Premium Essay

Critical Evaluation of Positioning Concept

In:

Submitted By mizdip
Words 1218
Pages 5
Critical Appraisal of 10 References
1.1 Butt, I., Kumar, U., Kumar, V. 2009. “Achieving alignment between manufacturing and marketing through strategy.” Indian Journal of Economics and Business. p83 http://0-go.galegroup.com.prospero.murdoch.edu.au/ps/i.do?action=interpret&id=GALE%7CA280093139&v=2.1&u=murdoch&it=r&p=AONE&sw=w&authCount=1 (accessed September 27, 2012).

Summary: This article indicates that the competitive capability and success of a firm is directly linked to the manufacturing strategy and marketing objectives; which are inadvertently linked by understanding market requirements. It described positioning as the backbone of a business plan also used to combat competition in the market.
Critical Evaluation: The positioning conceptual framework proposed in this article is crucial for manufacturing firm’s success. The set variables identified in the concept work in harmony and the organization’s performance are also measured and discussed.
Rating: 3 out of 5

1.2 Landow, Y., 2012. “A Brand Positioning Nightmare.” Pharmaceutical Executive 32 (6): 60 – 62. http://0-search.proquest.com.prospero.murdoch.edu.au/docview/1041092781 (accessed on September 27, 2012).

Summary: This article talks about a drug that has received a new indication within a short period of time and how the brand director approached an action plan to help the drug thrive in multiple targets with different needs and mindsets.
Critical Evaluation: The situation in this article is useful should any company face a repositioning problem that could be turned into a success by exploring potential avenues that the brand can own. The article and solutions are simplified thus easy to digest and comprehend.
Rating: 4 out of 5

1.3 Scoviak, M., Conroy, K., Russell, K., Smith, P. 2004. “Enviable Positioning.” Hotels 38 (2): 32.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Lols

...GUIDELINES Critical evaluation of an advertisement (individual assignment) In order to demonstrate the marketing skills acquired during this module, you are asked to conduct a critical analysis of an advertisement. You have to choose only one advertisement out of the following two: 1. “Starbucksadvertisement”,availableontheInternetthroughthefollowing link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKy7mrAL0Dk 2. “Samsung Teases iPhone 5 With Their New Commercial”, available on the Internet through the following link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRkmtbWURwo You have to write a detailed analysis demonstrating an adequate comprehension of the following marketing concepts: segmentation, targeting and positioning. As we saw during the lectures and the tutorials, advertising is one of the tools through which organisations seek to reach their marketing goals by communicating to specific audiences. Your task is to identify and reflect upon (a) the market segments that have been chosen by the advertisers to craft their message and (b) the communication strategies that create a distinctive positioning for the organisation/product/service featured in the ad in relation to the market segment targeted. Of course, you do not have access to: the meeting reports and documents describing the relationship between the organisation and the advertising agency that produced the ad; the marketing plan which identifies the marketing goals, the segments targeted, the competitors and the positioning strategy...

Words: 843 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Giordano

...Giordano change its current positioning in the • Would the factors that had contributed to Giordano’s success in the past remain equally critical over the coming years or were new key success factors (KSF) emerging • Are Giordano’s competitive strengths readily transferable to other markets Concept • Brand Positioning By definition, brand positioning involves defining the one core idea that the brand stands for in the minds of customers. Besides, it helps in working out a strategy that forms the basis of pricing, promotion, product development and distribution decisions. Giordano at a Glance • “To be the best and the biggest world brand inthe apparel retailing.” • Giordano’s mission is to provide value for money merchandise • Giordano is a retailer of casual clothes • It was founded by jimmy Lai in 1980 • In 1985 it opened its first outlet in Singapore • After 1987 it repositioned itself as a retailer of unisex apparel Management value & styles • Lai’s management philosophy • Employee treated as an assets • Spent heavily on training-average 224 hourstraining for each employee • Paid high wages to employees • Flat organizational structure • Services of Giordano – key strength • Employee evaluation- service star award • Store evaluation- Best service shop • Value for money-selection of suppliers, cost control etc Management value & styles • Inventory control-Inventory turnover reduced to28 days in 1999 from 58 days in 1996 • Product positioning-simple having limited...

