Free Essay

Law - Negligence

In: Business and Management

Submitted By eec6
Words 654
Pages 3
Chapter 6 – Negligence
Case 1

Submitted to: Chantelle Troy
Submitted by: Elaine Crocker, Justine Byrne and Brandon Noelle
March 12th, 2014

The plaintiff, Dean Zastowny, had been incarcerated after committing a number of crimes to support his drug habit. While imprisoned he was sexually assaulted by a prison officer. Zastowny then developed personality disorders such as low self-esteem, anti-social behaviour, and sexual anxiety. After being released the conditions remained and Zastowny found ease in the use of heroin; he continued to lead a life of crime. After spending 12 years in prison Zastowny had decided to sue the prison guard and the province. The defendants (prison guard and the province) admitted liability. The trial judge states that if the sexual assault did not occur Zastowny would not have become addicted to heroin, and he would not have committed additional crimes leading to his return to prison. The judge also states that because of the sexual assault Zastowny developed personality disorders and was not able to obtain and hold a job. Therefore, Zastowny argues that he should be compensated for income loss of the past 15 years, and for the future.
The plaintiff, Dean Zastowny is in the position of suing the prison guard and the province (as the guard’s employer) for the intentional tort of sexual assault. Zastowny is requesting compensation for all of the income that he has lost during the past 15 years spent in jail. He is also requesting compensation for the future since his personality problems continue to exist and he will most likely have difficulty maintaining a job.
The defendants, the prison guard and the province are being accused of sexual assault and have accepted liability. The prison guard committed the tort of negligence and is liable because the guard owed a duty of care, breached the standard of care and caused harm to the plaintiff. When compensating the plaintiff, the prison guard may pay or the province may.
The tort of negligence and the intentional tort of sexual assault are observed in Zastowny’s case. The tort of negligence determines whether the defendant can be held liable for carelessly causing injury to the plaintiff. The tort of negligence requires the plaintiff to prove that the defendant owed a duty of care, in that they were required to act carefully toward the plaintiff, breached the standard of care by acting carelessly, and caused harm to the plaintiff. An intentional tort is a deliberate act intended to injure others, or to interfere with another person’s rights. Sexual assault is committed when someone knowingly causes another person to engage in an unwanted sexual act by force or threat. I believe the judge should not award damages to Zastowny for all of the losses. Zastowny has a past of frequent drug use and was imprisoned for criminal acts that he had done before he was sexually assaulted. While being imprisoned from his own actions he was sexually assaulted. If he had not been imprisoned perhaps he might not have been in the situation. However, it is not Zastowny’s fault that he was sexually assaulted, but the matter may have been prevented if he did not commit previous crimes. I believe Zastowny should be compensated for the sexual assault because he suffered and is still suffering from low self-esteem, anti-social behaviour and sexual anxiety. Zastowny should not be compensated for the amount of time he spent in prison for crime that he has committed because he has a past of drug use and he could have received help after the incident happened. If the case were to go to court, the judge would most likely be in the plaintiffs favor because it is the workers responsibility as well as the institutions to make sure all inmates are safe. Also, criminals have rights that remain the same as any other person and should not be disregarded because of criminal actions.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Law Negligence

...(Thursday). 1. Describe TWO situations where a potential Plaintiff would have little or no difficulty in establishing a duty of care. (2 marks) 2. Explain in brief any TWO of the following Tests in Negligence. (3 marks for each test) State the Element of Negligence under which the Test is explained. (1 mark for each test). (Maximum 8 marks) a. The Reasonable Man Test b. The But For Test c. The Neighbour’s Test d. The Reasonable foreseeability Test 3. Under the first element of Negligence, state ONE key point on the concept of ‘foreseeability’ with an example; (3 marks) and explain the 2-stage test in words or using a flow-chart. (2 marks) What is the purpose of this test? (2 mark) (Maximum 7 marks) 4. How can you as a member of the public assist in the law-making process? (2 marks) 5. What is the meaning of ‘gazetted’? (2 marks) 6. Share three differences between Law and Morality. (3 marks) 7. Explain in brief any TWO concepts of ‘Rule of Law’; ‘Judicial Precedence’; or ‘office of profit’ under the Constitution of Singapore. (2 marks each) (Maximum 4 marks) 8. State the sources of law in Singapore (3 marks). Provide two salient features of any TWO sources of law (2 marks each) (Maximum 7 marks)...

