Cost Benefit Analysis

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ucalgary
Words 3831
Pages 16
-------------------------------------------------
Cost Benefit Analysis [ECON 453]
-------------------------------------------------
Assignment II
Aditya Gurung

Dr. T.M. Horbulyk
April 2, 2012

1. Based on the article, describe as best you can:
(i) The reference group for the cost benefit analysis
Reference group for the cost benefit analysis (CBA) refers to the set of persons whose gains and losses are to be included as directly relevant to the project decision-making process. It is a sub set of people who will be benefited or affected by the implementation of the project. In the case of Bolu Mountain Tunnel project, the set of people who will directly benefit from the implementation of the project are the people who can now avoid traveling by Bolu Mountain Passage (D100 highway) as they can get to there destination by traveling through the tunnel in much safer conditions along with reduced travel time.
(ii) The purpose of the study
The purpose of any social CBA is to examine and assess whether or not the social benefits of the proposed policy or project outweigh its social cost. By doing so, it can assist decision-making by facilitating the allocation of resources to their most valuable application. In the case of given article, the purpose of the study is to conduct the CBA of the Bolu Mountain Tunnel Project and examine if the project is worth to be implemented.
(iii) The estimated project life over which the project is evaluated
The estimated project life is the optimal period over which the project should be run to maximize its return to the project implementer. In other words, it is the project’s economic life over which the project is evaluated. In our case in study, the assumption made for the estimated project life is of 50 years.
(iv) formative or summative
These are models of CBA analyses that differ from one another. In formative…...

Similar Documents

Cost Benefit Analysis

...------------------------------------------------- Cost Benefit Analysis [ECON 453] ------------------------------------------------- Assignment II Aditya Gurung Dr. T.M. Horbulyk April 2, 2012 1. Based on the article, describe as best you can: (i) The reference group for the cost benefit analysis Reference group for the cost benefit analysis (CBA) refers to the set of persons whose gains and losses are to be included as directly relevant to the project decision-making process. It is a sub set of people who will be benefited or affected by the implementation of the project. In the case of Bolu Mountain Tunnel project, the set of people who will directly benefit from the implementation of the project are the people who can now avoid traveling by Bolu Mountain Passage (D100 highway) as they can get to there destination by traveling through the tunnel in much safer conditions along with reduced travel time. (ii) The purpose of the study The purpose of any social CBA is to examine and assess whether or not the social benefits of the proposed policy or project outweigh its social cost. By doing so, it can assist decision-making by facilitating the allocation of resources to their most valuable application. In the case of given article, the purpose of the study is to conduct the CBA of the Bolu Mountain Tunnel Project and examine if the project is worth to be implemented. (iii) The estimated project life over which the project is evaluated The estimated project...

Words: 3831 - Pages: 16

Cost-Benefit

... access to her money early with the term deposit account. As these fees change, her increasing or decreasing marginal costs would have to be taken into account. On the other hand, if she decided to keep her money out of the bank she would forgo any interest that her money would earn in that time. In other words, her opportunity costs would be the interest that she would be missing out on. In the situation of the woman, it could be argued that the stress encountered by trusting the bank could also be considered a cost. Would the stress affect her health, which in turn could also be counted as a cost? An additional cost-benefit analysis would be to investigate if her time lost waiting in a bank or automatic bank teller queues verses her ability control her money instantly play a part. Is the opportunity cost of her time worth more than the benefit of keeping her money in a bank? One could surmise that because this woman had experienced the collapse of a bank in the past, the benefit for the woman to put her money into a more secure facility was less than the cost of taking the risk of someone thieving the money from her handbag. Unfortunately this decision did not work out for the woman but at the time of her decision it was the best economic reasoning she had. Word Count: 485 References Frank, RH Jennings, S and Bernanke, BS 2009, Principles of Microeconomics, 2st edn, McGraw Hill Australia Pty Limited, North Ryde, NSW....

