Free Essay

The Place of Non Humans in Environmental Issues


Submitted By matt2120
Words 1529
Pages 7
Matthew Adams
Business Ethics
12, Oct 2014
Final Essay

The Place of Nonhumans in Environmental Issues

Peter Singers essay titled “The Place of Nonhumans in Environmental Issues”, focuses on a general question. How the effects of our actions should figure in our deliberations on what we ought to do in regards to nonhuman beings, or generally speaking, animals and our environment.
Speciesism is defined as “involving the assignment of different values, rights, or special consideration to individuals solely on the basis of their species membership”.
Simply put, we humans consider ourselves while discounting the effects of our actions on the nonhumans. When a new roadway is to be built that may directly interfere with
Elk habitat, or a dam that is to be built where salmon flood the river during spawning season, we do a cost benefit analysis. But, when we do the analysis, we rarely figure in the impact on the surrounding wildlife and only figure the benefits to human beings. A new roadway will help us travel to work faster, but interferes with the surrounding wildlife that lives in these areas. And a new dam will help power hundreds of new homes, while decimating the already low salmon numbers. We humans calculate our benefit, while discounting the effects of our actions on nonhumans and the environment.

We can use the example of the past racist white slave owners of the South.
These slave owners only were concerned with benefiting themselves and those of their white race, while never considering the interests of their black slaves whom lived in destitute, forced to work long hard hours to benefit only the racist white slave owner with free labor and cleanly harvested fields.
Why is it that we hold a species such as dogs below ourselves? Because we are more intelligent? Just because one species is more intelligent than another does not give one the right to enslave, exploit or disregard them based on the idea that they are a lesser species. It is up to us as individuals to take a moral stance, and look out for those whom cannot speak for their interests and realize that for every action we take on this planet there is and always will be a reaction.
Peter Singers principle of equal consideration of interests points at the very value of one’s life over that of a nonhuman. Such example would be someone having to make the choice between saving the life of a human over a dog, that, when given equal consideration of interest, one would choose to save the human as the human is more aware. The human would suffer more, knowing what was coming, and we have to consider the loved ones left behind and the emotional pain that it would cause. But, he also states that if the human involved in this scenario were mentally deficient, and without family to grieve over the loss, we may choose the dog in this case.
The more positive side of the case for equal consideration of interest, lies in the case when interests are equal, they must be given equal weight. The area in which humans and nonhumans share an equal interest lies in avoiding physical pain. Peter also states that it is not equal to hit a horse with a stick and compare it to hitting a

human with a stick, as the horse has a thick hide, and thus the horse would suffer less pain than his human counterpart. The principle holds between similar amounts of pain between human and nonhuman. It of course would vary on a case by case basis.
In the majority of households around the country we consume the flesh of other animals as a regular part of our daily diet. But, according to Mr. Singer we eat animals merely out of pleasure of our palate, as we do not need to eat meat as a part of our diet.
The proteins that are essential to a healthy diet can be found in that of soy beans and other high protein vegetable supplements.
The act of killing the animals alone is not the single indication of what we are ready to do to another species in order to please our taste buds. But the conditions and the suffering we inflict on them is a clear indication of speciesism. Our society tolerates poor living conditions in order to satisfy not only our insatiable desire for meat, but out pocket books as well. The majority of the public is not willing to throw down a few extra bucks for meat raised on a farm where the animal was free to walk about, away from its cage. Most hens in commercial egg production facilities will never see the light of day, share a small cage with four or five other hens, live in deplorably unsanitary environments, and may never get to stretch their wings. These are the conditions we have accepted in order to keep the price point low enough for us to buy these products.
Since these practices cater to our taste rather than need, Peter believes that it is morally wrong for us to continue eating meat. That the continued practice of raising animals to kill and eat is a clear sign of speciesism. Where we are putting our interests over that of other species in order to satisfy our own trivial needs.

