Free Essay

Media Effects on Democracy

In: Other Topics

Submitted By Staceymcm
Words 1513
Pages 7
The media is too influential and this undermines democracy in the UK.
This paper will examine the above statement in regards to media undermining democracy. It will look at arguments both for and against, what influence the media has on our democracy, it will look in to media and government bias, refer to statistics along with some theories, this is to try and determine if behaviours and attitudes can be influenced by what we see and hear in the media. Other points that will be addressed include the effects of spin and how the media tends to deliver its information to its audience.
In todays society more or less everyone knows about the media. We as a nation tend to partake in some kind of media activity daily. It has been said that we take the modern media very much for granted as we are totally immersed in them. For example “Just as fish will be the last life form on earth to discover water, because they are completely surrounded by it and know of nothing else” (the new politics, 2007:301). There for it’s hard to imagine what life would be like without the daily paper, radio and tv.
Some allege that the effects of the media are strong and clearly visible, however others argue with equal conviction that the media have minimal or no direct effects (the new politics, 2007).
According to the reinforcement theory the media can only reinforce attitudes that already exist and this is down to two reasons markets and personality. They believe that the effects of mass media are minimal and only confirm what people already believe rather than influencing political life and attitudes. However Direct effect theorist say that the mass media can and do directly influence attitudes and behaviour, including voting behaviour. This in turn leads to the question of is media bias (developments in british politics). How ever before diving in to media bias it is important to understand the growth of the media from previous years. To try and demonstrate this fully here is a few contrasts between 1945 and modern times to consider.
In 1945 there was no tv in Britain. The BBC resumed its post war broadcast in 1946, with only 25,000 viewers. Now days though virtually every house hold owns at least one tv, and has instant access to over 100 chanels. On average British adults spend over 26 hours a week watching tv and half of the nation watch tv news seven days a week. In 1945 politicians mainly interacted with voters through the use of public meetings, newspapers and the radio. The newspapers were very thin and had little in depth analysis of politics and had little commentary. They didnt use opinion polls and reporting of parliamentary debates were limited. Modern papers on the other hand are glossy and fat. There political content is vastly larger, and they are far more party political than in 1945. Apparently three people read every newspaper sold, which means that 37 million read a daily paper. In 1945 about ten million households had a ‘wireless’(radio), but politicalbroadcasting was limited, and there was very little coverage of the 1945 election. Now there is more than 750 radio stations in the UK, and many of these stations include regular news updates. In 1945 the term ‘spin doctor’ had not even been invented. The government had a small handfull of press departments and offices, but nothing like the scale of nodern operations today.
It has been said that many people are convinced that the media are biased, how ever when considering the political bias of the media it is necessary to ascertain between print and electronic media. Electronic media are obliged to be politically balanced and unbiased, where as the news papers can be as partial and partisan as they wish. In relation to newspapers there are ten main publications. Amongst those ten the two most circulated are the Sun and the Times both who are owned by News International. In 2004 the Sun alone sold 3,378.000 and the Times sold 609,000 per day (developments in British politics). This shows the kind of audience these news prints reach, and more importantly showing how many people are exposed to the political views of just these two newspapers alone. This also raises the question of media ownership and does this matter (British Politics, Leach Page 150). There is seen to be a danger that the ownership of the media is being concentrated in too few hands. News International, owned by Rupert Murdoch, controls a large number of news and media organizations. There are concerns that, as a result, he is able as an individual to shape public opinion and influence voting behaviour. This can be seen as an indication that maybe the media do have to much influence when it comes to reporting in regards to political issues, especially if they are putting their own opinions or points of view across. There for this then suggest that certain stories that are covered could be portrayed or written in an unfairly biased way towards a certain political party. However in turn it has also been said that the media coverage of modern political issues makes the voters and readers in the UK more aware of what is going on in the different political parties and it helps them to make a more informed decision when the general elections take place (developments in British politics). Having said that statistics show that the British newspapers from much of the post war period, had been heavily conservative. The circulation of conservative newspapers outnumbered both Labour and Liberal papers. These statistics prove sympathies towards the conservatives, which in turn tends to be seen as backing up the theory of media bias (The new British politics).
Having considered this, Labour scored an exceptional victory in 1945, and went on to win again in 1964, 1966 and in 1974, all with most papers against it. Besides does the newspaper influence the voting of their readers or do the voters choose their paper to suit their own politics? In 1997 the Sun switched their support to Labour, at that time most sun readers voted Labour, and of course Labour duly won the election by far. But does this prove ‘it was the Sun wot won it’? Probably not. It was estimated that about 60 percent of Sun readers would have voted Labour anyway regardless of who the paper backed. However from the papers point of view it’s bad to run against the grain of your own readers. In any case so many individuals had firm voting intentions of their own and the newspaper effect may well have been small if even there at all (The new British politics).
There is also government bias and this tries to shape the news in two different formats. The first being suppression of news; On the one hand, freedom of information is relatively weakly protected in the UK and, on the other hand the official secret act is powerful. Compared with many other democracies, these two factors combined allow the British government a lot more room to manipulate in controlling information, news flows and keeping thing secret. And the second format being the manipulation of news; The government provides a large proportion of daily news usually done through press releases and tends to try and shape the news in its own interests, also more commonly known as ‘spin’.
Spin is a form of propaganda achieved through providing an interpretation of a campaign or event to persuade public opinion in favor or against a certain organization or public figure. A prime example of this would be Alistair Campbell. Alistair was a political editor at the daily mail, but after the 1997 election he took on the role of Tony Blair’s chief press advisor. It has been largely documented that he played an enormous part in the Labour party’s press releases. He was known for spinning stories that would in turn make the Labour party along with Tony Blair look good in the eyes and ears of their audience. He also had a powerful effect on what was broadcast or printed in certain news press, in an attempt to sway viewer’s opinion towards the Labour party. Having said that all political parties have press advisors who do the same thing to sway public perceptions and opinions (BBC news website).
Although there are strong views for both sides of the argument, it turns out to be extremely difficult to demonstrate the effects of media, even more so to measure them. There is no denying that yes the media is influential and in some cases this may seem to undermine democracy, but it could also be argued that it depends on the individual. If you have core beliefs that you stand by then other influences shouldn’t affect your decision. Given these difficulties it is scarcely surprising that experts disagree about the impact of the newspapers on politics, and more generally about the impact of mass media on politics.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Share-Service Argumentative Essay

