Premium Essay



Submitted By mcrdmc
Words 10652
Pages 43
Criminology & Criminal Justice
© 2006 SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks & New Delhi) and the British Society of Criminology. ISSN 1748–8958; Vol: 6(1): 39–62 DOI: 10.1177/1748895806060666

A desistance paradigm for offender management

Universities of Glasgow and Strathclyde, UK

In an influential article published in the British Journal of Social Work in 1979, Anthony Bottoms and Bill McWilliams proposed the adoption of a ‘non-treatment paradigm’ for probation practice. Their argument rested on a careful and considered analysis not only of empirical evidence about the ineffectiveness of rehabilitative treatment but also of theoretical, moral and philosophical questions about such interventions. By 1994, emerging evidence about the potential effectiveness of some intervention programmes was sufficient to lead Peter Raynor and Maurice Vanstone to suggest significant revisions to the ‘non-treatment paradigm’. In this article, it is argued that a different but equally relevant form of empirical evidence—that derived from desistance studies—suggests a need to re-evaluate these earlier paradigms for probation practice. This reevaluation is also required by the way that such studies enable us to understand and theorize both desistance itself and the role that penal professionals might play in supporting it. Ultimately, these empirical and theoretical insights drive us back to the complex interfaces between technical and moral questions that preoccupied Bottoms and McWilliams and that should feature more prominently in contemporary debates about the futures of ‘offender management’ and of our penal systems.

Key Words desistance • effectiveness • ethics • offender management • nontreatment paradigm • probation



Criminology & Criminal Justice 6(1)

Critical analysts of the history

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Maruna Response Paper

...Maruna Response Paper 1) The idea of desistance is talked about throughout the course of the Maruna book. Desistance can be defined as a sudden end of criminal behavior. Understanding desistance has been a challenge for many years, with many criminologists publishing theories. Matza and Glazer believed that criminal behavior was sporadic. Matza was one of the first people to explain the idea of desistance and theories of criminal behavior. Glazer described criminal behavior as a “zigzag path” because criminals often go back and forth between committing crimes (Maruna, 2001). These criminals can commit a crime and then obey the law for the next couple weeks. The problem with defining desistance is the question of what really constitutes as legit desistance. Like stated before, someone can go months or even years without committing a crime, but does that mean the offending behavior is terminated? Farrall and Bowling view desistance as the ending of a criminal career (Maruna, 2001). Farrall and Bowling describe this type of desistance almost the same way that a person quits a job where one stops doing a routine. The factors that had the most impact on the desistance process would be choice or rational choice. When criminals were asked why they stopped committing crimes most became sick of the lifestyle and hit rock bottom so they wanted to start a new chapter in their lives. This is important because the ex offenders are making rational decisions to stop committing crimes. These...

Words: 2401 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay


...| Critically discuss the nature of desistance and evaluate the extent to which current probation practices support desistance. | | | | | | Desistance has many definitions according to numerous theorists. Some definitions are vague. For example, Laub and Sampson explained how Neal Shover (1996) defines desistance as “voluntary termination of serious criminal participation”. Some other definitions are more arbitrary. For instance, Professor Laub and Professor Sampson came across other definitions, such as Farrington and Hawkins (1991) and how they define desistance as having no conviction between the age 21 and 32, following a conviction before 21. Another study they found was that of Weitekamp and Kerner (1994), and this explained how together they have both tried to unravel various workings in the area of desistance. They have defined the desistance as the period of time when the criminal or delinquent actions ends permanently. Comparing this notion, they define suspension as an interruption in offending activities. Laub and Sampson also showed how Maruna (2001), points out that the fore mentioned researchers, in addition to their definitions, view desistance as a developmental progression, and not as a happening; which means the rate of offending recurring decelerates and also becomes far less appealing. In a documentary by Allen Weaver, on desistance, he spoke about Laub and Sampson’s study, about a research that was conducted in the 1940’s as part...

Words: 2692 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Cjs 230 Rehabilitation Paper

...are programs that are to prevent habitual offenders, help a criminal get to their normal state of mind and not to be punishing for their action that may cause the criminal to change and become an outstanding citizen that follows the rules instead of the individual getting out and committing another crime. Throughout the years there has been many processes created to form rehabilitation process of criminal justice. The process has helped many offenders by allowing him/her to return within their community as a changed individual. Rehabilitation is a specific program that is applied within a prison setting to bring the end of a criminal behavior called desistance, the meaning to cease and stop. It is supposed to be a formula of, prisoner classification X appropriate programming X positive participation= probability of desistance. An inmate getting into the right program would keep them long enough in order to complete the program successfully, once the program has been completed then the inmate can be put in the community so that their behavior would be tested as a non-criminal behavior. There are some facilities that offer rehab, religion, and anger management (Foster, 2006). In the twentieths century it was believed that prison official were not able to give a defined and clear method of rehabilitation (Foster, 2006). Scientific penology was a major role in defining and conducting structured thoughts and scientific studies that is utilized through rehabilitation (Foster, 2006)...

