Free Essay

Difference Between Nurses with Different Level of Education

In: Other Topics

Submitted By shinto1
Words 1096
Pages 5
Difference between nurses with different level of education As nursing has become a highly competent profession, the educational opportunities for nurses have increased significantly. The hospitals and other organizations that provide health care are also competing with each other and now the demand for nurses with bachelor degree is increasing. For decades the American Nurses association and the National League for nursing have attempted to make the BSN the only educational program for RNs in the US. This essay focuses on the difference in the competencies between nurses prepared at the associate-degree level versus the baccalaureate-degree level in nursing. Studies have shown that the higher educated RNs have a better overall patient satisfaction, better outcomes related to medical condition, and a lower overall cost of care. According to Williams, (1995) a study conducted by Little and Brian, indicates that higher education enhances the personal and professional growth during and after graduation. The article also indicates that as per the study conducted by Whalen nurses with baccalaureate degree had a strong bureaucratic and professional orientation. Some studies indicated that the more number of nurses with bachelor degree are members of professional organization where as very few nurses with associate degree have membership in professional organizations (Williams). The trend in nursing is going professional. Professional nursing in the hospital setting in particular is associated with a bachelor’s degree. Surveys shows that most hospitals prefer to hire nurses with bachelor’s degrees, though they often cannot find enough. Lawmakers in several states, including New York, New Jersey have introduced bills that would require at least some hospital staff nurses to have bachelor’s degree with in 10 ears. The American association of colleges of nursing emphasizes that education has a great impact on the knowledge and skills of the nurse clinician. According to the American association of colleges of nursing, nurses with bachelor’s degree in nursing are well prepared to meet the demands placed on the nurses today (Rosseter, 2010). The associate degree in nursing is short in duration as compared to bachelors’ degree in nursing which is a four year course where as the former is as short as two years. The BSN curriculum is formulated not only with technical skills but also leadership and managerial skills. There fore, the BSN nurses can easily take up management positions where as the ADN nurses may find difficult to take up. BSN nurses also have more autonomy in the medical field because with their knowledge they are more efficient take critical decisions on their own (Academic writing tips.org, 2011). Baccalaureate degree in nursing provides much more emphasis to critical thinking skills for the students and by having better critical thinking skills nurses can meet the needs of their patients within their context, and considering their preferences. One’s ability to think critically can be affected by age, length of education (e.g., an associate vs. a baccalaureate decree in nursing), and completion of philosophy or logic subjects (Benner, Ronda, & Molly). Therefore, nurses with experience may be able to use critical thinking skills efficiently as the critical thinking skills can be improved with past experience. When comparing two new grads with different levels of nursing education such as associate and BSN, the BSN nurse may be able to take the decision effectively than the other new graduate nurse. With continues experience, both the nurses will learn to develop critical thinking skills, but doing so will be much easier for the one with higher educational background such as BSN. When working on the medical unit, a BSN nurse may be able to analyze and question or agree with a medical prescription after considering the patient’s history, condition, and age as well as dietary requirements and restrictions. The BSN nurse is able to do so because she has some knowledge on how to integrate facts about age, pharmacology, diet and exercise in enhancing the recovery process, in other words a BSN nurse is whole rounded and well informed compared to an ADN nurse(Academic writing tips.org, 2011). On a telemetry floor when two new nurses, each with different educational background, that is BSN and ADN started working, it was noted that they both competed with each other in terms of the patient care skills. In regards to critical thinking skills such as collecting all the necessary information, prior to calling the doctor, or making appropriate decisions in a patient emergency, was noted to be more prominent in the nurse with BSN degree when compared to the ADN nurse. Even though their skills are not comparable with the experienced nurses the nurse with BSN was able to develop the critical thinking skills faster and work more efficiently. The BSN nurse also exhibited leadership skills, and was motivated and enthusiastic to learn more. When a post angioplasty patient was bleeding from the groin site, the two above mentioned new nurses went into the room, and the AND nurse was noted to go out to call an experienced nurse for help. At the same time, the BSN nurse stayed with the patient even though did not know what to do, and used the phone in the room to call for help which is more appropriate and safety of the patient. Healthcare is progressing toward advance degrees. The BSN is really an entry level now. The bachelor degree in nursing provides the nurses with critical thinking, leadership and management skills along with the basic knowledge that the associate degree provides. As the health care is getting more and more competent, and the nursing is advancing day by day, nurses with higher education are in demand as the efficiency of the nurses increases with higher education. Completing bachelor degree opens door for further expanding the career as well as education. Therefore, getting baccalaureate degree in nursing is always beneficial to the individual and the society.