...them to be produced by the same newsroom. These stations air the same footage, broadcasts, and stories which constricts diversity of the media. This has created conflict on whether or not these agreements should be allowed because they go against ownership limits. When brought to the attention of the Federal Communications Commision, they allowed it because no broadcast license had been exchanged; everything they had done was legal. The share-service agreement does however decrease the number of voices in the media, negatively impacting...

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Love

...Chapter 6  The media, government accountability, and citizen engagement  Katrin Voltmer  The past two decades or so have seen an unprecedented spread of democracy around the  globe.  With  the  fall  of  the  Berlin  wall  in  1989  and  the  end  of  the  Cold  War,  the  ‘third  wave’  of  democratization,  which  started  in  the  early  seventies,  now  encompasses  countries  in  Asia  and  Africa.1  And  even  in  states  whose  governments  continue  to  resist  a  more  open  and  participatory  form of governance, such as North Korea, Burma or Zimbabwe, the idea of democracy is a powerful  force that inspires people to take on a more active role in public life. However, many of the newly  emerging  democracies  seem  to  fall  short  of  some,  often  many,  of  the  basic  standards  that  define  democratic  rule,  with  irregular  voting  procedures,  corruption,  inefficiency  and  autocratic  styles  of  government  being  but  a  few  of  the  maladies.  In  addition,  as  many  of  the  newly  emerging  democracies belong to the developing world, inequality and poverty remain severe obstacles to full  self‐determination of the people.  The experiences of the past decades have shown that democracy is not a one‐way road and  that  a  viable  democracy  requires  more  than  the  implementation  of  the  key  institutions  of  government.  Rather,  an  accountable  and  efficient  government  is  embedded  in  a  complex  web  of  interdependent  conditions ......