Words: 394 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Me in Politics

...1.2. Individual and G roup Mechanisms of Radicalization (C lar k Mc C auley,     Sophia Moskalenko)1 Authors: Clark McCauley and Sophia Moskalenko Organization: Bryn Mawr College Contact Information:;   We define political radicalization as changes in beliefs, feelings and behavior in the direction of increased support for a political conflict. Radicalization can involve the movement of individuals and groups to legal and nonviolent political action (activism) or to illegal and violent political action (radicalism). An extreme of radicalization is terrorism, in which a nonstate group targets not only government forces but civilian citizens supporting the government. !"#$%&'&()*'+"(,+&-./0+(1/2#,/&'(.#,/-#$/3#'/)"(#&(+/'2+.(4')5-,)6"7().(40)'')8-957(:;#B&((#'"!#'*-*11%$&(>#*N!*'0#%-$"11#!+*#B+"(*#&'14$;*'!#'*!B"$6.8 5. What is the Role of Emotion in Radicalization? The literature on radicalization tends to emphasize cost/benefit calculations, but many have noted the salience of emotions such as anger or outrage, shame, and humiliation in political conflict. Research on emotional aspects of radicalization is needed. For instance, it is not clear whether hate is an emotion or a powerful form of negative identification that can be the occasion of many emotions - both positive and negative - depending on what is happening to the target of hatred (Royzman, McCauley, & Rozin, 2005). Similarly, it is not clear whether humiliation is...

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Adolsescent Alcohol Use

...ADOLESCENT ALCOHOL USE AND DATING VIOLENCE PERPETRATION: THREE STUDIES EXAMINING CONCURRENT AND LONGITUDINAL RELATIONS ACROSS GRADES 8 THROUGH 12 Heathe Luz McNaughton Reyes A dissertation submitted to the faculty of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Health Behavior and Health Education Chapel Hill 2009 Approved by Vangie A. Foshee, PhD Susan T. Ennett, PhD Daniel J. Bauer, PhD Carolyn T. Halpern, PhD J. Michael Bowling, PhD UMI Number: 3387971 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. UMI 3387971 Copyright 2010 by ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This edition of the work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, MI 48106-1346 © 2009 Heathe Luz McNaughton Reyes ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT Heathe Luz McNaughton Reyes—Adolescent alcohol use and dating violence perpetration: Three studies examining concurrent and longitudinal relations across grades 8 through 12 (Under the direction of Vangie A. Foshee, Susan T. Ennett,...

Words: 5782 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay


...they have still been rehabilitated, but they are still a criminal. This just shows that it is possible for a person to change, but still also be set in their old ways. When most people think about prisoner rehabilitation, they think about the different programs that are offered in an effort to try to get the prisoners to turn their lives around and “turn over a new leaf” and also end their lives of crime and live a normal, crime free life (Foster, Chapter 13, 2006). Whenever the law enforcement officers and government officials are trying to determine whether or not to try to rehabilitate someone, they try to figure out what that particular prisoner’s chance of desistance is. This can be expressed in a kind of formula: prisoner classification x appropriate programming x positive participation=probability of desistance (Foster, Chapter 13, 2006). It is important for the prisons to try to rehabilitate as many inmates as possible in an effort to help society when the inmates get out. Prisoner rehabilitation helps to ensure that...

Words: 763 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Reintegration And Pains Of Re-Entry: A Case Study

...Reviewing the victim contact reports is necessary for the process to minimize victimization and returning back to criminal activities. There are versions that have been advocated to ensure that there is a change in the perception of the society and ease the desistance process but there are no documented scientific reports to support the same. However, the criminal justice system has officers working in the regions for evaluating the community ideas, opinions and take on the release of the convicts back to the society. Under the Correctional and Conditional Release Act, there are procedures and conditions that parolees are issued with to ensure that the process is successful (Government of Canada, 2018). With the extensive training, the parole and probation officers conduct an analysis of the risk factors before releasing the inmates back to the “hostile...