As for myself I can agree with some of Mr. Singer’s thoughts on this subject matter. As I have decided recently to pursue my degree in Environmental Science rather than Information Technology. First I will start with what I agree with.
I can agree in part with Mr. Singer in regards to his views on speciesism.
Specifically the degradation of lands. All too often I see hundreds of acres of forest land clear cut for our insatiable need for wood products. We seem to give no thought to the hundreds of species that call that forest land home. Here in Western Washington, we are surrounded by hundreds of square miles of forests, rivers, mountains and lakes. Yet year after year we are losing more land to new housing developments and roadway construction projects that encroach on wildlife. Yet, the same people that complain about deforestation and our encroachment of wildlife, are also the same people buying houses in these neighborhoods. They are also the same people that call me a murderer because I hunt big game animals for sustenance, not trophy’s.
Yet they do not realize that when human activity such as the building of neighborhoods and deforestation pushes animals into new territory, the animals have a shortened food supply, due to the overabundance of one particular species. As a hunter, I feel that what we do is critical for the eco system so long as human interference continues to destroy their environment. Thinning the herds is a crucial part that we as hunters play in the balance. Without it, animals starve to death over the long winters due to a shortened food supply. In Washington State, Fish and Game estimates that between deer, elk and bear populations, over ten percent of the animals will die over the winter due to starvation.

Mr. Singer fails to recognize in his essay that the majority of hunters are conservationists, and hold a high regard and respect for the animals we take in order to be self-sufficient. Without organizations like Ducks Unlimited and the Rocky Mountain
Elk Foundation, huge populations of these animals would be decimated due to human development and interference. These organizations have purchased hundreds of thousands of acres for the conservation of these animals for future generations.
I also do not agree with the fact that Mr. Singer made the point that "in fact hunting and shooting are likely to contribute more to the benefit side of the calculations because larger sums of money are spent on them, and they therefore benefit manufacturers and retailers of firearms as well as the hunters and shooters themselves”. I think that aside from the purchase of firearms, we as hunters also pay for hunting licenses and harvest tags. These items purchased go directly to the conservation of the environment we hunt and fish in. For the majority of hunters, they won’t even harvest an animal in any given year. But still financially support conservation of wild animals in our home states and protection of our hunting and fishing rights through the purchase of licenses.
I find it acceptable to experiment on certain species of animals. Rats and mice are very abundant in numbers and are widely used in experimentation. These experiments have the potential to better the lives of human beings. I suppose one would have to weigh the life of a rat or mouse against that of a human. In equal consideration of interests, the human wins every time. But when we start to talk about experimentation on monkeys, a creature that is more self-aware than that of a rat, my opinion changes.

Maybe someday we will not have to experiment on animals, but for the time being it is all we have to continue to push the progress of our species forward.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Bioethics: Modern Science and Ethics

...Science defines human life as a characteristic that exhibit a process with organization, growth, adaptation, etc.; however, ancient sages told people human life is extremely valuable and sacred, as a religious doctrine in the Ten Commandments: “Thou shalt not kill.” Moreover, when people talk about ethics, they will think about rules to differentiate right and wrong. It might be wise maxims of Confucius or religious beliefs. The most general way to define “ethics” is that “moral principles that govern a person's or group's behavior” (American English in Oxford Dictionary). Bioethics is a pretty young interdisciplinary study, which is considered with ethical questions related to the relationships among human beings, animals, and environments in the late twentieth century. Based on this, bioethics derived three main subdisciplines, which are medical ethics, animal ethics, and environmental ethics. Although each sub-discipline has particular study area in bioethics, there still are overlaps of ethical considerations and approaches. This makes it difficult to easily discuss ethics questions such as stem cell research, xenotransplantation, the ethical status of animals and the ethical status of the environment. Further discussion about the vital issue of moral status solutions is necessary at the same time. In the rapid development of the natural sciences and biotechnology has greatly promoted better living conditions and improve the living standards of people around the world...

