Free Essay

What Is the Difference Between a Nation and a State and Why Are They Often Confused?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By aaliyahak
Words 644
Pages 3
What is the difference between a nation and a state and why are they often confused?
The term nation tends to be employed with little precision, often being used interchangeably with terms such as state, country, ethnic group or race. Nations have many features. First and most basically, nations are cultural entities. A nation is a group of people who share a common language, religion, history and traditions. Second, nations are political entities. A nation is a group of people who regard themselves as a natural political community. This is expressed most clearly in the desire to establish or maintain statehood. Nations are often based on rights, democracy, common laws and common territory. E.g. USA, South Africa. Lastly, they are psychological entities. A nation is a group of people bound together by shared loyalties or allegiances, often expressed in the form of patriotism. Nations can be viewed as either primary cultural communities or cultural political communities.
A state is a formal political entity which has clearly defined territorial boundaries within which some form of government exercises the powers of the state. The state normally is seen to have certain duties e.g. ensure peace and stability, provide social welfare, protect property etc. The state is seen to be sovereign and has sovereign power over a certain jurisdiction. It is therefore superior to all other institutions including government. The government is a short term institution and just the principal agent existing to facilitate the state’s objectives by following a written constitution.
A nation and state are often confused because nations can be defined politically with national consciousness often used in a desire to achieve or maintain statehood or self determination. Politically a nation is a group of people who regard themselves as a natural political community and normally have the express desire to maintain statehood. States and nations often overlap to form nation-state and a nation state can be defined as a sovereign political association within which civic identity and nationality overlap. One nation within a single state. Nations rely on the emotive aspects of a countries society with it being determined by culture and psychological factors. States claim to make decisions in the public interest and exercise authority through institutions. Lastly the aim of Nationalism is usually to create a nation-state. This was rooted after Versailles where the Nation-State was put forward as a fundamental right of all people. Also President Wilson declared that 11 nations had the right to statehood. However, Nationalist overseas colonies were not resolved until post World War Two.

There are many examples in World politics that highlights how state and nation are often confused because of the reasons above. Primarily, not all states contain just one nation, for example the UK is a multi-national state in that it is a single sovereign state with a unitary government, but it contains within it a system of several different countries and nationalities. None of these countries have individual sovereignty and there are many regional differences with strong nationalistic aspects but they’re not considered to be individual countries. Secondly, a number of nations do not have a state, many of the problems that a nation state must deal with have become much more international. For example markets are increasingly international, crime now operates between different countries and environmental problems do not recognise national boundaries. Thirdly, some nations cross state boundaries, movements have sought to unite ethnic groupings such as Pan-Arabism and pan-slavism which promotes exclusive racial unity without a sense of superiority. Lastly, some nationalisms are content with a measure of self rule, cultural forms of nationalism have arisen seeking a degree of autonomous control over cultural institutions but not general independence. For example the Welsh Assembly that was established in 1998 has some control over education, the arts, sports and the Welsh Language.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

What Is the Difference Between Work and Fun?

...What is the difference between work and fun? In the world we live in today, gambling is a professional career to some, whilst others gamble for leisure, a combination of necessity and pure enjoyment. However there is hardly any single moment where a person just fell into being a professional gambler, but there will be some people who realized that they didn’t have any other source of income. The truth is that there are many thousands of people around the country who make a good living exclusively from gambling. It is not easy, but it can be done. In order to become a professional gambler, he/she needs to practice, practice and practice some more. He/she needs to have the rules of whatever game you are planning on playing down cold. Once he/she knows the rules, he/she needs to practice, either live or online. In addition to practice, one also needs to have discipline. Discipline comes in many forms. Can you maintain your focus so that you make the right decisions? Can you maintain and stick to a proper budget? Discipline and practice is normally not enjoyable by any party, however obliged to do in order to become skilled and successful in the profession of gambling thus should be considered as work. When you are betting on sports, the number one priority that you should have is good solid research. It is difficult enough even with the greatest knowledge and excellent research to make accurate bets at a successful ratio, without research......

Words: 605 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Is the Difference Between "Procurement" and "Purchase"?

