Free Essay

Chiang Kai Shek

In:

Submitted By lax90265
Words 2899
Pages 12
Chiang Kai-Shek lost control of China to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in 1949 following two and a half decades of mistakes and fundamental errors in ruling the struggling and fractured republic. Under his leadership, corruption was allowed to flourish in the nationalist party, failed military campaigns were commonplace, national unity was never created, and the obsession with personal wealth and gain was the rule among large numbers of the higher ranking members of the nationalist party, all of which lead to a complete breakdown of support for the nationalist party from the Chinese people. Chiang never had a “relationship with the common people.”1 From the time he came to power in 1925, he appeared never to understand his people. His obsession with purging the Kuomintang (KMT) of all Communists, his push for a New Life Movement2, making the claim, “first internal pacification, then external resistance”*3, and his use of foreign relationships and criminal organizations to gain superiority and exterminate the communists each played a role in confirming Chiang’s failure. In the fight against the Japanese in World War II, Chiang’s single-minded focus on the Chinese Communists allowed Japan to gain a strong grip in China and occupy parts of the country. It eventually required the help of the United States to defeat and oust the Japanese. Chiang’s repeated military failures against the Japanese caused him to lose support within his own elite KMT group. In an effort to reestablish power, he attacked the Communists, which led to a deterioration of support amongst the Chinese people. It made him appear aggressive and hypocritical to the massive peasant population as he attacked the one Chinese group who was actually intent on helping the poor agrarian workers. By 1945, the Communists were strong enough to defeat Chiang Kai-Shek due to his repeated tactical errors in military, political and social policies. To understand how Chiang Kai-shek failed China, the events that led him to lose control of the Mainland must be considered. In 1949 Mao Zedong and the CCP easily defeated what remained of his Nationalist Party. The prospect of civil war between the two groups had existed since the great purges against the communists in 1927. In 1947, with World War II ended, the Nationalists resumed their eradication of the CCP. They launched an attack on the Northern regions of China and even though they enjoyed “absolute superiority….being] ten times richer than the Communist army in military-suppl[ies]”4, they still lost. Reviewing these blunders, Tao Xisheng a member of the Chinese Reform Commission of 1950 said, the Nationalist lost because “The party emphasized form rather than substance.”5 Chiang himself stated, the use of “officers who did not use their brain,” who were “unwilling to study” and, “who embezzled supplies intended for their troops” contributed to the loss.”6 Furthermore, Chiang admitted that their acts of corruption were because “their revolutionary spirit [had] almost completely dissipated.”7 The party went into the Civil War during a period of terrible inflation, and without public support. These factors were detrimental to the success of the party and could have been prevented.8 Chiang Kai–Shek was born October 31st, 1887 in Xikou, China. He was the son of a wealthy salt merchant family. “Salt was a government monopoly, and the merchants who handled it enjoyed a certain standing.”9 That made the “Chiangs the leading family in the village.”10 Growing up Chiang took on a role of dominance as a schoolboy, when his classmates would play “games of soldiers, he preferred to be commander.”11 Chiang always “liked to be at the head of the children,”12 an obvious trait considering what he went on to be in life. In 1907 Chiang attended the Shikan Gakko Military Academy in Tokyo, Japan where he met a group of Chinese revolutionaries. He became close with them and joined their republican movement. In the fall of 1911 Chiang returned from Japan to fight in the Wuhan Uprising and the Xinhai Revolution. By 1918 he became a prominent member of the Nationalist Party or the Kuomintang (KMT) by befriending the leader Sun Yat-sen. Chiang then served under Sun Yat-sen, traveling to the Soviet Union on Sun’s behalf to study military tactics. In 1923 Chiang was appointed by Sun as head of the Whampoa Military Academy. Sun’s death in 1925 triggered a power struggle amongst the KMT and the Communist Party, which had been united from 1912-1925. Chiang was able to succeed Sun with the help of the Whampoa Academy Forces and the support of the chief Soviet in China, Galen. The transition was volatile as Chiang faced threats to