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Aspect of Law and Negligence

...01.2013 | | | Aspect of contract and negligence | | Aspect of contract and negligence | Acknowledgement I would like to express my gratitude to Mr.Frank Gunasekara who gave me the possibility to complete this assignment and for the guidance and support they gave in preparation of this study. Especially, I would like to give my special thanks to my parents who enabled me to complete this work. However, it would not have been possible without the kind support and help from my friends. Last but not the least I would like to thank all our peers and staff at I.C.B.T and specially Mr.Dilum our coordinator who were ready to lend a hand in whatever way they can. I am making this project not only for marks but also to increase my knowledge. Thanks again to all who helped me. Executive Summary The reason of this study is to learn the basic legal principles for which we can use in the practical aspect of business. Also from the case studies which is given is very helpful for practical day to day issues. This study is focused on non-lawyers therefore we should give a clear picture of the concepts such as the contracts, negligence torts , breach of conditions etc. this is also helpful to understand and learn the legal terms used in business contracts. This study helped me to understand the key elements of a business contract, Tort of Negligence and also the consequences of breach, and also to apply the rules and laws for practical scenarios.......

Words: 4431 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay


...for such torts as negligence, product liability and defamation. For most businesses such torts are better handled before they happen. Companies make sure many issues are addressed in the company policy and regulations manuals when new employees are hired as well as in training sessions for topics such as sexual harassment and safety. For a Company such as Firestone Tires and Rubber for example, one type of negligence could be Negligent Hiring. If an employee in a supervisory position verbally abuses another or in an extreme case, assaults another employee with a tire iron used in the performance of his duties, the victim could claim negligent hiring on the part of the company where they both were employed. This could be the case if the aggressive supervisor has had a history of this type of behavior at a previous place of employment. This begs us to ask the question: Has the company made enough effort to fulfill its obligation of providing a safe working environment for its employees? As it was touched on before there are measures that can be taken before something like this happens. For one, the hiring manager could have followed up on references to possibly find out if the candidate for employment has had a history of violence in the workplace, or perhaps public criminal records could have been investigated to check whether any evidence of crimes exist on the potential candidate for employment involving violence. Another two forms of negligence that could......

Words: 992 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Negligence in Healtcare Law

...MBA 5101 Unit 1 Case Study Gary Campbell Our text defines a tort as “a civil wrong” and negligence as “a tort, a civil or personal wrong” (Pozgar, 2012). Negligence as it is related to healthcare is an unintentional commission or omission of an act that a reasonably prudent person or organization would or would not do under normal circumstances. Not following a recognized standard of care could be considered negligence. The case I have chosen to study is one from the Circuit Court of Baltimore City Maryland and is that of Enso Martinez a minor by and through his parent (Rebecca Fielding) vs The Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore Maryland July 2013. I would describe this as a landmark, “David vs Goliath” case involving medical negligence in the form of nonfeasance and malpractice. Reckless and willfulness disregard for safety is called criminal negligence and is often considered a form of gross negligence, a more serious tort (Pozgar, 2012). The question in my mind throughout the read was; “did the conduct of the provider and the hospital constitute criminal negligence”? The jury’s verdict and plaintiff’s award seemed to suggest yes. As a health professional, while I might agree with the Jury’s decision, I’m not so sure I agree with the size of the award. Did Johns Hopkins Hospital (the Hospital), negligently fail to perform a timely Caesarean section, causing Martinez to suffer from cerebral palsy, retardation, and other disorders. The following......

Words: 2082 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

School Sport Injuries and Negligence

...decades, more tort cases have been filed. A tort concerns civil wrongs and address the duty, breach and injury sustained to one individual as a result of another's conduct. The premise is that a person who is injured could be able to recover something from the person who injured him or her. Usually, in a tort case, injured parties typically seek monetary damages. In an educational setting, tort law is the prevalent area of the law that subjects educators to personal liability. There are a variety of torts, which can basically be divided into three types of torts: (1) intentional torts, the intent to do harm to a person, (2) negligent torts, no intent to do harm to a person but to fail to exercise proper care and (3) strict liability, actions that causes damages regardless if the person is not at fault or negligent. Of the three categories, intentional and negligent torts tend to be more common types of tort actions in school sports settings. However, the vast majority of tort liabilities applicable to school situations are based on negligence. The tort of negligence is an unintentional tort that focuses on an individual's behavior or actions. It differs from intentional torts, which focuses on an individual's state of mind or intent. Normally, it is quite difficult to find a school or a coach liable for a student's injury during a sporting event. Recovering compensation...