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Cost Benefit of College Education

... summary of cash flows : Cash Flow Year 1 (College) Year 2 (College) Year 3 (College) Year 4 (College) Year 1 (Work) Year 2 (Work) Year 3 (Work) Year 4 (Work) IRR NPV -101798 -133182 -148112 -166051 51250 141150 216000 560000 13% 150,475.56 The Net Present Value is positive at Php 150, 475.56 with the series of cash flows shown above. Below are the summary of details. Costs (Ages 17 to 20) Direct Costs Indirect Cost Total Cost 305,591 243,552 549,143 Benefits (Ages 21 to 24) Earnings for 4 years 968,670 Net Present Value Internal Rate of Return Benefit-Cost Ratio 150,475.56 13% 1.76 The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is at 13% which is also a positive factor on pursuing college. As an additional comparison, suppose the same amount of Php 549, 143 (cost of college education) is invested in a bank, at 4.25% in four or eight years, the future values are: BPI Time-Deposit at 4.25% Amount FV after 4 years FV after 8 years 549,143 648,619 766,115 Conclusion Based on the calculated data and comparison, below are the conclusions in this analysis:    The amount of investment needed to pursue a college education is at Php 549,143. The opportunity cost or the forgone earnings of choosing to work after high school graduation and not going to college is Php 243,552. If the same amount of Php 549, 143 will be used to invest in a bank and not to provide for college schooling, its future values (both for 4 years and 8 years at 4.25% time-deposit......

Words: 1751 - Pages: 8

Sarbanes Oxley Cost Benefit Analysis

...Sarbanes-Oxley Act: Cost Benefit Analysis The Sarbanes Oxley Act was signed into law by President Bush in 2002. This Act was in direct response to the accounting scandals of the early 2000s. A time that I remember very well, because I’d just graduated from college into the accounting industry, and it was in a total uproar. The Sarbanes Oxley Act (SOX) ordered a number of reforms to enhance corporate responsibility, financial disclosure, and to fight corporate and accounting fraud. This regulation also put financial as well as criminal pressure on the perpetrators, including the auditors. The Sarbanes Oxley Act (SOX) was named after two of its main architects, Senator Paul Sarbanes and Representative Michael Oxley. The SOX Act is composed of eleven titles. They are: Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, Auditor Independence, Corporate Responsibility, Enhanced Financial Disclosures, Analysis Conflicts of Interest, Commission Resources and Authority, Studies and Reports, Corporate and Criminal Fraud Accountability, White Collar Crime Penalty Enhancement, Corporate Tax Returns, and Corporate Fraud Accountability. This Act requires that top management assume responsibility for the financial records that are put out by the corporation. The have to sign off on the information before it is released. This is covered in Section 302. They are certifying that the report does not contain material untrue statements and that the statements provide a fair picture of the...

Words: 1558 - Pages: 7

Cost Benefit Analysis

...“Cost-Benefit Analysis” (e-Activity part I-IV) Scenario; support the reasons for recommending and accepting the financial implications of Project A over the superiors choice for Project B. After reviewing all the information in the e-Activity on the process of capital budgeting it is important to remember the stipulation of the critical acceptance level of 2.75 years and the Internal Rate of Return is set at 12% when making the decision. Project “A” Project “B” Payback Period (PP) = 1.89 years Payback Period (PP) = 3.75 years Internal Rate of Return (IRR) = 26.72% Internal Rate of Return (IRR) = 19.74% Net Present Value (NPV) = $56,922.85 Net Present Value (NPV) = $ 144,409.02 Assuming this is a mutually exclusive project, meaning that only one can be accepted make for a hard sell on accepting Project A. If these were samples of independent projects then both should be accepted because PP is unreliable and NPV is the optimum rule to follow when there is a discrepancy between the three models. In an attempt to convince the superior that Project A is the better choice for the organization I would need to point out that the payback period of less then 2 years falls well below the critical acceptance level of 2.75 years. As a BA, It would also be necessary stress the point that the IRR for project “A” calculates at nearly 27% where Project “B” has a IRR of under 20%. At his point the superior is looking...