his power from factions of the Communist Party, and from Japanese and Chinese warlords. The lapses of Chiang Kai-Shek that caused the defeat of the KMT began in 1926 with the launching of Chiang’s Northern Expedition. He declared at the start of the expedition that, “To protect the welfare of the people we must overthrow all warlords and wipe out reactionary power so that we may implement the Three People’s Principles and complete the when Nationalist Revolution.”13 For almost a year the expedition succeeded in its goal of overthrowing the warlords. However, in April 1927 its success started to falter when Chiang, who felt that the communist within the KMT were beginning to pose a threat, tried to expel the communists from the party and from the Republic of China (ROC). He marched into Shanghai, and with the help of Shanghai 's secret societies (organized crime groups) attacked the CCP members in Shanghai. Thousands of CCP members were executed or went missing, others were arrested and imprisoned, and the purge of the CCP had begun. Chiang had just killed his and China’s “most politically energetic and creative individuals.”14 This was hugely unpopular with a large portion of the vast underclass of people who were big supporters of the communists in the Nationalist party. At this point widespread corruption grew within the government as KMT Party officials began firing the lower level party members and filling their slots with their own “friends, family members, or other inadequately trained individuals.”15 It’s clear that the original political ideology of the KMT had been forgotten and spoiled by the party members who “disregard party organization and policy, and act instead largely on the basis of personal connections.”16 Chiang didn’t have firm control over his government, and the corruption spread like a cancerous disease throughout the government. By 1947 when the civil war broke out the massive corruption has seriously undermined the Nationalist Party than the Communists that have protected themselves from corruption and maintained and organized executive power all along. Chiang was obsessed with the destruction of the CCP. This led him to ignore governing or leading his country and resulted in the increasing loss of support from fellow party members and the general public. When Japan invaded China and captured Manchuria in 1931 and Beijing in 1935, the people asked Chiang to stop the purge of the communists but Chiang continued on. His answer to the public’s plea, “first internal pacification, then external resistance.”17 This was widely unpopular with the Chinese people, and only worsened internal problems, and for the first time angered a lot of KMT party officials.18 War against a foreign enemy generally united a nation’s people but by opting not to go to war with Japan, Chiang killed the Chinese “revolutionary spirit.”19 This meant he failed to promote any form of national unity, and consequently lowered the morale of the party and the people. Low morale was one of the effects that led to the nationalist’s defeat in 1949. Also, while Chiang was losing support because he was appeasing the Japanese, the CCP took a fervent anti-Japanese stance and gained the support that the KMT lost. All of which was significant, considering that the Nationalists went into civil war lacking support from the public. Chiang Kai-Shek’s inability to focus on important matters or to understand and listen to his people caused problems for him. In the case of the Japanese invasion, which occurred in 1931, Chiang chose not to focus on the Japanese in a timely manner and delayed taking decisive action until 1936. This mistake occurred because Chiang thought he was smarter than everyone else which led to errors in military strategy that allowed the Japanese to secure a strong foothold in China. By the time he decided to confront the Japanese they were much stronger than when they first invaded in 1931. Chiang’s military decision to defeat the communists then fight the Japanese was the source of his failure. By the time Chiang decided to confront the Japanese, morale in the Nationalists forces was all but extinguished and the corruption in the military and government was overwhelming. Chiang’s passive approach to the Japanese aggravated the members of the Nationalist Party. Taking action, they kidnapped Chiang at a military encampment in Xian in 1936. They refused to release him until he agreed to their proposal of a “United Front” to fight the Japanese.20 Chiang reluctantly agreed, and In July of 1937, war against Japan was declared. In August, Chiang Kai-shek sent half a million of his best troops to defend Shanghai, while he sent the rest of his forces to fight the Japanese. Chiang’s decision to divert forces