disguises as Claudio in Act I  and confesses his love to Hero at the mask ball because he feels that the two would make a perfect couple. Don John decides to...

Words: 511 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Much Ado About Nothimg

...characters in “Much Ado About Nothing” are the victims of deception, and because they’ve been deceived is the reason they act in the ways that they do. Even though the central deception is directed against Claudio in an attempt to destroy his relationship with Hero, it is the deception pertaining to Beatrice and Benedick which is the play's main focus. Almost every character in the play at some point has to make interpretations from what he or she sees, has been told or overheard. At the same time, nearly every character in the play at some point plays a part of consciously pretending to be what they are not. (Act I, Scene I) ”Thou wilt be like a lover presently and tire the hearer with a book of words. If thou dost love fair Hero, cherish it, and I will break with her and with her father, and thou shalt have her. Was't not to this end That thou began'st to twist so fine a story?” Here is when Don Pedro tries to put a spin on words making it sound like if Claudio really wants to be with Hero, they should first trick her into believing that Don Pedro is actually Claudio. They go on forward with the idea and as Don Pedro is swooning Hero with his words and charm at the masked ball and Claudio is actually eavesdropping near-by trying to make sure everything is going according to plan. Deception is one of the focal themes throughout the play which grows out of the love game. Deceit is not evil in nature; it can be used for the purpose good or bad outcomes. “In Much Ado......

Words: 560 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Major Themes in 'Much Ado About Nothing'

...Major Themes in 'Much Ado About Nothing' Shakespeare’s treatment of love in Much Ado About Nothing differs from his other romantic comedies. Sure, it shares the same stagy plot, which finishes with the lovers finally getting back together, but Shakespeare also mocks the conventions of courtly love which was popular at the time. Although Claudio and Hero’s courtly marriage is central to the plot, their relationship is the least interesting thing in the play. Instead, our attention is drawn to Benedick and Beatrice’s unromantic backbiting – it is this relationship that seems more believable and enduring. By contrasting these two different types of love, Shakespeare manages to poke fun at the conventions of courtly, romantic love. Claudio uses highly contrived language when speaking of love, which is undermined by Benedick and Beatrice’s banter: “Can the world buy such a Jewel?” says Claudio of Hero. “My dear Lady disdain! Are you yet living?” says Benedick of Beatrice. As an audience, we are supposed to share Benedick’s frustration with Claudio’s transparent, pompous rhetoric of love: “He was wont to speak plain and to the purpose, like an honest man and a soldier … His words are a very fantastical banquet, just so many strange dishes.” Deception As the title suggests, there is a lot of fuss over very little in the play – after all, if Claudio wasn’t so impetuous, Don John’s rather weak plan wouldn’t have worked at all! What makes the plot so intricate is the use of......

Words: 491 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Goooooo

...How far does the humour in Much Ado About Nothing derive from Shakespeare’s presentation of gender? Much ado about nothing is one of the most famous comedies written by Shakespeare. It is written in the modern style, and is mainly in prose form. It was written for the audience in the Elizabethan era of England, which was the age when females were considered significantly inferior to their male counterparts. Shakespeare has used this concept of gender for creating humour in his play. The characters Benedict and Beatrice are involved in a complex relationship which contrasts between love and hate. Both Beatrice and Benedict are strong willed, intelligent characters, who fear that falling in love will lead to a loss of freedom and eventually heartbreak. Various theories have been proposed which govern humour and comedy. The superiority theory proposed by Plato describes the darker side of comedy that Is often laughed at over unfortunate situations and social standings. Infirmity in others as compared to our own is often laughed at. These same principles has been applied to the story of the play, and the inferiority of females has been used as the basis for creating humour. [quick quote & example to back this up?] The characters Shakespeare's “Much Ado about Nothing” contribute to build the humorous essence of play through their roles. Several characters of the play presented comical language and gestures such as Benedick and Beatrice’s unromantic......

Words: 1851 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Much Ado About Nothing Love Analysis

...MAAN: Love, what is it good for? Merriam-Webster dictionary defines love as “strong affection for another arising out of kinship or personal ties;” Throughout the play, Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare, there is never really a love connection between the characters Benedick and Beatrice. In the beginning of the play, they despise one another and made witty comments about one another; not only that, but they also question why the other one loved them after overhearing the conversation between their friends. By this definition Beatrice and Benedick can't truly be in love, because of words spoken by their friends. At the start of the play, when Benedick first arrived in Messina, the first thing they did was make witty comments about...

