Free Essay

Comparitive Myth

In: English and Literature

Submitted By bernardg3
Words 847
Pages 4
Ladies and gentlemen please join me to on a journey to a realm filled with fantasy, lore, adventure and mayhem. Lend me your ear as we unravel the mythical inspirations behind one of the greatest, epic movie trilogies of all time: The Lord of the Rings! We learned in our first lesson together that studying myths introduces other cultures to us and provides us with different perspectives through which to view our own (Myth & Knowing, page 2). The Lord of the Rings trilogy truly introduced us to culture of a mythical proportions and allowed us to perhaps see our own world's history in a different light. Let us begin with a quote from the author J.R.R. Tolkein, "All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us" (Tolkien, page 3). So let's make the best of it shall we! As a professor at Oxford, Tolkien, while grading papers, one of the students left this phrase on a blank page of his answer book. "In a hole in the ground there lives a hobbit (Tolkien Society, 2002.)" Curiosity got the best of Tolkien as he set out to discover what a hobbit was. Answers to his discoveries were revealed in stories he told his children, stories he embellished and those stories manifested themselves into the book called the Hobbit and eventually The Lord of Rings. The Lord of the Rings stories were inspired by many myths but none more prevalent than the Germanic poem called Beowulf. Tolkien explained to his editors that "Beowulf is among my most valued sources (Colbert page 21). Many similarities exist between Beowulf and the Lord of the Rings. For example, the hellish Orcs in the LOTR come from orcneas. This word was also used for monsters in Beowulf (Colbert page 22). Another example is the setting. LOTR displays large mead halls, where "Tolkien expert Thomas Shippey notes, the Elf Legolas (one of my favorite characters, I might add) describes Meduseld (the Golden Hall) with the same line that describes the mead hall in Beowulf: "The light of it shines far over the land (Tolkein,The Lord of the Rings. page 496)". Also, in Beowulf and LOTR they share the same themes. The heroes in both, must fight the urge to turn into the very evil that they fight. This very theme is present today in the various conflicts throughout our world today. The challenges of our mythical heroes is not unfamiliar to many of our world leaders today. Next, we shall discuss some of the myths that inspired Tolkien to develop some of the characters in LOTR. We shall start with the ugly first. The Orcs. Some of you might have been considering the Dwarfs as ugly, but Gimli's bravery and loyalty improves his lot. The name Orcs come from the Roman god Orcus. He was the god of the underworld. Orcus is also the Latin word for Hell. Since many of the Orcs hang out in a fiery, underground hell this name fits perfectly (Colbert page 130). Now that we know where the handsome Orcs name came from, let's talk about their creator, Sauron aka a big meanie as my daughter calls him. The all mighty chief Norse god Odin himself was an inspiration to Tolkien for the all evil Sauron. "...the story of how Odin loses one eye may be the most important, because it reveals the source of his power." Odin lost his eye in return for the "world's knowledge". "Afterwards Odin often appears as an old man with a single blazing eye (Colbert page 126). When you think of Gandalf, do you think of Merlin the Wizard? I did. However, I am your enlightened lecturer and I am going to share my newfound knowledge with you. Once more we find Norse mythology influencing Tolkien. Odin, who was the inspiration for evil Sauron is also the inspiration for the noble, wizened Gandalf. They are not exactly paired at the hip but they do share similar qualities. Colbert explains, "Odin is depicted as a long-bearded old man, often with a walking stick. He has supernatural power. Like Gandalf, he seems to be wondering alone on a quest that others cannot understand Magic World, In conclusion, we have learned of the many things that have inspired Tolkien to create and develop his famous Lord of the Rings Trilogy. Particularly how myth from days of old has influenced the manifestation of a masterpiece. I hope that you are now more sensitive to the background of the story the next time you watch these classics on film. Works Cited Colbert, David "The Magical Worlds of The Lord of the Rings." 2002: pages 21,22,30,53,103,126. 3 Oct. 2012
"J.R.R. Tolkien: A Biographical Sketch." The Tolkien Society. 2002. Web. 14 Oct. 2012
Tolkien, J.R.R. (John Ronald Reul) "The Fellowship of the Ring" 1954: pages 3, 496. 3 Oct. 2012

Leonard, Scott and McClure. Myth & Knowing: An Introduction to World Mythology. McGraw-Hill, 2004. page 2. Print.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Theories of Myth