Words: 2352 - Pages: 10

Free Essay


...ecosystem) composed of both living and non-living elements. All ecosystems tend towards a state of harmony or equilibrium through a system of state regulation. Biologists refer to this as homeostasis: Process where food and other resources are recycled and the population size of animals; insects and plants naturally adjust to the available food supply.Eco systems interact with other ecosystems.E.g. A lake may constitute an ecosystem, but it also needs to be fed fresh water from tributaries and receive warmth and energy from the sun. In turn, lakes provide water and food for species living along its shores. The natural world is therefore made up of a complex web of ecosystems – the largest of which is the global ecosystem: the “ecosphere” or “biosphere”.Ecologists argue that humankind currently faces the prospect of environmental disaster because of material wealth.Material wealth and consumption upsets the ‘balance of nature’ and endangered the ecosystems that make human life possible. * This is all a result of the growth in human population * The depletion of finite and irreplaceable resources such as: Coal, Oil, and Natural Gas * The eradication of tropical rain forests * The pollution of rivers, lakes and forests and air itselfEcologism presents a radically different vision of nature and the place of human beings within it - one that favours ecocentrism and challenges anthropocentricism. The distinction between the environmental movements: Shallow * Basically environmentalism...

Words: 3124 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Of Environmental and Natural Resource Economics

...Purpose The purpose of this paper is to gain an understanding of marine protection areas within Australian waters and to analyse its policy from an environmental and economic viewpoint, in order to forward policy recommendations for future consideration. A Background to Environmental Policy The underlying assumption behind environmental policy is that by designing social intervention we can bring about environmental improvement. However, designing a policy that actually produces the changes you seek is extremely difficult. Chiefly, planning and policy attempt to exercise control, to develop a desired future (Thomas 2007, p.7). But control is difficult enough to achieve over people, let alone trying to control the physical environment (Thomas 2007, p.7). Another fundamental issue for policy-makers is the direction of the policy. In particular they have to consider whether they are attempting to prevent environmental impacts that result from human action, or whether they are attempting to adapt to such changes, consciously or unconsciously (Thomas 2007, p.8). Natural Resources Natural resources have been critical for human welfare since people first started to walk the earth several million years ago (Field 2005 p.27). Natural resource economics is the study of how the flow of goods and services derived from natural resources is, and should be, managed in today’s world (Field 2005 p.37). Field continues to state that resource management problems derive from the underlying...

Words: 3864 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay


...WORKING PAPER USING ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNICATION AND LEADERSHIP TO LEVERAGE ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES: LESSONS FROM GHANA Mr. Isaac Kwasi Egyir Human Ecology Department, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, BELGIUM Email: CONTENT PAGE ACRONYMS 3 ABSTRACT 4 1. Introduction 5 1.1 The Definition and Concept of Communication 5 1.1.1 Concept of Environmental Communication 6 1.2 The Definition and Concept of Leadership 8 1.2.1 Concept of Environmental Leadership 9 1.3 Link between Environmental Communication and Leadeship 10 2. Statement of Research the Problem 10 2.1 Objectives of the Paper 11 2.2 Guiding Hypotheses 11 3. Conceptual Framework of the Paper 11 4. Materials and Methods 13 4.1 The Study Location 13 4.2 Data Collection Analysis 13 5. Results and Discussion 15 5.1 The State of Ghana's Environment 16 5.1.1 Perception of Environmental Problems in Ghana 16 5.2 Environmental Policy and Implementing Instituitions in Ghana 17 5.2.1 Economic Recovery Programme (ERP) 18 5.2.2 National Environmental Action Plan (NEAP) 18 5.2.3 Ghana Environmental REsources Management systems (GERMS) 19 5.2.4 Forest and Wildlife Policy 20 5.2.5 Environment Sanitation Policy (ESP) 20 5.2.6 Strategic Environment Assessment (SEA) 20 5.3 Environmental Implementing Instituitions...