Words: 10604 - Pages: 43

Premium Essay

The Role of Media in American Democratic Processes

...notion that a free media, and thus the flow of free information are necessary prerequisites to a functioning democracy. However, over time changes in the nature of mass media in the United States have lead to issues in the system that have raised questions as to the relationship between media and democracy. The concentration of media outlets in several seemingly omni-powerful conglomerates has made the media market less competitive than ever before, which has, in turn, had negative effects on the media in its capacity educator and informer. News outlets have moved farther and farther from political centricity, all while programming has been adjusted in an effort to maximize profit. The sum of these changes has been an increasingly skeptical public and an increasingly inhibitory media. Still, media output only matters because it bears significant influence on its audience. In the United States today the media plays a larger role than perhaps ever before. American households spend such a significant amount of time in the exposure of media that it is inevitable that they will be influenced by the media in some capacity. Furthermore, as the media has traditionally been relied upon as a sort of educator for the American public, the information delivered by the media carries significant powers of persuasion. For these reasons, it is necessary to consider and information that is transmitted from traditional mass media sources. Nevertheless, the role of the media is......

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Media and the 20th Century

...Media in the 20th Century John D. Allmon COM/156 March 3, 2013 Carey Rodriquez ------------------------------------------------- Media in the 20th Century I. To fully understand mass media, we need to come to grips with the enormous role that mass media has played in shaping that culture over the past one hundred years. With the development and evolution of mass media, there have been tremendous advantages and disadvantages that have contributed to major changes in society throughout the 20th century. However, these changes not only affect society but it has also affected the way business is done today. With the dawn of media convergence, globalization of media, audience dependency, concentration of ownership, and issue of media literacy; all the parties in the mass communication process are forced to think dramatically about their positions in it. Mass media can affect knowledge, attitudes, opinions and behavior of individuals. These effects can be immediate or delayed, for a short duration or long-lasting. II. With the development and evolution of media, we find that media convergence and media dependency have become a major factor in how society is affected and the way we respond throughout our everyday life. Encyclopedia Britannica (2013) states that, “Media convergence, a phenomenon involving the interlocking of computing, and technology information companies,  telecommunications networks, and content providers from the publishing worlds of......

Words: 1790 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Definition Of Democracy In The United States

...epitome of democracy. As a country believed to be founded on freedom and rights we have credited our founding fathers for the constitution and its ability to structure our society. There are many democracies all over the world, many whom have recently recently experienced a democratic transition. Many political scientists have been studying this trend and have been trying to determine what makes countries choose to become democracies and what factors allow them to thrive as democracies. In order to answer this question it is important to first define the term democracy. The most common definition of democracy today is a system of government that is ruled by the people. In order for...

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Media

...“The Role of Media in Democracy” The media is a lifeline of a nation. It provides not only information on what may affect the normal human being in his day-to-day functioning, but also by other features that keep him informed of developments, national and international. The reach of the media and the effect that it can have on general public has always been recognized and never been challenged. “If it were left on me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.” - Thomas Jefferson A democracy is a government of the people, for the people and by the people. Thus, the public opinion is an important aspect. The people in turn could hold the government accountable and change it, if they knew what it was doing. So, there is a need to inform the people of things around them so that there is a check on the government. And media is the one who informs them. As an informer, it should supply information in true and unbiased form and let the public choose, what may be the best in their interest. It may be right in educated democracies like in the UK, but in a country like Pakistan, or Bangladesh where most of the people are illiterate non-participant in asking questions, the matter arises whether the role of media can be limited to supplying information alone. The creation of a public opinion in an uneducated democracy: - Public opinion has to be generated and some agency is......

Words: 334 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Critical Essay Analysis Within a Cultural Studies Approach

... and argues that several features of social conduct add to the living and expanding of society and its organizations. Symbolic Interaction perspective: Positions that to understand society its necessary to understand the connotation of people’s actions and beliefs. At the moment of discussing society and its organizations, despite the sociological perspective used there are interconnected factors to be considered: Technology, politics, economy, values and beliefs. (Ray 2007) In the critical essay The Crisis of Public Values in the Age of the New Media, Henry A. Giroux’s discourse on the control of large corporations over the economy and how this affects the values of democracy, having as a result an individualistic attitude of the American people towards important factors that affect them as a society. Giroux explores the different uses of new media and its relation to the economical crisis and the essence of a democracy under a neoliberal setting, arguing that public education has to be the main instrument for a better...