directly from fighting with Japan in order to protect Shanghai from a possible communist invasion outraged the Whampoa Academy Officers21. Chiang lost their support and his political base. His decision to weaken his forces on the Japanese front allowed the Japanese to push Chiang and the KMT out of their capital, Nanjing, and inland to Chongqing, which was “ devoid of economic and industrial resources.”22 Being in a city that was so depleted led to “wartime shortages that in turn caused increased inflation and corruption with ever decreasing spirits”23. From then on the United Front was able to hold off the Japanese from further encroachments, but unable to push the Japanese back. China couldn’t defeat the Japanese without allying itself with the United States (US). Conversely, the US could not rid China of the Japanese without the help of the Nationalist forces. Aligning with President Roosevelt, Chiang was able to get the US to provide his KMT forces with ammunition and weapons.23These resources were intended to fight the Japanese except Chiang chose to stockpile the weapons for future use against the Communists. Chiang’s abuse of his relationship with the US and the mindset that he could use a superior country to service his own personal agenda made a lot of people, including the Americans, angry with him. In 1945 when the war ended, Chiang was blamed for the large number of KMT casualties. People in his party directly attributed this to the late entry into the war and the failure to properly utilize the weapons provided by the US against the Japanese. His support base was eroding but despite these circumstances and the enormous losses in the KMT forces, Chiang chose to resume his purge of the Communists. Amongst the people, “the War had severely weakened the Nationalists both in terms of resources and popularity.”25 Given all of these negative conditions, Chiang believed he could prevail against the Communists. With his government and forces exhausted, he was forced to turn to the US and Japanese to help reclaim former Nationalist areas now under control of the Communists. His usage of the enemy and foreign nationals to reclaim parts of China was deeply unpopular. Under the Nationalists the country was quickly “deteriorating with corruption and inflation.”26 In a desperate attempt to prevent the collapse of his Nationalist party, he formed an alliance with the wealthy Chinese landlords who controlled large swaths of the country. This resulted in the almost total “alienation of the peasant population”7 against the Nationalists and led to a massive switch by the people to support the CCP who were energetic, organized and promoted land reform, which was a popular measure. Chiang lost support from “the group representing 90%”of the population.28 His government was in shambles, his military was on its last legs and his support from the people was nonexistent. The CCP had become more powerful than Chiang Kai-shek and the KMT. His “international recognition”29 had become meaningless. In 1947 with his prospects dwindling, Chiang passed a constitution trying to promote a “democratic constitutional government”30 He hoped he could forge an alliance with the Communists and retain his role as leader but it was too late. The CCP and their following didn’t want to hear it and refused the legitimacy. Civil war erupted between the two and devoid of energy and morale the Nationalists couldn’t successfully combat the rising tide of the Communists. In December 1949 the CCP forces invaded Chengdu, the last KMT controlled city in China, and Chiang and his family were forced to flee to Taiwan. They never set foot on Mainland China again. Chiang’s obsession with purging the communists from the KMT was his downfall. It distracted him from tackling China’s myriad of domestic issues and enabled the Japanese occupation. If Chiang hadn’t pursued the CCP with such vehemence and single mindedness he “would have maintained support from the large peasant portion of the population.”31 With his government rife with corruption and nepotism, where decisions were “decided largely on the basis of an individual’s whim or personal favortisim”32, the Communists were able to attract the intelligent and uncorrupt officials to their cause. The Nationalist’s problems were further compounded by the generals’ selfish pursuits on and off the battlefield. The lack of military success directly correlated to a lack of national unity. Without a unifying spirit or strong ideological base, the Nationalists were ineffectual and China remained divided. Chiang spent years “ignoring the demands of the masses.”33 This opened the door for the Communists to promote their liberal agenda in support of the vast underclass, which comprised 90% of the nation.