Words: 539 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Much Ado About Nothing Benedick Analysis

...In William Shakespeare’s comedy, Much Ado About Nothing, he uses the dialogue to show the transition of Benedick and his feelings toward Beatrice and marriage in general. Shakespeare uses the dialogue to show the reader the progression of Benedick’s outlooks on life go from hating Beatrice and the whole idea of marriage to then loving Beatrice and asking her to marry him. This kind of transition is very large and it can only be down by a great writer, such as William Shakespeare. Throughout the whole story Benedick shows very strong feelings toward both marriage and Beatrice, both good and bad, but in the end his true feelings are shown. In the very beginning of the book, after the war ended, Benedick and his fellow soldiers stay at a friend of Don Pedro’s house named Leonato. Leonato’s niece is named Beatrice, whom has a strong dislike of Benedick and vice versa. Benedick dislikes her so much that he states, “I will fetch you a toothpick from the furthest inch of Asia . . . do you any embassage to the pigmies, rather than hold three words’ conference...

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Deception In William Shakespeare's Much Ado About Nothing

...William Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing emphasizes the subject of deception through the use of language, but the 2013 film adaptation of the play directed by Joss Whedon emphasizes the actions that go along with the words, making the film a superior representation of deception. The concept of deceit starts getting momentum in the scene of the masquerade, where all the characters are masked, so nobody knows who is who. Benedick and Beatrice are dancing together and making small talk, but before Beatrice will confess anything to Benedick, she wants to know who he is. She politely asks “Nor will you not tell me who you are?” to which he replies “Not now”, implying that he will eventually tell her who he is (Much Ado.II.I.125-126). He is deceiving her through his words first by not telling her who he is, and because he is masked, she can not identify him, so...

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Much Ado About Nothing

...Christine Joy A. Tag at BSEDE-II Reflection Paper on Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing Without any idea of what Much Ado About Nothing is all about, I just let myself absorb whatever thoughts and ideas I could get as the movie started to play. The movie which is originally a play written by Shakespeare is a comedy drama but not pure humor as what most audience would expect in a comedy. I really find the work a genius one, with how the story evolves. And unlike any love stories, its plot is a very unique one. The theme is obviously full of deceptions. This act of deceiving is not at all what I know as a bad act. As from the drama, deception could sometimes lead the characters to goodness like how Don Pedro and Claudio intentionally let Benedict eavesdrop to their conversation about Beatrice’s love for him. Hero and her company also did the same to Beatrice. It ended up that Beatrice and Benedict really loved each other after all their ‘wars’. On the other hand, deception could be a bad act. When Don John planned to ruin the wedding by making Claudio and Don Pedro believe that ‘Hero’ is an unfaithful maiden and not anymore a virgin, the plan went out as it is which made Hero be publicly humiliated by Claudio. This only showed that purity of woman is very precious and the only honor that she could have. But whether deception is bad or good, I would first prefer not to believe easily what I hear or see or what others will tell to me. I must not depend on the......

Words: 416 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Much Ado About Nothing: a Love Story

...Shakespeare My first impression of Much Ado About Nothing is that it would be a love story. Although it is categorised as a Shakespearean comedy, I found the many "funny" parts of the play were foggy and required you to read the scene over a few times before you understood them. But then again, I had to read the whole scene over again a few times to understand anything. All of the characters in Much Ado About Nothing seemed to develop a personality of their own from the very first scene. It also helped that I saw the movie version of Much Ado About Nothing before we read the play so I could almost get a picture in my head as to what each character looked like. As the character's had their own personality, so did the two love relationships in the play. Benedick and Beatrice seemed to hate each other so much from the very start of the play that as the play carried on it almost seemed like the two went full circle in their relationship. But their relationship might not have changed for the better without help from Claudio, Don Pedro, Leonato, Ursula or Hero. In Claudio's and Hero's relationship seemed to be much more conventional in the way they came together. Claudio first saw Hero and instantly fell in love with her, while Hero stood by and took orders from her father, Leonato. Only when Don John devised his deception to break Claudio and Hero apart that I felt the relationship was in trouble, but even then I felt there was hope. In Act...

Words: 373 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

What Atmosphere Does Kenneth Branagh Create at the Start of His Film Version of Much Ado About Nothing and Where in the Play Is the Source of His Ideas?