...language as cosmogony, the diverse myth of creation varies drastically among many areas of the earth and during numerous periods throughout history (Leonard & McClure, 2004). The telling of such myths and stories gives insight to the culture and behavior of many societies. This information becomes religion for some and yet a way to pass down the history, heritage, and tradition of a civilization to another. The most common way to dissect and question a myth uses tools that would identify the nature of the story and outline the origin. The many distinct views in use to theorize and question mythoi are commonly the social, the psychological, the literary, the structural, and the political form of the myth. The areas in which to question commonly reference back to a toolkit that when brought into use in examination of a myth, the analysis is simple and questions cover many concerns. The debate of whether a myth is a story of imagination or holds any fact depends on if it comes from “a tale told by idiots,” or rather “sages, religious fundamentalists and agnostic theologians, idealists and cynics, racists and fascists,” or “philosophers and scholars” (Leonard & McClure, 2004, p. 5). Choosing to use social, psychological, and structural for the theoretical methods of inspection to breakdown and question the narrations of various myths of creation will show the function in their respective societies and cultures. The social aspect questions how the myth affects a group of......

Words: 1005 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Aboriginal Spirituality Sacred Scriptures

...Taylor 1 Taylor Aboriginal Spirituality Sacred Scriptures First Nation religions involve different aspects of social and cultural myths and stories. The stories and myths that the First Nation peoples are not generally written down, and so have been passed on by word of mouth to others in the particular group of Natives. Stories and myths that have been passed on through the generations include of different creation stories, and trickster myths. Creation stories are very important to the First Nation peoples, as they tell the story of how the Earth and they were made. The First Nation peoples have a total of eight creation stories - to which they all do not necessarily mention a God, or a higher power than our own; but instead mention animals, and how we are all connected by life. The story usually included of animals and the four elements (water, earth, fire and air). Earth Diver, being the most traditionally told and known, within the Northern Plain and Eastern Woodland tribes, is the story “in which...the Great Spirit...dives or orders other animals to dive in the...water to bring up mud, out of which he fashions the earth” (Smith). Taylor 2 The trickster myths are generally told to be comedic, as that is somewhat what the myths are. They usually tell about how the transformer, though not always the transformer, would play around and “trick” people. These “tricks” would include of taking fire, water, food, light, animals, or even other people, and then setting...

Words: 472 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Noah and The Great Flood The Great Flood is a story that is questioned by some people, historians, and theologians. There always will be a question of whether this event really happened. If someone really believes that the messages in the Bible are real and they are coming from God, then that someone would believe that this event really happened. The messages in the Bible are lessons from God, he tries to teach us and tell us how to conduct our lives. This story is one of his lessons; he is trying to tell us something through this story. God uses Noah to reward humankind with his grace and mercy; he wanted to give humankind another chance to redeem themselves. With the story of the Great Flood, God recreates the world. God had to destroy humankind because of what they have turned into, evil and disobedient. God could see that humankind was lost in sin. They forgot all about him, he who created them. He did not like what his creation had turned into. God then made a decision to destroy and eliminate humankind from earth. Humankind made God regret the fact that he created them. But there was a good man, which God wanted to save, because he was good and faithful servant to him. Noah had an unbelievable faith in his Lord, so God trusted Noah. Noah was the man that God loved and cared for because Noah had shown his faith to him (Moore, 2005). Noah was the tenth in line from Adam, having descended from the line of Seth. He was the son of Lamech, as well as the......

Words: 2033 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

The Origin of Old-Earth Geology and Its Ramifications for Life in the 21st Century

...Ashley Dr. Travis Bradshaw PHSC 210 April 7, 2014 Journal Article Review Introduction In this paper I will discuss and review Dr. Terry Mortenson’s article about The Origin of Old-Earth Geology and its Ramifications for Life in the 21st Century. I will discuss the many strengths of this article and also the weaknesses that are also involved in Dr. Terry Mortenson’s paper. Brief Overview and Main Points Dr. Mortenson’s paper discussed the many different scientific views of how the Earth was created from the point of view of many different scientists such as scriptural geologists, uniformitarians and catastrophists. Each have their own views on the history of the Earth and how it was created. Dr. Mortenson then goes into explaining how these scientific theories have impacted our society today. Towards the end of the paper, we learn the author’s view of how the Earth was created and how it impacts society today. Article Strengths I think Dr. Mortenson did very well writing this article in many different ways. Everything appeared to be stated in a professional and grammatically correct way, with little to no errors. Dr. Mortenson also does a great job in describing each scientist according to their different theories such as scriptural geologists by providing just enough detail. He didn’t go overboard by boring the reader with too many facts about each scientists, but clearly stated the facts needed and their scientific views without straying from the main topic.......