Notes:

1.Eastman, Lloyd E. "Who Lost China? Chiang Kai-Shek Testifies." The China Quarterly (1981): 658-668. JSTOR. 13 Nov. 2006. Pg.665

2.Fenby, Jonathan. Chiang Kai Shek: China's Generalissimo and the Nation He Lost. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2004. Pg.120

3.The Strategy of Chiang Kai-Shek Author(s): Walter H. Mallory
Reviewed work(s): Source: Foreign Affairs, Vol. 17, No. 4 (Jul., 1939), pg 125

4.Fenby, 18

5.Fenby, 18

6.Fenby, 19

7.Fenby, 19

8.Eastman, 658

9.Eastman, 665

10.Eastman, 659

11.Eastman, 658

12.Lieberthal, Kenneth. Governing China. New York: WW Norton & Co, 1995. pg 34

13.Fenby, 115-116

14.Coble, Parks M. “Chiang Kai-Shek and the Anti-Japanese Movement in China.” The Journal of Asian Studies (1985): 293-310. JSTOR. 7 Nov 2006. pg 295

15.Fenby, 135

16.Eastman, 665

17.Mallory, 125

18.Lieberthal, 30

19. Doenecke, Justus D. "Chiang Kai-shek and the Struggle Between the Nationalist and Communist." The History of Nations. China ed. New Haven: Greenhaven, 2003.pg 116

20. “Japanese Military Campaigns in China, July 7, 1937 – August, 1945.” Discovering World History Online Edition. Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center. Thomson Gale. 7 Nov. 2006 pg unknown

21.Fenby, 25

22.Discovering World History Online Edition, pg unknown

23.Lieberthal, 36

24.Mallory, 710

25. Mallory, 711

26.Fenby 416

27.Fenby 416

28.Fenby 422

29. Fairbank, John K., and Merle Goldman. China: a New History. Cambridge: Belknap P of Havard UP, 1998. 185

30.Lieberthal, 42

31.Fenby 474

32.Eastman, 662

Bibliography:

Chiang Kai-shek's March Twentieth Coup d'Etat of 1926 Author(s): Tien-Wei Wu
Reviewed work(s): Source: The Journal of Asian Studies, Vol. 27, No. 3 (May, 1968), pp. 585-602

Coble, Parks M. “Chiang Kai-Shek and the Anti-Japanese Movement in China.” The Journal of Asian Studies (1985): 293-310. JSTOR. 7 Nov 2006.

Crozier, Brian. The Man Who Lost China. New York: Scribner, 1976

Doenecke, Justus D. "Chiang Kai-shek and the Struggle Between the Nationalist and Communist." The History of Nations. China ed. New Haven: Greenhaven, 2003. 109-20

Eastman, Lloyd E. "Who Lost China? Chiang Kai-Shek Testifies." The China Quarterly (1981): 658-668. JSTOR. 13 Nov. 2006.

Fairbank, John K., and Merle Goldman. China: a New History. Cambridge: Belknap P of Havard UP, 1998.

Fenby, Jonathan. Chiang Kai Shek: China's Generalissimo and the Nation He Lost. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2004.

“Japanese Military Campaigns in China, July 7, 1937 – August, 1945.” Discovering World History Online Edition. Gale, 2003. Student Resource Center. Thomson Gale. 7 Nov. 2006

Lieberthal, Kenneth. Governing China. New York: WW Norton & Co, 1995.

The Collected Wartime Messages of Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, 1937-1945 by Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek; The Chinese Ministry of Information
Review by: Knight Biggerstaff
Pacific Historical Review , Vol. 16, No. 4 (Nov., 1947), pp. 466-467

The Collected Wartime Messages of Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek. by Chinese Ministry of Information Review by: Earl Swisher The Far Eastern Quarterly, Vol. 6, No. 2 (Feb., 1947), pp. 184-186

The Strategy of Chiang Kai-Shek Author(s): Walter H. Mallory
Reviewed work(s): Source: Foreign Affairs, Vol. 17, No. 4 (Jul., 1939), pp. 699-711 and 120-147

Similar Documents

Free Essay

China's Destiny

...Chiang Kai Shek Chiang Kai-Shek lost control of China to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in 1949 following two and a half decades of mistakes and fundamental errors in ruling the struggling and fractured republic.   Under his leadership, corruption was allowed to flourish in the nationalist party, failed military campaigns were commonplace, national unity was never created, and the obsession with personal wealth and gain was the rule among large numbers of the higher ranking members of the nationalist party, all of which lead to a complete breakdown of support for the nationalist party from the Chinese people.   Chiang never had a “relationship with the common people.”1 From the time he came to power in 1925, he appeared never to understand his people.   His obsession with purging the Kuomintang (KMT) of all Communists, his push for a New Life Movement2, making the claim, “first internal pacification, then external resistance”*3, and his use of foreign relationships and criminal organizations to gain superiority and exterminate the communists each played a role in confirming Chiang’s failure. In the fight against the Japanese in World War II, Chiang’s single-minded focus on the Chinese Communists allowed Japan to gain a strong grip in China and occupy parts of the country. It eventually required the help of the United States to defeat and oust the Japanese. Chiang’s repeated military failures against the Japanese caused him to lose support within his own elite KMT group.  ...