Words: 703 - Pages: 3

Cost Benefit Analysis

...Description: Look around you. Is there anything which you see which seems like a riddle but when looked at with the lens of costs and benefits makes sense? List one such example. This example is from personal experience. I have recently changed my job. The day before joining I bought a branded hand bag for say price X knowing very well that the end of season sale was likely to start in the next fifteen days. I was also aware from past experience that I would easily get a discount of 25% on waiting till that period. I went ahead and bought it in spite of a nudging feeling of making an irrational purchase and having indulged myself. Now in the light of cost benefit analysis my decision appears rational as at that time I had not considered the benefits drawn on purchasing: 1. My old hand bag had worn out and I was uncomfortable in carrying it to the new workplace. With the new bag I felt more confident and positively disposed for the new assignment. Changing jobs is a big step and there is an underlying concern about being able to adjust to the new environment and culture. Not that the bag would help me adjust but psychologically I felt more confident. 2. I had been exploring the markets for a suitable hand bag for a long time as mentioned above the old one had worn out. At the time of purchase I had liked the handbag in the first look itself. I did not want to wait till the end of season sale for two reasons. First as I was taking up a new job and I knew I will have to...

Words: 427 - Pages: 2

Business Analysi

... into many tracks exchanged online. Recognizing an opportunity to establish a market for high quality and legal music downloads; Apple introduced iTunes, the iTunes Music Store and the iPod Music Player. Although digital players had already surfaced in the market, the iPod offered gigabyte storage capacity and communicated with computers through iTunes software freely available for Windows and Macintosh-based systems. iTunes not only simplified the transfer of digital music, but also linked purchases to the iTunes music store. Songs were available for $0.99. Entire albums were available at a discounted rate. By 2003, five record labels had signed with Apple and the catalogue of songs exceeded 2000 items. In its first year alone, the iTunes store sold more than $70 million songs, capturing 70% market share in the process. In the second fiscal quarter for 2004, Apple shipped 807 000 iPods. Its stock rose to 45$ per share and its net profit increased to $46 million (AppleHistory.com). Sales of its Macintosh computers also surged, and Apple reported the sale of 750 000 units during the quarter. The Total Cost of Ownership Debate Rages on The Controversial Gartner Report Gartner Inc is a leading research provider, offering analysis of the global IT industry. In 2002, it released a study comparing the TCO for Melbourne University’s Mac environment with its pc environment. The study concluded that Macs were 36% cheaper to run than pc’s. The report...

Words: 3798 - Pages: 16

Cost Benefit Analysis A5 Vienna - Brno

...1.12.2014 Advanced Economic Evaluation Introduction: The highway A5 Nord/Weinviertel Autobahn should connect Vienna (Austria) and Brno (Czech Republic). Nowadays travellers have to go through a mix of highways and country roads which go through cities and villages. Construction is performed in three stages: In 2010 the first construction stage with a length of 23.5 km from Eibesbrunn to Schrick was opened to traffic. The second stage from Schrick to Poysbrunn with a length of 25 km is supposed to be constructed till 2017 and the last stage from Poysbrunn to Drasenhofen with a length of 9 km should be finished in 2018. From Drasenhofen, the Austrian boarder travellers can use the Czech highway to Brno, so there will be a continuous highway between Vienna and Brno. The construction and maintenance of the highway is financed through Public Private Partnership by the Bonaventura Straßeneinrichtungs-GmbH Problem statement: The objective of a new highway is to improve the travel conditions and improve the quality of life for the people who are living close to the old road and suffer from noise, thus these benefits exceeds the costs of constructing and operating a highway? For answering this question an economic evaluation has to be done. Theoretical and methodological considerations An in Medias res Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) where all relevant economic environmental and social impacts are included, is performed for the highway case. A CBA as an economic evaluation method...