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ms Rebecca

...ideals of a detailed marketing plan demand a critical approach. The marketing processes, the market environment variables are essentially relevant to the overall ideals of a campaign. In this study it will be important to ascertain certain definitions which are fundamental to the study. According toAMA (1985) marketing involves the ideals of planning and execution of the concept, pricing strategies, promotional tactics, and the distribution of ideas, commodities and services and the creation of exchange and the satisfaction of objectives. Pettinger(2002) states that the ideals of marketing encompasses the offering of goods and services to the buyer at a price to achieve profit.CIM(2001) insists that marketing is managerial in nature and it involves the activities of identification, anticipation, and the satisfaction of customer needs with the intension of making profit, DISCUSSION/FINDINGS LO1.1 MARKETING PROCESSES Kotler, Amstrong, Saunders and Wong (1999) explain that the market process involves activities of critical analysis of the market. This involves the system of analyses regarding the market. Lancaster (1998) suggests that the marketing process consist of the Strategic market analysis This encompasses a managerial activity where the organisation focuses on utising opportunities that are opened to them with the intension of creating a long-term competitive advantage. This process inculcates formulation, evaluation, and the selection of strategies that are market...

Words: 3964 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Marketing Management

...Marketing Environment 2.1 Macro Environment (a) Political and Legal Environment (b) Economic and Competitive Environment (c) Social Cultural Environments (d) Technological Environment 2.2 Micro Environment 2.3 Competition (a) Competitors of Bosch Kettle 3. Critical analysis of relevant theories 3.1 SWOT Analysis 3.2 Portfolio Analysis 3.3 Porter’s Matrix 3.4 The Boston Matrix (The Product Portfolio) 3.5 Response Hierarchy Model (a) The AIDA Model (b) The innovation – adoption Model (c) The DAGMAR Model Market Attractiveness Model: the GE matrix 3.6 Critical Analysis 4. Critical Analysis of Buyer Behaviour 4.1 Consumer as Buyer 4.2 Conclusion and Analysis 5.0 Buyer Behaviour 5.1 Buyer Behaviour Role in Marketing 5.2 Consumer as Buyer 5.3 Why People Buy 5.4 How people choose (a) what influence Buyers? 6.0 Segmentation Targeting and Positioning Strategies 6.1 Segment Identification 6.2 Consumer basis 6.3 Physiographic 6.4 Geodemographics 6.5 Psychographics 6.6 Segmentation Techniques 6.7 Targeting Through Marketing Mix 6.8 Positioning 6.9 Practical Approaches 7.0 Marketing Mix 7.1 Product 7.2 Price 7.3 Place 7.4 Promotion 8.0 BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. Introduction The kettle assigned for marketing is Bosch TWK 6831. We have analyzed marketing environment and the key issues that are related to...

Words: 6526 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Word of Mouth

...Ch11-H8566.qxd 8/8/07 2:04 PM Page 222 CHAPTER 11 Market segmentation YORAM (JERRY) WIND and DAVID R. BELL All markets are heterogeneous. This is evident from observation and from the proliferation of popular books describing the heterogeneity of local and global markets. Consider, for example, The Nine Nations of North America (Garreau, 1982), Latitudes and Attitudes: An Atlas of American Tastes, Trends, Politics and Passions (Weiss, 1994) and Mastering Global Markets: Strategies for Today’s Trade Globalist (Czinkota et al., 2003). When reflecting on the nature of markets, consumer behaviour and competitive activities, it is obvious that no product or service appeals to all consumers and even those who purchase the same product may do so for diverse reasons. The Coca Cola Company, for example, varies levels of sweetness, effervescence and package size according to local tastes and conditions. Effective marketing and business strategy therefore requires a segmentation of the market into homogeneous segments, an understanding of the needs and wants of these segments, the design of products and services that meet those needs and development of marketing strategies, to effectively reach the target segments. Thus focusing on segments is at the core of organizations’ efforts to become customer driven; it is also the key to effective resource allocation and deployment. The level of segment aggregation is an increasingly important issue. In today’s global economy,...

Words: 14313 - Pages: 58

Premium Essay

Consumer Attitude Towards Brand Extensions

...Consumer Attitude Towards Brand Extensions: An Integrative Model and Research Propositions Sandor Czellar1 University of Geneva 1 University of Geneva, Section HEC, 40, boulevard du Pont-d’Arve, 1211 Geneva 4, Switzerland. 00 41 22 705 8114 (tel), 00 41 22 705 8104 (fax), czellars@hec.fr (email). 1 Consumer Attitude Towards Brand Extensions: An Integrative Model and Research Propositions The paper proposes an integrative model of the antecedents and consequences of brand extension attitude based on the dominant cognitive paradigm. The four key processes of the model are: (1) the perception of fit, (2) the formation of primary attitudes towards the extension, (3) the link between extension attitude and marketplace behaviour and (4) the reciprocal effect of brand extension attitude on parent brand/extension category attitude. Moderator and control variables of these processes are identified and classified into three groups: (1) consumer characteristics, (2) marketer-controlled factors and (3) external factors. This integrative model leads to the identification of missing links and variables in past research, resulting in a propositional inventory for future studies. The paper ends with a reflection on the long-term perspectives of scientific inquiry on brand extensions. Keywords: Brand extensions, Consumer Attitudes, Brand Associations, Brand Affect, Cognitive Psychology 2 Introduction Brand extension is the "use of established brand names to enter...