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Chinese Civil War

...WHAT CAUSED THE CHINESE CIVIL WAR? Cases of Chinese Civil war can be divided into long and short term causes. 1. Struggle for power since 1927 between Nationalists and Communists 2. Chiang Kai-shek had tried to eradicate members of CCP 3. Japanese War unite CCP and GMD. However, Chiang Kai-shek couldn't accept Communists as his partners so he attack Communist forces in the south. 4. Polarized society Short term: 1. Divided country 2. Revolutional spirit 3. The Chinese Civil War (1927 – 1949/1950) was a civil war fought between the Kuomintang (KMT or Chinese Nationalist Party), the governing party of the Republic of China, and the Communist Party of China (CPC) (also known as CCP - Chinese Communist Party),[6] for the control of China which eventually led to China's division into two Chinas, Republic of China (ROC) and People's Republic of China (PRC). The war began in April 1927, amidst the Northern Expedition,[7], and essentially ended when major active battles ceased in 1949-1950. However there is debate on whether the war has officially ended. The conflict continues in the form of military threats and political and economic pressure, particularly over the political status of Taiwan. The continued tension is described in cross-Strait relations. The war represented an ideological split between the Nationalist KMT, and the Communist CPC. In mainland China today, the last three years of the war (1947–1949) are more commonly known as the War of Liberation, or alternatively...

Words: 618 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Chinese Civil War : Kmt vs. Ccp

...The Chinese Civil War KMT vs. CCP The Chinese civil war of 1946-49, is considered one of the most brutal and bloody conflicts near the final stages of the Second World War, which took the lives of millions of soldiers and civilians. The war was fought between two parties, the Kuomintang (KMT or Nationalists) and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP or Reds). The leaders of these parties respectively were Chiang Kai-shek and Mao Zedong. The war between the KMT and CCP wasn’t a new struggle but a continuation that dates back more than a couple decades and resumes after the Japanese had surrendered in 1945. In 1949, the better armed KMT were ultimately defeated by the CCP. The reasons for the CCP’s decisive victory are due to the poor mismanagements of Chiang Kai-shek combined with the corruption of the KMT, the superior leadership and tactics of Mao Zedong and the communists, the positive support from the peasants, and the aid provided by the Soviet Union. Although Chiang and his Nationalists looked like they had all the advantages over the CCP at the end of the Japanese war, Chiang’s leadership and the corruption of officers in the KMT’s forces known as the “Nationalist Revolutionary Army” (NRA), would be a major cause in the KMT’s defeat. One of Chiang’s military goals was to be the head of a national army that would heed all of his orders which was never fully accomplished. Throughout the civil war, the armies he controlled were a mixed bag. There were...

Words: 1390 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Chinese Civil War

...many respects, China had been in a state of civil war since the Shanghai Massacre and the collapse of the First United Front in 1927. The main phase of the Chinese Civil War, however, is usually regarded as the period from late 1945 to 1949. After the Japanese surrender in August 1945, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and Guomindang (GMD) agreed to hollow peace talks and an abortive ceasefire. By the start of 1946, however, the two groups were again fighting for control of China. This final phase of the Chinese Civil War culminated in the CCP’s capture of Beijing and its leader Mao Zedong (Wade-Giles: Mao Tse-tung) declaring the formation of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in October 1949. Nationalist generalissimo Jiang Jieshi (Chiang Kai-shek) was forced to retreat to Taiwan, where he established an alternative government called the Republic of China (ROC). The civil war inflicted major suffering on China’s civilian population, already exhausted and economically ravaged by decades of revolution, warlordism and conflict with the Japanese. The war caused millions of casualties, triggered economic disintegration through hyperinflation and corruption, and displaced millions of refugees. The CCP may have secured victory in 1949 but like the republicans of 1912, they inherited an unstable, dysfunctional and economically depleted nation. With the Japanese surrender in August 1945, most observers believed the CCP and Guomindang would resume their struggle for control of China...

