Free Essay

Central Park as a Cultural Text

In:

Submitted By etran123
Words 1434
Pages 6
New York City's Central Park was the first landscaped public park in the United States. In the early 1850s, wealthy New Yorkers envisioned a project to construct a park that had spanned for over a decade and cost the city millions of dollars. Following a long period of debate concerning the site and cost of the project, the state legislature authorized the acquisition of 700 acres of land through eminent domain. Advocates of the park hoped to refute the European notion that Americans were devoted to a life of materialism without taking consideration of the common good. Furthermore, in awe of the public grounds in London and Paris, wealthy New Yorkers wanted to uplift the international reputation of the city—or better yet, the United States—by constructing a similar feature. The high society of New York City imagined an idyllic and rustic landscape, where they could travel in carriages, socialize with the rest of the upper class, and allow the poor to live in a safer and cleaner environment as well. Using the "Greensward Plan" designed by Frederick Law Olmstead and Calvert Vaux as winners of a design contest, the park underwent construction in 1853. Upon the park's completion in 1873, the idyllic landscape that encompassed large meadows, several lakes and hills, and a reservoir finally came to life. During a time period when industrialism in New York City was growing at a rapid and extraordinary pace, the green space intended to lure workers into spending time towards a life of healthy leisure and recreation, perhaps as a rejuvenating retreat from the unnatural urban life. While Central Park may appeal to the general public as an innocent green world for the entire society, it became clear within the first act of landscaping of the park that the project would be problematic. Original inhabitants of this particular region in Manhattan had to be displaced to initiate the early acts of construction. Even though at this point Native Americans like the Lenape tribe were already dwindling in numbers from contact with Europeans, the city nevertheless drove out the residing park settlers at the time: "1,300 African Americans, Irish, and German New Yorkers" (Fisher, 28). A space that previously served as a housing shelter for early settlers to fish, farm, and raise domestic animals ultimately disappeared. Fisher concludes through Oliver Goldsmith's poem, "The Deserted Village", that the city's removal of New Yorkers is no different from the approaches Europeans took to build urban landscapes. In fact, European aristocrats had to displace large-scale villages in order to build breathtaking public parks. The creation of an awe-inspiring park in New York City required the relocating of ordinary people to another part of the city. This process brings to light regarding whether landscaping and urban planning is worth the loss and displacement of the local population. The city government and the upper class society might have intended to create the park for the common good, but they made a choice that did not value the lives of working class immigrants. In constructing the park site and acquiring nearly 700 acres of land through eminent domain, the government had the power to determine the significance of the previously swampy, rocky, and muddy site and whether it was worthy enough of preserve and thus move social minorities. The process is indicative of the government's authority over certain social classes without seeking their interests. To this day, the Central Park Conservancy, a nonprofit and charitable organization under contract with the city government, manages the restorations and enhancements of the park. Even though Central Park today is a protected area that anyone can visit and spend leisurely time in, this historic landmark obscures the controversial obstacles that had transpired in the process of building the park. To highlight further scrutiny of authority of Central Park, the Central Park Conservancy relies on the private funds and donations of Park-area residents, corporations and foundations in order to keep maintenance. In 2012, hedge fund billionaire John Paulson donated $100 million dollars to the Central Park Conservancy, which some claim to believe is a way for him to establish his legacy on Wall Street and in New York City (Ulam, 65). Subsequently, this is an issue concerning how the public parks are financed, and serves as a means of establishing upper-class control. Furthermore, the influx of private funds toward the Conservancy resembles the privatization of public space. With state and local governments coming under increased budget pressure, the private management of public parks becomes a convincing tool for public authorities intending to keep the park open for the public. At the same time, the actions of people like Paulson causes one to question whether the public park is in the hands of wealthy individuals. The privatization occurring in Central Park can emerge to a point where the Conservancy will no longer operate in the eyes of public interest. While it appears that the constant maintenance of Central Park will stand for generations, local New Yorkers have frequently sparred with the Conservancy—and lost—regarding its responsiveness to how the public would like to use Central Park. The Conservancy might be concerned with the appearance of the park, but they are not too concerned with the local residents who want to play soccer or softball on the park's Great Lawn. As a result, the park will look beautiful and natural, but will succeed at the cost of not properly serving what local residents' desire. With the public voice falling on deaf ears, local city residents lose faith in the government's ability to do what it takes to provide for the public good. Every year, nearly thirty-five million people visit the scenic beauty of lush green. Among the millions of park visitors, Angel Chan came across the pastoral scenery every day for three months when commuting to her fashion internship at Marchesa. As a foreign intern from London, she never ceased to be amazed at the lushness and beauty of large fauna while strolling through the walking trails. With an abundance of trees surrounding the park site, she claimed that she could barely see the city's buildings from within the park. As a result, she found herself in a secluded ambience, where she wouldn't have to be concerned with the stressful demands that came from designing clothes at her internship (Interview). As visitors of the park admire in awe of Central Park, they lose sight of the effort taken for the park to become as natural as it seems, and the effort to implement the park's intended plan was anything but natural. Before construction of the park site even began, Olmstead and Vaux created a plan that imposed an "idealized landscape of gentle slopes and sweeping vistas on a rugged, 778-acre site characterized by bogs, ridges, plateaus, and rocky outcrops" (Brown, 42). With the assistance of engineers, the project's design attempted to follow the natural topography while performing industrial tasks such as building a drainage system, excavating the earth, and constructing bridges and roads. The extent to which industrialism emerged in New York City was undoubtedly prevalent in the formation of Central Park. In fact, urban landscapes like Central Park can be rendered contributions to the formation of an industrialized city. There is an ironic result in which engineering and man-made work shaped a landscape that many people consider natural. In spite of the controversy and tension that transpired from an urban park in the heart of Manhattan, the park nevertheless holds a wondrous place through a combination of relaxation and recreation. Central Park is not only a place for naturalists to seek a close feeling of nature, but it is an undisputed place for the festive soul to seek fun through pastimes. Times have changed the perspectives people make of Central Park, and perhaps the disputed tensions that came about in the past will be resolved in the future. Working immigrants who once lived on the grounds of the park site might have been displaced, but perhaps the relocation has brought forth a better lifestyle. Moreover, the government might be facing pressure with budgets to sustain the park's scenery, but the private funds toward the Conservancy can help the government build funds that will relieve the financial burden of taxpayers. Additionally, industrialism today seeks to find ways to be more sustainable than before. The park can in some ways represent the progress of architectural landscaping, with a goal of aiming to become more natural. Conclusively, Central Park is a site that provides history, significance, and a variety of meanings.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Dienstleistungsmarketing