Words: 11112 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Unit 4: Marketing Principles

...Higher National in Business Unit Number and Title Start Date Assignment Due Date Assessor Name Assignment No Assignment Title Assignment Brief Unit 4: Marketing Principles March,16 2015 April 12, 2015 Qamar Riaz 01 Understand the concept and process of marketing & Concepts of segmentation, targeting and positioning A. The assignment envisages process of marketing and marketing orientation. The Dunkin Donut case scenario will help the students to understand and explore further the importance of marketing orientation for an organization. B. The assignment encompasses the concepts of marketing environment, segmentation, targeting and positioning and the role of marketers in specific buying behaviors. Students are expected to use suitable examples, provide reasons and justifications to support their answers in their own words. Part A Assignment Task / Description: 1. Define Marketing. What is marketing process as set out in your text book. Explain the various elements of marketing process. ( LO1; Assessment Criteria 1.1) 2. Select an organization of your choice, identify the marketing orientation it focuses on and evaluate the benefits and costs of the marketing orientation for the selected organization ( LO1; Assessment Criteria 1.2) 3. The Dunkin’ Donut Case: ( LO1; Assessment Criteria 1.2) For more than 50 years, Dunkin’ Donuts has offered customers throughout the United States, and around the world, a consistent experience – the same donuts, the same coffee, the same store...

Words: 1094 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hfkjshfhdfskjk

...home. The organizational consumer is buying for the organization or to re-sell to the personal consumer. Although both types of consumer entities are important, we will be focusing on the personal consumer throughout these presentations. Slide 10- The marketing concept was developed over time through two other important business orientations called the production and the sales orientation. They will be discussed in more detail on the following slides. Slide 12- During the production orientation, companies wanted efficient production lines to mass produce products for the consumer. Because the demand was higher than the supply, consumers were content to get a product and were not focused on product variation. This was the time that the control was in the hands of the producers who said, “if we make it they will buy it.” Slide 13- There was overproduction during the production orientation, which led to excess product. Although the products were still similar and there was little variation, during the sales orientation period, the manufacturers focused on selling the product which they had overproduced. Slide 14- Rather than focus on what can be manufactured, the focus shifts with the marketing concept to what consumers prefer. It became a time to put the customer first and to understand their needs and wants. With this information, marketers can deliver satisfaction to their target...

Words: 1885 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Buyer Behavior

...Robinson / Mr. Brian McCauley Teacher guided hours Learner directed hours Course Description 36 108 Concentrating on buyers needs is fundamental to the marketing concept. The emphasis of this subject is to look more closely at the buyer, covering the factors effecting: • • • • • why people make purchase decisions what products (goods and services) people buy how people go about the purchase process the frequency with which people purchase the buying decision process It is crucial that practitioners are able to usefully apply these buyer behaviour concepts to their marketing programs. The increasing complexity, competitiveness and change in today’s markets require a marketing practitioner to have a thorough understanding of buyer behaviour theories and dynamics if they are to have a competitive edge. MKTG 1052 BUYER BEHAVIOUR S1 2014 Course Guide 1 On completion of the course, students will normally be able to: Learning Outcomes • • Develop familiarity with the theories of buyer behaviour in consumer markets. Enhance their abilities to appraise models of consumer behaviour and determine their relevance to particular marketing situations. • Enhance their abilities to input this knowledge in the marketing planning process, particularly in market segmentation, positioning, and marketing mix development. • Understand the impact of on-line technologies and societal changes to marketing •...

Words: 3468 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Assignment

...FINAL ASSIGNMENT |Programme Title |Edexcel BTEC Level 5 HND Diploma in Business (QCF) | |Unit Title |Marketing Principles | |Unit Code |F/601/0556 | |Assignment No |01 | |Level |Level-5 HND | |Credit value |15 credits | |Assessor | | |Deliverer | | |Handout Date | | |Hand in Date |31/07/2014 | Assignment Title: Making Marketing Decisions You have been appointed...

