Premium Essay

Victim Impact Circles

In:

Submitted By bulletswimmer
Words 521
Pages 3
in recent years and how they appear to be more effective than previously used victim impact panels. The reason the circles work better is because all individuals involved can face each other. Circles historically have been used to listen to ideas and make decisions. The panels did not have the personal interaction that the circles have shown to have. The idea of restorative justice is that you can use dialogue and discussion in order to try to solve delinquency problems before going to court. Results are measured by how much preparing has been done rather than how much punishment has been inflicted. The idea of the courts is often to punish and victims and suspects never speak to each other face to face. In the victim impact panels both parties have a chance to speak their mind. Because children often have a narrow view of the world and are unable to put themselves in peoples shoes, putting a face and personality to a person they harmed is often effective to turn the bad behavior around. Dan talked about how the victim offender conferencing is voluntary on everyone's part and that more offenders say no than the victims. They are often too embarrassed. The idea is that the door is open at all times and anyone is free to leave, that way no one feels they are being held against their will. The most important aspect of the conference is safety. If safety cannot be insured than a VOC should not be conducted. Accountability for the juvenile offender means taking responsibility and acting to repair the harm that they had done. If the offender is not willing to do this than the issue is returned to the court system. Dan gave many examples of how victims and offenders have negotiated a deal and things worked out smoothly in the end. This program began as a probation project with the approval of the judiciary in agreement with the states attorney office. In a VOC it is

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

R V Gittany Case Study

...Criminal Case Case: R v Gittany Facts: Lisa Cecilia Harnum’s body fell from her shared high-rise apartment in the Sydney CBD minutes after trying to leave her abusive fiancé Simon Gittany. Gittany has had a dark past being associated with violence, drugs, having an uncontrollable temper and committing several criminal offences which included biting off parts of a policemen’s ear and selling cocaine. Gittany claims Harnum either slipped or deliberately fell to her death. Gittany had ‘bugged’ Harnum’s cell phone reading all her text messages and emails as well as listening to all her calls. When he discovered his fiancé was seeing a councillor he physically threatened her that if she saw his fiancé again he will “harm [her].” The day of Harnum’s death she had planned to flee to Canada to get away from her abusive fiancé and to be with her parents. As she left her apartment to go to the airport he was seen on CCTV with his hand over her mouth and pushing her back into the apartment. Harnum was seen very distressed as she tried to run away from Gittany. Neighbours then heard Harnum pleading “help! Help! Somebody help me! God help me!” 69 seconds later she fell to her death. Judgements: Judge Lisa McCallum declared Simon Gittany to be guilty and sentenced him to a minimum of 18 years imprisonment. The court charged Gittany with premeditated murder. Why?: McCallum made this judgement in court as sufficient evidence found that Gittany planned on killing Harnum on several occasions yet...

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Madd, Impact on Society

...MADD, Impact on Social Policy Jacqueline Boyd BSHS 355 February 12, 2014 Pam Harris MADD, Impact on Social Policy The impact MADD has had on social policy is history breaking. Mother Against Drunk Driving has changed the laws regarding drinking and driving throughout the United States. MADD changed the legal age for drinking and purchasing alcohol. MADD has made the laws stricter; including more fines and punishment for breaking the laws. MADD has become one of the nation’s largest agencies to help improve assistance for families that have lost loved ones to drunk drivers. The organization has made historical changes in laws and legislature. MADD, Impact on Social Policy Mothers Against Drunk Drivers has made a significant impact on our society today by bringing changes in our drinking and driving laws. MADD, more commonly referred to, has implemented a change in drinking age and mandated strict laws for people who break these laws. From a simple outcry by the founder of MADD, this organization has grown to service millions. MADD was originally founded by Candy Lightner in 1980 after her 13 year old daughter, Cari was struck from behind and killed by a drunk driver. The driver had three previous drunk driving violations and had been involved in a hit-and-run accident and arrest two days before the incident involving Cari. One of the most effective leaders was Rebecca (Beckie) Brown from New Port, Florida. Rebecca became involved in MADD after her son Marcus...