Words: 10253 - Pages: 42

Free Essay

Ethics: Pollution and Multinational Corporations

...Running Head: ETHICS: POLLUTION AND MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS Ethics: Pollution and Multinational Corporations HRL ETHICS: POLLUTION AND MULTINATIONAL CORPORATIONS 2 Pollution is a broad term. It encompasses far more than just chemicals affecting our environment. Pollution is defined by The Merriam Webster dictionary as “the introduction of contaminants into the natural environment that cause adverse change. Pollution can take the form of chemical substances or energy such as noise, heat or light.” There are many types of pollution including, but not limited to, air pollution from man-made and naturally occurring contaminants, water pollution, noise pollution, light pollution, soil contamination, thermal pollution, as from commercial cooling systems or nuclear power plants, visual pollution from man-made structures like radio towers and billboards, and electromagnetic pollution such as radio frequency interference produced by man-made appliances. There is pollution we can control and pollution that we cannot control. Each type of pollution may have its own set of ethics which, of course, must relate back to the subject of a previous assignment relating to the ethics and culture of the civilization that one is existing in. For example, there are cultures that use incense for religious and entertainment purposes. They would not consider fumes and chemicals...

Words: 1997 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...WisconsinMadison Abstract When do humans extend their ethical scope to include nature? Anthropocentrism and ecocentrism are two ways of understanding an extension of ethics to nature. In an anthropocentric ethic nature deserves moral consideration because how nature is treated a¡ects humans. In an ecocentric ethic nature deserves moral consideration because nature has intrinsic value. In two experiments participants (n=91 and 84) generated moral reasoning responses to ecological moral dilemmas. The reasoning was coded as ecocentric, anthropocentric, or nonenvironmental (i.e., social contracts, truthfulness). Individual di¡erences and situational variables were examined in relation to moral reasoning about ecological dilemmas. Pro-environmental attitudes were related to more ecocentrica nd anthropocentrica nd less nonenvironmental reasoning. The presence of information about the impact of ecological damage on the environment, especially a more ‘‘wild’’ environment, elicited more ecocentric reasoning, while the presence of a social commitment elicited more nonenvironmental moral reasoning. The implications of the research for con£icts over environmental commons dilemmas are discussed. # 2001 Academic Press Ecocentrism and Anthropocentrism: Moral Reasoning about Ecological Dilemmas There is as yet no ethicd ealing with man’s relation to land and to the animals and plants which grow upon it. . . The extension of ethics to this third element in human environment is. . .an evolutionary ...

Words: 8444 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Cyber Crime

...NEED OF SUSTAINABLE ENVIRONMENT AS A HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE ABSTRACT Environmental protection is a recent concept, developed in the international or regional human right protection systems or mechanisms. In those early days, especially when modern human rights protection mechanisms such as UDHR, ICCPR, IESCR and other human rights instruments adopted, the concern given to environmental protection was not that much significant . The only few provisions in these instruments recognizes some rights like the right to healthy and favorable condition of work, the right to get adequate food, clothing and shelter and the like. It was during in 1992, earth summit, that the relationship between human rights and sustainable environment is addressed. The need for the protection of environment becomes a necessity. In fact environment is a totality of human life; it means that it is sources of food, clothing, and shelter. The denial of environmental protection could bring about the denial of some fundamental rights such as the right to health, life, food and so on. It is true that, environment should be properly managed in order to make it favorable to human life. However; the effort to protect the environment faces different challenges like the issue of locus-standi, justifiability, conflict between developmental efforts and environmental protection, burden of proof, lack of cooperation among states and...

Words: 9961 - Pages: 40

Premium Essay

Morality Obligations with Nature

...Introduction ❖ Group point of view • Society - Points to concern Government Education Economic Definition • ❖ Environmental ethics • ❖ Protection of environment • ❖ Overview worldwide environmental problematic (Introduction to the problem) Global warming Main types of pollution Preservation of trees Animal experimentation Disagreement • Business Utilitarianism Anthropocentric ethics Kantian theory Counterargument Agreement To future generation Giving a great habitat to animals Biocentric ethics Ecocentric ethics Conclusion We live with the world Introduction: Since the environment problem has taken attention in today's society, there have been number of opinions about our obligations with nature. Some people claim that human has the right to act and that nature is here just to satisfy human desires and needs. In the other hand, there is a group of people who state that this argument sound egoist because we are not the only species living in this world and we should share this earth with species. “Individuals can not be used as merely as a means to the end- there are ends in themselves” Kant basic ideas here are that persons have the position to make rational choice about their own lives. They have moral autonomy and fee will. This fact about person confers dignity upon them. They command respect. To treat people as a mean to some other end, be it own welfare or that of others, it is fail to...