References Academic writing tips.org (2011). Disparities in competencies between BSN and ADN, RN nurses. Retrieved 03/30/2012, from accademicwritingtips.org/component.
Benner, P., Ronda, H. G., & Molly, S. Clinical reasoning, critical thinking and action: thinking critically and clinically. In Patient safety and quality: an evidence- based hand book for nurses: AHRQ publication. Retrieved on 03/30/2012 from http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/nurseshdbk/docs/BennerP_CRDA.pdf
Rosseter, R. (2010),. American Association of College Nursing: The impact of education on nursing practice, retrieved on 10th January, 2011 fromhttp://www.aacn.nche.edu/Media/FactSheets/ImpactEdNp.htm
Williams, M. J. (1995). A comparison of self perceptions of professionalism of Diploma, Associate degree, and Articulated BSN, RN Graduate. Miami, An Arbor: MI.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Differences in Competencies

...Differences in Competencies between Nurses Based on Degree Level Name University Introduction Nursing profession has many levels of education from more than forty years like, the diploma nurses, technical nurses, professional nurses, master level degree nurses and doctorate degree nurses. In 1965 the committee on nursing education of the American Nurses Association (ANA) published a position paper which addressed the different levels of education for registered professional nurses. Different Approaches to Nursing Education There are three different approaches to nursing education: I. 3-year diploma program, administered at hospitals. II. 3-year associate degree usually offered at community colleges. III. 4-year baccalaureate degree offered at senior colleges and universities. Baccalaureate nursing programs encompass the entire curriculum in associate degree and diploma programs, and also vide in-depth treatment of the physical and social sciences, nursing management, nursing research, public and community health, and the humanities. The Baccalaureate nursing programs enhances the student’s professional development, develops the new nurse for a more liberal scope of practice, and provides the nurse with a better understanding of the cultural, political, economic, and social issues that affect patients and determine health care delivery. Throughout the last decennium, policymakers and practice leaders have recognized that education makes a......

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The Differences Between Adn and Bsn Nurses

...The Differences Between ADN and BSN Nurses Grand Canyon University: NRS-430v 5/01/16 For those not working in the healthcare field, the profession of nursing can cause a lot of confusion. There are multiple different certifications or degrees that get lumped into many peoples’ idea of nursing. For example, there are certified nursing assistants (CNAs), licensed practical nurses (LPNs), associate-level nurses (ADNs), baccalaureate-level nurses (BSNs), masters-level nurses (MSNs), doctorate level nurses (PhDs) and (APRNs) and many different types of specialty certifications. All of these different levels of nursing require varying levels of schooling and certification. For the purposes of this paper the discussion will focus on the differences in competency levels between ADNs and BSNs. Schooling One big difference between the associates nurse and the bachelors nurse is the length of time to get the degree. To get an associate’s degree, the schooling is usually done through a junior college or community college and completed within 2-3 years. On the other hand, the BSN is done through a traditional university and completed within 4 years. This difference in the length of time has made the ADN very popular because you get to start working and making money much more quickly. Also the ADN is much cheaper since you are in school for less time. The BSN has all of the same courses as an ADN, however, the education goes much more in depth. The additions of nursing......

Words: 1049 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Nurse Preparedness

...Nurse Preparedness: ADN vs BSN Grand Canyon University June 7, 2015 Nurse Preparedness: ADN vs BSN In the early 1980’s though 2000 a shortage within the nursing field came to peak within the healthcare industry. For over 50 years the associate’s degree had significantly addressed the needs of nurses and nursing staff. However, with the rapid technological advancement of medical diagnosis and treatment, the competencies between nurses with an associate’s degree and a baccalaureate degree became the focus of the healthcare industry. With a demand for higher educational hospitals, a link between patient care and the education levels of nursing staff; the question was, are the competency levels adequate for the nurse with an associate’s degree? Though in writings, there have been no real major differences that are noted between the cognitive abilities of nursing students within baccalaureate degree programs and associate degree programs. Baccalaureate nurses are generally perceived as being better prepared for a wide range of nursing competencies and are seen as performing in the professional role for which they have been prepared during their education. Associate degree nurses are seen as performing well in the technical role for which they have been prepared in their education. In general, nurses were seen as performing in the roles for which they had been educationally prepared (Davis-Martin, 1990). I read an article in the Journal of......

Words: 762 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Education Prep.