Words: 428 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Chinese Revolution

...Chinese Revolution Revolution is a total change. It can be a change that is political, social, economic, cultural or technological. Revolutions change the way people live. There were many revolutions throughout history. The one that will be introduced to you in this essay is Chinese Revolution. Chinese Revolution happened in 1949. There were many events that caused the revolution. Chiang Kai-Shek was the leader of nationalist government and Mao Zedong was the leader of communist group. Nationalist government was trying to suppress the communists and eliminated them. Civil War started in 1927 between these two groups. Sun Yat Sen's impact on the Chinese Revolution Sun Yat Sen is a figure that is impossible not to refer to while studying the Chinese Revolution. His involvement in the early days of the revolution is hard to deny but how effective and important his contribution was is arguable. There are many different arguments to whether Sun was a failed revolutionary or well deserving of the title ‘Father of the revolution”. There is a variance of opinion of how much sun contributed to the 1911 revolution is a great one. By early 1900 Sun had already expressed his need for the overthrowing of the Qing dynasty. To begin this Sun sent followers into China to attempt uprisings to make the most of the turmoil during the boxer rebellion but these uprisings failed. In 1905 two student revolutionary groups in Japan allied themselves with Sun Yat Sen’s Revive China Society to...

Words: 2502 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Nhd- the White Terror

...Sophia Fan Mr. Carter & Mrs. Farley Humanities - Matteo Ricci November 15, 2012 The Domino Effect of the White Terror Have you ever tapped lightly against one domino and watched it knock down a whole line of these small squares? It is amazing how one single action can reciprocate so many other events. This is not only the case for dominoes, of course- everyday events have occurred like this too. A perfect example of the domino effect is the Communist split from the Nationalists, commonly known as the White Terror. This sudden purge only lasted around three nights, but the effects of the split would last for many decades in the future. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) split from the Chinese Nationalists in 1927 affected both China itself and other foreign nations through the triggering of major wars, changes in international relations, and the formation of modern China- one of the world’s leading economies. The effects of the split, both positive and negative, would last for many years to come. After splitting from the Nationalists, Mao Zedong led the legendary Long March- a campaign that would garner support for him and split the country into two parties. Although the route was extremely long and dangerous, the popularity gained along the way sustained the marchers. As Mao Zedong wrote in his 1935 poem The Long March, “the Red Army fears not the trials of the Long March, holding light ten thousand...

Words: 4155 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Gmd Were Better Equipped….but the Communist Took Advantage of the Mass Support

...more foot binding, prostitution, Land reform, When they made mistake, too radical for land reform, they backed down and began to more moderate. * Conclusion has to go back to the question Compare the two!! GMD & CCP Why did a Civil war break out in China in 1947? * Intro * Main Body (1st/2nd developed point) (division between GMD and CCP), 1925 – 1945 main points (shanghais massacre, extermination campaigns, long march, war with Japan) * Main Body (2nd developed point) 1945-1946 (end of the Sino-Japanese war, CCP willing to compromise, GMD not) * Conclusion – long term factors + the short term caused the civil war The Chinese civil war was a power struggle between China’s GMD nationalist party under Chiang Kai Shek ant the CCP communist party under Mao Ze Dong. Although...

Words: 969 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

China

...others being Mesopotamia, the Indus Valley civilization, the Maya civilization, the Minoan civilization of ancient Greece, and Ancient Egypt.[5] It reached its golden age during the Tang Dynasty (about A.D. 10th century). China is home to some of the oldest artwork in the world. Statues and pottery, as well as decorations made of jade, are some classic examples. China's economy and military weakened during the Qing Dynasty (around the 17th century to 20th century) and the country was oppressed by foreign nations. In 1911 a country, the Republic of China was founded by Sun Yat-sen (Sun Zhongshan-孙中山). But its government was very weak. Army leaders in different area controlled the local governments, and later fell into the dictatorship of Chiang Kai-shek (Jiang Jieshi). In 1931, Japan invaded Manchuria, a place in the...