Words: 3465 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Geoengineering: a Global Issue

...What is it? 4. Environmental Issues & Science 5. Human Impact 6. Ethical & Justice Issues 7. Conclusion 8. Bibliography Geoengineering: A global issue Essay Abstract Geoengineering is a set of new technologies which aim to change the environment in human favour. Considering the technology is nascent, the morality, ethics, technological knowhow and the human impact are all uncertain as they relate to geoengineering. This paper argues that on these grounds, the geoengineering issue should be a global issue. Local governments fail to implement this technology effectively. The subsidiarity test should be passed when it relates to the geoengineering issue. Introduction With rising CO2 levels, changing weather patterns and an ever increasing intensity of weather events, governments and environmental groups are trying to address the global warming issue. There are many theories on how to deal with climate change; from a reduction in pollution to carbon capture. Geoengineering is a relatively new idea in the field of science which “describes this array of technologies that aim, through large-scale and deliberate modifications of the Earth’s energy balance, to reduce temperatures and counteract anthropogenic climate change.” (Bracmort et all., 2011: 1) The vast majority of technology is nascent and at a theoretical stage but it has the potential to affect populations and climate on a global scale. (Bracmort et all., 2011: 1) Any issue that has the ability...

Words: 2681 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay


...** Explain the ethical issues a business needs to consider in its operational activities. BUSINESS ETHICS: - is the application of ethical values (the standards that are set by a business or individuals that control their behaviour) to business behaviour. - apply to: all aspects of business conduct, all levels of the organization, all activities that affects stakeholders and the organization as a whole. P1 ETHICAL ISSUES: 1. Corporate governance and corporate social responsibility Corporate governance – the people and procedures for taking the major decisions within a business. It is "the system by which companies are directed and controlled". Corporate social responsibility (CSR) – refers to the extent that a business considers what it does in relation to a wider world. It is the policy of the business towards all stakeholders that takes their interests into account. It is when a firm establishes its own policies regarding its standards of behaviour and its relationship with stakeholders. 2. Environmental ethical issues and sustainability Environmental ethical issues – are problems with the planet's systems (air, water, soil, etc.) that have developed as a result of human interference or mistreatment of the planet. Sustainability - is the capacity to endure. For humans, sustainability is the long-term maintenance of responsibility, which has environmental, economic, and social dimensions, and encompasses the concept of the responsible management of resource...

Words: 991 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Intern Assignment on International Relations and Global Climate Change

...things, global climate change also got a strong basis of global agenda in international relations specificly in 1972. Since then international relations and global climate change have become very intimate to one another to be discussed. By 1972 and having a remarkable benchmark in 1992, global environment as well as global climate change is being practiced almost with every aspect of international relations which include state, non-state actors, domestic international relationship, various political approach, several global accord, security and world trade as well. In this paper, we will try to find out the intensity of the intimacy between international relations and global climate change through several different approaches. In the beginning of the paper we will survey on the theories of international relations through which both international relations and global climate change can be explained then the discussion will be shifted to the role of state and non state actors on climate change, which will be pursued to the effect of climate change on human activities and the history of global climate change co-operation. Then we will move to an analysis of the global climate change regime through the several grand theories of international relations. Having theoretical analysis the paper will look forward to the domestic-international relationship on the global climate change negotiation and the political approach to climate...