Words: 2443 - Pages: 10

Cost Benefit Analysis

...MBA 439: Business Economics CBA Report Writing Topic: Benefit-Cost Analysis of Pacific Islands Alternative Energy (An Economic Assessment of Renewable Energy Options for Rural Electrification in Pacific Island Countries) Lecturer: Professor Jim MacMaster By Tamaroa Tekeiaki – s11059287. Introduction Is there a way for Pacific island countries to opt for a more inexpensive and environmental friendly power source for rural electrification or should they just stick to the current source of energy they are using at the moment? This report provides then a summary of the evaluation on the economic and financial cost of these alternative renewable energy projects that the pacific islands may opt to in terms of their cost-benefit analysis. From recent data report the world relied on renewable sources for around 13.1% of its primary energy supply, according to IEA statistics. Renewables accounted for 19.5% of global electricity generation. (IRENA websites, 2009) According to the report, Woodruff stated that, “In the pacific islands alone approximately 70% (or approximately 50% excluding Papua New Guinea) of the region’s population still lacks access to electricity. In addition, Pacific Island Countries, despite their abundance of renewable energy resources, remain almost completely dependent on imported fossil fuels for meeting their energy needs. However, imported fuel from overseas account for an average of 40% of countries’ gross domestic products. With rising...

Words: 2286 - Pages: 10

Cost Benefit Analysis by Ford

...Questionable cost-benefit analysis by Ford In 1968, Lee Iacocca, president of Ford Motor Co., faced fear of losing market share in subcompact auto market by German Auto, Volkswagen. Although the automobile preproduction process usually takes three and a half years, Ford made it within two years from designing phase to releasing to the market. Market seemed to be impressed by Ford, but it did not go last that long. Pinto had a critical problem that its fuel tank cannot withstand any rear-impact over 20mph speed. The fuel tank would rupture and cause fire. Moreover, Ford’s directors and their engineers already realized this issue and the potential number of people would die from fires due to Pinto’s defective design. There were remedies for Ford that they can either give up some trunk space or increase cost by putting rubber bladder for protection. However, Ford chose neither of options, rather they analyzed the cost of settlements potentially be incurred by car accidents and decided to stick with the original design as a result of profit maximization in that way. Within seven years since Pinto had been released, over 500 deaths and indeterminate numbers of injuries were caused by Pinto crashes and majority of those killed had no other injuries, meaning they burned to death. How much worth one’s life be valued in terms of dollar amount? How much is enough to pay for victim’s pain and suffering? How can you predict the number of people will die or get injured through newly...

Words: 997 - Pages: 4

Ubuntu Touch Cost Benefit Analysis

...Ubuntu Touch Cost Benefit Analysis After being tasked with finding the best phone to meet Eduboost’s various needs, it is my pleasure to present you with my findings. But before I get into this discussion on the particular phone that I have chosen, I would like to give some background on the criteria that was used to come to this decision. I considered the various needs of Eduboost, the 170 Eduboost members, the cell phone corporation I chose, as well as Eduboost’s donors, shareholders as well as the general public. I also took into consideration the savings, the future proofing, as well as the maintenance that the device would offer when we begin promoting literacy throughout the country of Melandria. With that being said, I have chosen the Ubuntu Touch as the official phone for Eduboost’s future projects. One of the factors I focused on in the beginning is how much each phone would cost. Due to the fact that our shareholders and donors have given us a set budget, I wanted to be certain that the phone we use was as practical and cost efficient as possible. According to the CNET, the Firefox OS is offered for $25 with a compatible smartphone. That is a huge difference in price when it is compared to the Ubuntu Touch, which is priced at $170 with a compatible smartphone. When factoring in the 170 Eduboost members, the total cost of Firefox OS phones would be $4,250 for the Eduboost; whereas, the total cost for Ubuntu Touch would be $11,900. Now while Firefox OS is offering...

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Cost Benefit Analysis

... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 1.1 The Animal Procedures Committee 1.2 Background to this review 1.3 The Cost Benefit working group Chapter 2 Moral issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Action 2.3 Motivation 2.4 Consequences 2.5 Conclusion Chapter 3 The scientific validity of animal experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Background 3.3 Arguments concerning the scientific validity of animal experiments 3.4 More detailed analysis: the role of examples in debate about the scientific validity of animal experiments 3.5 Criteria for assessing the scientific validity of animal experiments 3.6 Further questions and concerns 3.7 General conclusions Chapter 4 The identification and assessment of costs and benefits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Information to assist in identifying harms and benefits 4.3 Factors in the assessment of costs to animals 4.4 Factors in the assessment of benefits 4.5 Particular issues in the assessment of costs and benefits 4.6 Advance constraints on the scientific purpose and nature of animal use 4.7 General conclusions Chapter 5 Practical procedures for......

