Free Essay

Cyber Racism

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By bradmic
Words 1327
Pages 6
Evaluating effectiveness
Criteria:
* Protection of Individual rights – Are individuals looked after by this law? Are people’s rights infringed? * Enforceability – Is it possible to enforce the law? * Accessibility – Is the law difficult to access in terms of expense, is it time consuming, unduly stressful or complex? * Resource efficiency – Does enforcing the law or accessing the law cost huge amounts, would there be a cheaper or more appropriate way of responding to the issue * Responsiveness – Does the law keep up with societies expectations? Does it meet our needs? Is it out of date or behind the times in some way? * Justice been achieved? – Does the law create just outcomes? Is it moral? * Application of the rule of law – Are all people treated equally by the law? Are some people privileged or discriminated by the law? * Meeting society’s needs – Does the law do what society wants it to do? Does it keep pace with our evolving needs? How the law has been out-dated by social change e.g. same-sex marriage, or by technologies e.g. protection of privacy?

Criteria: (A few of the aforementioned criteria)
Thesis: (An educated opinion on the answer to the question)
Content: (Cases/Laws regarding the question)

Legal Assignment – Cyber Racism
Assess the effectiveness of the legal system in addressing the use of technology and its impact on individuals focusing on: Cyber-racism

Cyber-racism
Technology is best described as the use of knowledge to develop or engineer useful things intended to solve problems or make life easier in general. Technology plays a large role in our everyday lives, whether we are completing complex tasks such as analysing DNA from a crime scene to even minute tasks like sweeping the floor; technology has impacted us all. Resulting from the widespread access to technology and the continuous development of new technologies our laws must change in order to accommodate these creations. One prime example of an issue resulting from technological advancements is cyber-racism.
Cyber-racism is defined as any use of information and communication technologies to convey racist attitudes and behaviour which intends to cause harm or distress to another person. This includes but is not limited to: racist material published online such as images, videos, or racist websites as well as racist comments, images and language used in text messages, email or social networking sites. The issues arising from advancements in technology are evident in our everyday life, and our legal system is generally effective in addressing the use of technology and its impacts on individuals, particularly regarding cyber-racism.
One case regarding cyber-racism is Jones v Toben (September 2002). This case involved numerous websites constructed and maintained by the defendant, Frederick Toben (the director of the Adelaide Institute). The websites contained various opinion-related comments regarding the holocaust. The prosecution claimed that the websites were unlawful under Section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth). The judge found that the content was posted in violation of this act under interpretation of the law which states ‘It is unlawful for a person to do an act, otherwise than in private, if: (a) the act is reasonably likely, in all the circumstances, to offend, insult, humiliate, or intimidate another person or a group of people’ after the content was deemed ‘public’ as it was posted on the internet with no password protection. The defendant was forced to remove the material, as well as any other similar materials, from all the World Wide Web sites controlled by him or the Adelaide Institute and not to republish such materials. In this case, the legal system proved effective in addressing the use of technology and its impact on individuals. It was responsive to changing technology as this was the first Australian case where the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) had been applied to the internet, also making the law more enforceable. In doing so, it was able to better protect the rights of individuals and their Human Rights. Overall, this process highlights how the law was very effective in addressing the use of technology.
Another case arising from technology was one between two employees at a finance company. The complainant in the case alleged that his former supervisor sent him an offensive email about Muslim women. He also alleged that the respondent discriminated him in front of other employees by referring to him as an ‘Arab’ and a ‘bomb thrower’. After the complainant made an internal grievance about his supervisor, he alleged that he was further discriminated against as his higher duties were removed, his work was over-scrutinised and his performance unfairly criticised. The respondent denied sending the email and said his comments were misunderstood. The company also denied that any action taken in relation to the complainant’s work performance was because of his race or the fact he made an internal grievance. The key legal issue in this case is whether the actions of the company were based off of race. The debate focused around whether the complainant’s loss of higher duties was a result of discrimination against his racial background or his internal grievance. The complaint was resolved at a conciliation conference where respondent provided a verbal apology to the complainant. The company agreed to pay the complainants legal costs of $5000 as well as $10,000 to assist his career development. The company also agreed to hold a staff meeting to confirm that such behaviour within the workplace is unacceptable. This case highlights how technology such as emails can be used as a basis for racism. The case proves how alternatives to court such as conciliation conferences are used to solve issues arising from technology, also making the case resource efficient because of the fact that conciliation conferences are cheaper and consume less time than court. In knowledge that the company’s actions were discriminative, a settlement was reached between the two parties, further protecting the complainant’s individual rights. The case was also effective in achieving justice for the complainant, as well as proving that the law is accessible in less formal ways than court. Thus supporting the aforementioned statement that the law is very effective in addressing the use of technology and its impacts on individuals, particularly regarding cyber-racism.
In addition to the cases, the New South Wales laws have also been amended as a result of technological advancements. The Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW) has been regulated many times since its creation in order to keep up with society’s needs and expectations. In June 2010, the section regarding racism was amended to include cyber racism. It states: “An act of cyber racism could be considered unlawful under this NSW Act, providing it: 1) Takes place in a public area 2) Is identified as discriminatory conduct 3) Is considered a serious incitement of violence or offence towards a racial group. This set grounds for when an act can be considered as Cyber-racism. This emphasises the effectiveness of the legal system in addressing the use of technology as it is very effective in showing responsiveness to society’s continually changing needs and expectations. It also creates equality within society by making acts of racism committed using technology suffer similar consequences to acts of racism committed without the use of technology, proving effectiveness regarding the rule of law. Therefore, the legal system is largely effective in addressing the use of technology.
In conclusion, the Australian legal system is very effective in addressing the use of technology and its impact on individuals. As technology improves, it has a larger impact on individuals – particularly regarding cyber-racism. The legal system is very responsive to changing times and is constantly improving in order to meet society’s needs. It is also further improving individual’s rights by ensuring they aren’t discriminated against and endeavouring to become widely accessible. As a result of this, our legal system is extremely effective in combatting cyber-racism and addressing impacts of the use of technology on individuals as a whole.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