Words: 819 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Week 2 Hum 105

...Comparison of Creation Myths Carin M. Valencia HUM / 105 February 11, 2013 Gerald Grudzen PhD. Comparison of Creation Myths In the Chinese creation myth of Yin and Yang, it is taught that in the beginning, before the existence heaven and earth there was nothing but chaos. It is this chaos that eventually gave birth to one God and one Goddess and they would create Heaven and Earth and come to be known as Yin and Yang. “Yin gathered into herself all that was dark and heavy. And, like a thick, plodding mass, Yin sank downward into the earth and became one with it. And earth became square.” (Rosenberg, 2006, p.345) “Yang gathered into himself all that was bright and light. And, like a mist, Yang drifted upward into Heaven and became one with it. And Heaven became round.” (Rosenberg, 2006, p.345) It is also said, that Yang’s breath became hot and made fire and the sun, while Yin’s was cool and created water and the moon. From these came celestial bodies as well as different bodies of water, settling with their creators in Heaven and on Earth. The sheer essence of the Goddess Yin and the God Yang become the four seasons and from that comes all that is in existence, plants, trees, insects, humans etc. In this myth we see the two become separate entities that together form all of existence. The celestial beings and water together help to create all living things upon the earth that has been created. We see no destruction caused by the previous chaos, but the opposite, it......

Words: 1379 - Pages: 6

Free Essay


...Comparative Religions Mr.Lydy September 5, 2014 The Earth’s Creation Myths….Similar or Different? When you look at all of the earth’s creation myths that have emerged throughout the different cultures/ religions, you will see that there are multiple myths as to how the earth was created. For example the myth of Phan Ku the creator which is a story of a space aged mythological creature who uses a chisel to carve earth; which is a major difference from the myth of Earth Starter the creator which is a story of a mythical being that created the world by using mud from earth. I feel that the earth’s creation myths are distinctly different based on the creation of the earth, the creation of mankind, and the relationship between the creator and its/ their creations. When looking at the creation of the earth, there are many factor that come into play to determine that the earth’s creation myths are different. While reading “In The Beginning” a book written by Virginia Hamilton, there were creation myths that was referenced one titled Phan Ku the creator, and the other tilted Earth Starter the creator. In the creation myth of Phan Ku, the earth was created by a being chiseled/carved out by Phan Ku. The creation of the earth that is displayed in the story of Phan Ku differs from the earth’s creation myth of Earth Starter the creator. The creation of earth in the myth of Earth Starter was displaying that the earths was created by taking mud from under some sort of river/ and or......

Words: 615 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Coogan Research

...Scholarly Journal Summary The “Journal for the Study of the Old Testament” had a very interesting topic that is discussed almost an unlimited amount of times in today’s society. The topic is sex, and how it is defined in Leviticus, with particular attention to Leviticus 18:6-23. This is due to the fact that in chapter 18 of Leviticus, it is formatted in such a way where it is laid out as law, or apodictic law. The author tries to deviate from just explaining what the scriptures mean in its context, but instead tries to use the contextual format from the chapters before and after chapter 18 to see what its true interpretation should lay on. Leviticus Chapter 18:6-23 is Lord God talking to Moses about the things that the Israelites shall not do. God speaks to Moses telling him to tell the people of Israel what he is telling him and no to do as others do. “You shall not do as they do in the Land of Egypt, where you lived, and you shall not do as they do in the land of Canaan, to which I am bringing you. You shall not follow their statutes” Leviticus 18:3. (Collins, Harper pg 177) Shortly after God states this to Moses, he describes multiple different ordinances of law dealing with Sexual Relations. A great deal of these ordinances deal with Incest Relationships, such as “None of you shall approach anyone near of kin to uncover nakedness” Leviticus 18:6. (Collins, Harper pg 177) Along with that verse there are multiple others deal with uncovering nakedness of your father,......