Words: 1191 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Essay-You Decide Mgmt 597

...everything. At the dinner, John called Coleman fat, and he responded by punching John in the eye and causing severe damage. Jimmy’s mom, John, Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar (partnership owned by 5 partners), and the jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the damages caused by their employee. There are some questions or problems arising from this situation. First of all, Software Inc. needed to give Coleman the final interview upon as establish on Software Inc. employee’s contract. Can Coleman win this termination sue? Also if the incidents happened during the time that Coleman was supposed to be doing duties related to his job, Is Software Inc. liable for anything that happened in reference to Jimmy’s bar partners including his mom? The same law should be applied to both cases? About the incidents occurred with John at his dinner; John sued Software Inc. for the injuries suffered. Will John win his lawsuit? As CEO or head of HR, what...

Words: 990 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Palsgraf V. the Long Island Rsiroad Company

...Franco Chuquilin Business Law 1. Tort - Torts are civil wrongs recognized by law as grounds for a lawsuit. These wrongs result in an injury or harm constituting the basis for a claim by the injured party. While some torts are also crimes punishable with imprisonment, the primary aim of tort law is to provide relief for the damages incurred and deter others from committing the same harms. The injured person may sue for an injunction to prevent the continuation of the tortious conduct or for monetary damages. 2. International Tort – a category of torts that describes a civil wrong resulting from an international act. 3. Negligence – Conduct that falls below the standards of behavior established by law for the protection of others against other people. 4. Strict Liability – Liability without fault. Franco Chuquilin Business Law Palsgraf v. The Long Island Railroad Company 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. 99, Wed 1928 N.Y. Lexis 1269 Court of Appeals of New York, 1928 Key Facts * Mrs. Palsgraf was standing on a Long Island Railroad train platform when two men ran to catch a train.  * The second man was carrying a small package containing fireworks. He was helped aboard the train by one guard on the platform and another on the train. The man dropped the package which exploded when it hit the tracks. * The shock of the explosion caused scales at the other end of the platform many feet away to fall, striking and injuring Palsgraf. ...

Words: 702 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Nadel Et Al V Burger King Corp

...MGMT 520 Week 3 Assignment Nadel et al. v. Burger King Corp. & Emil, Inc. case 1. What court decided the case in the assignment? (2 points) COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO, FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT, HAMILTON COUNTY 2. According to the case, what must a party establish to prevail on a motion for summary judgment? (3 points) Emil moved for summary judgment, claiming that no genuine issue of material fact existed. BK also moved for summary judgment and pointed to evidence in the depositions that appellants knew the coffee was hot and that coffee was purchased and served as a hot beverage. It also contended under the circumstances that Evelyn's and Paul's actions were intervening, superseding causes precluding any actionable negligence on its part. 3. Briefly state the facts of this case, using the information found in the case in LexisNexis. (5 points) Christopher Nadel received second degree burns from coffee spilling on his right foot purchased at Burger King by his grandmother Evelyn Nadel. The Nadel’s brought suit against Burger King and franchise owner Emil, Inc, for product liability for a defectively designed product and for failure to warn of the dangers of handling a liquid served as hot as their coffee. The court granted both the Burger King owner and Burger King Corporation request for motion of summary of judgments. The Nadel’s appealed. The court affirmed in part and reversed in part. The summary judgment was wrongly granted on the products......

Words: 1465 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Tort Reform

...and relations be it by laws or morals or both. Ivan Nuy, an author who developed the Social Control Theory in 1958, proposed that there are four types of social control: Internal, Indirect, Control with Needs Satisfaction and Direct. Social Control Theory proposes that people's relationships, commitments, values, norms, and moral beliefs encourage them not to break the law. Thus, if moral codes are internalized and individuals are tied into, (their) community, they will voluntarily limit their propensity to commit deviant acts. [ (Nuy, 1958) ] Law is needed for when comfort, morals and disapproval fail to prevent undesirable acts against people in a society. In our country’s system, we have two main types of classifications for justice, civil law and criminal law. Criminal law, under public law, covers laws and regulations that aim to protect all members of the society. Its emphasis is on punishment. Criminal offenders are prosecuted by government officials, who must provide “the burden of proof” to prove the guilt of the defendant beyond a reasonable, doubt, usually a district attorney or attorney general, and can be punished with fines, imprisonment or even death. Civil law, under private law, covers the rights and duties of individuals among themselves. [ (Roberts, 1998) ] Civil law deals with disputes between individuals or organizations where compensation for the injury or wrongdoing may be awarded to the victim. The purpose of civil law is to...