...There is a broad range of concepts in the bibliography referring to Procurement and purchasing. Here below you could find a summary of some of this concepts as well as some different point of view. Procurement Purchase Source Is considered as the function responsibly to acquire all items or materials needed by an organization Is part of procurement in charge of buying all items and material for an organization, often it is use as synonym of procurement. Wile.com (n. d.) Glossary of Inventory Management Terms It is a business function responsibly for several activities such as planning, purchasing, inventory control, traffic, receiving, incoming inspection, and rescue operations. It could be seen as a synonym of purchasing. It Is the function specifically associated with buying the goods and services required by the organization. SUPPLY CHAIN and LOGISTICS TERMS and GLOSSARY logisticsservicelocator.com (2006) Often could be understood as purchasing however procurement is the totality of acquisition starting from the identification or a requirement to the disposal of that requirement at the end of its life. Its functions may include pre contract activities supplier relationship and sourcing but it does not include logistic functions, such as storage, or transport. Could be used as the same meaning of procurement but it refers specifically to acquire goods, work or services, from suppliers. It is a component function of Procurement that is......

Words: 727 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Is the Difference Between Causation and Correlation

...What Is The Difference Between Causation and Correlation? The major discrepancy concerning causation and correlation is the power and measure to which two things are associated and the assurance with which anybody can institute a underlying relationship. Basically when you say one thing causes another, you are saying that there is a direct line between that one thing and the result. Cause means that an action will always have a predictable reaction. Once you describe correlation, the expressions cause and correlation grow to be easier to comprehend. If you see a correlation connecting two things, you can see that there is a affiliation between those two things. One thing does not automatically result in the other thing occurring, but it may increase likelihood that something will occur. The way to understand the difference of cause and correlation can best be understood by an example. For instance, “Violent video games cause violent behavior.” According to all research on this matter, this statement is not true, due to the use of the word causes in the sentence. Research has shown that violent video games may influence violent behavior. The correlation between violent video games and violent behavior some researchers have shown that there is a connection/correlation there. Violent games may influence others to act in more hostile but they are not the only reason and sometimes not even a factor for predicting violence. I believe that it really have a great impact on our...

Words: 342 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Are the Differences Between Newspapers and Magazines?

...press is one of the oldest categories of media and communication. Again, print also has such types of it as newspapers and magazines. This essay is aimed to distinguish and determine the most important differences between newspapers and magazines. Firstly, it is necessary to define general distinctions between newspapers and magazines. Newspapers are periodic editions and publications issued permanently, temporarily or “just-one-time”. Usually newspapers have not stapled sheets with a variety of articles, texts, and images of relatively small size. In general, newspapers dedicated primarily to current events of modern politics, culture, economics, science, sports and so on; and newspaper can be devoted to one particular of the areas and topics based on social conditions of the place where it is issued. Normally newspapers are compactly organized and structured in terms of physical size, and newspapers are also light weighted, so it is comfortable for readers to store them and they can be easily carried. Newspapers are made from soft paper while magazines are made from glossy paper. Magazines are also mainly periodic editions, which include a number of works by different authors, articles, and other documents, unified in one framework and papers bound together in the spine. Difference in attractiveness of magazines and newspapers also depends on many factors such as appearance, size, content, price and others. Magazines are more colorful than newspapers, because newspapers......

Words: 1398 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

What Is the Difference Between a “Dashboard” and a “Scorecard”? Why Is It Important That Managers Know the Difference Between the Two? What Can They Learn from Each of Them?

...|[pic] [pic] | | | MISY 3310 Management Information Systems Section W01: Online Course; 2013 Spring Semester Instructor: Dr. Tim Klaus Office: OCNR 385 Telephone: Office: (361) 825-2379 Cell Phone: (361) 248-8495 – feel free to call Mon-Sat between 9AM-10PM (I’ll be able to receive or return your call quicker than if you call the office) E-mail: tim.klaus@tamucc.edu Office Hours: Monday 8:30-8:55 AM, 9:55-10:55 AM, 12:00-3:10 PM Wednesday 8:30-8:55 AM, 9:55-10:55 AM Other days and times by appointment Course Website (Blackboard): http://iol.tamucc.edu/ Course Materials 1. Required Text: O’Brien, James and George Marakas, Introduction to Information Systems: Essentials for the E-Business Enterprise, 16th ed., Irwin/McGraw-Hill. Print - ISBN: 0073376884 eText – ISBN: 0077506413 2. Course material through http://iol.tamucc.edu/ Optional Materials None Prerequisites MISY 2305 or equivalent and Junior standing or above. Course Description: Provides an understanding of the importance of computer-based information in the success of the firm. Illustrates ways in which companies utilize computer systems to strategically compete within certain......