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Music

...the criminal justice process and the extent to which it serves to satisfy the victims’ experiences. An Evaluation of the Pilot Victim Statement Schemes in Scotland commissioned by the Scottish executive was carried out in 2007. Six different aspects of the Scheme was investigated which included the response rates of victims, their views on the pilot schemes, the criminal justice professionals’ views on the pilot schemes, the content of victim statements, the impact of the victim statement scheme on workload and court processes and the outcome of cases in which a victim statement was made. The research found that 61% of respondents felt better after making the statement even though more than half had no idea whether their statement was considered in court. Very few respondents made suggestions relating to the victim statement scheme itself and instead felt the desire to put their point of view across more generally. Another Research review requested by the Commissioner for Victim and Witnesses in England and Wales in 2011evaluated empirical research into the use of victim statements. The report was split into two parts where the first part contained general information about the scope of the VPS scheme in England and Wales while part 2 reviews empirical research into the use of victim statements at sentencing. The review found that there a common finding amongst several studies that victims were generally satisfied with making and submitting a statement as it had a therapeutic...

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Restorative Justice

...restorative and contemporary justice, and how restorative justice worked for the RJ city case study. Restorative Justice Process Restorative justice deals with "the need to compensate victims, the need to place appropriate responsibility on the criminal offender, and the need to attempt the reintegration of the offender with the community" (Schmalleger, Hall, & Dolatowski, 2010, Chapter 14). The way we used to view crime was like a violation against the state. We now understand that crime also violates an individual. The idea of restorative justice is to restore the victim and the criminal instead of just the criminal. There are three main processes involved in the restorative justice system. There are restorative circles, restorative conferencing, and victim-offender mediation. Restorative Circles Restorative circles are meetings that include the offenders, victims, friends and families, interested members of the community, and some representatives of the justice system. ("Restorative Justice Online", 1996-2014). There is a facilitator who keeps the process in order and summarizes the information given in the meeting. The circle gives each person time to discuss the issues with the offender. The meeting works to help the members get involved in helping the offender. The idea of a circle is to find a solution to helping the offender to find ways to better him/herself. Restorative Conferencing Conferencing brings...

Words: 1315 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Theories Of Retributive Justice

...the victim. An affordable alternative to the retributive justice system is the restorative justice practices which can be considered unique in its emphasis on not just one component of the criminal justice system such as punishment, but as incorporating victims,...

Words: 1262 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Restorative Justice

...meeting in a mediated setting and follow-up. First component of the restorative justice process is mutual. Both the criminal and the victim must be agreeable to meet without pressure or coercion from anybody. In fact, the simply principle for whether a felonious difficulty must be well-thought-out for restorative justice processes is whether the victim and criminal have developed to the procedure. Only if both parties decide to arbitrate will the process happen. The second component of restorative justice process is the meetings in which the facilitator will meet separately with both the victim and the criminal. During these meetings the facilitator hears from both parties what occurred and in what way the crime has affected individuals and families. The facilitator defines the procedure and the objectives of facilitation and replies to any inquiries that both parties may have. The final component is the follow-up process. Once an agreement has been prepared by the law breaker that will be overseen, they have a trend to implement the agreement. When contracts are preserved, the lawbreaker is requested to a get-together, with or without the victim at the victim’s select, to explain his or her intentions. The scenarios in the case study demonstrates how the crime had consequences to the community past mischief to the direct victim. Associates of the community felt offended due to wrongdoing being committed nearby to their homes. As panic spread throughout the community...

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Carlos

...commonly defined as being physically threatening to someone else to cause harm. However, with the internet and social media sites in full swing, bullying becomes more intricate and diverse. It can cause emotional damage just as it does physical. Some bullies prefer to harm someone using gossip, name calling and/or leaving someone out of a social circle. Bullying should be defined accurately so that it can be discussed and prevented. Actions that coincide with bullying do not just impact the bully and the victim, but it can also impact those witnessing it. An incorrectly defined problem creates more of a problem. When researched and clearly defined, strategies can be implemented to prevent bullying from taking place. Also, interventions become more efficient. The problem is that there are over 217 bullying cases every year, sometimes even more. This is a problem because a lot of teenager’s even adults try to commit suicide by either overdosing with drugs, hanging themselves, or by cutting their wrist, ECT. Bullying can affect everyone, no matter what age, gender, or culture. One of them main people that bullying affect is the victim as well as the parents. My definition of the term bullying hasn’t changed because the article has the same definition as mine, same accuracy and same subject. My definition is more specific as best of my knowledge, a more specific definition would better because people could understand the different ways of the term bullying and how to be able to...