...Euro Disneyland (“Euro Disneyland” or “EDL”)6 in Marne-la-Vallee, France. The ´ realities of opening and operating EDL in France were far different than Disney’s expectations when it began negotiations—so much so that the Resort narrowly escaped bankruptcy.7 For an “entertainment empire”8 like Disney, this was an unprecedented * Assistant Professor of Law, Ohio Northern University, Pettit College of Law; B.A., Georgetown University, 2004; J.D., Harvard Law School 2007. 1 As used herein, “Resort” refers to a Disney resort property, consisting of (unless otherwise indicated), Parks, hotels, all entertainment facilities, and the transportation systems that connect them. “Park” refers to a Disney theme park, including (unless otherwise indicated) the park grounds, rides, and attractions, and surrounding resorts, hotels, and other Disney-affiliated entertainment facilities. 2 Tokyo Disney was Disney’s third Park and first international venture, located in Tokyo, Japan. See The Walt Disney Co., Annual Report (Form 10-K), at 11–12 (Nov. 21, 2012) [hereinafter Annual Report]. 3 Disney refers to Resort visitors and patrons as “guests.” This terminology derives from Walt Disney, who, at the opening of Disneyland Resort (“Disneyland”), established the motto “At Disneyland, the visitors are our guests.” BILL CAPODAGLI & LYNN JACKSON, THE DISNEY WAY: HARNESSING THE...