I Love to Write

...Tswane Muslim School. Grade; 10B Due date; 8 September 2014 1.1) INTRODUCTION * RACISM- The belief that race accounts for differences in human character or ability and that a particular race is superior to others. Therefore, it is Discrimination or prejudice based on race * BULLYING- Aggressive behavior that involves a real or perceived power imbalance. This behavior is usually regular and rarely a one time thing. Bullying is not only physical but also verbal and in today’s times it is also cyber. 1.2) CAUSES RACISM * Xenophobia, the fear of people who are different. The element of xenophobia is present in racism. * Fear of sharing power with other groups of people. * Lack of empathy- Empathy is the ability to put oneself in the shoes of another person, and understand and feel what that person is going through. BULLYING * To get power, they think if you push people around and make them do what you want them to do you will be noticed. The * Some people have problems at home and want to take their feelings out on others and so they bully. * Some people just have an aggressive personality, and low self-confidence issues 1.3) IMPACT: ON THE LOCAL COMMUNITIES: RACISM * It separates communities because some people cannot except people of different races living together thus drive a wedge between people in the community. * Racism does not allow for a collective contribution of its citizens, which I believe to be a......

Words: 1681 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Racism and Bullying

...Racism and Bullying Team A PSYCH 620 January 12, 2015 Racism and Bullying Introduction: Society has been experiencing a rash of racism and bullying with no end in sight. There have been news reports of white cops killing unarmed black men and teens that have endured bullying taking their lives. The social learning skills children learn are carried into adulthood. What is Bullying? According to Stopbullying.gov (2013), “Bullying is unwanted, aggressive behavior among school-aged children that involve a real or perceived power imbalance” (p. 1). The aggressive behaviors, children, use to bully others, are verbal attacks such as name-calling, making threats, physical and exclusion from the group. Acts of bullying take place at various locations like schools, in public places, and on the Internet. Internet bullying is called cyber-bullying where children and teens use the worldwide web (WWW) to attack another with written words for all to see. “Stopbullying.gov (2013) states, Nationwide, 14.8% of students get electronically bullied, including being bullied through e-mail, chat rooms, instant messaging, websites, or texting, during the 12 months before the survey” (p. 9). Bullying has always been referred to as something children do. However, in a recent study adults in the workplace are also involved in bullying. Home Life and Stability The home life of a child has an impact on his or her life. Children and teens, who experience a home life where verbal and physical......

