Free Essay

Student Athletes

In:

Submitted By bwg1551
Words 378
Pages 2
Brandon Greulich
Critical Thinking
What are Arguments

I found the article quite intriguing and I found myself agreeing with it 100 percent. One of the arguments that he presents is that athletes should be able to sell their own jerseys if they want to. So what if a football player makes more for his than a soccer player, that is a lesson in supply and demand Mike argues. I also agree with this argument in the fact that it is your jersey with your name on it, you should be able to do whatever you want with it. There have been penalties issued to college athletes before for selling their jerseys and other items, and I do not agree with the punishments that were handed out.
Another main argument that Mike presents is the fact that college football players and basketball players are bringing in millions, if not billions of dollars to the NCAA for broadcasting contracts, and they are not receiving any share of it. He says that they have become employees of the college with no compensation. I feel that this is very true, and that the heads of the NCAA see the athletes as nothing but a profit for their own wallets. He says that NCAA agreed to a $10.8 billion contract for televising the NCAA basketball tournament for 13 years. The tournament only lasts about a month, so they are only busy one month out of the year for this event. That is quite a profit for the NCAA if you ask me. I feel that the players should receive some sort of share of that, or at least not penalizing them for selling their jerseys.
The last argument I want to talk about is the one Mike mentioned about how nobody mentions a music student at a college, going out and profiting off his/her music. I feel that this is the same as a football player selling and profiting off his own jersey. For some reason it is ok for a music student to go to a night club or bar and play and receive a paycheck for it. But if an athlete profits off of clothing, autographs or anything of that nature it is considered a huge wrong-doing.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Student Athletes Should Not Be Paid

...Would you work for free? How would you feel if you had devoted thousands of hours while attending college and thousands of hours prior to attending to college to receive no compensation for your efforts. This is the exact situation that student athletes in the NCAA are faced with. The NCAA, the National Collegiate Athletic Association is one of the largest nonprofit organizations in the world today with revenues exceeding twelve billion dollars a year. This money comes from ticket sales, marketing and fees for the use of the athletes likenesses across a variety of media. It all directly financially benefits the universities with the student athletes not getting even a bite of that pie. It is surprising that even though student athletes are the most easily identifiable figures in college sports and often the driving force behind this...

Words: 826 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Should Student Athletes Get Paid

...Derek Layton Professor Bird EN 300 11/18/14 Are College Athletes Going to be Paid? The NCAA is one of the top organizations in the world that brings in billions of dollars in revenue on college athletics alone most notably with college football and college basketball. Yes some of these athletes do get compensated with some sort of scholarship which does help out with their expenses but the chances of an athlete receiving an athletic scholarship that is worth anything meaningful is less than 2%. A full ride scholarship might as well be compared to as finding the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. In cases that an athlete does receive a scholarship this does not come close to covering the expenses of tuition yet alone all of the other expense such has room and board, food and everything else a human being needs to survive. Playing a colligate sport is just as demanding as a full time job and according to a survey done by “[1] The NCAA in 2011 playing football required 43.3 hours per week; college baseball, 42.1 hours; men's basketball, 39.2 hours; and women's basketball, 37.6 hours.” So these athletes have no time with school and their respective sport to find a job to help them with other expenses so they have to rely on student loans, grants or their parents to help them get through school. This also makes it much more difficult for a student athlete to pursue a more rigorous degree such as sciences and engineering. One problem that I have with the NCAA is all...

Words: 1492 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Should Student-Athletes Get Paid?