Words: 2297 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Why Are Nations Confused with the State?

...Sam Morris Why is the nation sometimes confused with the state? A nation is defined by a group of people who share a common cultural background, whether this be through shared traditions, a common language, history, religion, etc. They will consider themselves to be a community that has the ability to communicate on may level. A state is a sovereign power which is geographically defined and is governed by a certain set of laws and principles, which entitles it to be a self-determined entity. In today’s society some may view that because a state has these set of values, and that its citizens are by the very nature of fact that they abide by these values, are a nation. For example even though France is a state, the French people are also seen to form a nation. This combination of people sharing cultural values and having self-determination creates a nation-state. There is confusion caused because the state and the nation are linked heavily. Apart from the fact that most states are nations, the fact that the United Nations is actually a collection of states, recognised because of their political sovereignty. The two are also sometimes confused because nations which are not states will usually be struggling to gain statehood, which furthers the point that’s the two are intrinsically linked, such as Scotland who are seeking independence from the UK. Therefore they are currently part of the UK as a state, however they see their national identity as being......

Words: 378 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Differences Between United States and Puerto Rico

...Are there differences between living in Puerto Rico and living in the United States? I believe that there are big differences. I came to the United States when I was fifteen years old. Although, I am currently living in the United States, I always go back to Puerto Rico to visit my family. I love it there. I like living in the United States but there are many things that differ from Puerto Rico such as food, education and weather. Puerto Rico has variety of Spanish food that make you go there. Puerto Rico’s food is one of the best reasons to visit the island. It is diverse, rich, and flavorful with a combination of rice, beans, meat and fish fried. Puerto Rico cooking is somewhat similar to both Spanish and other Hispanic cuisines. It’s is a unique blend of influences. In Puerto Rico they cook rice with beans as a weekly menu. Traditional foods remind us of who we are, what we like, and those we love. In contrast the United States has variety of food from all over the world. Their food is a combination of everything because it has a lot of different people from other countries. Also, you can find Spanish food, Italian food, Mexican food, etc. The American people adopted a style of life, so they eat a lot of junk food, so there is high percentage of fast food places. In what I seemed American people tend to eat nachos, hot dogs and cheese burger instead of eating rice with beans. The style of education in Puerto Rico based in schools. In the other hand, their education......

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

What Is the Difference Between Sex and Gender?

...What is the Difference Between ‘Sex’ and ‘Gender’? To start this essay I will clearly state definitions of ‘Sex’ and ‘Gender’ respectively. ‘Sex’ is described as ‘the biological properties that distinguish organisms on the basis of their reproductive roles.’(Princeton University – 2010). Whereas gender is listed as ‘the state of being male or female, typically with reference to social or cultural differences rather than biological.’(Michigan University – 2010). In this essay I will explore and investigate both sex and gender, whilst identifying the differences between the two. I will start by elaborating on the given definitions. Sex is defined on the Princeton University website as ‘biological’. This is a word that has recurred in many other definitions that I have researched for the word ‘sex’. This would suggest that sex is able to be categorized in a straight forward manner. However, there are several high profile cases in the media, when the issue of ‘sex’ has come into question. Perhaps most recently is the case of South African athlete, Caster Semanya. Semanya won the 800m race during the African Junior Championship, with the fastest time of the year. This lead to some spectators questioning her sex. When looking at the athlete she has an incredibly muscular and angular frame, and this coupled with her record breaking run made the International Athletic Association ask for a sex test. This case brought the issue of ‘sex’ into much disrepute. Now, we......