Words: 11943 - Pages: 48

Premium Essay

Corporate Social Responsibility

...Corporate Social Responsibility An Implementation Guide for Business Paul Hohnen, Author Jason Potts, Editor Corporate Social Responsibility An Implementation Guide for Business Paul Hohnen, Author Jason Potts, Editor ii Corporate Social Responsibility: An Implementation Guide for Business © 2007, International Institute for Sustainable Development The International Institute for Sustainable Development contributes to sustainable development by advancing policy recommendations on international trade and investment, economic policy, climate change and energy, measurement and assessment, and sustainable natural resources management. Through the Internet, we report on international negotiations and share knowledge gained through collaborative projects with global partners, resulting in more rigorous research, capacity building in developing countries and better dialogue between North and South. IISD’s vision is better living for all—sustainably; its mission is to champion innovation, enabling societies to live sustainably. IISD is registered as a charitable organization in Canada and has 501(c)(3) status in the United States. IISD receives core operating support from the Government of Canada, provided through the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and Environment Canada; and from the Province of Manitoba. The Institute receives project funding from numerous governments inside and outside Canada,...

Words: 41123 - Pages: 165

Premium Essay

Mitigation Strategies and Solutions

...Pollution is the water resource issue I selected for my Mitigation Strategies and Solutions. According to (2010), water pollution “began in the nineteenth century as a result of urbanization, industrial development and modern agricultural practices.” Water Pollution is categorized as two sources Non-point source pollution which contributes to eutrophication in freshwater resource as a result of water pollution because usually this type of pollution results from “land runoff, precipitation, atmospheric deposition, drainage, seepage or hydrologic modification,” according to (2010). However, Point Source Pollution happens because the dumping of the sewage, garbage, ship oils, and other waste from human activity. These pollutants and toxins kill the ecosystem. These would be the negative human impacts. Additional effects are contaminated drinking water which can cause a variety of health problems such as, ear , eyes and throat irritation, aggravate symptoms of asthma and chronic bronchitis just to name a few. These pollutants are a threat to public health These effects from pollutants have damaging consequences on the drinking water supplies, fisheries, wildlife, and recreational use such as swimming. The growing human population is also a problem because the demand for water already exceeds the current water supply. As the human population continue to increase so will the demand the demand for water. Humans pollute the water with trash...

Words: 1807 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Kld Lists

...economically disadvantaged, e.g., the National Equity Fund or the Enterprise Foundation. | Support for Education | The company has either been notably innovative in its support for primary or secondary school education, particularly for those programs that benefit the economically disadvantaged, or the company has prominently supported job-training programs for youth. | Indigenous Peoples Relations | The company has established relations with indigenous peoples in the areas of its proposed or current operations that respect the sovereignty, land, culture, human rights, and intellectual property of the indigenous peoples. KLD began assigning this strength in 2000. In 2002 KLD moved this strength rating into the Human Rights area. | Non-US Charitable Giving | The company has established substantial, innovative charitable giving programs outside the U.S. In 2002 KLD stopped assigning strengths for Non-U.S. charitable giving in the Non-U.S. category, companies with exemplary giving programs outside the U.S. are tracked in the Community area. | Other Strength | The company has an exceptionally strong volunteer program, in-kind giving program, or other particularly strong community program. | Concerns | Investment Controversies | The company is a financial institution whose lending or investment practices have led to controversies, particularly ones related to the Community Reinvestment Act. | Negative Economic Impact | The company’s actions have resulted in major controversies...

Words: 2256 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Enivironmental Issues

...Rishika Rathi , and Pooja Chokhani , B.Com Department , I st Semester Ri Rishika Rathi , and Pooja Chokhani ,B.Com Department , I st Semester THE DRAWBACKS IN ENVIRONMENTAL LEGESLATIONS IN INDIA: In today's world the conservation, protection and improvement of human environment are major issues all over the world. Human environment consists of physical environment and biological environment. Physical environment covers land, water and air. Biological environment includes plants, animals and other organisms. Industrialization, urbanization, explosion of population, over exploitation, disruption of natural ecological balances, destruction of plant and animal species for economic reasons are the major reasons behind environment deterioration. Our country’s degradation of environment degrades the global environment. Therefore, it is all the more important to have legislations to protect our environment. 1.Introduction In the Constitution of India it is stated that it is the duty of the state to ‘protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests and wildlife of the country’. It is the duty on every citizen ‘to protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers, and wildlife'. The Department of Environment was established in India in 1980 to ensure a healthy environment for the country. This later came to be known as the Ministry of Environment and...

Words: 1002 - Pages: 5