...Thomas Bessinger Professor Hortman February 18, 2014 Should Student-Athletes get paid? A very popular question that has been lingering around the sports world for sometime now is whether or not student-athletes should get paid. There are a lot of different opinions about this topic. The NCAA does not allow student-athletes to receive any type of benefits of any kind from the university; if the student-athlete does, he is no longer an amateur athlete and can no longer compete at the college level. This problem has been common over the past years and is causing athletes and universities to be penalized. If the NCAA would allow student-athletes to receive some benefits this would not be as common. Therefore, student-athletes should get paid because they are making money for their university, many student-athletes cannot have a job, and it is unfair for the NCAA to profit off of student-athletes. This reasoning has led many people to try and incorporate change in the collegiate world. Student-athletes, particularly at “big time” schools, have been bringing in millions of dollars in for their universities. The universities are selling jerseys that have the athletes’ names on the back, but the student-athletes are not receiving anything from that (Chen, 2013). Student-athletes are not even allowed to sell their jerseys or other apparel that is given to them by the university. In 2010 the NCAA did an investigation and found out that AJ Green sold one of his jerseys for $1000...

Words: 1188 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Student Athlete Philosophy

...Mission: To enhance the growth of students-athletes by providing an environment where student-athletes can grow and prepare for their futures by learning, modeling, and promoting integrity, trust, and leadership while inspiring school spirit. The ultimate goal is for our student athletes to take these skills and use them in each aspect of life. Philosophy: Participation in athletics is an important part of the overall development of student-athletes. Participating in athletics gives student-athletes the opportunities for emotional, mental, and physical development. Athletic competition is a valuable experience because it teaches student-athletes the lifelong lessons of good sportsmanship, working cooperatively as a team, and preparing for life’s...

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Stress on College Student-Athletes

...Stress amongst College Athletes & Non-Athletes Jeff Bennett University of Mount Union Abstract Athletic participation and academic stress has been a challenging topic and one that has made many question about. With all the extracurricular activities that students have, they don’t realize that their stress could be affecting them more than they may know. This study examines the stress level results amongst 10 college student athletes and 10 non-athletes. The results present a rare finding regarding stress amongst the students. Stress has become an on-going issue that has affected the college satisfaction of a student. Many people don’t realize that they have stress and it’s affecting them in some sort of way or some may know they have stress but don’t want to take any type of action towards getting help. Possible explanations for the findings and implications for stress amongst athletes and non-athletes of the University of Mount Union are provided. Introduction Stress has been a rising issue concerning not only college students but also college athletes. With all the extracurricular activities the students take on in college along with the academic part of it have led to very high stress level. Controlling time and having an organized schedule is the main fix to this problem. Whether you’re a college athlete or just a normal college student, everyone has stress or has experienced stress. The purpose of this study was to figure out whether or not there is a significant...

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Genetic Testing & College Athletes

...Genetic Testing and College Athletes On April 13, 2010, the NCAA made tests for Sickle Cell Trait (SCT) mandatory, effective in August 2010. SCT is a condition where the blood cells are elongated and potentially block blood flow and resist bonding to oxygen. The trait is generally benign but becomes active under extreme physical stress. For athletes, when performing strenuous activities, the trait is sometimes triggered and can potentially cause death. The statute states “student-athletes must be tested for sickle cell trait, show proof of a prior test or sign a waiver releasing an institution from liability if they decline to be tested.”(Brutlag, 2010) SCT genetic testing and NCAA regulations were implemented in order to protect student athletes, but the testing raises questions of who should receive the test results, the use of the results in discrimination against affected athletes and its potential to be cascade towards excessive genetic testing. In the current legislation, the results from an athletes test are given to the school, the coach and the athlete. This disclosure policy has the potential to be used to discriminate against those who are afflicted with SCT. Although the athlete has the option to opt out of testing initially once they have the test, the disclosure to the school and coaching staff is automatic. The test results should be first given to the student, and then they should have the option to waive liability and not disclose to the university...