Words: 2217 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Anti-Muslim Racism

...Introduction The social construction of the “Muslim race” has influenced the racialisation of the community on the basis of their Muslim identity. The racialisation process has been exacerbated by the recent terror attacks in France and Belgium, resulting in the unjust attachment of these acts to the Muslim community. Anti-Muslim racism is now the predominant form of racism in Britain, manifesting itself on an institutional and individual level (Mahamadille, 2005). This essay aims to discuss the reality of anti-Muslim racism in Britain through processes of racialisation and through manifestations of anti-Muslim hostility and discrimination. But first emphasis is placed on how “the Muslim race” has become socially constructed by mainstream British society. Social Construction of “Muslim Race” Social constructionists share the belief that categorisation on the basis of biologically transmitted traits is a pseudo that traditionally was used to justify the unequal treatment of certain groups by others (mainly relating to skin colour) (Machery, 2005). Biology, religion and culture merely provide the materials from which we socially construct the ideas of difference and community. Scholars now widely believe that race is socially constructed as opposed to biologically based (Bonilla, 1997). The “Muslim Race” is arguably the greatest example of a socially constructed race in recent times. Despite major differences in skin colour, nationality and culture, the Muslim community......

Words: 936 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Miss

...1 COM 3702 MEDIA STUDIES Policy management and media representation Semester 1,2014 Student number : 3356-7514 2 I, the undersigned, hereby declare that this is my own and personal work, except where the works or publications of others have been acknowledged by mean of reference techniques. I have read and understood Tutorial Letter CMNALLE/301, regarding technical and presentation requirements, referencing techniques and plagiarism. Name: Bonita Europa Student Number: 33567514 Date: 2014/05/06 Assignment Number: PORTFOLIO EXAM 892092 Witness: Clint Newkirk 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 MEDIA POLICY AND REGULATION 1.1 History of communication policy 1.1.1 Emerging communications industry policy 1.1.2 Public service media policy 1.1.3 New communications policy 1.2 Freedom of the media 1.2.1 The need for freedom of speech 1.2.2 Threats to it 1.2.3 If, how and why such threats can or cannot be motivate 2 MEDIA MANAGEMENT AND MEDIA MARKETS 2.1 Media concentration 2.1.1 The relationship of competition to concentration 2.1.2 The dual nature of the media industry 2.1.3 The four forms of concentration 2.1.4 The dangers of concentration 2.1.5 Positive externalities of the media 3 REPRESENTATION AND THE MEDIA 3.1 Media representation of race 3.1.1 Discussion 3.1.2 Brief explanation of the meaning whiteness 3.2 Media representation of violence 3.2.1 An introductory thesis (argument) 3.2.2 Define and explain representation, violence and moral panics 3.2.3...

Words: 12513 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

Cybercrime: Impact on Today’s World

...of computer – related crimes committed on large scale every day. One common definition describes cybercrime as any activity in which computers or networks are a tool, a target or a place of criminal activity. There are several difficulties with this broad definition. It would, for example, cover traditional crimes such as murder, if perchance the offender used a keyboard to hit and kill the victim. Another broader definition is provided in Article 1.1 of the Stanford Draft International Convention to Enhance Protection from Cyber Crime and Terrorism (the “Stanford Draft”), which points out that cybercrime refers to acts in respect to cyber systems (Lewis, 2012). There have been different forms of Cybercrime activities. This includes, but not limited, Denial of Service (DOS) attacks, Malware, and computer viruses. The second class of Cybercrime activities includes, information warfare, phishing, swindles, fraud (Cybercrime, 2012) as well as, cyber-stalking. Computer fraud involves insincere misrepresentations of facts. This could be, altering, destroying and suppressing unauthorized transactions of information. In...