Words: 12089 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Mickey to France

...Euro Disneyland (“Euro Disneyland” or “EDL”)6 in Marne-la-Vallee, France. The ´ realities of opening and operating EDL in France were far different than Disney’s expectations when it began negotiations—so much so that the Resort narrowly escaped bankruptcy.7 For an “entertainment empire”8 like Disney, this was an unprecedented * Assistant Professor of Law, Ohio Northern University, Pettit College of Law; B.A., Georgetown University, 2004; J.D., Harvard Law School 2007. 1 As used herein, “Resort” refers to a Disney resort property, consisting of (unless otherwise indicated), Parks, hotels, all entertainment facilities, and the transportation systems that connect them. “Park” refers to a Disney theme park, including (unless otherwise indicated) the park grounds, rides, and attractions, and surrounding resorts, hotels, and other Disney-affiliated entertainment facilities. 2 Tokyo Disney was Disney’s third Park and first international venture, located in Tokyo, Japan. See The Walt Disney Co., Annual Report (Form 10-K), at 11–12 (Nov. 21, 2012) [hereinafter Annual Report]. 3 Disney refers to Resort visitors and patrons as “guests.” This terminology derives from Walt Disney, who, at the opening of Disneyland Resort (“Disneyland”), established the motto “At Disneyland, the visitors are our guests.” BILL CAPODAGLI & LYNN JACKSON, THE DISNEY WAY: HARNESSING THE...

Words: 12089 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Hinduism

...practice. Hinduism lacks what is commonly a uniting belief system, in religion. As opposed to being held together by that uniting system, Hinduism is bound by traditions and beliefs which have developed over centuries. Amongst these traditions and beliefs in Hinduism there are different sects, however each one venerates the Vedas. (What Makes Up The Hindu Religion) The Vedas are the main text of Hinduism, such as the Bible to Christianity. Aside from their importance related to Hinduism, the Vedas also donate insight on life in India four thousand years ago. India, is the region of Hindu origination, there is no one person, however that it can be traced to as Hinduism is too old. Through Indo- European tribes invading Northern India, the religion took on influence. (Hinduism, A General Introduction) This influence through invasion took place over thousands of years. When Russia and Central Asia brought their religion of Vedism, which eventually mingled with Hinduism, (Hinduism, A General Introduction) This is the type of societal influences Hinduism faced and conformed well with. As far as cultural influence is concerned, Hinduism is practiced by eighty percent of India's population. Also, according to hindustanlink.com: India is one of the few countries on earth in which the social and religious structures which define the nation's identity remain intact, and have continued to do so for at least 4000 years despite invasions, persecution, European colonialism and political upheaval...

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ysm Art

...Yong Soon Min: Art Connecting With Cultural Experiences Yong Soon Min is a Korean born artist that emigrated from South Korea to the United States as a seven year-old child. Having been born at the end of the Korean War and growing up in the Cold War Era, she felt a strong connection to her cultural ties and grew up with some discomfort in having to adjust to life as a an immigrant. She derives inspiration for her artwork through her own personal experiences as both Asian and American while embodying the motto “Personal is political” (Oxford University Press 317). A great deal of her work is done in a mixed media format or as a performance piece and often calls for audience participation (Oxford University Press 317). DMZ-XING Yong Soon Min, DMZ-XING, 1994, (Mixed-Media Installation) One such piece by Min is called DMZ-XING (1994), a mixed-media piece taking its name from the Korean Demilitarized Zone. Yong Soon Min created an installation in 19pictures, and a series of narrative texts strewn about (Min 134). Here, she was capturing and retelling her own story as well as the stories of several families from Asia—Cambodia, Korea, Viet Nam, and others—that escaped from their homelands due to the onslaught of wars, and the experiences that they encountered while acclimating to the new experiences they would find for themselves in America (Min 134). Particularly in focus within the art piece is the story of a Laotian man, Mr. Saengaly, who fled with his wife to America...