Words: 1974 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cultural Differences Between the United States and Japan

...Cultural Differences between the United States and Japan Dena Lassley Saint Leo University There are many differences between the cultures of the United States and Japan. Some of these include religion, the food they eat, the clothes they wear and the way they view their people. According to Ivancevich and Konopaske, Hofstede believes that cultural differences are not changing, but work related norms and values may be. He also feels that those cultural views continue to have strong influences on the way organizations practice business. The differences between Japan and the United States as seen through Hofstede’s model can be seen in the chart below. As seen in this chart, Japan and the United States are only close in one of the six dimensions, Power Distance, Both countries are less likely to push for the symbols of authority and power in comparison to a culture with a higher power distance. They are also more likely to allow employees to give input into important decisions that have an impact on business practice. In the second dimension, individualism, Japan and the United States are very different. In the United States, emphasis is placed on the accomplishments and goals of the individual. In Japan, it is the achievements of the group that they find more important. In the sixth dimension, the United States also scored much higher than Japan. The United States is showing to be a more indulgent culture. They are more likely to have less control over their......

Words: 585 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

What Are the Distinguishing Factors Between the Contemporary Views of Health Promotion Versus the Historical View? How and Why Did These Differences Develop?

...Recognizing differences in the meaning of health can clarify outcomes and expectations in health promotion and enhance the quality of health care” (Edelman & Mandle, 2010, p. 3). This statement is so powerful when we are investigating health promotion in general. When discussing the differences between the contemporary and historical views of health promotion, it is important to think about how nursing and medicine has evolved to its current state. The historical view of health promotion has to do with where we started. This view includes the view that some of our elders still may believe in. These people often believe that if you weren’t feeling well, then you didn’t need to see a doctor. These people mainly saw their doctors for a specific reason, they didn’t think ahead. This lead too many people’s “miss fortune” which our, now, contemporary view focuses on preventing these illnesses. Currently in the contemporary view of health promotion, in the medical field we are constantly stressing screening and prevention of illness. For example, we all know that we can screen for cancer in the colon by doing colonoscopies routinely after the age of 50 years old, have a pap smear done routinely to prevent cervical cancer, and do mammograms routinely to screen for breast cancer. Also, an example of preventing illness we stress the importance of vaccines. All of these health promotional aspects of health care in the contemporary view have to do with where we were and what we......

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Differences Between the State and Federal Court System

...DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE STATE AND FEDERAL COURT SYSTEMS 2 Differences Between the State and Federal Court Systems Both the state government and federal government have their own separate court systems. They select their judges differently, hear different types of cases, and are structured a bit differently as well. The states use different types of ways to select their judges for their courts. In some states, voters get to vote for their judges during elections. In other states, the governor appoints their judges. Each state indicates the number of years that the judges will serve. In the case for federal judges, they are elected differently. The President of the United States nominates the judges and then the Senate confirms each nomination. Typically, federal judges hold office for lifetime, unless they are impeached. Judges can be impeached for misconduct and have to go through Congressional impeachment proceedings. Different types of cases are heard in state and federal courts. In the state courts, typically, criminal cases, contract cases, family matters, etc. are heard. In the federal courts, cases that are heard are those that involve violation of laws of the United States, public ministers, bankruptcy, disputes between two different states, etc. Depending on each case, the case will be heard upon the state court or the federal courts. This is due to the different laws each state has. For example, Illinois’ laws are different from...

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Distinguish Between the Nation and the State, and Explain Why the Two Terms Are Often Confused. (15marks)

...The definition of a state is an organized body of institutions that hold a monopoly of coercive powers over a territorial area. Unlike a nation, membership of a state is objective with citizenships assigned which clearly shows the legal status of a person. A state has a fixed territory, which its power does not extend. The state is a sovereign entity; a state cannot exist without a centre of sovereignty that is in control of the territory as sovereignty is at the heart of the formation of a state. Normally a state is characterized as having for major components: population, sovereignty, government and territory. If one of these is missing the state is unable to exist. States don’t have to take into account individual’s thoughts towards belonging to a state, as they are purely political bodies. A nation is defined by a community, which is united by a numbers of elements. These include; land, culture, language, tradition and a mutually accepted identity. Being part of a nation is more of a psychological bond supported by patriotism. Therefor it is subjective. The individuals themselves therefor decide upon membership. Patriotism is defined as a strong emotional attachment to an individual’s homeland and therefore giving their primary allegiance to the nation over all other aspects like religion. Nations do not necessarily have a defined geographical area however nations are still able to survive such as the case of the Kurds, which can be found in Turkey, Syria, and Iraq or......