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Pay College Athletes

...college athletes?” Whether or not to pay college athletes has been in debate for a number of years. No one seems to be able to decide whether or not these “students” deserve to be compensated for their actions on the gridiron, or whether they should be treated just like every other student at the school. The fact of the matter is that these athletes are not actually like every other average student. These athletes for some of these big name schools aren’t just helping the NCAA rake in small chunks of money; in fact they are helping the NCAA make billions of dollars every single year. It seems like only the NCAA is benefiting from the money who are the people in charge, and the workers, the athletes, are working for such a large profit, with no compensation towards them. To some this is the way it should be, but to others, they feels as if the athletes are being abused in a way that they are unable to fight back about. Therefore, do scholarships and free-living expenses make up for the billions of dollars these top tier athletes are bringing in? Or are these college athletes being abused by the billion-dollar industry that they help fuel? Some people view college sports as students at a school, representing their school through the act of a sport. However, the truth is that these college students fuel a billion dollar business that has no income for the actual “employees.” In Taylor Branch’s article, “The Shame of College Sports”, he continuously shows how these students are...

Words: 1759 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Death of the Ball Turrel Gunner

...Should Student Athletes be Paid? Should the student-athlete receive pay for his athletic performance for the school? This argument has been the topic of debate for many years. Some argue that the student-athlete receives a full scholarship, and this should be his total pay. After all, receiving a college degree should be the player’s primary concern. The point has to be made, however, that the scholarship does not cover all of the student-athletes’ living expenses (Meshefejian). When the student cannot pay his extra expenses, they either chose to leave college or move on to professional sports. Leaving school for any reason eliminates the whole purpose of attending college, which is to receive a degree. The college and the NCAA receive enormous amounts of money from the student-athlete’s sports ability. Because the student-athlete provides the college with such a large sum of income, the student-athletes should be given enough scholarship funds to pay the total cost of attending the school which would provide the student-athlete with a diploma and a degree. The college, as well as the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), earns substantial amounts of money from the sports programs at most colleges. In the 2013-2014 basketball season, NCAA received over $1.15 billion dollars just from advertising sales during the tournament(Benedykcik). Mike Benedykcik further reports in his article, The Blue Line: College Athletes Should be Paid that the University of...

Words: 1027 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Should College Athletes Be Paid

...College Athletes Be Paid In 2013 the NCAA made 912.8 million and 85% of that came from the division I men’s basketball tournament as you can see college sports is very popular in the United States but who really wins? The average division I football player spend about 44 hours per week to football with practice and other sport related activity now mind you this is a college student. College student across the country are given homework and are expected to study for test and be prepared for class when need be so as you can see the athlete doesn’t have lots of time to spare for like working a job. Teams travel to different parts of the country to play sports against others college teams and we all know how hard travel time can be now if I’m not mistaken in this country you have to have some kind of income to make ends meet. The NCAA make all this money while the athletes in which they make the money off of has to travel and dedicate most of all their time to the sport they play. If a student can’t work a job how are they supposed to take care of themselves many student go without eating a hardy meal or having the basic needs to survive yes they may have a dorm room and a cafeteria lunch but your taking about athletes most of which are big human beings that need to eat. The NCAA make money off these kids’ jerseys, video games and autographs but the student is not allowed to take money or profit off anything while not working a job. Many people say well the athlete get a...

Words: 620 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

College Athletes Get Paid

...of income, and they attract students to their institutions. Universities depend on their athletes to produce and maintain the popularity of their school's name. According to NCAA rules, “You are not eligible for participation in a sport if you have ever: Taken pay, or the promise of pay, for competing in that sport” (NCAA Regulations 1).Even though the athletes are the one making the money for the college the students are not paid for their time spent playing sports. The NCAA has the capabilities to pay the students but it has not happen yet. The college athletes have no incentive to stay in college and finish their degrees, as many cannot afford to pay for the increasingly expensive college...