Words: 522 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Criminal Behavior

...There are various theories and are very different and used to explain the criminal behavior. A theory is an abstract statement that explains why certain things do or do not happen. A valid theory is based on and must have the ability to be able to predict future occurrences of the phenomenon in question. Also, a valid theory has the ability to be validated or tested through experiment or other observation. Today the theories used to explain criminal behavior include what are the onsets, the continuation, and the eventual desistance from a criminal career. The rational theory is when a person commits a crime and their actions are rational and contain detailed planning and making decisions used for personal gain. The person in this theory does everything and thinks outside of the box to avoid capture or punishment. The offender thoroughly evaluates and weighs the potential benefits against the consequences and then decides that the benefit outweighs the potential outcome. There are theories beyond rational theory that we know that these criminals are rational and that their behavior can be controlled or even avoided by fear of punishment. The situational crime control is a theory that state that desperate people may think about crime but only irrational would attack a well-defended, an unreachable target and ultimately risk strict punishment. Crime prevention is reached by reducing the open opportunities people may have to commit particular crimes. The situational crime...

Words: 564 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Novation Compensation

...non-compliance. 3. To punish the debtor 4. Provide for liquidated damages. CLASSIFICATION OF PENAL CLAUSE 1. SUBSIDIARY( ACCESSORY) only penalty is demandable on case on non-compliance 2. JOINT- both the principal contract and the penal clause can be enforced. WHEN DAMAGES AND ONTEREST ALSO DEMANDABLE 1. WHEN STIPULATED in the obligation 2. When the debtor refuses to pay the penalty 3. When the debtor is guilty of fraud in the fulfillment of the obligation. PAYMENT ON PERFORMANCE – PAYMENT means not only the delivery of money but also the performance, in any other manner of the obligation. PAYMENT- means to deliver of money or thing ( in obligation to give), the doing of a thing (in obligation to do) or the desistance from doing something( in obligation not to do). PERFORMANCE- means that the parties to the contract have done that which they agreed to do. The possibility of non- performance should be anticipated when drawing up contract terms conditions. HOW PAYMENT IS MADE 1. In a monetary obligation by the delivery of the money in full. 2. In an obligation to deliver a thing or an object. 3. In an obligation to do something, by the performance of the supposed undertaking. 4. In an...

Words: 1051 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Abbreviated Quantitative Plan

...Abbreviated Quantitative Plan Abbreviated Quantitative Plan Introduction Recidivism amongst United States inmates has been an on-going battle since the existence of prison institution (Serin & Lloyd, 2009). As prison populations continue to grow today, statistics show one out of every100 adults are incarcerated (Boduszek, Adamson, Shevlin, Mallett & Hyland, 2013). Scholars have discussed and debated for centuries what factors tend to incite criminal behavior. Over time, many scholars developed theories implicating supernatural influence, genetics, and/or environment as the dominant factors that produced criminality (Serin & Lloyd, 2009). Far from accepting external forces as the sole motivating factors, scholars also looked internally for the answer, touting physiology, both mental and physical, as creating an innate predisposition to crime (Boduszek et al, 2013). Today, we recognize both internal and external factors as contributors to criminal behavior and recidivism (Serin & Lloyd, 2009). These factors, known as risk factors, are split into two categories: dynamic and static (Boduszek et al, 2013). Aptly named, static factors, like criminal history, family criminality, age at first admission to a correctional facility, number of prior incarcerations, and the commitment offense are related to recidivism but cannot be altered through the delivery of services (Boduszek et al, 2013). Dynamic risk factors, on the other hand, are changeable factors...

Words: 742 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Canon 15 Case Digest

...CANON 15: RUTHIE LIM-SANTIAGO vs ATTY. CARLOS SAGUCIO     A.C. No. 6705  March 31, 2006 FACTS: Respondent, atty Sagucio was a former Personnel manager and Counsel of Taggat Industries Inc. Thereafter in 1992, he was appointed as Asst. Provincial prosecutor of Tuguegarao Cagayan . Employees of Taggat filed criminal charges against the complainant who took over the management and control of Taggat, withheld the payment of their wages and salaries without a valid cause. The complainant charges respondent with the engaging in private practice of law while working as a government prosecutor and for violation of Rule 15.03 of CPR. ISSUES: 1. Whether or not the respondent violated Rule 15.03 of CPR. 2. Whether or not being a former lawyer of Taggat posits conflict of interests with his work as Asst. Provincial Prosecutor  HELD: The Court finds that there is no conflict of interest on the part of the respondent when he handled the preliminary investigation of the criminal charges filed by the Taggat Employees. The issue of the matter of the criminal complaint was pertaining to the withholding of the wages and salaries of the Taggat employees which occurred from April 1, 1996 to July 15, 1997. Evidently, the respondent was no longer connected with the Taggat Inc during such period since he is working as Assistant Provincial Prosecutor since 1992. Should there be apparent conflict of interest, it must be supported by sufficient evidence that Taggat, respondent’s...