Words: 447 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cultural Differences Between Venezuela and the United States

...------------------------------------------------- CULTURAL dIFFERENCES United States and Venezuela Introduction When examining the cultures of Venezuela and the United States there are some aspects of each that make them unique and special. There are three areas in which there is considerable difference. The first would be the cultural dimensions, which reflects the underlying framework of each society, the second would be the family structure and values, and the third would be the social norms, which dictate how people in a society ought to behave. It is important to understand these differences so that as an international marketer one is culturally competent and prepared to interact successfully within another culture. Cultural Dimensions Cultural values are the ideas and things of importance within a society. Starting in 1980, Geert Hofstede studied cultural values of more than 90,000 people in 66 countries, and found that nations differed along four primary dimensions. The four dimensions are; the Individualism/Collectivism Index (IDV), which focuses on self-orientation; the Power Distance Index (PDI), which focuses on authority orientation; the Uncertainty Avoidance Index (UAI), which measures the tolerance of uncertainty and ambiguity among members of the society; and the Masculinity/Femininity Index (MAS), which focuses on assertiveness and achievement. (International Marketing 16th Edition, 2013) Indulgence refers to the extent to which people try to...

Words: 1868 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Form of Gdp and What Is the Difference Between

...Gradable Assignment 1 1.     Full form of GDP and what is the difference between GDP per Capita Ans: GDP–Gross Domestic Product GDP per Capita – An estimate of an individual spends as a consumer compared to the total population spending on products and services. GDP is gross domestic product, the total economic output of a country, i.e., the amount of money a country makes. GDP per capita is the total output divided by the number of people in the population, so you can get a figure of the average output of each person, i.e., the average amount of money each person makes. 2.     Define or explain Purchase Power Parity in two lines Ans: Purchasing power parity (PPP) is a theory which states that exchange rates between currencies are in equilibrium when their purchasing power is the same in each of the two countries. 3.     Which of these are Formal Institutions and Informal Institutions Ans: a.     Laws- b.    Ethics- c.     Culture- d.    Regulations- e.     Norms- f.     Rules- 4.     Name two countries under Theocratic Laws Ans: Vatican City 5.     Name at least two of the three kinds of economies Ans: An economy is a system whereby goods are produced and exchanged. Without a viable economy, a state will collapse. There are three maintypes of economies: free market, command, and mixed. 6.     Name two characteristics each of Low Context and High Context cultures Ans: High Context Cultures 1. Space is communal; people......

Words: 698 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

What Is the Difference Between Living and Existing?

...Why i will choose this question because I found that it sounds quite interesting. Actually everyone of us might be confusing in this question because we don’t really know that we are living or existing in this world. How do we define it? Maybe for someone it will be quite easy because it can be find through the way you live and your lifestyle… The first question for me is what is living? For my opinion living is doing things your way. Doing reckless things, things you've always wanted to do. Fulfilling every dream you have and helping others to fulfill theirs. And living is also about waking up everyday knowing that your live has purpose and meaning because you make it so. Living is manifesting dreams into reality, actualizing your full potential. That's living. Follow by what is existing? Existing is simply being on earth. Not doing anything of any significance, just breathing. Like you waking up everyday only because your metabolic processes need you to eat or drink something to keep going. Existing is going through the motions, letting life happen to you instead of making things happen. I think the biggest distinction between living and existing comes from how much control you have over life decisions. Where do you see control coming from? In general, someone who exists feels as if everything is outside of their control while someone living knows they determine the path their life takes. Emotions have a big role to play in this. Someone who exists lets......

Words: 422 - Pages: 2