...Introduction Education is must for every individual in this world; it’s the step stone of knowledge and learning. Education can make difference in one’s life by providing the respect and well career advancement for their future. People often call uneducated person illiterate; without an education a person waste his whole life. Education is a form of learning, usually transferred from one generation to other. It is provided through teaching, training, or research. One chooses his or her career to earn what they want. Every career is different, and they are different in their competencies. Nursing education is another career people choose to go for; they also have different competencies. Licensed vocational nurse has different competencies than associate degree nursing; and Baccalaureate degree different than associate degree nursing. In this paper, we are going to discuss the differences in competencies between nurses prepared at the associate-degree level versus the baccalaureate-degree level in nursing. Competencies Differences The associate program is usually 2-3 years long and it is usually offered at the community colleges. The associate degree nursing students usually learn the knowledge, and skills. These skills are required to care for individuals and families during illness and recovery after medical treatment. ADN nurses practice a more restricted level of nursing care such as skilled nursing and long term care facilities, corrections and clinics. The associate......

Words: 958 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Adn vs Bsn

...Running ahead: Differences in Competencies between Nurses Prepared at the Associate Degree Level Versus the Baccalaureate Degree Level 1 Associates Degree Nursing Education vs. Baccalaureate Degree Nursing Education: Differences in Clinical Practice Suja Kuruvilla Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V Professor Lorraine Hoover September 2, 2012 Health care is a field that is changing dramatically. Many practicing nurses have various degrees in nursing like Associate Degree, Diploma, Baccalaureate and Master’s degree.  Due to the varying levels of education and training, differences exist between the nurses prepared with an Associate degree (ADN) when compared to those nurses who have trained in a Baccalaureate degree (BSN).  Though nurses getting these degrees have their differences in preparation, nurses earning these degrees have adequate theoretical and clinical learning experiences.  The license qualifying examination for many states- National Council Licensure Examination (NCLEX) - does not differentiate between ADN and BSN degree prepared nurses and allows nurses with both degrees to take the licensing examination after completion of the degree regardless of the educational background of the applicant.  The differences in competencies between nurses prepared with an ADN compared to those prepared with a BSN include the quality of training and......

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Differences in Competencies Between Associate Degree and Bacculaurate Degree

...Differences in competencies between nurses with associate degree verses baccalaureate degree level Is there a difference in the thinking and processing of a nurse with baccalaureate degree and associate degree? According to the researches that were done in the past, there are difference in competencies between Baccalaureate nursing and associate nursing. Performance in nursing care by well educated nursing is higher than one with lesser education. A role of nursing is to help provide healthy and safe environment So that a person can live in an optimal health. Practice of nursing requires good theoretical understanding of health, diseases and their management. It would also need competence in technical skills, critical thinking process organization and time management. How does a nurse get all these qualities? Some of these qualities can be obtained from nursing education and some from experience. What is a competency? “Competencies are outcomes of an educational process, and they also describe the kind of personal abilities most nurse educators are seeking to develop in students, and administrators are seeking to select for and develop on the job” (Alverno College Faculty, 1976; Alverno CollegeNursingFaculty, 1985; Mentkowski & Doherty, 1984). According to this definition competencies are attained by education and experience. Faculty is responsible to evaluate the competency of a nursing student. Competencies can be tested by giving a scenario and see how the......

Words: 807 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Associate Degree vs Bsn Nursing

...Differences and in Competencies between Nurses Prepared at Associate-Degree versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing Yolanda Youngblood Grand Canyon University Some will argue that there is Avast difference between nurses that possess a BSN vs those that possess an AND. Nurses with a BSN when compared to nurses with a AND display apparent variances and likenesses when the amount of education in various programs, the years required to obtain a degree, how educational/degree rankings affect delivery of patient’s care and effect, and the various requirements needed for licensing where all analyzed. It is understood that nurses with a BSN and nurses with a AND are held to the same standards, have the same responsibilities and liabilities, and usually work in the same healthcare settings. Nevertheless; a nurse’ professional experience, work setting, and level of education could possibly create a difference in the manner in which said nurse might administer patient care, handle stressful scenarios, and work towards their career trajectory. The direction in which modern technology and the healthcare industry are heading in a nurse’ level of education should be brought to the forefront. There isn’t substantial evidence to prove that nurses with BSNs are better equipped than nurses with ADNs, but there are those in the healthcare sector that are leaning towards requiring nurses to have their BSNs. A BSN is vastly encouraged in......