...Essay: What atmosphere does Kenneth Branagh create at the start of his film version of much ado about nothing and where in the play is the source of his ideas? In the act 1 of the scene 1 of much ado about nothing by William Shakespeare, a messenger arrives in the Italian town of Messina, with a letter that informs the kindly Leonato that he will welcome to Messina some soldier friends who are coming from a victorious battle. These friends are Don Pedro of Aragon, a nobleman, and Claudio, a warrior. Hero, Leonato’s daughter and Beatrice, her cousin, accompany him. Beatrice and another soldier of Don Pedro’s army, Signor Benedick, are in a “merry war” but they never saw each other. Beatrice cleverly mocks and insults Benedick. There are no stage directions so this leaves the stage director lot of freedom to achieve the adaptation. The opening of the film version isn’t the same as the book version; the film starts with a poem recited by Beatrice, but Shakespeare original version starts directly with the messenger that arrives. Firstly, in the film adaptation of much ado about nothing by William Shakespeare, at the beginning, Kenneth Branagh creates conviviality and a merry atmosphere that isn’t really described in the play thanks to: - The landscape and the climate, the bright light of the sun. They live in Messina, in Sicily, and Sicily is known for the hot climate. After the poem of Beatrice, at the beginning, we see a painting of Messina; it shows that Messina is......

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Much Ado About Nothing Love Stor

...Much Ado About Nothing Love Story Shakespeare My first impression of Much Ado About Nothing is that it would be a love story. Although it is categorised as a Shakespearean comedy, I found the many "funny" parts of the play were foggy and required you to read the scene over a few times before you understood them. But then again, I had to read the whole scene over again a few times to understand anything. All of the characters in Much Ado About Nothing seemed to develop a personality of their own from the very first scene. It also helped that I saw the movie version of Much Ado About Nothing before we read the play so I could almost get a picture in my head as to what each character looked like. As the character's had their own personality, so did the two love relationships in the play. Benedick and Beatrice seemed to hate each other so much from the very start of the play that as the play carried on it almost seemed like the two went full circle in their relationship. But their relationship might not have changed for the better without help from Claudio, Don Pedro, Leonato, Ursula or Hero. In Claudio's and Hero's relationship seemed to be much more conventional in the way they came together. Claudio first saw Hero and instantly fell in love with her, while Hero stood by and took orders from her father, Leonato. Only when Don John devised his deception to break Claudio and Hero apart that I felt the relationship was in trouble, but......

Words: 379 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

How Is Benedick Presented In Much Ado About Nothing

...“You’ve stained your virtue with your own actions. What man were you talking to at your window last night, between the hours of midnight and one?” (Shakespeare 157) In Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare, a man named Claudio falls in love with the governor's daughter named Hero. Don John Convinces Claudio that she was unfaithful, so Claudio accused her at the wedding. Afterwards, Claudio falls in love with her again while Benedick and Beatrice fell in love with each other. In Much ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare, Claudio serves as the foil character of Benedick by which Claudio’s gullible ways are illuminated through Benedick’s intelligence; thus partially influences the climax. Claudio and Benedick contradict each other because Claudio is Charming, as Benedick is disagreeable. In act I, scene I of Much Ado About Nothing, Claudio pulls Benedick aside to find out whether he found Hero pleasant. Benedick says that she is pretty enough for him. Claudio believes that Hero is the prettiest girl in Messina, but Benedick doesn’t agree with Claudio....

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Gender Collisions in Much Ado About Nothing

...Gender Collisions in Much Ado about Nothing Some of Shakespeare’s plays are related to the love between male and female, such as, Romeo and Juliet, Twelfth Night, Much Ado about Nothing and etc. Shakespeare’s focuses in these plays varied from different periods in his life. I’m going to analyze the gender collisions in the following couples in Much Ado about Nothing: Hero and her father Signor Leonato, Hero and Claudio, Benedick and Beatrice. I. Hero and her father Signor Leonato Hero and Leonato’s relationship is the typical father-daughter relationship in the feudal patriarchy. Signor Leonato, the father, is an arbitrary male chauvinist, loves his daughter superficially but never truly care about Hero. Hero, like most women in that time, follows everything what her father says. Obedience is rooted in her life. Marriage and obedience are the only two things she could use to please her father. As a “useless” girl in feudal society, Hero accepts her fate. All these factors result in the chaos in wedding. When Claudio doubted Hero’S chastity and dishonored Hero, Leonato’S first response is feeling humiliated for himself, worrying about his reputation and wanting to kill his daughter to save his fame. Hero just cried and even cried to faint. The only thing she could do is sitting, crying and saying “no”. She never thought stand up, and tell her father Claudio bravely “No! You are wrong! I am innocent!” The arbitrary and arrogant father and the coward daughter are still......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3