Words: 290 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Doctor

...Collateral Murder Morgan Pollock 496751 LM2A Table of content Final draft Page 3 First draft Page 7 Second draft Page 9 Third draft Page 12 Sources Page 16 Collateral Murder By Morgan Pollock On April 4th, 2010, a whistle-blowing website by the name of Wikileaks, released a classified United States military video depicting the indiscriminate slaying of over a dozen people in the Iraqi suburb of New Bagdad by an Apache helicopter crew (collateralmurder.com). Among the victims killed were two Reuters news reporters, Namir Noor-Eldeen and Saeed Chmagh . The video also contains an audio track of the soldiers voices responsible for the attack in which they laugh about the unprovoked slaughter. The following document covers, in detail, the events that unfold during the video, an extract from the U.S Military Rules Of Engagement for Iraq and in what ways they were violated by the soldiers in question and what happened during the days after the attack. It concludes with a brief discussion of the video by Wikileaks and the effects it has had. All the points in this document will provide evidence that proves, that the actions taken by the crew of the Apache helicopter were unwarranted and despicable. At 9:50 am, on the day of July 12th 2007, U.S. armed forces received reports of small arms fire in a Baghdad suburb of New Bagdad. The military claims it was unable to positively identify the...

Words: 7101 - Pages: 29

Premium Essay

The Ups and Downs of Social Media

...be limitless. Social media is something I never heard of until well after high school. I graduated in 2002 and bullying at my high school was done face to face instead of on the internet. Bullying in the information age has been defined as Cyber Bullying. Cyber bullying can be defined as an aggressive, intentional act carried out by a group or individual, using electronic forms of contact, repeatedly and over time against a victim who can not easily defend themselves. (Research Briefs www.dfes.gov.uk/research ). There are 7 types of cyber bullying: text message, picture/video (via mobile phone cameras), phone call (via mobile phones), Email, chat-room, instant message, and through websites. (Research Briefs www.dfes.gov.uk/research ). Cyber Bullying through pictures or video were perceived to have more of an impact on victims than traditional forms of bullying (Research Briefs www.dfes.gov.uk/research ). Bully victims are 2 to 9 times more likely to commit suicide than non-victims, according to studies done by Yale University. The impact on any form of...

Words: 820 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

American Corrections

...As a matter of fact there are several types of bullying that i will be discussing with you shortly. The most common type of bullying is physical bullying. Physical bullying can be anything from hitting, pushing, kicking, spitting, and even stealing. Most of this type of bullying occurs in and around schools. Physical bullying is a serious problem, affecting not only the bully and the victim, but also the other students who witness the bullying. Parents, teachers, and other concerned adults and young people should be aware of what physical bullying is and some of the ways to handle it. Physical bullying can start at any age, although it is most common around the middle school age. Males are more likely to be involved with bullying than girls. However, girls can be involved with bullying too. Usually when a person wants more control of another person, he or she gains that control by becoming a bully. Some reasons why people are bullied can be based someone’s weight, height, strength, race, gender, and/or appearance. Bullies usually have extremely low self-esteem or he or she has been an actual victim of bullying. There are many signs to look for when...

Words: 2324 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Hypothesis Testing

...back in American history the major importance of crime as a social problem. Society in America has been increasingly concerned about this problem and the victims experience with hate. This type of crime has generated the development of a numerous variety of victim service programs and research that will focus on victims instead of giving the criminals their five seconds of fame. “Hate violence crimes are those directed against persons, families, groups, or organizations because of their racial, ethnic, religious, or sexual identities or their sexual orientation or condition of disabilities. These crimes include arson of homes, businesses, and harassment, destruction of religious property, cross burnings, personal assaults, and homicides.” (Barnes & Ephross, 1994) It could be a difficult task to estimate the current prevalence of hate violence in the United States. With the help of media sources, there is a way to keep track and be more aware of these types of crimes. Focus group meetings, individual interviews, and questionnaires would be a way of sampling victims. Victims should include black, white, and Southeast Asians. Would these victims show anger, fear and sadness as the emotional responses? The findings would also provide if there were a series of attacks rather than a single attack. How many of the victims would move away from the neighborhood? Or would they consider purchasing a gun instead? A questionnaire conducted by the Journal of Consulting and...