Words: 56267 - Pages: 226

Cost Benefit Analysis

... Cost-benefit analysis of Trademark protection Name Course Institution Date Outline Cost-benefit analysis of Trademark protection Introduction Thesis statement: Trademark protection provides an effective platform for business activities in the marketplace though creating and developing a strong trademark that enhances production of high-quality products. A. Limitations of trademark protection 1. The use of the actual person’s name in the business can cause confusion in the business. 2. Fair use doctrine is another limitation applicable to trademark protection. 3. Import limitation. B. Advantages of trademark protection 1. Trademark reduces the search cost for the customers in the market. 2. Trademarks provide them with the incentive to produce high-quality products. 3. Trademark helps consumers identify the right product they want in the market. 4. Trademarks help the producers to reduce the cost of advertising their products. C. Analysis of the cost benefit 1. Sellers in the marketplace might have the same product that is produced with different companies; however, the goods might be similar but cannot be identical. 2. Trademark protection ensures that every consumer is protected and not overexploited by the sellers. 3. Trademark protection is based mostly on the economic cost-benefit analysis; it considers the trademark as a tool for controlling and regulating communication in the marketplace. D. Economic-based concept of...

Words: 4325 - Pages: 18

Cost Benefit Analysis

...A cost benefit analysis is done to determine how well, or how poorly, a planned action will turn out. Although a cost benefit analysis can be used for almost anything, it is most commonly done on financial questions. Since the cost benefit analysis relies on the addition of positive factors and the subtraction of negative ones to determine a net result, it is also known as running the numbers. Cost Benefit Analysis A cost benefit analysis finds, quantifies, and adds all the positive factors. These are the benefits. Then it identifies, quantifies, and subtracts all the negatives, the costs. The difference between the two indicates whether the planned action is advisable. The real trick to doing a cost benefit analysis well is making sure you include all the costs and all the benefits and properly quantify them. Should we hire an additional sales person or assign overtime? Is it a good idea to purchase the new stamping machine? Will we be better off putting our free cash flow into securities rather than investing in additional capital equipment? Each of these questions can be answered by doing a proper cost benefit analysis. Example Cost Benefit Analysis As the Production Manager, you are proposing the purchase of a $1 Million stamping machine to increase output. Before you can present the proposal to the Vice President, you know you need some facts to support your suggestion, so you decide to run the numbers and do a cost benefit analysis. You itemize the benefits...

Words: 1319 - Pages: 6

Cost-Benefit Analysis

...Submitted by : Manjunath Hiremath Batch: L1Sep2015 Date: 15-11-2015 Core Problem : Why do companies promote exchange offer of old watches to New Company' s View : A great way to engage consumers The origin of the exchange offer idea: The offer was conceptualised from the insight that Indians love to preserve things for a long time in hope of getting some value for it someday. Watches, in particular, have always been preserved nicely in cupboards for decades even if not working The Target customers: Both new and existing consumers as old watches of any brand are accepted. This offer also allows customers to exchange watches in any condition, which is a definite crowd-pleaser. * Cost :Consumer felt they were earning that 20 per cent discount on exchange old watch to new . While for the company Strategically it promotes multiple purchase and ownership of watches * Benefits: For consumer there is an element of engagement with the consumer as the consumer is giving away old stuff for which he/she would not have got any value otherwise. In addition, it also bringing happiness to the underprivileged with this initiative. While for companies sales almost double compare to the pre-scheme period (Consumers prefer a brand over others if the offering is interesting). Brand's preference score goes up (it is about 70% during discounts).Tactically, as an activity the exchange offer helps to bring in more footfalls. Engage in a social cause by donating selected watches......

Words: 288 - Pages: 2