Words: 1694 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Appellate Brief

...Appellate Brief Kate Voigt July 26, 2013 Professor Doug Simon MBA 660 The Legal and Ethical Environment of Management ______________ No. 1 ___________________________________ IN THE EIGHT CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS _____________________ MARY DEAREST, Petitioner, V. STATE OF MINNESOTA, Respondent, ___________________ IN REVIEW TO THE SUPREME COURT OF MINNESOTA ____________________ BRIEF FOR THE RESPONDENT ___________________ Kate Voigt 1678 Snelling Ave, Suite #987 St. Paul, MN 55108 (123) 456-7890 TABLE OF CONTENTS Table of Authorities………………………………………………………………………5 Statement of the Issues……………………………………………………………………6 Statement of the Case and Facts …………………………………………………..7 Argument…………………………………………………………………..7 Mr. Gonzalez should not be held negligent for leaving the matches on the sales table; they were set out of reach of children, in a position where he could see customers take them if he were to be standing behind the counter. …………………………7,8,9,10,11,12 THE RULING THAT MR. GONZALEZ SHOULD NOT BE HELD NEGLEGENT SHOULD STAND BECAUSE THERE WAS NO FORSEEABLE INJURY INVOLVED IN GIVING THE CUSTOMERS FREE MATCHES…………………………8,9,10 MR. GONZALEZ SHOULDN’T BE HELD NEGLEGENT FOR GIVING HIS CUSTOMERS FREE MATCHES BECAUSE IF THEY WERE DEFECTIVE, THERE SHOULD’VE BEEN A RECALL BUT SINCE THERE WAS NO KNOWN DEFECT, THE MATCHES CANNOT BE RECALLED……………………………………………..9, 10 The court should uphold the ruling due to the product not being defective in its design…..9,10,11,12 THE STATES PRODUCT......

Words: 3426 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Legal Writing

...IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, ABC COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION-LAW LUKE SPENCER & LAURA SPENCER : 100 Maple Street                                 : Anywhere, PA 19100                            :                         Plaintiff                          :               v.                                              :  No. 04-1234                                                         : GENERAL HOSPITAL                           : 200 City Avenue                                  : Anywhere, PA 19100                            :                         Defendant                      : PLAINTIFFS' MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS IN THE NATURE OF A DEMURRER Statement of Facts Laura Spencer was admitted to General Hospital on May 1, 2003. Lucky Spencer was delivered at 11:52 p.m. The following morning a nurse brought the baby into the plaintiff’s room in a rolling crib and then left. After about fifteen minutes of nursing, Laura feeling tired called the nurse to come and take the baby back to the nursery. When the nurse returned she was hurried and appeared tired. She picked up the baby to the transport him back to the nursery, but failed to put the baby into the rolling crib per hospital policy. Instead, she held the baby in one arm and attempted to open and close the door to plaintiff’s room. The nurse lost her grip and dropped the newborn on his head onto the floor. The plaintiff immediately......

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Recognizinig and Minimizing Tort and Regulatory Risk Plan

...Regulatory Risk Plan Law 531 Charles Cook January 24, 2011 Recognizing and Minimizing Tort and Regulatory Risk Plan For organizations to avoid detrimental situations that can create excessive loss for the business, it is imperative for them to Recognize and minimize the risks associated with torts. According to Henery Cheeseman, 2010, “Tort law imposes a duty on persons and business agents not to intentionally or negligently injure others in society”(Cheeseman, 2010). Developing a clear plan that reduces and eliminates any fines, penalties and tort liabilities will help the success of a business. Cheeseman (2010) states “Tort law imposes a duty on persons and business agents not to intentionally or negligently injure others in society” (Cheeseman. 2010). Plan elements Knowing the four elements of defending against negligence is fundamental to developing a preventative plan against negative effects of a tort. With foresight, a business can plan against the occurrence by superseding or intervening the event. Having knowledgeable team members who can determine whether or not the company is actually responsible for an event is essential. Assuming the risk of potential negligence can help to diminish the possibility of tort. Keeping a business team aware of what risks are possible and can help to avoid situations where a company knowingly enters into risky practices will keep businesses safe from liability. Finally, both contributory and comparative negligence are......