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Planning a Persuasive Essay

...to identify and understand the cause and effects of cyber bullying. Cyber bullying is a new form of bullying that has harmful psychological side effects on youth such as depression and anxiety. Although I am no longer in high school a friend of mines cousin has recently committed suicide because she was maliciously bullied online. Her story is one of many and the number of teens committing suicide because of cyber bullying seems to only be getting bigger. My goal on this casual analysis research paper is to educate parents and educational professionals on the consequences of cyber bullying and how to help prevent it. Outline: Thesis: Cyber Bullying leads to psychological damage in our community’s adolescents. I. Extent of the issue: a. Explain what cyber bullying is. b. According to CBC 78% of victims of bullying have been cyber bullied. c. Compare how an adult using social media is different then adolescents. IV. Cause of cyber bullying: a. Children do it to prove their social standing 1. Boos their egos 2. Gain praise from peers b. Children use social media as an outlet for revenge 1. Use out lets like face book and twitter to spread mass and public rumors 2. Quick and public way for kids to humiliate others III. Effects of cyber bullying: a. Cyber bullying gives fuel to prejudice issues 1. Can lead to racism. 2. Can lead to mental discrimination b. Cyber bullying can lead to psychological issues in teens ...

Words: 632 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Cyber Crime

...Cybercrime Name Institutional Affiliation Date Cyber Crime a 21st Century Problem Abstract Subsequent research has focused in establishing Cybercrime as an activity only for computer programmers. However, Cybercrime has recently expanded to appear as a full capital offense since it integrates multiple forms of criminal activities. Per se, Cybercrime has proved to be a social, economic, and political form of disturbance, or in other words, a mother of 21st century crimes. The commencing research will endeavor to prove that Cybercrime should be managed in a more responsive method since it encourages the development of other crimes. The research is defragmented into three main sections, firstly, a background establishing the crude nature of Cybercrime. Secondly, the research will provide a critical review of forms and the extent of crime. Thirdly, the research will provide the authors opinion on what should be done in relation to Cybercrime. Background Half a decade ago, when computers were evolving to their current state, little was known of any criminal activity, which could have been associated with the process. However, with time, Cybercrime grew leading to the introduction of malicious activities that attempts to swindle the information wealth of the user. In recent times, most countries, even in the developing world are processing laws, which should mitigate or even extinguish Cybercrime. Cybercrime is one of the most sophisticated crimes since the attacker is......

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cyber Bullying

...of challenging behaviour and one of the most common and prominent ones is bullying. There are several different types of bullying and I am going to discuss three of them, including the reasons behind these types of bullying and the possible effects on an individual who may be subjected to bullying. The first type of bullying I am going to discuss is cyber bullying. Cyber bullying is a form of bullying that takes place with the use of technology/over the internet. Cyberbullying can include behaviours like sending threatening or nasty to emails to another person or to a group of people. Emails like this can include any type of message from racist comments to sexist comments or just plain nasty names or threats. (Teenwirral.com, 2015) Social networking sites are another way a person can cyberbully an individual. People can post offensive statuses which could either be again, racist, sexist, mean or threatening. They also have the power to post embarrassing pictures of someone or they could just harass someone on their profile by commenting nasty things on the victim’s profile. Social media websites are prominent platform for cyber bullying as the bully has the power to create a fake/anonymous account which can be used to bully a person, without any consequences. This links in to one of the main causes of cyberbullying which is that the bully has the ability to hide behind a device, therefore they aren’t required to take any responsibility for their actions. This lack of......