Words: 1461 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Native Studies

...Changes in the Aboriginal Justice System through Colonialism Austin Jamieson 11153678 Native Studies 107 Ron Laliberte November 20, 2013 Aboriginal justice system has gone through many changes throughout history. This has mostly been because of Colonialism. Its presence is highly noticed in the formation of cultures and their ways, as well as in the elimination of others cultures and their ways. Colonialism has affected Aboriginal culture in several ways; however, a significant area that has been affected is the traditional Aboriginal justice system. Aboriginal communities had their own sense of justice and punishment prior to the arrival of the Europeans in Canada, Aboriginal communities lost their traditional means of sentences to the implementation of European corporal punishment. In the Western concept of justice, the system punishes the offender through a process of trying to make the offender conform, often locking them away to protect society from the dangers that offender brings to those around them. Aboriginal systems (which varying) try to focus on restoring the peace and harmony of the community. The concept is meant to use the justice system to bring equilibrium into the offender and community, as balance is necessary for kinship and relationships to flourish. Elders within Aboriginal communities began to bring many of these traditional correction techniques back into society to fix the growing numbers of criminal offenders throughout the country nearing...

Words: 2423 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

History

...year * Community Partners will be recognized in a full page advertisement in the Huntsville Times a minimum of one time per year * Your company will be recognized on the NCAC Campus Donor Wall.   * Your company will be recognized in the NCAC Annual report that is distributed to approximately 5,000 people per year.  * Your company will be featured in a special newsletter section for Community Partners mailed twice a year to over 7,000 people * The National Children's Advocacy Center will serve as a resource for your company for child abuse issues, including training, guidance and input from the trained professionals on staff at the NCAC. * We are excited and honored again to serve as the chairs of the 2012 Protectors' Circle Initiative.  We know that you are aware of the important role that the National Children's Advocacy Center plays in our community, helping children and families whose lives are impacted by child sexual abuse and severe...

Words: 1488 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Restorative Justice Literature Review

...juveniles. In the Teen Court program juveniles offenders are encourage to understand the harm they’ve caused to the victim and their communities. Moreover, the opportunities that are given to offenders not only to give back to the communities but to also restore their relationships. The authors went on to example the different types of restorative justice programs offer to juveniles in the Teen Court. The examples of restorative justice programs include; peacemaking circles, community/ and family group conferencing and victim/offender mediation. The specific goals of the Teen Court restorative justice programs include changing problematic behavior through positive peer pressure exerted by a peer jury, decreasing the juvenile court’s workload, decreasing the negative effects of labeling juveniles as delinquents, increasing offender community involvement through community service, obtaining closure for victims, and reducing rates of crime and recidivism...

Words: 735 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Domestic Violence

...Idea” I have decided to tackle is Prevention of Domestic Violence Against Women. My working thesis statement is Domestic Violence is a serious issue nationwide and women are at greatest risk of becoming victims of this form of abuse. Therefore, the only way to break the cycle of domestic violence is to take action; the sooner the better.” I believe my topic is extremely relevant to the present day context. With the necessary research and past experiences I plan to acquire, I hope to develop an effective essay wherein I put up a convincing argument for my reader. To start with, I will research many reliable online sources such as VAWnet.org, an National Online Resource Center on Violence Against Women, which contains resources relevant to research on domestic violence including Applied Research Documents, data sets, research and evaluation tools, fact sheets, research reports, and other publications that provide an analysis, critique and/or review of current related issues (VAWnet.org, 2011). I will look to the Kaplan library’s extensive database to find articles on case studies and statistics of the actions taken against the abusers. I will also be interviewing a few people in my family and friends circle who have been victims of such a heinous act and the impact it left on the rest of their lives. These real life situations and instances will add the necessary fervor to my appeal and will help in providing evidence of my claim: that stricter legal policies and rules...

Words: 541 - Pages: 3