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Educational Preparation

...Running head: EDUCATION PREPARATION PAPER Education Preparation Paper Dimple Patel Grand Canyon University: NRS 430v August 19, 2012 Education Preparation Paper Teaching someone how to drive a car for the first time can be challenging because the driver has no knowledge about the rules of the roads and laws, but as the driver learns the rules and practices, then they become a safer driver (Hill, 2010). Similarly are the different levels of nursing. The new driver can be compared to the associate degree nurse (ADN) and as knowledge is mastered, the nurse continues to a baccalaureate degree (BSN) and then to an advanced practice degree (APN). The progression of academic experience promotes higher levels of patient care (Spencer, 2008). The purpose of this paper is to use scholarly research to discuss the difference in competencies between nurses prepared at the ADN level verses the BSN level, using a patient care situation to describe differences in approach to nursing care. First we will define the difference in competencies between an ADN, BSN, and APN. Differences in Competencies Educational levels in nursing hold different competencies. All nurses must pass a state board exam, regardless of their educational level, to enter the profession. There are four levels of nursing which include the ADN, BSN, APN, and clinical nurse leader (CNL). Although the CNL will not be discussed, the ADN, BSN, and APN......

Words: 1154 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Future of Nursing

...Write a formal paper of 750-1,000 words that addresses the following: 1. Discuss the differences in competencies between nurses prepared at the associate-degree level versus the baccalaureate-degree level. 2. Identify a patient care situation in which you describe how nursing care or approaches to decision-making may differ based upon the educational preparation of the nurse (BSN versus a diploma or ADN degree). Refer to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) Fact Sheet: Creating a More Highly Qualified Nursing Workforce as a resource. Prepare this assignment according to the APA guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, Within the nursing profession, education is an essential component to the training and preparedness of nurses. This is also true with all healthcare providers as education provides the necessary tools and resources for personnel to complete tasks. The following paper will discuss the differences between an Associate degree in nursing and a Baccalaureate degree in nursing including each degrees’ implications in competencies. Additionally, to further explore these differences, a case scenario will be provided to demonstrate differences in decision making between each level of education. Associates Degree A nurse receiving his or her associate’s degree implies that they have undergone a minimum of two years of training and education. This can be achieved at most colleges including community colleges. Additionally, in order to......

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Educational Preparation

...Educational Preparation: The Differences in Competencies Between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree Level Versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing Eric Bradford Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V Professional Dynamics June 16th, 2013 Educational Preparation: The Differences in Competencies Between Nurses Prepared at the Associate-Degree Level Versus the Baccalaureate-Degree Level in Nursing Throughout the United States there a two basic nursing programs one can complete to become a licensed nurse. There are associate degree programs (or an ADN program) and bachelors degree programs (or BSN programs) available to students willing to complete either program. There are multiple differences between the two programs and the objectives and competencies taught in each degree. A few differences between those competencies will be discussed in this paper along with a patient care situation involving the decision-making skills between a nurse prepared at the baccalaureate level and associate level. The first difference between the two degrees is the multiple studies on nursing education linked to patient outcomes. These studies all show that the hospitals with a higher percentage of nurses baccalaureate level of nursing resulted in a lower mortality rate for their patients. In the January 2007 Journal of Advanced Nursing they reported findings that indicated just a 10% increase in the proportion of nurses who held a bachelor’s degree resulted in 9 fewer......

Words: 947 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Title

...returning from the dark side to vanquish the evil Emperor by means of hurling the villain over a rail to unseen depths and certain death. In the case of Bachelors level nursing compared to Associates level nursing however, there really is no good versus evil to compare. There is no dark versus light there is just a different level of attained educational degree. The question is what does the difference in education level provide in the level of competency of each nurse. The aim of this paper is to discuss what is the definition of competency in nursing and how is it measured, what are the advantages in nursing care for associates and bachelors degree care, and how do the differences in educational level affect overall patient outcomes. What is competency in nursing? The American Nurses Association, or ANA, defines competency by stating, “competency is an expected level of performance that results from an integration of knowledge, skills, abilities, and judgment” (ANA 2004). A nurses’ ability to provide proficient and safe care at the bedside in any setting demonstrates competence. This statement is true for associates and bachelors level education alike. When comparing a BSN level educated nurse to an ADN level associated nurse, how can the two be compared in terms competency. One indicator that measures a nurses’ level of competency is the NCLEX-RN. Passing an NCLEX-RN...