Words: 896 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Current Crimes and Criminal Issues

...Current Crimes and Criminal Issue Hasaye S. Newton CJA 394 October 6, 2015 Juan Campos Current Crimes and Criminal Issue Global crime are not as many as local or regional crimes, they range from illegal immigration, cybercrimes, terror, racism and terrorism. The 'war on terror' in the aftermath of the attacks of Sep. 11, 2001 has undermined human rights globally, according to activists and experts who when the UN conference in Paris. 'Immediately after Sep. 11 2001 there was dramatic change in government policies in regard to terrorism, suspected terrorism, and the monitoring of citizens, with the underlying believe that human rights norms as established in conventions and treaties no longer apply,' Joanne Mariner, director of the terrorism and counter-terrorism program at Human Rights Watch said at the conference in Paris last week. The trend has worsened over the last seven years, according to Mariner, Some 2,000 human rights experts and activists have attended the annual United Nations Department of Public Information Non-Governmental Organizations Conference. The UN DPI/NGO conference on 'Reaffirming Human Rights for all: The Universal Declaration at 60' was held at the headquarters of the Unites Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). The conference this year commemorated the 60th anniversary of the signing of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) in Paris in December 1948. During the war on terror, however, the......

Words: 939 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

It and More It

...Kim Kell Craig Boswell Bullying and Cyber Bullying November 29, 1983 Bullying is a very unfortunate situation that has been around for generations. The world may have not of had a term for it back in those days however making a individual or individuals feel as if they are not equal or less than them has always been an unfortunate situation humans have had to fight rough whether in school, at the park or over the internet. Bullying is around and is getting worse the more the Internet expands and links individuals through social networking. In history there has been billions of bullying situations, not all have been documented and broadcasted through the web and news. In 2010 Tyler Clementi killed himself after his roommate at Rutgers University filmed him kissing another man. Phoebe Prince a 15-year-old innocent young girl moved from Ireland and not even after living in the United States for a year killed herself because of bullying in a Massachusetts school. These are just a few of the innocent lives that were taken resulting from being bullied. The most unfortunate bullying results can be when multiple individuals gang up on one person. In Tampa Florida for over a year 15 girls ganged up on an innocent 12 year old named Rebecca Ann Sedwick. Not only did they physically abuse her bullies harassed her online sending her messages saying “why don’t you go kill yourself” and “You should die”. Soon after she could not take the cyber bullying any longer and changed......

Words: 1638 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Social Media

...The Importance of Social Media: Non-Profit Organization Ianita Byrd Indiana Wesleyan University The Important Role of Social Media in Expanding a Non-Profit Organization The YWCA of Northwest Indiana has turned to social media to reach out to as many people as possible. By using social media, the organization can let their donors or potential donors know what upcoming events are taking place. The YWCA of Northwest Indiana was established in 1920 and has served the Gary area for over 90 years. The goal of YWCA is to offer programs and services to empower young women and men. The YWCA is a Christian based organization that is focused on developing the young people within the community. The mission of the YWCA is to eliminate racism and empower women. They are attempting to accomplish this goal by implanting programs that can improve the lives of young people and the elders in the area. They offer programs for the seniors that include aerobics, dance, jazzercise, health & wellness classes and lunch from meals on wheels. The YWCA also provides after-school programs for the youth. This program offers homework assistance, tutoring for students in kindergarten to high school seniors, The YWCA is in the process of improving their social media presence. They have established a website that list all the current programs that are available. The site contains any future fundraising events, and it also allows you to make donations. The organization will focus......

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Social Network Privacy Settings

...networking websites that allow you to connect with people across the globe. There is protocol standard that all websites must use to make all their users’ personal information safe; these are called privacy settings. They are set to conceal private information such as email addresses, phone numbers, their real names and other information. Users can change the settings at any time to make their profile even more private or open. The virtual environment makes online communities an easy target place for cyber bullying and stalking. Bullies can direct unwanted attention to the unsuspecting victim, pose as a person they are not or even steal their identity without their knowledge and this is a contemporary issue that affects the community. Should there be legislation to prescribe how Facebook is to protect their users by using affective privacy settings? Legislation should be enacted to prescribe the way privacy settings are to function on Facebook to ensure that users are safe from cyber bulling, harassment, assault and deception. Issues that have been raised over 12 months Over the past 12 months, there have been some re-occurring attacks of people who use online communities. A majority of them are associated with the popular Facebook. Many predators sign up for online communities looking for vulnerable people and design a profile claiming to be someone they are not. The case of Nona Belomesoff’s was the start of this issue. Authorities were asked to investigate the......