Words: 1219 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Expressive Essay

...Expressive Essay (Observation, Ethnography or Memoir) First Draft ENC 1101 – CR Junkins Purpose: What do I want the student to do? In this course, we will explore the two most commonly used forms of writing for college students: expressive writing and academic writing. Expressive writing captures what is important to the writer. In order to succeed, writers must understand themselves. Such writing is deeply personal. Expressive writing is designed to prepare students for writing outside academics—communicating feelings and observations, beliefs and opinions, community and individuality—all skill sets that will enable students to succeed in any discipline or career path. From a learning perspective, expressive writing is often an easier form of writing than academic. It allows students to begin working with such concepts as language, reasoning and mechanics while working with material they find worth discussing. In this assignment, I want students to carefully examine both themselves and their community. What makes their community unique? What is their place within the community? How did their unique, individual personality take shape? Project Overview: How do I want the student to do the assignment? Component One: Personal Students will choose to write on one of the following three topics: • One’s sense of place (observation) • One’s place within a community (ethnography) • One’s relationship to an event from the past (memoir) ...

Words: 1855 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Napcan Title I

...Colin Fisher Nature in the City: Urban Environmental History and Central Park E very year, thirty-five million growing population that was people visit Manhattan’s deeply divided along lines of Central Park, a vast island of class, ethnicity, and race. It is green situated in the midst of one within this historical context that of the world’s largest cities. For a group of merchants, politicians, many of these visitors, walking and middle-class reformers began through one of the park gates pushing for the creation of a large means leaving the artifice of the urban park (2). city behind and entering into an innocent green world, a vestige of A Cleansing Landscape the original Manhattan that existed For some, the new park would prior to the rise of the city. For increase adjacent property values urban environmental historians, and provide a leisure ground for though, there are two serious probrides in well-appointed carriages. lems with viewing the park in this way. Most of the city elite, though, First, Central Park is not nearly as offered less self-serving argunatural as it may appear. Far from ments, at least publicly. A large predating the rise of Manhattan, green space would not only cleanse the landscape is very much a product the air of dangerous smoke and of the mid nineteenth-century city. miasmas, it would convince the As such, Manhattan’s “front lawn” overworked sons and daughters of can be read as a primary source, a Puritans to leave their homes and unique window...

Words: 4489 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Academic Integrity in a Cultural Context

...Academic Integrity in a cultural context What is Academic Integrity in a cultural context? According to the Oxford School Dictionary & Thesaurus Academic means something to do with education or studying, especially at a school or college or university. Integrity means telling something that is true. Cultural means the custom and traditions of a people. Context means the background to an event that helps to explain it. So we can deduce from these definitions that academic integrity in a cultural context refers to academic honesty as against the background of the customs and tradition of people in an academic world. Academic Integrity in Nigeria With three major ethnic group and over 150 sub ethnic group, I daresay Nigeria is a very rich country in terms of culture and diverse in terms of customs and traditions. From time immemorial information has been passed down from generations to generations orally. Words and proverbs were actually not attributed to a singular person but to an ethnic group, for instance, the Yoruba adage, the Igbo adage, the Hausa adage, the Bini adage and so on. As we advance over the years, we started attributing word or group of words as quotes to an individual and also books were written by individuals. It was in the bid to stop mass reproduction of books that copyright came into been. During my research on this topic, I found out that most of the research works and journals on academic integrity in Nigeria only focus on cheating, malpractice...

Words: 1863 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Travelers to Africa

...time, for its traditions and way at life. This analysis is focused on two regions in particular, West and Central Africa : the region of West Africa was explored by Mungo Park first, at the end of the 18th century, and by Mary Kingsley exactly one hundred years later, while Henry Stanley went to the Central part of the continent, with the purpose of finding his companion Livingstone, in a first journey from 1871 to 1872, and he secondly came back to Africa for a new mission in 1874. This essay highlights the different approaches these authors took to talking about the country, and the different ways in which they set off for a journey into the “Dark Continent” at their time. It will be divided into three different sections, one for each author, following a chronological time. In each part the main differences and common themes Park, Stanley and Kingsley share, will be analysed. MUNGO PARK’S TRAVEL IN THE INTERIOR DISTRICTS OF AFRICA Mungo Park’s book recounts an eighteen-month expedition in West Africa [...] that commenced in May 1795 . He was accompanied by two African servants and his aim was to reach the Niger River. It is important to say that Park set off for the journey at the behest of the African Association, who asked him to accomplish three principal tasks: • he had to ascertain the direction in which the Niger flowed; • he had to find the city of Timbuktu...