Words: 3540 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Creation Story

...A creation story or a creation myth can be defined as a symbolic narrative of how the world began and how humans adapted to it. Some creation stories, such as African creation stories existed for years. These stories has been told and passed down by many. With creation stories many people can interpret in many different ways. One of the most common creation stories that have been told was the creation of the world. In this paper I chose to write about The Planet of Life. I chose to write about this creation paper because the story itself is really interesting to me and this story reminds me of stories from the bible. This creation story, The Plant of Life, comes from a Nyamwezi story. The alternate name for Nyamwezi is Wanyamwezi. It is located in Unyamwezi. Tanzania’s national language is Kinyamwezi. The religion they believe in is spirituality shaped by traditional beliefs; Islam and Christianity. They have much respect for the living dead. The Nyamwezi people were called Wanyamwezi. They lived in East African country of Tanzaina. Their home area was called Unyamwezi, “the place of the Wanyamwezi”. As years passed the Nyamwezi culture has both influenced the cultures of neighnoring African societies as well as the national Tanzanian culture. Their religion has also had great impact on modern Nyamwezi customs. The Nyamwezi tribe “people of the moon” is the second largest in Tanzaina. The family lives together and the villages are not necessarily based on kinship......

Words: 801 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Creation

...Compare/Contrast ENG 099/011 Professor Ficarotta Patrick St. Fleur The Creation The creation of the world has been told in many ways and through the cultures has significant differences. The concept of creation that I’m most familiar with come from the bible, Genesis: Chapter 1-3. However during my recent studies on creation myths, I’ve learned many others. A common theory of the earth started is reflected in the bible and occurred within six days. Creation myths are beliefs and stories on the earliest beginnings of the world. Oral traditions throughout the different cultures are regarded as truth for the “creation” and served as the historical reference we know today. Common element s of creation myths begin with a birth, a supreme being, human and animals and instructions from the creator. Almost all cultures have at least if not all these elements in the creation myths but vary to some degree. Every revolving culture has developed creation myths centered on historical interpretation, factual events and cultural influence however the African Bushmen and the Egyptian’s are similar on morals however different in the creation. All creation myths consist of a supreme being of some kind or form. The being is not always represent but is importance is just as equal. The Greek and the Japanese show gods and goddesses, whereas the Aborigines had to supreme beings: Father of All Spirits and the Sun Mother.(Murtagh). The Japense also has two gods Izanagi and......

Words: 702 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

World Creators

...World Creators Creation myths are stories about the birth of our world and the people that inhabit it. Every culture has a myth or story on how the world was created and where civilization began. During ancient time creation myths and stories were their cosmological research. Creation myths reveal a lot about the thoughts of humans from the past and how they saw and understood the world during their time. Their minds were not that much different than ours, and the myths of the past teach us a lot about ourselves today. Even though it is not the oldest of the creation myths it is however one of the oldest that is documented. Enuma Elish or also known as the Babylonia creation story begins with the creation of the world with a battle for sovereignty between the Gods. According to the myth the Babylonian God Marduk defeats the gods of old that the neighboring culture inherited. When it comes to the actual creation of the world, which is my main interest in the epic, Enuma Elish has two separate accounts of it. The first one is in the beginning, where the waters of Tiamat and Apsu are joined, and the second one is when Marduk has killed Tiamat and uses her corpse to build the world (Stenudd, N.d.). Another myth that I found to be interesting was Xingo or The creation of man from Brazil, in this myth the world was already created but man was not. This myth begins with Mavutsinim, the primordial deity whom may or may have not created the world. The story of Mavutsinim is that he...

Words: 830 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Kristine Moore Dr. Mills American Literature I 26 April 2015 The One that Launched A Thousand Religions “خالق واحد صحيح” (For purposes of understanding I refer to the creators in each religion as a he. This research is not intended to argue the gender of a higher being.) Native Americans, Christians, Deists, Muslims, and many other cultures have similarities in the ways they view the dawn of man. Creation stories have dated back anywhere from thousands of years to millions, yet it cannot be decided which version tells the true beginning. Religions and tales of the supreme beings who created Earth and life, come down in manuscripts and drawings that depict each individual purpose of life. With the advancement of technology, war, and government, the reason for man’s existence has changed and therefor his purpose needs to be redefined. خالق واحد صحيح in Arabic means “the one true creator” who holds and gives all power and life. The God, Allah, or Sky-Holder’s power is taken away in order for man to make what he has created right and so begins the beginning of a thousand religions. When man first thought about how to expand his power he did so while looking at his kingdom. From ancient Greeks, Egyptians, and even men like Christopher Columbus, power has stemmed from the ownership of land masses and the conquering of unexplored terrain. The world is in the state it is now because it shows who has gained the most power, yet man has neglected to protect the one thing that......