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Why Athletes Should Be Paid

...December 2014 Should College Athletes Be Paid? College sports is one of America’s biggest industries. It is an industry that brings in almost 4 billion dollars every year to the NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic Association). The NCAA is not the only one profiting from this large industry. TV networks like ESPN and CBS, retailers, and of course universities make millions each year because of the work of college athletes. It seems that everyone is profiting off the college sports industry except for the ones who are actually performing. College athletes are not being compensated for their hard work and diligence in this highly profitable market industry. While some college athletes get scholarships, which are renewed each year depending on the athlete’s performance and usefulness to the team, that is still not enough to meet the needs of the athletes. Also these college athletes cannot profit off their marketability and their name. College athletes are not allowed to receive anything of monetary value in exchanged for autographs or memorabilia. Every year, thousands of student athletes across America sign the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s Form 08-3a, the “Student-Athlete” form, waiving their right to receive payment for the use of their name and image (Infante et al). However, retailers and college universities make millions off these athletes with university apparel with the athlete’s number on the merchandise. College athletes also bring a lot of interest...

Words: 2865 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Cash Tech

...was to say that many people across the nation believe that a form of slavery still exists in our country today? As shocking as it sounds, there is support of the belief that the NCAA is profiting off of “slave labor” in the form of its student athletes. A relatively recent college football controversy involving former Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel has served as an ideal platform for people to make their case for whether or not college athletes should receive compensation. It’s a debate that’s been up in the air for decades but has now really heated up in the aftermath of the Manziel controversy. The best way to put it is that when the NCAA issued a one game suspension for receiving money in exchange for autographs, the NCAA also sparked a possible revolution upon itself. In the summer of 2013, one of the biggest stories in sports was the Johnny Manziel autograph scandal. Manziel had been accused of receiving a five-figure payment for autographed jersey’s, pictures and memorabilia (Manfred). On the surface, people might not even flinch at the sound of that. A star athlete selling autographs, no big deal, right? Well the “big deal” was that he was a collegiate, not professional, athlete. By NCAA rules and regulations a student-athlete cannot profit off of their name. In other words, this is hypocrisy at its finest. By signing to play football at Texas A&M, Manziel’s name now belonged to Texas A&M until the day he leaves the school. So basically they have the...

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Student Athlete Athletes

...Sporting events such as track and field, football and basketball are mainly dominated by blacks. On any given Saturday afternoon at majority white institutions, the black athlete can be found entertaining not only their immediate white master, but their white masters in term of the disproportionate number of white fans including faculty, staff and college administrators. This in itself has pre-dated far too many black athletes to slavery and the conditions of modern day slavery at the hand of athletics. Truly sports in America today as we know it has psychologically damaged the black athlete....

Words: 1277 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Student Athlete Stereotypes

...Even before coming to UNC and researching UNC as a prospective student, I knew about UNC being home to one of the most well-known college athletics programs in the United States. I watched many basketball games on TV as a kid, and even attended a game here when I was in kindergarten. What I did not realize at the time, being 5 years old, that the athletes that I was watching were not only athletes, but also students, students who juggle many responsibilities, both on the court and in the classroom. Student athletes at UNC may feel that with all of their obligations, they work harder than many non-athlete students, as well as dealing with a stigma and dumb-jock stereotype that sometimes surrounds being a student athlete. In order to examine the accuracy of these claims, I observed the track and field team as well as interviewing a member of the team. To first get an idea of what the extracurricular expectations of being a student-athlete at UNC is, I observed one of our track team’s practices which was a...

Words: 1193 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Student Athletes Insane

...Many instances in life go unnoticed, whether it be the mailman marching through snow to deliver our mail, or the thousands of bumblebees that pollinate our flowers, something will go unnoticed in the average person’s life. During high school, I was given the privilege of participating in football and track and field. I played center and middle linebacker in football, and threw shot put and discus in track. One thing I noticed while playing these sports was the insane amount of work my coaches put in to help each and every one of my teammates. I believe the coaches get unnoticed by many student athletes because they have been adjusted to the coaches doing everything behind the scenes. Student athletes never really see what the coaches...

Words: 312 - Pages: 2