Words: 1686 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Diff in Compet in Adn and Bsn

...DIFFERENCES IN COMPETENCIES BETWEEN NURSES PREPARED AT ASSOCIATE DEGREE LEVEL VS BACCALAURATE LEVEL. The development in research and advancement in technology demands highly qualified individuals in many professions especially in the health care industry There are three ways to become an RN such as a nursing diploma program offered by hospitals. 2 -year associate degree usually offered at community colleges and a 4 year baccalaureate in nursing offered at colleges and universities. After World war II, demand for nurses grew dramatically in United States to meet the severity of the shortage. The faculty was forced to develop new entry level nursing program to prepare nurse technicians in a two year associate degree. (Creasia, 2011). In this paper, we are going to discuss the differences in competencies between a nurse who holds an associate degree versus a baccalaureate degree. Education differences between associate and baccalaureate degree nursing In addition to all the course work taught in associate degree nursing, BSN nurses are taught more "in depth treatment of physical and social sciences, nursing, research, public health, community health, nursing management and humanities" (Rosseter , 2013). These additional courses make a BSN nurse to grow in their profession, and to better understand cultural, political ,economic and social issues that affect patient and influence healthcare. So these different level graduate nurses perform from the same......

Words: 760 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Educational Preparation

...While there was not a formal education program when nursing was in its infancy, the need for higher and continuing education has grown exponentially. There are many pathways to choose to enter the field of nursing. Healthcare has had many changes and much advancement. The field continues to evolve on a daily basis. The needs of people are more complex, nurses have a lot of responsibility, and the need for a nurse with a higher education is in demand. There are differences between nurses prepared at a higher level of education, and the care that is delivered may also be affected depending on level of education. There are many differences between the nurse who has been prepared at the associate degree level and the nurse who has been prepared at the baccalaureate degree level. One big difference is what is viewed as critical content in the curriculum. Nursing educators from both the associate degree and baccalaureate degree programs agreed that important content for curriculum include, “nursing process, caring, communication, ethics, accountability, aging, and cultural diversity” (Meyer, 1997). However, BSN nursing educators also included “critical thinking, health teaching, leadership, and professionalism as essential components” (Meyer, 1997). Patient outcomes are better when nurses have continued their education beyond the diploma or associate degree. Many research studies have shown that mortality rates are lower when a higher number of nurses hold a BSN degree or higher......

Words: 995 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Educational Preparation

...Patel Grand Canyon University: NRS-430V May 11, 2014 The differences in competencies between the Registered Nurse who is completing the ADN versus the BSN are many. In this country there are two types of Registered Nurses: the Registered Nurse who graduates from an Associate Degree program and the Registered Nurse who graduates from the Baccalaureate Degree program. Both types of RNs take the National Council Licensure Examination also known as the NCLEX-RN. The results of the NCLEX-RN examination determines if the nurse has the technical competency to practice nursing. What the exam does not determine is the difference between graduates who have different levels of education. Although the passing rate for the exam is the same among the two groups of nurses, it is not proof that there are no differences between the two groups. The length of the ADN program is two years, while the BSN program is four years. The ADN is the shorter, faster path to obtaining RN licensure. Both types of Registered Nurses have the same license. Although both types of RNs may go through similar clinical training and have a similar income, there are differences in their educational and professional training as well as in their level of competency. The associate degree program’s emphasis is on clinical skills that are required to work in a hospital or clinic setting. The RN is trained to be task oriented. Education and competency are confined to hands on patient care. The......

Words: 813 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Discussing Competancies Between Adn and Bsn

...Discussing the differences in competencies between nurses prepared At the ADN level versus the BSN level in nursing Kelly Ann Willis Grand Canyon University: Professional Dynamics NRS-43OV 02/09/14 Professor Tish Dorman Discussing the differences in competencies between nurses prepared At the ADN level versus the BSN level in nursing The differences in competencies between nurses prepared at the Associates degree in nursing versus the Bachelor’s degree in nursing is one of advanced critical thinking on behalf of the BSN nurse. The Associates degree nurse is more task oriented. While the Bachelor’s degree nurse is more focused on the plan of care from beginning of admission to discharge needs. While both of these mindsets are a part of nursing theory, as we progress we are able to take our task knowledge and incorporate the advance critical thinking skills that are needed for a more positive outcome for the patient by becoming BSN’s. When we come out of our NCLEX testing modes, According to the (Nursing(AACN)) we may all pass the exams but have a much different level of understanding and ability for the practice of nursing. The NCLEX tests for the lowest amount of competency of a nurse to enter the employment field. Not that we are as advanced as possible in our skill sets. We as nurses have to advance our education base by experience and education. The difference in how an ADN nurse sees a patient and how a BSN nurse sees a patient are measurable when we......

Words: 989 - Pages: 4