Words: 2657 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Psych 101 Doc Carrarol Assignment 1

...Psych 100: Introduction to Psychology Course Outline—Spring 2012 Professor: James Carroll Office: 102 Sloan Hall Phone 774-6470 Email: carro1jl@mail.cmich.edu Office Hours: T and TR 12:30 -3 pm Web address for class: Blackboard @cmich.edu Welcome to Psych 100 – Introduction to Psychology: Why take this course? Yes, I know that it is one of the courses that meet some requirement or other for your degree – so you might feel that you have to take it! However, is there anything worthwhile that you can take away from this class besides 3 credits and hopefully a decent grade? I think so. Here are some thoughts about our course. Psychology is the study of behavior and mental processes; and just who engages in behavior and mental processes? You do – so this course is really all about you. We will look at the brain and see how it helps you to make sense of your world. We will look at lifespan development – your past, present and future. We will look at motivation and problem-solving – we all have motivational issues from time to time, and as for problems, most of us have lots of those to deal with. Although our focus is on normal behavior, we will look at what happens when our psychological self becomes overloaded, and we will examine ways to cope. We will see how individuals act and react within a group context. Throughout the course we will see real life applications for the material that we are learning. Course Description: The purpose of this...

Words: 1097 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Shanghai Branding Report

...Introduction The International Exposition (Expo) is an organization for placing brand and converging the public diplomacy. Since the Great Exhibition of 1851in London had opened the door to a procession of spectacular festivals of self-representation and image making, most western countries have accepted the Expo as an opportunity to show that their method to challenge of sustainable development of the city is in a more environmentally friendly interactive displays than others. However, the greatest honor cumulative to the hosts. The city of Shanghai, which was a badge member of the exclusive club of the world’s premiere cities, worthy of the event in a world-class. More widely, the Beijing Olympics of 2008 showed the new China and precisely provided an example of socialism with Chinese characteristics. Hence, the Chinese government may point to the Expo as another example of the admiration of the world turning toward China. It was reported that in the last 160 years, there has never an Expo similar to that, which took place in the 2010 Shanghai Expo. A case in point is that more than 700,000 people poured into a site the size of Baltimore in Shanghai in 184 days. They found that an unprecedented number of pavilions, built by the state and enterprises exhibitors, which deployed cutting edge architecture and state-of-the-art exhibition techniques to comment as ‘Better City, Better Life’ in English, but the Chinese version is closer to ‘city: let ’s make life better ’.  Methodology ...

Words: 1900 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

2008 Beijing Olympic Games

...same hopes and dreams. "One World One Dream" (One World One Dream), a profound reflection of the core concept of the Beijing Olympic Games, reflecting as a "Green Olympics, Scientific Olympics and Humanity Olympics" the core of the three concepts of the human soul, the harmony inherent in the Olympic Games of values. Building a harmonious society and achieving harmonious development is our dream. "Heaven" and "harmony" is the Chinese people since ancient times, man and nature, the ideal of a harmonious relationship between human beings and the pursuit. We believe: peace and progress, harmonious development, harmony, cooperation and win-win and the good life is the common ideal of the world. "One World One Dream" (One World One Dream), the text concise deep, is of China, the world's. Slogan expressed the Beijing people and the Chinese people and peoples of the world there are beautiful homes, share the fruits of civilization, the lofty ideals to work together in the future; expression has five thousand years of a civilization, is a big step toward modernization of the great nation committed to peace and development, social harmony, and happiness of the people's firm belief; expression of the 1.3 billion Chinese people for the establishment of a peaceful and better world to contribute to the voice. English slogan "One World...

Words: 988 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

9/11 Memorial Analysis

...description of the wide array of responses that arose after the attack. Many artists sought to provide their creative symbolic art representation that have been critical to the tragic event that changed most people perceptions about the world and the United States. Also, to honor the several anniversary artworks inspired by the events that took place this day. Some of the art include Zurab Tsereteli, Eric Fischl, Serhat Tanyolacar, and Roy Ray, among other collections of sculptures and photographs that reflect the deep emotional responses that resulted after the attack. The memorial includes other symbolic elements namely the trees, the thundering sound of the waterfalls combined with the noises of the busy city quieted by the memorial. The deep cultural reflection and individual remembrance are of greater significance to the experience of all Americans particularly those who lost their loved ones during the...