Words: 1102 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

"The Long March Was a Retreat That Changed the Destiny of China" to What Extent Do You Agree with This Statement?

...“The Long March was a retreat that changed the destiny of China” To what extent do you agree with this statement? The Long March was an epic journey across China conducted by the Red army in 1934. After the breakdown of the first United Front, Chiang Kai Shek launched an offensive which forced a retreat from Mao and the Red army. This retreat is believed to have lasted for over a year and covered 6000 miles. By the end of the march, of the 80000 marchers who embarked on the journey, only 6000 made it to Yenan. It was a march rich with heroism and hardship. However to call the Long March a retreat that changed the destiny of china is controversial. The term 'destiny' can be interpreted in two different ways. It can be the outcome of the Long March influencing the civil war by 1949 or the world's perspective of China. According to many historians, such as Richard Cavendish, the Long March was a victorious march for Mao and the CCP. It made the survival of the imperiled CCP possible, gave Mao a secure grasp on its leadership and ultimately led to the creation of the People's Republic of China. “As a bulwark of Chinese pride and patriotism, skillfully exploited as such by Mao and his circle”. It is also sometimes believed that the Long March was a seeding machine, one that spread the Marxist ideology and manipulated the opinions of China and Mao across the globe. Before the epic journey began, the CCP was in a quagmire and the Nationalists seemed on the point of establishing...

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hu Shi

...practice, this attitude identifies the existing flaws of the current status quo and innovates new ideas and improvements to the system. For example, throughout the movement many controversies were put forward such as the problem of Confucianism and technological development, vernacularism and the classical language, and our ethical practices to name a few. This stance to challenge encourages people to introduce new academic theories, to which it is developed and adjusted. To a substantial extent, I agree with Hu Shi’s interpretation of the May fourth movement. After all, it appears that throughout history, society tends to replace traditional institutions through a process of reflection and creative destruction. In concordance with Chiang Monlin’s interpretation, Hu Shi views the May fourth movement as an “emancipating movement”. The movement was an era of challenge. Tradition was challenged by reason, authority was challenged by freedom, and suppression was challenged by humanist values. The movement was faced with a surge of radicalized idea’s many of whom were influenced by western politics. Communism was born with the downfall of the Russian Tsar Nicholas ll in 1917, and nationalism was born out of foreign imperialism. Culturally, china was previously dominated by Confucianism values, which was not only...

Words: 792 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Modern Chinese Politics

...period of warlordism after the death of Yuan Shikai. After World War I, upset with the Treaty of Versailles, students broke out in protest. The May Fourth Movement essentially formed the Communist Party of China (CCP). During the 1920’s there was a power struggle between the CCP and Sun Yat-sen’s Kuomintang Nationalist party (KMT). KMT was strong in China’s urban areas while the CCP was influential in its rural areas. However, by 1927, the CCP was expelled from China and it became a Nationalist country under the KMT. By 1931, the CCP had reemerged but could not be defeated by Chiang Kai-shek. Instead they retreated to the north in the Long March. Also in 1931, Japan began to occupy Manchuria and established a puppet government called Manchukuo. The Japanese aggression in China became full blown on July 7, 1937, the beginning World War II. By 1939, Japan controlled most of the east coast of China, while Chiang blockaded the Communists in the northwest region. By 1944, the United States began to help nationalist China, but the nationalist remained weak due to high inflation and economic strife. Fighting between the two groups increased in 1946. With the CCP ultimately pushing the KMT back into Taiwan. This opened the door for Mao Zedong to establish the People’s Republic of China. The PRC set up five-year...

Words: 808 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Analyse the Causes of the Chinese Civil War.