Words: 1867 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Business

...Marketing Principles and Analysis MKT 305 Winter Quarter 2014-2015 Instructor: Bill Froese Office Location: See Blackboard Office Hours: See Blackboard Phone: 224-616-4789 Email: wfroese@robertmorris.edu Course: MKT 305 Quarter Hours: 4 COURSE DESCRIPTION: This course will introduce students to key marketing principles including the marketing concept, management of the marketing mix (product, price, place and promotion), analysis of the external environment, ethical issues in marketing, segmentation, targeting and positioning. This course examines how organizations discover needs or wants that they can serve in the market place. Upon completion of the course, students should understand and appreciate the significant role that marketing plays in our fast-changing global marketplace. LENGTH OF COURSE: 10 weeks TEXTBOOK: Boone, Louis E. and Kurtz, David L. Contemporary Marketing, 15th Edition 2013. Mason, Ohio. Southwestern/Cengage, 2013. ISBN: 978-1-111-57971-5 NOTE: Make sure you get the 15th Edition and not the 16th! There is also a bundled package including the Text with Blackboard MindLink for CourseMate and e-text access printed access code card. ISBN: 978-1-305-59157-8 Finally, you can get the Blackboard MindLink for CourseMate and e-text access printed access code card. ISBN: 9781285369488 Special Note Regarding CourseMate: CourseMate supplemental resources are bundled with the purchase of a new textbook. CourseMate can become...

Words: 3876 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Moments of Truth

...Moments of Truth Mocha – Coffees and Conversations Submitted by – Group 5   Table of Contents About Moments of Truth 3 About Mocha 5 Moments of Truth 6 Decisions as a CEO 9 Moments of Truth Customer Moment of Truth (MOT) can be defined as “In customer service, instance of contact or interaction between a customer and a firm (through a product, sales force, or visit) that gives the customer an opportunity to form (or change) an impression about the firm. Managing reputations and managing problems are especially important for service organizations. Services sell intangibles, through expectations and promises of what is to come. A critical moment, which forms or destroys the relationship with customers, is a “moment of truth” for service organizations; this is the point where the customer and organization come together. In recent years, mature companies with far-flung networks of frontline sales staff—banks, retailers, airlines, and incumbent telecom providers, for example—have devoted a great deal of money and effort to retaining their current customers. As many academic studies have noted, the costs of doing so tend to be much lower than those of acquiring new ones. The success of this strategy ultimately depends on expanding the breadth and depth of customer relationships and on translating the resulting loyalty into higher sales of goods and services, as well as a healthier bottom line. We...

Words: 1535 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Guidline

...managerial problem. It’s as if the reader is inside the organization (at the time the case was written) and has most, if not all, relevant information, facts, and circumstances. The student’s role in case analysis is to diagnose and evaluate the situation described in the case. You then develop recommendations, supporting arguments, and the appropriate action steps that should be taken to rectify the problem presented in the case. After reading this guide, you will be able to: * Understand what a case study is * Appreciate the benefits of using case studies in the learning of strategic management and how their use can help develop your managerial skills * Use the key steps in analyzing case studies * Apply theoretical concepts and frameworks to the case material The case approach to strategic analysis is an exercise in “learning by doing.” Because cases provide you with detailed information about conditions and problems of different industries and companies, your task of analyzing organization after organization and situation after situation has the double benefit of increasing your analytical skills and demonstrates the ways companies and managers actually do things. Case analysis helps substitute for on-the-job experience by: 1. Giving you broader exposure to a variety of...

Words: 1671 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mkt 575

... 0 Market segmentation analysis d. 0 Customer profile analysis Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors. 3. _____ recognizes that active competition among industry members helps determine industry performance and it is the most direct and intense form of competition. a. 0 Rivalry among existing firms b. 0 Threat of new entrants c. 0 Threat of substitute products d. 0 Bargaining power of suppliers Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors. 4. An analysis of each competitors past sales would be included in a _____. a. 0 Customer value report b. 0 Market forecast c. 0 Competitors' analysis d. 0 Market segment analysis Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors 5. If critical inputs are in jeopardy or prices of those inputs are extraordinarily high, companies may pursue vertical integration strategies or develop collaborative relationships to reduce the _____ a. 0 Rivalry among existing firms b. 0 Bargaining power of buyers c. 0 Threat of...

Words: 1517 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Mkt 575

... 0 Market segmentation analysis d. 0 Customer profile analysis Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors. 3. _____ recognizes that active competition among industry members helps determine industry performance and it is the most direct and intense form of competition. a. 0 Rivalry among existing firms b. 0 Threat of new entrants c. 0 Threat of substitute products d. 0 Bargaining power of suppliers Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors. 4. An analysis of each competitors past sales would be included in a _____. a. 0 Customer value report b. 0 Market forecast c. 0 Competitors' analysis d. 0 Market segment analysis Objective: Analyze the industry, market, and competitors 5. If critical inputs are in jeopardy or prices of those inputs are extraordinarily high, companies may pursue vertical integration strategies or develop collaborative relationships to reduce the _____ a. 0 Rivalry among existing firms b. 0 Bargaining power of buyers c. 0 Threat of...

Words: 1517 - Pages: 7