Words: 1510 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Censorship Online

...This essay talks about issues regarding Censorship of the Internet. According to the textbook, censorship is a way used by governments or religious institutions to supervise or regulate the public access to offensive or harmful materials (Quinn 2012, p.496). Internet censorship applies the same discipline which regulates the public access to harmful content on internet. Nowadays, internet is a place with huge potential for growth. Statistics suggest that the total growth of new internet users is 566.4% from December 31, 2000 to 2012 (Internet World Stats 2012) (Refer to Appendix one). In the mean time, the resources and contents on the internet are growing rapidly at an uncontrollable rate. To some extent, there are almost no restrictions of these materials on the internet. Basically people can almost find everything they want on internet no matter the information they found is right or wrong. Is it necessary to censor the internet and restrict the access to harmful contents? This is a controversial topic that leads to a hot debate these years. Some people think censorship can work effectively and is necessary on internet, while others think not. In the main part, the essay will explain and give evidence about how censorship can work in some cases but may become negatives in others. There is no doubt that internet censorship can work in some cases, especially when it comes to some vulnerable groups on internet such as children, youth and the old. One of the obvious......

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Media Issue Paper and Info. Literacy Worksheet

...Media Issue Paper and Info. Literacy Worksheet Student’s Name University Affiliation Governments should be allowed to monitor and/or censor the Internet use of citizens Introduction Internet censorship is the restriction of the content that can be accessed, published, or viewed through the internet. In any country, the government has a vital role and responsibility in the enhancement of information and technology. It is the right of everyone to have freedom of opinion and expression. Every person has freedom to hold their own opinions without hindrance and to seek, get and pass information and opinions via any media channels. However, in many countries this important human right is usually curtailed through various ways which include censorship, laws that restrict the press, molestation of journalists and other people who articulate their views and opinions. It is also important any government to monitor and control the information which can be accessed by its citizens without infringing the fundamental right to information and opinions. Failure to censor the internet can cause extreme harm to the citizens or even the government (Constance, Theo & Ina, n.d.). Firstly, if the content that can be accessed or published in the internet is not filtered malicious people can spread information that can jeopardize the security of a country. Many countries argue that lack of internet censorship could lead to spread of secret information that is necessary for protecting the......

Words: 1358 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Bullying Is the Most Unfair Thing in the World

...Running Head: BULLYING IS THE MOST UNFAIR THING IN THE WORLD Bullying Is The Most Unfair Thing In The World Richard Salvatierra Luis Peredo Roberto Aponte Santa Cruz Cooperative School 3.7 million youths engage in bullying, and more than 3.2 million are victims of “moderate” or “serious” bullying each year. Bullying is unwanted, aggressive behavior usually among children that involves a real or observed power inequality. The behavior is repeated, or has the potential to be repeated, over time and usually gets worse. Bullying includes actions such as making threats, spreading rumors, attacking someone physically or verbally, and excluding someone from a group on purpose. Bullying is tremendously unfair in the world we live in because it can engage them into violence and other risky behaviors into adulthood, mental health issues and lower their self-esteem. Bullying has come to be one of the most unjust things in our planet because it can engage them into violence and other risky behaviors into adulthood. William E. Copeland lead author of the study and an associate professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Duke University Medical said, ‘’Men who were victims were 18.5 times more likely to have had suicidal thoughts in adulthood, compared to the participants who had not been bullied or perpetuators’’(Copeland, 2005) This quote shows how bullying is unfair since it can affect the future of the victim because it can cause them to do......

Words: 1472 - Pages: 6