...• The seed that planted the Chinese Civil war lies in its social, political and economic instability within the Chinese society. The Chinese civil war was an armed conflict between two ideologically opposed forces - the Nationalists Guomingdang (GMD) and the Communists People Liberation Army (CCP) – to see who could ultimately restore power and regain central control over China. As Historian Jonathan Spence argues, the Chinese Civil War should refer more narrowly to this latter conflict between 1946 and 1949, as this produced a decisive result. Although there are many causes to the outbreak of the war, the main long term, mid-term, immediate and catalyst causes will be discussed. The overthrow of the Manchu Dynasty coupled with the Warlord era, followed by the ideological divide between the CCP and the GMD during the First United Front led to the catalyst cause during the Sino-Japanese war, in which the two parties truly showed the extent to which they will go to, to become the leader and unifier of the country, unleashing the ultimate trigger to the outbreak of the Chinese Civil War. The most significant long term cause of the civil war in China was the collapse of the Qing Dynasty, as it played a fundamental role in creating the conditions for the event. The Qing government became weakened economically, socially and politically from internal and external threats by the end of the 19th century. European imperialist powers and Japan forced their way into China to take advantage...

Words: 2371 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Mao in China

...Mao’s choice of ideology appealed to the masses as it provided them with an equal opportunity, gave them land, rights and privileges and offered them an alternative to political instability and lack of unity. Before Mao, the peasants who made up 85% of society, had endured humiliation and suffering under the imperialist dynasty. After the overthrow of the dynasty, the people were looking for answer to their extreme poverty. Mao provided that answer through his own form of Marxism Leninism, where every man, woman and child got a share. He gained support from the people by giving them land rights through land reform and offering them fair and equal treatment in the Red army. Mao also provided the peasantry with an alternative to the harsh ways of the Nationalist government. Under the GMD, the peasants had to pay 40-60% of their crops in rents, with further taxes on top. The peasants found it very hard to sustain a living under GMD control whereas Mao set to eliminate taxes for poorer peasants, set up price controls, and only have the upper 20% pay taxes. Mao also gained further support by promising to rid China of domination and interference by foreign nations. The Long March is to date considered as one of the major propaganda tools which Mao employed in solidifying his cult of personality and gaining support. The Long March occurred when the CCP had to flee a concerted GMD attack and the CCP retreated. Speaking of the Long March as a tool of propaganda, Mao himself said “The...

Words: 351 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Advertisments

...State Department, May 1947. The extract is a report by the US consul in Shenyang to the US State Departament, it is a primary source as it shows Source B Strive to annihilate the enemy in mobile warfare, but at the same time pay attention to tactics of positional attack for seizing enemy strongholds and cities. In the mater of siege operations, resolutely seize all the weakly defended enemy positions or cities. In the case of an enemy position or city defended with medium strength, seize it when the opportunity arises and circumstances permit. In the case of a strongly defended enemy position, take it only when the conditions are ripe. Extract from an essay by Mao Zedong on war, may 1947, to guide his troops. Source C Ching Kai-chek (Jiang Jieshi) was personally honest and well-meaning, [but] he was hemmed in by untrustworthiness of provincial leaders, the intrigues of his headquarters and the widespread communist influence. In 1947 the communist armies faced nationalist superiority in men and materials of two and half to one. After less than a year of fighting, they had reversed the proportion. The nationalist armies voted with their feet. Gray, J. 1990: Rebellions and revolutions, China from 1800s to the 1980s. (Oxford) Source D Military victory was achieved through a brilliant use f strategy against an erroneous campaign plan adopted by the nationalists. On the political front, victory...

Words: 375 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bababa

... Opium War Taiping Rebellion 1860s-90s 1885 1894 1898 1900 1905 1911 Self-Strengthening Movement Sino-French War over Vietnam Sino-Japanese War over Korea Kang Youwei’s 100 Days Reform Boxer Uprising Sun Yat-sen forms Revolutionary Alliance Republican Revolution 1912-1949 Republic of China Yuan Shikai Presidency 1913 1915 1916 Yuan establishes military dictatorship Yuan imperial restoration Civil War 1916-26 1919 1921 1922 Warlord period May 4th Incident Founding of Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Nationalist Party revitalization by Sun Yat-sen United Front with CCP Death of Sun Yat-sen (Succession by Chiang Kai-shek) 1925 1926-27 1931 1934 1936 Nationalist reunification Purge of CCP Japanese seize Manchuria CCP Long March to north China Kidnapping of Chiang...

Words: 337 - Pages: 2