Words: 1708 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking

...main ideas of texts 2 Aims of Lecture 1  The main goal is to develop in students the skills and the confidence to approach a piece of academic text, read it efficiently and critically, and extract main ideas and key details.  But the goal of academic reading is more than just retrieve information. It is also the development of academic writing. Assessment for EAS Assignment 1 (Written) Assignment 2 (Presentation) Mid Term (Week 6 or 7) Final Exam 20% 15% 15% 50% 3 4 WHAT DO YOU FIRST SEE? 5 6 1 5/26/2014 7 8 WHAT DO YOU SEE AND BELIEVE?  Seeing is not believing.  An idea should be formed based on valid evidences and unbiased perception.  However, other perceptions and interpretations are possible.  Acceptance of other opinions.  To think CRITICALLY! BARRIERS TO CRITICAL THINKING… 9 10 Barriers to Critical Thinking (Why do people find Critical Thinking so difficult? What prevents people from thinking critically?) 1. Egocentrism - inability to see other people’s viewpoint - focus on self: I, ME, MYSELF  selfish 1. Egocentrism 2. Sociocentrism 3. Unwarranted Assumptions and Stereotyping 4. Relativistic Thinking 5. Wishful Thinking 11 12 2 5/26/2014 Two common forms of Egocentrism are: 2. Sociocentrism (family, friends, community, society)  Self-interested Thinking - To accept and defend beliefs that serves your own interest / benefit / convenience Eg. In UTAR: car park vs. poor bus service ...

Words: 1768 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Five-Question Method for Framing a Qualitative Research Study

...The Qualitative Report Volume 8 Number 3 September 2003 447-461 http://www.nova.edu/ssss/QR/QR8-3/mccaslin.pdf The Five-Question Method For Framing A Qualitative Research Study Mark L. McCaslin University of Idaho, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA Karen Wilson Scott University of Idaho, Idaho Falls, Idaho, USA The Five-Question Method is an approach to framing Qualitative Research, focusing on the methodologies of five of the major traditions in qualitative research: biography, ethnography, phenomenology, grounded theory, and case study. Asking Five Questions, novice researchers select a methodology appropriate to the desired perspective on the selected topic. The Method facilitates identifying and writing a Problem Statement. Through taking a future perspective, the researcher discovers the importance and direction of the study and composes a Purpose Statement. The process develops an overarching research question integrating the purpose and the research problem. The role of the researcher and management of assumptions and biases is discussed. The Five-Question Method simplifies the framing process promoting quality in qualitative research design. A course outline is appended. Key words: Qualitative Research, Five-Question Method, Biography Research, Phenomenology Research, Grounded Theory Research, Case Study Research, and Ethnography Research Introduction Planning a qualitative study for the first time tends to be an intimidating venture for graduate students just entering...

Words: 6473 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Szt Task 1

...Community Health Task 1 Alisha Diehl Western Governors University Community Health Community Description and Data Interpretation Located in South Central Pennsylvania, comprising a total of 910 square miles, York County was founded in 1749. It was formed out of Lancaster County, and became the fifth county established in Pennsylvania, as well as the first county established west of the Susquehanna River. A dispute grew between Pennsylvania and Maryland, as both states claimed a portion of York County. Thus the government hired British surveyors Charles Mason and Jeremiah Dixon to establish the boundary line between Maryland and Pennsylvania, who formed a demarcation which became known as the Mason-Dixon Line. York County lies just north of this famous Mason-Dixon Line, which later became integral during the Civil War for dividing the Union and Confederate Armies. (York County Historic Timeline, 2012). Population/Economic Assessment The total population of York County is 434,972 as of the 2010 Census, with York being the largest city with 43,550 people. The median age is 40.1 years, with 24.1% of the population being age 65 and older. This is an increase of 6% since the year 2000. The average household income for York County is $57,027, while the average household income for all of Pennsylvania is $49,520. The total percentage of households in York County living in poverty is 9.0%, with 7.1% for White Non-Hispanic residents and 24.5% for Hispanic or Latino...

Words: 2674 - Pages: 11