Words: 1540 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mass Media

...THE ROLE OF THE MEDIA IN DEEPENING DEMOCRACY SHEILA S. CORONEL EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Since the 17th century, the role of the press as Fourth Estate and as a forum for public discussion and debate has been recognized. Today, despite the mass media’s propensity for sleaze, sensationalism and superficiality, the notion of the media as watchdog, as guardian of the public interest, and as a conduit between governors and the governed remains deeply ingrained. The reality, however, is that the media in new and restored democracy do not always live up to the ideal. They are hobbled by stringent laws, monopolistic ownership, and sometimes, the threat of brute force. State controls are not the only constraints. Serious reporting is difficult to sustain in competitive media markets that put a premium on the shallow and sensational. Moreover, the media are sometimes used as proxies in the battle between rival political groups, in the process sowing divisiveness rather than consensus, hate speech instead of sober debate, and suspicion rather than social trust. In these cases, the media contribute to public cynicism and democratic decay. Still, in many fledgling democracies, the media have been able to assert their role in buttressing and deepening democracy. Investigative reporting, which in some cases has led to the ouster of presidents and the fall of corrupt governments, has made the media an effective and credible watchdog and boosted its credibility among the public. Investigative......

Words: 8223 - Pages: 33

Free Essay

New Media and Politics

...ITRODUCTION In an attempt to understand ‘new media’ and politics we need to define what ‘new media is and what politics is. First we start by defining politics. According to Mansoor Maitah, Politics, in the broadest sense, is the activity through which people make, preserve and amend the general rules under which they live. Lasswell also defines politics as the process of who gets what, when, and how. He believes that politics is the process of allocating scarce values. He comes up with this equation; politics = allocation values (resources) wealth status power. By definition ‘new media’ according to Marshall McLuhan (1980) generally refers to the digital media which is interactive, incorporate two- way communication and involve some form of computing as opposed to ‘old media’ such as telephone, radio and TV. However there is a thin line between ‘old media’ and ‘new media’. This is because the ‘old media are getting digitized and some have consolidated with some ‘new media’ forms. Therefore we surround the term ‘new media’ with quotation marks to signify that they are digital interactive media. Without the quotation marks we generally are denoting media which is new to the context of discussion. To illustrate this, TV at is invent was new media and therefore cannot be said to be ‘new media’. Also parts of the world that have not received certain types of media will call them new media when introduced to them. GAGETRY DEFFERETIATION FROM THE PLAT FORMS.-TO BE......

Words: 2774 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Importance of Media and Democracy:

...Importance of Media and Democracy: Media democracy is a set of ideas advocating reforming the mass media, strengthening public service broadcasting, and developing and participating in alternative media and citizen journalism. The stated purpose for doing so is to create a mass media system that informs and empowers all members of society, and enhances democratic values. It is a liberal-democratic approach to media studies that advocates the reformation of the mass media with an emphasis on public service broadcasting and audience participation, through the use of citizen journalism and alternative media channels. A media democracy focuses on using information technologies to both empower individual citizens and promote democratic ideals through the spread of information. Additionally, the media system itself should be democratic in its own construction shying away from private ownership or intense regulation. Media democracy entails that media should be used to promote democracy as well as the conviction that media should be democratic itself; media ownership concentration is not democratic and cannot serve to promote democracy and therefore must be examined critically. The concept, and a social movement promoting it, have grown as a response to the increased corporate domination of mass media and the perceived shrinking of the marketplace of ideas. The term also refers to a modern social movement evident in countries all over the world which attempts to make mainstream......

Words: 1945 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Social Movements

...Name of Student Instructor’s Name Course Title Date Social Movement Introduction The concept of participatory democracy entails direct involvement of the people in decisions concerning politics, especially those which impacts their lives. This idea underpinned the activities of most social movements between 1960s and 1970s. Its emergence was mostly characterized by establishing democracy at workplace or industries, a method regarded as useful in allowing workers to participate in decision-making. However, the concept ceased to narrow on democratizing workplace as social scientists modified it to a theory which is applicable in restoring democracy in the society (Bachrach et al. 1). The modified concept focuses on achieving egalitarian redistribution of power in the society, a process which would lead to greater effects on the agenda of democratization. Social media can be cited as one of the achievements of participatory democracy because a lot of information can be gathered and shared across the populations and countries. This article focuses on tracing the influence of participatory democracy on women liberation as well as highlighting its impact on the 21st century social media. The Influence of Participatory Democracy on Women Liberation Officially, women liberation can be traced back to 1960s and should not be confused with the women movement in United States around the same time. In fact, most social scientists regard women movement as a unique branch of......