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Torts Cases (Scenario #1)

...Torts Cases Nathaniel Brown, Maxine Holley, Jacinta King, and Cheryl Williams BUS415/Business Law June 25, 2012 Monique Peebles Torts Cases A tort is “the French word for a ‘wrong’. Tort law protects a variety of injuries and provides remedies for them. Under tort law, an injured party can bring a civil lawsuit to seek compensation for a wrong done to the party or to the party’s property.” (Cheeseman, 2010, p. 95). Tort laws are enforced under civil law and help individuals recover damages incurred related to property damage or loss, medical expenses, restitutions for pain and suffering, and mental anguish. Team A will identify the tort actions in four scenarios, potential plaintiffs, potential defendants and why each one is viewed as a defendant. The team will also identify various elements of the tort claim that constitute the plaintiff’s claim, defenses the defendants may assert, and provide hypotheses as to how the claims might be resolved and the legal reasoning behind the hypothesis. Scenario One Daniel and Ruben are enjoying the day at a football game when Malik, a fan, reacts unexpectedly spilling beer on Ruben when the referee’s calls an incomplete pass. Daniel shoves and injures Malik when he falls against the railing, which gives way causing Malik’s face to hit the steps in the aisle knocking out two teeth. When leaving the game, Daniel, a diabetic, stops to buy diet drinks and a lady waiting in line smells beer on Ruben and begins shouting at Daniel,......

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Law Case

...To: Dr. DDT MEMORANDUM From: Dena Zapata Date: July 15, 2013 Re: Tammy Jones Case Tammy Jones is a 19 year old resident of Tillman County but appears to be at least 21. Tammy owns and uses a fake Oklahoma driver’s license which lists her age as 21. On the night of August 5, 2001, Tammy goes to a local tavern named Cooter’s Brew, a sole proprietorship located in Kiowa County. At Cooter’s Brew, Tammy is ready and willing to present her fake license to the bartender but he never asked for her identification because Tammy appeared to be old enough to consume alcohol, and having young, attractive females in the bar is good for business. The bartender is not the owner of the tavern, but the bartender has been trained by the owner to request identification from all patrons. Tammy orders and drinks numerous alcoholic beverages. When the bar closes, Tammy gets into her car to drive home even though she is beyond the legal limit of intoxication. Tammy’s friend, Lisa Lu, asks for a ride and Tammy happily obliges. Lisa is sober and knows that Tammy is intoxicated. After leaving the bar, Tammy and Lisa proceed northbound on Main Street toward Lisa’s house, where they have both decided to stay for the evening. Tammy is driving and she is traveling at a rate of 55 miles per hour. The speed limit on the streets in town is 35 miles per hour. At the same time, Sam Smith is traveling westbound in his pick-up truck on Broadway Avenue, a street that intersects Main Street. Sam...

Words: 1103 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Assisted Siucide

...Small Non-Profit Hospital in Crisis: Small non-profit Hospital Mark Good HSA 515 Dr. Griffin 04/24/2011 HSA 515 P. 2 An exchange of "legal consideration" whether it be financial or of another sort between the parties to a contractual arrangement is crucial for the agreement to be legally enforceable. Each of the parties to a legal agreement must give and receive something of value in order for the written arrangement to be legally enforceable. The 'something of value' may be either something that the person actually hands over (that they would not otherwise be indebted to hand over) or some right that they give up (that they would otherwise have been entitled to exercise). Is the Hospital Negligent or are the nurses negligent? The question of which entity to bring the lawsuit against, the hospital or the care givers, typically depends on the working arrangement or relationship of the physician to the hospital. If the staff member, including support staff, was directly employed by the hospital then the hospital itself would be considered liable. In most situations the staff included as hospital employees would encompass lab and hospital technicians, emergency room staff, paramedics and nursing staff. Doctors and other medical specialists, including surgeons, are typically subcontracted under the hospital and therefore may be held liable rather than the hospital. In some situations......

Words: 1521 - Pages: 7