Words: 3903 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Cosmic Creations

...perception of creation, that perception is told through the cultures myths. The two myths that will be discussed in this paper are Egyptian creation and Zulu creation. The paper will discuss how the different creations are characterized along with the legends and the components of those myths. Egyptian Creation Egyptian creation signifies earth, sky, dark and waters. They believed that in the beginning the only thing that existed was dark watery abyss of chaos that was called nun or nu. As the waters of the great Nile gave birth to life through the muddy Earth, Bebben came out of the num. Benben is a mound that is shaped like a pyramid. Once the pyramid emerged it was the first place where the sun rose for the first time and produced light. It was also said that the pyramid was the place where the first god, Atum stood. Atum was not male or female but he created life by using the female part in him to create Shu, which is the god of air and his sister Tefnut, which is the goddess of moisture and fertility. Some people believe that they were created by sneezing and spitting. Shu is the sound of sneezing and Tef is the sound of spitting. Tef and Shu had two children the Sky Goddess Nut and Earth God Geb. While Geb layed down to form the Earth Nut the Sky Goddess was forming the sky. Zulu Creation The Zulu culture myth is from South Africa, which is considered to be the biggest group in Africa. The Zulu creation myth signifies Earth, sun, moon as gods. They believe that......

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

AP Essay 'The Stranger'

...Marlon Straker Ms. Tobenkin AP Literature, Period 1 1 May 2016 The Stranger Essay While Meursault is walking down the beach, he is creating a tension that leads him to the killing of the Arab. By walking down the beach, he is using this to demonstrate his freedom and independence towards the Arabs and the readers. While he is walking down the beach, the Arabs are following him but they are not threatening or doing anything to harm him. But for safety reasons, Meursault decides to take a gun which he uses to kill one of the Arab. When Meursault shoots the Arab, Camus creates a tension that builds onto the climax of the story. “All I could feel were the cymbals of sunlight crashing on my forehead and, indistinctly, the dazzling spear...

Words: 486 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Bill Gates

...Contemporary Creation Myth Team B understood the concepts in this weeks reading and found the stories to be interesting. The stories most interesting are the sacrifice stories. The God Ymir was killed because the other Gods thought he was mean. When his lifeless body fell his body parts turned into different things such as seas, lakes, skies, trees, and mountains. T he belief of these stories actually teach that in order to have life there must be death. Other types of stories are the stories that consist of secretion of body fluids that create birth as in the accretion myths (Leonard & McClure, 2004, p. 34). Reminds us of the movie Gremlins and how they keep making new evil little monsters when they come in contact with water or eat after midnight. As long as these two things do not happen the gremlin stays sweet almost sacred furry animal. A concept is the emergence myths. These myths have people that travel through worlds until they emerge into one. A person could keep traveling until they become perfect and can continue the work of other Gods (Enotes, 2013). A person in this particular time could be a man that is successful in our world today, such as Bill Gates. A person as successful as Bill Gates is an icon and to some Godly for representing such things that are in the future. A modern day creator, Bill Gates was a technological innovation keen business strategy with aggressive gung ho tactics. He and his partner Paul Allen built the......

Words: 415 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Theories of Myth

...Theories of Myth University of Phoenix Theories of Myth Myths could have dissimilar meaning to society. A myth can portray a fairy-tale that is not true which could be precisely meant for entertainment to a narrator and whoever is listening to the story. A myth could portray a fairy-tale that maybe true. The stores told many years ago could have some false and true meaning. In order to comprehend the history of mythology, brilliant intellects capture dissimilar methods to understand the fairy-tales being read and determining to view if the stories were true, to view if the stories were false, to view if the stories of the imagination or if the stories were actually real thousands of years ago. An example of brilliant intellect is Sir William Jones who found legitimacy in the myths by investigating the dialect the stories were printed in. Sir William Jones was valued and respected as a young adult who spoke five languages and was considered a youthful genius in the 18th century. Sir William Jones assumed he could confirm the authenticity of the fairy-tales by using the dialect utilized many years ago. Sir William Jones traced the languages to one resource that all languages were developed from; this was called proto-indo-European that was a dialect presented as an idea. Sir Jones found a way to give legitimacy to his process, which others used and found that myths were vital and crucial windows into cultures......

Words: 877 - Pages: 4