Words: 989 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Terrorism and the Media

...relationship between terrorism and the news media best understood? Terrorism and the Media co exist in a symbiotic relationship, meaning they both need each other. The media need terrorism to attract viewers and terrorists need media coverage for exposure. Media’s primary purpose is communication. Terrorism is a form of communication that is amplified by the media. Terrorism is outrageous violence that seizes the public’s imagination and awakens its audience to political issues and propaganda that are of importance to the perpetrators. The terrorists have a need to reach a target audience and seek publicity to display their actions and achieve exposure. Without such exposure of the acts, the goals of the terrorist have not been achieved (Lutz & Lutz, 2013 pg. 10). A terrorist act by itself achieves nothing without coverage from the media. In essence media is a terrorist’s best friend, for without the exposure given it is plausible to conceive that terrorism would cease to exist. The progression of technology such as mobile recording devices and hand held cameras has heightened the ability for terrorism to be displayed in a cinematic experience. These functions allow front seat access to world viewers of horrific terrorist acts, training camps, messages of hate or encouragement which are in turn beamed throughout the globe via specific terror home pages or through the various media outlets (Hoskins, 2006 pg. 1). Media exposure and coverage is imperative to......

Words: 687 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Terrorism

...publication may be reproduced, stored, transmitted, or disseminated, in any form, or by any means, without prior written permission from UİK, to whom all requests to reproduce copyright material should be directed, in writing. References for academic and media coverages are boyond this rule. Statements and opinions expressed in Uluslararası İlişkiler are the responsibility of the authors alone unless otherwise stated and do not imply the endorsement by the other authors, the Editors and the Editorial Board as well as the International Relations Council of Turkey. Uluslararası İlişkiler Konseyi Derneği | Uluslararası İlişkiler Dergisi Web: www.uidergisi.com | E- Mail: bilgi@uidergisi.com Is Terrorism Still a Democratic Phenomenon? Erica CHENOWETH* ABSTRACT In recent years, multiple studies have confirmed that terrorism occurs in democracies more often than in nondemocratic regimes. There are five primary groups of explanations for this phenomenon, including the openness of democratic systems, organizational pressures resulting from democratic competition, the problem of underreporting in authoritarian regimes, gridlock resulting from multiparty institutions, and the coercive effectiveness of terrorism against democracies. Most of these studies, however, examine the relationship only through 1997. In this article, I explore whether...

Words: 6756 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Love

...Role of Media in Various Sectors Advantages and Disadvantages on Youth Pragati Maheshwari* Abstract In this paper it is observed that media includes sources like print media and electronic media. Newspapers, magazines and any other form, which is written or printed, is included in print media and in electronic, media radio, television and Internet etc. are included. When there are so many channels and newspapers we cannot ignore its importance in the society.Mediacan change opinions because they have access to people and this gives it a lot of strength. This strength can either be used constructively by educating the people or it can be used destructively by misleading the innocent people. Power of the media can transform the whole society. Keywords: Print Media, Electronic Media, Democratic Media, Educative Media, Media in Entertainment. Introduction Media is everywhere; it has become a part of our daily life. The media play a dominant role in the learning process. Media has potential to shape personalities, change the way we perceive and understand the world and our immediate reality. The term media is derived from Medium, which means a carrier or mode. Media denotes an item specifically designed to reach a large audience or viewers. The term was first used with the advent of newspapers and magazines. However, with the passage of time, the term broadened by the inventions of radio, TV, cinemas and Internet. Connecting with media means being connected with the world around...

Words: 2994 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Net Neutrality Rules

...decision has reignited heated debate on the value of public versus private interests, as well as government regulation of the media and internet throughout the nation. So, why does this decision matter? In order to understand the implications of the repeal, it is necessary to understand what net neutrality itself is, its history, and the inherent link between the internet and democracy in the United States in our modern age. Throughout history, the government has struggled to keep up with the rapid advancement of communication technology. The Federal Communications Commission is “...an independent...

Words: 1424 - Pages: 6