Words: 953 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Initial Involvement Model This significantly increases the likelihood that they will be caught with no way to escape. The selected house is easily accessible and have lower security allowing the individual to work without restraints. Once the area is chosen the individual will choose a house in the same reject select pattern. The burgled home has plenty of cover, no one home, and affluent while the unburgled house is visible from the street, with a dog, and an alarm. Again we can determine that the burgled home lowers the risk factors for the individual while increasing his benefits since they are affluent. The criminal event model will continue throughout the life on the individual as they determine their readiness to commit a crime again known as the desistance model. External events such as an arrest, injury, or legitimate work could inhibit an individual from committing the act again. However, if the individual accomplished the immediate need with high benefits and low cost the individual will continue to engage in crime to meet future needs until met by an external force. Rational choice theory pulls factors from other general theories of crime however they apply them differently to highlight situational variables which leads the individual to weigh the costs and benefits of their crime(s). ...

Words: 828 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Recidivism In Prisons

...individual interests and abilities. As we can see, employment is not only essential to fulfill one’s basic needs, but it also plays a major role in rebuilding self-esteem, developing a conventional lifestyle, and creating a sense of belongingness in the community. Most “turning point” perspectives believe that life-course transitions such as marriage or employment can lead to behavioral change and less re-offense in the lives of criminal offenders. According to this perspective, life-course transitions are unlikely to result in lasting changes in behavior without strong personal desire to undertake a conversion effort. Besides, the theory of cognitive transformation argues that objective changes in life circumstances may contribute to desistance as long as they are preceded by an internalized commitment to change. ...

Words: 940 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Substance Abuse In Prisons

...they tend to resort back to their old lifestyles. However, offenders who are able to secure employment are often working at least 40 hour per week, and occupied engaging in enjoyable activities with law-abiding citizens, and thus, have less time to associate with deviant peers and engage in criminal activities (Davis et al., 2012; Keena & Simmons, 2015). Additionally, Keena & Simmons (2015) argued that employment enables ex-prisoners to be productive, take care of their families, develop valuable life skills, and strengthen their self-esteem and social connectedness. Studies suggest that employment can aid in preventing recidivism but a lack of financial stability may significantly affect the ability of many ex prisoners to maintaining desistance and successfully reintegrate (Davis et al., 2012; Pogrebin et al., 2014). Substance Abuse Substance abuse along with limited education and unemployment has been cited as the most influential factors which often interact to limit chances for successful reintegration (Hunter et al, 2016; Keena & Simmons, 2015). Studies indicate that drug abuse among offenders is prevalent. Davis et al. (2012) reported that among prison inmates in the United States, 73 percent used drugs regularly prior to their incarceration. Research suggests that despite of the severity, only few inmates will receive intensive substance abuse treatment while incarcerated (Ray et al., 2015). For example, Bender et al. (2016) argued that 45% of state prisons and 68% of jails...

Words: 1177 - Pages: 5

Free Essay


...Does Employment Reduce Recidivism? Elliott Markson Do individuals who obtain employment upon release likely to stay crime-free or are they going to commit another crime? The main purpose of this research is explanatory. It is explanatory because researching the issues surrounding employment and recidivism should be able to explain behavioral changes, a change in social status, and the effects that employment has on the individuals released from prison. The main independent variable of this research question is whether or not the released inmate will be employed or not upon release. The main dependent variable is whether or not the individual will return to their criminal behavior or not. The unit of analysis we will be studying is individual ex-offenders. Our goal will be to learn something about the population that we are studying and to gather information to identify certain common traits. Observations will be made using the longitudinal study method. Observations will be stretched over an extended period of time, and made twice a year for five years. The notion that having a job reduces the probability of recidivism is suitably confirmed throughout criminological literature. Employment offers the essential earnings for survival, increases self-esteem, advances the connection to a community, and progresses the impression of belonging to a group. Consequently, even if locating employment is strenuous for ex-offenders, a policy that aids these individuals in gaining...

Words: 2110 - Pages: 9